ePortfolios and 
Open Badges: 
Visual Pathways to the Future 
IMMIGRANT INTEGRATION VERSION 
September 2, 2014 
Don Presant
Learning Agents 
ePortfolio, eLearning, eMedia 
http://donpresant.ca
The long and winding road… 
Pre-arrival to full integration
The long and winding road… 
Pre-arrival to full integration
Needs of immigrants 
Learning and Recognition 
• Learning and experience not recognized 
– Foreign universities, experiential work learning not valued 
(lack of “Canadian experience”) 
• Individualized assets/gaps….but instruction in cohorts 
– Language skills, soft skills, workplace culture 
– Keeping the job, advancing in career 
• Retention issues over long process of integration 
– Discouragement, distraction, financial pressures 
• Slow progress thru QR hurdles & higher CLB levels 
• Handoff gaps between agencies, advisors 
– Completely fixed with Correlate? Depth of data? 
– Tracking longer term outcomes beyond Y1
Research 
Information Practices of Immigrants 
Nadia Caidi, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto, 2009 
http://www.slideshare.net/settlementatwork/information-practices-of-immigrants
http://blog.qmee.com/qmee-online-in-60-seconds/ 
The 
Read-Write Web 
has changed the 
Internet from: 
• a shopping mall 
• an encyclopedia 
• a television 
To a place where we 
personalize our 
experience and leave 
our footprints behind
Key Message: 
ePortfolios can be FOR and OF Learning 
FOR Learning OF Learning 
focused on process focused on product 
intrinsic extrinsic 
supports learning demonstrates learning 
private workshop public shop window 
learning environment learning showcase 
learning activities learning outcomes 
formative assessment summative assessment 
lower stakes higher stakes
Personal Planning and Learning 
Online Locker, Interactive Workbook 
• Online archive 
– Personal & downloaded documents, links 
• Resources for self-directed learning 
– Webinars, videos, self-assessment surveys 
• Learning plans and tracking tools 
– Set goals and track progress to them (Learning Plans) 
– Keep records of learning activities over time (CPD) 
• Personal journal 
– Reflect on goals and alternative futures 
– Keep ad hoc “notes to self”, prepare agendas, etc.
Employment & related purposes 
Demonstrate, assess & improve Human Capital 
• Qualification Recognition 
– Initial, formative, summative assessment 
• Academic recognition 
– PLAR/RPL for courses and programs 
• Career Development 
– Gap analysis, exploration of alternatives, building pathways 
• Employment (Web CV) 
– Hiring, career advancement, team building tool for employers 
• Continuing Professional Development (CPD) 
– Tracking ongoing learning activities and reflection on practice 
– Recertification
In MB: “Brochure”ePortfolio 
Manitoba Start
www.issbc.org 
Helping immigrants build a future in Canada 
Employability ePortfolios for 
Immigrants: Arrival to 
Employment 
Cannexus – Ottawa 2014 
www.issbc.org
Immigrant Services Society of BC 
ePortfolio – Cooperative Framework 
• LINC and employment staff working together 
• Clients develop language, career planning and 
job search skills as a package 
www.issbc.org 
Employment 
Facilitator 
ESL 
Teacher 
Skills, 
ePortfolio 
Evidence
Moodle + Mahara 
eLearning + ePortfolio 
www.issbc.org
Mahara 
Hands-on workshop
Contribution to PLAR 
 Previously, simple referral to Employment Facilitator 
Now provide: 
– Evidence of 
hard skills 
experience 
language ability 
soft skills 
– More skills to better represent themselves to employers and 
professional associations 
www.issbc.org
Professional Pages – Learner Owned 
www.issbc.org
www.issbc.org 
Resume 
Audio 
Intro 
Past 
Projects 
Certificates 
Publications
ePortfolios: leveraging the “e” 
The “Flexible Binder” for the 21st Century 
• Information Management capabilities 
– Collecting, archiving, sharing, multiple versioning 
– Quick links to cross-reference evidence 
– Accessible multimedia with free Web 2.0 tools 
– Align to frameworks, rubrics, track learning over time 
• Social learning, digital identity 
– Building professional profile, Personal Learning network 
• Digital technology skills, Internet literacy 
– Demonstrated by and within the ePortfolio 
• Learning and collaboration integration 
– Online research: documents, networks 
– Easy to add comments, edit, mentor, coach
New service: savvyfolio.net 
Multi-institution ePortfolio community 
Professional Body Workplace Trainer 
College 
Employer Industry Sector Body 
University 
Adult Learning Centre 
Employability Agency
Digital credentials FOR and OF learning 
Micro-credentialing 
using Open Badges
Brief introduction 
http://www.savvyfolio.net/user/don/overview-open-badges
Open Badges and Badge Passports 
“Micro credentials in a modular eportfolio” 
Richard Wyles, Totara LMS at MaharaUK12 
http://maharauk.org/mod/resource/view.php?id=117
A picture + descriptive words… 
Simple data structure for easy sharing 
bit.ly/ePIC2013_Belshaw
Badges in Action 
Demonstration
Origins 
• Badges, medals, 
ribbons since 
pre-Roman 
times 
• Military, Boy 
Scouts 
http://jproc.ca/rrp/apend_l_trade_designators_1960.html 
• Public recognition rewarding positive 
(desired) behaviour
Recent corporate trends 
Social media, gamification for productivity 
tech.co/gamify-your-new-hire-onboarding-process-with- 
mindtickle-2013-02 
http://www.tibbr.com/
Gamification and engagement 
Air Canada 
earnyourwings.aircanada.com 
114,716 registrations 
$26.2 million added revenue 
ROI >500% 
t.co/ZQEjrL0BxE
Gamification and math skills 
Khan Academy: Internal Badges for Learning
Gamification of physical reality 
Foursquare 
socialmediaexaminer.com
Recent productivity trends 
Social enterprise and process gamification 
joshbersin.com/2011/07/17/badges-swarm-the-internet-and-soon-intranet/ 
http://www.cornerstoneondemand.com/connect
Gamification of Onboarding 
New employee orientation
Enterprise Gamification 
Consulting overview 
“One trend we are seeing is 
enterprises seeking to instill a more 
proactive attitude about career 
development among the workforce.” 
Download PDF
Gamification of language learning 
Duolingo – scaffolded text translation 
youtu.be/WyzJ2Qq9Abs 
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duolingo
Gamification of language learning 
busuu.com – Farmville for language? 
Common European Framework of Reference (CEFR):
Gamification of integration 
Citizenship course for Youth (Ontario)
Open Badges 
A learning ecosystem 
http://openmatt.org/ 
Goal 
#openbadgesMOOC
Open Badges 
Making learning visible 
• Progress markers 
– Motivating learners, supporting 
advisors 
• Learning pathways 
– Granular, incremental, flexible 
• Visual branding 
– Issuers and learners 
• Online trust system 
– Demonstrate skills & capabilities
Badge Pathways 
Mozilla Discover (Gates funding) 
http://discover.openbadges.org/
Pearson Acclaim (VUE) 
If Pearson are getting into badges.… 
Acclaim’s unique 
approach…is to work with 
academic institutions and 
high-stakes credentialing 
organizations to offer 
diplomas, certificates and 
other professional 
credentials as Open Badges. 
blog.youracclaim.com/
Books@Work 
College-led study groups in workplaces 
http://www.booksatwork.org/the-bookswork-badge/
Badging Health Professionals 
Continuing Professional Development 
http://www.paincommunitycentre.org/cpd/badges
Benefits 
Open Badges & Digital Certification 
• Visually efficient and appealing 
– Fun, motivating to earn (gamification) 
– Visualize progress for advising 
– Automatically / manually awarded 
• Individual learning pathways 
– Modular, flexible, diverse, portable, shareable 
– Personal goal setting, achievement for self-directed learning 
– Builds confidence 
– Blend and ladder from multiple sources in badge passports & ePortfolios 
– Progress in incomplete programs can still be recognized and recombined 
• Transparent, “trustable” 
– Criteria, evidence, issue/expiry date 
– Ongoing connection to issuer 
– Report outcomes 
– Issuer is validated and branded by the badges it issues, along with 3rd party 
endorsement (coming)
Badges and Immigrants 
Ideas for EAL (to be validated) 
• FORMATIVE 
– Portfolio Based Language Assessment (PBLA) progress tracking 
– Course activities and assignments 
– Self-directed learning achievements 
– # books/articles read, docs written, grammar/vocab quizzes (self-assessments) 
& exercises, journal reflections and other portfolio inventory tasks completed 
– Recognize/aggregate achievements from external language programs 
• Rosetta Stone, Tell Me More, busuu.com, etc. 
– Enhance with Essential Skills, workplace culture learning 
• Digital Technology, Working with Others, problem solving, etc. 
– Real world badge “missions” 
– # “stretch” assignments in the real world (e.g. conversations with strangers) 
• SUMMATIVE 
– Internal: CLB levels in progress reports: e.g. Reading: Developing 7 
(linked to evidence as appropriate) 
– External: IELTS scores?
Badges and Immigrants 
Ideas for Employability (to be validated) 
• FORMATIVE 
– Workshop program/job search milestones, achievements 
• CV, cover letter, elevator speech, employability portfolio 
– Real world badge “missions” 
– # “stretch” assignments in the real world (e.g. # cold calls, # informational 
interviews…) 
• SUMMATIVE 
– For service providers and funders 
• Learner achievements: CVs, interviews, placements, hirings, etc. 
– For Employers 
• Essential Skills assessments (TOWES, Prove It, Microsoft, etc.) 
– Computer, Document Use, etc. 
• Job-related language assessments (e.g. IELTS) 
• Courses/workshops taken 
• Affiliations (e.g. Toastmasters, professional associations) 
• Volunteer service, other experiential learning 
• Summary credentials (“work ready”, etc. if available)
Badging Kirkpatrick 
For EAL (to be validated) 
Kirkpatrick Level Affordances & Indicators 
5: ROI (Phillips) Badge reports of outcomes linked to budgets 
4: Results Badge trails, aligned to CLB, by date? 
Badges linked to PBLA evidence. 
Badges from subsequent language learning. 
NB: Follow-up and learner cooperation required 
3: Transfer Badge collections: sequencing, laddering, clustering 
Badges from multiple sources curated in badge passports & 
channeled to goals 
Badges in eportfolios enhanced with reflection 
2: Learning Badges with embedded skills outcomes 
1: Reaction Visual appeal, gamification, completion
Badging Kirkpatrick 
For employability (to be validated) 
Kirkpatrick Level Affordances & Indicators 
5: ROI (Phillips) Badge reports on longer term employment outcomes 
4: Results Badges for interviews, placements? 
Badges for permanent hires (in their field)? 
Badges for retention: still working after 1 year? 
NB: Follow-up and learner cooperation required 
3: Transfer Badge collections: sequencing, laddering, clustering 
Badges from multiple sources curated in badge passports & 
channeled to goals 
Badges in eportfolios enhanced with reflection 
2: Learning Badges with embedded skills outcomes 
1: Reaction Visual appeal, gamification, activity completion
Badges for PD? 
Ideas for EAL and Employment Professionals 
• Conference badges 
– Participant, Presenter, “Networker”, “Reflector”, etc. 
• Online community badges 
– As above, other activities (e.g. link sharing) + peer assessments 
• Non-formal learning 
– Workshops, lectures, ConEd programs, Special Interest Groups, reading 
logs, MOOCs 
• Awards and recognition 
– Including “honourable mentions” and short lists 
• Professional affiliations and volunteer service 
… arranged/curated in a professional eportfolio or “badge passport” 
with other evidence
Badges for EAL PD 
English Online 
Criteria: Attended webinar 
training/preparation session, 
presented online, contributed to 
the resource page and discussion 
thread) 
Evidence: <link to webinar 
recording> 
Upcoming for 2015: “Contributor” 
myenglishonline.ca/for-teachers/realize/
Open Badge Factory 
Centralized badge management 
bit.ly/ePIC2013_Rousselle
Open Badge Factory 
Detailed Reports
Open Badge Factory 
Badge Application
Features and Benefits 
openbadgefactory.com 
• Current: 
– Controlled access for organizations 
– Controlled roles within organizations 
• Creator, Issuer, Administrator 
– Detailed reports 
– Badge applications 
– Milestone badges 
• Level up… 
– Earner evidence field 
• Coming (Sep-Dec 2014): 
– Badge Passports 
• Private/public badges, badge collections, mobile display 
• Multilingual badges 
• Issuer community features: sharing and endorsement of badges
Link to presentation: 
bit.ly/openbadges4immigrants 
don@learningagents.ca 
Web: learningagents.ca 
Twitter: donpresant 
ePortfolio: donpresant.ca

ePortfolios and Open Badges for Immigrants

  • 1.
    ePortfolios and OpenBadges: Visual Pathways to the Future IMMIGRANT INTEGRATION VERSION September 2, 2014 Don Presant
  • 2.
    Learning Agents ePortfolio,eLearning, eMedia http://donpresant.ca
  • 3.
    The long andwinding road… Pre-arrival to full integration
  • 4.
    The long andwinding road… Pre-arrival to full integration
  • 5.
    Needs of immigrants Learning and Recognition • Learning and experience not recognized – Foreign universities, experiential work learning not valued (lack of “Canadian experience”) • Individualized assets/gaps….but instruction in cohorts – Language skills, soft skills, workplace culture – Keeping the job, advancing in career • Retention issues over long process of integration – Discouragement, distraction, financial pressures • Slow progress thru QR hurdles & higher CLB levels • Handoff gaps between agencies, advisors – Completely fixed with Correlate? Depth of data? – Tracking longer term outcomes beyond Y1
  • 6.
    Research Information Practicesof Immigrants Nadia Caidi, Faculty of Information, University of Toronto, 2009 http://www.slideshare.net/settlementatwork/information-practices-of-immigrants
  • 7.
    http://blog.qmee.com/qmee-online-in-60-seconds/ The Read-WriteWeb has changed the Internet from: • a shopping mall • an encyclopedia • a television To a place where we personalize our experience and leave our footprints behind
  • 8.
    Key Message: ePortfolioscan be FOR and OF Learning FOR Learning OF Learning focused on process focused on product intrinsic extrinsic supports learning demonstrates learning private workshop public shop window learning environment learning showcase learning activities learning outcomes formative assessment summative assessment lower stakes higher stakes
  • 9.
    Personal Planning andLearning Online Locker, Interactive Workbook • Online archive – Personal & downloaded documents, links • Resources for self-directed learning – Webinars, videos, self-assessment surveys • Learning plans and tracking tools – Set goals and track progress to them (Learning Plans) – Keep records of learning activities over time (CPD) • Personal journal – Reflect on goals and alternative futures – Keep ad hoc “notes to self”, prepare agendas, etc.
  • 10.
    Employment & relatedpurposes Demonstrate, assess & improve Human Capital • Qualification Recognition – Initial, formative, summative assessment • Academic recognition – PLAR/RPL for courses and programs • Career Development – Gap analysis, exploration of alternatives, building pathways • Employment (Web CV) – Hiring, career advancement, team building tool for employers • Continuing Professional Development (CPD) – Tracking ongoing learning activities and reflection on practice – Recertification
  • 11.
  • 12.
    www.issbc.org Helping immigrantsbuild a future in Canada Employability ePortfolios for Immigrants: Arrival to Employment Cannexus – Ottawa 2014 www.issbc.org
  • 13.
    Immigrant Services Societyof BC ePortfolio – Cooperative Framework • LINC and employment staff working together • Clients develop language, career planning and job search skills as a package www.issbc.org Employment Facilitator ESL Teacher Skills, ePortfolio Evidence
  • 14.
    Moodle + Mahara eLearning + ePortfolio www.issbc.org
  • 15.
  • 16.
    Contribution to PLAR  Previously, simple referral to Employment Facilitator Now provide: – Evidence of hard skills experience language ability soft skills – More skills to better represent themselves to employers and professional associations www.issbc.org
  • 17.
    Professional Pages –Learner Owned www.issbc.org
  • 18.
    www.issbc.org Resume Audio Intro Past Projects Certificates Publications
  • 19.
    ePortfolios: leveraging the“e” The “Flexible Binder” for the 21st Century • Information Management capabilities – Collecting, archiving, sharing, multiple versioning – Quick links to cross-reference evidence – Accessible multimedia with free Web 2.0 tools – Align to frameworks, rubrics, track learning over time • Social learning, digital identity – Building professional profile, Personal Learning network • Digital technology skills, Internet literacy – Demonstrated by and within the ePortfolio • Learning and collaboration integration – Online research: documents, networks – Easy to add comments, edit, mentor, coach
  • 20.
    New service: savvyfolio.net Multi-institution ePortfolio community Professional Body Workplace Trainer College Employer Industry Sector Body University Adult Learning Centre Employability Agency
  • 21.
    Digital credentials FORand OF learning Micro-credentialing using Open Badges
  • 22.
  • 23.
    Open Badges andBadge Passports “Micro credentials in a modular eportfolio” Richard Wyles, Totara LMS at MaharaUK12 http://maharauk.org/mod/resource/view.php?id=117
  • 24.
    A picture +descriptive words… Simple data structure for easy sharing bit.ly/ePIC2013_Belshaw
  • 25.
    Badges in Action Demonstration
  • 26.
    Origins • Badges,medals, ribbons since pre-Roman times • Military, Boy Scouts http://jproc.ca/rrp/apend_l_trade_designators_1960.html • Public recognition rewarding positive (desired) behaviour
  • 27.
    Recent corporate trends Social media, gamification for productivity tech.co/gamify-your-new-hire-onboarding-process-with- mindtickle-2013-02 http://www.tibbr.com/
  • 28.
    Gamification and engagement Air Canada earnyourwings.aircanada.com 114,716 registrations $26.2 million added revenue ROI >500% t.co/ZQEjrL0BxE
  • 29.
    Gamification and mathskills Khan Academy: Internal Badges for Learning
  • 30.
    Gamification of physicalreality Foursquare socialmediaexaminer.com
  • 31.
    Recent productivity trends Social enterprise and process gamification joshbersin.com/2011/07/17/badges-swarm-the-internet-and-soon-intranet/ http://www.cornerstoneondemand.com/connect
  • 32.
    Gamification of Onboarding New employee orientation
  • 33.
    Enterprise Gamification Consultingoverview “One trend we are seeing is enterprises seeking to instill a more proactive attitude about career development among the workforce.” Download PDF
  • 34.
    Gamification of languagelearning Duolingo – scaffolded text translation youtu.be/WyzJ2Qq9Abs en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Duolingo
  • 35.
    Gamification of languagelearning busuu.com – Farmville for language? Common European Framework of Reference (CEFR):
  • 36.
    Gamification of integration Citizenship course for Youth (Ontario)
  • 37.
    Open Badges Alearning ecosystem http://openmatt.org/ Goal #openbadgesMOOC
  • 38.
    Open Badges Makinglearning visible • Progress markers – Motivating learners, supporting advisors • Learning pathways – Granular, incremental, flexible • Visual branding – Issuers and learners • Online trust system – Demonstrate skills & capabilities
  • 39.
    Badge Pathways MozillaDiscover (Gates funding) http://discover.openbadges.org/
  • 40.
    Pearson Acclaim (VUE) If Pearson are getting into badges.… Acclaim’s unique approach…is to work with academic institutions and high-stakes credentialing organizations to offer diplomas, certificates and other professional credentials as Open Badges. blog.youracclaim.com/
  • 41.
    Books@Work College-led studygroups in workplaces http://www.booksatwork.org/the-bookswork-badge/
  • 42.
    Badging Health Professionals Continuing Professional Development http://www.paincommunitycentre.org/cpd/badges
  • 43.
    Benefits Open Badges& Digital Certification • Visually efficient and appealing – Fun, motivating to earn (gamification) – Visualize progress for advising – Automatically / manually awarded • Individual learning pathways – Modular, flexible, diverse, portable, shareable – Personal goal setting, achievement for self-directed learning – Builds confidence – Blend and ladder from multiple sources in badge passports & ePortfolios – Progress in incomplete programs can still be recognized and recombined • Transparent, “trustable” – Criteria, evidence, issue/expiry date – Ongoing connection to issuer – Report outcomes – Issuer is validated and branded by the badges it issues, along with 3rd party endorsement (coming)
  • 44.
    Badges and Immigrants Ideas for EAL (to be validated) • FORMATIVE – Portfolio Based Language Assessment (PBLA) progress tracking – Course activities and assignments – Self-directed learning achievements – # books/articles read, docs written, grammar/vocab quizzes (self-assessments) & exercises, journal reflections and other portfolio inventory tasks completed – Recognize/aggregate achievements from external language programs • Rosetta Stone, Tell Me More, busuu.com, etc. – Enhance with Essential Skills, workplace culture learning • Digital Technology, Working with Others, problem solving, etc. – Real world badge “missions” – # “stretch” assignments in the real world (e.g. conversations with strangers) • SUMMATIVE – Internal: CLB levels in progress reports: e.g. Reading: Developing 7 (linked to evidence as appropriate) – External: IELTS scores?
  • 45.
    Badges and Immigrants Ideas for Employability (to be validated) • FORMATIVE – Workshop program/job search milestones, achievements • CV, cover letter, elevator speech, employability portfolio – Real world badge “missions” – # “stretch” assignments in the real world (e.g. # cold calls, # informational interviews…) • SUMMATIVE – For service providers and funders • Learner achievements: CVs, interviews, placements, hirings, etc. – For Employers • Essential Skills assessments (TOWES, Prove It, Microsoft, etc.) – Computer, Document Use, etc. • Job-related language assessments (e.g. IELTS) • Courses/workshops taken • Affiliations (e.g. Toastmasters, professional associations) • Volunteer service, other experiential learning • Summary credentials (“work ready”, etc. if available)
  • 46.
    Badging Kirkpatrick ForEAL (to be validated) Kirkpatrick Level Affordances & Indicators 5: ROI (Phillips) Badge reports of outcomes linked to budgets 4: Results Badge trails, aligned to CLB, by date? Badges linked to PBLA evidence. Badges from subsequent language learning. NB: Follow-up and learner cooperation required 3: Transfer Badge collections: sequencing, laddering, clustering Badges from multiple sources curated in badge passports & channeled to goals Badges in eportfolios enhanced with reflection 2: Learning Badges with embedded skills outcomes 1: Reaction Visual appeal, gamification, completion
  • 47.
    Badging Kirkpatrick Foremployability (to be validated) Kirkpatrick Level Affordances & Indicators 5: ROI (Phillips) Badge reports on longer term employment outcomes 4: Results Badges for interviews, placements? Badges for permanent hires (in their field)? Badges for retention: still working after 1 year? NB: Follow-up and learner cooperation required 3: Transfer Badge collections: sequencing, laddering, clustering Badges from multiple sources curated in badge passports & channeled to goals Badges in eportfolios enhanced with reflection 2: Learning Badges with embedded skills outcomes 1: Reaction Visual appeal, gamification, activity completion
  • 48.
    Badges for PD? Ideas for EAL and Employment Professionals • Conference badges – Participant, Presenter, “Networker”, “Reflector”, etc. • Online community badges – As above, other activities (e.g. link sharing) + peer assessments • Non-formal learning – Workshops, lectures, ConEd programs, Special Interest Groups, reading logs, MOOCs • Awards and recognition – Including “honourable mentions” and short lists • Professional affiliations and volunteer service … arranged/curated in a professional eportfolio or “badge passport” with other evidence
  • 49.
    Badges for EALPD English Online Criteria: Attended webinar training/preparation session, presented online, contributed to the resource page and discussion thread) Evidence: <link to webinar recording> Upcoming for 2015: “Contributor” myenglishonline.ca/for-teachers/realize/
  • 50.
    Open Badge Factory Centralized badge management bit.ly/ePIC2013_Rousselle
  • 51.
    Open Badge Factory Detailed Reports
  • 52.
    Open Badge Factory Badge Application
  • 53.
    Features and Benefits openbadgefactory.com • Current: – Controlled access for organizations – Controlled roles within organizations • Creator, Issuer, Administrator – Detailed reports – Badge applications – Milestone badges • Level up… – Earner evidence field • Coming (Sep-Dec 2014): – Badge Passports • Private/public badges, badge collections, mobile display • Multilingual badges • Issuer community features: sharing and endorsement of badges
  • 54.
    Link to presentation: bit.ly/openbadges4immigrants don@learningagents.ca Web: learningagents.ca Twitter: donpresant ePortfolio: donpresant.ca