How to REALLY
improve lessons!
TES, 5/3/2010


 1 in 13 “failing schools”
Doubled since September
“pre-occupied with exam
 results, meeting guidelines
  introduced to safeguard
children from sex offenders”
Schools with “low” raw exam results
will be unable to achieve an overall
 outstanding or good grade, except in
“the most exceptional circumstances”
        new OFSTED FRAMEWORK
“In nine years of working on inspections I
            have never known fear like it.”
                                   KEITH DENNIS, INSPECTIONS CONSULTANT, ASCL



   Judgements before and after the new framework (%)
                   outstanding         good         satisfactory     inadequate

     special             39 33.5          46 38.1         12 24.5           3 3.0

    primary               16 7.1          52 42.6           29 43           3 7.3

   secondary              22 9.5          41 36.7           31 44           6 9.7

   all schools            19 9.2          50 41.3           28 42           4 7.5

Figures in red are percentage of schools receiving judgements in 2008/09
Figures in red are percentage of schools receiving judgements in between
Sept 09 and Feb 2010 under new framework
“Everything ratched up”


       “We’re having to jump higher and higher
       through more hoops to move forward”


“The expectation that the attainment of all children will
 reach the national standard regardless of their starting
          point is tough on schools like ours.”


                          JANET REID, HEADTEACHER
5 Questions
Do we know our - strengths and weaknesses?




                    5 Questions
Do we know our - strengths and weaknesses?

Are our improvement priorities based on them?




                     5 Questions
Do we know our - strengths and weaknesses?

Are our improvement priorities based on them?

         Are they the right priorities?




                       5 Questions
Do we know our - strengths and weaknesses?

Are our improvement priorities based on them?

         Are they the right priorities?

Are they being acted on with sufficient urgency?




                       5 Questions
Do we know our - strengths and weaknesses?

     Are our improvement priorities based on them?

               Are they the right priorities?

     Are they being acted on with sufficient urgency?

Are they resulting in better progress and rising standards?




                             5 Questions
National Challenge (exam results)

             Literacy

            Numeracy

   Student Numbers at Malling

          Pupil Attitudes

Insufficient Attainment by Specific
       Groups of Students

        Assessment (AfL)
Environment & Resources
                               ICT Infrastructure
       The Federation
                      Student Numbers at Holmesdale
Student & Teacher Relationships
                                    Growing Sixth Form
 AEN
          Extra-curricular activities
                                      Trust Status
   Strong Governing Body
                              TAs and LSAs
        Sport       Vertical Tutoring         Libraries
                                  Tydeman Centre
Specialist School Status
                             Community Links
       Training School     Curriculum Development
Better progress & raising standards
won’t come from increased monitoring or
trying to radically improve current practice...




                        ...it’ll come from changes to
              curriculum and aspirations to meet the
               skills needs of the 21st Century!
Standards in many state
                              schools are "woefully
                              low" and employers
                              must "pick up the
                              pieces" SIR TERRY LEAHY, TESCO

                               40% of employers
                               seriously concerned
                               about school leavers’
employers want "an
                               literacy and numeracy;
education system that
                               17% providing remedial
equips young people
                               help JOHN CRIDLAND, CBI
with the right skills and
mindset for the world of
work" TOM IRONSIDE, BRITISH   Economically Valuable Skills
        RETAIL CONSORTIUM
Leith Report (2006)
 over 1/3 school leavers unqualified
 over 50% adults have trouble with numbers
 1 in 7 are not functionally literate


UK has to become a world leader in skills

    Skills = “economically valuable skills”
            which are demand-led
TRANSFORMATION TEAM

Employers’ Consultation
       Evening
Future Socio-                2020 targets
 economic Trends
                     Parents

                               Exam Boards / QCDA
      Staff

                   Curriculum
                                          Students
      Employers


                         Futher & Higher Education
Stakeholders
What Skills?
“Employers consistently identify the kinds of people they
want in their workplaces. They want people who are
literate and numerate and have information
technological skills. They look for people who can build
and maintain relationships, work productively in teams
and communicate effectively. They look for problem-
solvers, people who take responsibility and make
decisions and are flexible, adaptable and willing to learn
new skills.”

                QCA Futures Programme
QCA Futures            PLTS          Opening       Creative       FutureLab     Core Skills
 Programme                             Minds        Learning        (study)

literate and
                                                                                 Literacy (includes speaking & listening)
numerate                                                                         Numeracy
information
technological
                                   managing
                                   information
                                                 distributed
                                                 cognition
                                                                 developing
                                                                 ideas           Digital Information (ICT)
skills (ICT)

building and       effective       relating to
maintaining        participators   people                                        Interpersonal Skills
relationships

working            Teamworkers     managing      community and   collaboration
                                                                                 relating to others (social skills)
productively in
teams
                                   people        communication                   team-work, leadership & networking
problem-solving Creative                                         making          citizenship & career development
                Thinkers                                         connections

taking             Self-Managers                                 communication
responsibility                                                   and             Learning Skills
and making                                                       collaboration
decisions                                                                        Knowledge building & problem-solving (KS3)
flexibilty,
adaptability and
                   effective
                   participators
                                                 engagement                      independent enquiry
willingness to
work
                                                                                 Critical thinking (KS4)
                   reflective       learning      knowledge
                   learners                      builders
                                                                                 Self-management Skills
                   independent
                   enquirers                                                     decision-making & resourcefulness
                                   citizenship                                   engagement & perseverance
                                                                 creating and
                                                                 making          work ethic & adaptability

                                                                                 Creativity Skills
Competencies                                                                     conceptualising & imagining

What Skills?
                                                                                 creating & making
                                                                                 reflection & refinement
Better Lessons...
Better Lessons...
adopt a competencies-based (skills) approach
to learning

students understand and do rather than
acquire a body of knowledge

use new technologies

flexible, personalised learning takes place

there is “independent” rather than “receptive”
learning taking place
exam results

OFSTED     National Curriculum

 Develop Craft of
  the Classroom
                      motivation
organisation
     &          behaviour
procedures     management
support social skills
take skills-based approach to planning,     develop critical
         delivery & assessment                  thinkers
                                      Innovate
    exam results avoid “didactic” teaching
                   & “receptive” learning
OFSTED     National Curriculum
                        students active: doing
 Develop Craft of
                           & understanding
   the Classroom
                                         use ICT for
                     motivation         collaborative,
 organisation
                                      communicative &
      &       behaviour               creative activities
 procedures management

Ofsted And Mhf

  • 1.
  • 2.
    TES, 5/3/2010 1in 13 “failing schools” Doubled since September
  • 3.
    “pre-occupied with exam results, meeting guidelines introduced to safeguard children from sex offenders”
  • 5.
    Schools with “low”raw exam results will be unable to achieve an overall outstanding or good grade, except in “the most exceptional circumstances” new OFSTED FRAMEWORK
  • 6.
    “In nine yearsof working on inspections I have never known fear like it.” KEITH DENNIS, INSPECTIONS CONSULTANT, ASCL Judgements before and after the new framework (%) outstanding good satisfactory inadequate special 39 33.5 46 38.1 12 24.5 3 3.0 primary 16 7.1 52 42.6 29 43 3 7.3 secondary 22 9.5 41 36.7 31 44 6 9.7 all schools 19 9.2 50 41.3 28 42 4 7.5 Figures in red are percentage of schools receiving judgements in 2008/09 Figures in red are percentage of schools receiving judgements in between Sept 09 and Feb 2010 under new framework
  • 7.
    “Everything ratched up” “We’re having to jump higher and higher through more hoops to move forward” “The expectation that the attainment of all children will reach the national standard regardless of their starting point is tough on schools like ours.” JANET REID, HEADTEACHER
  • 8.
  • 9.
    Do we knowour - strengths and weaknesses? 5 Questions
  • 10.
    Do we knowour - strengths and weaknesses? Are our improvement priorities based on them? 5 Questions
  • 11.
    Do we knowour - strengths and weaknesses? Are our improvement priorities based on them? Are they the right priorities? 5 Questions
  • 12.
    Do we knowour - strengths and weaknesses? Are our improvement priorities based on them? Are they the right priorities? Are they being acted on with sufficient urgency? 5 Questions
  • 13.
    Do we knowour - strengths and weaknesses? Are our improvement priorities based on them? Are they the right priorities? Are they being acted on with sufficient urgency? Are they resulting in better progress and rising standards? 5 Questions
  • 14.
    National Challenge (examresults) Literacy Numeracy Student Numbers at Malling Pupil Attitudes Insufficient Attainment by Specific Groups of Students Assessment (AfL)
  • 15.
    Environment & Resources ICT Infrastructure The Federation Student Numbers at Holmesdale Student & Teacher Relationships Growing Sixth Form AEN Extra-curricular activities Trust Status Strong Governing Body TAs and LSAs Sport Vertical Tutoring Libraries Tydeman Centre Specialist School Status Community Links Training School Curriculum Development
  • 16.
    Better progress &raising standards won’t come from increased monitoring or trying to radically improve current practice... ...it’ll come from changes to curriculum and aspirations to meet the skills needs of the 21st Century!
  • 17.
    Standards in manystate schools are "woefully low" and employers must "pick up the pieces" SIR TERRY LEAHY, TESCO 40% of employers seriously concerned about school leavers’ employers want "an literacy and numeracy; education system that 17% providing remedial equips young people help JOHN CRIDLAND, CBI with the right skills and mindset for the world of work" TOM IRONSIDE, BRITISH Economically Valuable Skills RETAIL CONSORTIUM
  • 18.
    Leith Report (2006) over 1/3 school leavers unqualified over 50% adults have trouble with numbers 1 in 7 are not functionally literate UK has to become a world leader in skills Skills = “economically valuable skills” which are demand-led
  • 19.
  • 20.
    Future Socio- 2020 targets economic Trends Parents Exam Boards / QCDA Staff Curriculum Students Employers Futher & Higher Education Stakeholders What Skills?
  • 21.
    “Employers consistently identifythe kinds of people they want in their workplaces. They want people who are literate and numerate and have information technological skills. They look for people who can build and maintain relationships, work productively in teams and communicate effectively. They look for problem- solvers, people who take responsibility and make decisions and are flexible, adaptable and willing to learn new skills.” QCA Futures Programme
  • 22.
    QCA Futures PLTS Opening Creative FutureLab Core Skills Programme Minds Learning (study) literate and Literacy (includes speaking & listening) numerate Numeracy information technological managing information distributed cognition developing ideas Digital Information (ICT) skills (ICT) building and effective relating to maintaining participators people Interpersonal Skills relationships working Teamworkers managing community and collaboration relating to others (social skills) productively in teams people communication team-work, leadership & networking problem-solving Creative making citizenship & career development Thinkers connections taking Self-Managers communication responsibility and Learning Skills and making collaboration decisions Knowledge building & problem-solving (KS3) flexibilty, adaptability and effective participators engagement independent enquiry willingness to work Critical thinking (KS4) reflective learning knowledge learners builders Self-management Skills independent enquirers decision-making & resourcefulness citizenship engagement & perseverance creating and making work ethic & adaptability Creativity Skills Competencies conceptualising & imagining What Skills? creating & making reflection & refinement
  • 23.
  • 24.
    Better Lessons... adopt acompetencies-based (skills) approach to learning students understand and do rather than acquire a body of knowledge use new technologies flexible, personalised learning takes place there is “independent” rather than “receptive” learning taking place
  • 26.
    exam results OFSTED National Curriculum Develop Craft of the Classroom motivation organisation & behaviour procedures management
  • 27.
    support social skills takeskills-based approach to planning, develop critical delivery & assessment thinkers Innovate exam results avoid “didactic” teaching & “receptive” learning OFSTED National Curriculum students active: doing Develop Craft of & understanding the Classroom use ICT for motivation collaborative, organisation communicative & & behaviour creative activities procedures management

Editor's Notes

  • #2 Trans Team putting things together
  • #3 Shenfied High School - downgraded - “Good with Outstanding Features” Now “Satisfactory” - John Fairhurst (head) claims they used one year group’s figures rather than 3 year trends
  • #4 New emphasis on pupil safety - claims that they have been marked down for risks like “low door handles”
  • #5 While the framework has identified 8 priorities, it seems to be concentrating on... results
  • #6 “raising the bar” implies improving quality - within a narrow focus that seems to be ignoring the context schools face
  • #7 Keith Dennis: real issue is the greater emphasis on raw exam results or “attainment” - school problems like recruiting Maths & English teachers - regardless of the challenging intake of a school
  • #8 Experience of inspected schools is different; Janet Reid, Yeo Valley Primary - gone from “Good” 3 years ago to “Inadequate”
  • #9 Whatever position you are: teacher, middle leader, VP, TT Issues of leadership
  • #10 Whatever position you are: teacher, middle leader, VP, TT Issues of leadership
  • #11 Whatever position you are: teacher, middle leader, VP, TT Issues of leadership
  • #12 Whatever position you are: teacher, middle leader, VP, TT Issues of leadership
  • #13 Whatever position you are: teacher, middle leader, VP, TT Issues of leadership
  • #14 Areas need developing These are in no order...
  • #15 So many strengths... so much happening... so much OFSTED isn’t interested in.
  • #16 Deborah Andrew. Evidence & research showing that monitoring doesn’t lead to improvement. You need to know the data/facts/what’s going on... but it also needs curriculum change
  • #17 Concerns by employers (this stretches back to 60s) Every time results issued, CBI issues response - inevitably drawing attention to mis-match of qualifications & employment skills. Maths & Science. Mike Perry.
  • #18 Raised this with middle leaders: economically-driven, demand led
  • #21 Changes to curriculum: Core Skills, Social Skills, Learning Skills, Self-Management, Creativity
  • #23 How does this all link to better skills? Competencies-based approach; understanding & doing; ICT rich (3 C’s); flexible; non-receptive
  • #24 How does this all link to better skills? Competencies-based approach; understanding & doing; ICT rich (3 C’s); flexible; non-receptive
  • #25 How does this all link to better skills? Competencies-based approach; understanding & doing; ICT rich (3 C’s); flexible; non-receptive
  • #26 How does this all link to better skills? Competencies-based approach; understanding & doing; ICT rich (3 C’s); flexible; non-receptive
  • #27 How does this all link to better skills? Competencies-based approach; understanding & doing; ICT rich (3 C’s); flexible; non-receptive