Sustaining livelihoods, caring for the
planet: An agro-ecological approach
       to rooibos production
        Contribution to the Special Session
     “Agroecology as a powerful tool for the
            development of drylands”
                   Noel Oettle
  Environmental Monitoring Group, South Africa
At the northern
extremity of the Cape
Floristic Region, in the
arid west of South
Africa an isolated
farming community
descended from the
‘first people’ applies
agro-ecological
approaches in
producing a tea from
indigenous Aspalathus
linearis, or rooibos
Woman farmer Tempes Fortuin with a
sheaf of her freshly harvested rooibos
Small-scale farmers of the Suid Bokkeveld joined
together in 2001 to form a co-operative that promotes
and exports their product as an ecologically-sound
product made in the traditional manner
Processing the green rooibos on the tea court: natural
enzymes transform the tea from green to red before it is dried
Spreading out the transformed rooibos to dry in the sun
Developing market-linked ecological
            agriculture
• Identification with nature and tradition pre-disposed
  these farmers to ecological approaches
• Market incentives for organic products via the Fair
  Trade market promoted ecological agriculture
• Certification, knowledge sharing and education
  enhanced the understanding of ecological processes
  in rooibos production
Promoting Heiveld Rooibos Tea at the BioFach
Organic Trade Fair in Nuremberg, Germany
Social context: marginalised people who have experienced
multiple poverties since colonialism dispossessed their
forebears of land (land access is still severely limited for
people of indigenous descent)
Environmental context: richly biodiverse ecosystem whose
plant riches etc. are being depleted by modern, mono-cultural
agriculture
Biologically diverse and well-adapted endemic wild
rooibos has increasingly been replaced by plantations
Within a Participatory Action Research
 context, farmers answered their research
         questions with scientists:
• Can we verify that wild rooibos is more
  resilient to drought and climate variability?
• How can we use the wild resource sustainably
  and profitably?
• What can we do to increase the resilience of
  our farming systems that produce cultivated
  rooibos?
Following 3
years of
research on
management of
wild rooibos, the
outcomes of the
research were
condensed into
a farmers’
handbook
Heiveld members harvest their wild rooibos in accordance with
scientifically verified practices based on pre-existing local knowledge
Burning trial plots in old veld in autumn 2009
Wild rooibos seedlings emerge after the first winter rains
A mature wild rooibos plant re-sprouts after the fire: these plants
are far longer-lived than cultivated rooibos (>50 years vs. <5 years)
Surveys of species and plant cover are conducted annually
Blomfontein                               Burn                              Control                           Burn                               Control                  Limeum africanum                                                                     *
                               Plot A (sw)                         Plot B (nw)                      Plot C (ne)                        Plot D (se)                        Lobostemon argenteus                     *   *       *   *   *
Species                        Apr           2009    2010   2011 Apr           2009   2010   2011 Apr             2009 2010     2011 Apr             2009   2010   2011   Lobostemon echioides                     *   *               *
                                                                                                                                                                          Macrostylis squarrosa                            1           *   1   1   1   1   *   *   *   *
Adenogramma glomerata                            *      *      *                  *      1      *                    *      *      *                    *      *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Metalasia densa                  1   *   *   *           *   *   1   1   1   1   1   1   1   1
Aizoon sarmentosum                                      *      *                         *      *                                  *
                                                                                                                                                                          Metalasia fastigiata                                             *   *   *   *
Albuca cooperi                                   *
                                                                                                                                                                          Moraea fugacissima                                           *                       *       *
Anthospermum spathulatum              *                 *      *        1         *      *      *         1          1      1      1         1          1      1      1
                                                                                                                                                                          Moraea cookii                                        *       *                       *       *
Arctotis cf. bellidifolius                              *      *                         *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Moraea fugax                                                             *   *
Aristea dichotoma                     *          *      *      *                  *      *      *                                            *          *      *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Nemesia anisocarpa                   *   *   *       *   *   *                           *   *
Aspalathus linearis                              *      2      2                  *      1      2         1          1      2      2         1          1      1      1
                                                        *      *                         *      *                                                                         Oxalis flava                     *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *       *   *   *       *   *   *
Athanasia cf leptocephala

Babiana engysiphon                               *      *      *                  *      *      *                           *      *                    *      *      *   Oxalis luteola                           *   *           *   *           *   *           *   *

Babiana mucronata                                                                                                           *      *                                      Oxalis obtusa                        *   *   *       *   *   *       *   *   *       *   *   *

Centella tridentata                                     *      *                         *      *                                                                         Pelargonium coronopifolium               *   *               *                           *   *

Chlorophytum undulatum                           *      *      *                  *      *      *                    *      *      *                    *             *   Pelargonium longifolium              *       *                       *   *   *
                                                                                                                                                                          Pelargonium scabrum                      *                                       *
Chlorophytum viscosum                 *          *      *      *        *         *      *      *         *          *                       *          *
                                      1          *      *      *        *                *      *                                            *          *      *      *   Pelargonium triste                   1   1   *               *
Chrysocoma ciliata
                                      1          *      *      *        2         *      *      *         *          *      1      1         1          1      1      1   Pentaschistis curvifolia     *       *   *   *   *   *       *
Cliffortia teretifolia

Cotula nudicaulis                                *      *      *                  *      *      *                           *                           *                 Pentaschistis patula             2   2   2   1   *   2   2   1   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *

Crassula fascicularis                 *                                 *                                 *          *      *      *                           *      *   Phylica rigidifolia              1   *   *   *

Crassula filiformis                              *      *      *                  *      *      *                                                                     *   Polpoda stipulacea                                       *   *

Cyphia dentata                                                                                  *                           *      *         *          *      *      *   Polycarena batteniana                *   *   *           *   *
Diascia elongata                                 *             *                  *             *                                                                         Rafnia cf alata                      *   1   1       *   1   1
Dimorpotheca tragus                                     *      *                         *      1                                                       *      *      *   Rhus dissecta                    *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *   *           *   *   *   *
Chenopodiopsis hirta                             *      *      *                  *      *      *                                                                         Ruschia dichroa                                                  *   *           *   *   *   *
Disperis circumflexa                                                              *             *                                                       *             *   Ruschiella lunulata              1   *   *   *   1       *   *   1   1   1   1   *   *   *   *
Ehrharta thunbergii                   1          2      1      1                  *      1      1                                            1          1      1      1   Senecio sp                           *   *   *       *   *   *       *   *   *
Erica rigidula                                                                                            *          *      *                                             Stoebe fusca                     1   *   *   *   1           *   1   1   1   1   2   2   2   2
Euclea lancea                         *          *      *      *        *                                                                                                 Struthiola leptantha                     *   *           *   *
Euphorbia tuberosa                               *      *      *                  *      *      *                    *      *      *                                      Tetragonia hirsuta                   *   *               *   *       *               *
Felicia dubia                                           *                                *      *                    *      *      *                                      Tetraria cf. picta                               *   *       *                           *   *
Ficinia bulbosa                                         1      1                         *      *                                                                         Thamnochortus platypteris        2           *   1               2   2   3   3   *   *   1   1
Ficinia indica                                          *      *                         *      1                                                                     *   Trachyandra cf. falcata                      *       *       *                       *   *   *
Ficinia laevis                        *          *      *      *                                                                                               *      *                                        *   *           *                               *   *   *
                                                                                                                                                                          Trachyandra divaricata
Gladiolus alatus                                 *      *      *                  *      *                                                                                                                                                     *   *   *               *
                                                                                                                                                                          Trachyandra gracilenta
Gladiolus caryophyllaceus                               *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Ursinia anthemoides                  *       *                       *   *           *   *
Helichrysum micropoides                                        *                                *                           *      *                           *
                                                                                                                                                                          Ursinia sp (perennial)                   *   *
Helichrysum moeserianum               *          *      *      *        *         *      *      *         *                 *      *                           *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Wachendorfia multiflora              *               *               *               *   *
Heliophila sp                                    *      *      *                  *      *      *                    *             *                           *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Wahlenbergia sp nov (sp 3)           *   *               *           *   *           *   *
Hermannia scabra                                        *      *                         *      *
                                                                                                                                                                          Wahlenbergia tenella                     *   *           *   *
Hesperantha paucifolia                           *             *                  *
                                                                                                                                                                          Willdenowia glomerata            2           *   1       *   *   *   *   *   *   2   2   3   3

Ischyrolepis gaudichaudianus          1                 *      *                                          1          1      1      1         *          *      *      *   Cannomois parviflora                         *

Ischyrolepis monanthos                3                 *      *                         *      *         1          1      1      1         2          2      2      2   Microdon dubius                                              *

Isolepis marginata                               *      *      *                  *      *      *                                                                     *   Zygophyllum pygmaea                                          *
Lachenalia elegans                               *                                                                                                                        Schizodium flexuosum                                         *
Lampranthus pakhuisensis                                                                        *         *          *      *      *                                      Ornithogalum cf thyrsoides                                   *                               *
Leucadendron pubescens                1          *      *      *        *         *      *      *                                                              *      *   Pharnaceum cf lineare                                        *
Leucadendron sheilae                                                                                      1          1   dead                                             Gymnodiscus capillaris                                                       *
Zygophyllum pygmaea
                                    Microdon dubius


Pelargonium longifolium

                              Species previously
                              unrecorded on the
                              site subsequently
                              emerged
Long term monitoring of the fire trials provides
  the basis for management decision-making
Farmer innovation in rooibos
          cultivation and SLM
• Traditional practices have been enhanced by
  knowledge exchange and practical
  experimentation
• Combinations of direct seedling, sowing nurse
  crops of cereals, retaining organic material
  and establishing buffer strips have enhanced
  production despite low and variable rainfall
  (100 – 250 mm per annum)
Participatory scientific research
demonstrated that solitary bees
and wasps provide pollination
services to rooibos plants (and
wasps also control pests)




                                    These insects
                                    require specific
                                    undisturbed
                                    habitats (old
                                    wood, wetlands,
                                    etc)
Shelter belts of natural vegetation maintain biodiversity in cultivated areas,
controlling soil erosion and providing habitat for pollinators and predators
Keeping an eye out
for rodents: natural
control of problem
animals
Simple but effective
technology provides a perch
for the owls, and their scat
provides the evidence of their
contribution to controlling
rodent numbers
In conclusion …….
• The socio-cultural heritage of the farmers
  predisposes them to agro-ecological agriculture
• The Co-operative has been a vehicle for
  enhancing sustainable production practices via
  market-facing incentives and capacity
  development
• Participatory scientific research has verified and
  enhanced traditional agro-ecological practices
• People’s identity, self-sufficiency, livelihoods and
  sense of self-worth have all been enhanced
Thank you!!

Noel Maxwell OETTLE "Agro-ecological rooibos production"

  • 1.
    Sustaining livelihoods, caringfor the planet: An agro-ecological approach to rooibos production Contribution to the Special Session “Agroecology as a powerful tool for the development of drylands” Noel Oettle Environmental Monitoring Group, South Africa
  • 2.
    At the northern extremityof the Cape Floristic Region, in the arid west of South Africa an isolated farming community descended from the ‘first people’ applies agro-ecological approaches in producing a tea from indigenous Aspalathus linearis, or rooibos
  • 3.
    Woman farmer TempesFortuin with a sheaf of her freshly harvested rooibos
  • 4.
    Small-scale farmers ofthe Suid Bokkeveld joined together in 2001 to form a co-operative that promotes and exports their product as an ecologically-sound product made in the traditional manner
  • 5.
    Processing the greenrooibos on the tea court: natural enzymes transform the tea from green to red before it is dried
  • 6.
    Spreading out thetransformed rooibos to dry in the sun
  • 7.
    Developing market-linked ecological agriculture • Identification with nature and tradition pre-disposed these farmers to ecological approaches • Market incentives for organic products via the Fair Trade market promoted ecological agriculture • Certification, knowledge sharing and education enhanced the understanding of ecological processes in rooibos production
  • 8.
    Promoting Heiveld RooibosTea at the BioFach Organic Trade Fair in Nuremberg, Germany
  • 9.
    Social context: marginalisedpeople who have experienced multiple poverties since colonialism dispossessed their forebears of land (land access is still severely limited for people of indigenous descent) Environmental context: richly biodiverse ecosystem whose plant riches etc. are being depleted by modern, mono-cultural agriculture
  • 10.
    Biologically diverse andwell-adapted endemic wild rooibos has increasingly been replaced by plantations
  • 11.
    Within a ParticipatoryAction Research context, farmers answered their research questions with scientists: • Can we verify that wild rooibos is more resilient to drought and climate variability? • How can we use the wild resource sustainably and profitably? • What can we do to increase the resilience of our farming systems that produce cultivated rooibos?
  • 12.
    Following 3 years of researchon management of wild rooibos, the outcomes of the research were condensed into a farmers’ handbook
  • 13.
    Heiveld members harvesttheir wild rooibos in accordance with scientifically verified practices based on pre-existing local knowledge
  • 14.
    Burning trial plotsin old veld in autumn 2009
  • 15.
    Wild rooibos seedlingsemerge after the first winter rains
  • 16.
    A mature wildrooibos plant re-sprouts after the fire: these plants are far longer-lived than cultivated rooibos (>50 years vs. <5 years)
  • 17.
    Surveys of speciesand plant cover are conducted annually Blomfontein Burn Control Burn Control Limeum africanum * Plot A (sw) Plot B (nw) Plot C (ne) Plot D (se) Lobostemon argenteus * * * * * Species Apr 2009 2010 2011 Apr 2009 2010 2011 Apr 2009 2010 2011 Apr 2009 2010 2011 Lobostemon echioides * * * Macrostylis squarrosa 1 * 1 1 1 1 * * * * Adenogramma glomerata * * * * 1 * * * * * * * Metalasia densa 1 * * * * * 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Aizoon sarmentosum * * * * * Metalasia fastigiata * * * * Albuca cooperi * Moraea fugacissima * * * Anthospermum spathulatum * * * 1 * * * 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 Moraea cookii * * * * Arctotis cf. bellidifolius * * * * Moraea fugax * * Aristea dichotoma * * * * * * * * * * * Nemesia anisocarpa * * * * * * * * Aspalathus linearis * 2 2 * 1 2 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 * * * * Oxalis flava * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Athanasia cf leptocephala Babiana engysiphon * * * * * * * * * * * Oxalis luteola * * * * * * * * Babiana mucronata * * Oxalis obtusa * * * * * * * * * * * * Centella tridentata * * * * Pelargonium coronopifolium * * * * * Chlorophytum undulatum * * * * * * * * * * * Pelargonium longifolium * * * * * Pelargonium scabrum * * Chlorophytum viscosum * * * * * * * * * * * * 1 * * * * * * * * * * Pelargonium triste 1 1 * * Chrysocoma ciliata 1 * * * 2 * * * * * 1 1 1 1 1 1 Pentaschistis curvifolia * * * * * * * Cliffortia teretifolia Cotula nudicaulis * * * * * * * * Pentaschistis patula 2 2 2 1 * 2 2 1 * * * * * * * * Crassula fascicularis * * * * * * * * Phylica rigidifolia 1 * * * Crassula filiformis * * * * * * * Polpoda stipulacea * * Cyphia dentata * * * * * * * Polycarena batteniana * * * * * Diascia elongata * * * * Rafnia cf alata * 1 1 * 1 1 Dimorpotheca tragus * * * 1 * * * Rhus dissecta * * * * * * * * * * * * * * Chenopodiopsis hirta * * * * * * Ruschia dichroa * * * * * * Disperis circumflexa * * * * Ruschiella lunulata 1 * * * 1 * * 1 1 1 1 * * * * Ehrharta thunbergii 1 2 1 1 * 1 1 1 1 1 1 Senecio sp * * * * * * * * * Erica rigidula * * * Stoebe fusca 1 * * * 1 * 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 Euclea lancea * * * * * Struthiola leptantha * * * * Euphorbia tuberosa * * * * * * * * * Tetragonia hirsuta * * * * * * Felicia dubia * * * * * * Tetraria cf. picta * * * * * Ficinia bulbosa 1 1 * * Thamnochortus platypteris 2 * 1 2 2 3 3 * * 1 1 Ficinia indica * * * 1 * Trachyandra cf. falcata * * * * * * Ficinia laevis * * * * * * * * * * * * Trachyandra divaricata Gladiolus alatus * * * * * * * * * Trachyandra gracilenta Gladiolus caryophyllaceus * * Ursinia anthemoides * * * * * * Helichrysum micropoides * * * * * Ursinia sp (perennial) * * Helichrysum moeserianum * * * * * * * * * * * * * Wachendorfia multiflora * * * * * Heliophila sp * * * * * * * * * * Wahlenbergia sp nov (sp 3) * * * * * * * Hermannia scabra * * * * Wahlenbergia tenella * * * * Hesperantha paucifolia * * * Willdenowia glomerata 2 * 1 * * * * * * 2 2 3 3 Ischyrolepis gaudichaudianus 1 * * 1 1 1 1 * * * * Cannomois parviflora * Ischyrolepis monanthos 3 * * * * 1 1 1 1 2 2 2 2 Microdon dubius * Isolepis marginata * * * * * * * Zygophyllum pygmaea * Lachenalia elegans * Schizodium flexuosum * Lampranthus pakhuisensis * * * * * Ornithogalum cf thyrsoides * * Leucadendron pubescens 1 * * * * * * * * * Pharnaceum cf lineare * Leucadendron sheilae 1 1 dead Gymnodiscus capillaris *
  • 18.
    Zygophyllum pygmaea Microdon dubius Pelargonium longifolium Species previously unrecorded on the site subsequently emerged
  • 19.
    Long term monitoringof the fire trials provides the basis for management decision-making
  • 20.
    Farmer innovation inrooibos cultivation and SLM • Traditional practices have been enhanced by knowledge exchange and practical experimentation • Combinations of direct seedling, sowing nurse crops of cereals, retaining organic material and establishing buffer strips have enhanced production despite low and variable rainfall (100 – 250 mm per annum)
  • 22.
    Participatory scientific research demonstratedthat solitary bees and wasps provide pollination services to rooibos plants (and wasps also control pests) These insects require specific undisturbed habitats (old wood, wetlands, etc)
  • 23.
    Shelter belts ofnatural vegetation maintain biodiversity in cultivated areas, controlling soil erosion and providing habitat for pollinators and predators
  • 24.
    Keeping an eyeout for rodents: natural control of problem animals
  • 25.
    Simple but effective technologyprovides a perch for the owls, and their scat provides the evidence of their contribution to controlling rodent numbers
  • 26.
    In conclusion ……. •The socio-cultural heritage of the farmers predisposes them to agro-ecological agriculture • The Co-operative has been a vehicle for enhancing sustainable production practices via market-facing incentives and capacity development • Participatory scientific research has verified and enhanced traditional agro-ecological practices • People’s identity, self-sufficiency, livelihoods and sense of self-worth have all been enhanced
  • 27.