26
Everyone is hunting for the unicorn
“We have world class
universities!”
“The next big thing
will be created here!”
“Jobs galore!
Economic revival!”
FYI: 229 unicorns in June 2016 – 8
are healthcare IT only 2 are
biotech plus Theranos
Let’s play Mad Libs…
“We are Silicon….
(enter geography type here)….Square!”
And everyone is a genius
tech transfer is
hard with mixed
results
14
> Institutional Culture
> Commercial Applicability
> Licensing strategy
> Revenue pressure
Civic leadership doesn’t fully
get this piece and it becomes a
tension point when things don’t
happen quickly
Quick aside/editorial comment
Expand horizons beyond primarily university tech transfer – “knowledge
transfer” is equally if not more powerful especially for tech-enabled
business model innovation – they need your talent to grow and may even
be a partner in focused research
Find methods to communicate potential
success to help manage POLITICAL
“heartburn”later
Illustrating potential biotech company success
The first practical automobile
invented in Springfield MA
The first practical web
browser – National
Supercomputing Applications
Center – Champaign Ill
The electronic book –
Providence RI
29
BCG Study for Germany – Impact of Industry 4.0
Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015
BCG Study for Germany
Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015
 Loss of 610k production related jobs (production (4% of production jobs),
quality control (7%), maintenance, production planning)
 Gain of 210k new jobs related to new technology deployment, integration and
support
 Additional gain of 700k+ jobs from new product opportunities related to
intelligent machinery, and more custom products
 Net gain of 350k jobs
’
Address the “equity” issue through
communication and action
28
Explain the potential job mix…
Clean Tech is one of the Focus
Areas for Pittsburgh’s Roadmap
for Inclusive Innovation
The Green/Clean Economy
Economic activity that produces goods and services with
an environmental benefit or adds value to such products
using skills or technologies that are uniquely applied to
those products.
Pittsburgh’s Leading Sectors:
Energy efficient
building
technology
Renewable energy
and pollution
control
Water
technologies and
services
100 College Street Project
Key Aspects of Development Agreement
Public Improvements:
 Phase 1 Route 34 Tear-Down
 New Bike/Ped Improvements
 Enhanced Streetscape
 New Service Tunnel
Developer Improvements:
• 495,000 s.f. med/lab building
• Public Space
• Active First Floor
Benefits to the Community:
• Tax Revenue
• Construction Workforce (12½)
• Small Business (12¼)
• Bioscience Career Ladder
Economic Impact:
Bioscience Career Ladder
Timeline to start…
2011:
Economic Development Corporation
commissions a study by Ninigret Partners
on workforce development in the
biosciences.
2012:
New Haven Board of Alders approves the
100 College Street DLDA.
2013:
City and Developer develop a pool of
funding to support a bioscience career
ladder.
2014:
City and Southern Connecticut State
University leadership explore a partnership.
2015:
City and SCSU sign landmark MOA, forming
partnership and setting forth the
“Bio-Path”
Bioscience Career Ladder
..and ongoing progress:
2015:
SCSU launches academic and corporate
partnership committees.
2016:
Biology team enters “iGem” competition,
lands bronze medal
2017:
New BS in Biotechnology gains final
approvals, first class in Fall, 2017 semester.
Bioscience Career Ladder
..and ongoing progress:
Community
College Partners
New Haven
Public Schools
Connecticut
Biotechnology Industry
SCSU
(Project Lead)
BCG Study for Germany – Impact of Industry 4.0
Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015
Source: datacamp.com
Data Engineer Data Scientist
Source: Quant Crunch, Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
Source: Quant Crunch, Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
“ ”
Share of Job Postings by Industry
Source: “Quant Crunch”, Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
1
Creating
innovation
Capturing
the
Application
Translating
Innovation
to
Application
Not only “tech”
But also
…business
models
…new takes
on old
products
Sustaining
the
Opportunity
“ecosystem” to
…
Refine
Prototype
Test & Prove
Iterate
Facilities with the
right capacity &
price point
People with the
right skill sets to
bring it to market
First customers
Ability to bring it
to scale
Talent pipeline
by either local
training or an
attractive place
to aid recruiting
Market
accessibility
Thinking maybe all these link as chain?
“ ”
“ ”
- Anil Dash as quoted by Theodore Kinni
Excerpted from MIT Sloan Management Review
“ ”
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
SQL Java JavaScript c# Python PHP Perl c++ Ruby iOS
Cambridge MA vs Stamford, Hartford, New Haven
Coding Language Requirements
CT Cities Cambridge MA
Source: NP analysis of Indeed.com
Imagine if your
focus was
software or smart
electronics…
 Get granular
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
NH City Hartford Only Stamford Only Cambridge Only
jobs
cities
Jobs by Coding Skills by City
iOS
Ruby
c++
Perl
PHP
Python
c#
JavaScript
Java
SQL
Source: NP analysis of Indeed.com
Professional education matters
The dilemma for
smaller scale centers
is the professional
education business
model
Boston Biotech - An extreme example of professional education to
make the point
Source: Quant Crunch, Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
14
’
Innovation activity isn’t enough anymore
Protecting & Strengthening Kendall Square – BCG 2009
GROWTH IN CREATIVE & INNOVATION-BASED ENTERPRISES IS DRIVEN BY
TALENT
And
TALENT IS ATTRACTED BY A COMBINATION OF OPPORTUNITIES & LIFESTYLE
Therefore,
TO WIN AT THE TALENT GAME YOU NEED TO BUILD A DESTINATION
COMMUNITY - THE TYPE OF COMMUNITY WHERE TALENT EITHER WANTS TO
LIVE OR WANTS TO WORK FOR CAREER REASONS AND IDEALLY DOES BOTH
“ ”
Talent
PlaceOpportunity
innovation assets
Tech businesses
½ mile
24
1

Ninigrit - Job Creation Summit 2017

  • 2.
  • 3.
    Everyone is huntingfor the unicorn “We have world class universities!” “The next big thing will be created here!” “Jobs galore! Economic revival!” FYI: 229 unicorns in June 2016 – 8 are healthcare IT only 2 are biotech plus Theranos Let’s play Mad Libs… “We are Silicon…. (enter geography type here)….Square!”
  • 4.
  • 5.
    tech transfer is hardwith mixed results 14 > Institutional Culture > Commercial Applicability > Licensing strategy > Revenue pressure Civic leadership doesn’t fully get this piece and it becomes a tension point when things don’t happen quickly
  • 6.
    Quick aside/editorial comment Expandhorizons beyond primarily university tech transfer – “knowledge transfer” is equally if not more powerful especially for tech-enabled business model innovation – they need your talent to grow and may even be a partner in focused research
  • 7.
    Find methods tocommunicate potential success to help manage POLITICAL “heartburn”later Illustrating potential biotech company success
  • 8.
    The first practicalautomobile invented in Springfield MA The first practical web browser – National Supercomputing Applications Center – Champaign Ill The electronic book – Providence RI
  • 9.
  • 10.
    BCG Study forGermany – Impact of Industry 4.0 Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015
  • 11.
    BCG Study forGermany Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015  Loss of 610k production related jobs (production (4% of production jobs), quality control (7%), maintenance, production planning)  Gain of 210k new jobs related to new technology deployment, integration and support  Additional gain of 700k+ jobs from new product opportunities related to intelligent machinery, and more custom products  Net gain of 350k jobs
  • 12.
  • 13.
    Address the “equity”issue through communication and action 28 Explain the potential job mix…
  • 15.
    Clean Tech isone of the Focus Areas for Pittsburgh’s Roadmap for Inclusive Innovation
  • 17.
    The Green/Clean Economy Economicactivity that produces goods and services with an environmental benefit or adds value to such products using skills or technologies that are uniquely applied to those products. Pittsburgh’s Leading Sectors: Energy efficient building technology Renewable energy and pollution control Water technologies and services
  • 20.
    100 College StreetProject Key Aspects of Development Agreement Public Improvements:  Phase 1 Route 34 Tear-Down  New Bike/Ped Improvements  Enhanced Streetscape  New Service Tunnel Developer Improvements: • 495,000 s.f. med/lab building • Public Space • Active First Floor Benefits to the Community: • Tax Revenue • Construction Workforce (12½) • Small Business (12¼) • Bioscience Career Ladder Economic Impact:
  • 21.
    Bioscience Career Ladder Timelineto start… 2011: Economic Development Corporation commissions a study by Ninigret Partners on workforce development in the biosciences. 2012: New Haven Board of Alders approves the 100 College Street DLDA. 2013: City and Developer develop a pool of funding to support a bioscience career ladder. 2014: City and Southern Connecticut State University leadership explore a partnership. 2015: City and SCSU sign landmark MOA, forming partnership and setting forth the “Bio-Path”
  • 22.
    Bioscience Career Ladder ..andongoing progress: 2015: SCSU launches academic and corporate partnership committees. 2016: Biology team enters “iGem” competition, lands bronze medal 2017: New BS in Biotechnology gains final approvals, first class in Fall, 2017 semester.
  • 23.
    Bioscience Career Ladder ..andongoing progress: Community College Partners New Haven Public Schools Connecticut Biotechnology Industry SCSU (Project Lead)
  • 24.
    BCG Study forGermany – Impact of Industry 4.0 Source: BCG Perspectives Sept 2015
  • 25.
  • 26.
    Source: Quant Crunch,Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
  • 27.
    Source: Quant Crunch,Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
  • 28.
    “ ” Share ofJob Postings by Industry Source: “Quant Crunch”, Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
  • 29.
  • 30.
    Creating innovation Capturing the Application Translating Innovation to Application Not only “tech” Butalso …business models …new takes on old products Sustaining the Opportunity “ecosystem” to … Refine Prototype Test & Prove Iterate Facilities with the right capacity & price point People with the right skill sets to bring it to market First customers Ability to bring it to scale Talent pipeline by either local training or an attractive place to aid recruiting Market accessibility Thinking maybe all these link as chain?
  • 31.
  • 32.
    “ ” - AnilDash as quoted by Theodore Kinni Excerpted from MIT Sloan Management Review
  • 33.
    “ ” 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 SQL JavaJavaScript c# Python PHP Perl c++ Ruby iOS Cambridge MA vs Stamford, Hartford, New Haven Coding Language Requirements CT Cities Cambridge MA Source: NP analysis of Indeed.com
  • 34.
    Imagine if your focuswas software or smart electronics…
  • 35.
  • 38.
    0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 NH City HartfordOnly Stamford Only Cambridge Only jobs cities Jobs by Coding Skills by City iOS Ruby c++ Perl PHP Python c# JavaScript Java SQL Source: NP analysis of Indeed.com
  • 39.
    Professional education matters Thedilemma for smaller scale centers is the professional education business model Boston Biotech - An extreme example of professional education to make the point
  • 40.
    Source: Quant Crunch,Burning Glass Technologies & IBM
  • 41.
  • 42.
    Innovation activity isn’tenough anymore Protecting & Strengthening Kendall Square – BCG 2009
  • 45.
    GROWTH IN CREATIVE& INNOVATION-BASED ENTERPRISES IS DRIVEN BY TALENT And TALENT IS ATTRACTED BY A COMBINATION OF OPPORTUNITIES & LIFESTYLE Therefore, TO WIN AT THE TALENT GAME YOU NEED TO BUILD A DESTINATION COMMUNITY - THE TYPE OF COMMUNITY WHERE TALENT EITHER WANTS TO LIVE OR WANTS TO WORK FOR CAREER REASONS AND IDEALLY DOES BOTH
  • 46.
  • 47.
  • 48.
  • 49.