Place your chosen
image here. The four
corners must just
cover the arrow tips.
For covers, the three
pictures should be the
same size and in a
straight line.
National  Grid’s  Energy  Efficiency  Programs
John Rathbun
Technical Sales and Engineering Support
National Governors Association
Philadelphia, PA March 04, 2013
22
UK Electric
UK Gas
National Grid Overview
Customers
US – 8 Million
UK – 11 Million
2nd Largest US Utility
Pipes & Wires
US – 125,000 miles
UK – 215,000 miles
Largest UK Utility
Service Areas:
Gas
Both Electric and Gas
National Grid Gas and LIPA Electric
System
Electric
4,000 MW Electricity
Generation
3
National Grid:
Second-largest Utility in the U.S.
 The largest distributor of Natural Gas in the northeast U.S.
 Approximately 3.4 million customers in New York, Massachusetts,
and Rhode Island
 Delivers electricity to approximately 3.3 million customers
 Massachusetts, New York and Rhode Island
 Manages the electricity network on Long Island under an agreement with
the Long Island Power Authority
 Serving 1.1 million LIPA customers
 2011 – New US Operating Model
 Jurisdictional areas created state by state to be the local face of
National Grid
 Stronger connected community and customer relationships at a local
level
4
Energy Efficiency Programs
National Grid places a strong emphasis on helping our customers
manage their energy usage and take advantage of new sustainable
energy solutions
National  Grid’s  Energy  Efficiency  Programs  and  Incentives  will:
 Identify energy savings opportunities and provide technical services
for the installation of premium energy efficient equipment to replace
aging, inefficient equipment
 Lower project Costs by up to 50% for installing energy saving
equipment
5
Program Development
 Result of regulatory process - individual  state’s  social,  regulatory  
and policy decisions for both residential and commercial and
industrial customers
 Costs are covered through regulatory filings
Commission orders drive final program
design, incentive and funding levels
Regulatory approval is required for all
programs
7
Customer  Incentive  Options…  
CUSTOM
 Includes measures not covered
under the prescriptive incentives.
 Requires a technical analysis of
proposed energy measures and
associated energy savings to
determine incentive amount.
Incentives are generally the
lesser of:
 Up to 50% of the installed
cost which includes labor and
equipment
 A buy-down of equipment
costs equal to a six months or
a one-year payback
PRESCRIPTIVE
 Fixed incentives paid for
installation of specific,
predetermined energy efficiency
measures and equipment.
 Eligible equipment must
have specified energy
efficiency ratings
 Examples: Lighting,
Lighting Controls, Air
Compressors, EMS,
Heating and Insulation
8
C&I Programs – Prescriptive Programs - Electric
UNY
New Const Retrofit
Lighting n/a Y
Compressed Air n/a Y
Variable Speed Drives n/a n/a
Energy Mgmt Systems* n/a Y
MA
New Const Retrofit
Lighting Y Y
Compressed Air Y Y
Variable Speed Drives Y Y
Energy Mgmt Systems* Y Y
HVAC Y n/a
Chillers Y n/a
DNY
Gas Only Territory
RI
New Const Retrofit
Lighting Y Y
Compressed Air Y n/a
Variable Speed Drives Y Y
Energy Mgmt Systems* Y Y
HVAC Y n/a
Chillers Y n/a
* Includes Vending Misers
9
C&I Programs – Prescriptive Measures - Gas
UNY
New Const Retrofit
Heating Equipment Y Y
Water Heating Y Y
Prescriptive Controls n/a Y
Kitchen Equipment Y Y
Steam Trap Survey n/a Y
MA
New Const Retrofit
Heating Equipment Y Y
Water Heating Y Y
Prescriptive Controls n/a Y
Kitchen Equipment Y Y
DNY*
New Const Retrofit
Heating Equipment Y Y
Water Heating Y Y
Prescriptive Controls Y Y
Kitchen Equipment Y Y
Steam Trap Survey Y Y
RI
New Const Retrofit
Heating Equipment Y Y
Water Heating Y Y
Prescriptive Controls n/a Y
Kitchen Equipment Y Y
Non-Prescriptive Programs: offered in all the above areas
• Energy Efficiency Engineering Study
• Custom Projects
* Includes Multifamily
10
Residential Programs
UNY
Gas Electric
Products & Recycling Y Y
OPower Y Y
Multifamily Y Y
Enhanced Home Sealing Suspended Y
High-Efficiency Heating Y n/a
MA
Gas Electric
Products & Recycling Y Y
OPower Y Y
Multifamily Y Y
Deep Energy Retrofit Y Y
High-Efficiency Heating Y Y
Cool SMART n/a Y
Weatherization Y n/a
Home Energy Assessment Y Y
New Const. & Major Ren. Y Y
Heat Loan Program n/a Y
Work Force Development n/a Y
Education Program n/a Y
Energy Star Lighting n/a Y
DNY*
Gas
Products Y
Enhanced Home Sealing Suspended
High-Efficiency Heating Y
RI
Gas Electric
Products & Recycling n/a Y
Energy Star Lighting n/a Y
Multifamily Y Y
Cool SMART n/a Y
Deep Energy Retrofit n/a Y
Energy Star Homes n/a Y
High-Efficiency Heating Y n/a
Appliance Management Y n/a
* NYC and Long Island
11
What is Shareholder Incentive?
 Financial  “rewards”  for  National  Grid
 Money that is collected from ratepayers (through SBC
and Energy Efficiency)
 National  Grid  is  “rewarded”  financially…
 If we hit savings targets and stay with in budget that has
been agreed on with the regulators
12
Shareholder Incentive - Purpose
 Motivate the successful delivery of energy efficiency
programs to achieve savings goals
 Align business interests with public policy interests
 Partially compensated company for lost sales revenue
 With revenue decoupling, this is less of a factor
 Focus is on components that policy-makers think are
needed to achieve state policy
 Maximize savings
 Cost-effectiveness
 Other elements to drive program design to serve
selected target populations, innovate, and/or be more
comprehensive
13
National Grid Energy Efficiency
Customers Pay
System Benefit
Charge (SBC) or
Energy Efficiency
Charge
CUSTOMER IMPACT
$$ SPEND
Energy saved by
completing project
is recorded towards
goal
Energy
Savings
Target Savings for
Shareholder
Incentive
SHAREHOLDERS
Achieve
Incentive
Make Goal
YES
NO
Possible
penalty
MASS Save
NATIONAL GRID
Energy Efficiency
Programs $$
NYSERDA
Spend $$ on EE
Programs
Develop Program/
Portfolio/Targets
Customer Gets
Incentive
Customer
Completes EE
Project
1414
CHP Developments
 Electric Efficiency Program in MA & RI
 MA Alternative Energy Portfolio
 Rate decoupling
 Standby Tariff
 MA
 RI
 NY
 Technical Assistance
 Marketplace leadership
 US Combined Heat and Power Association
 EPA CHP Partnership
 Northeast Clean Heat and Power Initiative
 Northeast Clean Energy Application Center
 Micro CHP and fuel cells field demonstrations
15
MA & RI CHP Incentive
 Electric Energy Efficiency
Thermal output ~ kW
 $750/kw
 Must pass Benefit cost ratio test
 5 Mw CHP 2011 Largest EE project
 Technical Assessments
 Standby Tariffs
 Interconnect Process
16
Combined Heat Power - CHP
 270 Mw installed on site customer owned generation
 NE – 133 Mw 54 sites
 UNY – 48 Mw 10 sites
 DNY – 89 Mw 128 sites
 Over 72% below 300 kW
 Significant Projects
 NE –
 5.9 Mw at food manufacturer
 5 Mw at Medical School
 5.1 Mw at Pharmaceutical
 Upstate NY
 29 Mw steam turbine at Healthcare facility
 8 Mw ICE engines at Community College
 6 Mw Turbine at Casino/resort
 Downstate NY
 2.4 Mw at Hospital
 2.4 Mw at Shopping Mall
 2.4 Mw at College
16

National grid's energy efficiency programs

  • 1.
    Place your chosen imagehere. The four corners must just cover the arrow tips. For covers, the three pictures should be the same size and in a straight line. National  Grid’s  Energy  Efficiency  Programs John Rathbun Technical Sales and Engineering Support National Governors Association Philadelphia, PA March 04, 2013
  • 2.
    22 UK Electric UK Gas NationalGrid Overview Customers US – 8 Million UK – 11 Million 2nd Largest US Utility Pipes & Wires US – 125,000 miles UK – 215,000 miles Largest UK Utility Service Areas: Gas Both Electric and Gas National Grid Gas and LIPA Electric System Electric 4,000 MW Electricity Generation
  • 3.
    3 National Grid: Second-largest Utilityin the U.S.  The largest distributor of Natural Gas in the northeast U.S.  Approximately 3.4 million customers in New York, Massachusetts, and Rhode Island  Delivers electricity to approximately 3.3 million customers  Massachusetts, New York and Rhode Island  Manages the electricity network on Long Island under an agreement with the Long Island Power Authority  Serving 1.1 million LIPA customers  2011 – New US Operating Model  Jurisdictional areas created state by state to be the local face of National Grid  Stronger connected community and customer relationships at a local level
  • 4.
    4 Energy Efficiency Programs NationalGrid places a strong emphasis on helping our customers manage their energy usage and take advantage of new sustainable energy solutions National  Grid’s  Energy  Efficiency  Programs  and  Incentives  will:  Identify energy savings opportunities and provide technical services for the installation of premium energy efficient equipment to replace aging, inefficient equipment  Lower project Costs by up to 50% for installing energy saving equipment
  • 5.
    5 Program Development  Resultof regulatory process - individual  state’s  social,  regulatory   and policy decisions for both residential and commercial and industrial customers  Costs are covered through regulatory filings Commission orders drive final program design, incentive and funding levels Regulatory approval is required for all programs
  • 6.
    7 Customer  Incentive  Options…  CUSTOM  Includes measures not covered under the prescriptive incentives.  Requires a technical analysis of proposed energy measures and associated energy savings to determine incentive amount. Incentives are generally the lesser of:  Up to 50% of the installed cost which includes labor and equipment  A buy-down of equipment costs equal to a six months or a one-year payback PRESCRIPTIVE  Fixed incentives paid for installation of specific, predetermined energy efficiency measures and equipment.  Eligible equipment must have specified energy efficiency ratings  Examples: Lighting, Lighting Controls, Air Compressors, EMS, Heating and Insulation
  • 7.
    8 C&I Programs –Prescriptive Programs - Electric UNY New Const Retrofit Lighting n/a Y Compressed Air n/a Y Variable Speed Drives n/a n/a Energy Mgmt Systems* n/a Y MA New Const Retrofit Lighting Y Y Compressed Air Y Y Variable Speed Drives Y Y Energy Mgmt Systems* Y Y HVAC Y n/a Chillers Y n/a DNY Gas Only Territory RI New Const Retrofit Lighting Y Y Compressed Air Y n/a Variable Speed Drives Y Y Energy Mgmt Systems* Y Y HVAC Y n/a Chillers Y n/a * Includes Vending Misers
  • 8.
    9 C&I Programs –Prescriptive Measures - Gas UNY New Const Retrofit Heating Equipment Y Y Water Heating Y Y Prescriptive Controls n/a Y Kitchen Equipment Y Y Steam Trap Survey n/a Y MA New Const Retrofit Heating Equipment Y Y Water Heating Y Y Prescriptive Controls n/a Y Kitchen Equipment Y Y DNY* New Const Retrofit Heating Equipment Y Y Water Heating Y Y Prescriptive Controls Y Y Kitchen Equipment Y Y Steam Trap Survey Y Y RI New Const Retrofit Heating Equipment Y Y Water Heating Y Y Prescriptive Controls n/a Y Kitchen Equipment Y Y Non-Prescriptive Programs: offered in all the above areas • Energy Efficiency Engineering Study • Custom Projects * Includes Multifamily
  • 9.
    10 Residential Programs UNY Gas Electric Products& Recycling Y Y OPower Y Y Multifamily Y Y Enhanced Home Sealing Suspended Y High-Efficiency Heating Y n/a MA Gas Electric Products & Recycling Y Y OPower Y Y Multifamily Y Y Deep Energy Retrofit Y Y High-Efficiency Heating Y Y Cool SMART n/a Y Weatherization Y n/a Home Energy Assessment Y Y New Const. & Major Ren. Y Y Heat Loan Program n/a Y Work Force Development n/a Y Education Program n/a Y Energy Star Lighting n/a Y DNY* Gas Products Y Enhanced Home Sealing Suspended High-Efficiency Heating Y RI Gas Electric Products & Recycling n/a Y Energy Star Lighting n/a Y Multifamily Y Y Cool SMART n/a Y Deep Energy Retrofit n/a Y Energy Star Homes n/a Y High-Efficiency Heating Y n/a Appliance Management Y n/a * NYC and Long Island
  • 10.
    11 What is ShareholderIncentive?  Financial  “rewards”  for  National  Grid  Money that is collected from ratepayers (through SBC and Energy Efficiency)  National  Grid  is  “rewarded”  financially…  If we hit savings targets and stay with in budget that has been agreed on with the regulators
  • 11.
    12 Shareholder Incentive -Purpose  Motivate the successful delivery of energy efficiency programs to achieve savings goals  Align business interests with public policy interests  Partially compensated company for lost sales revenue  With revenue decoupling, this is less of a factor  Focus is on components that policy-makers think are needed to achieve state policy  Maximize savings  Cost-effectiveness  Other elements to drive program design to serve selected target populations, innovate, and/or be more comprehensive
  • 12.
    13 National Grid EnergyEfficiency Customers Pay System Benefit Charge (SBC) or Energy Efficiency Charge CUSTOMER IMPACT $$ SPEND Energy saved by completing project is recorded towards goal Energy Savings Target Savings for Shareholder Incentive SHAREHOLDERS Achieve Incentive Make Goal YES NO Possible penalty MASS Save NATIONAL GRID Energy Efficiency Programs $$ NYSERDA Spend $$ on EE Programs Develop Program/ Portfolio/Targets Customer Gets Incentive Customer Completes EE Project
  • 13.
    1414 CHP Developments  ElectricEfficiency Program in MA & RI  MA Alternative Energy Portfolio  Rate decoupling  Standby Tariff  MA  RI  NY  Technical Assistance  Marketplace leadership  US Combined Heat and Power Association  EPA CHP Partnership  Northeast Clean Heat and Power Initiative  Northeast Clean Energy Application Center  Micro CHP and fuel cells field demonstrations
  • 14.
    15 MA & RICHP Incentive  Electric Energy Efficiency Thermal output ~ kW  $750/kw  Must pass Benefit cost ratio test  5 Mw CHP 2011 Largest EE project  Technical Assessments  Standby Tariffs  Interconnect Process
  • 15.
    16 Combined Heat Power- CHP  270 Mw installed on site customer owned generation  NE – 133 Mw 54 sites  UNY – 48 Mw 10 sites  DNY – 89 Mw 128 sites  Over 72% below 300 kW  Significant Projects  NE –  5.9 Mw at food manufacturer  5 Mw at Medical School  5.1 Mw at Pharmaceutical  Upstate NY  29 Mw steam turbine at Healthcare facility  8 Mw ICE engines at Community College  6 Mw Turbine at Casino/resort  Downstate NY  2.4 Mw at Hospital  2.4 Mw at Shopping Mall  2.4 Mw at College 16