Leveling the Playing Field:
   Models of Teaching
            Linda S. Behar-Horenstein, Ph.D.
      Distinguished Teaching Scholar and Professor
   Department of Educational Administration and Policy
                  University of Florida

               Diane Archer-Banks, Ph.D.
                 Program Coordinator
                      UF Alliance
                  College of Education
Imagine the conversation

                Classrooms where
                  teachers carefully
                  explained to students
                  what and how they
                  were going to teach and
                  told students exactly
                  what they wanted
                  students to be able to
                  do as a result of their
                  teaching-learning
                  interactions.
Imagine the sense of sharing

                 The feeling that you
                   were going to be
                   part of something
                   bigger than you.
                 The sense of
                   excitement of
                   learning something
                   new -- that you
                   could almost taste it.
Imagine



The feeling of
 empowerment
Schools as places that students longed
to attend
Overview

Models of teaching
Benefits, limitations
Questions for critical reflection
What are Models of Teaching?

Prescriptive strategies to guide
planning and instruction

Supported by research based-
evidence
Models of Teaching


Detailed overview of how to teach
Role of instructor
Type of classroom structure
Ways teacher supports student
efforts
What are Models of Teaching?


Provide common language to discuss

 facets of instruction common across all

 classrooms among administrators and

 teachers.
What are Models of Teaching?
Conceptual frameworks grouped by
purpose and intended outcomes into 4
families.

Promote awareness about how
individuals and collective faculty teach.

Helps students learn how to learn.
What are Models of Teaching?


Eliminates differences due to gender,
race/ethnicity, socio-economic status.

Increases probability of learning
certain skills/knowledge.
FAMILIES OF TEACHING
      MODELS
INFORMATION-PROCESSING
          FAMILY
Enhances making sense of new
information.


Help students learn how to
construct knowledge.
Information-processing models: An
 example
Fourth grade students seated around a center. Jack
Jones’, the teacher, lights a candle and places a jar with
6 inch circumference over the candle. The candle burns
out.
He repeats this exercise several times with jars of
varying circumference and places them over lighted
candles.
He tells students, “Now we are going to develop some
ideas about what just happened.”
SOCIAL FAMILY

Uses group inquiry and problem-solving
strategies.

Encourages assimilation and
understanding.

Relies on students’ personal and social
values.
Social models: An example
Janie Hrock’s 12th grade class begins with a
videotape of a court room scene. A mother is
fighting to prevent a father from having time
together with their 9 year old daughter. Parents
have joint custody.
As the case proceeds Ms. Hrock asks students to
document the “issues” and their “questions.”
Following the tape, the students describe issues,
defend positions and ask questions.
PERSONAL FAMILY


Emphasizes self-actualizing, self-
awareness, directing destinies.
Exploration and reflection about
goals or future careers.
Personal models: An example
Terrace Banks’ 6th grade students enter
Language Arts classroom on first day of school.
As they take their seats, Banks tells students to
write about what they want to be when they
grow up and asks to them to explain why.
After about 30 minutes, students share essays
aloud. As students read, Banks asks them what
skills they think they will need to enter chosen
professions.
BEHAVIORAL FAMILY

Develop mastery in subject matter
or skills acquisition.
Seeks specific behavioral changes.
Measurable outcomes.
Behavioral models: An example
Lem McCoy’s 4th grade students
arrive to class and find a quiz on
their desks.
Students are given 100, 1 by 1 digit
multiplication problems. McCoy
tells them to complete as many
correctly in 5 minutes are they can.
Explicit use of teaching
models can accelerate rate
of learning, capacity and
facility in learning.
TEACHER BENEFITS
Improves the quality of instruction.




Systematic approach to planning for
instruction.
TEACHER BENEFITS

Facilitates awareness about students’
learning needs.

Assess impact of instruction.

Offers alternative ways of
representing content/skills.
TEACHER BENEFITS

 Develop learning experiences
 that yield successful outcomes.

 Facilitates student engagement
 in more meaningful ways.
STUDENT BENEFITS

Increases aptitude for learning and
retention.

Learn more rapidly.

Facilitates different kinds of
learning.
STUDENT BENEFITS

• Builds academic self-esteem.
• Acknowledges characteristics and
  aptitudes.
• Promotes student awareness of
  how they will be taught and what
 changes are sought.
Caveats
Do not replace pedagogical expertise
– subject matter knowledge
– creativity
– interpersonal skills

No model is effective for everyone

Some methods increase or diminish desired
outcomes
WHY USE MODELS OF TEACHING?


Meet learning needs of heterogeneous
groups.

Varied outcomes, different levels of
sophistication.

Repertoire of approaches.
Questions for Critical Reflection

1.   What models do you use during
     instruction?

2.   What other approaches do you
     want to use?
References
Anusavice, S. H., & Behar-Horenstein, L. S. (2005). Looking into
classrooms:
Student achievement, student absenteeism, teacher efficacy, and teacher
Instruction of highly mobile students in specialized and traditional
school settings. Curriculum and Teaching 20, 15-39.


Behar-Horenstein, L. S., & Ganet-Sigel, J. G. (1999). The Art and Practice of
Dance/Movement Therapy. Needham Heights, MA: Pearson Publishing
Solutions. 209 pp.

Behar-Horenstein, L.S., & Seabert, D. M. (2005). Looking into
classrooms: Teachers' use of models of teaching.
Educational Practice and Theory 27(1), 49-66.
References

Joyce, B. & Calhoun, E. (996). Creating Learning
Experiences: The Role of Instructional Theory and
Research. Alexandria, VA: Association for Curriculum
Development and Supervision.

Joyce, B., Weil, M., & Calhoun, E. (2004). Models of
Teaching. 7th ed. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
Dr. Linda Behar-Horenstein

Distinguished
  Teaching Scholar
  and Professor
University of Florida
Lsbhoren@ufl.edu
(352) 392-2391,
Ext. 299

Models of teaching

  • 1.
    Leveling the PlayingField: Models of Teaching Linda S. Behar-Horenstein, Ph.D. Distinguished Teaching Scholar and Professor Department of Educational Administration and Policy University of Florida Diane Archer-Banks, Ph.D. Program Coordinator UF Alliance College of Education
  • 2.
    Imagine the conversation Classrooms where teachers carefully explained to students what and how they were going to teach and told students exactly what they wanted students to be able to do as a result of their teaching-learning interactions.
  • 3.
    Imagine the senseof sharing The feeling that you were going to be part of something bigger than you. The sense of excitement of learning something new -- that you could almost taste it.
  • 4.
  • 5.
    Schools as placesthat students longed to attend
  • 6.
    Overview Models of teaching Benefits,limitations Questions for critical reflection
  • 8.
    What are Modelsof Teaching? Prescriptive strategies to guide planning and instruction Supported by research based- evidence
  • 9.
    Models of Teaching Detailedoverview of how to teach Role of instructor Type of classroom structure Ways teacher supports student efforts
  • 10.
    What are Modelsof Teaching? Provide common language to discuss facets of instruction common across all classrooms among administrators and teachers.
  • 11.
    What are Modelsof Teaching? Conceptual frameworks grouped by purpose and intended outcomes into 4 families. Promote awareness about how individuals and collective faculty teach. Helps students learn how to learn.
  • 12.
    What are Modelsof Teaching? Eliminates differences due to gender, race/ethnicity, socio-economic status. Increases probability of learning certain skills/knowledge.
  • 13.
  • 14.
    INFORMATION-PROCESSING FAMILY Enhances making sense of new information. Help students learn how to construct knowledge.
  • 15.
    Information-processing models: An example Fourth grade students seated around a center. Jack Jones’, the teacher, lights a candle and places a jar with 6 inch circumference over the candle. The candle burns out. He repeats this exercise several times with jars of varying circumference and places them over lighted candles. He tells students, “Now we are going to develop some ideas about what just happened.”
  • 16.
    SOCIAL FAMILY Uses groupinquiry and problem-solving strategies. Encourages assimilation and understanding. Relies on students’ personal and social values.
  • 17.
    Social models: Anexample Janie Hrock’s 12th grade class begins with a videotape of a court room scene. A mother is fighting to prevent a father from having time together with their 9 year old daughter. Parents have joint custody. As the case proceeds Ms. Hrock asks students to document the “issues” and their “questions.” Following the tape, the students describe issues, defend positions and ask questions.
  • 18.
    PERSONAL FAMILY Emphasizes self-actualizing,self- awareness, directing destinies. Exploration and reflection about goals or future careers.
  • 19.
    Personal models: Anexample Terrace Banks’ 6th grade students enter Language Arts classroom on first day of school. As they take their seats, Banks tells students to write about what they want to be when they grow up and asks to them to explain why. After about 30 minutes, students share essays aloud. As students read, Banks asks them what skills they think they will need to enter chosen professions.
  • 20.
    BEHAVIORAL FAMILY Develop masteryin subject matter or skills acquisition. Seeks specific behavioral changes. Measurable outcomes.
  • 21.
    Behavioral models: Anexample Lem McCoy’s 4th grade students arrive to class and find a quiz on their desks. Students are given 100, 1 by 1 digit multiplication problems. McCoy tells them to complete as many correctly in 5 minutes are they can.
  • 22.
    Explicit use ofteaching models can accelerate rate of learning, capacity and facility in learning.
  • 23.
    TEACHER BENEFITS Improves thequality of instruction. Systematic approach to planning for instruction.
  • 24.
    TEACHER BENEFITS Facilitates awarenessabout students’ learning needs. Assess impact of instruction. Offers alternative ways of representing content/skills.
  • 25.
    TEACHER BENEFITS Developlearning experiences that yield successful outcomes. Facilitates student engagement in more meaningful ways.
  • 26.
    STUDENT BENEFITS Increases aptitudefor learning and retention. Learn more rapidly. Facilitates different kinds of learning.
  • 27.
    STUDENT BENEFITS • Buildsacademic self-esteem. • Acknowledges characteristics and aptitudes. • Promotes student awareness of how they will be taught and what changes are sought.
  • 28.
    Caveats Do not replacepedagogical expertise – subject matter knowledge – creativity – interpersonal skills No model is effective for everyone Some methods increase or diminish desired outcomes
  • 29.
    WHY USE MODELSOF TEACHING? Meet learning needs of heterogeneous groups. Varied outcomes, different levels of sophistication. Repertoire of approaches.
  • 30.
    Questions for CriticalReflection 1. What models do you use during instruction? 2. What other approaches do you want to use?
  • 31.
    References Anusavice, S. H.,& Behar-Horenstein, L. S. (2005). Looking into classrooms: Student achievement, student absenteeism, teacher efficacy, and teacher Instruction of highly mobile students in specialized and traditional school settings. Curriculum and Teaching 20, 15-39. Behar-Horenstein, L. S., & Ganet-Sigel, J. G. (1999). The Art and Practice of Dance/Movement Therapy. Needham Heights, MA: Pearson Publishing Solutions. 209 pp. Behar-Horenstein, L.S., & Seabert, D. M. (2005). Looking into classrooms: Teachers' use of models of teaching. Educational Practice and Theory 27(1), 49-66.
  • 32.
    References Joyce, B. &Calhoun, E. (996). Creating Learning Experiences: The Role of Instructional Theory and Research. Alexandria, VA: Association for Curriculum Development and Supervision. Joyce, B., Weil, M., & Calhoun, E. (2004). Models of Teaching. 7th ed. Boston: Allyn & Bacon.
  • 33.
    Dr. Linda Behar-Horenstein Distinguished Teaching Scholar and Professor University of Florida Lsbhoren@ufl.edu (352) 392-2391, Ext. 299

Editor's Notes

  • #15 ACQUIRING AND ORGANIZING INFORMATION, IDENTIFYING AND SOLVING PROBLEMS LEARNING CONCEPTS.
  • #30 SHOULD BE COMPLEMENTED BY LEARNING EXPERIENCES AND APPROACHES TO TEACHING THAT MOST NEARLY MATCH DESIRED ENDS .