Outsourcing Engagement -
Delivery Performance Assessment
MindChips – Introduction
                                         MindChips

       • A leading Information Technology Consulting and Advisory Organization
       • Founded by passionate professionals with rich experience in Blue Chip companies
         like TCS, Infosys, Wipro, and EDS
       • Consultants Certified with Leading Industry Certifications like PMP, Lean,
         Six Sigma, and DDI

                                          Mission

                • Reduce Operational Cost and Improve Productivity
                • On-time and On-budget Projects
                • Timely and Right decision to Source in-house or Outsource




                                         MindChips
     Passion      Transparency
                                         A Trusted               Commitment         Integrity
                                          Partner


 2
Sourcing Advisory

            1   Outsourcing Go/No Go Advisory

            2   Organization IT Outsourcing Advisory


            3   Large Project/Program Advisory


            4   Outsourcing Governance


            5   Outsourcing Effectiveness Index (OEI)

                Outsourcing Engagement (OE) Delivery
            6
                Performance


 3
What you See Vs What it Is ?




4
Are you Facing below Challenges with
outsourcing?

           Cultural Alignment challenges for teams                           15%

              Vendor does not cooperate with other…                             19%

                 Vendor tries to upsell new services                                   27%

            Lack of Vendor investment in customer…                                       29%

                   Inflexibility regarding price model…                                   30%

          Inability of vendor or contract structure to…                                         36%

              Lack of innovation/continuous service…                                             38%

                 Inconsistent or poor service quality                                                 40%

              Cost savings are lower than expected                                                          50%

                                                   0%         20%                             40%            60%
                                          % Challenges in Outsourcing
    Ref: Gartner Inc. Research based on 942 North American and European IT services decision-makers


5
The Scary Statistical Truth of Outsourcing

                               How Can You Avoid These challenges While Benefiting
                          Cultural Issues          21%
                                From The Tremendous Advantages Of Outsourcing?
                                                16%

     Intellectual Property Concerns                                            31%
                                                                            24%

                         Hiring Difficulty                                                                   56%
                                                                                                     48%                  To
                                                                                                                          From
               Communication Issues                                                                       53%
                                                                                                 44%

                         Quality Problem                                                 37%
                                                                            24%

                                               0%       10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60%




    Ref: Studies conducted by organizations like the Gartner Inc., Sand Hill Group, and the Software & Information Industry
    Association
6
How MindChips can Help?
•   Provide unbiased health score on Engagement
    Performance
•   Optimize its outsourcing spend – Will help to reduce
    outsourcing cost by > 10 % for most engagements
•   Understand vendor operational strengths and areas of
    improvements
•   Alignment of vendor(s) operations with customers
    business and outsourcing objectives
•   Provide customer with the on-ground reality of vendor
    performance
•   Increase the success rate of projects




7
At what level is your Sourcing Relationship?
                                      Level 3 Strategic Sourcing
                                  • Fully “bought-in” global delivery model                     • Improved customer alignment
                                  • SLA driven governance tied to program and business          • Strategic partnership with few
                                    outcomes                                                      selected vendors
                                  • Workforce globalization a strategic imperative at top       • Balanced scorecard and program
                                    management level                                              level metrics for measuring
                                  • Collaborative co-existence of multiple sourcing models        business value



                      Level 2 Mature Sourcing
                   • Managing outsourced projects/processes, not FTEs             • Joint program and change management
                   • Outcome based relationship                                     office
                   • SLA pilots in critical business areas                        • Collaborative project and budget planning
                   • Vendor Focus from Tech to Domain                             • SLA based incentive system, not necessarily
                                                                                    tied to business outcomes
                   • Customer Staff trained offshore delivery processes


Level 1 Tactical Global Sourcing

• “Staff augmentation” approach for offshore resources                • Cost reduction the primary driver
• Managing FTEs, not projects                                         • “Discretionary” decision making on offshoring
• Organization change initiation for adjusting to Offshore Model      • Ad-hoc requirements based staffing model


                      Characteristics                                                   Results
8
OE Delivery Performance Assessment –
Engagement Model
                                          Contract Management
                                    •Risk Management (Financial &
                                    Legal Exposures)
      Financial Management          •Deal Structures / Contracts
                                                                              Operations Management
                                    • Clarity & Flexibility of Contract
 • Offshore Connectivity / Remote   • SLAs                                • Resourcing Model
   Access Infrastructure            • Critical Success Factors            • Offshore Connectivity / Remote
 •Programme Funding and             • Change Control                        Access Infrastructure
  Tracking                          • Issue Management                    • Data Security
 • Pricing                          • Sub-contracting                     • Disaster Recovery and Backup
 • Non-invoiced Services            • Content Awareness                   • Delivery Process - leveraging
 • Cash flow
                                                                            Offshore Delivery Model
 • Revenue Recognition
  (POS & Cost Model                                                       • Program and Project
  Tracking)
                                           Engagement                       Management Practices
 • Dispute Reserves                       Maturity Model                  • Quality Assurance


                                    Relationship Mgmt & Governance
       Process & Innovation                                                     People / Organization
                                    • Sourcing Capability and
• Transition Methodology                                                  • Retained Organization Model
                                      Governance
• Steady-state Knowledge                                                  • Critical SMEs
                                    • Vendor Performance management
  Management                                                              • Training / re-skilling
                                    • Satisfaction and Referencability
• Performance measurement                                                 • Metrics
  metrics                           • Client Acceptance
                                    • Level of Involvement and            • Organization Readiness
• Innovation Practices
                                      Governance
                                    • Executive Visibility and
                                      Relationship
                                    • Disputes
9
OE Delivery Performance Assessment - Approach
                           Engage
Identify Objectives                               Sponsor          Collect Data via -
                         Sponsorship -
      for the                                 Announcement &      Surveys, Workbook
                       Scope, timelines &
   Assessment                                 Kickoff Meeting.     s, Discussion etc.
                          Participants



   Analyze Data to      Deploy On-site       Conduct Interviews     Perform Data
  Identify Potential   Assessment Team           with Key           Analysis and
Issues & Exposures                              Resources             Validate



  Develop Issue        Publish Outsourcing
  Resolution &                               Deliver Findings &    Conduct Periodic
                          Engagement
 Corrective Action                                                Reviews to measure
                       Performance Index     Recommendations         Effectiveness
Recommendations



                           Governance & Periodic Reviews


10
OE Delivery Performance Assessment –
Post Assessment Process
                      Prioritize Corrective   Develop High-
    Engage                                                           Obtain Buy-in for
                             Actions/          Level Tactical
Corrective Action     Recommendations                                High-Level Plan
     Team                                     Resolution Plan




      Identify                                                        Implement to
                        Determine             Develop Detailed
 Deliverables and                                                       Schedule
                      Resource Needs          Project Schedule
 Success Criteria




  Monitor and
                            Closure
 Report Progress



             Governance & Periodic Reviews to Assess Effectiveness


11
OE Delivery Performance Assessment -
Deliverables
•    Executive Summary
      -Summarized Assessment Conclusion
      -Outsourcing Engagement Delivery Performance Index
      -Outsourcing Engagement Delivery Performance Metrics
      -OE Delivery Performance – Application Risk Index
      -Engagement SWOT
      -Top Risks, Issues
      -Key best practices
      -Summarized findings and recommendations for improvement by
      assessment discipline
•    Detailed Findings & Recommendations
•    Proposed Corrective Action Plan and Schedule


12
OE Delivery Performance Index
                                                        ILLUSRATIVE



     Performance Measures

            Contract Management
            Operations Management
            People/Organization
            Relationship Mgmt & Governance
            Process & Innovation                                                                        Excellent
            Financial Management



                                                                                                 All Performance Measures
                                                                            Optimistic           with below rating
                                                                                                     Excellent



                                                                      All Performance Measures
                                                                      with below ratings
                                                   Neutral                 Good
                                                                          Excellent


                                        One of more Performance
                                        Measures with below ratings
                                            Average
                        At Risk             Good
                                            Excellent


             All Performance Measures
             with below ratings
                 Below Average
                 Poor




13
OE Delivery Performance Metrics
                                 ILLUSRATIVE


                            Contract Management
      Engagement Ratings
                                     3



Financial Management                 2
                                                        Operations Management
                                     1


                                     0




Process & Innovation                                    People / Organization




                       Relationship Mgmt & Governance

 14
OE Delivery Performance – Application Risk
Index
                                   ILLUSRATIVE


                                    4/0


                             •A3



                                                      •A1

                                              •A4



                 3                      •A2
                                                            2
                                                •A5




                       •A6
                                                                High

                                                                  Business Criticality

                                                                Low

                                    2
15   8 February 2011
Improvement Prioritization Metrics

                                                     Business Priority

         Performance Rating
                              Not         Low           Medium       High
                                                                                Critical
                              Important   Priority      Priority     Priority



              Poor



              Below Average



             Average



              Good



             Excellent



16   8 February 2011
MindChips Profile


           •   Team with strong and widespread Consulting Experience in
               various areas:
               •   Outsourcing Conceptualization to Steady State Operations
               •   Assessment of Large IT Engagements
               •   IT Transformational Programs for Global Clients
 Profile




               •   Large Multi-Year and Multi-Geography Program Management
               •   Designing Executive Dashboards for Fortune 500 Clients
               •   Use of Best Practices and Industry Standards
               •   Organizational Change Management for Strategic Initiatives
               •   Assessment and Certification in BS 20000 and Organization
                   Security Audits
Contact MindChips


                 Office Address
           MindChips Consulting Pvt Ltd
               2nd Floor, Butte Patil Plaza,
               Erandwane, Pune– 411004

           Telephone: +91-88059 89020/1/2

              Email: info@mindchips.com

           Website: http://www.mindchips.com


18
Thank You




© 2010 MindChips
The information contained herein is subject to change without notice.

MindChips Consulting OE Delivery Performance

  • 1.
    Outsourcing Engagement - DeliveryPerformance Assessment
  • 2.
    MindChips – Introduction MindChips • A leading Information Technology Consulting and Advisory Organization • Founded by passionate professionals with rich experience in Blue Chip companies like TCS, Infosys, Wipro, and EDS • Consultants Certified with Leading Industry Certifications like PMP, Lean, Six Sigma, and DDI Mission • Reduce Operational Cost and Improve Productivity • On-time and On-budget Projects • Timely and Right decision to Source in-house or Outsource MindChips Passion Transparency A Trusted Commitment Integrity Partner 2
  • 3.
    Sourcing Advisory 1 Outsourcing Go/No Go Advisory 2 Organization IT Outsourcing Advisory 3 Large Project/Program Advisory 4 Outsourcing Governance 5 Outsourcing Effectiveness Index (OEI) Outsourcing Engagement (OE) Delivery 6 Performance 3
  • 4.
    What you SeeVs What it Is ? 4
  • 5.
    Are you Facingbelow Challenges with outsourcing? Cultural Alignment challenges for teams 15% Vendor does not cooperate with other… 19% Vendor tries to upsell new services 27% Lack of Vendor investment in customer… 29% Inflexibility regarding price model… 30% Inability of vendor or contract structure to… 36% Lack of innovation/continuous service… 38% Inconsistent or poor service quality 40% Cost savings are lower than expected 50% 0% 20% 40% 60% % Challenges in Outsourcing Ref: Gartner Inc. Research based on 942 North American and European IT services decision-makers 5
  • 6.
    The Scary StatisticalTruth of Outsourcing How Can You Avoid These challenges While Benefiting Cultural Issues 21% From The Tremendous Advantages Of Outsourcing? 16% Intellectual Property Concerns 31% 24% Hiring Difficulty 56% 48% To From Communication Issues 53% 44% Quality Problem 37% 24% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% Ref: Studies conducted by organizations like the Gartner Inc., Sand Hill Group, and the Software & Information Industry Association 6
  • 7.
    How MindChips canHelp? • Provide unbiased health score on Engagement Performance • Optimize its outsourcing spend – Will help to reduce outsourcing cost by > 10 % for most engagements • Understand vendor operational strengths and areas of improvements • Alignment of vendor(s) operations with customers business and outsourcing objectives • Provide customer with the on-ground reality of vendor performance • Increase the success rate of projects 7
  • 8.
    At what levelis your Sourcing Relationship? Level 3 Strategic Sourcing • Fully “bought-in” global delivery model • Improved customer alignment • SLA driven governance tied to program and business • Strategic partnership with few outcomes selected vendors • Workforce globalization a strategic imperative at top • Balanced scorecard and program management level level metrics for measuring • Collaborative co-existence of multiple sourcing models business value Level 2 Mature Sourcing • Managing outsourced projects/processes, not FTEs • Joint program and change management • Outcome based relationship office • SLA pilots in critical business areas • Collaborative project and budget planning • Vendor Focus from Tech to Domain • SLA based incentive system, not necessarily tied to business outcomes • Customer Staff trained offshore delivery processes Level 1 Tactical Global Sourcing • “Staff augmentation” approach for offshore resources • Cost reduction the primary driver • Managing FTEs, not projects • “Discretionary” decision making on offshoring • Organization change initiation for adjusting to Offshore Model • Ad-hoc requirements based staffing model Characteristics Results 8
  • 9.
    OE Delivery PerformanceAssessment – Engagement Model Contract Management •Risk Management (Financial & Legal Exposures) Financial Management •Deal Structures / Contracts Operations Management • Clarity & Flexibility of Contract • Offshore Connectivity / Remote • SLAs • Resourcing Model Access Infrastructure • Critical Success Factors • Offshore Connectivity / Remote •Programme Funding and • Change Control Access Infrastructure Tracking • Issue Management • Data Security • Pricing • Sub-contracting • Disaster Recovery and Backup • Non-invoiced Services • Content Awareness • Delivery Process - leveraging • Cash flow Offshore Delivery Model • Revenue Recognition (POS & Cost Model • Program and Project Tracking) Engagement Management Practices • Dispute Reserves Maturity Model • Quality Assurance Relationship Mgmt & Governance Process & Innovation People / Organization • Sourcing Capability and • Transition Methodology • Retained Organization Model Governance • Steady-state Knowledge • Critical SMEs • Vendor Performance management Management • Training / re-skilling • Satisfaction and Referencability • Performance measurement • Metrics metrics • Client Acceptance • Level of Involvement and • Organization Readiness • Innovation Practices Governance • Executive Visibility and Relationship • Disputes 9
  • 10.
    OE Delivery PerformanceAssessment - Approach Engage Identify Objectives Sponsor Collect Data via - Sponsorship - for the Announcement & Surveys, Workbook Scope, timelines & Assessment Kickoff Meeting. s, Discussion etc. Participants Analyze Data to Deploy On-site Conduct Interviews Perform Data Identify Potential Assessment Team with Key Analysis and Issues & Exposures Resources Validate Develop Issue Publish Outsourcing Resolution & Deliver Findings & Conduct Periodic Engagement Corrective Action Reviews to measure Performance Index Recommendations Effectiveness Recommendations Governance & Periodic Reviews 10
  • 11.
    OE Delivery PerformanceAssessment – Post Assessment Process Prioritize Corrective Develop High- Engage Obtain Buy-in for Actions/ Level Tactical Corrective Action Recommendations High-Level Plan Team Resolution Plan Identify Implement to Determine Develop Detailed Deliverables and Schedule Resource Needs Project Schedule Success Criteria Monitor and Closure Report Progress Governance & Periodic Reviews to Assess Effectiveness 11
  • 12.
    OE Delivery PerformanceAssessment - Deliverables • Executive Summary -Summarized Assessment Conclusion -Outsourcing Engagement Delivery Performance Index -Outsourcing Engagement Delivery Performance Metrics -OE Delivery Performance – Application Risk Index -Engagement SWOT -Top Risks, Issues -Key best practices -Summarized findings and recommendations for improvement by assessment discipline • Detailed Findings & Recommendations • Proposed Corrective Action Plan and Schedule 12
  • 13.
    OE Delivery PerformanceIndex ILLUSRATIVE Performance Measures Contract Management Operations Management People/Organization Relationship Mgmt & Governance Process & Innovation Excellent Financial Management All Performance Measures Optimistic with below rating Excellent All Performance Measures with below ratings Neutral Good Excellent One of more Performance Measures with below ratings Average At Risk Good Excellent All Performance Measures with below ratings Below Average Poor 13
  • 14.
    OE Delivery PerformanceMetrics ILLUSRATIVE Contract Management Engagement Ratings 3 Financial Management 2 Operations Management 1 0 Process & Innovation People / Organization Relationship Mgmt & Governance 14
  • 15.
    OE Delivery Performance– Application Risk Index ILLUSRATIVE 4/0 •A3 •A1 •A4 3 •A2 2 •A5 •A6 High Business Criticality Low 2 15 8 February 2011
  • 16.
    Improvement Prioritization Metrics Business Priority Performance Rating Not Low Medium High Critical Important Priority Priority Priority Poor Below Average Average Good Excellent 16 8 February 2011
  • 17.
    MindChips Profile • Team with strong and widespread Consulting Experience in various areas: • Outsourcing Conceptualization to Steady State Operations • Assessment of Large IT Engagements • IT Transformational Programs for Global Clients Profile • Large Multi-Year and Multi-Geography Program Management • Designing Executive Dashboards for Fortune 500 Clients • Use of Best Practices and Industry Standards • Organizational Change Management for Strategic Initiatives • Assessment and Certification in BS 20000 and Organization Security Audits
  • 18.
    Contact MindChips Office Address MindChips Consulting Pvt Ltd 2nd Floor, Butte Patil Plaza, Erandwane, Pune– 411004 Telephone: +91-88059 89020/1/2 Email: info@mindchips.com Website: http://www.mindchips.com 18
  • 19.
    Thank You © 2010MindChips The information contained herein is subject to change without notice.