This document summarizes a project that used SenseMaker, a participatory storytelling and analysis method, to evaluate development initiatives in Kenya funded by the GlobalGiving crowdfunding platform. Over 2,700 stories were collected from community members about their experiences. Analysis of these stories using SenseMaker software revealed stark differences compared to self-reports and expert perspectives, providing new insights. GlobalGiving and participating organizations aim to refine this approach and use it as an ongoing feedback and learning tool.