PRP in muscle and tendon
injuries
Lars Engebretsen MD, PhD
Professor and Chair Department of
Orthopaedic Surgery, U of Oslo
Disclosures 2013
n 

n 

n 

Consultant
n  Arthrex equipment development
Fellowship grants
n  Smith and Nephew
n  Arthrex
Editor and Editorial board
n  BJSM
n  JBJS (am)
n  SJMSS
n  KSSTA

n 

n 

Research grants
n  Smith & Nephew
n  Fin-Ceramica
n  TBF-Tissue Engineering
n  Biomet
Competitive grants
n  Norwegian NIH
n  AOSSM
n  FIFA
n  IOC
n  NIH
n  Health South East Norway
n  Department of Culture
Norway
Been in Sports Traumatology as a
clinician researcher since 1984
n 

n 

n 

n 

Cochair of the Oslo Sports Trauma Research Center
Chief of the Orthopedic Department at the
University of Oslo
Consultant at the Norwegian Olympic Center
Head of three research groups in Cartilage, Knee
ligaments and Injury Prevention

n 

Head of Scientific activities in the IOC

n 

Past President of ESSKA

n 

Editor of BJSM IPHP

n 

Deputy Editor JBJS (Am)
This lecture will discuss:
n 
n 

Why is PRP hot?
Proof of concept?
n 

n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 

Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage

Procedure- dose- frequency
White cells ?
Local anesthesia ?
Antiinflammatories ?
Adverse effects ?
Anti doping regulations
Summary
IOC Consensus statements

• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 
• 

Sports Nutrition (2003)
Sex Reassignment in Sports (2003)
Sudden Cardiovascular Death in Sports (2004)
Training the Elite Child Athlete (2005)
Female Athlete Triad (2005)
Sexual Harassment & Abuse in Sport (2006)
Molecular Basis of Connective Tissue and Muscle Injuries in Sport (2007)
Non-contact ACL Injury in the Female Athlete (2008)
Concussion in Sport (2008)
Asthma in Elite Athletes (2008)
Fasting in Sports (2009)
Periodic Health Evaluation of Elite Athletes (2009)
Age Determination in High-Level Young Athletes (2009)
Sports Nutrition (2010)
Functional Hyper-Androgenism and Sport (2010)
The Use of Platelet-Rich Plasma in Sports Medicine (2010)
Fitness and Health in Young People through Physical Activity and Sport (2011)
Thermoregulatory and altitude challenges in the high-level athlete (2011)
Did PRP win it?
n 
n 

n 

n 

Hines Ward
Pittsburgh Steelers
wide receiver
Super Bowl XLIII Feb
2009
Pittsburgh Steelers
versus Ravens
Sandeep Patel MD AJSM 2013
PRP: what does it contain?
Comparison of mean cell counts
amongMajor commercial PRP systems
Not all PRPs are the same
n 

Leukocytes (white blood cells)
n  Platelet concentration
n  Platelet activation

Andia et al. Expert Opin Biol Ther.
2010 Oct;10(10):1415-26

Jia et al. Oper Tech Sports Med. 2011
Differences in PRP Systems
Competitor 1

Competitor 2

PRGFTM

Types of PRP

L-PRP1

P-PRP2

P-PRP

Input Blood
Volume

30-55ml3

9ml4

Variable (9ml per
tube)

Centrifuge
Protocol

3200rpm
(1100g) for
15min1

1500rpm
(400g) for
5min2

580g for 8min

PRP Yield

3-6ml3

2-3ml4

2ml of F2 per tube

Platelet
Enrichment
Factor

2.07 ± 1.11

1.3x2

2.3 ± 0.6

Leukocyte
Concentration
[103/ul]

34.4 ± 13.61

0.68 ± 0.422

0.7±0.7

Is Scaffold
Forming
Activator
Included in the
Kit?

No

No

Yes

3

1Castillo

et al. Am J Sports Med. 2011 Feb; 39(2): 266-71
2Sundman et al. Am J Sports Med. 2011 Oct;39(10):2135-40

Data available at: http://www.biomet.com/biologics/information/pdf/BBI0003.0.pdf
4 Data

Available at: https://www.arthrex.com/innovations/index.cfm?adid=28
Why should it work?
AUTOLOGOUS PLATELETS CAN BE A SOURCE OF
GROWTH FACTORS FOR HEALING AND
TISSUE REGENERATION

Platelet-Rich Plasma
is the outcome of a
centrifugation of
autologous blood.
Contains a high
concentration of
platelets
(4-8 times)
PLATELETS

Role in
HAEMOSTASIS

Growth Factors
RELEASE

Ø  Promote tissue repair
Ø  Influence the reactivity of vascular and other
blood cells in angiogenesis and inflammation
Where are the GFs?
Platelet activation
§  Activation
§  exposed collagen, damage or thrombin
§  Dramatic morphological change
§  Adhesion, spreading, aggregation,
activation of other platelets and clot
retraction
§  Alpha Granule release
§  200-500 nm, ~50 to 80 per platelet
§  Over 30 bioactive proteins, with
roles in haemostasis and tissue
healing.

Harrison and Cramer 1993

0.5 µm
Platelet granule release

Alpha granules migrate
to platelet periphery (a),
where the plasma
membrane blebs (b),
and ruptures (c) Loss of
electron density with
rupture

Polasek J. Lysosomal concept of platelet secretion - revisited. Eur J Haematol 1989. Suppl 50; Vol 43.
SOURCES

ROLE

PRP
(multiplication factor)

Platelets

Blood

Initial control of haemorrhage, release GF

3-8

PDGF

Platelets

Stimulates cell replication, angiogenesis, mitogen for fibroblasts

5-29

VEGF

Platelets

Angiogenesis

6-52,7

TGF-β	


Platelets

Increase chondrocyte expression, induce Chondrogenic differentiation
of MSCS, enhance matrix deposition, decrease the suppressive effects
of inflammatory mediators IL-1 on proteglycans synthesis in cartilage

3,5-27

FGF

Platelets

Stimulates proliferation of myoblasts, angiogenesis

Detected

EGF

Platelets

Proliferation of mesencymal and epithelial cells, Potentiation other GF

3

HGF

Plasma

Angiogenesis, mitogen for endothelial cells, anti-fibrotic

No increase from baseline

IGF-1

Plasma

Stimultes myoblasts and fibroblasts, mediator in growth and repair of
skeletal muscle

No increase from baseline

EGF: epidermal growth factors, HGF: hepatocyte growth factor, IGF-1: insuline-like growth factor, PDGF: platelet-derived growth factor, TGF-b: transforming
growth factor beta, VEGF: vascular endothelial growth factor, FGF: fibroblasts growth factor
Does ACP/PRP increase human
tendon, bone, cartilage and muscle
cell proliferation

Mazzocca et al UCon
Local anesthesia and cortison has a
harmfull effect on proliferation of
tenocytes

Mazzocca et al UCon
Does repeated dosage help?

Mazzocca et al U Con
Where and when is the
action?
n 

n 

n 
n 

Cook and Purdam
BJSM 2009
Reactive
tendinopathy?
Tendon dysrepair?
Degenerative
tendinopathy?
Consider a
patient with
Achilles tendon
pain as just one
example
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways and PRP
acts??????
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways
The heel drop stimulates
integrins to flip and this triggers
signaling pathways
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA and PRP acts?
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA
Gene transcription and PRP
acts?
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA
The nucleus is signaled to
create mRNA
Ribosomes create protein

Ribosomes
Ribosomes create protein

Ribosomes
Collagen extrudes from matrix

Ribosomes
Collagen extrudes from matrix
Collagen is repaired
Recent studies:
Recent RCT in OA:
Knee OA:
CASE: PATELLAR TENDON LESION
RMN BASAL

RMN AT 6 M F U

Male, 25 y, D LEAGUE SOCCER PLAYER
3y of pain and limited function, bilateral, previous surgery

RETURNED AT PREVIOUS ACTIVITY LEVEL AT 4 MONTHS
PRP IN TENDON PATOLOGY
TREATMENT
ü  PROMISSING RESULTS IN ATHLETES
ü  TREATMENT OF FAILED CASES
ü  HAVE TO BE COMBINED WITH
PHYSICAL THERAPY
ü  RANDOMIZED STUDIES ARE NEEDED
Tendinopathy: Effect?
PRP and muscles
AFTER TREATMENT
ü  Restricted activity for 24 hours
ü  No use of non-steroidal medication.
ü  Mild activities with bike or mild exercises in pool
Use ultrasound guided injections!
This lecture will teach you:
n 
n 

Why is PRP hot?
Proof of concept?
n 

n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 

Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage

Procedure- dose- frequency
White cells ?
Local anesthesia ?
Antiinflammatories ?
Adverse effects ?
Anti doping regulations
Summary
Adverse effects?
n 

n 

So far no serious side
effects reported
A case report on DVT in
November 2010 and a
comment on being aware
of this possibility
This lecture will teach you:
n 
n 

Why is PRP hot?
Proof of concept?
n 

n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 

Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage

Procedure- dose- frequency
White cells ?
Local anesthesia ?
Antiinflammatories ?
Adverse effects ?
Anti doping regulations
Summary
PRP from a regulatory viewpoint:
n 
n 

n 

n 

Autologous blood
No agreement on procurement (degree of
centrifugation, white cells?)
Principally no difference in mechanism on
muscle, tendon and ligaments
No indication that PRP has any effect in
healthy tissue
Where does it belong?…
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 
n 

Exercises for rehabilitation
Strength training
Aligning tissue with stretching
Manual therapy
NSAIDs, cortisone
Hyaluronic acid, PRP
Surgery

PRP?
Intratendinous	
  injections	
  of	
  
autologous	
  conditioned	
  
plasma,	
  or	
  platelet	
  rich	
  plasma	
  
with	
  or	
  without	
  WBC	
  
enrichment	
  for	
  patellar	
  
tendinopathy	
  
A	
  mul&-­‐centre,	
  double-­‐blind,	
  randomized	
  controlled	
  trial	
  
*Alex	
  Sco*1,	
  *Kim	
  Harmon2,	
  Roald	
  Bahr3,	
  Lars	
  Engebretsen3,	
  Robert	
  LaPrade4	
  
1.	
  Department	
  of	
  Physical	
  Therapy,	
  University	
  of	
  BriJsh	
  Columbia,	
  Canada	
  
2.	
  Departments	
  of	
  Family	
  PracJce,	
  Orthopaedics	
  and	
  Sports	
  Medicine,	
  University	
  of	
  
Washington,	
  USA	
  
3.	
  Oslo	
  Trauma	
  Research	
  Centre,	
  Norway	
  
4.	
  Steadman	
  Clinic,	
  Vail,	
  USA	
  
	
  
EBM: Definition
Integrate current “best evidence”
from clinical research
with individual clinical expertise
and patient preferences
in making decisions about the care of individual patients

Rosenberg W & Donald A. BMJ 1995; 310:1122-6
The Oslo Sports Trauma Research Center
has been established at
the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences
through generous grants from the Royal Norwegian Ministry of
Culture, the South-Eastern Norway Regional Health Authority,
the International Olympic Committee, the Norwegian Olympic
Committee & Confederation of Sport, and Norsk Tipping AS

Lars Engebretsen MD, PhD Professor and Chair Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, U of Oslo

  • 1.
    PRP in muscleand tendon injuries Lars Engebretsen MD, PhD Professor and Chair Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, U of Oslo
  • 2.
    Disclosures 2013 n  n  n  Consultant n  Arthrexequipment development Fellowship grants n  Smith and Nephew n  Arthrex Editor and Editorial board n  BJSM n  JBJS (am) n  SJMSS n  KSSTA n  n  Research grants n  Smith & Nephew n  Fin-Ceramica n  TBF-Tissue Engineering n  Biomet Competitive grants n  Norwegian NIH n  AOSSM n  FIFA n  IOC n  NIH n  Health South East Norway n  Department of Culture Norway
  • 3.
    Been in SportsTraumatology as a clinician researcher since 1984 n  n  n  n  Cochair of the Oslo Sports Trauma Research Center Chief of the Orthopedic Department at the University of Oslo Consultant at the Norwegian Olympic Center Head of three research groups in Cartilage, Knee ligaments and Injury Prevention n  Head of Scientific activities in the IOC n  Past President of ESSKA n  Editor of BJSM IPHP n  Deputy Editor JBJS (Am)
  • 4.
    This lecture willdiscuss: n  n  Why is PRP hot? Proof of concept? n  n  n  n  n  n  n  n  Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage Procedure- dose- frequency White cells ? Local anesthesia ? Antiinflammatories ? Adverse effects ? Anti doping regulations Summary
  • 5.
    IOC Consensus statements •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  •  SportsNutrition (2003) Sex Reassignment in Sports (2003) Sudden Cardiovascular Death in Sports (2004) Training the Elite Child Athlete (2005) Female Athlete Triad (2005) Sexual Harassment & Abuse in Sport (2006) Molecular Basis of Connective Tissue and Muscle Injuries in Sport (2007) Non-contact ACL Injury in the Female Athlete (2008) Concussion in Sport (2008) Asthma in Elite Athletes (2008) Fasting in Sports (2009) Periodic Health Evaluation of Elite Athletes (2009) Age Determination in High-Level Young Athletes (2009) Sports Nutrition (2010) Functional Hyper-Androgenism and Sport (2010) The Use of Platelet-Rich Plasma in Sports Medicine (2010) Fitness and Health in Young People through Physical Activity and Sport (2011) Thermoregulatory and altitude challenges in the high-level athlete (2011)
  • 7.
    Did PRP winit? n  n  n  n  Hines Ward Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver Super Bowl XLIII Feb 2009 Pittsburgh Steelers versus Ravens
  • 11.
  • 12.
    PRP: what doesit contain?
  • 13.
    Comparison of meancell counts amongMajor commercial PRP systems
  • 15.
    Not all PRPsare the same n  Leukocytes (white blood cells) n  Platelet concentration n  Platelet activation Andia et al. Expert Opin Biol Ther. 2010 Oct;10(10):1415-26 Jia et al. Oper Tech Sports Med. 2011
  • 16.
    Differences in PRPSystems Competitor 1 Competitor 2 PRGFTM Types of PRP L-PRP1 P-PRP2 P-PRP Input Blood Volume 30-55ml3 9ml4 Variable (9ml per tube) Centrifuge Protocol 3200rpm (1100g) for 15min1 1500rpm (400g) for 5min2 580g for 8min PRP Yield 3-6ml3 2-3ml4 2ml of F2 per tube Platelet Enrichment Factor 2.07 ± 1.11 1.3x2 2.3 ± 0.6 Leukocyte Concentration [103/ul] 34.4 ± 13.61 0.68 ± 0.422 0.7±0.7 Is Scaffold Forming Activator Included in the Kit? No No Yes 3 1Castillo et al. Am J Sports Med. 2011 Feb; 39(2): 266-71 2Sundman et al. Am J Sports Med. 2011 Oct;39(10):2135-40 Data available at: http://www.biomet.com/biologics/information/pdf/BBI0003.0.pdf 4 Data Available at: https://www.arthrex.com/innovations/index.cfm?adid=28
  • 17.
  • 18.
    AUTOLOGOUS PLATELETS CANBE A SOURCE OF GROWTH FACTORS FOR HEALING AND TISSUE REGENERATION Platelet-Rich Plasma is the outcome of a centrifugation of autologous blood. Contains a high concentration of platelets (4-8 times)
  • 19.
    PLATELETS Role in HAEMOSTASIS Growth Factors RELEASE Ø Promote tissue repair Ø  Influence the reactivity of vascular and other blood cells in angiogenesis and inflammation
  • 20.
  • 21.
    Platelet activation §  Activation § exposed collagen, damage or thrombin §  Dramatic morphological change §  Adhesion, spreading, aggregation, activation of other platelets and clot retraction §  Alpha Granule release §  200-500 nm, ~50 to 80 per platelet §  Over 30 bioactive proteins, with roles in haemostasis and tissue healing. Harrison and Cramer 1993 0.5 µm
  • 22.
    Platelet granule release Alphagranules migrate to platelet periphery (a), where the plasma membrane blebs (b), and ruptures (c) Loss of electron density with rupture Polasek J. Lysosomal concept of platelet secretion - revisited. Eur J Haematol 1989. Suppl 50; Vol 43.
  • 23.
    SOURCES ROLE PRP (multiplication factor) Platelets Blood Initial controlof haemorrhage, release GF 3-8 PDGF Platelets Stimulates cell replication, angiogenesis, mitogen for fibroblasts 5-29 VEGF Platelets Angiogenesis 6-52,7 TGF-β Platelets Increase chondrocyte expression, induce Chondrogenic differentiation of MSCS, enhance matrix deposition, decrease the suppressive effects of inflammatory mediators IL-1 on proteglycans synthesis in cartilage 3,5-27 FGF Platelets Stimulates proliferation of myoblasts, angiogenesis Detected EGF Platelets Proliferation of mesencymal and epithelial cells, Potentiation other GF 3 HGF Plasma Angiogenesis, mitogen for endothelial cells, anti-fibrotic No increase from baseline IGF-1 Plasma Stimultes myoblasts and fibroblasts, mediator in growth and repair of skeletal muscle No increase from baseline EGF: epidermal growth factors, HGF: hepatocyte growth factor, IGF-1: insuline-like growth factor, PDGF: platelet-derived growth factor, TGF-b: transforming growth factor beta, VEGF: vascular endothelial growth factor, FGF: fibroblasts growth factor
  • 26.
    Does ACP/PRP increasehuman tendon, bone, cartilage and muscle cell proliferation Mazzocca et al UCon
  • 27.
    Local anesthesia andcortison has a harmfull effect on proliferation of tenocytes Mazzocca et al UCon
  • 28.
    Does repeated dosagehelp? Mazzocca et al U Con
  • 29.
    Where and whenis the action? n  n  n  n  Cook and Purdam BJSM 2009 Reactive tendinopathy? Tendon dysrepair? Degenerative tendinopathy?
  • 30.
    Consider a patient with Achillestendon pain as just one example
  • 39.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways and PRP acts??????
  • 40.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways
  • 41.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways
  • 42.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways
  • 43.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways
  • 44.
    The heel dropstimulates integrins to flip and this triggers signaling pathways
  • 45.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA and PRP acts?
  • 46.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA
  • 47.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA Gene transcription and PRP acts?
  • 48.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA
  • 49.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA
  • 50.
    The nucleus issignaled to create mRNA
  • 51.
  • 52.
  • 53.
    Collagen extrudes frommatrix Ribosomes
  • 54.
  • 57.
  • 60.
  • 62.
  • 63.
  • 65.
    CASE: PATELLAR TENDONLESION RMN BASAL RMN AT 6 M F U Male, 25 y, D LEAGUE SOCCER PLAYER 3y of pain and limited function, bilateral, previous surgery RETURNED AT PREVIOUS ACTIVITY LEVEL AT 4 MONTHS
  • 66.
    PRP IN TENDONPATOLOGY TREATMENT ü  PROMISSING RESULTS IN ATHLETES ü  TREATMENT OF FAILED CASES ü  HAVE TO BE COMBINED WITH PHYSICAL THERAPY ü  RANDOMIZED STUDIES ARE NEEDED
  • 67.
  • 68.
  • 70.
    AFTER TREATMENT ü  Restrictedactivity for 24 hours ü  No use of non-steroidal medication. ü  Mild activities with bike or mild exercises in pool
  • 75.
  • 77.
    This lecture willteach you: n  n  Why is PRP hot? Proof of concept? n  n  n  n  n  n  n  n  Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage Procedure- dose- frequency White cells ? Local anesthesia ? Antiinflammatories ? Adverse effects ? Anti doping regulations Summary
  • 78.
    Adverse effects? n  n  So farno serious side effects reported A case report on DVT in November 2010 and a comment on being aware of this possibility
  • 79.
    This lecture willteach you: n  n  Why is PRP hot? Proof of concept? n  n  n  n  n  n  n  n  Role in tendon, ligament, muscle and cartilage Procedure- dose- frequency White cells ? Local anesthesia ? Antiinflammatories ? Adverse effects ? Anti doping regulations Summary
  • 80.
    PRP from aregulatory viewpoint: n  n  n  n  Autologous blood No agreement on procurement (degree of centrifugation, white cells?) Principally no difference in mechanism on muscle, tendon and ligaments No indication that PRP has any effect in healthy tissue
  • 88.
    Where does itbelong?… n  n  n  n  n  n  n  Exercises for rehabilitation Strength training Aligning tissue with stretching Manual therapy NSAIDs, cortisone Hyaluronic acid, PRP Surgery PRP?
  • 94.
    Intratendinous  injections  of   autologous  conditioned   plasma,  or  platelet  rich  plasma   with  or  without  WBC   enrichment  for  patellar   tendinopathy   A  mul&-­‐centre,  double-­‐blind,  randomized  controlled  trial   *Alex  Sco*1,  *Kim  Harmon2,  Roald  Bahr3,  Lars  Engebretsen3,  Robert  LaPrade4   1.  Department  of  Physical  Therapy,  University  of  BriJsh  Columbia,  Canada   2.  Departments  of  Family  PracJce,  Orthopaedics  and  Sports  Medicine,  University  of   Washington,  USA   3.  Oslo  Trauma  Research  Centre,  Norway   4.  Steadman  Clinic,  Vail,  USA    
  • 95.
    EBM: Definition Integrate current“best evidence” from clinical research with individual clinical expertise and patient preferences in making decisions about the care of individual patients Rosenberg W & Donald A. BMJ 1995; 310:1122-6
  • 96.
    The Oslo SportsTrauma Research Center has been established at the Norwegian School of Sport Sciences through generous grants from the Royal Norwegian Ministry of Culture, the South-Eastern Norway Regional Health Authority, the International Olympic Committee, the Norwegian Olympic Committee & Confederation of Sport, and Norsk Tipping AS