CITI Corp inc.Learning to Innovate (1970 – 1993)
What will you do with 100 bricks?
 Counting=AccountingScattering=EngineeringRestructuring=PlanningThrowing=Operation
Sleeping=SecurityBreaking=ITStay Calm=HRThrow out of window=Procurement
Lying=SalesDisappear=MarketingHolding=Internal AuditSat Vacant=Strategic Planning
Company ProfileEstablished in 1812 “National City Bank of New York”
Head Quarter in New York
Over 2,000 branches in 93 countries (~1993)
More than 90,000 employees (~1993)Sense of Innovation (Before 1970)Start Global operations in the beginning  of 20thcentury(among the first banks)In 1921, The 1st commercial bank to have Individual lending serviceIn 1951, Launch the 1stcredit card – Dinner’s Club
“Fast-growing, competitive and customer-oriented organization”
In CITI Corp during 1970 - 1993What’s Happened?
“A man with a mission, he steamrolled his way to success”Walter Wriston – CEO (1970 – 1983)Transform ‘Traditional Commercial Lender’ to ‘Innovative Organization’
Walter Wriston’s Changes“Annual growth rate of 15% for ROA”Investment Bankingand across states
Transform traditional commercial  lender to“Innovative Org”
Offervariety of services
Bring young managers from outside “Young Tiger”Young Tigers (Some Example)John Reed New CEO‘Paradigm Shifter’Literature, MetallurgyExperience at Ford MotorRun banking as “Factory”Transform ‘Back Office’ => Low Cost, High-QualityRecruit production backgroundReorganize & Reduce HCAutomated & Redesign work- flow and control systems
Young Tigers (Some Example)Pei-Yuan ChiaHead of global consumer bankingExperience at General Food as Brand Manager for coffeeLawrence M. SmallHead of commercial banking OperationsClassically Trained GuitaristExperience at Ford Motor
Young Tigers (Some Example)Steve PriceCitibanking Concept CreatorExperience at General Food as MarketerRichard S. BraddockPresident and head of individual bankingExperience at General Food as Product Manager
PerformancesThe 1st bank to launch ATM & E-Banking
Mortgage Financing / Insurance
Inter-Bank/Corporate Lending
Offer credit on checking account
15% Growth in transaction volumeThe highest profits among banks in America in 1981, 1982EPS growth from $2.11 to $6.48 between 1973 – 198350% of earnings were from new servicesVariety ServicesFinances
AchievementsBecomeNo.1bank in AmericaFortune’s most admired companies for innovativenessMarket Leader in Defining trend and rules for others’Trendsetter
AchievementsAmong the most professional banks in services and solutionsVoted the best bank for information service(1992)Polled the best bank for arranging Forex(Euromoney, 1993)Top ten investment bank (1993)Ranked as the 15th largestin the world (1993)
Diversity & ContradictionsMeritocracy & EntrepreneurshipExperimentation & Action LearningCustomer ResponsivenessManagement of InformationHow Citicorp does it…
Diversity & ContradictionsObjectiveCreate new things (Change) by encourage diversities, deviations, internal contradictions
Allow NO Excuses!!Diversity & ContradictionsAction / ResultDiverse backgrounds, nationalities and cultures across all levels=> pool of corporate talent     	=> not allow political nexusRisk-taking, initiative and innovativeness but simultaneously system-driven and result-oriented organization
Diversity & ContradictionsAction / Result    Decentralization      Assign tasks    with overlappingBalance Powerful VS Contradictory forces“One’s survival depends on the boss’s evaluation”Force compete against and negotiate/collaborate with their colleagues
Meritocracy & EntrepreneurshipObjectiveEncourage individualistic initiativeTo drive innovation
Action & ResultPay to PerformanceNurtures talents, seek out and support “High-flyers” early in their careers, create own unique career path“Superstars”Meritocracy & Entrepreneurship
Meritocracy & EntrepreneurshipAction & ResultHires above baseline requirementsworking together will create new jobs	and opportunities  for them and the bankJob Rotationcreate their own nichesSmall team, push decision-making downengine of innovation
Customer ResponsivenessObjectiveBuilding customer-oriented business worldwide
Customer ResponsivenessAction & Result“Clients value the quality of relationshipmore than the cost of relationship”Customer focus is a basic necessityInnovative services to meet customer needs
Customer ResponsivenessMortgage Financing15 minutes to process loans!Based on thorough understanding nature of market and customer needs
Customer ResponsivenessDeveloping long-term relationship with clientsWorld Corporate Group (WCG) focus on top global companyRelationship Managerto develop ‘relationship-continuity’Clients visited every two months to understanding client’s business‘relationship review’yearly survey to get client’s perceptionsInternal meetings with clientsCustomizing solution to fit client
Customer ResponsivenessManage intangible (service performance)Control quality of service & Measure performance‘cross-selling’ before present to clientLearning from past mistakesweekly meetingTransfer intangible to tangibleCustomer survey‘tier-positioning’
Experimentation & Action LearningObjectiveProactive and creates an environment for itself
Experimentation & Action LearningAction & ResultDeveloping and implementing the ATMs“Most competitive in U.S. 80% of customer using ATMs”
Experimentation & Action LearningAction & ResultLearning from experiments and field experiments“Credit-scoring system and become largest card-issuer 36M cards globally”
Experimentation & Action LearningAction & ResultEncourages speed in action and decision-makingTo be impulsive, experiment and learn from success and failures“Citicorp culture”Failure rate of initiatives is high !!!
Management of InformationObjectiveMake the bank capitalise on the vast potential of technology
Management of InformationAction & ResultUsing information technology for data processing, telecommunications, MIS, decision support and production control “Competitive weapon with 200 data centers operate world-wide”
Management of InformationAction & ResultWide area network (WAN)Subscribe extensive to financial studies“Speed up operation & Leverage knowledge, planning and problem-solving”
Management of InformationAction & ResultEmphasis on sharing of expertise and knowledgeUrging people work together“Best Partnership and Best Transaction”
Management of InformationAction & ResultHorizontal movement Internal meeting and conference“Knowledge transfer”
Management of InformationAction & ResultCirculating information on regular basisPosted new ideas and solutionsPublished monthly journal“Convert local solutions to global competitive advantage”
Sense of LO & KMShukla Model (1997) – Components of LOMadhukarShukla
Components of LOStrategic intent to learnLearning mechanismSupporting structures and processes
1) Strategic Intent to LearnTransformational LeadershipWriston – “A man with a mission”John Reed – “Paradigm Shifter”Stretch goals and visionInnovative OrganizationRocking-the-boat-factorsInjection new blood
1) Strategic Intent to Learn“Failures are part of the landscape if you’re trying to change things and grow”

KM_Citi

Editor's Notes

  • #11 Walter Wriston - visionary, visualized Citicorp’s future beyond merely operating within the boundaries fixed by the regulators and by the prevailing banking norms - gave the bank an aggressive stance and a unique identity in the banking community=>เข้ามาเพิ่มบทบาทของ bank ให้ aggressive มากขึ้น และสร้างความแตกต่างในธุรกิจของ bank - keep Citicorp expanding into investment banking and across state lines
  • #13 HBS study
  • #21 -Recruiting starts from the view that we are a different business from a traditional bank (Holistic Approach)- Focus on management and marketing- Allows no excusesManagers are expected to achieve each of their five mandatory MBO targets
  • #22 Just a few years experience, handed major accounts/clientsNo one here has a clear territory or clear ownership of a total activity
  • #24 Superstars => special attention and job transfers to acquire a broad-based experience at the bank
  • #27 Quality of relationship => service, responsivenessCost of relationship => interest rate, charges- Poll results best rate over quick processing- High rate interest rate charged but offered the most efficient serviceCredit card account increased threefold (3.2M to 10M) => smarter way applied collective learning knowledge
  • #28 Normal time to process loans was around 45 days => Citicorp offering 15 days, and then 15 minutes!Accepted 80% of value => price sell if defaultRedesign procedures => insure its mortgagesElectronic data transmission => save about a weekReal estate agents => screened applications
  • #29 Long-term relationship with clients => creating stability in changing environmentInternal meetings with clients => discuss and understand what the bank is doing (or should be doing) with client
  • #30 ‘cross-selling’ => to sell services to relationship managers to refinement idea before present to clientLearning from past mistakes => weekly meeting to discuss and analyze failures and derive constructive lessons for the future‘tier-positioning’ - Tier one => top three - Tier two => top six - Tier three => below this
  • #32 Bought Transaction Technology Inc. and set up ‘the lap’ in New York office building. Headed by Lawrence Weiss => understand customer response, observe and talk to customer. Sixth-generation prototype.
  • #33 e.g. Credit Card division approve without perform any credit evaluation. Citicorp lets them default on payment to get better statistics picture of how defaulters behave => 1.Credit-scoring system used for monitoring the behaviour of the existing and future cardholders.2.Largest card-issuer 36M cards globally
  • #34 Encourages speed in action and decision-making, even if the solution is less than perfect => Failure rate of initiatives is rather high The strategy is to be impulsive, to experiment, and to learn both from success and failures => Citicorp culture
  • #36 Using information technology – data processing, telecommunications, MIS, decision support and production control => Competitive weapon with 200 data centers operate world-wide
  • #37 Wide area network => Speed up operation and widespread to networkSubscribe extensive to financial studies=> Leverage knowledge, planning and problem-solving
  • #38 Best partnership => award for the relationship between managers and product specailistBest transaction => award for increased activity between 2+ contries.
  • #39 Awards (Motivation)Horizontal movement – transfer expertise from one place to another => Knowledge transfer
  • #40 Facilitating contact between people => Global competitive advantage
  • #43 Transformational Leadership - Envisioning skill - Energizing skill - Enabling skill
  • #44 Transformational Leadership - Envisioning skill - Energizing skill - Enabling skill
  • #46 In-house journal => Every issue contains 10-15 innovative solutions, permitting ideas to be drawn from solutions developed by others