Wayne Bovier, founder and CEO of Higher Digital, gave a presentation on the digital challenges facing higher education. He argued that higher education is lagging in adapting to digital changes and unrelenting student expectations of technology. Institutions need to take ownership of their digital strategies instead of relying on software companies. Bovier suggested that embracing learning and change through iterative releases, listening to students, and tightening the partnership between business leadership and IT can help institutions address these challenges.
Keynote Address: Are Software Companies Failing the Higher Ed?
1. #KUROGO2017
KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017
Digital Challenges Facing
Higher Education
Wayne Bovier
Founder | CEO
HIGHER DIGITAL, LLC
2. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 2
#KUROGO2017
About Me
• Founder & CEO of HIGHER DIGITAL
– Product & Digital Transformation Experts
• Last 9 Years in Education
– Blackboard
– Ellucian
– Laureate
• 4 Software Start-ups
• Graduate of Dickinson College and
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
3. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 3
#KUROGO2017
Starting With The End In Mind
• Incredible Digital
Challenges
• Impacting Everything
and Everyone
• Education is Lagging
• Students Expectations
• What Can You Do?
4. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 4
#KUROGO2017
Education Is Horrible At Learning
5. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 5
#KUROGO2017
Institutions Need to Own Digital Strategy
“Institutions can no longer
look to software
companies to provide
thought-leadership and
direction for their digital
strategy.”
“These software companies
are experiencing their own
digital disruptions and
focusing most of their energy
in how to survive in this
rapidly changing landscape.”
7. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 7
#KUROGO2017
Is This Really A Unique Time?
8. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 8
#KUROGO2017
1900’s
In 1900, 41% of the US workforce was employed in
agriculture; by 2000, that had fallen to 2%
9. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 9
#KUROGO2017
ATM’s
ATM’s were introduced in 1970; however bank teller
employment rose from 500,000 to 550,000 in 30 years
10. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 10
#KUROGO2017
Recommended Reading
11. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 11
#KUROGO2017
GE – “A Digital Industrial Company”
12. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 12
#KUROGO2017
Digital Disruption & Opportunity
Bold, tightly integrated digital
strategies will be the biggest
differentiator between companies that
win and companies that don’t, and the
biggest payouts will go to those that
initiate digital disruptions.
-McKinsey & Company (February 2017)
13. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 13
#KUROGO2017
Unrelenting Student Expectations
“Students (16-22) spend an average of +9 hours a day on a
digital device… this dynamic is the root of the challenge for
institutions and, more specifically, where software companies
are failing them.“
14. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 14
#KUROGO2017
How Students Use Technology
Source: https://www.educause.edu/research-and-publications/books/educating-net-generation/convenience-communications-and-control-how-students-use-technology
94.4% of
students
expect and
benefit
from
technology
15. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 15
#KUROGO2017
User Experience
16. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 16
#KUROGO2017
Who’s Leading This in Education?
17. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 17
#KUROGO2017
Is Higher Education Special?
18. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 18
#KUROGO2017
Our Collective Challenges
• Student experience is disjointed
• Financial waste
• Increased faculty workload
• Distributed and un-aligned data and reporting
• Outdated and costly digital infrastructure
• Legacy, high-cost architecture
19. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 19
#KUROGO2017
The Digital World Today & Our Barriers
Top Performers Higher Education
1 Skills Resources 1 Skills/Resources
2 Funding/Budgets 2 Funding/Budgets
3 Management Sponsorship 3 Culture/Structure of Org
4 Technology Challenges 4 Management Sponsorship
5 IT/Business Alignment 5 Capacity/Willingness to Change
6 Culture/Structure of Org 6 IT/Business Alignment
7 Lack of Time 7 Business Value of IT
8 Lack of Leadership 8 Conflicting Priorities
9 Pace 9 Technology Challenges (Legacy…)
10 Market Competition 10 Governance
Source: EDUCAUSE & Gartner “CIO’s 2017 Priorities: A Gartner Report”
http://events.educause.edu/~/media/files/events/educause-live/2017/live1713slides.pdf?la=en
20. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 20
#KUROGO2017
Fear of Change?
21. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 21
#KUROGO2017
Our Systems Are Getting More Complicated
A Tuition-driven institution with 13,000 students has
32 enterprise systems with another 50 smaller systems
22. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 22
#KUROGO2017
Not All Systems Are Equal
23. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 23
#KUROGO2017
Who Owns User Experience?
24. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 24
#KUROGO2017
New Skills & Processes Required
Tech Management Capability Description
1. Continuous delivery • Combine Agile development and rapid deployment
through DevOps
2. Ongoing strategy • Continuous strategic planning
• Fast-cycle project portfolio management
• Innovation has to accelerate
3. Outcome management • Fast-cycle governance.
• Rapid and continuous intra-year adjustments
4. Flexible sourcing • CIOs must secure and allocate variable resources
• Demand for resources beyond those currently on staff
5. End-to-end architecture • The technology stack has to support end-to-end CX.
• Continuous business services enable end-to-end CX
with minimal change to core systems
25. KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017 25
#KUROGO2017
What Can You Do About It?
• Own the User Experience
– Mobile & Portals
• Acknowledge Importance of
Technology for Students
• Embrace Learning & Change
– Small iterative releases
– Listen and Learn
– Agile and ScaledAgile
• Tighten Partnership Between
Business Leadership & IT
• Own The Digital Strategy
27. #KUROGO2017
KUROGO HIGHER ED MOBILE CONFERENCE 2017
Thank you!
Wayne Bovier
HIGHER DIGITAL
wayne.bovier@higherdigitalconsulting.com
@waynebovier
Editor's Notes
Digital challenges facing education is unlike anything the industry has ever seen
These same digital forces are causing software companies to become internally focused to survive – however there are exceptions
Across most industries, Education is lagging behind in all aspects of digital transformation and strategy
Students expectations for better digital services are unrelenting
How to survive and thrive in this world… own the user experience
In 1900, 41 percent of the US workforce was employed in agriculture; by
2000, that share had fallen to 2 percent (Autor 2014), mostly due to a wide range
of technologies including automated machinery. The mass-produced automobile
drastically reduced demand for many equestrian occupations, including
blacksmiths and stable hands
As a contemporary example, consider the surprising complementarities between
information technology and employment in banking, specifically the experience with
automated teller machines (ATMs) and bank tellers documented by Bessen (2015).
ATMs were introduced in the 1970s, and their numbers in the US economy quadrupled
from approximately 100,000 to 400,000 between 1995 and 2010. One might naturally
assume that these machines had all but eliminated bank tellers in that interval. But
US bank teller employment actually rose modestly from 500,000 to approximately
550,000 over the 30-year period from 1980 to 2010 (although given the growth in the
labor force in this time interval, these numbers do imply that bank tellers declined
as a share of overall US employment). With the growth of ATMs, what are all of these
tellers doing? Bessen observes that two forces worked in opposite directions. First, by
reducing the cost of operating a bank branch, ATMs indirectly increased the demand
for tellers: the number of tellers per branch fell by more than a third between 1988
and 2004, but the number of urban bank branches
Tell story of Northwood Univ.
Tell story of Amer Univ.
How many systems… who’s leading the digital transformation?