The document reports a case of isolated rupture of the brachialis muscle in a 24-year-old man, which is a rare injury. He presented with numbness and weakness in his right arm after sustaining a stab wound. Imaging revealed a tear in the distal brachialis muscle. He was treated conservatively with wound closure and rest. Over 4 months, he made a full recovery with normal strength and range of motion through non-operative treatment. This case suggests isolated brachialis muscle tears can be successfully treated non-operatively.