This document provides an overview of medical ethics, informed consent, and advance directives. It discusses key principles of medical ethics including autonomy, beneficence, non-maleficence, and justice. It defines informed consent and its legal and ethical basis, noting it is based on a patient's right to receive information and choose treatment. Exceptions to informed consent requirements are also outlined. Advance directives allow for healthcare decision making according to a patient's wishes if they become incapacitated. Case examples demonstrate how these principles apply to clinical scenarios.
This presentation talks about the context of developing the Electronic Health records for India. the guidelines as mentioned in the GOI site is described vividly with examples, for better understanding.
N.B: Please download the ppt first, for the animations to work better.
This presentation contains an introduction to emerging healthcare Technologies. These emerging technologies include Data Analytics, AI, Blockchain, Telehealth, virtual reality, cloud computing, and IOT. The concept of Nanorobots as future medicine is also included in this presentation.
This presentation talks about the context of developing the Electronic Health records for India. the guidelines as mentioned in the GOI site is described vividly with examples, for better understanding.
N.B: Please download the ppt first, for the animations to work better.
This presentation contains an introduction to emerging healthcare Technologies. These emerging technologies include Data Analytics, AI, Blockchain, Telehealth, virtual reality, cloud computing, and IOT. The concept of Nanorobots as future medicine is also included in this presentation.
WHO defines Quality of Life as an individual's perception of their position in life in the context of the culture and value systems in which they live and in relation to their goals, expectations, standards and concerns.
In this live webinar, Valora outlines the three main stages of starting a medical practice:
1) Planning - creating a business plan, setting a budget and outlining your timeline
2) The Nuts and Bolts - finding a location, credentialing, administrative setup, and choosing the right technology for your needs
3) Opening - hiring staff and activating your marketing plans
MHealth or Mobile Health is an emerging and an innovative of medication in India, by doctors can communicate and treat their patients very conveniently even from far distances.
The keynote address was delivered at the NYSAVSA Annual Conference on June 7, 2012 in Geneva, NY. The purpose of the address was 3-fold: (1) Outline what patient- and family-centered care is, its core components, and benefits; (2)Highlight some best practice volunteer programs aligned with the PFCC philosophy; (3) Provide conference participants with an assessment grid to evaluate their volunteer programming based on two PFCC standards and walk away from the presentation with concrete strategic next steps to enhance and strengthen their volunteer programming based on the PFCC model and philosophy.
The Philippine Board of Ophthalmology embarks on a difficult task of mandating teaching of ethics and professionalism for residency Training Programs in Ophthalmology in the country. This is the first lecture in that conference defining both ethics and medical professionalism.
WHO defines Quality of Life as an individual's perception of their position in life in the context of the culture and value systems in which they live and in relation to their goals, expectations, standards and concerns.
In this live webinar, Valora outlines the three main stages of starting a medical practice:
1) Planning - creating a business plan, setting a budget and outlining your timeline
2) The Nuts and Bolts - finding a location, credentialing, administrative setup, and choosing the right technology for your needs
3) Opening - hiring staff and activating your marketing plans
MHealth or Mobile Health is an emerging and an innovative of medication in India, by doctors can communicate and treat their patients very conveniently even from far distances.
The keynote address was delivered at the NYSAVSA Annual Conference on June 7, 2012 in Geneva, NY. The purpose of the address was 3-fold: (1) Outline what patient- and family-centered care is, its core components, and benefits; (2)Highlight some best practice volunteer programs aligned with the PFCC philosophy; (3) Provide conference participants with an assessment grid to evaluate their volunteer programming based on two PFCC standards and walk away from the presentation with concrete strategic next steps to enhance and strengthen their volunteer programming based on the PFCC model and philosophy.
The Philippine Board of Ophthalmology embarks on a difficult task of mandating teaching of ethics and professionalism for residency Training Programs in Ophthalmology in the country. This is the first lecture in that conference defining both ethics and medical professionalism.
Ethical Issues in Obtaining Informed Consent.pptxAhmed Mshari
Medical ethics is a set of moral principles, beliefs and values that guide decisions about patient care.
It is an integral part of good medical practice.
The health care professional uses knowledge, experience, and judgment and considers the ethical principles to make decisions on management recommendations.
Ethics Grand Rounds presented at Providence Health Care on 9/29/15 regarding questions and dilemmas in psychiatric care, particularly in the hospitalized medical patient
The goal of this webinar was to help hospice and healthcare professionals understand the ethics and application of artificial nutrition and hydration (ANH) for patients near the end of life.
When Decision-Making Is Imperative: Advance Care Planning for Busy Practice S...VITAS Healthcare
Complex, chronically ill patients present an opportunity to discuss and implement hospice and palliative care. Many elderly patients who present to the ED and other busy practice settings are hospice-eligible because of functional decline and multi-morbidity. Key tools can quickly facilitate goals-of-care (GOC) conversations, advance care planning, and hospice referrals amid time constraints and high-acuity challenges.
Assessment and Management of Disruptive Behaviors in Persons With DementiaVITAS Healthcare
This webinar helps physicians conduct a systematic evaluation for behavioral changes
in persons with dementia. It offers approaches for developing a comprehensive care plan for
disruptive behaviors. These methods incorporate caregiver education and non-pharmacologic
interventions followed by pharmacologic management.
Pain Management in the Context of an Opioid Epidemic: Considerations and Tool...VITAS Healthcare
This presentation details how to conduct a comprehensive pain assessment, considerations when prescribing analgesics, and when opioids may be appropriate.
Understanding Pain Management and Daily Practice ManagementVITAS Healthcare
Supported by evidence-based data, this webinar helped physicians and healthcare professionals gain greater understanding of the multifaceted applications of pain management in the context of palliative hospice care.
The goal of this webinar was to educate healthcare professionals about advance directives and advance care planning,
including the types and purposes of legal documents that govern patients’ decisions and
preferences.
The goal of this webinar was to help healthcare professionals improve care coordination for patients with advanced illness and to reduce hospital readmissions and length of stay (LOS).
The goal of this webinar was to educate physicians and healthcare professionals about hospice eligibility and the benefits of hospice for patients with advanced cardiac disease (ACD).
The goal of this webinar was to educate healthcare professionals about the differences between palliative and curative care while exploring the history and philosophy of the hospice movement.
The goal of this webinar was to equip healthcare professionals with an understanding of military veterans’ unique medical, emotional, and spiritual needs as they near the end of life.
The goal of this webinar was to equip healthcare professionals with an understanding of military veterans’ unique medical, emotional, and spiritual needs as they near the end of life.
Advanced Lung Disease: Prognostication and Role of HospiceVITAS Healthcare
The goal of this webinar was to educate physicians and healthcare professionals about the medical management of advanced lung disease (ALD), the value of advance care planning (ACP) and the benefits of hospice for end-of-life patients.
The clinical case study of a patient with advanced COPD who has multiple comorbid conditions and develops sepsis provideD the backdrop for two potential clinical pathways—sepsis and post-sepsis syndrome.
Understanding Pain Management and Daily Practice ManagementVITAS Healthcare
Supported by evidence-based data, this webinar helped physicians and healthcare professionals gain greater understanding of the multifaceted applications of pain management in the context of palliative hospice care.
The goal of this webinar was to help hospice and healthcare professionals understand the ethics and application of artificial nutrition and hydration (ANH) for patients near the end of life.
Key tools can quickly facilitate goals-of-care (GOC) conversations, advance care planning, and hospice referrals amid the ED’s time constraints and high-acuity challenges.
COVID-19 PCR tests remain a critical component of safe and responsible travel in 2024. They ensure compliance with international travel regulations, help detect and control the spread of new variants, protect vulnerable populations, and provide peace of mind. As we continue to navigate the complexities of global travel during the pandemic, PCR testing stands as a key measure to keep everyone safe and healthy. Whether you are planning a business trip, a family vacation, or an international adventure, incorporating PCR testing into your travel plans is a prudent and necessary step. Visit us at https://www.globaltravelclinics.com/
Letter to MREC - application to conduct studyAzreen Aj
Application to conduct study on research title 'Awareness and knowledge of oral cancer and precancer among dental outpatient in Klinik Pergigian Merlimau, Melaka'
ALKAMAGIC PLAN 1350.pdf plan based of door to door delivery of alkaline water...rowala30
Alka magic plan 1350 -we deliver alkaline water at your door step and you can make handsome money by referral programme
we also help and provide systematic guideline to setup 1000 lph alkaline water plant
Navigating Challenges: Mental Health, Legislation, and the Prison System in B...Guillermo Rivera
This conference will delve into the intricate intersections between mental health, legal frameworks, and the prison system in Bolivia. It aims to provide a comprehensive overview of the current challenges faced by mental health professionals working within the legislative and correctional landscapes. Topics of discussion will include the prevalence and impact of mental health issues among the incarcerated population, the effectiveness of existing mental health policies and legislation, and potential reforms to enhance the mental health support system within prisons.
Veterinary Diagnostics Market PPT 2024: Size, Growth, Demand and Forecast til...IMARC Group
The global veterinary diagnostics market size reached US$ 6.6 Billion in 2023. Looking forward, IMARC Group expects the market to reach US$ 12.6 Billion by 2032, exhibiting a growth rate (CAGR) of 7.3% during 2024-2032.
More Info:- https://www.imarcgroup.com/veterinary-diagnostics-market
Stem Cell Solutions: Dr. David Greene's Path to Non-Surgical Cardiac CareDr. David Greene Arizona
Explore the groundbreaking work of Dr. David Greene, a pioneer in regenerative medicine, who is revolutionizing the field of cardiology through stem cell therapy in Arizona. This ppt delves into how Dr. Greene's innovative approach is providing non-surgical, effective treatments for heart disease, using the body's own cells to repair heart damage and improve patient outcomes. Learn about the science behind stem cell therapy, its benefits over traditional cardiac surgeries, and the promising future it holds for modern medicine. Join us as we uncover how Dr. Greene's commitment to stem cell research and therapy is setting new standards in healthcare and offering new hope to cardiac patients.
Under Pressure : Kenneth Kruk's StrategyKenneth Kruk
Kenneth Kruk's story of transforming challenges into opportunities by leading successful medical record transitions and bridging scientific knowledge gaps during COVID-19.
CHAPTER 1 SEMESTER V PREVENTIVE-PEDIATRICS.pdfSachin Sharma
This content provides an overview of preventive pediatrics. It defines preventive pediatrics as preventing disease and promoting children's physical, mental, and social well-being to achieve positive health. It discusses antenatal, postnatal, and social preventive pediatrics. It also covers various child health programs like immunization, breastfeeding, ICDS, and the roles of organizations like WHO, UNICEF, and nurses in preventive pediatrics.
International Cancer Survivors Day is celebrated during June, placing the spotlight not only on cancer survivors, but also their caregivers.
CANSA has compiled a list of tips and guidelines of support:
https://cansa.org.za/who-cares-for-cancer-patients-caregivers/
ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance.pdfNEHA GUPTA
The "ICH Guidelines for Pharmacovigilance" PDF provides a comprehensive overview of the International Council for Harmonisation of Technical Requirements for Pharmaceuticals for Human Use (ICH) guidelines related to pharmacovigilance. These guidelines aim to ensure that drugs are safe and effective for patients by monitoring and assessing adverse effects, ensuring proper reporting systems, and improving risk management practices. The document is essential for professionals in the pharmaceutical industry, regulatory authorities, and healthcare providers, offering detailed procedures and standards for pharmacovigilance activities to enhance drug safety and protect public health.
INFECTION OF THE BRAIN -ENCEPHALITIS ( PPT)blessyjannu21
Neurological system includes brain and spinal cord. It plays an important role in functioning of our body. Encephalitis is the inflammation of the brain. Causes include viral infections, infections from insect bites or an autoimmune reaction that affects the brain. It can be life-threatening or cause long-term complications. Treatment varies, but most people require hospitalization so they can receive intensive treatment, including life support.
We are one of the top Massage Spa Ajman Our highly skilled, experienced, and certified massage therapists from different corners of the world are committed to serving you with a soothing and relaxing experience. Luxuriate yourself at our spas in Sharjah and Ajman, which are indeed enriched with an ambiance of relaxation and tranquility. We could confidently claim that we are one of the most affordable Spa Ajman and Sharjah as well, where you can book the massage session of your choice for just 99 AED at any time as we are open 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Visit : https://massagespaajman.com/
Call : 052 987 1315
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...ILC- UK
The Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index is an online tool created by ILC that ranks countries on six metrics including, life span, health span, work span, income, environmental performance, and happiness. The Index helps us understand how well countries have adapted to longevity and inform decision makers on what must be done to maximise the economic benefits that comes with living well for longer.
Alongside the 77th World Health Assembly in Geneva on 28 May 2024, we launched the second version of our Index, allowing us to track progress and give new insights into what needs to be done to keep populations healthier for longer.
The speakers included:
Professor Orazio Schillaci, Minister of Health, Italy
Dr Hans Groth, Chairman of the Board, World Demographic & Ageing Forum
Professor Ilona Kickbusch, Founder and Chair, Global Health Centre, Geneva Graduate Institute and co-chair, World Health Summit Council
Dr Natasha Azzopardi Muscat, Director, Country Health Policies and Systems Division, World Health Organisation EURO
Dr Marta Lomazzi, Executive Manager, World Federation of Public Health Associations
Dr Shyam Bishen, Head, Centre for Health and Healthcare and Member of the Executive Committee, World Economic Forum
Dr Karin Tegmark Wisell, Director General, Public Health Agency of Sweden
Global launch of the Healthy Ageing and Prevention Index 2nd wave – alongside...
Introduction to Medical Ethics
1. Introduction to Medical Ethics
Informed Consent & Advance Directives
Developed by:
Barry M. Kinzbrunner, MD
Chief Medical Officer
VITAS Healthcare
Miami, FL
2. Goals
• To provide an overview of medical ethics
• To demonstrate how informed consent and advance directives serve
to allow health care decision making to be carried out in an ethical
fashion
3. Objectives
At the end of this presentation, the participant will be able to:
• Define medical ethics and its various principles
• Articulate the legal and ethical bases for informed consent
• Comprehend the legal and ethical bases for advance directives
• Demonstrate an understanding of the legal and ethical bases for
surrogate decision making
4. Medical Ethics
Medical ethics is the discipline of evaluating the merits, risks
and social concerns of activities in the field of medicine. Many
methods have been suggested to help evaluate the ethics of a
situation. These methods tend to introduce principles that
should be thought about in the process of making a decision.
http://www.wordiq.com/definition/Medical_ethics
5. Medical Ethical Values
• Autonomy
• Beneficence
• Non-maleficence
• Justice
- Social
- Distributive
6. Medical Ethical Values (Cont.)
• Autonomy
– The right of an individual to choose among various options of treatment
free of coercion
• Beneficence
– The obligation to provide therapy with intent of doing good for the
individual
• Non-maleficence
– Providing therapy without intent of causing harm. Since all interventions
have risks, the basis of this is to minimize the potential risks and
avoidable harms
7. Justice
• Social Justice
– Provision of therapies realizing that all resources in a society are
limited and not everything is available to everyone
• Distributive Justice
– Interventions are provided as equitably as possible
Medical Ethical Values (Cont.)
8. Principle of Double Effect
Attributed to St. Thomas Aquinas
• The act itself must be morally good or at least indifferent
• While there is a risk of the bad effect occurring, it is not
guaranteed to occur
• The good effect must come from the intervention, NOT from the
bad effect
• The good effect must be sufficiently desirable as to outweigh the
potential risk of the bad effect
Connell, FJ: “Double Effect, Principle of,” New Catholic Encyclopedia (Vol 4),
New York: McGraw-Hill, 1967, pp. 1020–2.
9. Withdrawing vs. Withholding Care
Withdrawing care
• Decision to remove an active intervention that is already
being provided to a patient
Withholding care
• Decision not to provide an active intervention to a patient
10. Withdrawing vs. Withholding Care (Cont.)
• In medical ethics today, there is no distinction made between withdrawing
and withholding care in reference to the patient with a terminal illness
• In the past, withholding was considered ethically superior to withdrawing
• Most recently, ethicists are espousing the position that withdrawing is
ethically superior to withholding, since a trial of treatment gives information
on its efficacy for the particular patient
11. A Hypothetical Case
Mrs. H
• 83-year-old Hispanic female
• Alert and oriented
• Terminal advanced COPD
• Family agrees to hospice care for patient provided:
– Patient not be told she is dying and on hospice
– Hospice staff remove name badges when visiting
– Hospice staff not tell patient why they have come to see her
Question:
• Does this violate the concept of informed consent?
12. A Hypothetical Case (Cont.)
During the initial visit by hospice staff:
• Patient is given hospice papers and signs them without reading them
• Patient is told by family to sign papers without reading them,
which she does
• Family member signs papers for patient without the patient even knowing
this was done
Question:
• Which of these scenarios, if any, violate the concept of informed consent?
13. Informed Consent
• Implementation of the ethical principle of autonomy
• Accords individuals the option of accepting or refusing medical treatment
• Informed consent doctrine confers two separate and connected rights:
– The right to receive adequate information to make an intelligent choice about
whether to accept or refuse a proposed treatment
– The right to refuse medical treatment for any reason, including quality of life
based on the specific individual’s judgmenta
• To be considered legally valid, refusal of treatment must be based upon an
informed decision of the patient, after s/he has received all information material to
making such a decision
14. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Origins of the Informed Consent Doctrine
• Right to be free from nonconsensual interference with one’s person
• Morally wrong to force one to act against his or her will
• Serves six functions
– Protect individual autonomy
– Protect patient status as human being
– Encourage physicians to carefully consider decisions
– Avoid fraud or duress
– Foster rational decision-making by patients
– Increase public involvement in medicine
15. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Legal framework for Informed Consent
• Historically was based on “Battery Theory”
– Unwanted touching
– Not operative today in almost all jurisdictions
– May be operative if there is no consent at all (i.e. operating on the wrong knee)
• Negligence: Operative in virtually all jurisdictions
– Prima facie case based on:
• Duty to disclose information
• Failure to disclose (unless statutory exception met)
• If information had been disclosed, patient would not have consented to procedure
Injury and damages
16. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Duty to disclose standards
• Professional standard
– Physician has disclosed information that a reasonable or prudent doctor
would have disclosed under similar circumstances
• Patient-need standard
– What a reasonable person would want to know; information that would
be material to a patient
• States with statutes usually adopt the “Professional Standard”
• Case law is split 50-50 on which standard to follow
17. Informed Consent (Cont.)
What must be disclosed
• The condition or diagnosis
• Nature and purpose of treatment
• Risk of treatment
• Treatment alternatives which includes:
– Things that are already known
– Things that everybody should know
– Option of no treatment
– All alternatives do not have to be disclosed
18. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Exceptions to the General Rule of Disclosure
• Patient is unconscious or otherwise incapable of consenting
(emergency treatment)
– Harm from failure to treat is imminent
– Outweighs any harm threatened by proposed treatment
• Therapeutic privilege
– Risk disclosure poses such a threat of detriment to a patient as to become
unfeasible or contraindicated from a medical point of view
– Does not accept the paternalistic notion that the physician may remain silent
because divulgence might prompt the patient to forego therapy the doctor
believes the patient must receive
19. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Causation issues
• Disclosure of information would have caused the patient to refuse to
undergo the treatment
– Subjective: The patient states that if s/he had known, s/he would have
refused the intervention. This standard is impossible to prove because
anyone could say they would have refused if they had known
something they claim was not disclosed
– Objective: One must prove that a reasonable patient would not have
agreed to the intervention if s/he had known
• Most states have adopted the objective standard
20. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Hospice and Informed Consent
• Federal – Hospice §COP 418.62 Condition of Participation: Informed Consent
“A hospice must demonstrate respect for an individual’s rights by ensuring that an
informed consent form that specifies the type of care and services that may be
provided as hospice care during the course of the illness has been obtained for
every individual, either from the individual or representative as defined in §418.3”
• Representative
An individual who has been authorized under state law to terminate medical care or
elect or revoke the election of hospice care on behalf of a terminally ill individual
who is mentally or physically incapacitated
21. Informed Consent (Cont.)
Hospice and Informed Consent
General Provisions for Valid Medical Consent
Florida State Law §766.103 Fla. Stat.
• Consistent with accepted medical practice standards among similar trained and
experienced medical professionals
• Based on information provided by the medical profession, a reasonable person
would have a general understanding of the procedure, medically acceptable
alternatives, substantial risks and hazards.
• Based on all surrounding circumstances, a reasonable person would have
undergone the treatment
• The consent is validly signed by the patient (if mentally and physically competent
to give consent) or by another authorized person
22. A Hypothetical Case
Mrs. H
• 83-year-old Hispanic female
• Alert and oriented
• Terminal advanced COPD
• Family agrees to hospice care for patient provided:
– Patient not be told she is dying and on hospice
– Hospice staff remove name badges when visiting
– Hospice staff not tell patient why they have come to see her
Question:
• Does this violate the concept of informed consent?
23. A Hypothetical Case (Cont.)
During the initial visit by hospice staff:
• Patient is given hospice papers and signs them without reading them
• Patient is told by family to sign papers without reading them, which she does
• Family member signs papers for patient without the patient even knowing
this was done
Question:
• Which of these scenarios, if any, violate the concept of informed consent?
24. A Hypothetical Case (Cont.)
Mrs. H
• 83-year-old Hispanic female
• Unresponsive
• Terminal dementia
• Patient is referred for hospice care
Questions:
• Is this patient medically competent to make a decision?
• Who gets to decide and provide “informed consent” for the patient?
• Is the decision consistent with what the patient would have wanted if she was
able to make her own decisions?
• How could we know?
25. Informed Consent (Cont.)
When can a “representative” be substituted for a patient in the decision
making process?
Determining a patient’s competence
• Addressed by state law
• In Florida it is the primary responsibility of the attending physician
• A second physician evaluation may be obtained if the attending is unsure
• If there is a dispute, a judicial hearing may be scheduled although this is rarely
if ever required
• If a determination is made—either in the clinical setting or judicially—that a patient lacks
decision-making capacity, the patient cannot make decisions about his or her medical
treatment
26. Case of Karen Ann Quinlan
Early to mid 1970s
• The patient, Karen Ann Quinlan, a woman in her early 20s, suffered irreversible anoxic
brain damage resulting in a state of permanent unconsciousness now known as
permanent (or persistent) vegetative state (PVS)
• Her life was sustained for just over a year on a ventilator, with artificial nutrition and
hydration and other forms of medical and nursing care
• Her family came to the conclusion that being kept alive artificially was not what she
herself would have wanted done
• Physicians refused to honor the wishes of the family
27. Case of Karen Ann Quinlan (Cont.)
• Judicial relief was sought
• Landmark 1976 decision of the NJ Supreme Court
– As her legal guardian, Mr. Quinlan had the authority to have the ventilator withdrawn
– The legal basis for this decision was Ms. Quinlan’s constitutional right to privacy
– The fact that Ms. Quinlan was unconscious and unable to decide for herself did not mean that
she forfeited these rights, the New Jersey Supreme Court held
– It only meant that these rights would have to be exercised by someone else in this case her
father
• This was the first time that an individual’s right to refuse life-sustaining medical treatment was
affirmed by an American appellate-level court
• Also supports concept of “representative” decision making when a patient is medically
incompetent
28. Case of Nancy Cruzan
Mid-1980s
• A young woman named Nancy Beth Cruzan fell into a PVS after a devastating anoxic brain
injury
• The family requested that artificial nutritional support and hydration be discontinued
• The Missouri Supreme Court ruled
– Guardians did not have the authority to terminate life-sustaining medical treatment on the
basis of indirect or hypothetical reasoning about what the patient would have wanted
– Surrogate treatment decisions must be based on clear and convincing evidence of what
the patient would have wanted
– If there is no clear and convincing evidence of a patient’s wishes, the guardian is obligated
to act in the patient’s best interests, and for the Missouri Supreme Court, this meant the
continuation of life and of medical life support
29. Case of Nancy Cruzan (Cont.)
• The Cruzan family appealed to the United States Supreme Court
• The Court ruled that U.S. Constitution confers a right (“liberty interest”) to refuse
medical treatment, even life-prolonging medical treatment (including artificial
nutrition and hydration)
• However, it also held that states did not violate this constitutional right by requiring
clear and convincing evidence of the patient’s wishes when the patient lacked
decision-making capacity
• The Cruzan case marked the end of a period of legal consolidation because this
was the first time that the U.S. Supreme Court had addressed end-of-life medical
decision making in the light of the Constitution and established a right to refuse
medical treatment
30. Advance Directives
The requirement of the Missouri Supreme Court,
upheld by the US Supreme Court, that allowed
the need to establish “clear and convincing
evidence” of the patient’s wishes when the
patient lacked decision-making capacity led to
the development of advance directives and the
state and federal laws defining them
31. Advance Directives
• Advance directives are documents that tell your physician and
other health care providers what kind of care you desire or do not
desire to receive if you become unable to make medical decisions
• Advance directives can be designed to delineate what care you do
or do not wish based on the severity of illness and/or the likelihood
of recovery
32. Advance Directives (Cont.)
Types of Advance Directives
• Living will
– Instructions by the patient on interventions s/he desires or does not desire
should s/he be in a terminal condition or a PVS or other irreversible neurological
condition (in some states) and cannot express his or her wishes
• Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care
– Designates who will make health care decisions if one becomes
unconsciousness or otherwise incompetent to make medical decisions
(also known as a Health Care Proxy)
• Combination of both
• Each state has its own set of laws governing advance directives
33. A Hypothetical Case (Cont.)
Mrs. H:
• 83-year-old Hispanic female
• Unresponsive
• Terminal Dementia
• Patient is referred for hospice care
Questions:
• Is this patient medically competent to make a decision?
• Who gets to decide and provide “informed consent” for the patient?
• Is the decision consistent with what the patient would have wanted if she was
able to make her own decisions?
• How could we know?
34. Advance Directives
What happens if there is no advance
directive document and a patient is
incompetent and unable to make a medical
decision?
Who gets to decide, and how is the
decision made?
35. Case of Terri Schiavo
1990
• Terri Schiavo, a 26-year-old female, suddenly collapsed in her apartment and
suffered a cardiac arrest
• Despite being resuscitated successfully from the point of view of
cardiopulmonary function, she suffered significant anoxic brain damage
• Due to an inability to swallow, a percutaneous gastrostomy (PEG) feeding tube
was placed
• Lack of a neurologic recovery led to a diagnosis of persistent
vegetative state
• As Mrs. Schiavo did not have an advance directive (either a living will or durable
power of attorney) her husband was granted legal guardianship, without
objection from her parents
36. Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
Mid-1990s to about 2000
• Attempts at aggressive rehabilitation were unsuccessful and it became
clear to the husband that his wife’s condition was permanent and would
not improve
• He also believed that she would not have wanted to live in a persistent
vegetative state
• On that basis, Mr. Schiavo decided that he wanted his wife’s feeding tube
removed
• Mr. and Mrs. Schindler, the parents of Terri Schiavo, disagreed with her
husband’s decision
37. Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
• Because consensus could not be reached, Mr. Schiavo petitioned the Florida
courts to appoint a health care “proxy” in order to make an independent decision
on his wife’s medical condition and whether or not it would be reasonable to
discontinue feeding her through the PEG tube
• The court proxy decided that the patient’s condition was irreversible
• The husband demonstrated to the satisfaction of the court that his
wife would not have wanted to be kept alive in this state. The court therefore
agreed with the husband’s position that the feeding tube
could be removed
• The patient was admitted to an inpatient hospice facility for this purpose
38. Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
• However, the parents appealed this decision at every level within the
Florida court system, leading to the feeding tube removal being
postponed numerous times so the case could be adjudicated. In all
instances, the initial decision was upheld
• This led, in 2003, to the removal of Terri Schiavo’s feeding tube
• The parents appealed to the Florida legislature, and a law was passed
and signed by the state governor granting him the authority to order
Terri’s feeding tube replaced, which was done
39. Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
• Over the next 15 months, continued appeals and stays were granted at the
state level, leading to the finding by the Florida Supreme Court that the law
allowing the feeding tube to be replaced was unconstitutional
• The parents attempted to appeal to the US Supreme Court, and special
legislation was passed by the US Congress and signed by the President of
the United States to allow the US Supreme Court to hear the case
• However, the US Supreme Court refused to hear the case and the original
court, standing by its prior decision, ordered the feeding tube removed on
March 18, 2005
• Terri Schiavo passed away on March 31, 2005
40. What was the central issue in the Terri Schiavo case?
• Right to live vs. right to die
or
• Who gets to decide when there is no advance directive
Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
41. Health Care Surrogate
• Surrogate: As referenced in U.S. law, a person who makes decisions foran other
• In the context of health care it is the term used to refer to a person who has the legal
authority to make decisions for an incompetent patient
• Surrogates may be determined in one of several ways:
– Patient-designated surrogate: through a DPOA type of advance directive
– Judicially-designated surrogate: appointed by a judge and known as a “Court-
Appointed Guardian”
– Statutorily-designated surrogates: lists family members and other persons, in
order of priority, who are authorized to make medical decisions for an incompetent
patient who has not designated a surrogate, and for whom there is no court-
appointed guardian
42. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
Florida Surrogate Statute Order of Priority
• Judicially appointed guardian of the patient if already named
– Appointment not required if not named
• The patient’s spouse
• An adult child of the patient
– If the patient has more than one adult child a majority of the adult children who are
reasonably available for consultation
• A parent of the patient
• The adult sibling of the patient
– If the patient has more than one sibling, a majority of the adult siblings who are
reasonably available for consultation
43. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
• An adult relative of the patient
– who has exhibited special care and concern for the patient
– who has maintained regular contact with
the patient
– who is familiar with the patient’s activities, health and religious
or moral beliefs
• A close friend of the patient
44. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
• A clinical social worker licensed pursuant to chapter 491, or who is a graduate of a
court-approved guardianship program
– Chosen by the provider’s bioethics committee (or another committee if the
provider does not have one) and not employed by the provider
– The proxy will be notified that, upon request, the provider shall make available a
second physician, not involved in the patient’s care to assist the proxy in
evaluating treatment
– Decisions to withhold or withdraw life-prolonging procedures will be reviewed by
the facility’s bioethics committee
– Documentation of efforts to locate proxies from prior classes must be recorded
in the patient record
45. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
Standards for Surrogate Decision Making
• Informed consent must be obtained from the patient’s surrogate
• Since the goal of informed consent is to protect patient autonomy, the
surrogate must determine what the patient’s wishes are about treatment,
not what treatment is best for the patient in the surrogate’s opinion
• What is the standard as to the degree of certainty the surrogate should
have regarding the decisions made? This differs from state to state
46. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
Standards for Surrogate Decision Making
• Subjective standard
– Also known as “Clear and Convincing Evidence” standard
– Surrogate should be virtually certain that this is what the person
would have wanted
– Surrogate is acting as a conduit for expressing those wishes
– Written document preferred
– Oral evidence may be acceptable
47. Health Care Surrogate (Cont.)
Standards for Surrogate Decision Making
• Substituted Judgment Standard
– Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that simply because a surrogate was a
patient’s mother she would know what he wanted even though he had never
expressed any views on the subject
• Best Interest Standard
– In the absence of any clear knowledge or any knowledge of what the patient would
have wanted, the surrogate is empowered to make a decision that the surrogate,
in good faith, believes is in the best interests of the patient rather than one that
effectuates the patient’s own wishes
48. Case of Terri Schiavo (Cont.)
What was the central issue in the Terri Schiavo case?
• Right to live vs. right to die
or
• Who gets to decide when there is no advance directive
49. A Hypothetical Case (Cont.)
Mrs. H
• 83-year-old Hispanic female
• Unresponsive
• Terminal dementia
• Patient is referred for hospice care
Question:
• Who gets to decide and provide “informed consent” for the patient?
• Is the decision consistent with what the patient would have wanted if she was
able to make her own decisions?
• How could we know?