The document summarizes a report by the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights on strengthening the role of the EU in fighting child trafficking. Some key findings include: there is no clear definition of child trafficking in EU law; many children disappear from shelters and likely fall victim to trafficking; identification of victims is crucial but challenging; and protection of child victims needs to be a priority, including not detaining or punishing victims. The report calls for EU legislation to address these issues, define child trafficking, improve victim identification and protection, and ensure children's best interests.
Transnational organised crime (TOC) represents a major threat to global security. It threatens peace and human security, violates human rights and undermines the economic, social, cultural, political and civil development of societies worldwide. Because of its transnational character, TOC requires a targeted and comprehensive approach, including the swift application of international co-operation mechanisms.
This white paper, drafted at the request of the Committee of Ministers, establishes five areas in which the Council of Europe could contribute to fighting TOC and identifies specific tasks that could be carried out better or more efficiently by the Organisation: 1. Problems related to police and judicial international co-operation, 2. The use of special investigative techniques, 3. The implementation of witness protection programmes and collaboration of state witnesses, 4. The need for increasing co-operation with administrative agencies and the private sector and 5. The essential need to target the proceeds of crime in order to discourage this type of crime and to improve the effectiveness of the fight against criminal organisations that operate in a transnational setting.
With an innovative multidisciplinary approach and the choice to focus on improving the criminal response in a transnational setting, this White Paper is intended to become a helpful tool for policy makers and practitioners alike.
Guardian of human rights, democracy and the rule of law: activity report.
This publication presents the work carried out in 2015
by the different bodies and sectors of the Council of Europe, highlighting its particular strengths and achievements.
More information - http://www.coe.int/en/web/portal/home
Transnational organised crime (TOC) represents a major threat to global security. It threatens peace and human security, violates human rights and undermines the economic, social, cultural, political and civil development of societies worldwide. Because of its transnational character, TOC requires a targeted and comprehensive approach, including the swift application of international co-operation mechanisms.
This white paper, drafted at the request of the Committee of Ministers, establishes five areas in which the Council of Europe could contribute to fighting TOC and identifies specific tasks that could be carried out better or more efficiently by the Organisation: 1. Problems related to police and judicial international co-operation, 2. The use of special investigative techniques, 3. The implementation of witness protection programmes and collaboration of state witnesses, 4. The need for increasing co-operation with administrative agencies and the private sector and 5. The essential need to target the proceeds of crime in order to discourage this type of crime and to improve the effectiveness of the fight against criminal organisations that operate in a transnational setting.
With an innovative multidisciplinary approach and the choice to focus on improving the criminal response in a transnational setting, this White Paper is intended to become a helpful tool for policy makers and practitioners alike.
Guardian of human rights, democracy and the rule of law: activity report.
This publication presents the work carried out in 2015
by the different bodies and sectors of the Council of Europe, highlighting its particular strengths and achievements.
More information - http://www.coe.int/en/web/portal/home
Collaboration and Productivity with Microsoft SharePointEdgewater
Ori Fishler, Web Solutions Practice Director at Edgewater Technology, was invited to speak at the Delta Dental CFO Conference on April 26th on Marco Island, FL. Ori presented the collaboration benefits of SharePoint 2010, specifically how a collaborative platform like SharePoint:
- streamlines finance and accounting processes
- improves the productivity of the underwriting department
Improving Performance through Knowledge Management and CollaborationAndrew Muras, PMP
Presentation given at Performance Support Symposium; using knowledge management, social learning and collaboration for improving individual and organizational performance
Leveraging Technology in Collaborative Work - FoundationsStephen Judd
Modern knowledge work, such as that done by Extension professionals, often calls for collaborative efforts to address complex issues from a variety of angles. Using technology to facilitate collaboration can allow teams to span geographical boundaries, work at different times, easily share information, foster frequent interaction, expand the team’s expertise, and reduce costs. However, collaboration within virtual spaces is different than traditional face-to-face work and requires consideration of a variety of factors: comfort with and access to the technology, leadership and coordination of the team, scheduling across time zones and institutions, etc.
In this webinar we will highlight published research about technology-facilitated collaboration and discuss its benefits, challenges, and factors that contribute to success. This foundational webinar will set the stage for subsequent webinars that will address specific tools and techniques that can be used to foster the success of collaborative work using technology.
So you think collaboration tools might be valuable for your company but you just aren't sure how they can be used effectively? This short presentation is meant to introduce you to how Collaboration 2.0 tools can be used to effectively address real world business problems...and how you can identify these needs within your company.
Encouraging and Facilitating Collaboration at WorkMichael Sampson
The slides from my keynote presentation at Congres Intranet 2012 in Utrecht, in March 2012. I talked about the reality of the intranet, the nature of collaboration, and how to encourage and facilitate collaboration at work by overcoming barriers to collaboration.
This section addresses some of the social dilemmas that currently affect humanity on a global scale. We will see how game theory has provided tools to study them scientifically, and how cooperation theory is looking for a way out of them.
Cooperation theory research and proposals are grouped into three major areas: strategic, institutional and motivational.
We also review some global dilemmas to understand their inner dynamics, what would have to be done to correct them, and what obstacles there are to achieving this.
Social tools are now being offered by a number of collaboration vendors. Many organizations are unsure of how to integrate social tools with existing team workflows. Managers must embrace, rather than hinder, integration of social collaboration tools. This storyboard, along with its accompanying tools, will help you:
* Understand social collaboration and how it builds team effectiveness.
* Develop a strategy for enabling social collaboration patterns with technology.
* Understand the major vendors and feature sets for social tools.
* Foster a culture that encourages the use of social collaboration tools.
Managers must recognize that social tools are powerful enablers of knowledge-sharing and productivity in the age of the team.
What is collaboration? Here I present both a definition of collaboration and a model for how to think about collaboration. This gives us a framework for how to improve the way we collaborate.
Human Trafficking Today's Slavery Hidden In Plain Sight Scott Mills
Nick Kinsella, independent presentation on how to stop human trafficking to delegates of the 2011 Crime Stoppers International Training Conference in Montego Bay, Jamaica October 26, 2011
The children refugees on the move, traveling alone, unaccompanied and their p...Детска Амбасада Меѓаши
The children refugees on the move, traveling alone, unaccompanied and their position in the country, support and protection
Millions of children as victims of war flee to other countries. Almost never in the history children were exposed to such brutality as it has been these last few years, especially children refugees. They are the most vulnerable population in wars, emergency crises and they are facing with dangers from violence, abuse, illnesses, kidnapping and abducting. Traveling without their parents, the children refugees are more exposed to danger from child trafficking, kidnapping and adoptions. The children refugees who are traveling unaccompanied are in biggest danger from the traffickers.
The migrant crises that has been happening in Europe in the last two years brought number of risks and dangers for thousands of unaccompanied children who came to Southeastern Europe, including Macedonia. Europe is facing with the biggest crises these last few decades and Macedonia inadvertently “entered” in the center of the crises. The First children’s embassy in the world Megjashi reacted even in 2015 and demanded that no child would be allowed to transit without a parent, guardian or close family member. What we, as First Children’s Embassy in the world Megjashi most appeal is mobility and commitment of States Parties to the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Optional Protocols to the Convention on the Rights of the Child that they must not allow their children to be exposed to the risk to be abused or separated from their families
Summer School “The EU area of freedom, security and justice”, July 1-3, 2017
Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence, University of Macedonia, Thessaloniki, Greece
The Jean Monnet Centre of Excellence, in collaboration with the Jean Monnet Chair of the Democritus University of Thrace organize a summer school entitled “The EU area of freedom, security and justice”, that will take place in July 1-3, at the Conference Room of the University of Macedonia.
Trafficking in Human Beings by Anna Ekstedt (CBSS Task Force against Traffick...Gerd Tarand
Anna Ekstedts presentation at the youth conference in the framework of the European Commission’s Strategy for the Baltic Sea Region, held in the Free and Hanseatic City of Hamburg on the 3.-4. February 2009.
INTERPOL has its origins in the early twentieth century when high-ranking police officials from twenty European States came together to create a centralized police cooperation agency. At 1923 Criminal Police Congress in Vienna, in response to the need for enhanced international police cooperation to tackle international crime, theInternational
Criminal Police Commission („ICPC‟) was established, headquartered in Vienna, and at that stage under the management of Austrian police. When the institution subsequently came under the control of Nazi Germany, its headquarters were moved to Berlin and most national police forces withdrew their participation.
Loopholes in the sand how europe is outsourcing its international obligationsWillem Kleinendorst
The EU migration policy has been a hot topic for several years. Until today there is still no clear solution to the refugee crisis, leaving EU member states divided over how to deal with the situation. Meanwhile member states and refugees have stated to take matters into their own hands. Through bi-lateral agreements Europe has slowly but surely started to outsource its border control operations to third countries. Through these bi-lateral migration deals the EU cannot be held liable for their consequences. In essence, this paper will investigate Europe’s bi-lateral migration policy by using Libya as a case study. On the basis of the findings of the research a conclusion will be drawn and recommendations issued.
Presentation by Michael Diedring (Secretary General of the European Council on Refugees and Exiles) on the occasion of the conference on Immigration – a source of wealth and duties for Europe organised by the EESC, the Council of Europe and the French Economic, Social and Environmental Council in Brussels on 15 March 2013.
Global progress and delay in ending violence against childrenThomas Müller
The International NGO Council on Violence against Children was established in 2006 to work with NGOs and other partners, including member states, to ensure that the recommendations from the UN Study on Violence against Children are effectively implemented. Now, as the Sustainable Development Goals adopt the call to end all violence against children and the Global Partnership to End Violence Against Children take up the mantle of pursuing this goal, the NGO Council publishes its fourth and final report.
The report concludes that for many children around the world violence is an ever present fact of life. Where progress has been made, it remains tainted by its limitations. The contributions from key global experts on violence against children point to some hard truths about our failings, but also to the way ahead.
Innovation within organisations: Child Helpline International - Innovation Ex...Thomas Müller
Innovation within organisations: Child helpline International launched a campaign called Free Our Voices in order to raise awareness amongst telecom operators of the high number of unanswered calls to child helplines. The campaign is innovative because it is Child helpline International's first campaign, it involves ground breaking technology and it is entirely youth led. These slides were used in at The Innovation Exchange organised by War Child Holland in collaboration with TNO on 8 December 2015 in The Hague.
Creating a Non-Violent Juvenile JusticeThomas Müller
Child Helpline International is part of the "International NGO Council of Violence against Children", which developed this report. This report from creates an enriching
vision of a non-violent juvenile justice system.
The vision is no more than the fulfillment of states’
obligations under international law to create a distinct
and separate justice system which takes account of
the special status of the child, focuses exclusively on
rehabilitation and reintegration and protects the child
from all forms of violence.
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children: "creating a non-v...Thomas Müller
The International NGO Council on Violence Against Children has launched it latest report, "Creating a non-violent juvenile justice system". This report is a follow-up to the 2006 UN Study on Violence against Children. This report has been written to address the growing epidemic and global magnitude of the violence being experienced by children in juvenile justice systems. Whilst aspiring to clarify the many ways in which governments are failing to protect children in conflict with the law, the report also presents a non-violence vision of juvenile justice.
Chat Counselling for Children and Youth - A HandbookThomas Müller
This book was developed by Trine Sindahl from the Child Helpline International Danish member organisations Bornsvilkar. Child Helpline International has translated it from Danish into English language in order to make this great resource avaialble to a bigger target group.
Categorising or labelling large and diverse groups of people as vulnerable can lead to fragmented and
ineffective interventions, which ignore overlapping vulnerabilities and the changing nature of
vulnerabilities over time, even during one specific crisis”. To effectively and strategically respond to
the protection needs of populations across the conflict impacted region, decision makers must
determine which vulnerable groups are most in need of humanitarian support and what the factors
are that increase and compound their vulnerabilities.
Fundraising Handbook for child protection and gender based violence in humani...Thomas Müller
The global Gender Based Violence (GBV) and Child Protection Working Group
(CPWG) areas of responsibilities (AoRs) have developed this handbook to
provide practical guidance to child protection and GBV coordination groups and
their members; with the aim of helping them access more humanitarian funding.
Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian ActionThomas Müller
The Child Protection Working Group (CPWG) is the global level forum for coordination and collaboration on child protection in humanitarian settings. The group brings together NGOs, UN agencies, academics and other partners under the shared objective of ensuring more predictable, accountable and effective child protection responses in emergencies. - See more at: http://cpwg.net/cpwg/#sthash.wTqjET4D.dpuf
In 2010 the members of the global CPWG agreed on the need for child protection standards in humanitarian settings. The Minimum Standards for Child Protection in Humanitarian Action were developed between January 2011 and September 2012. The process of drafting the Minimum Standards involved over 400 individuals from 30 agencies in over 40 countries, including child protection practitioners, humanitarian actors from other sectors, academics and policy makers. - See more at: http://cpwg.net/minimum-standards/#sthash.01h1va2Z.dpuf
1. European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights (FRA)
MEMO / 24 June 2009
EU Agency for Fundamental Rights:
Report on strengthening the role of the EU
in the fight against child trafficking
In July 2007, the European Commission asked the European Union Agency
for Fundamental Rights (FRA) to develop indicators to measure how the rights
of the child are implemented, protected, respected and promoted in the EU
Member States. The indicators were published by the Agency in March 2009
and are available from http://fra.europa.eu.
In October 2007, the European Commission requested that the Agency
started collecting data on the basis of these indicators. Following a
consultation meeting with other international organisations and the European
Commission in Vienna, in April 2008, it was agreed that the FRA’s first
thematic study on the rights of the child would focus on child trafficking.
KEY RESULTS
Many children fall victim to trafficking every year
Trafficking in human beings is a major problem both in the EU and worldwide.
Every year a substantial number of children fall victim to trafficking for sexual
exploitation or other purposes. Estimates as to the full extent of the problem
have been provided by some reputable sources, yet there are no studies or
reliable statistics to provide a comprehensive picture. It is therefore impossible
to make accurate statements regarding the actual levels of human and child
trafficking at national, international and global levels.
A clear definition of child trafficking is lacking in both the EU legal framework,
and at Member State level. The definition of human trafficking provided by the
Council Framework Decision on combating trafficking in human beings of
2002 only covers child trafficking for the purposes of labour exploitation or
sexual exploitation, but fails to mention types of exploitation for other
purposes, such as organ extraction or exploitative forms of adoption. Although
1
2. intra-state trafficking is covered by the definition of human trafficking in
international law (see Council of Europe Convention on Action against
Trafficking in Human Beings from 2005), it is not covered by the definition of
human trafficking in a number of EU Member States.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights advocates that:
• the EU and the Member States should adopt a clear and
comprehensive definition of trafficking, as contained in the Council of
Europe’s Convention on Action against Trafficking in Human Beings.
Children disappearing from shelters most likely fall victim to trafficking
In 2008 400 of the 1320 minors that arrived in the Lampedusa
immigration centre disappeared. According to Roberto Maroni, the Ministry
of Interior, they might have been trafficked for organs. However, ‘Save the
children’ states that there is no evidence that this is the case, but that the
children may have fallen into the hands of criminal organisations, in particular
sex traffickers1.
According to NGOs, the disappearance of children from shelters in the EU
Member States is widespread, with their destinations largely unknown.
However, this problem remains largely ignored, with a severe lack of
monitoring as a result of insufficient data collection in at least 9 Member
States. Only a few Member States have developed policies to tackle this
issue.
Specialised shelters for victims of child trafficking are not provided in most
Member States. The children are sent to shelters for adult victims of
trafficking, specialised shelters for unaccompanied minors or other facilities
for vulnerable children.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights advocates that:
• EU legislation should guarantee that victims of child trafficking are
sheltered in suitable facilities which are tailored to their needs;
• EU legislation should oblige Member States to collect statistics on
children leaving shelters or otherwise disappearing, and to make them
available for public scrutiny;
• EU legislation should oblige Member States to enact a policy to tackle
disappearances, including offering a long-term perspective to victims of
child trafficking to stay in the country.
1
As reported in La Repubblica (24/02/2009) p 2., M. Reggio, “Traffico d’organi anche in Italia
Maroni lancia l’allarme minori”
2
3. Good practice: offering a long term perspective to victims of child
trafficking
The Czech Republic allows unaccompanied minors to stay in the country
until they reach the age of 18. Children who are studying may then apply for
national residency status. Upon the condition of integration, a permanent
residence permit may then be granted to them.
Extremely low number of child trafficking convictions
There are generally very few final convictions in child trafficking cases.
Convictions for child trafficking could only be detected in 4 Member States in
the 2000-2007 period.
Identification of victims is vital to prosecuting traffickers
In 2000 Dayo, 15 years old, was brought from Nigeria to the U.K. She looked
after 3 children, did all the domestic tasks and was daily beaten. In 2003,
when she finally contacted a help group, the trafficker tried to return her to
Nigeria. She refused to get on to the plane and was therefore taken to the
immigration services. The immigration officers did not believe anything she
said and let the trafficker go and kept her in a centre. After 5 days they took
her to the airport for deportation but she managed to contact an Asylum Aid
group that prevented the deportation, claiming that she was an
unaccompanied minor who was seeking asylum in the UK2.
The identification of victims of child trafficking is crucial to prosecuting
traffickers and providing victims with protection and assistance.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights advocates that:
• EU legislation should contain minimum standards for the identification
of victims of child trafficking;
• the application of EU legislation combating trafficking in human beings
needs to be regularly reviewed to ensure that it is effective and does
not merely exist on paper. The European Commission should be
entrusted with the task of drawing up a periodic report on the
implementation of the relevant EU legislation, taking into account the
views of the European Union Agency for Fundamental Rights, as well
as the views of relevant non-governmental organisations.
2
“I was a victim of child traffickers”, in: BBC news (17/05/2004) http://news.bbc.co.uk
3
4. Good practices for identifying victims of child trafficking
Early identification of victims, which facilitates easy entry into the
assistance system, is a top priority for the Finnish Border Guard in combating
child trafficking. For this reason, the Finnish Immigration Service has prepared
instructions for authorities involved in asylum processes (including the police,
the Finnish Border Guard and the Finnish Immigration Service), through which
the authorities are informed of how to identify victims of human trafficking and
unaccompanied minors who are at risk of becoming victims of trafficking,
upon arrival in the country. The instructions also include recommendations on
how authorities can co-operate effectively in the process of victim
identification and prevention of trafficking. They also underline sensitivity
when dealing with under-aged asylum seekers who are at risk of becoming
victims of human trafficking.
In co-operation with NGOs, the Government of the Czech Republic has
formalised its victim screening process with Victim Screening and
Identification Procedures, by issuing a pamphlet with a list of 12 basic
questions to police officers which may help them identifying victims of
trafficking in human beings. Detailed questions are often essential for law
enforcement to discover a human trafficking case.
In the Netherlands, the Aanwijzing Mensenhandel (Instruction Trafficking in
Human Beings) provides that police and prosecution officers are only to deal
with cases of trafficking in human beings and to have direct contact with
possible victims, if they hold a specific certificate.
Protection of child victims of trafficking needs to be a priority
Regina, 16/17 years old, a Nigerian national, was arrested on 29 February
2008 at the River Docks, while she was on a boat leaving the UK for France.
According to her statement, she was brought to the UK by a man, installed in
a flat where she was raped and forced into prostitution. When arrested by the
police, she handed over an identity card, which she later admitted was not
hers and was subsequently taken into custody. Although a social worker from
the ‘Poppy Project’ alleged that Regina was a victim of a sex trafficking
organisation, the girl was prosecuted for an immigration offence. Despite
the evidence suggesting that she was probably under aged, there was no
inquiry into her age. She was tried on March 2008 as an adult (not in the
Youth Court) and sentenced to 8 months imprisonment (less 16 days spent
on remand). She remained in custody until bailed on 26 June3.
According to international law, the interests of children must always be a
primary consideration at the heart of all law. However this is still not the case
for child trafficking. This ’principle of best interests of the child’ is, amongst
others, enshrined in Article 24 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the
EU. Member States have important interests in combating crime and
regulating immigration. However, these policy goals should not be allowed to
overshadow the best interests of victims of child trafficking.
3
United Kingdom / Court of Appeal / Judgment (2008) EWCA Crim *2835.
4
5. In half of the Member States, no formal policy on non-punishment exists. This
means that in these countries, victims of child trafficking could be prosecuted
for border offences or other offences such as illegal prostitution, in spite of
being victims themselves.
In these countries there is a higher risk that victims of child trafficking might
not develop a relationship of trust with state authorities, which would no longer
leave them dependent on their traffickers.
In the vast majority of EU Member States, the detention of victims of child
trafficking pending deportation is not explicitly prohibited by law.
The EU Agency for Fundamental Rights advocates that:
• EU legislation should strictly prioritise the best interests of the child as
a core general principle of EU law. The best interests of the child must
be respected, protected and promoted as a priority.
• EU legislation should ensure that a child who is believed to be a victim
of trafficking should not be detained as a matter of principle.
• EU legislation should include a formal policy of non-punishment of
victims of child trafficking to ensure that they can develop a relationship
of trust with state authorities, in order to escape their dependency on
their traffickers.
• Socio-economic rights (health care, housing, education) of victims of
child trafficking need to be ensured by EU legislation.
Good practice: prohibition of detention
In three Member States (Italy, Hungary and Slovenia), detention pending
deportation of minors is prohibited by law. In Hungary by virtue of the
Third Country Nationals Act, detention pending deportation cannot be
imposed against underage nationals of a third country, whether they are
victims of child trafficking or not. In Italy as general rule, the Italian legal
system does not allow the deportation of foreign children below the age of 18,
unless the minor constitutes a danger for public safety or State security, in
which case he/she may be deported for this special reason. In Slovenia
‘residence under stricter police supervision (i.e. confinement of free
movement to the premises of a Centre in accordance with the Centre's house
rules) for an unaccompanied third country national minor cannot be ordered
(due to his/her status as a minor)’. In Finland, while there is no general legal
prohibition to detain children, the basic principle is that a child who is believed
to be a victim of trafficking is not detained under any circumstances.
The report is available from: http://fra.europa.eu
For further questions please contact Mrs Waltraud HELLER
at the FRA Media Team:
E-mail: media@fra.europa.eu
Tel.: +43 1 58030-642
5