EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Regional analysis of forest and environmental product use and dependence amongst rural households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and Russia
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Regional analysis of forest and environmental product use and dependence amongst rural households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and Russia
This paper presents data from the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) on global forest ownership. It discusses the complexity of classifying forest ownership given varying land tenure systems. The paper notes that while FAO collects data on forest cover through remote sensing, understanding forest ownership requires collecting information directly from countries. It summarizes available data on forest area and ownership by region, finding gaps in information reported by some countries. The paper aims to contribute to improving FAO's strategy for systematically collecting, analyzing, and reporting data on global forest ownership and tenure rights.
Pacific Geographies (PG), ISSN (Print) 2196-1468 / (Online) 2199-9104, is the peer-reviewed semi-annual publication of the Association for Pacific Studies. From 1992-2012 it was labelled Pacific News (ISSN 1435-8360). It is published through the Department of Human Geography of Hamburg University, Germany.
It is an open access journal, all articles can be downloaded for free. There are no submission or APC charges. The authors retain copyright. Copyright & Licensing: CC BY-NC-ND.
The PG provides an interdisciplinary academic platform to discuss social, cultural, environmental and economic issues and developments in the Asia-Pacific region.
In order to uphold scientific standards, the PG is implementing a peer-review process. Articles marked as „scientific papers“ have been peer-reviewed by two external reviewers. Articles marked as „research notes“ have been peer-reviewed by one external reviewer and a member of the editorial board. All other articles have been reviewed by the editorial board. Scientific papers and research notes receive a Digital Object Identifier (DOI).
The Association for Pacific Studies (Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Pazifische Studien e.V.,
APSA) was founded in 1987 at the Department of Geography of the University of Technology in Aachen. Activities include workshops, conferences, public lectures
and poster exhibitions. The book series Pazifik Forum was initiated in 1990. In 1992, it was complemented by the journal Pacific NEWS. APSA-Members receive the Pacific Geographies at no cost as a membership benefit.
The APSA sees itself as one of the largest scientific networks in Germany for academics and practitioners with an interest in the Asia-Pacific region as well as academic exchange.
The Forest- within the context of sustainable developmentENPI FLEG
The document discusses the Forest Law Enforcement and Governance (FLEG) II European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI) East Countries Program which supports sustainable forest governance in participating countries including Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Moldova, Russia, and Ukraine. The program is funded by the European Union and implemented through partnerships between the World Bank, WWF, and IUCN to establish sustainable forest management practices through policy development, legal reforms, and pilot projects at national, regional and local levels.
11.the socio economic effects of community forest management]Alexander Decker
This document summarizes a study on the socioeconomic effects of community forest management in Dendi District, Ethiopia. The study found that participatory forest management enhanced livelihoods, conservation efforts, and social assets of local communities. Households participating in forest management had higher incomes and expenditures than non-participating households. Participating households also had more diverse livelihood strategies relying on natural resources like forests, compared to non-participating households who engaged more in wage labor and small businesses. The management approach helped increase forest cover while supporting local livelihoods, indicating it can achieve sustainable forest use.
The document discusses several main challenges facing Georgia's forest sector, including unsustainable and illegal logging, overgrazing by livestock, pests and diseases, invasive tree species, forest fires, climate change, and unsustainable forest management practices. It proposes strategic approaches to address these issues such as developing an effective wood tracking system, prioritizing native tree species in reforestation efforts, conducting studies on pests/diseases, and increasing education on sustainable forest management.
18.wild life and forest department A series of Presentation ByMr Allah Dad K...Mr.Allah Dad Khan
This document summarizes the state of forest management in Pakistan. It notes that deforestation remains a major problem in Pakistan, with around 39,000 hectares of forest being cleared annually. Most forests in Pakistan are state-owned and managed by the government forest department, which is underfunded and lacks expertise. The document critiques the simplistic view among policymakers that overpopulation is the primary cause of deforestation, arguing that the state's failure to properly manage forests is a more important factor. It then provides details on the geography, administration, legal classifications and resource use of Pakistan's forests.
Analysis of current Governance in the Sustainable Protection of the Virunga N...AI Publications
This article offers an Analysis on the Governance of the Virunga National Park (ViNP) using the Landscape Approach. We started from the constant misunderstanding and perpetual opposition of the riverside population on the management of the ViNP. The question is the management strategy to involve the local population in the sustainable management of the Virunga National Park. After presenting and analyzing the data provided to us by 394 respondents constituting the sample size consider in relation to strategies of public involvement in the sustainable management of the ViNP. The results showed that the local community is not fully involved in the management of the ViNP, and for their involvement we have proposed the Landscape approach that does not exclude anyone as an alternative to the integrated and sustainable management of the Park. After several years of experimentation, the results of the old approach are far from satisfactory. This study is one of the doctoral research findings on the landscape approach to sustainable management of the ViNP.
This paper presents data from the UN Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) on global forest ownership. It discusses the complexity of classifying forest ownership given varying land tenure systems. The paper notes that while FAO collects data on forest cover through remote sensing, understanding forest ownership requires collecting information directly from countries. It summarizes available data on forest area and ownership by region, finding gaps in information reported by some countries. The paper aims to contribute to improving FAO's strategy for systematically collecting, analyzing, and reporting data on global forest ownership and tenure rights.
Pacific Geographies (PG), ISSN (Print) 2196-1468 / (Online) 2199-9104, is the peer-reviewed semi-annual publication of the Association for Pacific Studies. From 1992-2012 it was labelled Pacific News (ISSN 1435-8360). It is published through the Department of Human Geography of Hamburg University, Germany.
It is an open access journal, all articles can be downloaded for free. There are no submission or APC charges. The authors retain copyright. Copyright & Licensing: CC BY-NC-ND.
The PG provides an interdisciplinary academic platform to discuss social, cultural, environmental and economic issues and developments in the Asia-Pacific region.
In order to uphold scientific standards, the PG is implementing a peer-review process. Articles marked as „scientific papers“ have been peer-reviewed by two external reviewers. Articles marked as „research notes“ have been peer-reviewed by one external reviewer and a member of the editorial board. All other articles have been reviewed by the editorial board. Scientific papers and research notes receive a Digital Object Identifier (DOI).
The Association for Pacific Studies (Arbeitsgemeinschaft für Pazifische Studien e.V.,
APSA) was founded in 1987 at the Department of Geography of the University of Technology in Aachen. Activities include workshops, conferences, public lectures
and poster exhibitions. The book series Pazifik Forum was initiated in 1990. In 1992, it was complemented by the journal Pacific NEWS. APSA-Members receive the Pacific Geographies at no cost as a membership benefit.
The APSA sees itself as one of the largest scientific networks in Germany for academics and practitioners with an interest in the Asia-Pacific region as well as academic exchange.
The Forest- within the context of sustainable developmentENPI FLEG
The document discusses the Forest Law Enforcement and Governance (FLEG) II European Neighbourhood and Partnership Instrument (ENPI) East Countries Program which supports sustainable forest governance in participating countries including Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Moldova, Russia, and Ukraine. The program is funded by the European Union and implemented through partnerships between the World Bank, WWF, and IUCN to establish sustainable forest management practices through policy development, legal reforms, and pilot projects at national, regional and local levels.
11.the socio economic effects of community forest management]Alexander Decker
This document summarizes a study on the socioeconomic effects of community forest management in Dendi District, Ethiopia. The study found that participatory forest management enhanced livelihoods, conservation efforts, and social assets of local communities. Households participating in forest management had higher incomes and expenditures than non-participating households. Participating households also had more diverse livelihood strategies relying on natural resources like forests, compared to non-participating households who engaged more in wage labor and small businesses. The management approach helped increase forest cover while supporting local livelihoods, indicating it can achieve sustainable forest use.
The document discusses several main challenges facing Georgia's forest sector, including unsustainable and illegal logging, overgrazing by livestock, pests and diseases, invasive tree species, forest fires, climate change, and unsustainable forest management practices. It proposes strategic approaches to address these issues such as developing an effective wood tracking system, prioritizing native tree species in reforestation efforts, conducting studies on pests/diseases, and increasing education on sustainable forest management.
18.wild life and forest department A series of Presentation ByMr Allah Dad K...Mr.Allah Dad Khan
This document summarizes the state of forest management in Pakistan. It notes that deforestation remains a major problem in Pakistan, with around 39,000 hectares of forest being cleared annually. Most forests in Pakistan are state-owned and managed by the government forest department, which is underfunded and lacks expertise. The document critiques the simplistic view among policymakers that overpopulation is the primary cause of deforestation, arguing that the state's failure to properly manage forests is a more important factor. It then provides details on the geography, administration, legal classifications and resource use of Pakistan's forests.
Analysis of current Governance in the Sustainable Protection of the Virunga N...AI Publications
This article offers an Analysis on the Governance of the Virunga National Park (ViNP) using the Landscape Approach. We started from the constant misunderstanding and perpetual opposition of the riverside population on the management of the ViNP. The question is the management strategy to involve the local population in the sustainable management of the Virunga National Park. After presenting and analyzing the data provided to us by 394 respondents constituting the sample size consider in relation to strategies of public involvement in the sustainable management of the ViNP. The results showed that the local community is not fully involved in the management of the ViNP, and for their involvement we have proposed the Landscape approach that does not exclude anyone as an alternative to the integrated and sustainable management of the Park. After several years of experimentation, the results of the old approach are far from satisfactory. This study is one of the doctoral research findings on the landscape approach to sustainable management of the ViNP.
Contribution of the non timber forest products to the local communities in th...Alexander Decker
The document discusses non-timber forest products (NTFPs) and their contribution to local communities in Dawro Zone, Ethiopia. It finds that 11 NTFPs are used for subsistence and income, including honey, spices, and forest coffee. Majority of respondents use NTFPs for both home consumption and commercial purposes. However, medicinal plants are seldom used. The study also finds that bamboo is underutilized despite its potential. It recommends efforts to plant utilized species on farms and increase bamboo products to enhance livelihoods.
Multi-level governance and decision-making on forests and PFES in VietnamCIFOR-ICRAF
This presentation was delivered by Anastasia Yang to the Vietnam Forest Protection and Development Fund in Hanoi, 11th November.
Topics discussed include arguments for researching multilevel governance, site selection, and an overview of the global study itself.
This document discusses non-timber forest products and their potential commodification and governance. It provides background on NTFPs and definitions used. While markets could help manage some forest services, many services are difficult to commodify due to their complexity, public good characteristics, and ethical and political issues. Commodification may not be a viable or appropriate solution for coordinating management of many forest ecosystem services and non-timber forest products. An integrated approach that considers interactions among multiple forest values may be more effective than separate programs for individual services or products.
Analysis of current Governance in the Sustainable Management of the Virunga N...AI Publications
This document analyzes governance in the sustainable management of Virunga National Park in the Democratic Republic of Congo. It finds that the majority of respondents living near the park are youths under 61 years old and have no collaboration with park management. Most respondents also do not participate in park management. The presence of park governance is highly contested by local communities and needs to be revised to better incorporate local population concerns to improve relationships and trust between locals and park management.
This document provides summaries of and links to several reports published by UNEP related to the environment in Europe and Central Asia. It discusses reports on topics like the GEO-5 assessment of environmental progress, green economy initiatives in several countries, climate change impacts and more. Links are provided to full reports and summaries on European policies, economic transitions, biodiversity, urban environments, and other issues.
Collective Action for Forest Management, Challenges and Failures: Review Pape...Premier Publishers
Collective forest management has been introduced in Ethiopia as an alternative to the failed state-based forest management approach. However, collective forest management faces several challenges in achieving sustainable management. The document reviews the role of collective action for forest management in Ethiopia, highlighting challenges and failures. It discusses how state forest management failed due to lack of local participation and access to remote areas. Collective forest management has been implemented through participatory forest management programs but also faces issues achieving success. The review aims to assess contributions, challenges, and lessons from collective forest management in Ethiopia.
2 ijfaf jan-2018-2-participatory mapping as a toolAI Publications
This study was carried out with the aim to contribute to the sustainable management of natural resources through the production of participative maps within forest communities in the Nguti subdivision. Specifically this was to illustrate the existing occupation and traditional tenure of forest lands and identify where conflicts of use or rights already exist or could arise both for national government planning and private investors. Data was collected through focus group discussions, household interview and field data collection with the local population through the use of GPS tablets. Results show that 90.7% of the population have no idea on this participative mapping process; however, 35.19% of the population are very interested in this mapping process as it could serve as a tool to enhance land security while 28% of respondents think it could serve as a tool for boundary clarification. Also 18% consider participative mapping an interesting tool to get good knowledge of an area and plan land use. However, forest is principally used here for farming, hunting and gathering with an average household farm size of 0.35ha per year with just 30% of the non-Timber forest products in this area being exploited. The study also revealed that, conflicts of use and right exist due to government affectations, unclear boundaries and the creation of chiefdoms. Participative mapping has proven to be the better tool for decision making as other tools such as satellite images have caused overlaps in state affectations.
This document provides a summary of the current status of Prey Lang forest in Cambodia based on data collected by the Prey Lang Community Network (PLCN) from forest monitoring activities between April and July 2016. Some key findings include:
- Deforestation and illegal logging continue to threaten Prey Lang despite recent government protection measures. PLCN data shows illegal logging occurring in both protected and unprotected areas.
- PLCN forest monitors documented natural resources like trees as well as illegal activities such as cleared forest areas and tree stumps. The most reported tree species were used for construction and resin extraction.
- Local tractors were the main method of transporting illegally logged wood. The province with the best
The Challenges of Decentralized Management of the Ngoyla-Mintom Forest Massif...AI Publications
The document summarizes a study on the challenges of decentralized management of the Ngoyla-Mintom Forest Massif in southeast Cameroon. It finds that the Ngoyla-Mintom forest conservation project had overall positive ecological and socioeconomic impacts. Locally, it led to regeneration of flora and repopulation of wildlife. It also improved livelihoods by financing income-generating activities and infrastructure. However, the project also faced some challenges in its ownership by local communities. The study assessed the strengths of the project, including capacity building of local actors, a financing mechanism, and participatory zoning of the forest area.
The document is the 2014 FAO Statistical Yearbook for Europe and Central Asia. It provides detailed data and trends on food and agriculture in the region. Some key facts:
- Population in the region is aging, with those over 65 making up over 15% of the total in 2010.
- Per capita supply of food was highest for cereals and lowest for fish. Total food production increased between 1995-2011.
- Agricultural land makes up over 50% of total land area. Major crops include wheat, coarse grains, and oil-bearing crops.
- Livestock is also important, with cattle, pigs, and poultry headcounts in the hundreds of millions. Meat and dairy production have
An analysis on the investment of forestland modelling using the agroforestry...Alexander Decker
1. The document analyzes investment in forestland modeling using agroforestry landscape systems in Kutai Kartanegara District, Indonesia.
2. It studies five forestland models: monoculture super teakwood, super teakwood and durian, monoculture durian, durian and coffee, and rambutan and mahogany.
3. The analysis finds that the super teakwood and durian model generates the highest income and production compared to other models and that all models are financially feasible based on their internal rates of return exceeding minimum acceptability rates.
A Review of Global Experiences on using of Indigenous Knowledge in Rangelands...AI Publications
With the further advancement of rangeland science in recent decades, the importance of utilizing the indigenous knowledge is further highlighted. However, in many cases, there are some disagreements between executive managers and specialists of rangelands on the one hand, and local communities on the other hand, which is usually due to the importance of each side to certain aspects of effective parameters in pastures. In any case, more attention to local communities and indigenous knowledge in this matter is indisputable and should be used to integrate these two factors. In this paper, the role of utilizing the indigenous knowledge in the utilization of the rangelands and their management and its experiences in Iran and several parts of the world that are located on different continents has been studied, then the results as well as the effectiveness have been discussed for pasture in Iran, and in the end, some suggestions have been made for this purpose in Iran.
Current status of commercial solid waste generation, composition and manageme...Premier Publishers
This study determined the quantity, composition, the levels of remaining recyclable materials, and to evaluate treatment methods for commercial solid waste (CSW) in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Waste samples were collected from 52 commercial sectors including hotels, restaurants, internet cafés, guesthouses, beer gardens, markets, schools, microfinance agencies and shops. The waste was collected daily for two weeks in 2013 and separated into 23 categories. The main composition of CSW were food (50-60%), followed by plastic and paper (30-40%) and glass (5-6%). The waste generation in kg/table/day was 4.83 (large restaurants), 3.36 (medium restaurants), 2.23 (beer gardens), 1.94 (internet cafés); in kg/room/day was 0.69 (3-star hotels), 0.45 (large guesthouses), 0.37 (medium and small guesthouses), 0.097 (small hotels) and in kg/person/day was 0.153 (family marts), 0.15 (ministries), 0.12 (council of ministers), 0.12 (supermarkets), less than 0.10 (shops and schools). Sorted waste was food, followed by glass bottles, paper, PET bottles, aluminium cans and steel. The remaining recyclable materials were food, plastic, paper, steel and aluminium cans. Well sorting activity was conducted by internet cafés and restaurants, followed by family marts, schools, beer gardens and guesthouses. If food waste and other recyclable materials were completely sorted, 61% of current waste could be minimized.
The Minnesota Forest Resources Council (MFRC) published its 2014 biennial report on the implementation of the Sustainable Forest Resources Act (SFRA). Some of the key accomplishments in 2014 included:
1) Revising the SFRA to update outdated provisions and streamline language.
2) Completing a study on the competitiveness of Minnesota's primary forest products industry which found the health of Minnesota's forests and forest industry are at risk.
3) Hosting a conference to discuss the competitiveness study findings and recommendations to enhance the forest industry's position.
Ecotourism an approach to the sustainable conservation of biodiversity in the...AI Publications
This study was carried out at the buffer zones of Benue National Park in the North Region of Cameroon. The objective of the study was to assess the governance of ecotourism with an aim to promote sustainable management of biological resources. Primary data was collected with the help of semi-structured questionnaires that were administered to 125 household heads that were involved in the conservation of biodiversity in the study area. Questionnaires and interview guides were design to collect data on: (the level of participation and involvement of communities, stakeholder in the ecotourism business and modalities for participation in the conservation of biological resources). The results showed that two categories of ecotourism actors are involved: Direct actors: conservation service, MINFOF/MINTOUL, eco-guards and indirect actors: NGOs and service providers. The issue of equity remained a major concern for stakeholders, as responsibilities and decision-making among the different actors were not shared equitably. Regarding the level of community participation in ecotourism activities, 79% of stakeholders are not involved in ecotourism activities; however, 21% of stakeholders who were involved are community guards, cooks and tour guides. In ZIC (Area of Cinegetic Interest) N° 1 and 4, 31% of respondents said that only the Union of Village Wildlife Committees (COZIC) have being participating in the ecotourism business. . However, it should be noted that the governance mode most frequently observed in this protected area is dominated by the state with 83% respondents involved even though the laws and policies on ecotourism shows a participatory management of ecotourism in the protected areas.
There are three main linguistic groups: the Bantu-speaking peoples of the south, the Sudanic-speaking peoples of the north, and those who speak the Semi-Bantu languages, situated mainly in the west. The first Bantu groups included the Maka, Ndjem, and Duala.
This study identifies causes of forest-related conflicts in the Equatorial rainforest of South-East Cameroon, based on field studies in three villages where industrial logging concessions have been granted. Local access to forests has been severely reduced and customary rights restricted as an effect of the national forest zoning plan. Hence, local livelihoods have been negatively affected. Corruption is moreover rampant. This has resulted in a solid majority among local people expressing negative attitudes toward logging companies and the state. Local inhabitants regard NGOs to have a significant potential to ameliorate their relationship with logging companies, while secured user rights was identified as the most significant avenue to improve their relationship with the state. Securing community rights to land and forest resources
Региональный анализ результатов предварительных исследований экономики экосис...ENPI FLEG
Региональный анализ результатов предварительных исследований экономики экосистем и биоразнообразия (TEEB) в лесных секторах Армении, Азербайджана и Грузии
Contribution of the non timber forest products to the local communities in th...Alexander Decker
The document discusses non-timber forest products (NTFPs) and their contribution to local communities in Dawro Zone, Ethiopia. It finds that 11 NTFPs are used for subsistence and income, including honey, spices, and forest coffee. Majority of respondents use NTFPs for both home consumption and commercial purposes. However, medicinal plants are seldom used. The study also finds that bamboo is underutilized despite its potential. It recommends efforts to plant utilized species on farms and increase bamboo products to enhance livelihoods.
Multi-level governance and decision-making on forests and PFES in VietnamCIFOR-ICRAF
This presentation was delivered by Anastasia Yang to the Vietnam Forest Protection and Development Fund in Hanoi, 11th November.
Topics discussed include arguments for researching multilevel governance, site selection, and an overview of the global study itself.
This document discusses non-timber forest products and their potential commodification and governance. It provides background on NTFPs and definitions used. While markets could help manage some forest services, many services are difficult to commodify due to their complexity, public good characteristics, and ethical and political issues. Commodification may not be a viable or appropriate solution for coordinating management of many forest ecosystem services and non-timber forest products. An integrated approach that considers interactions among multiple forest values may be more effective than separate programs for individual services or products.
Analysis of current Governance in the Sustainable Management of the Virunga N...AI Publications
This document analyzes governance in the sustainable management of Virunga National Park in the Democratic Republic of Congo. It finds that the majority of respondents living near the park are youths under 61 years old and have no collaboration with park management. Most respondents also do not participate in park management. The presence of park governance is highly contested by local communities and needs to be revised to better incorporate local population concerns to improve relationships and trust between locals and park management.
This document provides summaries of and links to several reports published by UNEP related to the environment in Europe and Central Asia. It discusses reports on topics like the GEO-5 assessment of environmental progress, green economy initiatives in several countries, climate change impacts and more. Links are provided to full reports and summaries on European policies, economic transitions, biodiversity, urban environments, and other issues.
Collective Action for Forest Management, Challenges and Failures: Review Pape...Premier Publishers
Collective forest management has been introduced in Ethiopia as an alternative to the failed state-based forest management approach. However, collective forest management faces several challenges in achieving sustainable management. The document reviews the role of collective action for forest management in Ethiopia, highlighting challenges and failures. It discusses how state forest management failed due to lack of local participation and access to remote areas. Collective forest management has been implemented through participatory forest management programs but also faces issues achieving success. The review aims to assess contributions, challenges, and lessons from collective forest management in Ethiopia.
2 ijfaf jan-2018-2-participatory mapping as a toolAI Publications
This study was carried out with the aim to contribute to the sustainable management of natural resources through the production of participative maps within forest communities in the Nguti subdivision. Specifically this was to illustrate the existing occupation and traditional tenure of forest lands and identify where conflicts of use or rights already exist or could arise both for national government planning and private investors. Data was collected through focus group discussions, household interview and field data collection with the local population through the use of GPS tablets. Results show that 90.7% of the population have no idea on this participative mapping process; however, 35.19% of the population are very interested in this mapping process as it could serve as a tool to enhance land security while 28% of respondents think it could serve as a tool for boundary clarification. Also 18% consider participative mapping an interesting tool to get good knowledge of an area and plan land use. However, forest is principally used here for farming, hunting and gathering with an average household farm size of 0.35ha per year with just 30% of the non-Timber forest products in this area being exploited. The study also revealed that, conflicts of use and right exist due to government affectations, unclear boundaries and the creation of chiefdoms. Participative mapping has proven to be the better tool for decision making as other tools such as satellite images have caused overlaps in state affectations.
This document provides a summary of the current status of Prey Lang forest in Cambodia based on data collected by the Prey Lang Community Network (PLCN) from forest monitoring activities between April and July 2016. Some key findings include:
- Deforestation and illegal logging continue to threaten Prey Lang despite recent government protection measures. PLCN data shows illegal logging occurring in both protected and unprotected areas.
- PLCN forest monitors documented natural resources like trees as well as illegal activities such as cleared forest areas and tree stumps. The most reported tree species were used for construction and resin extraction.
- Local tractors were the main method of transporting illegally logged wood. The province with the best
The Challenges of Decentralized Management of the Ngoyla-Mintom Forest Massif...AI Publications
The document summarizes a study on the challenges of decentralized management of the Ngoyla-Mintom Forest Massif in southeast Cameroon. It finds that the Ngoyla-Mintom forest conservation project had overall positive ecological and socioeconomic impacts. Locally, it led to regeneration of flora and repopulation of wildlife. It also improved livelihoods by financing income-generating activities and infrastructure. However, the project also faced some challenges in its ownership by local communities. The study assessed the strengths of the project, including capacity building of local actors, a financing mechanism, and participatory zoning of the forest area.
The document is the 2014 FAO Statistical Yearbook for Europe and Central Asia. It provides detailed data and trends on food and agriculture in the region. Some key facts:
- Population in the region is aging, with those over 65 making up over 15% of the total in 2010.
- Per capita supply of food was highest for cereals and lowest for fish. Total food production increased between 1995-2011.
- Agricultural land makes up over 50% of total land area. Major crops include wheat, coarse grains, and oil-bearing crops.
- Livestock is also important, with cattle, pigs, and poultry headcounts in the hundreds of millions. Meat and dairy production have
An analysis on the investment of forestland modelling using the agroforestry...Alexander Decker
1. The document analyzes investment in forestland modeling using agroforestry landscape systems in Kutai Kartanegara District, Indonesia.
2. It studies five forestland models: monoculture super teakwood, super teakwood and durian, monoculture durian, durian and coffee, and rambutan and mahogany.
3. The analysis finds that the super teakwood and durian model generates the highest income and production compared to other models and that all models are financially feasible based on their internal rates of return exceeding minimum acceptability rates.
A Review of Global Experiences on using of Indigenous Knowledge in Rangelands...AI Publications
With the further advancement of rangeland science in recent decades, the importance of utilizing the indigenous knowledge is further highlighted. However, in many cases, there are some disagreements between executive managers and specialists of rangelands on the one hand, and local communities on the other hand, which is usually due to the importance of each side to certain aspects of effective parameters in pastures. In any case, more attention to local communities and indigenous knowledge in this matter is indisputable and should be used to integrate these two factors. In this paper, the role of utilizing the indigenous knowledge in the utilization of the rangelands and their management and its experiences in Iran and several parts of the world that are located on different continents has been studied, then the results as well as the effectiveness have been discussed for pasture in Iran, and in the end, some suggestions have been made for this purpose in Iran.
Current status of commercial solid waste generation, composition and manageme...Premier Publishers
This study determined the quantity, composition, the levels of remaining recyclable materials, and to evaluate treatment methods for commercial solid waste (CSW) in Phnom Penh, Cambodia. Waste samples were collected from 52 commercial sectors including hotels, restaurants, internet cafés, guesthouses, beer gardens, markets, schools, microfinance agencies and shops. The waste was collected daily for two weeks in 2013 and separated into 23 categories. The main composition of CSW were food (50-60%), followed by plastic and paper (30-40%) and glass (5-6%). The waste generation in kg/table/day was 4.83 (large restaurants), 3.36 (medium restaurants), 2.23 (beer gardens), 1.94 (internet cafés); in kg/room/day was 0.69 (3-star hotels), 0.45 (large guesthouses), 0.37 (medium and small guesthouses), 0.097 (small hotels) and in kg/person/day was 0.153 (family marts), 0.15 (ministries), 0.12 (council of ministers), 0.12 (supermarkets), less than 0.10 (shops and schools). Sorted waste was food, followed by glass bottles, paper, PET bottles, aluminium cans and steel. The remaining recyclable materials were food, plastic, paper, steel and aluminium cans. Well sorting activity was conducted by internet cafés and restaurants, followed by family marts, schools, beer gardens and guesthouses. If food waste and other recyclable materials were completely sorted, 61% of current waste could be minimized.
The Minnesota Forest Resources Council (MFRC) published its 2014 biennial report on the implementation of the Sustainable Forest Resources Act (SFRA). Some of the key accomplishments in 2014 included:
1) Revising the SFRA to update outdated provisions and streamline language.
2) Completing a study on the competitiveness of Minnesota's primary forest products industry which found the health of Minnesota's forests and forest industry are at risk.
3) Hosting a conference to discuss the competitiveness study findings and recommendations to enhance the forest industry's position.
Ecotourism an approach to the sustainable conservation of biodiversity in the...AI Publications
This study was carried out at the buffer zones of Benue National Park in the North Region of Cameroon. The objective of the study was to assess the governance of ecotourism with an aim to promote sustainable management of biological resources. Primary data was collected with the help of semi-structured questionnaires that were administered to 125 household heads that were involved in the conservation of biodiversity in the study area. Questionnaires and interview guides were design to collect data on: (the level of participation and involvement of communities, stakeholder in the ecotourism business and modalities for participation in the conservation of biological resources). The results showed that two categories of ecotourism actors are involved: Direct actors: conservation service, MINFOF/MINTOUL, eco-guards and indirect actors: NGOs and service providers. The issue of equity remained a major concern for stakeholders, as responsibilities and decision-making among the different actors were not shared equitably. Regarding the level of community participation in ecotourism activities, 79% of stakeholders are not involved in ecotourism activities; however, 21% of stakeholders who were involved are community guards, cooks and tour guides. In ZIC (Area of Cinegetic Interest) N° 1 and 4, 31% of respondents said that only the Union of Village Wildlife Committees (COZIC) have being participating in the ecotourism business. . However, it should be noted that the governance mode most frequently observed in this protected area is dominated by the state with 83% respondents involved even though the laws and policies on ecotourism shows a participatory management of ecotourism in the protected areas.
There are three main linguistic groups: the Bantu-speaking peoples of the south, the Sudanic-speaking peoples of the north, and those who speak the Semi-Bantu languages, situated mainly in the west. The first Bantu groups included the Maka, Ndjem, and Duala.
This study identifies causes of forest-related conflicts in the Equatorial rainforest of South-East Cameroon, based on field studies in three villages where industrial logging concessions have been granted. Local access to forests has been severely reduced and customary rights restricted as an effect of the national forest zoning plan. Hence, local livelihoods have been negatively affected. Corruption is moreover rampant. This has resulted in a solid majority among local people expressing negative attitudes toward logging companies and the state. Local inhabitants regard NGOs to have a significant potential to ameliorate their relationship with logging companies, while secured user rights was identified as the most significant avenue to improve their relationship with the state. Securing community rights to land and forest resources
Региональный анализ результатов предварительных исследований экономики экосис...ENPI FLEG
Региональный анализ результатов предварительных исследований экономики экосистем и биоразнообразия (TEEB) в лесных секторах Армении, Азербайджана и Грузии
Brief Review of the Forest Policy and Forest Legislation of the Republic of B...ENPI FLEG
Brief Review of the Forest Policy and Forest Legislation of the Republic of Belarus: Approaches to Ensure Legality of Forest Use, Tackling Illegal Logging and Trade and Control over Activities of Logging and Timber Trade Enterprises
Analysis of the Voluntary Forest Certification Potential within Forestry Sect...ENPI FLEG
This document provides an analysis of the potential for voluntary forest certification under the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) scheme within Azerbaijan's forestry sector. It begins with background on FSC as an international organization and describes FSC's vision, mission, global strategy, and the different types of FSC certification. It then assesses Azerbaijan's current forestry situation in the context of FSC certification, including challenges and opportunities. The document analyzes how Azerbaijan's existing laws and policies correspond with FSC principles and criteria. It concludes by outlining possible steps to promote voluntary forest certification in Azerbaijan.
The Report on Multipurpose Use of Forest Resources, Challenges and Opportunit...ENPI FLEG
The Report on Multipurpose Use of Forest Resources, Challenges and Opportunities at National and Regional Levels and the State-of-Art of Multipurpose Use of Forest Resources at the Regional Level (in Russian)
This regional bulletin summarizes recent activities of the ENPI FLEG II Program. It describes an international workshop in Russia where experiences from the FLEG II program guided improvements to forestry governance and management. It also discusses the expansion of Young Foresters groups in Azerbaijan supported by the FLEG II program, and a round table in Azerbaijan that revealed increased youth interest in forestry issues.
Preference of FSC-Certified Paper in GeorgiaENPI FLEG
This document summarizes the results of a survey of 102 paper-consuming companies and organizations in Georgia about their use of paper and attitudes toward Forest Stewardship Council (FSC)-certified paper. The key findings are:
- Awareness of FSC certification is extremely low, with only 13 organizations aware of it beforehand and just 5 currently using FSC paper.
- While awareness is low, most organizations express interest in FSC paper if priced competitively with non-FSC paper.
- The ideal estimated price range for an FSC-certified box of A4 paper identified was 25-37 GEL, close to the price of non-FSC paper.
- The sample includes
TEEB Scoping study for forestry sector of AzerbaijanENPI FLEG
This document provides a scoping study for a potential full TEEB (The Economics of Ecosystems and Biodiversity) study on the forestry sector in Azerbaijan. It summarizes the country's forest resources, ecosystem services they provide, and governance/management challenges. Under business as usual practices, unsustainable logging, overgrazing, and climate change impacts threaten forests. A sustainable ecosystem management approach could maximize long-term economic and social benefits by sustainably using forest resources. The study recommends a future full TEEB study analyze alternative policy scenarios and their impacts on biodiversity and ecosystem services to inform sustainable forest policies in Azerbaijan.
Similar to EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Regional analysis of forest and environmental product use and dependence amongst rural households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and Russia
International Journal of Pharmaceutical Science Invention (IJPSI) is an international journal intended for professionals and researchers in all fields of Pahrmaceutical Science. IJPSI publishes research articles and reviews within the whole field Pharmacy and Pharmaceutical Science, new teaching methods, assessment, validation and the impact of new technologies and it will continue to provide information on the latest trends and developments in this ever-expanding subject. The publications of papers are selected through double peer reviewed to ensure originality, relevance, and readability. The articles published in our journal can be accessed online.
Ecological-edaphic and Socio-economic drivers of on-farm tree farming enterpr...Agriculture Journal IJOEAR
The biophysical-edaphic and socioeconomic factors do equally influence the on-farm tree farming in the smallholder farming systems. Naturally, neither of the factors do act in isolation, but they are interrelated. The study was carried out in Nsangi sub-county, Wakiso District, 2018. Using the stratified random sampling method based on landholding sizes, a sample of size of sixty households were selected and interviewed. The objectives of the study were to examine the influence of the bio-physical, edaphic and socio-cultural-economic factors onto the performance of the on-farm tree farming enterprise, and to evaluate the farmer's participation in on-farm tree farming activities. The results showed that both ecological-edaphic and socio-cultural-economic factors influence the performance of the tree volume, tree species diversity and tree stand density/ha. There is a negative correlation between size of landholding and farmer's interaction with the on-farm tree farming enterprises. Judging from the results of this study, there is a need for a policy review aimed at devising appropriate socio-cultural-economic and ecological-edaphic practices that promote on-farm tree farming programmes.
The FLEG II Program is working to establish a new forest sanctuary in the Tavush region of northern Armenia. A previous study found rich biodiversity in the area, including several endangered species. The proposed sanctuary would consolidate three existing sanctuaries to improve conservation efforts. It aims to protect biodiversity, support sustainable development of nearby communities, and promote ecotourism to improve local livelihoods. Progress is being made towards officially establishing the new sanctuary.
Assessing the sustainability of forest plantations in Mezam Division of the N...ijsrd.com
Objectives: The study examined the sustainability of plantation forestry in Mezam Division of the North West Region. Methodology and results: Respondents drawn from a cross-section of plantation owners in five (5) sub-divisions (i.e. Tubah, Bali, Bafut, Santa and Bemenda central) of Mezam Division. Fifty- (50) plantation owners selected through a system of random sampling. Data collected through the administered questionnaires were on social, economic, ecological, profitability, management strategies and constraints to plantation forestry in the study area. Structure questionnaires were instrument used for data collection. Analytical tools used were descriptive statistic including tables, means, and percentages to describe the socio-economic characteristic of respondents, while chi-square and Benefit Cost Ratio models were used to determined profitability and opinion of plantation owners respectively. The results reveal that majority of plantation owners were men 84.5% and widows make up 15.5% of the respondents. They all owned families. Benefit Cost Ratio B/C calculated was 0.7 (B/C . 1) this results implies that plantation business is not profitable compared to an alternative land use system, although they was a marginal profit of eight thousand five hundred francs 8500f ($ 17 USD) for the sale of one acre of plantation. Chi-square test of equal probability showed that they were no significant difference at 0.05% probability level for private plantation owners. The main constraints confronting plantation forestry business in the study area are access to finance, followed by wildfires, unfavorable government policies and finally bad road networks leading to their plantation. The Benefit Cost Ratio B/C calculated (B/C . 1) mean plantation business is not profitable compared to an alternative land use system, although they were marginal benefits. The study therefore recommend that private plantation be encourage to ensure less dependence on natural forest and to also mitigation climate change and through this jobs created and livelihood improved to the rural communities
Community perceived attitude on forest related environmental issues using mas...Alexander Decker
This document summarizes a study on community attitudes toward forestry-related environmental issues (FREI) in Osun State, Nigeria. The study aimed to assess these attitudes to strengthen the use of mass media in raising awareness. Data was collected through surveys in 3 local government areas. The results showed that 75% of respondents agreed it is important to consider FREI for environmental balance, while 60% saw FREI as a mere threat that cannot impact the environment. This suggests community awareness of forestry issues is low. The study concludes mass media could help disseminate environmental information but currently does little beyond incidental reporting. Improved coordination between media and government agencies is needed to support sustainable livelihoods through increased community
Sustainable Forestry for Food Security and Nutrition CIFOR-ICRAF
Presented by Terry Sunderland, from the Center for International Forestry Research (CIFOR), at the High Level Panel of Experts on
Food Security and Nutrition (HLPE) of the Committee on World Food Security (CFS), on June 27, 2017.
The document summarizes key results from Russia's participation in the FLEG II program from 2013 to 2016. The priority areas included improving FLEG planning and monitoring, building human resource capacity, facilitating actions by forest companies, safeguarding community rights, and increasing transparency. Key results included developing modular education programs, publishing recommendations to improve regulations, conducting surveys of suppliers to the EU market, and preparing maps and assessments of sustainable forest management. The exit strategy focused on delegating activities, transferring products, institutionalizing processes, and finding alternative funding. The program engaged stakeholders across Russia and in neighboring countries.
Resource potential of non timber forest products in dawro zone, south ethiopiaAlexander Decker
This document summarizes a study on non-timber forest products in Dawro Zone, South Ethiopia. A total of 11 non-timber forest products were recorded in the study area, including medicinal plants, spices, and bamboo. Most products are used for subsistence purposes like housing materials and medicines. However, the study found that bamboo and some spice species are underutilized and mismanaged. It was suggested that better management strategies are needed to diversify the benefits of these forest products for local communities.
ANTHROPOGENIC INFLUENCES ON THE NATURAL ECOSYSTEM OF THE NARAN VALLEY IN THE ...Shujaul Mulk Khan
People derive many essential goods from plant resources, including food, medicines and fodder. However, the link between biodiversity and ecosystem services and their role in the support of human well-being is often poorly understood. Mountain ecosystems support a high biological diversity including rare and endangered plant species. They also provide a home to some 12% of the world's human population, who use their traditional ecological knowledge to utilise local natural resources. The Himalayas are the world's youngest and largest mountain range that supports a high plant biodiversity and hence provides many ecosystem services. Due to remote location, harsh climate, rough terrain and topography, many areas in the Himalayas have been still poorly known for their vegetation ecosystem services. The people in the Naran Valley, in the western Himalayas, depend upon local plant resources for a range of services and goods, from grazing for livestock to use of medicinal plants. During this study abundance and uses of each species were computed using computational ecology; principal components analysis (PCA) and response curves (RC) using CANOCO. The analyses showed an increasing trend of grazing, but with a decrease in fodder availability, with altitude increase in the valley. The assessment of such ecosystem services may assist in developing conservation strategies, especially for endangered mountain ecosystems.
In the past, conservation effort has primarily focused on establishment of forest reserves for timber production, with minimal or no consideration to how these natural resources will help sustain or improve livelihoods of adjoining communities. This study examined the contribution of Aramoko forest reserve to the livelihoods of the adjoining communities in Ekiti State. One hundred and twenty pre-tested questionnaires were administered among the products collectors in the study area. Data collected were analysed and the result showed that 78.3 % of the respondents are married with 52.3 % of them male, while 50.8 % of the respondents aged between 51-70 years with 64.1 % having at least secondary education. Twenty-five (25) different products were collected by the respondents in the study area. These products include among others; timber with highest frequency of (120) followed by herbal plants (115), Archantina marginata (105), Thaumatococcus danielli (89), Bridelia ferruginea (70) and Irvingia garbonensis (65). The use of motor cycle accounted for 41.4 % of the respondents means of transportation, while 31.3 % of the respondents sell their product in bit at the village market. Picking, digging, plucking, cutting and uprooting were methods used for harvesting by the respondents while illegal felling (24 %) and indiscriminate bush burning (22.4 %) were the major conservation problem in the study area. Specifically, some of the products harvested are used for food, medicine, fuelwood, herbs and cultural purposes. The study recommends that research should be conducted into how these products can be artificially raised in the nursery for plantation establishment.
Forests are an important natural resource in Ethiopia, providing materials, ecosystem services, and supporting the livelihoods of many. However, Ethiopia's forest cover has declined significantly over time due to population growth and unsustainable use. Forest policy and legislation aim to manage this valuable resource sustainably by outlining principles and plans for forest conservation, protection, management, and utilization, as well as related industries, in order to maximize benefits for society while preserving forests for future generations. An effective forest policy provides guidance for government agencies and helps coordinate decision-making across sectors to balance forest conservation with community development needs.
Geoinformation support of forest management for sustainable development of th...Liashenko Dmytro
The global trend of forest overcutting is an important
the object of research in connection with climate change
and the need to ensure the sustainable development of
territories. An important issue is an adaptation of
sustainable development goals for a particular forest
areas. The territory of the Tyachiv district of the
Zakarpattia region in Ukraine was chosen as a key
region. A list of stakeholders interested in conflict-free
and inexhaustible forest use has been identified. The
the paper analyzes the existing approaches to sustainable
forest use proposes a conceptual model of forest
management (major stakeholders and their interests),
identifies features of the methodology of
geoinformation support for management and control
of forest use and forest protection.
Analysis of poverty environmental degradation nexus among arable crop farmers...Alexander Decker
This document analyzes the relationship between poverty and environmental degradation among crop farmers in Plateau State, Nigeria. It finds that 42% of surveyed farming households live below the poverty line. Factors like the quantity of wood collected, number of grazing animals, and length of grazing time were found to significantly increase poverty levels by degrading the environment. Increasing farm size and knowledge of conservation, on the other hand, were found to decrease poverty by reducing environmental degradation. The study concludes that poverty and environmental degradation are strongly linked, with each exacerbating the other in a vicious cycle. It recommends targeting poverty programs at the local level and introducing environmental aid to break this cycle.
Protected areas in Azerbaijan: landscape ecological diversity and sustainabilityEmil Jabrayilov
Establishment of protected areas is one of the most important activities in the conservation of natural resources, biodiversity and gene pools, including, promoting a healthy lifestyle for people in the world. The concept of preserving landscape-ecological diversity and sustainable development promotes the improvement of socio-economic indicators and at the same time ensuring the protection of the environment and ecosystems. The aim of the paper is to examine the relationship between landscape-ecological diversity in protected areas in Azerbaijan and the factors that contribute to this relationship with sustainable development. The article identifies landscape-ecological differences, including the principles and development of protected areas such as National Parks, Nature Reserves and Habitat/Species Management Areas in Azerbaijan. For the first time, a landscape-ecological frame model was developed to ensure environmental balance. A medium-scale digital (1:600,000) "ecological carcass" map of Azerbaijan has been developed and its structural elements explored. Currently, only 10% of the territory of Azerbaijan are protected areas. Given the anthropogenic pressure on landscapes in Azerbaijan, it has been established that the structure of the territorial organization of protected areas does not comply with existing environmental balance norms. To do this, proposals to increase the area of protected sites to 15% of the country's territory were justified. The current state of use of protected areas in the development of ecotourism has been considered and evaluated as an element of sustainability. Indicators of tourism activity in national parks were analyzed on the basis of statistical sources.
Dependency of Russian Villages on Forest Resources. Executive Summary of the ...ENPI FLEG
This document summarizes findings from a survey of rural communities in three regions of Russia on their dependency on forest resources. The regions surveyed were the North-West (Pskov Region), central Siberia (Altaisky Krai), and Russian Far East (Khabarovsky Krai). Across the regions, the main sources of income varied. In the North-West, the majority relied on pensions and direct forest income like berries and mushrooms. Central Siberia had more varied income sources but also higher unemployment. The Russian Far East had the highest rates of pensioners and unemployed relying on forest products like fuelwood. Wealthier families in each region derived significant cash income from forest products, especially cranberries in the North-West and pine
This document proposes establishing a Central Asia Sentinel Landscape to study forest degradation and resilience in Central Asia. It notes the region's unique biodiversity including over 7,000 plant species and importance as a center of origin for many fruit and nut species. However, Central Asia has little forest area and what remains is highly threatened, with an estimated 75% loss since 1960. The proposed landscape would cover a gradient from forests to farms across Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan to study drivers of ecological degradation and their impacts on vulnerable rural populations with high poverty levels. A core team from Bioversity, CIFOR and ICARDA is being assembled to finalize site selection and funding proposals to begin data collection and analysis by
India, beyond the glittering economy: By Shreekanth Guptabmbks321
This document summarizes a study on the relationship between poverty, the environment, and natural resource use in Jhabua, India. The study finds that poorer households depend on common pool natural resources for a greater percentage of their income than wealthier households. It also finds no consistent relationship between household income level and absolute levels of natural resource use. The study aims to quantify how use of and dependence on natural resources varies with household income and to estimate the impact of natural resource availability on household incomes. It collected data from 535 households in 60 villages over one year to analyze relationships between natural resource stocks, dependence, and household incomes.
The participatory management plan is a technical, legal and social device that joins the objectives of biodiversity conservation and the socio-economic needs of local populations. This research work aims to evaluate the impact of Wari-Maro classified forest management plan implementation on the structure and specific diversity of vegetation types. The methodological approach followed is based on the comparison of the dendrometric parameters and plant diversity parameters before and after the management plan implementation. The phytosociological and dendrometric database before the management plan was compiled with data from the forest inventory conducted by PAMF project in 2004 and others work. The forest and phytosociological inventories were carried out on the plots (70) from the forest inventory of PAMF project (2004) following the same methodological principles. The Shannon diversity index decreased from 3.35 ± 0.57 bits in 2004 to 1.98 ± 0.73 bits in 2014. The average density of dbh trees ≥ 10 cm decreased from 740.37 ± 269 , 86 stems / ha in 2004 to 184 ± 100 stems / ha in 2014. The results of the 5% sample matched t-test reveal a non-significant difference between the Shannon Diversity Index of 2004 and of 2014. On the other hand, the results of the sample t-test matched at the 5% threshold, reveal a significant difference between the average density value of 2004 and 2014 for all vegetation types except shrub savannas, fields and fallows. Most of the plant species found before the management plan are still present despite the decreased in individuals’ density.
Similar to EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Regional analysis of forest and environmental product use and dependence amongst rural households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and Russia (20)
The document summarizes the key results and activities of the FLEG II Country Program in Armenia from 2013 to 2016. It discusses priority areas including improving forest law and policy, building human capacity, increasing public awareness, strengthening sustainable forest management, and improving FLEG planning and monitoring. Key results included establishing public monitoring of forests to empower citizens to protect forests, training volunteers, using satellite imagery, and generating media attention. The program also introduced briquetting to reduce fuelwood consumption and donated efficient stoves. An exit strategy is to transition to a forest landscape restoration approach building on FLEG successes.
The document summarizes the 4th Steering Committee Meeting held in Brussels, Belgium on December 12-13, 2016. It provides an overview of Azerbaijan's country presentation, including key priority areas from 2013 to 2016 such as developing a young foresters' movement and strengthening staff capacity in the forest sector. It also outlines key results achieved in areas like sustainable forest management, training programs, and climate change adaptation. Ideas for future initiatives are presented, such as restoring forest landscapes and introducing information technologies to support forest management and monitoring.
Belarus' country priorities from 2013-2016 included updating forest policy and legislation, optimizing forest management systems, improving forestry training, and forest communication strategies. Key results included supporting strategic planning reforms through 2030, passing a new Forestry Code in 2016, and improving timber tracking systems. Forest managers participated in study tours and workshops on sustainable practices. FLEG helped introduce dialogue and new economic opportunities for rural communities based on forests. FLEG-supported policies will regulate ongoing forest management and strengthen international cooperation.
1) The document summarizes key results from Georgia's FLEG II Program from 2013-2016, including drafting a new Forest Code, developing supporting legislation, and building capacity of government institutions and forest users.
2) The program supported sustainable forest management practices through developing sustainable forest management plans, facilitating natural regeneration, and establishing a protected area. It also increased public awareness through educational activities.
3) A success story highlighted a video contest winner that depicted program objectives simply. Another success was reaching an agreement to manage the forests of Tusheti Protected Landscape locally, though it presented challenges of an unprecedented institutional setup and capacity building needs.
The 4th Steering Committee Meeting covered Moldova's priority areas in forest law enforcement and governance (FLEG) from 2013 to 2016. Key results included reforms to Moldova's forest institutional structure based on FLEG data, expanded forested areas, and development of a wood traceability system. Capacity building efforts trained local stakeholders in sustainable forest management. Outreach increased public awareness of FLEG through media coverage and educational events. An exit strategy was discussed to sustain FLEG progress through existing agencies like Moldsilva and projects from the World Bank and IUCN.
The 4th Steering Committee Meeting for Ukraine's country presentation summarized key results from 2013 to 2016 under the FLEG-2 Program. Priority areas included supporting forest policy and strategy dialogue, improving forest law enforcement and governance, and increasing transparency and public awareness. Despite challenges, the program team maintained priorities of reforming the forest sector. Key results included analytical works that informed legislative reforms, increased awareness of forest issues, and trainings on topics like GIS and forest management. An exit strategy aims to continue efforts through working groups, experts on committees, and NGO partnerships to further reforms and ensure sustainability of the FLEG-2 Program's initiatives.
The members of the "FLEG II Program - Complementary Measures for Georgia and Armenia" met in Armenia to discuss progress and plan future activities. The meeting reviewed recommendations from the main FLEG II program and the mid-term review. Country representatives from Armenia and Georgia presented updates and work plans for the coming year. The meeting approved the country work plans with some modifications. The program will continue supporting forestry policy development, sustainable forest management, and capacity building in Armenia and Georgia.
International experience in development of timber tracking systemsENPI FLEG
The document provides an overview of timber tracking systems used internationally. It describes systems used in several tropical timber exporting countries as well as some European countries. For the tropical countries, it outlines timber tracking systems that are state-mandated and aim to monitor timber flows from harvest to processing. These systems use a mix of individual log identification methods like tagging alongside balance-based monitoring of timber volumes. The systems described aim to establish oversight and legality across international supply chains for timber trade.
Analysis of legislation and practice of hunting in some EU countriesENPI FLEG
This document provides a summary of the legal hunting framework in EU countries. Key points include:
1) Hunting is primarily regulated by the EU Birds Directive (1979) and Habitats Directive (1992) which member states must comply with.
2) International conventions like CITES, CMS, and the Bern Convention also influence hunting policy.
3) The EU has established guidelines for sustainable hunting practices and collects hunting statistics to monitor bird populations.
4) Sustainable hunting is supported through the Natura 2000 protected areas network, involving hunters in habitat and species management.
A Comprehensive Guide on Cable Location Services Detections Method, Tools, an...Aussie Hydro-Vac Services
Explore Aussie Hydrovac's comprehensive cable location services, employing advanced tools like ground-penetrating radar and robotic CCTV crawlers for precise detection. Also offering aerial surveying solutions. Contact for reliable service in Australia.
Monitor indicators of genetic diversity from space using Earth Observation dataSpatial Genetics
Genetic diversity within and among populations is essential for species persistence. While targets and indicators for genetic diversity are captured in the Kunming-Montreal Global Biodiversity Framework, assessing genetic diversity across many species at national and regional scales remains challenging. Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) need accessible tools for reliable and efficient monitoring at relevant scales. Here, we describe how Earth Observation satellites (EO) make essential contributions to enable, accelerate, and improve genetic diversity monitoring and preservation. Specifically, we introduce a workflow integrating EO into existing genetic diversity monitoring strategies and present a set of examples where EO data is or can be integrated to improve assessment, monitoring, and conservation. We describe how available EO data can be integrated in innovative ways to support calculation of the genetic diversity indicators of the GBF monitoring framework and to inform management and monitoring decisions, especially in areas with limited research infrastructure or access. We also describe novel, integrative approaches to improve the indicators that can be implemented with the coming generation of EO data, and new capabilities that will provide unprecedented detail to characterize the changes to Earth’s surface and their implications for biodiversity, on a global scale.
Emerging Earth Observation methods for monitoring sustainable food productionCIFOR-ICRAF
Presented by Daniela Requena Suarez, Helmholtz GeoResearch Center Potsdam (GFZ) at "Side event 60th sessions of the UNFCCC Subsidiary Bodies - Sustainable Bites: Innovating Low Emission Food Systems One Country at a Time" on 13 June 2024
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: Regional analysis of forest and environmental product use and dependence amongst rural households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and Russia
1. Riyong Kim Bakkegaard
November 2014
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Regional analysis of forest and environmental
product use and dependence amongst rural
households in South Caucasus, Eastern Europe and
Russia
Photoby:LeylaMehtiyeva
This publication has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The content, findings, interpretations, and conclusions of this publication
are the sole responsibility of the FLEG II (ENPI East) Programme Team (www.enpi-fleg.org) and can in no way be taken to reflect the views of the
European Union. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect those of the Implementing Organizations.
2. Page 2
Introduction
An estimated 1.6 billion people are dependent to some degree on forests for their livelihoods,
of which 350 million to a high degree for their subsistence or income (World Bank 2004).
Environmental productsi
– i.e. products from non-cultivated ecosystems such as natural forests,
woodlands, wetlands, lakes, rivers, and grasslands – can be a significant income source for rural
households providing energy, food, construction and medicines both for subsistence and cash uses.
This has come to be known as the ‘hidden harvest’ (Campbell and Luckert 2002).
Forest products, specifically non-timber forest products (NTFPs) have been characterized as
often bulky, low value to weight, and need little skill to harvest. Furthermore, forest products are
characteristically quite extensively spread in remote areas, where access is relatively easy or
weakly regulated; (Angelsen and Wunder 2003). By their very characteristics, forest products are
attractive to the poorer segments of the population and represent both a dependable source of
subsistence food and fiber, as well as a source of quick income (e.g. de Merode et al 2004, Vedeld
et al 2004).
In the literature, attempts to quantify resource use amongst rural livelihoods have been case-
based (in selected communities), and as a result, the true value of forests and other environmental
products is not captured in GDP measurements and much debate about a forest’s potential to
achieve significant poverty alleviation, as the quantitative contribution of forests is not well-
documented (Dasgupta 1993, Oksanen et al. 2003, FAO 2006). A uniform methodology can assist
in consistently measuring the role of forests and environment in household income and address the
factors in environmental resource use, and efforts are underway to systematize the capture of
environmental resource use in nationwide and global surveys.
This document summarizes the outcomes of the regional activity, which aims at defining the
real value of forest resources in the region. It will ultimately fill a critical gap in information to quantify
the true value of fully-functioning forest for rural communities in these countries. The activity covers
seven countries: Armenia, Azerbaijan, Belarus, Georgia, Moldova, Ukraine, and the Russian
Federation and is implemented under the regional program “Improving Forest Law Enforcement and
Governance in the European Neighborhood Policy East Countries and Russia” implemented by
World Bank, the International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (IUCN) and
the World Wide Fund for Nature (WWF).
Today, the value of forest products and services other than timber is apparent in the wooded
areas. For the entire FOREST EUROPEii
region, the total value that was reported for non-wood
3. Page 3
goods reaches almost EUR 2 763 million, of which EUR 2 116 million are marketed plant products
and EUR 648 million are marketed animal products (Forests Europe et al, 2011). The concept of
sustainable forest management has also needed to encompass the contribution of forests to
livelihoods of rural communities in this region (Forests Europe et al, 2011). For example, fuelwood is
an essential resource on which household survival depends in this region, but there is a gap in
knowledge on the actual value of its contribution to household welfare and income.
The objective of this study is to quantify the relationship between rural communities and the
natural resource base around them. Through the implementation of a common and earlier tested
methodology adjusted to the region, the study aims to measure the true value of a fully-functioningiii
forest to rural communities and thereby generates quantitative results that can be used by policy
makers to improve forest governance and develop appropriate forest resource policy that
encompasses the priorities of local communities.
Methods
Using the common methodology based on elements of the World Bank Living Standards
Measurement Survey and the CIFOR Poverty Environment Network, a regionally-adapted
quantitative household survey was developed to systematically account for household income and
wealth for the preceding 12 months across the 7 countries to allow for inter-country comparisons of
environmental product use. Using a qualitative, focus group discussions method, a survey was also
implemented at the community level to judge the most important products to peoples' livelihoods, as
well as record community infrastructure and socio-economic characteristics.
The main method of valuing environmental goods was own-reported values, but estimating
value can be problematic to rural households who are not used to quantifying amounts of products
collected, let alone give value to them. In cases where products were difficult to value, such as
fuelwood for subsistence use, enumerators were instructed to first ask about the local prices of a
unit of fuelwood. If prices were not available or the respondent had difficulty, then barter prices were
used- where people were asked how much one unit of fuelwood could be bartered with another
traded product. Finally, enumerators could choose to ask respondents what they would be willing to
pay for a unit of fuelwood.
The ENPI-FLEG Forest Dependency team consisted of one regional consultant and seven
national consultants - one from each participating country. Questionnaire training took place from 31
March to 2 April 2014 in Chisinau, Moldova. Each national consultant had a team of enumerators
4. Page 4
who went to the field for implementation of surveys between May and August 2014. September and
October was spent mainly for data entry into a specially designed Microsoft Access database and
data was cleaned and analyzed thereafter.
For purposes of regional analysis, data was converted to USD Purchasing Power Parity
(PPP) using the World Bank 2013 conversion factors for private consumptioniv
. For inter-household
comparisons, data was also converted to adult equivalent units (aeu)v
.
National consultants were brought together on the 30th September 2014 for a consultant's
workshop where preliminary results of the national studies were presented. On 28th October 2014,
a regional conference was held to present the main results of the regional study.
Study area
The forests in the ENPI-FLEG region fall within the northern temperate and boreal forest
zones (FAO, 1999). Three of the ENPI countries, Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia belong to the
Southern Caucasus region which is one of the richest regions in the world for species and race
diversity of wild-growing fruits boasting over 260 species of fruit plants (FAO, 2006). Over 90% of
the forests of Russia are classified as undisturbed by humans (FAO, 2003), and the forests of
Belarus, Ukraine and Moldova also provide a rich variety of products upon which local communities
depend. In fact, temperate and boreal forests in this region are a traditional source of forest
products not only for timber but also for products such as resin, tannin, fodder, litter, medical plants,
fruits, nuts, roots, mushrooms, seeds, honey, ornamentals and exudates (Forest Europe et al, 2011).
The focus on timber production has increasingly been shifted towards people's use of the forests,
and particularly the subsistence use of forest products is becoming apparent (Forest Europe et al,
2011).
The region is unique when compared to other forested regions in the world, as it has
undergone a socio-political transformation after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991. Countries
in the region experienced various degrees of market reforms, decentralised decision-making and
privatization of previously state-owned lands. This led to recession, high unemployment and high
poverty especially in rural areas (Tikkanen et al, 2003). The difficult rural conditions, marked further
by a lack of alternative economic opportunities, has meant that rural populations are diminishing as
young people are migrating out and leaving behind an increasingly aging population (e.g Heleniak,
1999, Visser 2010).
5. Page 5
One of the major patterns of migration is labor migration to urban areas overseas or between
former soviet states, and is encouraged by promises of better living conditions, entrepreneurial
aspirations and supported by newfound freedoms of exit and entry (Tishkov et al 2005).
In all seven countries, surveys were conducted in the pre-identified pilot regions. 1256
households were surveyed across the regional sample, in communities located primarily in the
forested regions of the countries. In addition in each community, one community questionnaire was
implemented together with a key informant and/or village focus group discussion.
Figure 1 Regional map of study regions
The South Caucasus region is ranked among the planet’s 34 most diverse and endangered
hotspots by Conservation International, and the 2010 IUCN Red List identifies around 50 species of
globally threatened animals in the Caucasus. Over 43% of the land area is covered by priority
conservation areas and corridors (Slyven, undated). Half the total population of these three
countries live in the rural areas. High migration rates are common in the rural areas, where the
majority of the rural population lives below the poverty level (Balyan 2014; Figure 1). 196
households were sampled in forested and mountainous regions of Armenia: North (Lori Marz), North
6. Page 6
East (Tavush Marz) and South regions (Syunic Marz). 150 households were sampled in the
mountainous Zakatalsky district northwest of Azerbaijan, where two thirds of the territory is covered
by forests. In Georgia, 200 households were sampled in the Tianeti Municipality of Mtskheta-
Mtianeti Region, because of high land-use and forest resource dependence.
Compared to the other countries, most of the area in Ukraine, Moldova and Belarus consists
of plains and lowland with forest being concentrated in the Carpathians and Crimea (FAO, 2003).
Gomel Region in the southeast of Belarus with borders to Russia and Ukraine in the south has the
highest forest cover percentage, and therefore 200 households were sampled in this region. In
Moldova, the communities selected for the survey were spread between North, Central and South
regions, with a total of 150 households sampled. Three regions in Western Ukraine were selected
representing diverse forest types, and 150 households were sampled.
Finally, Russia accounts for more than one-fifth of the world’s total area of forest (865 million
hectares; FAO, 2010). Due to the geographical extent, three regions with high forest cover, and
contrasting natural conditions were chosen - North-West Russia, Central Siberia and the Russian
Far East. 210 households in total were sampled in these regions.
7. Table 1 Summary characteristics of countries
Armenia Azerbaijan Belarus Georgia Moldova Russia Ukraine
Forest cover 11.5% 11.8% 39.3% 40% 13% 45% 15.9% (16.5%
calculated per terrain
without water surface)
Area 351000ha 936000ha 9.48 million ha 3 million ha 450000ha 865 million ha 9.6 million ha
Forest type Broad-leaved (90%)
mainly oak, beech
and hornbeam.
coniferous (10%)
Mainly
broadleaved
beech with some
coniferous
Coniferous (59.6%),
with mainly Norway
spruce and Scots
pine. Broad-leaved
(40.4%)
Broad-leaved (80%)
coniferous (20%)
Broad-leaved,
mainly Robinia
pseudoacacia and
Oak
Northern boreal
mixed and
temperate broad
leaved.
Coniferous (80%)
Broad-leaved (56%)
coniferous (44%)
Forest ownership state state state State Mostly state (85%)
and municipality
(15%), private
(0,2%)
state Mainly state (87.5%),
communal (12.4%) and
private (negligible)
Forest use Very limited forest
available for wood
supply, and limited
commercial forestry,
with rest
inaccessible due to
economic reasons.
collection of
fuelwood, fruits,
aromatic and med
plants and fodder
important
Extraction for
wood, and also
collection of wild
fruits, game meat,
and fodder, nuts
and med plants
75% for wood
supply with rest
under conservation.
Collection of
NTFPs, berries and
mushrooms
Use of wood for
timber and NTFPs -
berries, fruits,
mushrooms, nuts.
Circa 90% of
harvest is fuelwood
and circa 10% is
timber. A number of
NFTPs, such as
game, berries,
fruits/nuts etc.
66% available for
wood supply and
rest inaccessible
due to economic
reasons.
Collection of
diverse NTFPs
incl. berries wild
fruits and game
meat.
Big environmental
importance of forests.
15.8% of forests belong
to nature protection
areas. In general,
about 50% of forests
have various limitations
of commercial timber
extraction. Other use:
Christmas trees, NTFP
collection (berries,
mushrooms, medical
plants), resins and and
birch sap
8. Use rights Paid use with issue
of license, warrant
or forest ticket for
single use.
Collection of NTFPs
for personal use
permitted.
Paid use for
leasing from 1-
10yrs with
provision that 20%
remain forested
Forest use rights
obtained for a
certain period of
time. For wood
1–15 years, or
short-term
use for < one year.
Usage rights also
given for collection
of NTFPs and
hunting.
Paid use of timber
forest resources for
personal consumption
within established
limits. Free use of
NTFPs for personal
purposes
Legal harvest done
by Agency
Moldsilva or
partially through
forest lease of
standing timber.
Hunting and other
NFTPs are
regulated. Access
to forests is
granted, except to
PAs and for
commercial harvest.
New forest code
has essentially
made it illegal for
local population to
harvest wood
products
Tree cutting without
felling ticket is
prohibited and
punishable. NTFPs can
be collected for free for
subsistence except in
protected areas where
it is restricted to certain
areas. Commercial
NTFP collection is
allowed by special
ticket.
Main regulation Forest Code 2005;
logging ban since
1996
Forest code
(1998)
Forest Code (2000) Forest Code (1999)
National Forest
Concept (2013)
Forest Code (1996) Forest Code of
the Russian
Federation (2006).
Forest Code (2006),
Land Code (2001)
Fuelwood
provision from
state?
8m3 to forest
dependent
communities
Some provided by
state, but mostly
illegal cutting
Fuelwood and
timber can be
bought from state at
subsidized price, up
to 4.99 m3 per year,
after which
fuelwood is sold at
a higher price
Can buy permit to cut
from state, with limit
of 7m3 (in the lowland
areas) 15 m3 (in high
mountainous areas),
Mostly illegal cutting
due to poverty
Authorized by
Ministry of
Environment,
Illegal logging Is
mainly subsistence
driven
previously
provided by the
state (under
Soviet times)
but now
generally illegal
due to
inconsistencies
in the Forest
Code and lower
level legislation
Only branches <3cm
diameter are free.
Otherwise bought from
forestry service, with
special ticket
Sources: FAO, World Bank, Metla, National Forest codes, National consultant reports
9. Page 9
Results and Discussion
Forest products and their value
Across the regional sample, 103 different products were identified.
Fuelwood is a vital resource for households in the region as it is the main source of heating
and energy for cooking for most rural households. Across the countries, fuelwood provisions by
national governments vary and often is not sufficient to meet the energy needs of rural households
(see Table 1). As a result, much fuelwood is illegally cut. Fuelwood surprisingly only makes up 17%
of all forest product value (Figure 2). However, due to the often complex and sensitive rules
surrounding fuelwood harvest, the recorded fuelwood is likely underestimatedvi
. Fuelwood
collection is mainly for subsistence, accounting for 27% of the value of subsistence forest products,
and only 3% of the value of cash products (Figure 3).
Approximately one quarter of the value of forest products comprised wild fruits, and of these
wild fruits, 65% of total value were from 17 different types of berries: primarily cranberry, blueberry
and wild strawberry. Berries dominate forest product collection for cash, making up over 50% of
total value of cash forest products collected (where only 10% is collected for subsistence). In
Armenia and Azerbaijan, cornelian cherry is a high value product sold fresh and used for
processing, along with a diverse range of other berries such as wild rose berries, wild strawberries,
blackberries and raspberries. In Russia blackberries and cranberries are collected in large quantities
(43% of total forest value), with cranberries being easier to collect and fetching high value.
Blueberries in Ukraine are an important seasonal income (43% of forest value in Ukrainian sample)
and also fetch a high price due to hand-picking and organic status. In Belarus, cranberries and
blueberries are collected for sale (52% of forest value in Belarus sample)
Mushrooms (17%) and nuts (15%) both have significant cash values across Russia, Belarus,
Moldova and Azerbaijan. Across the regional sample, quantities sold and consumed are relatively
equal. Hazelnuts in Azerbaijan and walnuts in Moldova are collected for sale. Mushroom collection
on the other hand, is a recreational activity in Ukraine and Russia, and across the countries
mushrooms are collected more for subsistence than sale.
Livestock related products, specifically fodder originating from the forest, makes up 11% of
total value and is largely for subsistence use. This is predominant in Armenia and Georgia where
livestock breeding are important livelihoods. Sawnwood processing is also common, particularly in
Russian Far East (contributing to 25% of value of forest products in this region), and Moldova (12%
10. Page 10
of value). Other products found across the sample, include alcoholic beverages (mainly in Georgia
and Russia), medicinal plants (small values across all countries), fish and meat.
Figure 2 Shares of total value of forest and environmental products ENPI FLEG countries and Russia
firewood
17%
wooden
4%
housing related
<1%
seeds
<1%livestock related
11%
fish
2%
other animal based
1%
wooden processed
2%
wild fruits
26%
nuts
15%
mushrooms
17%
roots and tubers
<1%
wild
vegetables
<1%
wild meat
1% medicinal
plants
<1%
other
non-
wood
<1%
other non-wood
processed
4%
11. Page 11
Figure 3 Forest and environmental products for cash and subsistence (percentage value)
firewood
3%
wooden
1%
wooden
processed
2%
wild fruits
53%
nuts
19%
mushrooms
14%
other non-wood
processed
4%
housing
related
1%
livestock
related
1%
fish
1%
other
animal
based
3%
Forest and
environmental
products sold
firewood
27%
wooden
6%
wooden
processed
2%
wild fruits
10%
nuts
12%
mushrooms
17%
wild meat
2%
medicinal plants
1%
other non-wood
processed
3%
livestock related
17%
fish
3%
Forest and environmental
products consumed
12. Page 12
Forest dependence
To measure the forest dependence, a numeric is used here called Relative Forest Income,
which is total forest incomevii
divided by total income (after Vedeld et al 2004).
Figure 4 Average forest dependence and total and forest incomes across countries
Figure 4 gives an overview of forest dependence (RFI; purple line) compared to total income
per aeu (blue bars) and forest income per aeu (red bars). Some distinct patterns emerge - Belarus
and Russia are the richest per aeu. On average Georgia and Moldova had the largest RFI and
the largest difference between RFI and RFI without fuelwood, indicating that fuelwood makes
up a significant component of forest product collection. The national reports also support
this- despite gasification in Georgia, fuelwood dependence remains high due to high costs of
gas. In Moldova, dependence on fuelwood for heating is high. Official statistics for sold fuelwood
are provided from the national forest authority Moldsilva who is responsible for sale, yet fuelwood
capture as income in the household survey suggests some degree of illegal logging (Zubarev et al,
0
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.1
0.12
0.14
0.16
0.18
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
ARM AZE BEL GEO MOL RUS UKR
Average of total income per aeu Average of forest income per aeu
Average RFI without fuelwood Average RFI
13. Page 13
2014). Armenia also shows this trend, and again high gas prices drive the high reliance on
fuelwood.
On the other hand, Azerbaijan, Belarus and Ukraine have almost no difference in forest
dependence when fuelwood is removed from forest income, reflecting the strict policies
around fuelwood extraction and the reluctance of respondents to report this, or the provision
of fuelwood at subsidized prices as in the case of Belarus.
Figure 5 RFI over regional averages for cash and subsistence forest incomes (USD PPP) per aeu
Further, the samples in each country were divided into five equal income categories
(quintiles) based on their total income per adult equivalent (aeu) income. Quintile 1 reflects the
poorest where quintile 5 is the richest. In Figure 5 a regional average for forest cash and
subsistence per adult equivalent is given across the five different quintiles. The red line represents
the regional average RFI, which importantly shows that poor are more forest dependent than
their richer income counterparts: the typical relationship shown in previous studies of forest
dependence amongst rural populations in tropical forest regions (e.g. Cavendish, 2000, Fisher
2004, Mamo et al 2007, Bakkegaard, 2008). Indeed, this relationship is due to a variety of factors,
0.00
100.00
200.00
300.00
400.00
500.00
600.00
700.00
800.00
0.00
0.02
0.04
0.06
0.08
0.10
0.12
0.14
0.16
1 2 3 4 5
averageforestincomeUSDPPP
RFI(forest/total)
Low Income -----------------------------> high income
Reg avg cash pr aeu
Reg avg sub pr aeu
Reg RFI
14. Page 14
including the fact that these resources require minimal capital and skills to harvest, and are usually
accessible for extraction (Angelsen and Wunder, 2003, Belcher 2005).
Similarly average regional cash forest income per aeu is also highest in the richest
quintiles, further confirming trends in other studies (Vedeld et al, 2004), and this was found in every
country sample. Richer quintiles often have better resources (e.g. money, labour) to invest in
extracting forest resources and also in realizing their cash potential and this can be often tied to
their higher social status and thus network in communities (Ambrose-Oji, 2003).
Socio-economic characteristics are also determinants in forest resource use behaviour, and
in a simple analysis using pairwise correlationsviii
household characteristics were correlated to RFI
and forest cash and subsistence per adult equivalent (Table 2). Larger household for instance could
mean greater income needs and the need to feed more household members (e.g. Appiah et al,
2007) but also more labour to diversify into more rewarding income streams (Mamo et al, 2007). In
this case, higher RFI is significantly correlated with smaller household sizes showing that
forest income make up larger shares of total household incomes in the smaller households.
In fact, the higher forest subsistence per aeu drives the correlation here, indicating that small
households harvest products for subsistence.
Table 2 Pearson correlation coefficients
RFI Forest cash
per aeu
Forest subsistence per aeu
r r r
Household size -0.1279 * -0.0554 -0.2908*
Distance to market (km) 0.1022 * 0.0800 0.0480
Age -0.0891 -0.0924 0.0540
Education of HH head (yrs) -0.0325 -0.0352 -0.0032
Wage per aeu (USD PPP) -0.1570 * 0.1237 * 0.2415 *
Other per aeu (USD PPP) -0.1672 * 0.1055 0.0640
Net livestock animal per aeu (USD PPP) -0.0753 0.0243 0.1358 *
Net agriculture per aeu (USD PPP) 0.0057 0.0548 0.2079 *
* denotes significance at 5%
Greater distance to market is also significantly correlated to greater share of forest income in
total household income and implies that households earning higher incomes from forests have
the opportunity to exploit a more expansive high quality resource base.
Lower income from other sources per aeu is significantly correlated to higher RFI, showing
that other income could suffice to support rural households without them having to tap into
forest income.
15. Page 15
However, it could be related in some degree to the demographics of those who receive other
income. Although age is not significant, 83% of other income is made up of aged pensions
suggesting that the aged population receiving pensions have lower shares of forest income in their
total household incomes. Studies from tropical regions suggest that the intensity of forest resource
collection could be beyond the capabilities of an aged household (Vedeld et al, 2004, Mamo et al,
2007), suggesting that the younger households are more likely to engage in resource collection.
Age and other socio-economic characteristics, such as the role of education, deserve further
analysis on the national level. Education of household heads has been found in other studies to lead
to less forest dependence (e.g. Godoy and Conteras 2001, Adhikari et al 2004) as education can
lead to better opportunities for outmigration and off-farm employment (Mamo et al 2007). This
however, could be confounded where forest product collection activities serve a recreational
purpose as in Russia and Ukraine.
In a simple analysis of gender role in collection, the regional sample showed that
subsistence products were collected by both adults in the households, but largely by men
(Figure 6). As in other regions, certain activities may culturally be the domain of men (e.g. charcoal
making in Malawi, Fisher 2004). In the regional sample, firewood, wild meat, fishing and livestock
related (fodder) were largely collected by men, but proportionally, women were relatively more
involved in nuts and medicinal plant collection.
16. Page 16
Figure 6 Main collector of subsistence and cash forest products
0 100000 200000 300000 400000 500000 600000
wife, adult female
both adults
husband, adult male
girls <15yrs
boys <15 yrs
children < 15yrs equally
all members
none of above
other person in HH
Value (USD PPP)
Forest products consumed
Forest products sold
17. Page 17
Forests and sustainability
In community focus group discussions, communities identified the most important products
for their livelihoods. Almost all country samples identified fuelwood as a central product with the
other main products being berries (cranberries or blueberries), nuts, and mushrooms. Most
communities also revealed a decline in availability in a forest product.
Often cited reasons for decline had to do with reduced forest areas due to logging or
overharvesting (berries). Non-local harvesters attempting to cash in on lucrative berries have left
cranberry distributions low. Furthermore destructive harvesting techniques that speed up harvesting
but damage regrowth have also led to their decline. Climate change was also an often cited reason
as the drying up of marshes shrinks cranberry distribution.
Nuts in the Siberian pine in Altai have also suffered from overharvesting and destructive
techniques. Chestnuts in Azerbaijan have also been in decline due to disease and drying climate,
and climate has also been the culprit for changing distributions of mushrooms in Russia.
Finally across countries, fuelwood was recognised as an important product and generally in
decline. Main reasons attributed were reduced forest area due to unregulated logging or forest use
restrictions, climate change (less rainfall and drought causing shrinking forest area), and increased
collection and overharvesting (illegal).
All of these reasons point to the need for better forest management to secure the availability
of economically and socially important forest products. Indeed, this is a resource base that is
essential for rural households to survive during winter months. Fuelwood harvesting and provision in
particular needs to be better managed as gas prices are beyond the affordability of some rural
households to make the total switch to gas.
Climate variability is also affecting both forests and forest product availability, and this is
already being felt by communities. Diminishing forest incomes in rural livelihood strategies means
that rural households need to be able to make a viable living from other activities. This could include
agriculture, which will require investments into technology transfer, market development and the
labour market. Alternatively, it could mean generating more employment opportunities for rural
people. In any case, policy makers will need to consider where incomes will be generated if not from
forests.
18. Page 18
Conclusion
The role of forest and environmental resources in rural household incomes is evident. Forest
products are important for subsistence and cash income in this region, and therefore vital to
livelihoods of the rural people. This is particularly pertinent in these countries, where rural
economies are still lagging behind their urban areas, and migration, poverty, and lack of jobs are
encouraging the depopulation of rural communities.
This analysis is one of the first characterising forest resources use in such an
extensive area of the northern temperate and boreal forests, in countries that are transitioning
from decades of Soviet rule to new economies. Results from this regional analysis have confirmed
the trends found in forest poverty studies in the tropical forest regions, but in this region outmigration
and aging populations are common, as are the opportunities to migrate for labour to neighbouring
countries.
The average regional forest dependence of households is 10.3% with national variation
from 5% to 17%, and even higher variation within study sites. Fuelwood remains important
despite the beginnings of gasification in communities. The latter remains practically out of
the reach of rural households due to high gas prices and costs of installation. Berries and
mushrooms contribute greatly to cash income, with some households using income from
these products to supplement other sources of household income.
The analysis has shown that forest income makes up a larger share of total household
income if the household is poorer. Consequently, poorer households are more dependent on
forests. Also, the richer households of the community generate more forest cash income.
Importantly, most communities see forest products as declining in availability citing
reasons such as overharvesting, illegal logging, and climate change as main drivers that result in
the shrinking of the resource base. Thus, in the face of overall macro-economic development and
climate change, it is critical to understand how people depend on nature so that appropriate
measures can be taken to secure households who may be dependent on forests for their livelihoods.
Although these studies are only snapshots in time of localised cases, they serve to
demonstrate that forests and the environment provide important resources to the rural households.
These not only points to the need for continued research and analyses, but for the development of
appropriate policies that take into account the resource needs of rural communities in order to
ensure that the people who are most dependent on forests and the environment are not excluded
from an important base for their survival.
19. Page 19
References
Adhikari, B, Di Flaco, S., and Lovett, J.C., 2004. Household characteristics and forest dependency: evidence
from common property forest management in Nepal. Ecological Economics 48: 245-257.
Angelsen, A. and Wunder, S. 2003. Exploring the forest-poverty link: key concepts, issues and research
implications. CIFOR Occasional Paper No. 40, 58 pp.
Ambrose-Oji, B. (2003) The contribution of NTFPs to the livelihoods of the ‘forest poor’: evidence from the
tropical forest zone of south-west Cameroon. International Forestry Review 5(2): 106-117
Appiah, M., Blay, D., Damnyag, L., Dwomoh, F. K., Pappinen, A., & Luukkanen, O. (2009). Dependence on
forest resources and tropical deforestation in Ghana. Environment, Development and Sustainability, 11(3),
471-487.
Bakkegaard, R. K, 2008. Forests and Poverty: forest contributions to household economies in western
Democratic Republic of Congo. MSc thesis. University of Copenhagen.
Belcher, B.M. 2005. Forest product markets, forests and poverty reduction. International Forestry Review 7
(2): 82-89.
Cavendish, W. 2000. Empirical Regularities in the Poverty-Environment Relationship of Rural Households:
Evidence from Zimbabwe. World Development 28 (11), 1979-2003.
Cavendish, W. 2002. Quantitative Methods for estimating the value of resource use to household income. In:
Campbell, B. and Luckert, M.K. (eds.) Uncovering the Hidden Harvest. Earthscan Publications Ltd. London.
Pp. 17-65.
Dasgupta, P. 1993. An Inquiry into Well-being and Destitution. Clarendon Press, Oxford
de Merode, E., Homewood, K., & Cowlishaw, G. 2004. The value of bushmeat and other wild foods to rural
households living in extreme poverty in Democratic Republic of Congo. Biological conservation, 118(5), 573-
581.
FAO 2010. Global Forest Resources Assessment (FRA), FAO, 2010.Online at: www.fao.org/forestry/fra2010/
FAO 2006. Better forestry, less poverty - A practitioner’s guide; Food and Agriculture Organization of the
United Nations. Rome.
FAO 2003 Forests and Forestry sector: Moldova. Online at:
http://www.fao.org/forestry/country/57478/en/mda/ accessed 1/11/2014
FAO 2003 Forests and Forestry sector: Belarus. Online at:
http://www.fao.org/forestry/country/57478/en/blr/ accessed 1/11/2014
FAO 2003 Forests and Forestry sector: Ukraine. Online at:
http://www.fao.org/forestry/country/57478/en/ukr/ accessed 1/11/2014
FOREST EUROPE, UNECE and FAO 2011. State of Europe’s Forests 2011. Status and Trends in
Sustainable Forest Management in Europe.
20. Page 20
Fisher, M. 2004. Household welfare and forest dependence in Southern Malawi. Environment and
Development Economics, 9(2), 135–154.
FAO 2003. Forests and Forestry sector: Russia. Online at:
http://www.fao.org/forestry/country/57478/en/rus/ accessed 1/11/2014
Godoy, R., & Contreras, M. 2001. A Comparative Study of Education and Tropical Deforestation among
Lowland Bolivian Amerindians: Forest Values, Environmental Externality, and School Subsidies*. Economic
Development and Cultural Change, 49(3), 555-574.
Heleniak, T. 1999. Out-Migration and Depopulation of the Russian North during the 1990s. Post-Soviet
Geography and Economics, 40(3), 155-205.
Sylven, undated. South Caucasus eco-region. Nature Needs Half. Online at <http://natureneedshalf.org/south-
caucasus-eco-region/> accessed 10/11/2014
Tikkanen, I., Niskanen, A., Bouriaud, L., Zyrina, Olk. Michie, B. and Pussinen, A. 2003. Forest Based
Sustainable Development: Forest Resoruce Potentials, Emerging Socio.economic issues and policy
development challenges in CITS. In Oksanen, T., Pajari, B, and Tuomasukka, T. (eds) Forests in Poverty
Reduction Strategies: Capturing the Potential. EFI Proceedings, NO. 47.
Tishkov, V., Zayinchkovskaya, Z., & Vitkovskaya, G. 2005. Migration in the countries of the former Soviet
Union. Paper for the Policy Analysis and Research Programme of the Global Commission on International
Migration.
Vedeld, P., Angelsen, A., Sjaastad, E., and Berg, G.K. 2004. Counting on the Environment: Forest Incomes
and the Rural Poor. Environmental Economic Series. Paper no. 98. The World Bank Environment
Department.
Visser, O. 2010, Insecure Land Rights, Obstacles to Family Farming, and the Weakness of protest in Rural
Russia. Laboratorium Vol. 2, no. 3:275–295
World Bank 2014. PPP conversion factor, private consumption (LCU per international $). Online at:
http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/PA.NUS.PRVT.PP accessed 30/7/2014.
Zubarev, V., Popa, B., Lozan., A., and Mosnoi, E., 2014. National Report Moldova. ENPI FLEG Forest
Dependency study. National Consultant Report. Oct 2014.
i Forest products are classified as a subset of environmental products. Forest products are any products
originating from forests, which are defined as lands of more than 0.5 hectares, with a tree canopy cover of more
than 10 percent, where the trees should be able to reach a minimum height of 5 meters in situ, and which are not
primarily under agricultural land use (FAO, 2000).
ii Covers the European continent as far south as Turkey and Cyprus and as far east as Georgia and Russia.
iii full-functionality refers to the functionality to rural communities as well as environment.
iv Purchasing power parity conversion factor is the number of units of a country's currency required to buy the
same amounts of goods and services in the domestic market as U.S. dollar would buy in the United States. This
conversion factor is for private consumption (i.e., household final consumption expenditure) (World Bank, 2014).
v after Cavendish (2002): Adult equivalence scales standardize households accounting for household composition
in order to allow one member of a household to be compared to another member of another household.
vi The issue of underestimation, particularly of certain products like fuelwood where harvesting is illegal in some
countries, and general reliability and validity of the data is discussed in the full regional report.
21. Page 21
vii Forest income captures income earned from forest as well as non-forest environments that exclude any form of
cultivated field (which would enter the household income as agricultural income). The term "forest dependence"
and its measure "Relative Forest Income" is therefore used to describe the share of forest and environmental (wild
non-cultivated) income in total household income.
viii Pairwise correlations in STATA v.11 is a statistical technique that is a measure how well two variables are
related to each other. A positive sign suggests that as the column variable increases, the row variable increases.
the size of the correlation coefficient is also indicative of the strength of the association, with all r values falling
between -1 to 0 to 1.
About the author
Riyong Kim Bakkegaard (Riyong@hotmail.com), the regional consultant for this study, has
worked extensively in tropical forests regions of South East Asia, and Congo and Brazilian
Amazon basins examining the socio-economics of rural livelihoods and dependence on natural
resources. She holds a PhD and MSc in natural resource economics and rural development with
specialization in tropical forestry and REDD+/PES. Based in Denmark, she is currently working
on developing methodologies for valuing the environmental contribution to household welfare
with FAO, CIFOR, PROFOR and the World Bank, and also works on low-carbon and climate
resilient development at UNEP DTU Partnership.
22. A
A
About
The Forest L
(ENPI) East
Program aim
commit to a
and legal a
management
Program wil
improved for
Azerbaijan, B
http://www.e
Projec
FLEG
Law Enforcem
Countries Pr
ms to implem
time-bound a
and administ
and good fo
l test and d
rest governan
Belarus, Geor
enpi-fleg.org
ct Part
G II (EN
ment and Go
rogram supp
ment the 200
action plan; a
trative struc
orest governa
demonstrate
nce practices
rgia, Moldova
tner
NPI Ea
overnance (F
orts particip
05 St. Peters
at the nationa
tures; and
ance in the p
best practic
s at the field-
a, Russia, and
EUROPEA
The Europe
EuropeAid D
Commission
aid througho
with a focus
proactive pla
and econom
preserving n
http://ec.euro
WORLD B
The World B
its 188 mem
owned by th
power within
issues. The
International
Developmen
Finance Cor
the Internati
plays a dist
decreasing t
percent, and
percent for e
http://www.wo
IUCN
IUCN, Intern
solutions to
focuses on v
of its use, an
developmen
world, and
policy, laws
environment
almost 11,00
over 1,000 s
around the w
www.iucn.org
WWF
WWF is on
organization
countries. W
and to build
world’s biolo
sustainable,
www.panda.o
ast) Pr
FLEG) II Euro
pating countr
sburg FLEG
al level the P
improve kno
participating
es for susta
-level on a pi
d Ukraine. Th
AN COMMIS
ean Union is th
Development a
, is responsible
out the world. E
s on ensuring
ayer in the deve
mic developmen
natural resource
opa.eu/index_e
BANK
Bank Group is on
mber-countries.
he governments
n the organizati
e World Bank
l Bank for Rec
nt Association (
rporation (IFC);
onal Centre for
tinct role in the
the percentage
d promote share
every country. F
orldbank.org, htt
national Union
our most press
valuing and con
nd deploying na
t. IUCN suppo
brings governm
s and best p
tal organisation
00 volunteer ex
staff in 45 offices
world.
g
ne of the world
ns, with almost
WWF’s mission i
d a future in wh
ogical diversity,
and promoting
org
rogram
opean Neighb
ries’ forest g
Ministerial D
Program will
owledge of
countries, an
ainable fores
ilot basis. Pa
he Program is
SSION
he world’s large
and Cooperatio
e for designing
EuropeAid deliv
the quality of
elopment field, E
nt and tackle u
s.
n.htm
ne of the world’s
The organizatio
of member nat
ons on all matt
Group compris
construction and
IDA), which tog
the Multilatera
r Settlement of
e World Bank
of people living
ed prosperity by
or additional inf
p://www.ifc.org, h
for Conservatio
sing environme
nserving nature
ature-based solu
rts scientific re
ments, NGOs,
ractice. IUCN
, with more tha
xperts in some
s and hundreds
d’s largest and
5 million suppo
s to stop the de
hich humans liv
, ensuring that
the reduction o
m
bourhood an
governance. A
Declaration a
review or rev
and suppor
nd at the sub
st manageme
articipating co
s funded by t
est donor of of
on, a Directora
European deve
ers aid through
EU aid and its
EuropeAid prom
niversal issues,
s largest source
ons that make
ions, which hav
ters, including p
ses five closel
d Development
gether form the
al Investment G
Investment Dis
Group’s missio
g on less than $
y fostering the in
formation please
http://www.miga.
on of Nature, h
nt and develop
, ensuring effec
utions to global
esearch, manag
the UN and co
is the world’
an 1,200 govern
160 countries.
of partners in p
d most respect
rters and a glo
egradation of th
ve in harmony w
the use of re
f pollution and w
nd Partnershi
At the regio
and support
vise forest se
rt for susta
b-national (lo
ent and the
ountries incl
the European
fficial developm
ate General of
elopment policy
h a set of finan
s effectiveness.
motes good gove
, such as fight
es of knowledge
up the World B
ve the ultimate d
policy, financial
ly associated
t (IBRD) and t
e World Bank; t
Guarantee Agen
sputes (ICSID).
on to end extre
$1.25 a day to
ncome growth o
e visit:
org
helps the world
pment challenge
ctive and equita
challenges in c
ges field projec
ompanies toget
’s oldest and
nment and NGO
. IUCN’s work
public, NGO and
cted independe
obal network ac
he planet’s natu
with nature, by
enewable natur
wasteful consum
ip Instrumen
nal level, the
countries to
ector policies
inable fores
ocal) level the
feasibility o
ude Armenia
n Union.
ment assistance
f the European
y and delivering
cial instruments
An active and
ernance, human
ing hunger and
e and funding fo
Bank Group are
decision-making
or membership
institutions: the
he Internationa
he Internationa
cy (MIGA); and
Each institution
eme poverty by
no more than 3
of the bottom 40
find pragmatic
es. IUCN’s work
able governance
limate, food and
cts all over the
ther to develop
largest globa
O members and
is supported by
d private sectors
nt conservation
tive in over 100
ural environmen
conserving the
ral resources is
mption.
t
e
o
s
t
e
f
a,
.
n
g
s
d
n
d
r
e
g
p
e
al
al
d
n
y
3
0
c
k
e
d
e
p
l
d
y
s
n
0
t
e
s