SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Dose-Volume Histogram
Dr Sasikumar Sambasivam
• A voxel represents a
value on a regular
grid in three-
dimensional space.
• Voxel is a combination
of "volume" and
"pixel" where pixel is a
combination of
"picture" and
"element"
Intro
• The display and analysis of dose distribution
Displaying dose
– Colour scales
– Dose banding
– Interactivity
Dose volume histograms
– Types
– Calculation and interpretation
– Problems and pitfalls
Displaying dose
Methods of displaying dose
• 1. Iso-dose contours
Sets of closed contours linking voxels of equal dose
• 2. Colour wash
The coding of CT and dose in the same voxel
through the modulation of both intensity (CT) and
colour (dose)
• 3. Iso-dose surfaces
The shaded surface (pseudo-3d) representation of
a particular dose level and selected VOIs
Intro
• To form a DVH for any 3D object, one looks at the dose value
for each voxel in the object and forms a histogram,
counting the number of voxels that receive each different
dose level
• Because the volume of each voxel is known, the volume of the
organ receiving each dose level is known.
• Both the volume (vertical) and dose (horizontal) axes can be
displayed in absolute terms (as cubic centimeters [cc] or
Gray [Gy]) or in relative terms (% volume or % dose),
depending on how the planner wants to analyze the results.
• DVHs are displayed in :
• cumulative,
• and differential
The differential histogram
• The generic form of any histogram, displaying the
volume of the organ that receives dose within each
dose bin (1% or 0.5 to 1 Gy is a typical dose bin
width).
• It is useful for display of the dose-to-target volumes,
because one can easily visualize the minimum dose,
the maximum dose, and the dose most
representative of the dose to the entire target volume
• This type is necessary in order to appropriately
compare DVHs formed with different dose bin
sizes, because the volume contained in any dose
bin changes as the dose bin size changes.
• The differential DVH plots (1/Dbin) *DV/DD, so
different differential DVHs can be compared even if
their dose bin sizes are different
Differential DVH
Cumulative DVH
• Volumes receiving at least a given dose
value are plotted.
• The cumulative DVH integrates the direct
histogram, so it always begins at 100% (100%
of the organ receives at least 0 dose), and
ends at the maximum dose
Cumulative DVH
Problems and Pitfalls
1. DVHs are insensitive to small ‘hot’ and ‘cold’
spots
2. The shape of a DVH alone can be misleading
3. DVHs can only be calculated for defined VOIs
4. DVHs throw away all spatial information
1) Insensitiveness to small ‘hot’ and ‘cold’ spots
Consider
comparative
DVHs from
competing
plans
• From DVHs,
plan 2
appears to be
the best
…apart from
apparently
inignificant
increase in high
dose to posterior
fossa
• Posterior fossa
2) The shape of a DVH alone can be misleading
3. DVHs can only be calculated for defined VOIs.
4. DVHs throw away all spatial information
Visual assessment of dose distributions
• The most direct and informative representation of a
treatment plan available - however….
• 3-D dose distributions are large and
cumbersome and difficult to analyse quantitatively
• User interactivity is essential to extract the most
information from dose distributions (slice
selection/multi slice display, dose banding, dose
querying etc).
• Provide a succinct and quantitative method of
representing 3-d dose within selected VOI’s
-however…
• DVH’s should only be used in conjunction with careful
visual analysis of 3-d dose distributions
• In particular, care should be taken when analysing
large volumes using DVH’s
• DVH’s should always be assessed in conjunction with
dose-volume statistics.
Assessing and ranking a plan—Dose Based Scoring
Possible score functions
1.Visual assessment of the 3-d dose distribution
2. Visual assessment of DVHs
3. Quantitative analysis of dose distributions (conformity
index, homogeneity index etc)
4. Quantitative analysis of DVHs
(max, min, dose-to-volume etc)
Thank you.

More Related Content

What's hot

Electron Beam Therapy
Electron Beam TherapyElectron Beam Therapy
Electron Beam Therapy
ajjitchandran
 
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in RadiotherapyEvolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
Nikhil Sebastian
 
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
Volumetric Modulated Arc TherapyVolumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
fondas vakalis
 

What's hot (20)

4dct (2012)
4dct (2012)4dct (2012)
4dct (2012)
 
Icru 50
Icru 50Icru 50
Icru 50
 
Plan evaluation in Radiotherapy- Dr Kiran
Plan evaluation in Radiotherapy- Dr KiranPlan evaluation in Radiotherapy- Dr Kiran
Plan evaluation in Radiotherapy- Dr Kiran
 
Imrt&vmat
Imrt&vmatImrt&vmat
Imrt&vmat
 
ICRU reports 50 and 62
ICRU reports 50 and 62ICRU reports 50 and 62
ICRU reports 50 and 62
 
Treatment plannings i kiran
Treatment plannings i   kiranTreatment plannings i   kiran
Treatment plannings i kiran
 
IMRT and 3DCRT
IMRT and 3DCRT IMRT and 3DCRT
IMRT and 3DCRT
 
ICRU 89 summary & beyond converted
ICRU 89 summary & beyond convertedICRU 89 summary & beyond converted
ICRU 89 summary & beyond converted
 
Modern Radiotherapy
Modern RadiotherapyModern Radiotherapy
Modern Radiotherapy
 
Patient positional correction stategies in radiotherapy
Patient positional correction stategies   in radiotherapyPatient positional correction stategies   in radiotherapy
Patient positional correction stategies in radiotherapy
 
Electron Beam Therapy
Electron Beam TherapyElectron Beam Therapy
Electron Beam Therapy
 
Role of SBRT in lung cancer
Role of SBRT in lung cancerRole of SBRT in lung cancer
Role of SBRT in lung cancer
 
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in RadiotherapyEvolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
Evolution of Fractionation and Conventional Fractionation in Radiotherapy
 
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
Volumetric Modulated Arc TherapyVolumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
Volumetric Modulated Arc Therapy
 
Time, dose and fractionation
Time, dose and fractionationTime, dose and fractionation
Time, dose and fractionation
 
ICRU 83 report on dose prescription in IMRT
ICRU 83 report on dose prescription in IMRTICRU 83 report on dose prescription in IMRT
ICRU 83 report on dose prescription in IMRT
 
Smart radiotherapy
Smart radiotherapySmart radiotherapy
Smart radiotherapy
 
Hemi body irradiation
Hemi body irradiationHemi body irradiation
Hemi body irradiation
 
ICRU CONCEPT
ICRU CONCEPTICRU CONCEPT
ICRU CONCEPT
 
Icru 58.
Icru 58.Icru 58.
Icru 58.
 

Similar to Dose volume histogram

Three dimensional conformal radiation therapy
Three  dimensional conformal radiation therapyThree  dimensional conformal radiation therapy
Three dimensional conformal radiation therapy
Deepika Malik
 
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
svmmcradonco1
 
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta MBioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
Vishnu Datta Maremanda
 
Introduction to sampling
Introduction to samplingIntroduction to sampling
Introduction to sampling
Situo Liu
 
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.pptMEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
VnDr
 

Similar to Dose volume histogram (20)

5.Plan Evaluation, DVH Analysis, TPS.pptx
5.Plan Evaluation, DVH Analysis, TPS.pptx5.Plan Evaluation, DVH Analysis, TPS.pptx
5.Plan Evaluation, DVH Analysis, TPS.pptx
 
Three dimensional conformal radiation therapy
Three  dimensional conformal radiation therapyThree  dimensional conformal radiation therapy
Three dimensional conformal radiation therapy
 
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
3DimensionalConformalRThPresentation.pdf
 
TWO COMPARTMENT MODEL.pptx
TWO COMPARTMENT MODEL.pptxTWO COMPARTMENT MODEL.pptx
TWO COMPARTMENT MODEL.pptx
 
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta MBioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
Bioequivalence experimental study design By Vishnu Datta M
 
Drug calculation
Drug calculationDrug calculation
Drug calculation
 
Presentation4.ppt
Presentation4.pptPresentation4.ppt
Presentation4.ppt
 
2. chapter ii(analyz)
2. chapter ii(analyz)2. chapter ii(analyz)
2. chapter ii(analyz)
 
Evaluation of radiotherapy treatment planning
Evaluation of radiotherapy treatment planningEvaluation of radiotherapy treatment planning
Evaluation of radiotherapy treatment planning
 
FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION.pptx
FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION.pptxFREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION.pptx
FREQUENCY DISTRIBUTION.pptx
 
Methods of data presentation.pptx
Methods of data presentation.pptxMethods of data presentation.pptx
Methods of data presentation.pptx
 
Statistics "Descriptive & Inferential"
Statistics "Descriptive & Inferential"Statistics "Descriptive & Inferential"
Statistics "Descriptive & Inferential"
 
Introduction to sampling
Introduction to samplingIntroduction to sampling
Introduction to sampling
 
ANOVA.pptx
ANOVA.pptxANOVA.pptx
ANOVA.pptx
 
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.pptMEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
MEASURES OF DISPERSION.ppt
 
Measures of dispersion
Measures of dispersionMeasures of dispersion
Measures of dispersion
 
MEASURES_OF_DISPERSION_-_II.pdf
MEASURES_OF_DISPERSION_-_II.pdfMEASURES_OF_DISPERSION_-_II.pdf
MEASURES_OF_DISPERSION_-_II.pdf
 
Topic 4 Measures of Dispersion.pptx
Topic 4  Measures of Dispersion.pptxTopic 4  Measures of Dispersion.pptx
Topic 4 Measures of Dispersion.pptx
 
ICRU 83
ICRU 83ICRU 83
ICRU 83
 
Frequency Distributions
Frequency DistributionsFrequency Distributions
Frequency Distributions
 

More from Nilesh Kucha

More from Nilesh Kucha (20)

Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases.pptx [read only]
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases.pptx [read only]Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases.pptx [read only]
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases.pptx [read only]
 
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseasesChapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
 
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseasesChapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
Chapter 39 role of radiotherapy in benign diseases
 
Chapter 38 role of surgery in cancer prevention
Chapter 38 role of surgery in cancer preventionChapter 38 role of surgery in cancer prevention
Chapter 38 role of surgery in cancer prevention
 
Chapter 37 svco
Chapter 37 svcoChapter 37 svco
Chapter 37 svco
 
Chapter 36 t reg cells
Chapter 36 t reg cellsChapter 36 t reg cells
Chapter 36 t reg cells
 
Chapter 35 tumor lysis syndrome
Chapter 35 tumor lysis syndromeChapter 35 tumor lysis syndrome
Chapter 35 tumor lysis syndrome
 
Chapter 34 medical stat
Chapter 34 medical statChapter 34 medical stat
Chapter 34 medical stat
 
Chapter 33 isolated tumor cells
Chapter 33 isolated tumor cellsChapter 33 isolated tumor cells
Chapter 33 isolated tumor cells
 
Chapter 32 invasion and metastasis
Chapter 32 invasion and metastasisChapter 32 invasion and metastasis
Chapter 32 invasion and metastasis
 
Chapter 31 genetic counselling
Chapter 31 genetic counsellingChapter 31 genetic counselling
Chapter 31 genetic counselling
 
Chapter 30 febrile neutropenia
Chapter 30 febrile neutropeniaChapter 30 febrile neutropenia
Chapter 30 febrile neutropenia
 
Chapter 29 dendritic cells
Chapter 29 dendritic cellsChapter 29 dendritic cells
Chapter 29 dendritic cells
 
Chapter 28 clincal trials
Chapter 28 clincal trials Chapter 28 clincal trials
Chapter 28 clincal trials
 
Chapter 27 chemotherapy side effects dr lms
Chapter 27 chemotherapy side effects  dr lmsChapter 27 chemotherapy side effects  dr lms
Chapter 27 chemotherapy side effects dr lms
 
Chapter 26 chemoprevention of cancer
Chapter 26 chemoprevention of cancerChapter 26 chemoprevention of cancer
Chapter 26 chemoprevention of cancer
 
Chapter 25 assessment of clincal responses
Chapter 25 assessment of clincal responsesChapter 25 assessment of clincal responses
Chapter 25 assessment of clincal responses
 
Chapter 24.3 metronomic chemotherapy
Chapter 24.3 metronomic chemotherapyChapter 24.3 metronomic chemotherapy
Chapter 24.3 metronomic chemotherapy
 
Chapter 24.2 lmwh in cancer asso thrombosis
Chapter 24.2 lmwh in cancer asso thrombosisChapter 24.2 lmwh in cancer asso thrombosis
Chapter 24.2 lmwh in cancer asso thrombosis
 
Chapter 24.1 kinase inhibitors and monoclonal antibodies
Chapter 24.1 kinase inhibitors and monoclonal antibodiesChapter 24.1 kinase inhibitors and monoclonal antibodies
Chapter 24.1 kinase inhibitors and monoclonal antibodies
 

Recently uploaded

Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdfAlcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Dr Jeenal Mistry
 
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
Oleg Kshivets
 
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial FreedomMastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
FatimaMary4
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Presentació "Advancing Emergency Medicine Education through Virtual Reality"
Presentació "Advancing Emergency Medicine Education through Virtual Reality"Presentació "Advancing Emergency Medicine Education through Virtual Reality"
Presentació "Advancing Emergency Medicine Education through Virtual Reality"
 
Arterial health throughout cancer treatment and exercise rehabilitation in wo...
Arterial health throughout cancer treatment and exercise rehabilitation in wo...Arterial health throughout cancer treatment and exercise rehabilitation in wo...
Arterial health throughout cancer treatment and exercise rehabilitation in wo...
 
Effects of vaping e-cigarettes on arterial health
Effects of vaping e-cigarettes on arterial healthEffects of vaping e-cigarettes on arterial health
Effects of vaping e-cigarettes on arterial health
 
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptxTemporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
Temporal, Infratemporal & Pterygopalatine BY Dr.RIG.pptx
 
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complexUS E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
US E-cigarette Summit: Taming the nicotine industrial complex
 
Relationship between vascular system disfunction, neurofluid flow and Alzheim...
Relationship between vascular system disfunction, neurofluid flow and Alzheim...Relationship between vascular system disfunction, neurofluid flow and Alzheim...
Relationship between vascular system disfunction, neurofluid flow and Alzheim...
 
Is preeclampsia and spontaneous preterm delivery associate with vascular and ...
Is preeclampsia and spontaneous preterm delivery associate with vascular and ...Is preeclampsia and spontaneous preterm delivery associate with vascular and ...
Is preeclampsia and spontaneous preterm delivery associate with vascular and ...
 
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptxDECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
DECIPHERING COMMON ECG FINDINGS IN ED.pptx
 
Why invest into infodemic management in health emergencies
Why invest into infodemic management in health emergenciesWhy invest into infodemic management in health emergencies
Why invest into infodemic management in health emergencies
 
CURRENT HEALTH PROBLEMS AND ITS SOLUTION BY AYURVEDA.pptx
CURRENT HEALTH PROBLEMS AND ITS SOLUTION BY AYURVEDA.pptxCURRENT HEALTH PROBLEMS AND ITS SOLUTION BY AYURVEDA.pptx
CURRENT HEALTH PROBLEMS AND ITS SOLUTION BY AYURVEDA.pptx
 
Hemodialysis: Chapter 3, Dialysis Water Unit - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 3, Dialysis Water Unit - Dr.GawadHemodialysis: Chapter 3, Dialysis Water Unit - Dr.Gawad
Hemodialysis: Chapter 3, Dialysis Water Unit - Dr.Gawad
 
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
Non-Invasive assessment of arterial stiffness in advanced heart failure patie...
 
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdfAlcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
Alcohol_Dr. Jeenal Mistry MD Pharmacology.pdf
 
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
Lung Cancer: Artificial Intelligence, Synergetics, Complex System Analysis, S...
 
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial FreedomMastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
Mastering Wealth: A Path to Financial Freedom
 
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptxANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
ANATOMY OF THE LOWER URINARY TRACT AND MALE [Autosaved] [Autosaved].pptx
 
Prix Galien International 2024 Forum Program
Prix Galien International 2024 Forum ProgramPrix Galien International 2024 Forum Program
Prix Galien International 2024 Forum Program
 
Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptxGauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
Gauri Gawande(9) Constipation Final.pptx
 
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
Young at heart: Cardiovascular health stations to empower healthy lifestyle b...
 
Scientificity and feasibility study of non-invasive central arterial pressure...
Scientificity and feasibility study of non-invasive central arterial pressure...Scientificity and feasibility study of non-invasive central arterial pressure...
Scientificity and feasibility study of non-invasive central arterial pressure...
 

Dose volume histogram

  • 2. • A voxel represents a value on a regular grid in three- dimensional space. • Voxel is a combination of "volume" and "pixel" where pixel is a combination of "picture" and "element"
  • 3. Intro • The display and analysis of dose distribution Displaying dose – Colour scales – Dose banding – Interactivity Dose volume histograms – Types – Calculation and interpretation – Problems and pitfalls
  • 5. Methods of displaying dose • 1. Iso-dose contours Sets of closed contours linking voxels of equal dose • 2. Colour wash The coding of CT and dose in the same voxel through the modulation of both intensity (CT) and colour (dose) • 3. Iso-dose surfaces The shaded surface (pseudo-3d) representation of a particular dose level and selected VOIs
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8. Intro • To form a DVH for any 3D object, one looks at the dose value for each voxel in the object and forms a histogram, counting the number of voxels that receive each different dose level • Because the volume of each voxel is known, the volume of the organ receiving each dose level is known. • Both the volume (vertical) and dose (horizontal) axes can be displayed in absolute terms (as cubic centimeters [cc] or Gray [Gy]) or in relative terms (% volume or % dose), depending on how the planner wants to analyze the results.
  • 9.
  • 10. • DVHs are displayed in : • cumulative, • and differential
  • 11. The differential histogram • The generic form of any histogram, displaying the volume of the organ that receives dose within each dose bin (1% or 0.5 to 1 Gy is a typical dose bin width). • It is useful for display of the dose-to-target volumes, because one can easily visualize the minimum dose, the maximum dose, and the dose most representative of the dose to the entire target volume
  • 12. • This type is necessary in order to appropriately compare DVHs formed with different dose bin sizes, because the volume contained in any dose bin changes as the dose bin size changes. • The differential DVH plots (1/Dbin) *DV/DD, so different differential DVHs can be compared even if their dose bin sizes are different
  • 13.
  • 15. Cumulative DVH • Volumes receiving at least a given dose value are plotted. • The cumulative DVH integrates the direct histogram, so it always begins at 100% (100% of the organ receives at least 0 dose), and ends at the maximum dose
  • 17.
  • 18.
  • 19. Problems and Pitfalls 1. DVHs are insensitive to small ‘hot’ and ‘cold’ spots 2. The shape of a DVH alone can be misleading 3. DVHs can only be calculated for defined VOIs 4. DVHs throw away all spatial information
  • 20. 1) Insensitiveness to small ‘hot’ and ‘cold’ spots Consider comparative DVHs from competing plans • From DVHs, plan 2 appears to be the best …apart from apparently inignificant increase in high dose to posterior fossa • Posterior fossa
  • 21.
  • 22. 2) The shape of a DVH alone can be misleading
  • 23. 3. DVHs can only be calculated for defined VOIs.
  • 24. 4. DVHs throw away all spatial information
  • 25. Visual assessment of dose distributions • The most direct and informative representation of a treatment plan available - however…. • 3-D dose distributions are large and cumbersome and difficult to analyse quantitatively • User interactivity is essential to extract the most information from dose distributions (slice selection/multi slice display, dose banding, dose querying etc).
  • 26. • Provide a succinct and quantitative method of representing 3-d dose within selected VOI’s -however… • DVH’s should only be used in conjunction with careful visual analysis of 3-d dose distributions • In particular, care should be taken when analysing large volumes using DVH’s • DVH’s should always be assessed in conjunction with dose-volume statistics.
  • 27. Assessing and ranking a plan—Dose Based Scoring Possible score functions 1.Visual assessment of the 3-d dose distribution 2. Visual assessment of DVHs 3. Quantitative analysis of dose distributions (conformity index, homogeneity index etc) 4. Quantitative analysis of DVHs (max, min, dose-to-volume etc)