SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Community Based Monitoring of Health Services and related trends of change and improvements in the rural health services in the state of Maharashtra Dr. DhananjayKakde- SATHI , Pune (With Inputs from SATHI team members)
What is community based monitoring of health services?  At the core of CBM is the act of tracking, recording and reporting the state of public health services in villages, as experienced by the people themselves. CBM processes related to NRHM are organised at the village, primary health centre (PHC), block, district and state levels. Regular information collection at the community level in the villages   Processes for regular dialogue between community representatives and health care providers Helps to develop community ownership and accountability of Health services
Levels of committees forFeedback & Action  State Planning & Monitoring Committee District Monitoring & Planning Committee Block Monitoring & Planning Committee PHC Monitoring & Planning Committee Village Health, Water supply, Nutrition and Sanitation Committee
Five Key processes in Community Based Monitoring of Health Services
Tools for community monitoring Monitoring booklet forms Village Health Calendar  Interview format for MO PHC / CHC Actual medicine stock taking at PHC/CHC Format for Exit interview (PHC / CHC) Documentation of testimony of denial of health care
Filling up of the report card and display
Objective positive impact of CBM in improving health services
Practice of PHCs prescribing medicine from private shops has largely stopped Illegal charging and private practice by certain medical officers has now been checked Frequency of visits of ANM and MPWs in villages has led to improved village health services in many villages  Definite improvement in immunisation coverage in many villages Certain sub-centres and mobile units which were not working have now started functioning CBM has contributed to significant improvements in rural health services
Change after six months of monitoring in villages of Velha block, Pune October 2008 April 2009
‘Good’ ratings for village level Health services across 220 villages in Maharashtra over 3 phases
‘Bad’ and ‘Partly satisfactory’ ratings for village level Health services across 220 villages
Increase in people’s OPD utilisation in PHCs covered by CBM
Increase in people’s inpatient utilisation in PHCs covered by CBM
From community based monitoring to planning of health services Key future strategy for planning of health services would be to use information about local issues/ priorities and resources identified during the community monitoring process.
CBM has given us hope that in context of public health system, the positive alternative to dominant trend of privatisation is communitisation of health services Thank you.

More Related Content

What's hot

Census of india 2011
Census of india 2011Census of india 2011
Census of india 2011
Tehsildar
 
National Urban Health Mission
National Urban Health MissionNational Urban Health Mission
National Urban Health Mission
Narasimha B.C
 
Control of diarrheal diseases
Control of diarrheal diseasesControl of diarrheal diseases
Control of diarrheal diseases
Dinusha Sirisena
 
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
nisaiims
 
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
Public Health
 
eVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
eVIN- an Innovation To WelfareeVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
eVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
ITSU - Immunization Technical Support Unit
 
Health system of Bangladesh
Health system of BangladeshHealth system of Bangladesh
Health system of Bangladesh
Rishad Choudhury Robin
 
NFHS 3
NFHS 3NFHS 3
Presentation on migrate labour in punjab
Presentation on migrate labour in punjabPresentation on migrate labour in punjab
Presentation on migrate labour in punjab
micropoint2524
 
New vision for tb control
New vision for tb controlNew vision for tb control
New vision for tb control
prapulla chandra
 
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
meeenamu
 
Demographic profile of nagaland
Demographic profile of nagalandDemographic profile of nagaland
Demographic profile of nagaland
Abhilasha Abhilasha
 
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIAHEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
MAHESWARI JAIKUMAR
 
Urban health mission
Urban health missionUrban health mission
Urban health mission
Subraham Pany
 
Health system in bangladesh for interns
Health system in bangladesh  for internsHealth system in bangladesh  for interns
Health system in bangladesh for interns
Ikarus Isteshan
 
National nutrition mission
National nutrition missionNational nutrition mission
National nutrition mission
Seema Verma
 
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
DrAvnishUpadhyay
 
Significance of biostatistics in public health
Significance of biostatistics in public healthSignificance of biostatistics in public health
Significance of biostatistics in public health
Paramjot Panda
 
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptxPrimary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
ucghimire6
 
National Rural Health Mission
National Rural Health MissionNational Rural Health Mission
National Rural Health Mission
Namita Batra
 

What's hot (20)

Census of india 2011
Census of india 2011Census of india 2011
Census of india 2011
 
National Urban Health Mission
National Urban Health MissionNational Urban Health Mission
National Urban Health Mission
 
Control of diarrheal diseases
Control of diarrheal diseasesControl of diarrheal diseases
Control of diarrheal diseases
 
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
Evidence-based Practice: Knowledge, Attitudes and Practice Among Nurses in AI...
 
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
public health officer Loksewa 2077-10-19 first paper
 
eVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
eVIN- an Innovation To WelfareeVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
eVIN- an Innovation To Welfare
 
Health system of Bangladesh
Health system of BangladeshHealth system of Bangladesh
Health system of Bangladesh
 
NFHS 3
NFHS 3NFHS 3
NFHS 3
 
Presentation on migrate labour in punjab
Presentation on migrate labour in punjabPresentation on migrate labour in punjab
Presentation on migrate labour in punjab
 
New vision for tb control
New vision for tb controlNew vision for tb control
New vision for tb control
 
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
Primary health care outreach clinic and EPI
 
Demographic profile of nagaland
Demographic profile of nagalandDemographic profile of nagaland
Demographic profile of nagaland
 
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIAHEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
HEALTH CARE SERVICES IN INDIA
 
Urban health mission
Urban health missionUrban health mission
Urban health mission
 
Health system in bangladesh for interns
Health system in bangladesh  for internsHealth system in bangladesh  for interns
Health system in bangladesh for interns
 
National nutrition mission
National nutrition missionNational nutrition mission
National nutrition mission
 
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
1 Roles Responsibilites of HWC team.pptx
 
Significance of biostatistics in public health
Significance of biostatistics in public healthSignificance of biostatistics in public health
Significance of biostatistics in public health
 
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptxPrimary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
Primary Health Care in Nepal.pptx
 
National Rural Health Mission
National Rural Health MissionNational Rural Health Mission
National Rural Health Mission
 

Viewers also liked

Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two RiversCommunity Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
Nadia B. Ahmad
 
Community based monitoring
Community based monitoringCommunity based monitoring
Community based monitoring
DrOmRajSingh
 
MIS Project for Organization
MIS Project for OrganizationMIS Project for Organization
MIS Project for Organization
Chaudhuary Nusrat
 
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
ILRI
 
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation 16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
ifadseahub
 
MIS: Project Management Systems
MIS: Project Management SystemsMIS: Project Management Systems
MIS: Project Management Systems
Jonathan Coleman
 
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATIONCONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
Ignesias Tsotetsi
 
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
UNICEF Algérie
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two RiversCommunity Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
Community Based Monitoring in India: A Tale of Two Rivers
 
Community based monitoring
Community based monitoringCommunity based monitoring
Community based monitoring
 
MIS Project for Organization
MIS Project for OrganizationMIS Project for Organization
MIS Project for Organization
 
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
Development and implementation of a community based monitoring and evaluation...
 
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation 16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
16. MIS for Project Monitoring and Evaluation
 
MIS: Project Management Systems
MIS: Project Management SystemsMIS: Project Management Systems
MIS: Project Management Systems
 
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATIONCONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
CONDITION BASED MONITORING PRESENTATION
 
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
CBMS as a tool for promoting equity, PEP-Asia CBMS Network (Philippines).
 

Similar to Community based monitoring as an accountability tool and related trends of change and improvements in the rural health services in the state of Maharashtra.-Dhananjay Kakade

Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
IPHIndia
 
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
IPHIndia
 
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
TaniskhaLokhonary
 
Health System Assessment JRC 2011
Health System Assessment JRC 2011Health System Assessment JRC 2011
Health System Assessment JRC 2011
Isaac Munene Ntwiga,MPH
 
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdfJan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
Ajay Sood
 
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
Jeff Knezovich
 
Mp 1
Mp 1Mp 1
Mp 1
Lord Reza
 
swasthya2014
swasthya2014swasthya2014
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
Mid-Atlantic Telehealth Resource Center
 
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
CORE Group
 
Innovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
Innovation in informal health markets in BangladeshInnovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
Innovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
IDS
 
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
chskenya
 
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
AJHSSR Journal
 
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi governmentayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
TusharBansal425676
 
Essential SERVICES Learning event1
Essential SERVICES Learning event1Essential SERVICES Learning event1
Essential SERVICES Learning event1
Vanshita Sinha
 
Community Health Officer CHO An Overview
Community Health Officer CHO An OverviewCommunity Health Officer CHO An Overview
Community Health Officer CHO An Overview
ijtsrd
 
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
Laura Miller, MPH
 
NRHM in Assam
NRHM in AssamNRHM in Assam
NRHM in Assam
Dr. Ramkesh Prasad
 
Assessment of community utilization of chps services in komenda edina-eguafo...
Assessment of community utilization of chps  services in komenda edina-eguafo...Assessment of community utilization of chps  services in komenda edina-eguafo...
Assessment of community utilization of chps services in komenda edina-eguafo...
Alexander Decker
 
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
IJRES Journal
 

Similar to Community based monitoring as an accountability tool and related trends of change and improvements in the rural health services in the state of Maharashtra.-Dhananjay Kakade (20)

Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
Exploring perceptions and functioning of Rogi Kalyan Samiti in selected distr...
 
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
Impact of functional VHSCs on maternal health and the delivery of antenatal a...
 
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
1.0 Overview of implementation of CPHC.pptx
 
Health System Assessment JRC 2011
Health System Assessment JRC 2011Health System Assessment JRC 2011
Health System Assessment JRC 2011
 
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdfJan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
Jan_Aarogya_Samiti_Web_Compressed.pdf
 
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
Impact of voucher system on access to maternal and child health services in E...
 
Mp 1
Mp 1Mp 1
Mp 1
 
swasthya2014
swasthya2014swasthya2014
swasthya2014
 
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
The Role of Telebehavioral Health Services in an Integrated Behavioral and Pr...
 
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
Evidence of Social Accountability_Geraldine McCrossan_5.7.14
 
Innovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
Innovation in informal health markets in BangladeshInnovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
Innovation in informal health markets in Bangladesh
 
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
Community Health Strategy Implementation Guide 2007
 
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
INHIBITING FACTORS AND SUPPORTING FACTORS IN THE IMPLEMENTATION OF FINANCIAL ...
 
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi governmentayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
ayushmann bharat by Government of India under Modi government
 
Essential SERVICES Learning event1
Essential SERVICES Learning event1Essential SERVICES Learning event1
Essential SERVICES Learning event1
 
Community Health Officer CHO An Overview
Community Health Officer CHO An OverviewCommunity Health Officer CHO An Overview
Community Health Officer CHO An Overview
 
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
UtilizationofPrevenativeMedicalServices_Compliance_BerwynIllinois_LauraEMille...
 
NRHM in Assam
NRHM in AssamNRHM in Assam
NRHM in Assam
 
Assessment of community utilization of chps services in komenda edina-eguafo...
Assessment of community utilization of chps  services in komenda edina-eguafo...Assessment of community utilization of chps  services in komenda edina-eguafo...
Assessment of community utilization of chps services in komenda edina-eguafo...
 
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
The implementation of BPJS health program At public health center martapura i...
 

More from IPHIndia

Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham josephSummary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
IPHIndia
 
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
IPHIndia
 
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
IPHIndia
 
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
IPHIndia
 
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
IPHIndia
 
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
IPHIndia
 
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.PanwarStrengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
IPHIndia
 
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
IPHIndia
 
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
IPHIndia
 
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
IPHIndia
 
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
IPHIndia
 
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
IPHIndia
 
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
IPHIndia
 
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
IPHIndia
 
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
IPHIndia
 
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana NandiA study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
IPHIndia
 
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
IPHIndia
 
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
IPHIndia
 
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
IPHIndia
 
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart CrielKeynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
IPHIndia
 

More from IPHIndia (20)

Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham josephSummary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
Summary of presentation and discussion on four themes-Abraham joseph
 
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
Public Health Policies and Governance Issues Health-NRHM-Selva Kumar.S.
 
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
Determinants of performance of doctors in public health systems of three stat...
 
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
Study of initiatives for addressing shortage of specialists for Emergency Obs...
 
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
Which doctors for primary health care?An assessment of task shifting among pr...
 
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
Equipping missionaries for the mission:Case study of the capacity building in...
 
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.PanwarStrengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
Strengthening support mechanisms for performance improvement of ASHAs-D.S.Panwar
 
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
Status of human resources for health in India -Thamma Rao
 
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
Health system by- Dileep Mavalankar
 
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
Is awareness of DOTS amoung medical practitioners in Mysore a worry ?-Mudassi...
 
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
Low coverage of Janani Suraksha Yojana(Maternal Protection Scheme) among moth...
 
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural South India-evidence from two ...
 
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
The contribution of Accredited Social Health Activist under NRHM in the imple...
 
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
Quality of care in obstetric services in rural south India evidence from two ...
 
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
 
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana NandiA study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
A study to analyse implementation of RSBY in Chhattisgarh - Sulakshana Nandi
 
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
District fund flow under National Rural Health Mission and service delivery: ...
 
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
Patterns of public health expenditure in India: Analysis of state and central...
 
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
A rapid evaluation of the Rajiv Arogyasri Community Health Insurance Scheme, ...
 
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart CrielKeynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
Keynote address: Financing for Universal Coverage - Bart Criel
 

Community based monitoring as an accountability tool and related trends of change and improvements in the rural health services in the state of Maharashtra.-Dhananjay Kakade

  • 1. Community Based Monitoring of Health Services and related trends of change and improvements in the rural health services in the state of Maharashtra Dr. DhananjayKakde- SATHI , Pune (With Inputs from SATHI team members)
  • 2. What is community based monitoring of health services? At the core of CBM is the act of tracking, recording and reporting the state of public health services in villages, as experienced by the people themselves. CBM processes related to NRHM are organised at the village, primary health centre (PHC), block, district and state levels. Regular information collection at the community level in the villages Processes for regular dialogue between community representatives and health care providers Helps to develop community ownership and accountability of Health services
  • 3. Levels of committees forFeedback & Action State Planning & Monitoring Committee District Monitoring & Planning Committee Block Monitoring & Planning Committee PHC Monitoring & Planning Committee Village Health, Water supply, Nutrition and Sanitation Committee
  • 4. Five Key processes in Community Based Monitoring of Health Services
  • 5. Tools for community monitoring Monitoring booklet forms Village Health Calendar Interview format for MO PHC / CHC Actual medicine stock taking at PHC/CHC Format for Exit interview (PHC / CHC) Documentation of testimony of denial of health care
  • 6. Filling up of the report card and display
  • 7. Objective positive impact of CBM in improving health services
  • 8. Practice of PHCs prescribing medicine from private shops has largely stopped Illegal charging and private practice by certain medical officers has now been checked Frequency of visits of ANM and MPWs in villages has led to improved village health services in many villages Definite improvement in immunisation coverage in many villages Certain sub-centres and mobile units which were not working have now started functioning CBM has contributed to significant improvements in rural health services
  • 9. Change after six months of monitoring in villages of Velha block, Pune October 2008 April 2009
  • 10. ‘Good’ ratings for village level Health services across 220 villages in Maharashtra over 3 phases
  • 11. ‘Bad’ and ‘Partly satisfactory’ ratings for village level Health services across 220 villages
  • 12.
  • 13. Increase in people’s OPD utilisation in PHCs covered by CBM
  • 14. Increase in people’s inpatient utilisation in PHCs covered by CBM
  • 15. From community based monitoring to planning of health services Key future strategy for planning of health services would be to use information about local issues/ priorities and resources identified during the community monitoring process.
  • 16. CBM has given us hope that in context of public health system, the positive alternative to dominant trend of privatisation is communitisation of health services Thank you.