Design procedure of an electrohydraulic drive

IJRET: International Journal of Research in Engineering and Technology eISSN: 2319-1163 | pISSN: 2321-7308
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Volume: 04 Issue: 06 | June-2015, Available @ http://www.ijret.org 242
DESIGN PROCEDURE OF AN ELECTROHYDRAULIC DRIVE
Srishti Sharma1
, Ramesh R. Lekurwale2
, Amith Masade3
1
Department of Mechanical Engineering, K. J Somaiya College of Engineering, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
2
Department of Mechanical Engineering, K. J Somaiya College of Engineering, Mumbai, Maharashtra, India
3
Manager, Product & Technology Development Centre, Heavy Engineering, Larsen & Toubro Ltd, Mumbai,
Maharashtra, India
Abstract
Aerodynamicists use wind tunnel to test models as well as for proposed aircraft components and engines. In order to keep these
models fixed in place for testing, ground based equipment is essential. Electrohydraulic drives form the back bone of such type of
mechanism which requires continuous motion for life time operations with controlled motion for start stop and bi-directional
motion mechanisms. Focus of this paper is on systematic approach for optimal designing of a typical electrohydraulic drive that
will provide roll motion to the testing model with emphasis on reliability of the system. This paper further highlights the design,
selection, testing and qualification procedures of different elements of the drive and the electrohydraulic drive assembly as a
whole.
Keywords - Design, Develop, Electrohydraulic roll drive, Spindle.
--------------------------------------------------------------------***------------------------------------------------------------------
1. INTRODUCTION
The modern technology and ever demanding need for the
design of newer means to test models in wind tunnel has led
to significant developments in the area. With the increase in
demand of large appendage deployment and several tracking
mechanisms; the application of electrohydraulic drives has
increased exponentially. Hydraulic servo systems can
generate high forces also exhibit rapid responses, and have a
high power-to-weight ratio compared to other technologies.
On the other hand, they have a significant nonlinear
behavior due to the nonlinear flow/pressure characteristics,
oil compressibility, time varying behavior, nonlinear
transmission effects, flow forces acting on spool and
friction, which is not only largely uncertain but is greatly
influenced by external load disturbances. Hydraulic systems
are mechanically “stiffer”, resulting in higher machine
frame resonant frequencies for a given power, high loop
gain and improved dynamic performance. They also have
the benefit of being self-cooled since the driving fluid
effectively acts as a cooling medium carrying heat away
from the actuator and flow control components [1]. Quality
and reliability aspects are of prime importance at each stage
[2]. Every component whether designed or selected is
checked for various aspects related to the requirement and
chosen such that the complete design is compact and
accurate. The roll drive is very important from aerodynamic
testing point of view as well as to hold the model in correct
and steady position for testing at various roll ranges.
2. PROBLEM DEFINITION
The paper discusses design of a roll drive that would roll at
a specific rate and for a specific roll range by overcoming
the aerodynamic forces and moments acting on the roll
drive. In order to design a roll drive the various mechanical
and electrical devices conceptualized are the sting, pod,
motor/actuators, bearings, feedback devices, hydraulic
cylinders, servo valves, seals, retainers, bolts, etc. Motors,
Bearings, feedback devices, valves, cylinders, seals and
bolts are the standard parts and were studied in depth with
the various classifications and types to choose the best as
per our requirement. There is a five axis manipulator with
Horizontal, Vertical, Yaw, Pitch & Roll motions. The
aerodynamic loads and moments act on the face of the roll
drive and can be seen as below:
Table 1: Aerodynamic Forces and Moments acting on the
Roll drive.
Forces/Moments Symbol Unit
Normal Force Fn N
Axial Force Fa N
Side Force Fs N
Pitching Moment Mp Nm
Yawing Moment My Nm
Rolling Moment Mr Nm
Accuracy of the roll required is ±0.05 degrees or better. The
roll range is of -90⁰ to +90⁰, whereas the roll rate is 0-25
rad/sec at variable rate.
3. DESIGN & DEVELOPMENT
3.1 Motors/Actuators
The very first system required to conceptualize the roll drive
is a motor/actuator. There were three concepts that were
realized to achieve this type of motion namely (a) Direct

_______________________________________________________________________________________
Electric drive (b) Gearbox with Electric Drive (c) Gearbox
with Hydraulic Drive.
(a) Direct Electric Drive: There exist various electric
drives but there are specifically three drives that are
used for aerospace related applications [2] and can be
listed as :
 Brush DC motors
 Brushless DC motors
 Stepper or Servo motors
Based on the comparison between the drives and
advantages of the servo motor for the need of the
application we choose the Servo Motor from make
such as Moog or Rexroth to fulfill the space
requirements, torque and size parameters.
(b) Gearbox with Electric Drive: The limitation with the
direct drive is the bulkiness of the servo motor due to
which a gearbox was conceptualized with a motor of
lesser torque value such as Parker gearbox & motor kit,
or any other to reduce the size of the motor and fulfill
the torque characteristics.
(c) Gearbox with Hydraulic Drive: an alternative for an
electric drive is a hydraulic drive option which is
explored with a planetary helical gearbox. One may
choose Dan Foss hydraulic motor with a Parker
Gearbox to fulfill the functional requirements.
To choose the best available option for the drive a decision
matrix was made on the basis of few engineering parameters
[3] and can be seen as in the table below:
Table 2: Decision Matrix
PARAMETERS
DIRECT
ELECTRI
C DRIVE
ELECTRI
C DRIVE
WITH
GEARBO
X
HYDRAULI
C DRIVE
WITH
GEARBOX
FUNCTIONAL
REQUIREMEN
T
2 2 2
OPERATIONA
L SAFETY
2 2 2
EASE OF
ASSEMBLY/
DISASSEMBL
Y
2 1 0
RELIABLITY 2 2 2
FEASIBLITY 2 2 2
ACCURACY 2 1 1
PROCUREMEN
T
0 1 2
COST 0 1 1
AESTHETICS 2 1 0
WEIGHT 0 1 1
SPACE
REQUIRED
0 1 2
OIL LEAK IN
VACUUM
2 2 0
EMI/EMC 0 0 2
TOTAL 16 17 17
Weightage: 0-Undesirable, 1-Desirable, 2-Most Desirable
Although there is an equal score of option (b) & (c) we
choose the option (c) due to EMI/EMC issues [4] with the
electric motor and the sensors and force balances that will
be attached on the prototype for testing. A Rotary Hydraulic
Actuator which incorporates many quality features including
precision ball bearings to provide shaft support, externally
removable gland for ease of seal replacement and cylinders
honed to a 10 micro inch finish to ensure long seal life
giving the required torque specifications at feasible pressure
values is selected.
3.2 Bearings
The selection of bearings and sizing the model according to
the specifications is of importance in order to balance the
forces and the moments. The classification of bearings can
be seen as below [5]:
Table 3: Characteristics table for choosing Bearings
Bearing
Type
Radia
l Load
Axial
Load
Accuracy
Low
Noise
Low
Frictio
n
Deep
Groove
Ball
Bearing
s
Good
Nor
mal
Normal
Very
Good
Very
Good
Crosse
d Roller
Bearing
s
Very
Good
Very
Good
Good Good
Very
Good
Cylindr
ical
roller
bearing
s
Very
Good
Good Good
Suffi
cient
Good
Taper
Roller
Bearing
s
Very
Good
Very
Good
Sufficien
t
Good Good
Spheric
al
Roller
Bearing
s
Very
Good
Good
Unsuitabl
e
Suffi
cient
Good
From the above table, choosing crossed roller bearings since
it is good with respect to all the parameters and is suitable
for our application. These bearings will be extremely critical
in the application to take the entire thrust load. In the Cross-
Roller Ring, cylindrical rollers are arranged crosswise, with
each roller perpendicular to the adjacent roller, in a 90⁰ V
groove, separated from each other by a spacer retainer. This
design allows just one bearing to receive loads in all

_______________________________________________________________________________________
directions including, radial, axial and moment loads. Since
the Cross-Roller Ring achieves high rigidity despite the
minimum possible dimensions of the inner and outer rings,
it is optimal for applications such as joints and swivelling
units of industrial robots, swivelling tables of machining
centres etc. [6]. Crossed roller bearing was chosen for the
assembly in order to fix one end of the assembly (transfers
the thrust forces to the bottom or to the whole assembly) and
the other end fixed to the spindle such that it is free to rotate
and provide the desired angular motion. To support these
bearings we use radial ball bearings on the other end.
Crossed Roller bearings and radial ball bearings are
preloaded during manufacturing itself, pre-load values for
various rigidity levels are available in catalogue, and no
adjustment is possible during assembly unlike angular
contact bearings.
3.3 Load Calculations & Model Generation
One important standard part extremely critical in the
application because of the high speed, high temperature flow
region is a seal ( to avoid fluid leakage in environment and
from drying the bearings out of lubrication), U-Cup type of
seal has a maximum pressure range up to 40 MPa and would
be suitable for the design. Other non-standard part used is
the flange placed so that all the cables from prototype
sensors and force balances can be taken out from this flange
out to the main console for result evaluation. Standard bolts
selected according to the stress analysis on the assembly.
The assembly was then analyzed for loads & moments
acting on center of axis of the roll drive. Since the forces are
non-coplanar, vector mechanics is used to solve the forces
and moments in the three planes and a resultant used to
calculate the maximum value on the sting. The sting is taken
into consideration and loads and moments applied since it is
the rotating critical member of the assembly. Reactions on
the points where the bearings are placed are calculated using
simple engineering mechanics. Of the three planes yaw &
pitch planes are considered for force calculations, and
making shear force & bending moment diagrams for each
plane [7]. Now the forces and moments on each point on the
two planes are summed up using vector mechanics. With the
shear forces and bending moments now combined at each
point on the spindle, weakest section of the member is taken
and designed for failure.
With the load ratings of the bearings from respective bearing
catalogs, Basic life and Safety factor of the bearings is
calculated for optimum performance of the bearings without
failure during operation. The CAD model was designed
using SEIMENS PLM software NX 7.5. The cross section
of the complete assembly can be seen as below with the
details of the various parts.
Fig 1: Cut sectional view of the Assembly
3.4 Feedback Devices
In order to determine the true position of the output shaft of
the electrohydraulic drive, a position sensor is required.
There are several types of position sensors available and
each has its own merit and demerits [2]. They can be listed
as below:
Table 4: Characteristics table for choosing Position Sensor
Description Resolver Optical
Encoder
Rotary
Potentiomet
er
Accuracy High High Moderate
Reliability Very High High Moderate
Availability All Sizes All Sizes All Sizes
Cost High Moderate low

_______________________________________________________________________________________
Principal selection criteria for selection of Position sensors
are the accuracy requirements. Once the accuracy
requirements are established the type of position sensor is
selected based on ease of operation and cost. Thus, choosing
Absolute encoders with hollow shaft mounting having
number of turns of 24 bits having an SSI interface.
4. HYDRAULIC SERVO SYSTEM
A typical hydraulic servo system will have the following sub
systems and can be named as below:
1) Hydraulic Power Supply
2) Servo Valve
3) Hydraulic Actuator
4) Encoder
5) Servo Controller
From the above mentioned sub systems, hydraulic actuator
and encoder has already been discussed. The block diagram
to explain the system can be seen below:
Fig 2: Block diagram of a position controlled Hydraulic
Servo system
4.1 Servo Valve
There are two most important parameters on which the
selection & sizing of a servo valves [8] depends:
(a) Flow Requirement
 Specified or Desired Actuator Speed
 Limits by Pump flow
(b) Dynamic performance
 Acceleration
 Cycle time
 Accuracy
The electro-hydraulic flow control valve acts as a high gain
electrical to hydraulic transducer, the input to which is an
electrical voltage or current, and the output a variable flow
of oil. The vast majority of flow control servo valves in
existence employ a double flapper nozzle pilot stage and a
single spool boost stage. A stiff feedback spring is generally
used to provide feedback from the boost stage to the pilot.
These types of servo valves tend to be difficult to
manufacture and expensive. A less conventional, less costly
type of flow control servo valve utilizes a two-spool boost
stage and a flapper nozzle pressure control pilot. Because a
feedback wire between the nozzle flapper pilot and the boost
stage is not needed, assembly is simplified [1]. In order to
size a servo valve its flow capacity should be calculated
with the actuator specifications so that it is not oversized or
undersized thereby reducing the system accuracy. An excel
sheet is made on these lines to size the servo valve whose
rated flow is estimated.
The servo valve with the complete system to produce a roll
motion can be seen as in the Simulink model:

_______________________________________________________________________________________
Fig 3: Simulink model of the Electrohydraulic Roll drive
The Simulink model is a design of the servo valve with the
pump, motor and the hydraulic fluid used in the system. A
position sensor or encoder detects the position of the Sting.
A Simulink model prepared using a servo valve with the
specifications from calculations and assumptions is as seen
below: The graph shows the output angles or the motion
profile of the rotary actuator:
Fig 4: Angular displacement of rotary actuator
The above motion profile gives 280º of rotation in the
stipulated time, thus achieving the desired motion. The
hydraulic forces acting on the ports of the servo valve can be
as seen below:
Fig 5: Hydraulic Forces on the valve ports.

_______________________________________________________________________________________
Thus the system operates typically with the desired angular
motion and the forces under permissible value. Therefore
the designed system follows a procedure that can be used to
design various such sub systems in robotic analysis and
research in order to achieve the desired motion.
5. CONCLUSION
1) This paper provides details of the criteria to be studied
during the selection of various standard components to
design an electro hydraulic system with the load
conditions and accuracy requirements.
2) The parameters to be considered for choosing an
electric or hydraulic drive are also summarised and the
block diagram for the complete position control of the
system is listed.
3) The paper includes the mathematical model of the
system in SIMULINK using MATLAB with a servo
valve for the controlled roll motion as well as the
output graphs of the desired angular position.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
We are highly grateful to Prof. Sangeeta Bansode, K.J.
Somaiya College of Engineering and Mr. Arun
Ramchandani & Mr. Mahesh Verma, of HEIC, Larsen &
Toubro Ltd, Powai for giving the opportunity to carry out
our project and we acknowledge their help in reviewing the
Paper. We would like to express our gratitude to other
faculty members of Mechanical Engineering Department of
KJSCE, family and friends for providing academic inputs,
guidance and encouragement throughout this period.
REFERENCES
[1]. Vijaya Sagar Tenali, Simulation of Electro-hydraulic
Servo Actuator, masters diss., National Institute of
Technology, Rourkela, India, 2007.
[2]. Abhishek Kumar, Anoop Kumar Srivastava, K
Prakasha, and N Viswanatha, Design and Development of
an Electromechanical Drive for Spacecraft Mechanisms- A
Systematic Approach, 9th National Symposium and
Exhibition on Aerospace and Related Mechanisms (ARMS
2015), 2015.
[3]. Jose L. Salmerona and Florentin Smarandache,
Redesigning Decision Matrix Method with an
indeterminacy-based inference process, Pablo de Olavide
University at Seville (Spain), 2007.
[4]. B. Archambeault, O.M. Ramahi, C. Brench, EMI/EMC
Computational Modeling Handbook, Second Edition,
Kluwer Academic, 2001
[5]. Xiaofan Xie, Comparison of Bearings --- For the
Bearing Choosing of High-speed Spindle Design, 2003.
[6]. Naoki Yamaguchi, Motion System Design, NB Corp. of
America Hanover Park, III. 2010.
[7]. S. Ramamrutham & R Narayanan, Strength of materials,
Dhanpat Rai, 2008, 160-282.
[8]. Neal Hanson, “Selecting Proportional Valves And High
Response Valves”, Rexroth Bosch Group, 2006.

Design procedure of an electrohydraulic drive

More Related Content

What's hot

Similar to Design procedure of an electrohydraulic drive

More from eSAT Journals

Recently uploaded

Design procedure of an electrohydraulic drive