The document summarizes an energy summit for self storage owners and managers. It provides an agenda for the summit including discussions on:
1) The economic benefits of investing in energy efficiency from an investment and tax perspective.
2) Low interest financing options such as C-PACE financing.
3) A case study of an actual energy proposal and financial analysis for a Connecticut storage facility.
The summit also includes panelists to discuss topics like tax benefits, financing, audits, insurance requirements, utility assistance programs, and a solar case study.
2. Overview
Discuss economic benefits of investing in
energy efficiency measures from both an
investment and a tax perspective.
Discuss low interest financing options.
Review a case study – i.e. take you through an
actual proposal and financial analysis for a CT
storage facility.
3. Introductions
Panelists
• Stephanie Grubb, Cohn Reznick - Investment Considerations and Tax Benefits
• Jessica Bailey, CEFIA Commercial & Industrial Property Assessed
Clean Energy - C-PACE Financing
• Elena Cahill, Globele Energy - Audit Requirements and Benefits
• Nicholas Malagisi, Sperry Van Ness Advisors; Real Estate Benefits
• Scott Hainey, Storage Insurance Brokers - Insurance Requirements
• Tim McGrew, Connecticut Light & Power – CL&P Assistance to Improve
Energy Efficiency
• Christy Bradway, Connecticut Light & Power – Discussion of ZRECs
• Ted Lawrence, Renewable Resources Inc. – Solar Process and Case Study
• Tom Loredo, Renewable Resources Inc. - Panel Moderator
5. “Fuel for Thought”
UN Population Growth Estimate
to 9 Billion by 2040
What will the effect be on:
The Use of Energy?
The Cost of Energy?
The Environment, if
we continue to use
fossil fuel based
energy?
6. World Energy Outlook by 2035
World primary energy demand will increase 36%
China’s demand for energy is rising by 75%
The US is now the second largest energy
consumer behind China
The use of renewable energy will triple
Renewables account for 7% of all energy and will
rise to 14%
7.
8. Electricity Rates
On average, CT electric rates have increased
5% per year, over the last 10 years.
(Source: US Energy Information
Administration)
Currently, the average commercial cost is
between $0.16 - $0.17/kWh in CT
Straight line projection of 5%/year =
$0.27/kWh in 2023
10. How can you conserve energy in a building:
1. Look at your process and learn if you can lean
out the process;
2. Make process equipment more energy
efficient;
3. Look at the building systems and determine if
you can replace any systems with energy
efficient technology;
4. Manage you process and building systems with
technology.
5. An audit or benchmarking will help you
determine the present situation and provide
options for you
11. Next make sure you understand the economics of
conservation.
As you will learn today there are many programs available to
assist with funding for conservation projects.
Understand some monies are incentive monies to do the
project, other programs can help you finance the project,
and yet other benefits are federal tax credits or deductions.
The benefits are cumulative: you may be qualify for incentive
dollars which requires less funding for the projects and
then take the federal tax credit or deduction on your tax
return.
12. Federal programs apply to every state.
Every state and within the sate the utility company
may have their own programs for conservation or
generation.
CT has the energy efficiency fund and CEFIA and now
CPACE
MA has Massachusetts Energy and Utility Assistance,
National Grid has efficiency programs, etc
NY has NYSERDA, Con ED has efficiency
programs, etc
DSIRE website for the benefits in your state
13. Alternative electric and natural gas supply.
Deregulation intended to save money and it can but be
knowledgeable
CT utility companies can change their rates January 1
and July 1 – this year UI will change their rate next in
January 1, 2014 and CLP in July 2013.
Present 24 hr rates- UI -.076 CLP - .078
Make sure the rate can not go up.
Natural Gas utility companies change their rates
monthly on the 1st.
14. You can generate energy through renewable
technologies such as solar, wind, etc
You can generate energy with cleaner technologies
such as fuel cell, co-gen etc
Federal tax credits available for projects through 2016
In CT - CPACE program can potentially fund the
projects, you will learn more later-CPACE is in 27
other states
Cumulative benefits again- CPACE- Fed tax credits,
etc
DSIRE will list renewable programs as well
16. Why Solar Power?
Solar is a clean and renewable
energy source
Every hour, enough sunlight shines on
the earth to meet global energy needs
for an entire year
17. It’s Natural – Just like the Sun
Silicon
Ingot
Virgin
Wafer
Silicon
Array Solar Cell
Modules
21. The Economics of Solar
Avoided Cost of Electricity equals Lower
Operating Expenses
Federal Tax Benefits – ITC and Depreciation
State/Utility Incentives - ZREC
Life of Solar System (25 Year Warranties)
22. Federal Solar Programs
30% Federal Tax Credit through 2016
5-year accelerated depreciation (MACRS)
50% bonus depreciation in 2013
Depreciable base is reduced by 50% of ITC
credit value
23. Project Finance
Direct Purchase – Conventional financing
Capital Lease – 10 year term with $1 Buyout
C-PACE – Property Assessed Lending
24. Solar Project Development Timeline
Month 1 2 3 4
Week 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Stage I II III
B. Physical
A. Agreements
Stage I - Design Plan/Site C. Final Design
Completed Review
Municipal
Permits Utility
D. State
Stage II - Applications Authorization
Application/
Assumes no zoning or Interconnection
variances required
E. System
Installation F. Municipal G. Utility-Net H. State
Stage III - Installation (Assumes good Inspection Meter Install Inspection
weather conditions)
25. Next Steps
Data Collection
12 Month History of Electric Use
Site plan
Blue Prints
Site review and structural analysis
Proposal
Financing Discussion
Preliminary Project Timing
26.
27.
28.
29.
30. Proposed Bill No. 203
AN ACT CONCERNING PROPERTY TAX EXEMPTIONS FOR
RENEWABLE ENERGY SOURCES.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives in General Assembly
convened:
That section 12-81 of the general statutes be amended to exempt from property
tax any Class I renewable energy source installed for the generation of
electricity for commercial and industrial use, and to make such exemption
applicable to assessment years commencing on or after October 1, 2012.
Statement of Purpose:
To encourage the use of renewable energy sources, and to allow the commercial
and industrial sectors to benefit from such sources by expanding current law
that allows the property tax exemption for renewable energy sources only if the
generation of electricity is for residential or farm use.
35. Commercial Business Case Study
Solar Installation
• System Size— 46.08 kW
• Panels— 192 @ 240 watts
• System Production— 51,358 kWh (Year 1)
• Percentage of Electricity Produced by Solar— 98%
• System Degradation— 0.8%/year
• System Mounting— S5 Metal Roof Clips
• System Warranty— 25 year manufacturer’s warranty
41. Agenda
• What drives the Renewable Energy Market
• What is the ITC
• How to finance a renewable energy project
• What are the benefits to you
42. Renewable Energy Market Drivers
• Renewable Portfolio Standards (RPS)
• Financial incentives
̶ Renewable Energy Certificates (RECs), particularly for Solar (SRECs)
̶ Feed-in Tariffs (FIT)
̶ Rebate and grant programs
̶ Federal tax incentives
̶ State tax incentives
• Rising cost of electricity
̶ Driven by fossil fuel prices and growth in demand
̶ Electricity prices (average retail price) vary considerably across the country
• U.S average retail price for electricity is $0.0983/kWh
• California costs are high, ~$0.13/kWh
• New Jersey costs are higher, ~$0.147/kWh
• Rates in Hawaii are among the highest, ~$0.25/kWh
• Source (as of 1/30/2012): http://www.eia.gov/electricity/state/
43. Key Renewable Energy and Solar Terms
PPA – Power Purchase Agreement = Contract for sale of electricity
MW – Mega Watt - Utility Scale Power generation. Powers neighborhoods
kWh – Kilowatt-hour – smaller unit of power output – e.g., a solar panel’s
electrical output
REC or SREC – Renewable Energy Certificate or “credit.” NOT a tax credit.
Represents the green/clean aspect of actual energy that is separately
produced. S in “SREC” means a Solar REC.
EPC – Engineering Procurement and Construction contractor
Off-taker – purchaser or user of the electricity
Host – person or place where a project is physically located (could be the
buyer in a PPA)
COD – Commence Operations Date (aka “Placed in Service”)
44. Key Renewable Energy and Solar Terms
Sponsor – Energy Project developer or project manager
PV – Solar Photovoltaic (PV) technology. Makes electricity directly from
sunlight Light
SPE – a Special Purpose Entity (often an LLC) that plays a specific role in
the renewable energy project such as owning and/or operating it.
ITC – Investment Tax Credit (more on this later)
PTC – Production Tax Credit (more on this later)
Net Metering – Excess electricity is fed into the electrical grid. Project
owner is given a credit on their utility bill to use when the system generates
less electricity than needed.
45. Key Renewable Energy and Solar Terms
Avoided Cost- is the cost the utility would have incurred had it supplied the power itself
or obtained it from another source. It is the price at which an electric utility purchases the
output of a Qualified Facility (QF)
47. T a x D e d u c t i o n v s . Ta x C r e d i t
Tax deductions are a reduction of a taxpayer’s total income that
decreases the taxable income used in calculating the actual tax to be
paid.
What is a deduction worth?
̶ $1 Deduction = $1 x tax rate
̶ Assume 35% tax rate
̶ $1 x 0.35 = 0.35¢ of after tax value
Tax credits reduce dollar for dollar the amount of tax actually owed and
payable to IRS.
What is a tax credit worth?
̶ $1 tax credit = $1 of after tax value
48. Renewable Technology: Solar Electricity
Use of solar equipment (e.g. photo-voltaic (“PV”) or concentrated solar
power) to generate electricity.
Eligible for 30% ITC (or 1603) through December 31, 2016, 10% thereafter.
49. IRC 48 – Energy Investment Tax Credit (ITC)
• ITC is based on the percent of eligible equipment, not on how much
electricity is produced and not on total project cost. Most ITCs are 30%
with some 10% credits depending on technology.
• Unlike production tax credits (PTCs), there is no requirement that
electricity be sold, only that the facility generates
electricity, heating, cooling or lighting or meets other standards per the
tax code.
• One year credit – generally claimed in year placed-in-service (PIS)
̶ End-user of tax credit must be an owner/partner in the deal before
COD/PIS date
̶ 5 year compliance/holding period (like § 47 Historic Rehab Tax
Credits)
̶ Credit vests and recapture period burns off 20% per year for 5
years from date of COD/PIS
50. IRC 48 – Energy Investment Tax Credit (ITC)
• 5 year MACRS depreciation on most technologies (Bonus Depreciation
applies when law allows)
• Basis reduction – Must reduce depreciable tax basis by 50% of the credit
amount
• No governmental or tax exempt use allowed (“use” means ownership or
lease)
• Credits are Allocated by profit/loss ratio (like Historic Rehab Tax Credit)
• May offset Alternative Minimum Tax liability (for tax years starting after
2008)
• Note, the ATRA of 2012 extended the election to claim the section 48
investment tax credit (ITC) rather than the PTC for eligible wind and
other PTC facilities. Not all PTC eligible facilities are allowed this option.
For those that are, the election now applies for projects where
construction begins prior to January 1, 2014. This is a new rule.
51. Ta x E q u i t y C a l c u l a t i o n
$1,000,000 Eligible Cost of Energy Property
x 30% Applicable ITC Rate (sometimes 10%)
$ 300,000 ITC to standalone project
52. Solar Tax Credits: Eligible Property Defined
Equipment that uses solar energy to generate electricity
Constructed/Purchased by the taxpayer
Must be Depreciable or Amortizable (i.e., used in a trade or business)
Acquired by the taxpayer and first used by the taxpayer
– Exception for sale-leasebacks - 90 day rule (Old IRC Section 48(b)(2))
53. Eligible Energy Tax Credit Basis – Solar ITC
Which costs are eligible for the credit?
• Solar panels, mounts, racks, wiring, inverters etc.
• Hard construction costs in general
• Direct and indirect costs of installation
System integration/design/testing
Permits, fees etc.
Interest expense prior to PIS – Subject to Section 266 Election
Developer fee if Reasonable
Other soft costs properly capitalized
54. Eligible Energy Tax Credit Basis
Practical Issue: The extent to which a support system (i.e., “racking”) for
solar qualifies for the credit. Note– roof surfaces do not qualify, unless the
solar panel is also the actual roof; See, PLR 201121005.
• Base for ground-mounted units that have no other uses do qualify
• Parking garage structures which support panels but provide shade?
̶ Portion of roofing repair?
̶ Parking garage/carport cost? What portion?
For Solar Walls – See, PLR 201043023
56. Bonus Depreciation
ATRA Extended Bonus Depreciation
50% - Additional 1 st year depreciation of 50% for qualified property
acquired and placed in service before Jan. 1, 2014 (before Jan. 1, 2015 for
certain longer-lived and transportation property). (Code Sec. 168(k)(2), as
amended by Act Sec. 331(a)).
A conforming change is made to Code Sec. 460(c)(6)(B) (relating to 50%
bonus depreciation not being taken into account as a cost in applying the
percentage of completion method for certain long-term contracts).
Bonus depreciation may be allocated as of the placed in service date, so
planning of Investor entry is important.
57. MACRS Depreciation
• Wind, solar and geothermal are generally classified as five -year
property
• Biomass is typically classified as seven-year property
• Ancillary components such as transmission lines are depreciated over a
longer period, generally not include in tax credit basis.
• MACRS Permanent part of the tax code
Wind/ Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 6
Solar
MACRS 20.00% 32.00% 19.20% 11.52% 11.52% 5.76%
MACRS + 60.00% 16.00% 9.60% 5.76% 5.76% 2.88%
50% bonus
depreciation
59. Why Finance Renewable Energy?
For investors –
Tax incentives:
– Solar - 30% Investment Tax Credit (ITC), and for certain other
technologies, owners can elect Production Tax Credits (PTC) or a 30%
immediate Investment Tax Credit depending on technology.
– Five year tax depreciation (with some exceptions) on the equipment.
Yields can be considerably higher with shorter holding periods than
LIHTC and other tax credit investments.
For owner-operators –
Cash flow from the sale of energy to tenants or utilities under long term
agreements and renewable energy certificates (REC’s)
For energy user or “off-takers” –
Lock in their energy costs for 10-20 years
• Bloomberg Energy estimates the US energy tax credit equity market is at
$7B (source
http://www.cohnreznick.com/sites/default/files/The%20Return%20%E2%8
0%93%20and%20Returns%20%E2%80%93%20of%20Tax%20Equity%20for%20
US%20Renewable%20Projects.pdf)
60. How to Finance Renewable Energy
Property
•Educate Lenders
•Be aware of “At Risk Rules”
62. W h o C a n U s e E n e r g y Ta x C r e d i t s ?
Corporate investors (widely-held corporations)
An estimated 15-20 active investors; expiration of the Sec.1603 grant will
create demand for much more tax equity from investors
Individuals (and closely-held corporations)
There are several rules that may come into play here.
Tax-exempt and government entities
Qualified allocations
– Not eligible for tax credits, but won’t affect other partners if there are
“qualified allocations.” A technical rule.
– Section 168(h) election required for wholly-owned subsidiaries of tax-
exempts
PPA needs to be respected as sales/service contract… or lose / defer
incentives
63. Where can I find more information?
CohnReznick – Renewable Energy
http://www.cohnreznick.com/industries/renewable-energy
Energy Tax Credits – DSIRE
http://www.dsireusa.org/
– Information on federal tax credits and incentives
– Provides links to relevant state websites
Solar Energy Industries Association
http://www.seia.org/
American Wind Energy Association
http://www.awea.org/
64. C o h n R e z n i c k C a n H e l p Yo u
Stephanie Grubb, CPA
Manager
CohnReznick LLP
525 N. Tryon Street
Suite 1000
Charlotte, NC 28202
Main (704) 332-9100
Direct (704) 837-7252
stephanie.grubb@cohnreznick.com
www.cohnreznick.com
www.cohnreznick.com/industries/renewable-energy
65. The LREC/ZREC
PROGRAM
An Opportunity to Develop Behind-The-Meter Renewable
Generation in Connecticut
Christie Bradway
Manager, Renewable Power Contracts
Northeast Utilities
66. Why are People Interested in Renewable
Generation?
Drivers:
• To “Go-Green”
• To reduce, or better predict, spending on energy
Barriers:
• Cost of Systems
• No clear long-term revenue streams to support capital
investments
• Public Act 11-80 created a billion dollar opportunity for
developers and installers of small renewable systems
• CL&P and UI will enter into 15 year contracts to purchase
“RECs” from new small renewable projects
67. What is a REC? = Renewable Energy Certificate
• How is a REC Created?
Each time a renewable generation unit produces, the energy is
considered “renewable”
LREC: Low – emission RECs = e.g Fuel Cells
ZREC: Zero – emission RECs = e.g Solar, Wind, Small Hydro
Each megawatt hour of energy produced = 1 REC
• Why Should You Care About RECs?
• RECs have a value (commodity) and are used by electric companies to
satisfy regulatory requirements (RPS)
68. How Many RECs & How Much Are These RECs Worth?
RECs from Zero Emission units (solar, wind, hydro) may be worth up to $350 each* (cap) :
However, average price of selected medium zrec bids from 2012 = +/- $150 each
Example 1: Residential Home = 5 kW Solar System= 6 RECs/year
Annual Payment = $900.
$150/REC x 6 RECs/year =+/- $900. per year
Total Payment over 15 years = $13,500.
$900 x 15 years = $13,500
Example 2: Commercial Business = 100 kW Solar System = 114 RECs/year
Annual Payment = $17,100.
Total Payment over 15 years = $256,500.
RECs from Low Emission units (Fuel Cells) may be worth up to $200 each* (cap)
However, average price of selected bids from 2012 = +/- $90 each
Example 3: Commercial Business = 400 kW Fuel Cell = 3,154 RECs/year
Annual Payment = $283,860
Total Payment over 15 years = $4,257,900
69. REC Contract directly with
customer
The REC
Utility purchases
purchase is a
excess energy under
separate
existing tariff
transaction
71. LREC & ZREC Eligibility
General Project Eligibility Criteria
• Must be located behind contracting utility distribution meter
• Must not have received funding/grants from Clean Energy Finance Investment
Authority, or its predecessor the CT Clean Energy Fund (other than low cost
financing)
• Projects must be in service on, or after, July 1, 2011
LRECs
• No larger than 2,000 kW
• Must have low emissions
• <0.07 lbs/MWh NOx; <0.10 lbs/MWh CO; 0.02 lb/MWh VOCs, 1 grain per 100
standard cubic feet
• May include fuel cells and other low emission Class I resources, as well as all zero
emission Class I resources
ZRECs
• No larger than 1,000 kW
• Must have zero emissions
• May include solar, hydro and wind
72. Procurement Processes
1) Competitive Solicitation - (RFP)
Project Size Annual Renewable Energy Credit RFP Timeframe and Frequency
Type Budget Price Cap*
Large ≥250 kW to ~$2.13 M Max. $350/REC Annual in April for 6 years
ZRECs 1,000 kW 2013 will be year 2
Medium >100 kW < 250 Approxim Max. $350/REC Annual in April for 6 years
ZRECs kW ately 2013 will be year 2
$2.13 M
LRECs Up to 2,000 $4 M Max. $200/REC Annual in April for 5 years
kW 2013 will be year 2
2) Tariff
Project Size Annual Renewable Energy Credit Price Tariff Availability and
Type Budget Cap Frequency
Small Up to 100 kW ~$2.13 M Weighted Average of the Medium Annually, after the approval of the
ZRECs ZREC price + 10% up to $350/REC RFP and the filing of the medium
- Year 1 Avg = $164.22/REC ZREC rate + 10%
Expect to offer Yr. 2 Q4 2013 or
Q1 2014
74. Final Results of 1st RFP
Category Size # Bids # Average Committed Uncommitted % of Budget 15 Year
Bids Weighted Budget ($M) Budget ($M) Uncommitted Contract
Selected Price/REC Value ($M)
LRECs Up to 2 MW 43 12 $65.94 $3.0 $162K 5% $45.6
Medium 100 – 250 113 47 $149.29 $2.0 $78K 4% $29.8
ZRECs kW
Large 250 – 1,000 140 21 $101.36 $2.1 $145K 7% $30.8
ZRECs kW
Total 296 80 $89.13 $7.0 $386 k 5% $106
• Final Selected Projects weighted average price/REC = $89
1. Average prices were about 1/3 of the cap
• LREC Cap = $200 and Avg. Weighted Price/LREC = $65.94
• ZREC Cap = $350 and Avg. Weighted Price/ZREC = $121.13
2. RFP contracts will result in approximately 27 MW of installed renewable capacity in CT
• LRECs = 5.6 MW – fuel cells
• ZRECs = 21 MW - solar
75. Small ZREC Tariff
• Instead of competitive bidding - projects less than or equal to 100
kW are eligible to enroll in a tariff
• Price takers = $164.22/REC
• Program establishes the price as the average of the selected Medium ZREC
projects +10%
• Schedule - Small ZREC Tariff Program must open 30 days from
approval of Medium ZREC Contracts
• Medium ZREC Contracts approved 11/21/13
• Opened Small ZREC Program 1/8/13 (with PURA approval for extension due to
holidays)
• Initial two-week window closed 1/22/13
76. Small ZREC Tariff
Category Size # Approx. # of Price/REC Available Total Annual 15 Year
Applications Contracts to Budget Value of Contract
Received be awarded ($M) Applications Commitment
Value ($M)
Small 0 – 100 kW 479 200 $164.22 $2.36 $5.6 $35.4
ZREC
• At the close of the Small ZREC 2-week , CL&P received 479 completed Small ZREC Applications, which totaled over $5.6M in requested
Small ZREC funding - more than 138% above CL&P’s available Small ZREC budget of $2.36M for this round of the Small ZREC Program.
• Based on the volume of applications received during the two-week window, CL&P conducted a random selection process of completed
Applications submitted during the 2-week window, which process was observed by a representative of the State of Connecticut Office
of Consumer Counsel (OCC). The random selection process resulted in a numerical rank of all completed Applications received
during the two-week window.
• Based on the queue and available budget, we expect to enter into contracts with approximately 200 applications
• PURA approval of these individual contracts is not required
• PURA approved the Small ZREC Tariff and the price of tariff = $164.22/REC
• Small ZREC Tariff will be open until all available budget has been allocated, or at the time when a new Small ZREC price has been
established for the next year Small ZREC applications.
• Expect this round of the Small ZREC Program will result in an approximately 9 MW additional installed solar in CT
77. Timeline and Next Steps
Action Date Comments
Small ZREC Tariff Service January – July 2013 Execution of ~200 Service Attachments
Attachment Execution
LREC and Medium/Large ZREC RFP – April, 2013 Year 2 RFP to open in April 2013
Year 2 Opening
78. For additional information visit:
Website: CL-P.com, and Click on Renewable
Energy Credits under the “Going Green” tab
Email: LREC.ZREC@NU.COM
UI: www.uinet.com/powerprocurement
Email: LREC.ZREC@uinet.com
79. Energy Efficiency Programs for
Business Customers
Conservation & Load Management
Connecticut Light & Power and
Yankee Gas
80. Energize Connecticut: New
name, same great programs
• Energize Connecticut is the state’s new branding initiative to help
consumers save money and use clean, affordable energy.
• A partnership of the Energy Efficiency Fund, the Clean Energy Finance and
Investment Authority, and local electric and gas utilities
• Energy efficiency is a valuable resource for Connecticut, it:
– Reduces air pollutants and greenhouse gases
– Saves customers money
– Reduces need for more energy generation
– Creates jobs
• Program funding:
– Electric customers pay 3 mills per kilowatt-hour
– Natural gas programs are funded through gas utility bills and approved by the Public
Utilities Regulatory Authority
81. 2013 Program Incentive
Budgets & Caps
Budgets
CL&P C&I $ 35.2 M
YGS $ 2.4 M
CNG $ 2.3 M
SCG $ 2.1 M
Project caps
• CL&P $1,000,000 per federal tax ID
• YGS/CNG/SCG projects with an incentive amount greater
than $100,000 require PURA approval
82. New Construction & Equipment
• Captures electric and natural gas
savings where they are most cost-
effective: during design New Construction
Major Renovation
• Covers up to: Equipment Replacement
– 95% of the incremental
cost of installing Energy
Lighting HVAC
measures in new Efficient
Controls Equipment
construction Lighting
– 75% of the incremental
cost for equipment Building
Refrigeration
Process
replacement projects Envelope Equipment
Gas Boilers VFDs
83. Prescriptive Rebates
• HVAC Unitary • Gas heating
Equipment equipment
• Heat pumps – Condensing boilers
• Infrared heaters – Non-condensing
boilers
• Water heaters – Condensing furnaces
• Food service rebates – Condensing unit
heaters
84. Existing Buildings
• Incentives to replace functioning equipment with
more energy-efficient options
Covers up to: Energy EMS/
• 40% of installed cost efficient
Lighting
Programmable
controls
• 50% of installed cost lighting Thermostats
for comprehensive
projects
Process
VFDs
Equipment
Refrigeration
HVAC Gas Measures
Controls
85. Small Business Energy Advantage
(SBEA)
• Turnkey energy-saving program
• Pay nothing upfront
• Existing business, municipal, and
government customers
• Average 12-month peak demand between 10
kW and 200 kW
• All possible energy efficiency measures
• On-bill, 0% financing to qualifying customers
87. Business & Energy Sustainability
(BES)
• The next level after all or most
major capital improvements
have been completed
• Maximize operational
strategies with existing capital
equipment & people
• Develop management
practices
88. BES Programs
• Retro Commissioning: Optimizes operation of
customer’s facility without installing capital
equipment
• PRIME: Focuses on industrial manufacturing
processes
• Operations & Maintenance: Improves efficiency
through changes and repairs that can be classified
as maintenance or operational procedures
• Training & Outreach
89. Financing
Type Min Max Rate Term Pymt Source
Max
SBEA/ $500 $150,000 0% 4 yrs On-Bill Utility
Muni
C&I $2,000 $1 Million 2.99% or 5 yrs 3rd Party 3rd Party
(1st $100,000 4.99%
w/ subsidy)
PURA $1 1% below 10 yrs 3rd Party 3rd Party
Loan Million rate/no
(>50 kW more than
savings) prime
90. Residential Programs
Home Energy Solutions
HES – Income Eligible
Residential New Construction
Retail Products
Heating & Cooling
91. CL&P Contacts
• New Construction (ECB): Rich Asselin (860) 665-3292
• Retrofit (EO): Glen Eigo (860) 665-5084
• Business & Energy Sustainability: Dave McIntosh (860) 665-3531
• Cool Choice: Dennis Beauregard (860) 665-4758
• Express Lighting Rebates: Dennis Beauregard (860) 665-4758
• Small Business: Randy Vagnini (860) 665-4753
• Financing: Gentiana Darragjati (860) 665-4757
• Residential Programs: Lomont White (860) 665-3790
• Natural Gas Programs: Matt Fox (860) 665-3749
• Your Account Executive
92. UI Contacts
• New Construction (ECB) : Peter Aufdemorte (203) 499-4715
• Retrofit (EO) : Peter Aufdemorte (203) 926-4715
• Cool Choice ( CCH) : Will Riddle (203) 499 -2407
• Express Lighting : Will Riddle (203) 499 -2407
• Your account manager
94. Clean Energy Finance and Investment Authority
C-PACE:
A financing tool for multi-family
95. Property Assessed Clean Energy
▪ An innovative financing structure that enables commercial, industrial, and
multi-family property owners to access financing for qualified energy
upgrades and repay through a benefit assessment on their property tax.
Private capital A senior PACE lien is
provides 100% Repayment through put on the property
upfront, low-cost, property taxes and stays regardless
long-term funding of ownership
96. CRE Owners Face Barriers to Upgrades
REFERENCES
EE Indicator – NA 2010, Johnson Controls and International
Facilities Management Association (IFMA)
97. PACE Addresses Key Barriers
REFERENCES
EE Indicator – NA 2010, Johnson Controls and International
Facilities Management Association (IFMA)
98. Why C-PACE
▪ Zero up-front cash investment
▪ Immediate positive cash flow
▪ Long-term financing (up to 20 years) and low interest
rates
▪ PACE assessment stays with the property upon sale
▪ Ability to pass payments through to tenants
▪ Higher rents and greater long-term property value
because of energy efficiency
▪ Preservation of borrowing capacity through off-balance–
sheet financing
99.
100. Connecticut Special Session
Public Act 12-2 (June 2012)
▪ Commercial, industrial & multi-family property
▪ Requires the consent of the existing mortgage lender
▪ Requires SIR>1; permanently affixed
▪ Enables municipalities to opt-in
▪ Enables CEFIA to administer a statewide program
101. CEFIA’s Role in C-PACE
• Publish Guidelines November 2012
Design • Onboard Municipalities
Program • Website launched (www.c-pace.com)
• Technical Underwriting
Administer • Marketing & Outreach
Program • Work with Existing Mortgage Lenders
Attract • Qualify Capital Providers
• Offer Credit Enhancement tools (as needed)
Private • Provide capital (as needed)
Capital • Develop warehouse / bonding authority (Q2 2013)
102. CEFIA’s Role in C-PACE
• Publish Guidelines November 2012
Design • Onboard Municipalities
Program • Website launched (www.c-pace.com)
• Technical Underwriting
Administer • Marketing & Outreach
Program • Work with Existing Mortgage Lenders
Attract • Qualify Capital Providers
• Offer Credit Enhancement tools (as needed)
Private • Provide capital (as needed)
Capital • Develop warehouse / bonding authority (Q2 2013)
103. Municipalities Opted into C-PACE
▪ Beacon Falls ▪ Simsbury
▪ Bridgeport ▪ Southbury
▪ Durham ▪ Stamford Hartford
▪ Hartford ▪ Stratford West Hartford
Bridgeport
▪ Middletown ▪ West Hartford
Norwalk
Simsbury
Stamford
▪ Norwalk Stratford
▪ Westport Southbury
▪ Old Saybrook
▪ Wilton
▪ Putnam
▪ Windham
Coming Soon: Cheshire, Clinton, East Granby, East Hartford, Fairfield, Hamden,
Manchester, Meriden, New Haven, Plymouth, Torrington, Waterbury, Wethersfield
104. C-PACE Opportunities in Connecticut
Hartford
West Hartford
Bridgeport
Norwalk
Simsbury
Stamford
Stratford
Southbury
105. Customers Apply Into C-PACE
Hartford
West Hartford
Bridgeport
Norwalk
Simsbury
Stamford
Stratford
Southbury
106. CEFIA’s Role in C-PACE
• Publish Guidelines November 2012
Design • Onboard Municipalities
Program • Website launched (www.c-pace.com)
• Technical Underwriting
Administer • Marketing & Outreach
Program • Work with Existing Mortgage Lenders
Attract • Qualify Capital Providers
• Offer Credit Enhancement tools (as needed)
Private • Provide capital (as needed)
Capital • Develop warehouse / bonding authority (Q2 2013)
107. C-PACE Partners do Technical Underwriting
Technical Expertise:
Celtic Energy
• Glastonbury, CT
• $1bn of energy-related projects Hartford
Program Expertise: • Experience with large commercial Real Estate Expertise: West Hartford
end-users, utilities, and government Bridgeport
Buonicore Partners Sustainable Real Norwalk
Simsbury
• Milford, CT Estate Solutions Stamford
Stratford
• Modeled Energy Profile of CT
• Trumbull, CT Southbury
• Nationwide PACE experience
• Benchmarking Database
• Industry leader in building energy
performance assessment
3rd Party
Administrator:
Buonicore
Partners
108. Upgrades: What’s Eligible
Anything that saves energy from baseline … as long as it isn’t going anywhere
▪ High efficiency lighting ▪ Combustion and burner upgrades
▪ HVAC upgrades Hartford
▪ Fuel switching West Hartford
▪ New automated building and HVAC Bridgeport
controls ▪ Water conservation Norwalk
Simsbury
▪ Variable speed drives (VSDs) on motors ▪ Heat recovery and steam trapsStamford
Stratford
fans and pumps
▪ Building enclosure/envelope Southbury
▪ High efficiency chillers, boilers, and
furnaces improvements
▪ High efficiency hot water heating ▪ BMS
systems ▪ Renewable energy systems
109. Upgrades: What’s Not
▪ Appliances, e.g., refrigerators, ▪ Any measure that is easily
dishwashers, etc. removed/not permanently
▪ Plug load devices installed
Hartford
▪ Vending machine controls ▪ Any measure that does not West Hartford
result
in improved energy efficiencyBridgeport
▪ Any package of measures with a Norwalk
Simsbury
weighted average effective useful life ▪ Extending natural gas lines to the
Stamford
Stratford
(EUL) that does not meet or exceed property line to enable a PACE-Southbury
the life of the loan eligible gas conversion project.
▪ Any package of measures that does
not achieve an energy savings (over
the life of the loan) to [total project]
investment ratio > 1
110. CEFIA’s Role in C-PACE
• Publish Guidelines November 2012
Design • Onboard Municipalities
Program • Website launched (www.c-pace.com)
• Technical Underwriting
Administer • Marketing & Outreach
Program • Work with Existing Mortgage Lenders
Attract • Qualify Capital Providers
• Offer Credit Enhancement tools (as needed)
Private • Provide capital (as needed)
Capital • Develop warehouse / bonding authority (Q2 2013)
111. Capital Partners
Qualified Capital Providers
▪ CEFIA qualified 8 capital providers
through a RFI.
▪ “Lending tree” model Hartford
West Hartford
Owner Arranged Financing Bridgeport
Norwalk
▪ Property owner is free to choose Simsbury
Stamford
their capital provider from the Stratford
private market. There is no Southbury
government financing required.
Construction and Term Financing from
CEFIA
▪ CEFIA authorized $20M short term
facility for construction and term
financing.
112. Requirements
▪ Building must be commercial, industrial, or multifamily
▪ Non-profits eligible if municipality allows
▪ Building must be located in a municipality which has
opted in
▪ Feasibility study required for renewables
▪ Mortgage lender must consent
113. Application Review: Two Paths
▪ Full Assessment – Whole Building Analysis
– Begin with a Level I screening step (by CRE owners consultant),
designed to cost effectively identify projects with compelling
savings & ROI
– Proceed to Level II/III audit when significant savings potential
exists. Determine the optimized bundle of ECMs, calculate
project cost, projected energy savings & key financial metrics
▪ Fast Track
– Designed for buildings where prior energy audits have been
completed including ECM recommendations, but failed to get
implemented due to owner inability to self-fund the project
– Less technically complex projects (single ECM)
– Pre-approved projects under utility EE incentive/rebate programs
114. Application Review: Technical Standards
▪ Developed in light of other PACE and leading CRE energy
retrofit finance programs around the country
▪ Incorporates three established industry protocols
– ASTM Building Energy Performance Assessment (BEPA) Standard
E2797-11 for baseline energy use data collection and analysis
– ASHRAE Level 1, 2, 3 Energy Audit Guidelines to identify ECMs
and project energy savings
– International Performance Measurement & Verification Protocol
(IPMVP) for energy savings measurement and verification
▪ Underwriting methodology is technically sound,
standardized, reliable & fully-transparent
115. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Assessment & C-PACE
Conduit
$ Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
Agreement $ $
Town Tax
CEFIA $$$ Collector
Lien
Town Land
“M&V” Records
116. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Property Audit/
Energy Assessment
$ $
$ $
$$$
117. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Notification &
Consent
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
$ $
$ $
$$$
118. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Notification &
Consent
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Technical
$ $
Review
$ $
Program
CEFIA $$$
Administrator
119. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
$ $
$ $
CEFIA
120. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Assessment & C-PACE
$ Services Contract
$
$ $
CEFIA
121. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Conduit
$
Agreement
$
$ $
CEFIA
123. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Conduit Assessment & C-PACE
$
Agreement Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
$ $
CEFIA Caveat
Town Land
Records
124. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Equipment &
Services
Financial Conduit Assessment & C-PACE
$
Agreement Services Contract Property/ECMs
$
CEFIA Caveat
Town Land
Records
125. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Conduit Assessment & C-PACE
$
Agreement Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
$ $
CEFIA LIEN
Town Land
Records
126. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Conduit Assessment & C-PACE
$
Agreement Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
$ $
Town Tax
CEFIA LIEN
Collector
Town Land
Records
127. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification
Agreement & Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Conduit Assessment & C-PACE
$
Agreement Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
$ $
Town Tax
CEFIA $$$ LIEN
Collector
Town Land
Records
128. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification
Agreement & Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Assessment & C-PACE
Conduit
$$ Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
Agreement $$ $
Town Tax
CEFIA $$$ LIEN
Collector
Town Land
Records
129. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Mortgage Holder
Funding Notification &
Agreement Consent
C-Pace Capital
Provider
$$$ Property Owner $$$ Contractor
Financial Assessment & C-PACE
Conduit
$ Services Contract
$ Property/ECMs
Agreement $ $
Town Tax
CEFIA $$$ Collector
Lien
Town Land
“M&V” Records
130. Funding: Capital Flow Process
Recap:
▪ Audit
▪ Notification to Mortgage Holder / Consent
▪ Project Review by Program Administrator
▪ Referral out to Qualified Capital Providers
▪ Capital Provider Selected by Owner
▪ Negotiations Funding Agreement
▪ Assessment & C-PACE Services Agreement & Financial Conduit Agreement (CEFIA – Owner
– Cap Provider)
▪ Caveat on the Property (CEFIA – Town/City)
▪ Funding Disbursement(s) & Project Work Commences
▪ Project Completion
▪ Finalization of the Lien on the Property, Payment Schedule, etc.
▪ Owner Enjoys More Efficient Building & Repays Funding via Tax Bill 130
131. M&V: Data Management Platform
▪ Full Assessment & Fast Track project data are entered & tracked in CEFIA’s Data
Management Platform (CDMP)
CDMP is powered by SRS’s cloud-
based software platform
CDMP facilitates key project data &
analytics management across the
entire project life cycle (project
development through M&V)
132. Benefits to Other Stakeholders
Capital Providers Mortgage Lenders Municipalities
• Low risk investment • Improves Building • Creates economicHartford
opportunity Financials/Risk developmentWestjobs
& Hartford
Bridgeport
• Senior lien • Lowers OPEX Norwalk
Simsbury
• Secure repayment • SIR>1 • Reduces energy costs
Stamford
mechanism (taxes) • No acceleration for businesses Stratford
Southbury
• Legal and technical • Creates a more • Reduces pollution
structure administered attractive building for
by CEFIA occupants and owners
• Finances deferred
maintenance needs
133. The Customer (Building Owner):
PACE Addresses Key Barriers
Near term plan to sell? Tax obligation fixed to property Hartford
West Hartford
Bridgeport
Lack of funding? 100% upfront, 20 year financing Norwalk
Simsbury
Stamford
Cannot assume more debt? PACE assessments qualify as OPEX Stratford
Southbury
Insufficient payback/ROI? Positive cash flow in year 1
Split incentives? Assessment/savings pass to tenants
Uncertain savings/technical expertise? Technical underwriting / SIR>1
134. PACE Project Example
$1,500,000 add to Building Value (8.9%)
30 Year Old,
200,000 ft2
commercial
building
134
135. Jessica Bailey, Director C-PACE
Clean Energy Finance and Investment Authority
860.257.2888
jessica.bailey@ctcleanenergy.com
www.c-pace.com
These should be a refresher of terms and acronyms….Note PPA, SPE ITC and PTC will be covered soon
These should be a refresher of terms and acronyms….Note PPA, SPE ITC and PTC will be covered soon
These should be a refresher of terms and acronyms….Note PPA, SPE ITC and PTC will be covered soon
Many ways to incentivize investments in renewable energy and energy efficiency, such as a direct cash payments. Feed In Tariffs have been used in Canada, Germany and Spain for solar.America differs from other nations in the manner it implements its federal energy policy through the income tax code. TIME CHECK = 12:10 pm (10 mins in)
Recap of the various technologies that are typically financedSolar PVis probably the most common renewable energy technology financed today.
Recent section 167 PPA PLR ???????
TIME CHECK = 1:40 pm (100 minutes in)
TIME CHECK = 12:20 pm (20 mins in)
1st Bullet THEN…Will supply match demand? Not likely in the near future….
Whole Building Approach up to $3 per square foot.Incremental cost = Cost for Code (or Standard design) - Cost of proposed
Rebates on table in back of room
Up to 35% of installed cost of standard lightingUp to 40% of installed cost of high performance lighting (LED & induction)Up to 40% of installed cost of non lighting measuresComprehensive initiative – lesser of:Up to 50% of installed cost, orEnergy savings up to $0.50/kWh or $1500/kW
Energy dashboardsToolkits to manage & operate specific facilities
Services and incentives to create a more comfortable, affordable home.
Audit
Notification to Mortgage Holder / Consent
Referral then Capital Provider selected then Negotiations Funding Agreement
Disclosure mattersFunding is paid through an assessment levied on propertyFinancing particularsPrincipalInterestOther costsProcess for collectionRemedies for non-paymentCredit Enhancement (if applicable)M&VProgram compliance
Disclosure mattersFunding is paid through an assessment levied on propertyFinancing particularsPrincipalInterestOther costsProcess for collectionRemedies for non-paymentCredit Enhancement (if applicable)M&VProgram compliance
Funding Disbursement(s) & Project Work Commences
Project Completion, Finalization of the Lien on the Property, Payment Schedule, etc.