SlideShare a Scribd company logo
COMPARISON ESSAY

Hunchback of Notre Dame is an epic-animated Disney film which was produced
during the Disney Renaissance or specifically dated, 1996. The sequel was later
produced in 2002 as Hunchback of Notre Dame II with all the cast in the first movie
brought back, except for the villain who had died in the first movie, and a few extra
characters. Though both film are in the same settings and are related to one another,
there are some amount of changes from the movie such as the characters,
animation and also the soundtrack. Both film have received different reception from
reviews and audiences.

Despite how the story are in the same settings, the personality of the characters
have changed. In the first movie, Quasimodo, the main character, was a curious man
who seeks to know what the outside world is like. He was also a naïve, young man
who would only obey his master, Judge Frollo and fears him. In the movie, he also
shown to be rejected by the people of Paris and he himself fears the citizen of Paris.
However, in the sequel, Quasimodo was no longer curious about Paris as he have
walked Paris in day and night without the fear of being laugh at by the people. He
also no longer needed to obey anyone now that his master was gone. The citizen of
Paris accepted Quasimodo and liked him after he helped the citizen to overthrow the
cruel minister of Justice. Due to how Quasimodo was more accepted and less fear to
the outside world. There are less conflict in the sequel, making it’s story very much
weaker than the original story. The villains are also weak in the sequel in terms of
power and also the personality. The villain of the first movie, Judge Claude Frollowas
a minister of Justice and could easily burn down Paris for the sake of one gypsy
whom he loved. The citizen of Paris fear his power and the gypsies would tremble
just to hear his name. However, Sarousch was simply an evil-magician who plan to
steal a gigantic bell, Le Fidele. He was easily intimidated by Phoebus, a city guard,
and would put the blame on his one and only servant. To make Judge Claude Frollo
laugh, no one fears Sarousch except his servant. The difference in strength of
characters creates a difference in the quality of storyline of the movie.

The animation of the series degraded on ridiculous levels. The first movie is detailed
not only the movement of each characters but also the detail of the statues, bells,
etc. The texture of the background was painted and is beautifully presented. The
theme of series differs accordingly to their script. For example the festival scene
where everyone gather around and compare who was the ugliest of all. You can feel
the how cheerful with bits of confetti constantly falling from everywhere and the
crowd dancing. Hunchback of Notre Dame II, however, are lack of details in nearly
everything. Everything looks simplistic and slightly better than any cartoon seen on
television. The drawings or animation do not create any feeling or power to make the
audience understand what the character feels such as the scene where characters
singing “Le Jour D’Amour” which is another festival for lovers. No one was there
except for the few people who would dance with the song as if those people were
hired to dance at the outside of Notre Dame and then go back home instead of an
actual festival. There are also nothing else such as confetti or pennant flags
(although the first part of the scene shows Quasimodo hanging it in the street but I
suppose it’s not enough to tie around Notre Dame)
What is Hunchback of Notre Dame if not the soundtrack of the film? The soundtrack
of both movie are scripted so that story and the feelings of the character are
expressed in a musical manner. However, Hunchback of Notre Dame did it right
while the sequel did it worse. In the first movie, the good voice acting in every
characters are mixed with an orchestra and choir performed behind creating an epic
mixture. This mixture enhance the feelings the character were expressing in the
movie. One of the famous example is “Hellfire” sang by Judge Claude Frollo
expressing his love about a gypsy yet feels guilty and sinned for loving her because
of his prejudice against gypsies. The scream of Frollo shows his frustration for his
love towards her while the choir screams his inner thought, showing his real feelings
screaming “Mea Culpa!!” The movie uses this mixture a lot as the film continues till
the end to create the most epic soundtrack. Unfortunately, the composer changed for
the Hunchback of Notre Dame II and so did the entire feel for the soundtrack. What’s
left is the good voice actor from the first movie but the mixture changed entirely. The
choir are taken away and the orchestra performance were simplified to an obvious
way. So the entire soundtrack have absolute no depth and whatever that is heard will
be just that, no further analysis.

To conclude the comparison, I certainly hope there will be either improvement or
cancellation of the series. It’s better to let a good movie end with what it is than to
forcefully continue and making a mess out of it. My advice applies not only to
Hunchback of Notre Dame but also to any other movie sequels.
Comparison essay

More Related Content

What's hot

Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace
Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace
Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace NiyatiVyas
 
History of Comedy Films
History of Comedy FilmsHistory of Comedy Films
History of Comedy Filmstyler_beever
 
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis 'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis tomOD222
 
Media summer work
Media summer workMedia summer work
Media summer workbwinter3543
 
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaboration
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, CollaborationBaz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaboration
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaborationtashaxgs
 
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productions
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productionsApply narrative to one of your coursework productions
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productionsSianLynes
 
LOVEFIELD analysis
LOVEFIELD analysisLOVEFIELD analysis
LOVEFIELD analysisDylanRHayes1
 
Romeo n Juliet---Romeo character
Romeo n  Juliet---Romeo characterRomeo n  Juliet---Romeo character
Romeo n Juliet---Romeo characterHifza Kiyani
 
Different titles
Different titlesDifferent titles
Different titlest1995
 
Different titles
Different titlesDifferent titles
Different titlest1995
 
As media evaluation updated!
As media evaluation updated!As media evaluation updated!
As media evaluation updated!aj0
 

What's hot (20)

Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace
Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace
Chief Characteristics Of Comedy Of Menace
 
History of Comedy Films
History of Comedy FilmsHistory of Comedy Films
History of Comedy Films
 
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis 'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis
'Against the Moon' Noir and Post-Punk Analysis
 
Media summer work
Media summer workMedia summer work
Media summer work
 
Radio dramas 2
Radio dramas 2Radio dramas 2
Radio dramas 2
 
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaboration
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, CollaborationBaz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaboration
Baz luhrmann – Style, Themes, Collaboration
 
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productions
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productionsApply narrative to one of your coursework productions
Apply narrative to one of your coursework productions
 
Welcome
WelcomeWelcome
Welcome
 
Romeo and Juliet
Romeo and JulietRomeo and Juliet
Romeo and Juliet
 
LOVEFIELD analysis
LOVEFIELD analysisLOVEFIELD analysis
LOVEFIELD analysis
 
Romeo + Juliet
Romeo + JulietRomeo + Juliet
Romeo + Juliet
 
Openings
OpeningsOpenings
Openings
 
Romeo n Juliet---Romeo character
Romeo n  Juliet---Romeo characterRomeo n  Juliet---Romeo character
Romeo n Juliet---Romeo character
 
Opening credit analysis
Opening credit analysisOpening credit analysis
Opening credit analysis
 
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
 
Q1
Q1Q1
Q1
 
Dreamland
DreamlandDreamland
Dreamland
 
Different titles
Different titlesDifferent titles
Different titles
 
Different titles
Different titlesDifferent titles
Different titles
 
As media evaluation updated!
As media evaluation updated!As media evaluation updated!
As media evaluation updated!
 

Similar to Comparison essay (20)

Textual analysis short film
Textual analysis short filmTextual analysis short film
Textual analysis short film
 
Asff 2020
Asff 2020Asff 2020
Asff 2020
 
Film History- M Fritz Lang
Film History- M Fritz LangFilm History- M Fritz Lang
Film History- M Fritz Lang
 
Textual Analysis
Textual AnalysisTextual Analysis
Textual Analysis
 
Movie Essay
Movie EssayMovie Essay
Movie Essay
 
Film Comparisan Task
Film Comparisan Task Film Comparisan Task
Film Comparisan Task
 
FMP Y2: Research
FMP Y2: ResearchFMP Y2: Research
FMP Y2: Research
 
All 4 deconstructions
All 4 deconstructionsAll 4 deconstructions
All 4 deconstructions
 
Moulin Rouge Film Final
Moulin Rouge Film FinalMoulin Rouge Film Final
Moulin Rouge Film Final
 
Scene analysis.Sweeny todd
Scene analysis.Sweeny toddScene analysis.Sweeny todd
Scene analysis.Sweeny todd
 
劉品君' Gallery
劉品君' Gallery劉品君' Gallery
劉品君' Gallery
 
Genre Analysis/Auteur Theory
Genre Analysis/Auteur TheoryGenre Analysis/Auteur Theory
Genre Analysis/Auteur Theory
 
Textual analysis
Textual analysisTextual analysis
Textual analysis
 
Textual analysis
Textual analysisTextual analysis
Textual analysis
 
Film openings
Film openingsFilm openings
Film openings
 
Inspiration for our film
Inspiration for our filmInspiration for our film
Inspiration for our film
 
All 4 deconstructions
All 4 deconstructionsAll 4 deconstructions
All 4 deconstructions
 
Mise En Scene Analysis Essay
Mise En Scene Analysis EssayMise En Scene Analysis Essay
Mise En Scene Analysis Essay
 
Genre
GenreGenre
Genre
 
BOOK REVIEW "THE GREEN MILE"
BOOK REVIEW "THE GREEN MILE"BOOK REVIEW "THE GREEN MILE"
BOOK REVIEW "THE GREEN MILE"
 

More from Arthur Wilson

Pm project-control-compiled
Pm project-control-compiledPm project-control-compiled
Pm project-control-compiledArthur Wilson
 
Law relating-to-payment
Law relating-to-paymentLaw relating-to-payment
Law relating-to-paymentArthur Wilson
 
Vm assignment - presentation slide (1)
Vm   assignment - presentation slide (1)Vm   assignment - presentation slide (1)
Vm assignment - presentation slide (1)Arthur Wilson
 
Vm compiled-edited (print)
Vm compiled-edited (print)Vm compiled-edited (print)
Vm compiled-edited (print)Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017
De assignment-finalized-28112017De assignment-finalized-28112017
De assignment-finalized-28112017Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6De assignment-finalized-28112017 6
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5De assignment-finalized-28112017 5
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4De assignment-finalized-28112017 4
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3De assignment-finalized-28112017 3
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3Arthur Wilson
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2De assignment-finalized-28112017 2
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2Arthur Wilson
 
Research proposal draft v3
Research proposal draft v3Research proposal draft v3
Research proposal draft v3Arthur Wilson
 
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0Arthur Wilson
 
De & be final workshop submission
De & be final workshop submissionDe & be final workshop submission
De & be final workshop submissionArthur Wilson
 

More from Arthur Wilson (20)

Pm group-compileddd
Pm group-compiledddPm group-compileddd
Pm group-compileddd
 
Activity id
Activity idActivity id
Activity id
 
Pm project-control-compiled
Pm project-control-compiledPm project-control-compiled
Pm project-control-compiled
 
Final 2
Final  2Final  2
Final 2
 
Law relating-to-payment
Law relating-to-paymentLaw relating-to-payment
Law relating-to-payment
 
Cl report final
Cl report finalCl report final
Cl report final
 
Vm assignment - presentation slide (1)
Vm   assignment - presentation slide (1)Vm   assignment - presentation slide (1)
Vm assignment - presentation slide (1)
 
Vm compiled-edited (print)
Vm compiled-edited (print)Vm compiled-edited (print)
Vm compiled-edited (print)
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017
De assignment-finalized-28112017De assignment-finalized-28112017
De assignment-finalized-28112017
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6De assignment-finalized-28112017 6
De assignment-finalized-28112017 6
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5De assignment-finalized-28112017 5
De assignment-finalized-28112017 5
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4De assignment-finalized-28112017 4
De assignment-finalized-28112017 4
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3De assignment-finalized-28112017 3
De assignment-finalized-28112017 3
 
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2De assignment-finalized-28112017 2
De assignment-finalized-28112017 2
 
Research proposal draft v3
Research proposal draft v3Research proposal draft v3
Research proposal draft v3
 
Chapter 2 draft v1
Chapter 2 draft v1Chapter 2 draft v1
Chapter 2 draft v1
 
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0
Fm assignment-final-updated v2.0
 
De & be final workshop submission
De & be final workshop submissionDe & be final workshop submission
De & be final workshop submission
 
Community service
Community serviceCommunity service
Community service
 
Excavation
ExcavationExcavation
Excavation
 

Comparison essay

  • 1. COMPARISON ESSAY Hunchback of Notre Dame is an epic-animated Disney film which was produced during the Disney Renaissance or specifically dated, 1996. The sequel was later produced in 2002 as Hunchback of Notre Dame II with all the cast in the first movie brought back, except for the villain who had died in the first movie, and a few extra characters. Though both film are in the same settings and are related to one another, there are some amount of changes from the movie such as the characters, animation and also the soundtrack. Both film have received different reception from reviews and audiences. Despite how the story are in the same settings, the personality of the characters have changed. In the first movie, Quasimodo, the main character, was a curious man who seeks to know what the outside world is like. He was also a naïve, young man who would only obey his master, Judge Frollo and fears him. In the movie, he also shown to be rejected by the people of Paris and he himself fears the citizen of Paris. However, in the sequel, Quasimodo was no longer curious about Paris as he have walked Paris in day and night without the fear of being laugh at by the people. He also no longer needed to obey anyone now that his master was gone. The citizen of Paris accepted Quasimodo and liked him after he helped the citizen to overthrow the cruel minister of Justice. Due to how Quasimodo was more accepted and less fear to the outside world. There are less conflict in the sequel, making it’s story very much weaker than the original story. The villains are also weak in the sequel in terms of power and also the personality. The villain of the first movie, Judge Claude Frollowas
  • 2. a minister of Justice and could easily burn down Paris for the sake of one gypsy whom he loved. The citizen of Paris fear his power and the gypsies would tremble just to hear his name. However, Sarousch was simply an evil-magician who plan to steal a gigantic bell, Le Fidele. He was easily intimidated by Phoebus, a city guard, and would put the blame on his one and only servant. To make Judge Claude Frollo laugh, no one fears Sarousch except his servant. The difference in strength of characters creates a difference in the quality of storyline of the movie. The animation of the series degraded on ridiculous levels. The first movie is detailed not only the movement of each characters but also the detail of the statues, bells, etc. The texture of the background was painted and is beautifully presented. The theme of series differs accordingly to their script. For example the festival scene where everyone gather around and compare who was the ugliest of all. You can feel the how cheerful with bits of confetti constantly falling from everywhere and the crowd dancing. Hunchback of Notre Dame II, however, are lack of details in nearly everything. Everything looks simplistic and slightly better than any cartoon seen on television. The drawings or animation do not create any feeling or power to make the audience understand what the character feels such as the scene where characters singing “Le Jour D’Amour” which is another festival for lovers. No one was there except for the few people who would dance with the song as if those people were hired to dance at the outside of Notre Dame and then go back home instead of an actual festival. There are also nothing else such as confetti or pennant flags (although the first part of the scene shows Quasimodo hanging it in the street but I suppose it’s not enough to tie around Notre Dame)
  • 3. What is Hunchback of Notre Dame if not the soundtrack of the film? The soundtrack of both movie are scripted so that story and the feelings of the character are expressed in a musical manner. However, Hunchback of Notre Dame did it right while the sequel did it worse. In the first movie, the good voice acting in every characters are mixed with an orchestra and choir performed behind creating an epic mixture. This mixture enhance the feelings the character were expressing in the movie. One of the famous example is “Hellfire” sang by Judge Claude Frollo expressing his love about a gypsy yet feels guilty and sinned for loving her because of his prejudice against gypsies. The scream of Frollo shows his frustration for his love towards her while the choir screams his inner thought, showing his real feelings screaming “Mea Culpa!!” The movie uses this mixture a lot as the film continues till the end to create the most epic soundtrack. Unfortunately, the composer changed for the Hunchback of Notre Dame II and so did the entire feel for the soundtrack. What’s left is the good voice actor from the first movie but the mixture changed entirely. The choir are taken away and the orchestra performance were simplified to an obvious way. So the entire soundtrack have absolute no depth and whatever that is heard will be just that, no further analysis. To conclude the comparison, I certainly hope there will be either improvement or cancellation of the series. It’s better to let a good movie end with what it is than to forcefully continue and making a mess out of it. My advice applies not only to Hunchback of Notre Dame but also to any other movie sequels.