This case study examines the crisis Chobani faced in August 2013 when customers reported bulging and fizzing yogurt along with flu-like symptoms from a contaminated batch made in their Idaho plant. Chobani reacted by using their company blog as the primary communication channel, voluntarily withdrawing products from retail stores and working with the FDA. While retailers supported Chobani's messaging, media attention grew from informing the public to gathering FDA comments. Questions are raised about how Chobani could have avoided early criticism, their use of social media, how competitors could capitalize, and whether consumers would continue purchasing Chobani.