This case report describes a 19-year-old male who presented with chest pain and was found to have ST elevations on EKG suggestive of a heart attack. He received thrombolytics which normalized his EKG. Further testing showed normal coronary arteries and features of myocarditis on cardiac MRI. This is a unique case because the patient's EKG normalized immediately after thrombolytics, unlike typical cases of myocarditis, yet he was ultimately diagnosed with myocarditis rather than a heart attack. The report discusses the challenges in distinguishing myocarditis from heart attack given similarities in presentation and discusses the rare occurrence of EKG normalization after thrombolytics in myocarditis cases.