SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Banking Sector in Bangladesh:
Moving from
Diagnosis to Action
Fahmida Khatun
Executive Director
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
Dhaka: 8 December 2018
2
Acknowledgement
Team Members
- Fahmida Khatun, Executive Director
- Syed Yusuf Saadat, Research Associate
- Shamila Sarwar, Programme Associate
- Fahmid Tawsif Khan Chowdhury, Research Intern
The report has been prepared with substantive inputs from Dr Shah Md. Ahsan Habib,
Professor, BIBM.
Sincere thanks to Dr Debapriya Bhattacharya, Distinguished Fellow, CPD, Professor
Mustafizur Rahman, Distinguished Fellow, CPD, Dr Khondoker Golam Moazzem,
Research Director, CPD and Mr Towfiqul Islam Khan, Senior Research Fellow, CPD for
their suggestions.
The authors have also benefitted from participants of an expert group consultation.
1. Introduction
4
1.1 Context
• The banking sector of Bangladesh has expanded over the years in
terms of number of formal institutions, higher number of financing
instruments, and bigger volumes of assets.
• However, the sector has been facing a number of serious challenges
due to malpractices, scams and heists.
• These have affected the overall performance of the sector which are
reflected through various efficiency and soundness indicators.
• Repeated concerns have been expressed by relevant stakeholders
regarding the constant deterioration of banking performances and its
potential implications for the sustainability of the sector.
• Given that the financial sector of the country is mainly bank based,
poor health of the banking sector will also impact on economic
growth. Therefore, fixing the problems are critically important.
• While much has been talked about, it is time to act to address the
problems. For the next government, the banking sector should be a
priority for action.
5
1.2 Objectives
As the country prepares for the national elections on 30 December 2018,
CPD felt the need to bring the issues of banking sector performances to
the notice of the political parties. CPD has been continuously flagging
the issue for many years. The broad objective of this study is to revisit
the major challenges in the banking sector during the past decade and
make suggestions to act upon those.
Specific research questions are:
• What has been the performance of the sector across major indicators?
• What policy and institutional measures have been taken to improve
governance in the banking industry and what are their outcomes?
• How conducive the role the central bank is in ensuring sound
governance of the banking system
• Which should be the priority areas for the next government to
overcome the challenges of the banking sector?
The study is mainly based on secondary information. A number of
experts have been consulted in order to understand the dynamics of the
sector and related problems and how to move forward.
2. Performance of the
Banking Sector
• Bangladesh Bank’s Guidelines
on Risk Based Capital
Adequacy (2014) state that
banks in Bangladesh must
maintain a minimum total
capital ratio of 10% (or
Minimum Total Capital plus
Capital Conservation Buffer of
12.5%) by 2019, in line with
BASEL III.
• State-owned commercial banks
(SCBs) have failed to maintain
minimum capital adequacy
requirements since 2013.
• Development finance
institutions (DFIs) are critically
under-capitalised.
7
2.1 Capital Adequacy Status
Figure 1: Capital to Risk Weighted Assets Ratio
Source: Bangladesh Bank
Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Percent
SCB DFI PCB FCB
• Both BASIC Bank and
ICB Islamic Bank are
critically under-
capitalised.
• BASIC Bank has not
recovered from its
massive scam during
2009-2013
• ICB Islamic Bank
inherited a bankrupt
institution from
Oriental Bank, although
all its problems are not
hereditary
8
2.2 Capital Adequacy Problems of
Banks
Figure 2: Capital to Risk Weighted Assets Ratio in BASIC
Bank & ICB Islamic Bank
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
-15.6
-108.5
-11
-115.7
-12
-115.8
-140
-120
-100
-80
-60
-40
-20
0
BASIC Bank Limited ICB Islami Bank
Limited
Percent
2016 2017 2018
• Non-performing loans
(NPL) as a share of total
loans is exceptionally
high in SCBs and DFIs.
• As of June 2018, SCBs
had 28.2% NPL, which is
highest in the last ten
years.
• About 47% non-
performing loans were
concentrated in 5 banks
as of end-June 2018
(BB, 2018).
9
2.3 Non-performing Loans
Figure 3: Non-performing Loans as a Share of Total Loans
Source: Bangladesh Bank
Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Percent
SCB DFI PCB FCB
• Classified loans as a share
of total loans was more
than 10% for 9 banks
during 2016-2018.
• ICB Islamic Bank had
more than 60% and BASIC
Bank had more than 50%
classified loans during
2016-2018.
• The actual percentage of
classified loans would be
higher if loans were not
written off.
10
2.4 Asset Quality of Banks
Figure 4: Classified Loans as a Share of Total Loans
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
0 20 40 60 80 100
Sonali Bank Limited
Janata Bank Limited
Agrani Bank Limited
Rupali Bank Limited
BASIC Bank Limited
Bangladesh Development
Bank Limited
ICB Islami Bank Limited
Bangladesh Commerce
Bank Limited
The Farmers Bank
Limited
Per cent
2016 2017 2018
• During 2016-2018, all
SCBs had expenditure-
income ratios greater
than 0.5.
• This reveals poor
management
effectiveness of these
banks during this
period.
11
2.5 Management of State-Owned
Commercial Banks
Figure 5: Expenditure-Income Ratio of State-Owned
Commercial Banks
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
0 0.5 1 1.5
Sonali Bank Limited
Janata Bank Limited
Agrani Bank Limited
Rupali Bank Limited
BASIC Bank Limited
Bangladesh Development
Bank Limited
2016 2017 2018
• In terms of Return on
Asset (ROA) and Return
on Equity (ROE), the
performance of FCBs,
PCBs, and FCBs
deteriorated.
• As of June 2018, ROA and
ROE of the banking
industry stood 0.3% and
5.3% respectively.
• However, performance of
FCBs and PCBs were much
better as compared to that
of SCBs during 2008-
2017.
12
2.6 Return on Asset & Equity
Figure 6: Return on Asset
Source: Bangladesh Bank
Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Percent
SCB PCB FCB
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Percent
SCB PCB FCB
Figure 7: Return on Equity
• ICB Islamic Bank and
The Farmers Bank have
been making losses in
the last 3 years.
• BASIC Bank, Rupali
Bank, and Agrani Bank
made huge losses in
2016.
• However, losses made
by BASIC Bank alone
was greater than the
losses of all other banks
combined.
13
2.7 Loss Making Banks
Figure 8: Net Profit (in million BDT)
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
228
248
90
19
-998
6889
498
-6709
-405
-540
-6970
-1258
-14930
-271
229
-20000 -10000 0 10000
Agrani Bank Limited
Rupali Bank Limited
BASIC Bank Limited
ICB Islami Bank
Limited
The Farmers Bank
Limited
Million BDT
2016 2017 2018
• A fluctuating Advance-
Deposit Ratio (ADR)
was observed over the
last ten years
• This indicates
inefficiency in liquidity
management of some
banks
• During last few years,
the banking industry
faced more than two
unusual incidences of
both liquidity surpluses
and liquidity shortages
14
2.8 Liquidity Management
Figure 9: Advance-Deposit Ratio of Banks
Source: Bangladesh Bank
Note: Data for 2018 is as of June
78
75
76
78
79
73
73 73
72
74
77
66
68
70
72
74
76
78
80
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017
2018
Percent
• Fourth generation banks such
as The Farmers Bank, NRB
Global Bank, and NRB
Commercial Bank faced
liquidity crisis during 2016-
2017.
• The problem was particularly
acute in the case of The
Farmers Bank, which had to be
bailed out by the government.
• In May 2018, four state-owned
banks and a financial
institution signed share
purchase agreements with The
Farmers Bank to inject BDT 765
crore into the bank (The Daily
Star, 2018).
15
2.9 Liquidity Crisis in Banks
Figure 10: Liquid Assets as a Share of Total Assets
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
-5.4
-0.9
0.6 0.2
-7.3
-17.1
0.4 0.1
2.4
1.8
0.4 0.4
-20.0
-15.0
-10.0
-5.0
0.0
5.0
Mercantile
Bank
Limited
The
Farmers
Bank
Limited
NRB Global
Bank
Limited
NRB
Commercial
Bank
Limited
Percent
2016 2017 2018
• 9 banks consistently
maintained an
interest rate spread
greater than 5%
during 2016-2018
• While some of these
were troubled banks,
others were simply
taking advantage of
lax regulations
16
2.10 Interest Rate Spread
Figure 11: Interest Rate Spread
Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance
Note: Data for 2018 are as of June
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Bangladesh Development Bank
Limited
ICB Islami Bank Limited
Dutch Bangla Bank Limited
BRAC Bank Limited
NRB Global Bank Limited
Standard Chartered Bank
National Bank of Pakistan
Woori Bank
HSBC
Per cent
2016 2017 2018
3. Major Scams,
Irregularities,
& Heists in Banks
18
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/
Institution
Involved
Scam Measures
Sonali, Janata,
NCC,
Mercantile and
Dhaka Bank
(2008 -2011)
Bank loan of BDT 5.89 crores
with forged land documents
(Dhaka Tribune, 28th August,
2013)
On August 1st 2013, the ACC
filed cases against Sonali
Bank, Fahim Attire Limited
and some individuals. (Dhaka
Tribune, 2nd August, 2013)
BASIC Bank
(2009-2013)
Embezzlement of BDT 4,500
crores through fake companies
and dubious accounts.
(The Daily Star, 28th June, 2013)
In September 2015, the ACC
filed 56 cases against 120
people on charge of swindling.
(New Age Bangladesh, 13th
August, 2018)
19
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/ Institution
Involved
Scam Measures
Sonali Bank
(2010-2012)
Hall Mark and some other
businesses embezzled BDT 3,547
crores.
(The Daily Star, 14th August, 2012)
In October 2012, the ACC filed 11
cases against 27 people, including
Hallmark Group Chairman and
Sonali Bank's 20 former and present
officials.
(Dhaka Tribune, 11th July, 2018)
Janata Bank
(2010-2015 &
2013 to present)
Fraudulence by Crescent and
AnonTex involving BDT 10,000
crores.
(Dhaka Tribune, 3rd November,
2018)
On 30th October, 2018, an inquiry
committee, headed by an Executive
Director of BB, submitted a report to
the BB on the scam.
(Dhaka Tribune, 3rd November,
2018)
20
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/ Institution
Involved
Scam Measures
Janata Bank, Prime
Bank, Jamuna
Bank, Shahjalal
Islami Bank Ltd
and Premier Bank
(June 2011-July
2012)
Embezzlement and
laundering of BDT 1,174.46
by Bismillah Group and its
fake sister concerns.
(The Daily Star, 7th
October, 2016)
On November 3, 2013, the ACC
filed 12 cases against 54 people
over the scam.
(The Independent, 11th
September, 2018)
AB Bank
(2013-2014)
Money laundering of BDT
165 crores.
(The Daily Star,12th June,
2018)
On January 25, 2018, the ACC
filed a case against former AB
Bank chairman and officials.
(The Daily Star, 12th March,
2018)
21
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/
Institution
Involved
Scam Measures
NRB
Commercial
Bank
(2013-2016)
Gross irregularities over
disbursing loans of BDT
701 crores.
(New Age Bangladesh, 10th
December, 2017)
On December 29, 2016, the central
bank appointed an observer at the
bank to restore discipline and
corporate governance.
(Dhaka Tribune, 7th December,
2017)
Janata Bank
(2013-16)
Loan scam involving BDT
1,230 crores
(The New Nation, 22nd
October, 2018)
In October 2018, Thermax
requested to reschedule the entire
loan again (previously restructured
in 2015). Janata Bank’s board
endorsed this proposal by Thermax
and sent it to the BB for approval.
(The Daily Star, 21st October, 2018)
22
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/
Institution
Involved
Scam Measures
Farmers Bank
(2013-2017)
Fund embezzlement of
by 11 companies eg: NAR
Sweaters Ltd, Advanced
Development
Technologies etc.
involving BDT 500
crores.
(The Daily Star, 24th
March, 2018)
In January 2018, Farmers Bank was
directed by the BB to conduct a
functional audit on credit accounts
with outstanding amount of at least
BDT 1 crore in its Motijheel branch.
(The Daily Star, 24th March, 2018)
In April 2018, the Anti-Corruption
Commission (ACC) arrested four
accused, including the Farmers Bank's
former Audit Committee chairman.
(The independent, 11th April, 2018)
23
3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists
(contd...)
Bank/
Institution
Involved
Type of Scam Amount Measures
Bangladesh
Bank
(February 5,
2016)
Heist of BDT 679.6 crores by
international cyber hackers
from treasury account of
Bangladesh Bank with the
New York's US Federal
Reserve Bank.
(The Daily Star, 5th August,
2017)
On March 19, 2016, the
government formed a 3-member
investigation committee, headed
by former governor of Central
Bank Dr Farashuddin.
(The Daily Star, 5th August,
2017)
24
3.2 Total Money Lost through Major
Scams, Irregularities, & Heists
Sonali, Janata, NCC, Mercantile & Dhaka Bank BDT 5.89 crore
BASIC Bank BDT 4,500 crore
Sonali Bank BDT 3,547 crore
Janata Bank BDT 10,000 crore
Janata Bank, Prime Bank, Jamuna Bank, Shahjalal
Islami Bank & Premier Bank
BDT 1,174 crore
AB Bank BDT 165 crore
NRB Commercial Bank BDT 701 crore
Janata Bank BDT 1,230 crore
The Farmers Bank BDT 500 crore
Bangladesh Bank BDT 679 crore
TOTAL BDT 22,502 crore
25
3.3 Cost of Major Scams, Irregularities,
& Heists
• 34% of total allocation for education in national
budget of FY2017-18
• 39% of income tax revenue of GoB in FY2017-18
as of May 2018
• 78.2% of Padma Multipurpose Bridge (PMB)
• 64.3% of Padma Bridge Rail Link
• 62.5% of Matarbari 2x600 MW Ultra-Super
Critical Coal-Fired Power Project (MUSCCFPP)
• 40.9% of Deep Sea Port in Sonadia
• 19.9% of 2x1200 MW Ruppur Nuclear Power
Plant (RNPP) Main ProjectSource: Monthly Fiscal Report, Ministry of Finance and CPD (2018): State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2018 (Third Reading)
26
3.4 BDT 22,502 crore would be
enough for
• Total allocation for health in national budget of FY2017-
18 (BDT 20,651 crore)
• Dhaka Mass Rapid Transit Development Project
(DMRTDP) (Cost: BDT 21,985 crore)
• Construction of Single Line Dual Gauge Track from
Dohazari-Ramu-Cox’s Bazar and Ramu to Ghundum near
Myanmar Border (Cost: BDT 18034 crore)
• 2×660 MW Moitree Super Thermal Power Project
(MSTPP) in Rampal (Cost: BDT 16000 crore)
• Construction of Bangabandhu Railway Bridge (Cost: BDT
9,734 crore)
• Construction of Multilane Road Tunnel under River
Karnaphuli (Cost: BDT 8,447 crore)
• Deep Sea Port at Paira (Cost: BDT 3351 crore)
Source: CPD (2018): State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2018 (Third Reading)
4. Cronyism in Banking
28
4.1 Problems of Monopolisation
• When banks transform from being financial
intermediaries to becoming monopolies, they
become a growing cause for concern.
• The monopolisation of banking is usually
accompanied with a deterioration in
governance.
• When financial capital becomes concentrated
into the hands of few, monopolies extract
supernormal profits at the cost of the welfare of
the ordinary population.
• Crony capitalists use banks as vehicles for
reaching their goal of financial oligarchy
29
4.2 Detrimental Amendments of
Banking Company Act
• Two detrimental amendments of dubious
nature have been made to the Banking
Company Act in 2018, which undermined the
cause of good governance.
• The tenure of board of directors was
increased from 6 years to 9 years, and up to 4
family members would be allowed to be on
the Board, instead of the earlier 2 per family.
• These changes are apprehended to reinforce
crony capitalism in a sector of the economy
already impaired by poor governance.
30
4.3 Banking Oligarchies
• In 2017, a single corporation gained control over
7 private commercial banks in Bangladesh (The
Daily Star, 2017).
• Following this development, there were major
changes in the top management of these banks
(New Age, 2017)
• However, monopolization of banking was not
only limited to corporations, but also spread to
business families.
• Despite being cautioned by the central bank in
2014, two private commercial banks still had 4
or more members from the same family in their
Board of Directors, as of 12th January 2018
(CPD, 2018).
5. Do We Need
More Banks?
• Mexico has only 47 commercial
banks even though the GDP of
Mexico in 2016 was about 7.4
times larger than that of
Bangladesh in 2016 and the
total surface area of Mexico is
about 13.2 times larger than
that of Bangladesh (CPD, 2018).
• Globally, if microstates that
have a land area less than 1000
square kilometres are
disregarded, Bangladesh has
the 8th highest geographic
concentration of commercial
bank branches (CPD, 2018).
• In 2016, Bangladesh had 75
branches of commercial banks
per 1000 square kilometres of
land, which was the highest in
the South Asia region (CPD,
2018).
32
5.1 High Concentration of Banks and
Bank Branches in Bangladesh
Figure: Branches of commercial banks per 1,000 square
kilometres in South Asia (2016)
Source: IMF Financial Access Survey Data
Note: * indicates data for 2015
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Bangladesh
Bhutan
India
Nepal
Pakistan
SriLanka*
Numberofcommercialbankbranchesper1000
squarekilometres
33
5.2 Bank Licenses as Gifts
• In 2013, the government approved licenses of 9 new
private commercial banks: Meghna Bank Limited,
Midland Bank Limited, Modhumoti Bank Limited,
NRB Bank Limited, NRB Commercial Bank Limited,
NRB Global Bank Limited, South Bangla Agriculture
and Commerce Bank Limited, The Farmers Bank
Limited, and Union Bank Limited.
• All of these banks were backed by politically
powerful owners.
• License for opening a new commercial bank has, in
fact, become a tool for misappropriation of public
money.
• The fourth generation banks (9 newly approved
commercial banks) are beset with large amounts of
NPLs and are making losses.
34
5.3 Excessive number of banks, yet
attempts to permit more
• According to the Bank Company
(Amendment) Act 2013, the central bank will
decide to grant licenses to new commercial
banks after considering the need for such
banks and the overall state of the economy.
• Ironically, this principle is not followed in
Bangladesh in case of issuing bank license.
• 95% of the bank officials believed that the
fourth generation banks in Bangladesh were
redundant (Nabi, 2016).
6. Measures Taken?
• Recurrent
recapitalization of SCBs by
the government has
emerged as an issue of
grave concern, and the
government has taken
recourse to this measure
on a regular basis.
• It has been estimated that
the GoB has spent BDT
15,705 crore in
recapitalizing the banks
during the period
FY2009-FY2017 (Monthly
Fiscal Frameworks,
Budget Briefs, Finance
Division).
36
6.1 Recapitalisation
Figure: Amount of Recapitalisation (in crore BDT)
Source: Monthly Fiscal Frameworks, Budget Briefs, Finance Division.
0
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
3500
4000
4500
FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17
CroreBDT
37
6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking
Sector
Date Brief Description of Change
2009 Anti-Terrorism Act is passed to address terror financing
(GoB, 2009)
2009 Banking and Financial Institution Division is formed within the
Ministry of Finance, curtailing the authority of Bangladesh Bank
and acting as an obstacle to the monitoring of state-owned
commercial banks (FID, 2010)
2009 ‘Guidelines on Risk Based Capital Adequacy for Banks’ is
introduced by Bangladesh Bank, in line with Basel II
(Bangladesh Bank, 2008)
2011 Whistleblowers' Protection Act 2011 states that no criminal, civil
or departmental proceedings can be initiated against a person for
disclosing information in the public interest to the authorities,
and his or her identity will not be disclosed without his or her
consent. (GoB, 2011)
38
6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking
Sector (contd...)
Date Brief Description of Change
2012 Customer Interest Protection Centre' (CIPC) is established in the
head office and branch offices of Bangladesh Bank
2012 Money Laundering Prevention Act gives Bangladesh Bank
responsibility for money laundering offences (GoB, 2012)
2012 Bangladesh Financial Intelligence Unit (BFIU) is established for
analyzing Suspicious Transaction Reports (STRs), Cash
Transaction Reports (CTRs) & information related to money
laundering (ML) or financing of terrorism (TF) received from
reporting agencies and other sources and disseminating
information/intelligence thereon to relevant law enforcement
agencies. (Bangladesh Bank, 2012)
2012 Financial Integrity and Customer Services Department (FICSD)
department is established in Bangladesh Bank with a view to
minimizing fraud and forgery in the banking industry.
(Bangladesh Bank, 2014)
39
6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking
Sector (contd...)
Date Brief Description of Change
2013 Bank Company Act is amended. More than two members of the
same family are not allowed to be on the board of directors, and
the tenure of the directors is restricted to six years. (GoB, 2013)
2013 Anti-Terrorism Act is amended to make provisions for the
prevention of terrorist activities and ensure effective
punishment for such activities (GoB, 2013)
2014 ‘Guidelines on Risk Based Capital Adequacy for Banks’ is
introduced by Bangladesh Bank, in line with Basel III
(Bangladesh Bank, 2014)
2014 Bangladesh Bank imposes “Regulations on Electronic Fund
Transfer” (Bangladesh Bank, 2014)
2014 Bangladesh Payment And Settlement Systems Regulations is
introduced by Bangladesh Bank (Bangladesh Bank, 2014)
2015 Money Laundering Prevention Act is amended to reenact a law
regarding the prevention of money laundering and other
connected offenses (GoB, 2015)
40
6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking
Sector (contd...)
Date Brief Description of Change
2015 Financial Reporting Act is passed which requires the
establishment of a new oversight body, referred to as the
Financial Reporting Council (FRC), whose main purpose will be
to regulate the financial reporting process followed by the
quoted companies (GoB, 2015)
2015 Bangladesh Bank introduces “Guideline on ICT Security for
Banks and Non-bank Financial Institutions”
(Bangladesh Bank, 2015)
2017 Bangladesh Financial Intelligence Unit (BFIU) issues a master
circular directing banks to identify relevant risks, risk tolerance
level, and readiness to handle the risks associated with new
technology based payment services before launching the
product (Bangladesh Bank, 2017)
41
6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking
Sector (contd...)
Date Brief Description of Change
2017 Code of Conduct for banks and non-bank financial institutions
introduced by Bangladesh Bank to implement National Integrity
Strategy in the financial sector of Bangladesh
(Bangladesh Bank, 2017)
2017 Bangladesh Bank introduces Guidelines on Environmental &
Social Risk Management (ESRM) for Banks and Financial
Institutions in Bangladesh (Bangladesh Bank, 2017)
2018 Bank Company Act is amended allowing increasing the
maximum number of family members on the board of directors
from two to four and extending the tenure of the board of
directors from six to nine years (Dhaka Tribune, 2018)
7. Recommendations
43
7.1 Recommendations
• The number of judges dealing with Money Loan
Court Act 2003 and Bankruptcy Act 1997 should be
increased to ensure speedy disposal of loan default
cases and to reduce backlog.
• Immediate actions must be taken against banks that
are performing poorly and are ill-prepared for
BASEL III.
• A new exit policy for troubled banks needs to be
formulated, particularly taking into cognisance the
ineffectiveness of the Oriental Bank model.
• Recapitalisation of SCBs year after year has to be
stopped. Such practice of bailing out the losing
banks with public money is economically unjustified
and morally incorrect.
44
7.1 Recommendations (contd...)
• The decision to keep 50% government funds with private
banks goes against the spirit of central bank’s monetary policy.
Only banks with less than 5% NPLs should be eligible for the
additional available funds from government entities.
• Bangladesh Bank should appoint a strong administrator
immediately to oversee the operation of troubled banks. A
proper audit of the bank should be performed to understand
the real health of the bank.
• The culture of giving licenses to new banks on political grounds
should be stopped. Given the size of the economy there is no
need for new banks.
• The internal control department of SCBs is in need of a serious
overhaul. During financial scams of the past, it was discovered
that the internal control departments either willingly or
unwillingly had failed to inform the Board of Directors
regarding large losses.
45
7.1 Recommendations (contd...)
• In order to truly bring about a profound change in the
banking sector, the most important emergent task is to
combat cronyism. The current practice of recruiting
Board of Directors on political grounds has to be
discontinued. Only unbiased, competent, and honest
individuals should be appointed as Member of the Board
of SCBs.
• The independence of the central bank should be upheld.
Interference in Bangladesh Bank’s activities goes against
the spirit of Bangladesh Bank Amendment Bill 2003
which was geared to guarantee the central bank with
autonomy.
• Lack of capacity building is a perennial problem that
besets the SCBs in Bangladesh. Without human resource
development through enhanced skills, SCBs will not be
able to handle the emerging challenges facing the sector.
46
7.2 A Commission for the Banking
Sector
• CPD has earlier argued for setting up an
independent commission for the banking sector
in view of addressing emerging challenges.
• The broad terms of reference (ToR) of the
commission will be to critically assess the
problems and weaknesses of the banking
industry.
• Such a commission will suggest concrete
recommendations for prudential banking, and
prepare guidelines regarding management,
automation, risk management, and internal
control.
• The budget should allocate adequate funds for
setting up this commission.
47
7.3 Commitments from Political
Parties during Electoral Debate
I. Recognise the Problem: First and foremost, the challenges of the
banking sector should be recognized. A thorough review of the
state of the banking sector has to be carried out and establish more
transparency on the state of affairs.
II. Autonomy of the Central Bank: Supervisory and monitoring role of
Bangladesh Bank should to be significantly strengthened for
smooth functioning of the sector
III. Blue Ribbon Committee for Appointing Board Members: The
process of appointing board members should be de-politicised. A
highly qualified and experienced committee should be formed to
select board members. The culture of selecting board members
based on the political loyalty and affiliation must change.
IV. No New Banks: Do not give licenses for new commercial banks.
V. Reform of Judicial Process: Trial of scams and irregularities cases
should expedited and exemplary measures should be taken against
the involved people. Speedy recovery of default loans should be
implemented through special tribunal should be set up for bank
defaulters.
THANK YOU
https://cpd.org.bd

More Related Content

What's hot

Banking Industry of Bangladesh
Banking Industry of BangladeshBanking Industry of Bangladesh
Banking Industry of Bangladesh
Md. Emon Patwary
 
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysisNational bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
iqra ishfaq
 
Internship presentation
Internship presentationInternship presentation
Internship presentation
Susmita Sen
 
Retail banking
Retail bankingRetail banking
internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
 internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
Md. Shohel Rana
 
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
Dhaka university
 
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
Md. Mazharul Islam Rana
 
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
International Islamic University Chittagong, Batch 28 A9
 
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking SectorCovid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
DVSResearchFoundatio
 
Currency management
Currency management  Currency management
Currency management
Salman Saedd
 
Monetary Policy in Bangladesh
Monetary Policy in BangladeshMonetary Policy in Bangladesh
Monetary Policy in Bangladesh
Pantho Sarker
 
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
Jeetu Matta
 
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANKFundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
Jeetu Matta
 
Credit appraisal in sbi bank project6 report
Credit appraisal in  sbi bank project6 report Credit appraisal in  sbi bank project6 report
Credit appraisal in sbi bank project6 report
Babasab Patil
 
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
Harsh Bohra
 
Internship report on mbl
Internship report on mblInternship report on mbl
Internship report on mbl
Nazish Sohail LION
 
ABL FULL REPORT
ABL FULL REPORTABL FULL REPORT
ABL FULL REPORT
Sajid Khattak
 
Commercial banks
Commercial banksCommercial banks
Commercial banks
Maksudul Huq Chowdhury
 
Capital Adequacy
Capital AdequacyCapital Adequacy
Capital Adequacy
T A Sairam
 
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bankA study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
Shami Zama
 

What's hot (20)

Banking Industry of Bangladesh
Banking Industry of BangladeshBanking Industry of Bangladesh
Banking Industry of Bangladesh
 
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysisNational bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
National bank of Pakistan (nbp) swot analysis
 
Internship presentation
Internship presentationInternship presentation
Internship presentation
 
Retail banking
Retail bankingRetail banking
Retail banking
 
internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
 internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
internship report on Credit management policy of janata Bank
 
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
Causes of Non-Performing Loan: A Study on State Owned Commercial Bank of Bang...
 
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
Internship Report on Agroni Bank Ltd.
 
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
Emphasize on overall banking activities & analyze the performance over last f...
 
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking SectorCovid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
Covid-19: Impact on the Banking Sector
 
Currency management
Currency management  Currency management
Currency management
 
Monetary Policy in Bangladesh
Monetary Policy in BangladeshMonetary Policy in Bangladesh
Monetary Policy in Bangladesh
 
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL ANALYSIS OF SBI AND BOB
 
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANKFundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
Fundamental analysis of banking sector SBI AND HDFC BANK
 
Credit appraisal in sbi bank project6 report
Credit appraisal in  sbi bank project6 report Credit appraisal in  sbi bank project6 report
Credit appraisal in sbi bank project6 report
 
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
HDFC Bank Financial Analysis & Industry Comparison 2017
 
Internship report on mbl
Internship report on mblInternship report on mbl
Internship report on mbl
 
ABL FULL REPORT
ABL FULL REPORTABL FULL REPORT
ABL FULL REPORT
 
Commercial banks
Commercial banksCommercial banks
Commercial banks
 
Capital Adequacy
Capital AdequacyCapital Adequacy
Capital Adequacy
 
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bankA study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
A study of non performing assets with special reference to icici bank
 

Similar to Banking sector in bangladesh moving from diagnosis to action

Non performing assets
Non performing assetsNon performing assets
Non performing assets
siguram rohith
 
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank TheoryRBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
RBSA Advisors
 
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulationRBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
Korivi Sravan Kumar
 
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
Mohammad Syahrial
 
Economic Capsule - May 2018
Economic Capsule - May 2018Economic Capsule - May 2018
Economic Capsule - May 2018
Commercial Bank of Ceylon PLC
 
Banking industry analysis report
Banking industry analysis reportBanking industry analysis report
Banking industry analysis report
Deepak Kasturi
 
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
ijtsrd
 
Beacon July 2014
Beacon July 2014Beacon July 2014
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptxpresentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
syedrayhan000
 
Bandhan
BandhanBandhan
Bandhan
tdjariwala
 
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
Mohit Kumar
 
Equity research report (1)
Equity research report (1)Equity research report (1)
Equity research report (1)
Nikita Bobhate
 
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final MemoYESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
Pawan Kaul
 
Sme 7 6_2014
Sme 7 6_2014Sme 7 6_2014
Sme 7 6_2014
BFSICM
 
State bank of india
State bank of indiaState bank of india
State bank of india
Jatin Parmar
 
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banksA strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
IAEME Publication
 
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - SampleCommercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
Netscribes, Inc.
 
Financial services banking
Financial services bankingFinancial services banking
Financial services banking
Sourav Mishra
 
Economic Capsule - February 2015
Economic Capsule - February 2015Economic Capsule - February 2015
Economic Capsule - February 2015
Commercial Bank of Ceylon PLC
 
The npa story
The npa storyThe npa story
The npa story
Sanjeev Kumar
 

Similar to Banking sector in bangladesh moving from diagnosis to action (20)

Non performing assets
Non performing assetsNon performing assets
Non performing assets
 
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank TheoryRBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
RBSA Advisors Research Report - The Big Bank Theory
 
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulationRBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
RBL Bank Strategy analysis and formulation
 
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
Indonesia Banking Review (April 2015)
 
Economic Capsule - May 2018
Economic Capsule - May 2018Economic Capsule - May 2018
Economic Capsule - May 2018
 
Banking industry analysis report
Banking industry analysis reportBanking industry analysis report
Banking industry analysis report
 
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
What are the Stimulating Factors Affecting NPL in Banking Sector of Banglades...
 
Beacon July 2014
Beacon July 2014Beacon July 2014
Beacon July 2014
 
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptxpresentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
presentation of Saima binte yusuf of patuakhali.pptx
 
Bandhan
BandhanBandhan
Bandhan
 
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
Weaker Corporate Balance sheet and its implication
 
Equity research report (1)
Equity research report (1)Equity research report (1)
Equity research report (1)
 
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final MemoYESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
YESBAN 2 Mar 2015 Final Memo
 
Sme 7 6_2014
Sme 7 6_2014Sme 7 6_2014
Sme 7 6_2014
 
State bank of india
State bank of indiaState bank of india
State bank of india
 
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banksA strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
A strategy to manage the np as of public sector banks
 
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - SampleCommercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
Commercial banking market in india 2017 - Sample
 
Financial services banking
Financial services bankingFinancial services banking
Financial services banking
 
Economic Capsule - February 2015
Economic Capsule - February 2015Economic Capsule - February 2015
Economic Capsule - February 2015
 
The npa story
The npa storyThe npa story
The npa story
 

More from Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)

CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD Annual Report 2017
CPD Annual Report 2017CPD Annual Report 2017
CPD Annual Report 2017
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD Annual Report 2018
CPD Annual Report 2018CPD Annual Report 2018
CPD Annual Report 2018
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical PerspectiveNational Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
South Asia Access of Electricity
South Asia Access of ElectricitySouth Asia Access of Electricity
South Asia Access of Electricity
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
South asia control of corruption
South asia control of corruptionSouth asia control of corruption
South asia control of corruption
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
South asia gender inequality index
South asia gender inequality indexSouth asia gender inequality index
South asia gender inequality index
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional ArrangementsFinancing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global PartnershipsSDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD)
 

More from Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) (20)

CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD's Budget Analysis FY2021
 
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
CPD Budget Analysis FY2021
 
CPD Annual Report 2017
CPD Annual Report 2017CPD Annual Report 2017
CPD Annual Report 2017
 
CPD Annual Report 2018
CPD Annual Report 2018CPD Annual Report 2018
CPD Annual Report 2018
 
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
CPD Budget Dialogue 2019
 
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical PerspectiveNational Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
National Budget for FY2019-20: An Analytical Perspective
 
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
State of the Bangladesh Economy and the Budget Challenges FY2019-20
 
South Asia Access of Electricity
South Asia Access of ElectricitySouth Asia Access of Electricity
South Asia Access of Electricity
 
South asia control of corruption
South asia control of corruptionSouth asia control of corruption
South asia control of corruption
 
South asia gender inequality index
South asia gender inequality indexSouth asia gender inequality index
South asia gender inequality index
 
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
Reducing Inequality in South Asia: Critical Issues and Policy Choices: Moving...
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
 
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
Fostering Connectivity and Economic Integration in South Asia: Role of Privat...
 
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional ArrangementsFinancing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
Financing Development in South Asia: Avenues and Institutional Arrangements
 
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global PartnershipsSDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
SDG Implementation Challenges in South Asia and Role of Global Partnerships
 
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of CooperationAchieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
Achieving Sustainable Energy for All in South Asia: Modalities of Cooperation
 
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
CPD Dialogue on Analysis of the National Budget FY2016
 
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
Centre for policy dialogue cpd analysis national budget fy2015 16 june 2015
 
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
CPD IRBD FY15 State of Bangladesh Economy June 2015
 

Recently uploaded

Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto RicoAuthentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
Corey Perlman, Social Media Speaker and Consultant
 
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
my Pandit
 
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 SlowdownPart 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
jeffkluth1
 
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM SoftwareHow to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
SalesTown
 
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
AnnySerafinaLove
 
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .pptChapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
ssuser567e2d
 
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and CreationIndustrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Christian Dahlen
 
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdfModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
fisherameliaisabella
 
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social MediaBuilding Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
LuanWise
 
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnapMastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Norma Mushkat Gaffin
 
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
jamalseoexpert1978
 
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media MasterclassRecruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
LuanWise
 
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
Any kyc Account
 
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 20243 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
SEOSMMEARTH
 
Authentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
Authentically Social Presented by Corey PerlmanAuthentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
Authentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
Corey Perlman, Social Media Speaker and Consultant
 
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptxTop mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
JeremyPeirce1
 
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
ecamare2
 
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
Lital Barkan
 
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdfThe 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
thesiliconleaders
 
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
Adam Smith
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto RicoAuthentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
Authentically Social by Corey Perlman - EO Puerto Rico
 
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
Taurus Zodiac Sign: Unveiling the Traits, Dates, and Horoscope Insights of th...
 
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 SlowdownPart 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
Part 2 Deep Dive: Navigating the 2024 Slowdown
 
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM SoftwareHow to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
How to Implement a Real Estate CRM Software
 
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
Anny Serafina Love - Letter of Recommendation by Kellen Harkins, MS.
 
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .pptChapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
Chapter 7 Final business management sciences .ppt
 
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and CreationIndustrial Tech SW:  Category Renewal and Creation
Industrial Tech SW: Category Renewal and Creation
 
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdfModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
ModelingMarketingStrategiesMKS.CollumbiaUniversitypdf
 
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social MediaBuilding Your Employer Brand with Social Media
Building Your Employer Brand with Social Media
 
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnapMastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
Mastering B2B Payments Webinar from BlueSnap
 
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
FIA officials brutally tortured innocent and snatched 200 Bitcoins of worth 4...
 
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media MasterclassRecruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
Recruiting in the Digital Age: A Social Media Masterclass
 
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
An introduction to the cryptocurrency investment platform Binance Savings.
 
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 20243 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
3 Simple Steps To Buy Verified Payoneer Account In 2024
 
Authentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
Authentically Social Presented by Corey PerlmanAuthentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
Authentically Social Presented by Corey Perlman
 
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptxTop mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
Top mailing list providers in the USA.pptx
 
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
Observation Lab PowerPoint Assignment for TEM 431
 
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
LA HUG - Video Testimonials with Chynna Morgan - June 2024
 
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdfThe 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
The 10 Most Influential Leaders Guiding Corporate Evolution, 2024.pdf
 
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
The Influence of Marketing Strategy and Market Competition on Business Perfor...
 

Banking sector in bangladesh moving from diagnosis to action

  • 1. Banking Sector in Bangladesh: Moving from Diagnosis to Action Fahmida Khatun Executive Director Centre for Policy Dialogue (CPD) Dhaka: 8 December 2018
  • 2. 2 Acknowledgement Team Members - Fahmida Khatun, Executive Director - Syed Yusuf Saadat, Research Associate - Shamila Sarwar, Programme Associate - Fahmid Tawsif Khan Chowdhury, Research Intern The report has been prepared with substantive inputs from Dr Shah Md. Ahsan Habib, Professor, BIBM. Sincere thanks to Dr Debapriya Bhattacharya, Distinguished Fellow, CPD, Professor Mustafizur Rahman, Distinguished Fellow, CPD, Dr Khondoker Golam Moazzem, Research Director, CPD and Mr Towfiqul Islam Khan, Senior Research Fellow, CPD for their suggestions. The authors have also benefitted from participants of an expert group consultation.
  • 4. 4 1.1 Context • The banking sector of Bangladesh has expanded over the years in terms of number of formal institutions, higher number of financing instruments, and bigger volumes of assets. • However, the sector has been facing a number of serious challenges due to malpractices, scams and heists. • These have affected the overall performance of the sector which are reflected through various efficiency and soundness indicators. • Repeated concerns have been expressed by relevant stakeholders regarding the constant deterioration of banking performances and its potential implications for the sustainability of the sector. • Given that the financial sector of the country is mainly bank based, poor health of the banking sector will also impact on economic growth. Therefore, fixing the problems are critically important. • While much has been talked about, it is time to act to address the problems. For the next government, the banking sector should be a priority for action.
  • 5. 5 1.2 Objectives As the country prepares for the national elections on 30 December 2018, CPD felt the need to bring the issues of banking sector performances to the notice of the political parties. CPD has been continuously flagging the issue for many years. The broad objective of this study is to revisit the major challenges in the banking sector during the past decade and make suggestions to act upon those. Specific research questions are: • What has been the performance of the sector across major indicators? • What policy and institutional measures have been taken to improve governance in the banking industry and what are their outcomes? • How conducive the role the central bank is in ensuring sound governance of the banking system • Which should be the priority areas for the next government to overcome the challenges of the banking sector? The study is mainly based on secondary information. A number of experts have been consulted in order to understand the dynamics of the sector and related problems and how to move forward.
  • 6. 2. Performance of the Banking Sector
  • 7. • Bangladesh Bank’s Guidelines on Risk Based Capital Adequacy (2014) state that banks in Bangladesh must maintain a minimum total capital ratio of 10% (or Minimum Total Capital plus Capital Conservation Buffer of 12.5%) by 2019, in line with BASEL III. • State-owned commercial banks (SCBs) have failed to maintain minimum capital adequacy requirements since 2013. • Development finance institutions (DFIs) are critically under-capitalised. 7 2.1 Capital Adequacy Status Figure 1: Capital to Risk Weighted Assets Ratio Source: Bangladesh Bank Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June -40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percent SCB DFI PCB FCB
  • 8. • Both BASIC Bank and ICB Islamic Bank are critically under- capitalised. • BASIC Bank has not recovered from its massive scam during 2009-2013 • ICB Islamic Bank inherited a bankrupt institution from Oriental Bank, although all its problems are not hereditary 8 2.2 Capital Adequacy Problems of Banks Figure 2: Capital to Risk Weighted Assets Ratio in BASIC Bank & ICB Islamic Bank Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June -15.6 -108.5 -11 -115.7 -12 -115.8 -140 -120 -100 -80 -60 -40 -20 0 BASIC Bank Limited ICB Islami Bank Limited Percent 2016 2017 2018
  • 9. • Non-performing loans (NPL) as a share of total loans is exceptionally high in SCBs and DFIs. • As of June 2018, SCBs had 28.2% NPL, which is highest in the last ten years. • About 47% non- performing loans were concentrated in 5 banks as of end-June 2018 (BB, 2018). 9 2.3 Non-performing Loans Figure 3: Non-performing Loans as a Share of Total Loans Source: Bangladesh Bank Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percent SCB DFI PCB FCB
  • 10. • Classified loans as a share of total loans was more than 10% for 9 banks during 2016-2018. • ICB Islamic Bank had more than 60% and BASIC Bank had more than 50% classified loans during 2016-2018. • The actual percentage of classified loans would be higher if loans were not written off. 10 2.4 Asset Quality of Banks Figure 4: Classified Loans as a Share of Total Loans Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June 0 20 40 60 80 100 Sonali Bank Limited Janata Bank Limited Agrani Bank Limited Rupali Bank Limited BASIC Bank Limited Bangladesh Development Bank Limited ICB Islami Bank Limited Bangladesh Commerce Bank Limited The Farmers Bank Limited Per cent 2016 2017 2018
  • 11. • During 2016-2018, all SCBs had expenditure- income ratios greater than 0.5. • This reveals poor management effectiveness of these banks during this period. 11 2.5 Management of State-Owned Commercial Banks Figure 5: Expenditure-Income Ratio of State-Owned Commercial Banks Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June 0 0.5 1 1.5 Sonali Bank Limited Janata Bank Limited Agrani Bank Limited Rupali Bank Limited BASIC Bank Limited Bangladesh Development Bank Limited 2016 2017 2018
  • 12. • In terms of Return on Asset (ROA) and Return on Equity (ROE), the performance of FCBs, PCBs, and FCBs deteriorated. • As of June 2018, ROA and ROE of the banking industry stood 0.3% and 5.3% respectively. • However, performance of FCBs and PCBs were much better as compared to that of SCBs during 2008- 2017. 12 2.6 Return on Asset & Equity Figure 6: Return on Asset Source: Bangladesh Bank Note: Data for 2017 and 2018 are as of June -8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percent SCB PCB FCB -30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percent SCB PCB FCB Figure 7: Return on Equity
  • 13. • ICB Islamic Bank and The Farmers Bank have been making losses in the last 3 years. • BASIC Bank, Rupali Bank, and Agrani Bank made huge losses in 2016. • However, losses made by BASIC Bank alone was greater than the losses of all other banks combined. 13 2.7 Loss Making Banks Figure 8: Net Profit (in million BDT) Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June 228 248 90 19 -998 6889 498 -6709 -405 -540 -6970 -1258 -14930 -271 229 -20000 -10000 0 10000 Agrani Bank Limited Rupali Bank Limited BASIC Bank Limited ICB Islami Bank Limited The Farmers Bank Limited Million BDT 2016 2017 2018
  • 14. • A fluctuating Advance- Deposit Ratio (ADR) was observed over the last ten years • This indicates inefficiency in liquidity management of some banks • During last few years, the banking industry faced more than two unusual incidences of both liquidity surpluses and liquidity shortages 14 2.8 Liquidity Management Figure 9: Advance-Deposit Ratio of Banks Source: Bangladesh Bank Note: Data for 2018 is as of June 78 75 76 78 79 73 73 73 72 74 77 66 68 70 72 74 76 78 80 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 Percent
  • 15. • Fourth generation banks such as The Farmers Bank, NRB Global Bank, and NRB Commercial Bank faced liquidity crisis during 2016- 2017. • The problem was particularly acute in the case of The Farmers Bank, which had to be bailed out by the government. • In May 2018, four state-owned banks and a financial institution signed share purchase agreements with The Farmers Bank to inject BDT 765 crore into the bank (The Daily Star, 2018). 15 2.9 Liquidity Crisis in Banks Figure 10: Liquid Assets as a Share of Total Assets Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June -5.4 -0.9 0.6 0.2 -7.3 -17.1 0.4 0.1 2.4 1.8 0.4 0.4 -20.0 -15.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 Mercantile Bank Limited The Farmers Bank Limited NRB Global Bank Limited NRB Commercial Bank Limited Percent 2016 2017 2018
  • 16. • 9 banks consistently maintained an interest rate spread greater than 5% during 2016-2018 • While some of these were troubled banks, others were simply taking advantage of lax regulations 16 2.10 Interest Rate Spread Figure 11: Interest Rate Spread Source: Financial Institutions Division, Ministry of Finance Note: Data for 2018 are as of June 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 Bangladesh Development Bank Limited ICB Islami Bank Limited Dutch Bangla Bank Limited BRAC Bank Limited NRB Global Bank Limited Standard Chartered Bank National Bank of Pakistan Woori Bank HSBC Per cent 2016 2017 2018
  • 18. 18 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Scam Measures Sonali, Janata, NCC, Mercantile and Dhaka Bank (2008 -2011) Bank loan of BDT 5.89 crores with forged land documents (Dhaka Tribune, 28th August, 2013) On August 1st 2013, the ACC filed cases against Sonali Bank, Fahim Attire Limited and some individuals. (Dhaka Tribune, 2nd August, 2013) BASIC Bank (2009-2013) Embezzlement of BDT 4,500 crores through fake companies and dubious accounts. (The Daily Star, 28th June, 2013) In September 2015, the ACC filed 56 cases against 120 people on charge of swindling. (New Age Bangladesh, 13th August, 2018)
  • 19. 19 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Scam Measures Sonali Bank (2010-2012) Hall Mark and some other businesses embezzled BDT 3,547 crores. (The Daily Star, 14th August, 2012) In October 2012, the ACC filed 11 cases against 27 people, including Hallmark Group Chairman and Sonali Bank's 20 former and present officials. (Dhaka Tribune, 11th July, 2018) Janata Bank (2010-2015 & 2013 to present) Fraudulence by Crescent and AnonTex involving BDT 10,000 crores. (Dhaka Tribune, 3rd November, 2018) On 30th October, 2018, an inquiry committee, headed by an Executive Director of BB, submitted a report to the BB on the scam. (Dhaka Tribune, 3rd November, 2018)
  • 20. 20 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Scam Measures Janata Bank, Prime Bank, Jamuna Bank, Shahjalal Islami Bank Ltd and Premier Bank (June 2011-July 2012) Embezzlement and laundering of BDT 1,174.46 by Bismillah Group and its fake sister concerns. (The Daily Star, 7th October, 2016) On November 3, 2013, the ACC filed 12 cases against 54 people over the scam. (The Independent, 11th September, 2018) AB Bank (2013-2014) Money laundering of BDT 165 crores. (The Daily Star,12th June, 2018) On January 25, 2018, the ACC filed a case against former AB Bank chairman and officials. (The Daily Star, 12th March, 2018)
  • 21. 21 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Scam Measures NRB Commercial Bank (2013-2016) Gross irregularities over disbursing loans of BDT 701 crores. (New Age Bangladesh, 10th December, 2017) On December 29, 2016, the central bank appointed an observer at the bank to restore discipline and corporate governance. (Dhaka Tribune, 7th December, 2017) Janata Bank (2013-16) Loan scam involving BDT 1,230 crores (The New Nation, 22nd October, 2018) In October 2018, Thermax requested to reschedule the entire loan again (previously restructured in 2015). Janata Bank’s board endorsed this proposal by Thermax and sent it to the BB for approval. (The Daily Star, 21st October, 2018)
  • 22. 22 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Scam Measures Farmers Bank (2013-2017) Fund embezzlement of by 11 companies eg: NAR Sweaters Ltd, Advanced Development Technologies etc. involving BDT 500 crores. (The Daily Star, 24th March, 2018) In January 2018, Farmers Bank was directed by the BB to conduct a functional audit on credit accounts with outstanding amount of at least BDT 1 crore in its Motijheel branch. (The Daily Star, 24th March, 2018) In April 2018, the Anti-Corruption Commission (ACC) arrested four accused, including the Farmers Bank's former Audit Committee chairman. (The independent, 11th April, 2018)
  • 23. 23 3.1 Scams, Irregularities and Heists (contd...) Bank/ Institution Involved Type of Scam Amount Measures Bangladesh Bank (February 5, 2016) Heist of BDT 679.6 crores by international cyber hackers from treasury account of Bangladesh Bank with the New York's US Federal Reserve Bank. (The Daily Star, 5th August, 2017) On March 19, 2016, the government formed a 3-member investigation committee, headed by former governor of Central Bank Dr Farashuddin. (The Daily Star, 5th August, 2017)
  • 24. 24 3.2 Total Money Lost through Major Scams, Irregularities, & Heists Sonali, Janata, NCC, Mercantile & Dhaka Bank BDT 5.89 crore BASIC Bank BDT 4,500 crore Sonali Bank BDT 3,547 crore Janata Bank BDT 10,000 crore Janata Bank, Prime Bank, Jamuna Bank, Shahjalal Islami Bank & Premier Bank BDT 1,174 crore AB Bank BDT 165 crore NRB Commercial Bank BDT 701 crore Janata Bank BDT 1,230 crore The Farmers Bank BDT 500 crore Bangladesh Bank BDT 679 crore TOTAL BDT 22,502 crore
  • 25. 25 3.3 Cost of Major Scams, Irregularities, & Heists • 34% of total allocation for education in national budget of FY2017-18 • 39% of income tax revenue of GoB in FY2017-18 as of May 2018 • 78.2% of Padma Multipurpose Bridge (PMB) • 64.3% of Padma Bridge Rail Link • 62.5% of Matarbari 2x600 MW Ultra-Super Critical Coal-Fired Power Project (MUSCCFPP) • 40.9% of Deep Sea Port in Sonadia • 19.9% of 2x1200 MW Ruppur Nuclear Power Plant (RNPP) Main ProjectSource: Monthly Fiscal Report, Ministry of Finance and CPD (2018): State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2018 (Third Reading)
  • 26. 26 3.4 BDT 22,502 crore would be enough for • Total allocation for health in national budget of FY2017- 18 (BDT 20,651 crore) • Dhaka Mass Rapid Transit Development Project (DMRTDP) (Cost: BDT 21,985 crore) • Construction of Single Line Dual Gauge Track from Dohazari-Ramu-Cox’s Bazar and Ramu to Ghundum near Myanmar Border (Cost: BDT 18034 crore) • 2×660 MW Moitree Super Thermal Power Project (MSTPP) in Rampal (Cost: BDT 16000 crore) • Construction of Bangabandhu Railway Bridge (Cost: BDT 9,734 crore) • Construction of Multilane Road Tunnel under River Karnaphuli (Cost: BDT 8,447 crore) • Deep Sea Port at Paira (Cost: BDT 3351 crore) Source: CPD (2018): State of the Bangladesh Economy in FY2018 (Third Reading)
  • 27. 4. Cronyism in Banking
  • 28. 28 4.1 Problems of Monopolisation • When banks transform from being financial intermediaries to becoming monopolies, they become a growing cause for concern. • The monopolisation of banking is usually accompanied with a deterioration in governance. • When financial capital becomes concentrated into the hands of few, monopolies extract supernormal profits at the cost of the welfare of the ordinary population. • Crony capitalists use banks as vehicles for reaching their goal of financial oligarchy
  • 29. 29 4.2 Detrimental Amendments of Banking Company Act • Two detrimental amendments of dubious nature have been made to the Banking Company Act in 2018, which undermined the cause of good governance. • The tenure of board of directors was increased from 6 years to 9 years, and up to 4 family members would be allowed to be on the Board, instead of the earlier 2 per family. • These changes are apprehended to reinforce crony capitalism in a sector of the economy already impaired by poor governance.
  • 30. 30 4.3 Banking Oligarchies • In 2017, a single corporation gained control over 7 private commercial banks in Bangladesh (The Daily Star, 2017). • Following this development, there were major changes in the top management of these banks (New Age, 2017) • However, monopolization of banking was not only limited to corporations, but also spread to business families. • Despite being cautioned by the central bank in 2014, two private commercial banks still had 4 or more members from the same family in their Board of Directors, as of 12th January 2018 (CPD, 2018).
  • 31. 5. Do We Need More Banks?
  • 32. • Mexico has only 47 commercial banks even though the GDP of Mexico in 2016 was about 7.4 times larger than that of Bangladesh in 2016 and the total surface area of Mexico is about 13.2 times larger than that of Bangladesh (CPD, 2018). • Globally, if microstates that have a land area less than 1000 square kilometres are disregarded, Bangladesh has the 8th highest geographic concentration of commercial bank branches (CPD, 2018). • In 2016, Bangladesh had 75 branches of commercial banks per 1000 square kilometres of land, which was the highest in the South Asia region (CPD, 2018). 32 5.1 High Concentration of Banks and Bank Branches in Bangladesh Figure: Branches of commercial banks per 1,000 square kilometres in South Asia (2016) Source: IMF Financial Access Survey Data Note: * indicates data for 2015 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Bangladesh Bhutan India Nepal Pakistan SriLanka* Numberofcommercialbankbranchesper1000 squarekilometres
  • 33. 33 5.2 Bank Licenses as Gifts • In 2013, the government approved licenses of 9 new private commercial banks: Meghna Bank Limited, Midland Bank Limited, Modhumoti Bank Limited, NRB Bank Limited, NRB Commercial Bank Limited, NRB Global Bank Limited, South Bangla Agriculture and Commerce Bank Limited, The Farmers Bank Limited, and Union Bank Limited. • All of these banks were backed by politically powerful owners. • License for opening a new commercial bank has, in fact, become a tool for misappropriation of public money. • The fourth generation banks (9 newly approved commercial banks) are beset with large amounts of NPLs and are making losses.
  • 34. 34 5.3 Excessive number of banks, yet attempts to permit more • According to the Bank Company (Amendment) Act 2013, the central bank will decide to grant licenses to new commercial banks after considering the need for such banks and the overall state of the economy. • Ironically, this principle is not followed in Bangladesh in case of issuing bank license. • 95% of the bank officials believed that the fourth generation banks in Bangladesh were redundant (Nabi, 2016).
  • 36. • Recurrent recapitalization of SCBs by the government has emerged as an issue of grave concern, and the government has taken recourse to this measure on a regular basis. • It has been estimated that the GoB has spent BDT 15,705 crore in recapitalizing the banks during the period FY2009-FY2017 (Monthly Fiscal Frameworks, Budget Briefs, Finance Division). 36 6.1 Recapitalisation Figure: Amount of Recapitalisation (in crore BDT) Source: Monthly Fiscal Frameworks, Budget Briefs, Finance Division. 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000 4500 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 CroreBDT
  • 37. 37 6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking Sector Date Brief Description of Change 2009 Anti-Terrorism Act is passed to address terror financing (GoB, 2009) 2009 Banking and Financial Institution Division is formed within the Ministry of Finance, curtailing the authority of Bangladesh Bank and acting as an obstacle to the monitoring of state-owned commercial banks (FID, 2010) 2009 ‘Guidelines on Risk Based Capital Adequacy for Banks’ is introduced by Bangladesh Bank, in line with Basel II (Bangladesh Bank, 2008) 2011 Whistleblowers' Protection Act 2011 states that no criminal, civil or departmental proceedings can be initiated against a person for disclosing information in the public interest to the authorities, and his or her identity will not be disclosed without his or her consent. (GoB, 2011)
  • 38. 38 6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking Sector (contd...) Date Brief Description of Change 2012 Customer Interest Protection Centre' (CIPC) is established in the head office and branch offices of Bangladesh Bank 2012 Money Laundering Prevention Act gives Bangladesh Bank responsibility for money laundering offences (GoB, 2012) 2012 Bangladesh Financial Intelligence Unit (BFIU) is established for analyzing Suspicious Transaction Reports (STRs), Cash Transaction Reports (CTRs) & information related to money laundering (ML) or financing of terrorism (TF) received from reporting agencies and other sources and disseminating information/intelligence thereon to relevant law enforcement agencies. (Bangladesh Bank, 2012) 2012 Financial Integrity and Customer Services Department (FICSD) department is established in Bangladesh Bank with a view to minimizing fraud and forgery in the banking industry. (Bangladesh Bank, 2014)
  • 39. 39 6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking Sector (contd...) Date Brief Description of Change 2013 Bank Company Act is amended. More than two members of the same family are not allowed to be on the board of directors, and the tenure of the directors is restricted to six years. (GoB, 2013) 2013 Anti-Terrorism Act is amended to make provisions for the prevention of terrorist activities and ensure effective punishment for such activities (GoB, 2013) 2014 ‘Guidelines on Risk Based Capital Adequacy for Banks’ is introduced by Bangladesh Bank, in line with Basel III (Bangladesh Bank, 2014) 2014 Bangladesh Bank imposes “Regulations on Electronic Fund Transfer” (Bangladesh Bank, 2014) 2014 Bangladesh Payment And Settlement Systems Regulations is introduced by Bangladesh Bank (Bangladesh Bank, 2014) 2015 Money Laundering Prevention Act is amended to reenact a law regarding the prevention of money laundering and other connected offenses (GoB, 2015)
  • 40. 40 6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking Sector (contd...) Date Brief Description of Change 2015 Financial Reporting Act is passed which requires the establishment of a new oversight body, referred to as the Financial Reporting Council (FRC), whose main purpose will be to regulate the financial reporting process followed by the quoted companies (GoB, 2015) 2015 Bangladesh Bank introduces “Guideline on ICT Security for Banks and Non-bank Financial Institutions” (Bangladesh Bank, 2015) 2017 Bangladesh Financial Intelligence Unit (BFIU) issues a master circular directing banks to identify relevant risks, risk tolerance level, and readiness to handle the risks associated with new technology based payment services before launching the product (Bangladesh Bank, 2017)
  • 41. 41 6.2 Major Reforms in the Banking Sector (contd...) Date Brief Description of Change 2017 Code of Conduct for banks and non-bank financial institutions introduced by Bangladesh Bank to implement National Integrity Strategy in the financial sector of Bangladesh (Bangladesh Bank, 2017) 2017 Bangladesh Bank introduces Guidelines on Environmental & Social Risk Management (ESRM) for Banks and Financial Institutions in Bangladesh (Bangladesh Bank, 2017) 2018 Bank Company Act is amended allowing increasing the maximum number of family members on the board of directors from two to four and extending the tenure of the board of directors from six to nine years (Dhaka Tribune, 2018)
  • 43. 43 7.1 Recommendations • The number of judges dealing with Money Loan Court Act 2003 and Bankruptcy Act 1997 should be increased to ensure speedy disposal of loan default cases and to reduce backlog. • Immediate actions must be taken against banks that are performing poorly and are ill-prepared for BASEL III. • A new exit policy for troubled banks needs to be formulated, particularly taking into cognisance the ineffectiveness of the Oriental Bank model. • Recapitalisation of SCBs year after year has to be stopped. Such practice of bailing out the losing banks with public money is economically unjustified and morally incorrect.
  • 44. 44 7.1 Recommendations (contd...) • The decision to keep 50% government funds with private banks goes against the spirit of central bank’s monetary policy. Only banks with less than 5% NPLs should be eligible for the additional available funds from government entities. • Bangladesh Bank should appoint a strong administrator immediately to oversee the operation of troubled banks. A proper audit of the bank should be performed to understand the real health of the bank. • The culture of giving licenses to new banks on political grounds should be stopped. Given the size of the economy there is no need for new banks. • The internal control department of SCBs is in need of a serious overhaul. During financial scams of the past, it was discovered that the internal control departments either willingly or unwillingly had failed to inform the Board of Directors regarding large losses.
  • 45. 45 7.1 Recommendations (contd...) • In order to truly bring about a profound change in the banking sector, the most important emergent task is to combat cronyism. The current practice of recruiting Board of Directors on political grounds has to be discontinued. Only unbiased, competent, and honest individuals should be appointed as Member of the Board of SCBs. • The independence of the central bank should be upheld. Interference in Bangladesh Bank’s activities goes against the spirit of Bangladesh Bank Amendment Bill 2003 which was geared to guarantee the central bank with autonomy. • Lack of capacity building is a perennial problem that besets the SCBs in Bangladesh. Without human resource development through enhanced skills, SCBs will not be able to handle the emerging challenges facing the sector.
  • 46. 46 7.2 A Commission for the Banking Sector • CPD has earlier argued for setting up an independent commission for the banking sector in view of addressing emerging challenges. • The broad terms of reference (ToR) of the commission will be to critically assess the problems and weaknesses of the banking industry. • Such a commission will suggest concrete recommendations for prudential banking, and prepare guidelines regarding management, automation, risk management, and internal control. • The budget should allocate adequate funds for setting up this commission.
  • 47. 47 7.3 Commitments from Political Parties during Electoral Debate I. Recognise the Problem: First and foremost, the challenges of the banking sector should be recognized. A thorough review of the state of the banking sector has to be carried out and establish more transparency on the state of affairs. II. Autonomy of the Central Bank: Supervisory and monitoring role of Bangladesh Bank should to be significantly strengthened for smooth functioning of the sector III. Blue Ribbon Committee for Appointing Board Members: The process of appointing board members should be de-politicised. A highly qualified and experienced committee should be formed to select board members. The culture of selecting board members based on the political loyalty and affiliation must change. IV. No New Banks: Do not give licenses for new commercial banks. V. Reform of Judicial Process: Trial of scams and irregularities cases should expedited and exemplary measures should be taken against the involved people. Speedy recovery of default loans should be implemented through special tribunal should be set up for bank defaulters.