SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Automatic Load Test Verification
Using Control Charts
Thanh Nguyen, Bram Adams, ZhenMing Jiang, Ahmed E. Hassan
Queen’s University, Kingston, Canada
Mohamed Nasser, Parminder Flora
Research in Motion, Waterloo, Canada
1
2
Load testing: Ensure the software
performance
With 2000 concurrent users, a GET request
should be responded within 2 seconds
3
Development
Functional
Testing
Load
Testing
Importance of software performance:
More users
4
Load testing is regression based
5
Apply operational
load e.g. 2000
requests/min
Existing version
e.g. version 1.2
New release
e.g. version 1.3
Baseline
Performance counters
Target
Performance counters
Compare the counters
to detect
performance
regression
Code changes
Automated
e.g. HP LoadRunner,
MS Visual Studio, …
Still a manual
process
Challenge in load testing: Lots of data
6
There are thousands of counters with millions
of samples
Frontend BackendClient
Client
Client
Frontend
Client
Frontend
Client
Backend
Backend
Load
balancer
CPU%
User CPU%
Privileged CPU%
IO data bytes/sec
IO read bytes/sec
IO write bytes/sec
Page faults/sec
Pool paged bytes
Private bytes
Virtual bytes
Manufacturing process also requires
automatic verification
7
Control charts example
8
730
735
740
745
750
755
760
765
770
775
0 5 10 15 20 25
Milk Filled (ml)
CL
LCL
UCL
Violation ratio: 0% 20% 20% 60%
Using control charts to verify load test
results
9
Baseline
Performance counters
Target
Performance counters
Determine the UCL,
CL, LCL
730
740
750
760
770
780
0 5 10 15 20 25
Performance counter
Using control charts to verify load test
results
10
Baseline
Performance counters
Target
Performance counters
Determine the UCL,
CL, LCL
730
740
750
760
770
780
0 5 10 15 20 25
Performance counter
Violation
ratio
11
Baseline
Performance counters
Target
Performance counters
Target
Performance counters
730
740
750
760
770
780
0 10 20 30
Performance counter
Baseline
Performance counters
720
730
740
750
760
770
780
0 10 20 30
Performance counter
Low
violation
ratio
High
violation
ratio
We conduct two case studies
• Enterprise system:
– Large and complex
– Multi-tiers
• Dell DVD store
– Small and simple
– 3-tiers
12
13
Type Description
Front end
problems
CPU hog a) 50% and b) 75% of CPU on
the front end server
Back end
problems
CPU hog a) 50% and b) 75% of CPU on
one of the back end servers
Busy waiting Busy waiting in the front end server
code
Query Extra query to the database back end
Normal
Performance counters
Problems
Performance counters
Type Description
Normal Runs of existing version without
performance problems
RQ1: Can control charts detect a
problematic run?
14
Enterprise’s Response Time
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Normal Front 50% Front 75% Back 50% Back 75%
Violation ratio
15
DVD Store’s Response Time
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Normal Front 50% Front 75% Back 50% Back 75% Busy Query
Violation Ratio
RQ2: Can control charts identify the
problematic component?
16
Frontend BackendClient
Client
Client
Frontend
Client
Frontend
Client
Backend
Backend
Load
balancer
High violation in
frontend’s
counters
High violation in
backend’s
counters
Backend 50% stress
17
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
F B B B B F O B F O
Violation ratioBaseline
Target
Filter out unstable counters
18
Baseline
Target
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
F F F F B B B B B B
Violation ratio
These counters are always out-of-control  We filter then
out
Backend 50% stress
19
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
B B B B B O
Violation ratioBaseline
Target
Frontend 50% stress
20
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
F F F F F F O
Violation ratioBaseline
Target
21

More Related Content

What's hot

Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
Kim Herzig
 
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software TestingThe Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
Software Testing Solution
 
Case study on Test Automation under RUP
Case study on Test Automation under RUPCase study on Test Automation under RUP
Case study on Test Automation under RUP
Oak Systems
 
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testingSolano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
MassTLC
 
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
Ho Chi Minh City Software Testing Club
 
Predictive Analytics in Software Testing
Predictive Analytics in Software TestingPredictive Analytics in Software Testing
Predictive Analytics in Software Testing
Pavan Kumar Kodedela
 
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
Ho Chi Minh City Software Testing Club
 
Machine learning in software testing
Machine learning in software testingMachine learning in software testing
Machine learning in software testing
Thoughtworks
 
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and TracingAutomation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
Markus Borg
 
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming SkillsHow Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
Ranorex
 
Agile, DevOps, & Hardware
Agile, DevOps, & HardwareAgile, DevOps, & Hardware
Agile, DevOps, & Hardware
David Evans
 
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing IntroductionAfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
Peter Marshall
 
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEWWhen is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
Mike Christesen
 
Risk based testing a new case study
Risk based testing   a new case studyRisk based testing   a new case study
Risk based testing a new case study
Bassam Al-Khatib
 
Seven testing principles
Seven testing principlesSeven testing principles
Seven testing principles
Vaibhav Dash
 
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
suresh ramanujam
 
[Europe merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
[Europe   merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing[Europe   merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
[Europe merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
Perforce
 
Software testing and test environment​
Software testing and test environment​Software testing and test environment​
Software testing and test environment​
adhirasable
 
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
IBM Rational
 
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be RequiredTesting 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
ArleneAndrews2
 

What's hot (20)

Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
Empirically Detecting False Test Alarms Using Association Rules @ ICSE 2015
 
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software TestingThe Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
The Myths and Facts Surrounding Software Testing
 
Case study on Test Automation under RUP
Case study on Test Automation under RUPCase study on Test Automation under RUP
Case study on Test Automation under RUP
 
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testingSolano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
Solano Labs presented at MassTLC's automated testing
 
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
[HCMC STC Jan 2015] Risk-Based Software Testing Approaches
 
Predictive Analytics in Software Testing
Predictive Analytics in Software TestingPredictive Analytics in Software Testing
Predictive Analytics in Software Testing
 
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
[Paul Holland] Bad Metrics and What You Can Do About It
 
Machine learning in software testing
Machine learning in software testingMachine learning in software testing
Machine learning in software testing
 
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and TracingAutomation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
Automation in the Bug Flow - Machine Learning for Triaging and Tracing
 
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming SkillsHow Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
How Manual Testers Can Break into Automation Without Programming Skills
 
Agile, DevOps, & Hardware
Agile, DevOps, & HardwareAgile, DevOps, & Hardware
Agile, DevOps, & Hardware
 
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing IntroductionAfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
AfterTest Madrid March 2016 - DevOps and Testing Introduction
 
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEWWhen is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
When is a project ready for Software Automation_NEW
 
Risk based testing a new case study
Risk based testing   a new case studyRisk based testing   a new case study
Risk based testing a new case study
 
Seven testing principles
Seven testing principlesSeven testing principles
Seven testing principles
 
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
Software Testing Principles and  Techniques
 
[Europe merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
[Europe   merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing[Europe   merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
[Europe merge world tour] Coverity Development Testing
 
Software testing and test environment​
Software testing and test environment​Software testing and test environment​
Software testing and test environment​
 
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
4.4.2013 Software Quality - Regression Testing Automated and Manual - RFT/RQM
 
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be RequiredTesting 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
Testing 3: Types Of Tests That May Be Required
 

Similar to Automatic Load Test Verification Using Control Charts

Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance TestAdding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
Rodolfo Kohn
 
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare networkThe experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
george.james
 
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More DefectsDevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
TechWell
 
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packagesOpen source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
Rogue Wave Software
 
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual DataAccelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
Kyle Hailey
 
Become a Performance Diagnostics Hero
Become a Performance Diagnostics HeroBecome a Performance Diagnostics Hero
Become a Performance Diagnostics Hero
TechWell
 
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance ProblemsExposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
Riverbed Technology
 
Real Time Network Monitoring System
Real  Time  Network  Monitoring  SystemReal  Time  Network  Monitoring  System
Real Time Network Monitoring System
Girish Naik
 
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of ExcellenceT3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
veehikle
 
XenApp Load Balancing
XenApp Load BalancingXenApp Load Balancing
XenApp Load Balancing
Denis Gundarev
 
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic ToolsWebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
Chris Bailey
 
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your PipelineTop Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
Andreas Grabner
 
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev opsUsing ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
Rob Jahn
 
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare networkThe experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
george.james
 
Virtualising Tier 1 Apps
Virtualising Tier 1 AppsVirtualising Tier 1 Apps
Virtualising Tier 1 Apps
Iwan Rahabok
 
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
Min Fang
 
Performance testing virtualized systems v5
Performance testing virtualized systems v5Performance testing virtualized systems v5
Performance testing virtualized systems v5
Mentora
 
Optimizing performance
Optimizing performanceOptimizing performance
Optimizing performance
Zend by Rogue Wave Software
 
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing ApplicationsWill it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
Navina Ramesh
 
Industrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
Industrial Automation and Modern ConnectivityIndustrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
Industrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
PlantEngineering
 

Similar to Automatic Load Test Verification Using Control Charts (20)

Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance TestAdding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
Adding Value in the Cloud with Performance Test
 
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare networkThe experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
 
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More DefectsDevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
DevOps: Find Solutions, Not More Defects
 
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packagesOpen source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
Open source: Top issues in the top enterprise packages
 
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual DataAccelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
Accelerate Develoment with VIrtual Data
 
Become a Performance Diagnostics Hero
Become a Performance Diagnostics HeroBecome a Performance Diagnostics Hero
Become a Performance Diagnostics Hero
 
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance ProblemsExposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
Exposing and Fixing Common App Performance Problems
 
Real Time Network Monitoring System
Real  Time  Network  Monitoring  SystemReal  Time  Network  Monitoring  System
Real Time Network Monitoring System
 
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of ExcellenceT3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
T3 Consortium's Performance Center of Excellence
 
XenApp Load Balancing
XenApp Load BalancingXenApp Load Balancing
XenApp Load Balancing
 
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic ToolsWebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
WebSphere Technical University: Introduction to the Java Diagnostic Tools
 
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your PipelineTop Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
Top Java Performance Problems and Metrics To Check in Your Pipeline
 
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev opsUsing ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
Using ai and automation to build resiliency into azure dev ops
 
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare networkThe experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
The experiences of migrating a large scale, high performance healthcare network
 
Virtualising Tier 1 Apps
Virtualising Tier 1 AppsVirtualising Tier 1 Apps
Virtualising Tier 1 Apps
 
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
Service Virtualization - Next Gen Testing Conference Singapore 2013
 
Performance testing virtualized systems v5
Performance testing virtualized systems v5Performance testing virtualized systems v5
Performance testing virtualized systems v5
 
Optimizing performance
Optimizing performanceOptimizing performance
Optimizing performance
 
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing ApplicationsWill it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
Will it Scale? The Secrets behind Scaling Stream Processing Applications
 
Industrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
Industrial Automation and Modern ConnectivityIndustrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
Industrial Automation and Modern Connectivity
 

More from SAIL_QU

Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
SAIL_QU
 
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
SAIL_QU
 
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load testsImproving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
SAIL_QU
 
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
SAIL_QU
 
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
SAIL_QU
 
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
SAIL_QU
 
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
SAIL_QU
 
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
SAIL_QU
 
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
SAIL_QU
 
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log ChangesTowards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
SAIL_QU
 
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution AnalysesThe Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
SAIL_QU
 
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
SAIL_QU
 
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
SAIL_QU
 
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
SAIL_QU
 
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
SAIL_QU
 
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
SAIL_QU
 
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
SAIL_QU
 
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
SAIL_QU
 
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
SAIL_QU
 
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with ProfessionalsMeasuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
SAIL_QU
 

More from SAIL_QU (20)

Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
Studying the Integration Practices and the Evolution of Ad Libraries in the G...
 
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
 
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load testsImproving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
Improving the testing efficiency of selenium-based load tests
 
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
Studying User-Developer Interactions Through the Distribution and Reviewing M...
 
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
Studying online distribution platforms for games through the mining of data f...
 
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
Understanding the Factors for Fast Answers in Technical Q&A Websites: An Empi...
 
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
Investigating the Challenges in Selenium Usage and Improving the Testing Effi...
 
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
Mining Development Knowledge to Understand and Support Software Logging Pract...
 
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
Which Log Level Should Developers Choose For a New Logging Statement?
 
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log ChangesTowards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
Towards Just-in-Time Suggestions for Log Changes
 
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution AnalysesThe Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
The Impact of Task Granularity on Co-evolution Analyses
 
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
A Framework for Evaluating the Results of the SZZ Approach for Identifying Bu...
 
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
How are Discussions Associated with Bug Reworking? An Empirical Study on Open...
 
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
A Study of the Relation of Mobile Device Attributes with the User-Perceived Q...
 
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
A Large-Scale Study of the Impact of Feature Selection Techniques on Defect C...
 
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
Studying the Dialogue Between Users and Developers of Free Apps in the Google...
 
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
What Do Programmers Know about Software Energy Consumption?
 
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
Threshold for Size and Complexity Metrics: A Case Study from the Perspective ...
 
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
Revisiting the Experimental Design Choices for Approaches for the Automated R...
 
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with ProfessionalsMeasuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
Measuring Program Comprehension: A Large-Scale Field Study with Professionals
 

Recently uploaded

Hand Rolled Applicative User Validation Code Kata
Hand Rolled Applicative User ValidationCode KataHand Rolled Applicative User ValidationCode Kata
Hand Rolled Applicative User Validation Code Kata
Philip Schwarz
 
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling ExtensionsUI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
Peter Muessig
 
Empowering Growth with Best Software Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
Empowering Growth with Best Software  Development Company in Noida - DeugloEmpowering Growth with Best Software  Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
Empowering Growth with Best Software Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
Deuglo Infosystem Pvt Ltd
 
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptxOracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
Remote DBA Services
 
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit ParisNeo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j
 
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit ParisNeo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j
 
Fundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
Fundamentals of Programming and Language ProcessorsFundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
Fundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
Rakesh Kumar R
 
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
OpenMetadata
 
How to write a program in any programming language
How to write a program in any programming languageHow to write a program in any programming language
How to write a program in any programming language
Rakesh Kumar R
 
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for EmbeddedWebinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
ICS
 
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FMEEssentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
Safe Software
 
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
Julian Hyde
 
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI AppAI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
Google
 
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
mz5nrf0n
 
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptxLORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
lorraineandreiamcidl
 
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissancesAtelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
Neo4j
 
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR SolutionsTransform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
TheSMSPoint
 
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph TechnologyGraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
Neo4j
 
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
Hironori Washizaki
 
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdfUnveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
brainerhub1
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Hand Rolled Applicative User Validation Code Kata
Hand Rolled Applicative User ValidationCode KataHand Rolled Applicative User ValidationCode Kata
Hand Rolled Applicative User Validation Code Kata
 
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling ExtensionsUI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
UI5con 2024 - Boost Your Development Experience with UI5 Tooling Extensions
 
Empowering Growth with Best Software Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
Empowering Growth with Best Software  Development Company in Noida - DeugloEmpowering Growth with Best Software  Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
Empowering Growth with Best Software Development Company in Noida - Deuglo
 
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptxOracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
Oracle Database 19c New Features for DBAs and Developers.pptx
 
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit ParisNeo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
 
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit ParisNeo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
Neo4j - Product Vision and Knowledge Graphs - GraphSummit Paris
 
Fundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
Fundamentals of Programming and Language ProcessorsFundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
Fundamentals of Programming and Language Processors
 
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
OpenMetadata Community Meeting - 5th June 2024
 
How to write a program in any programming language
How to write a program in any programming languageHow to write a program in any programming language
How to write a program in any programming language
 
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for EmbeddedWebinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
Webinar On-Demand: Using Flutter for Embedded
 
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FMEEssentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
Essentials of Automations: The Art of Triggers and Actions in FME
 
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
Measures in SQL (SIGMOD 2024, Santiago, Chile)
 
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI AppAI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
AI Fusion Buddy Review: Brand New, Groundbreaking Gemini-Powered AI App
 
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
原版定制美国纽约州立大学奥尔巴尼分校毕业证学位证书原版一模一样
 
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptxLORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
LORRAINE ANDREI_LEQUIGAN_HOW TO USE WHATSAPP.pptx
 
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissancesAtelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
Atelier - Innover avec l’IA Générative et les graphes de connaissances
 
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR SolutionsTransform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
Transform Your Communication with Cloud-Based IVR Solutions
 
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph TechnologyGraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
GraphSummit Paris - The art of the possible with Graph Technology
 
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
SWEBOK and Education at FUSE Okinawa 2024
 
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdfUnveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
Unveiling the Advantages of Agile Software Development.pdf
 

Automatic Load Test Verification Using Control Charts

Editor's Notes

  1. More user User requirement also change
  2. More user User requirement also change
  3. More user User requirement also change
  4. -Limits -Violation ratio