SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
Download to read offline
International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
Contents lists available at Science‐Gate
International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences
Journal homepage: http://www.science‐gate.com/IJAAS.html
13
A framework for effective leadership practices and skills for school principals
Susan Karimzadeh Ardebil1, Lotfollah Abbasi Sarvak2, Seyed Farhad Eftekharzadeh2, Azadeh Mehrpouyan2,*
1Department of Education Science, Rodehen Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
2Department of Education Science, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history:
Received 2 October 2015
Received in revised form
7 November 2015
Accepted 23 November 2015
This paper extends to inspire a shared vision of leadership at schools and
identify the practices and components that describe effective leadership. This
research also addresses to identify leadership components and their own
interrelationships on leadership practices. This paper examines the current
status of school principals and grades the studied components and features
in this study. This study was conducted through descriptive method and the
sampling was done by simple random. Randomly- Cluster and stratified-
relatively sampling, the effectiveness of seven identified components on
leadership of elementary schools principals’ performance from teachers’
perspective. A framework is designed to increase the effective leadership
role of principals and school efficiency, develop students’ social abilities and
promote the senior managers to apply the identified components in selecting
principals. The paper reports the principals has the highest performance in
responsibility and accountability of staff and the lowest performance in the
methods of inspiration, rewarding and creating motivation among staff. The
results show that a significant difference exists between these two of the
mentioned variables of leadership features i.e. cohesion, correlation and
solidary among these six components in the designed framework are a must
in order to fulfill the leadership.
Keywords:
Leadership
Practices
Skills
School principals
Components
Framework
Š 2015 IASE Publisher. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
*Efficiency of schools is basically affected by
leadership ability of principal and is result of his/her
attitude, insight, social and moral character. It is
necessary to deal with the most basic role of
principal i.e. leadership ability of schools in order to
increase the efficiency of education system
particularly in social and moral character building.
Leader principals pose a vision for their schools and
are well aware to achieve mentioned vision. An
effective educational environment demands the
following basic characteristics of this environment
such as dynamic and active cooperation among
effective people in education, and reinforcing and
supporting their innovative spirits. Since teaching is
a core responsibility of teachers and pose the highest
rate in the relationship among students and
principal, teachers can be the most effective people
in the educational environment. Then, being aware
of teachers’ attitude toward the leadership role of
principal is one of the most appropriate methods to
evaluate leadership ability of a school principal. This
matter requires describing the major practices and
components of leadership.
* Corresponding Author.
Email Address: dr.mehrpooyan@gmail.com
A large and basic stream of literature in the area
of principals’ leadership has identified independent
dimensions of leadership and the effective behaviors
of scientific leadership (e.g. Lewin et al., 1951; Likert
et al., 1961; Robbins, 2001). Moyer (1995) studied a
method of leadership oriented or group oriented
method through teachers’ attitude on job and
personal satisfaction about principal behavior based
on one of these two methods. Williafrodin (1973)
examined a relationship between principal and staff
in primary schools of United States with indirect
function components based on the rate of observed
effective characters by primary schools teachers.
Bayard Sally (2011) conducted a study on
quantitative analysis of relations between trust of
teachers, automation and educational function of
schools. Ghafooryan (2002) assessed the functional
components of elementary schools of Tehran city.
Khajeyee (2001) evaluated skills and qualification of
primary schools’ principals to obtain an appropriate
management model. Amiri (2007) investigated a
relationship between communication skills of
managers and staff job satisfaction in Central
administration offices of Northern Khorasan (quoted
by Grissom and Loeb, 2011).
Saadati (2007) also studied a relationship
between dimensions of organizational leadership
quality and teachers’ creativity rate of boy high
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
14
schools in Maneh and Salmaghan. Grissom and Loeb
(2011) studied general leadership skills which have
a relationship with school’s outcome and showed a
skill can constantly predict the rate of student
progress and other successes depend on
organizational management of principal. The
analysis argues for a broad view of principal
leadership that includes organizational management
skills as a key complement to the work of supporting
curriculum and instruction (quoted by Grissom and
Loeb, 2011).
Symmetry of social character formation and
sociability of children with school going age of 6 -7
makes significant to study primary school period in
this research. Guidance and giving directions to
educational and training processes depend on
quality and the way which human relationship
underpin at schools and principals are in charge for
that; moreover, sociability can be another
responsibility of principals. Hence, it is necessary to
pay a special attention to the leadership role of
principles and its relevant components and their
qualifications for obtaining this responsibility in
order to increase efficiency at schools. Leithwood et
al. (2008) summarizes the main findings from the
wealth of empirical studies undertaken in the
leadership field and suggest seven strong claims
about successful school leadership. On the other
hand, this research extends seven components for
effective leadership from teachers’ perspective and
they might be helpful to principal selection and
school performance.
Hence, the researchers identify leadership
components and examine their interrelationship and
relationship with leadership role. Leadership is
second only to teaching in its impact on student
outcomes (Leithwood et al., 2004). Principals play an
essential role as school leaders to achieve. The
principal objective of the present research is to
identify the practices and components that describe
effective leadership. Leader practices are the actions,
behaviors and functions found through research and
professional experience to have a positive impact on
school achievement from teachers’ point of view.
Leader components are the skills of effective
principals. The framework is not intended as a job
description for the leader, or as a checklist against
which to assess performance. Rather, it provides
framework for growth, which are sufficiently
detailed to describe good leadership. Structure of the
framework is made up of a major part: leader
practices and components.
This research was studied through descriptive
and literature review survey with applied purpose.
This study was conducted in government elementary
schools in 19 districts of Tehran education
organization.
2. Materials and methods
The study was conducted in 2013-2014 in
Tehran, Capital city of Iran. The data were collected
through researcher-made questionnaire. Items
identified from literature review helped in the
construction of the survey instrument.
2.1. Sample
In the light of the objectives of present study, the
survey population was identified as teachers of
government-primary schools in Tehran in 2013 –
2014. A convenience sample of 10838 woman
teachers and 764 men teachers was drawn using
systematic sampling of Krejcie & Morgan Table. As
increasing need for a representative statistical
sample in empirical research, Krejcie & Morgan
Table (1970) has created a demand for an effective
method of determining sample size. Present
researchers selected this table in order to determine
sample size for a given population for easy reference.
According to Krejcie & Morgan Table, the sample size
for given population of 15000 people determines
375 sample size including 350 female teachers and
25 male teachers. The sample size of present study is
379 (quoted by Leithwood et al., 2004).
Sampling methods are clustered randomized and
class proportional. Initially, Tehran city has divided
into five sectors of north, west, east, and center. Next,
accidentally regions number of 3, 8,9,11, and 16 are
selected for sampling and schools of these regions
are selected as analyzing units. Sampling was carried
out based on gender regarding number of female to
male teachers’ ratio to the population of total
number of teachers each region of Tehran in primary
school section.
The researchers attempted to select the schools
from different urban areas for further standardizing
in sampling of statistical population.
High volume of the required samplings in each
region made call many schools and teachers for
responding the questionnaires. Hence, the number of
participating schools in each region regarding the
required sample volume of each region reaches over
50 schools.
2.2. Instrument survey
The researcher-made questionnaire contained
two following information sections:
a-Personal profile and demographic information
b-Questionnaire questions according to study
problems
Present questionnaire includes 70 questions in 7
sections in 5 scales that evaluate principle’s behavior
in each specific case with 10 descriptive questions.
The limits of scales are as follows very low, low,
medium, high, and very high. Over 50 relevant
standard and researcher-made questionnaires has
been studied to provide present questionnaire e.g.
“Standards of school principals” questionnaire by
educational board of New York City. This
questionnaire determines some standards for
government school principals of New York and the
first priority of these standards is “educational
leadership standard” of principal.
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
15
For descriptive analysis of data, frequency
indexes, frequency, standard deviation, percent,
skewness, elongation, and for inferential analysis of
data univariate chi-square, Kruskal-Wallis, Whitney
U, and Friedman test has been used. The reliability of
questionnaire examined and confirmed by research
guide and consultant professors, and expert
professionals. Utilizing Cronbach’s alpha coefficients
validity and reliability of present questionnaire has
been summarized (See Table 1). Cronbach’s alpha in
each component and total components approves
popularizing, reliability and repeatability of current
test.
Table1: The reliability of questionnaire
In descriptive statistics section, firstly
assessment of responses to questions breakdown of
each component has been studied and in the next
step, an index is created from the sums of questions
of an index for the considered component. Average
of respondents’ assessment of each of
questionnaires’ questions are indexed in the scale of
1 to 5 and average of components (sums of questions
related to each component) are stated in the scale of
1 to 100. For studying method of variables
distribution Kolmogorov–Smirnov test (K-S test or
KS test) is used. If significant scale of Kolmogorov–
Smirnov test (sig) is lower than 0.05; it shows that
variable distribution is abnormal. Since all questions
are descriptive and the distribution of all variables is
abnormal, Single Variable Chi-Square test was used
which is a subset of non-parametric tests.
In Single Variable Chi-Square test, the observed
statistical frequency for each item is compared to the
predicted statistical frequency of that item and also,
being significant or insignificant differences between
them is studied. For example, if frequency is 379 and
5 choices exist to respond each question, the
predicted frequency for each choice will be 75.8 and
the observed frequency i.e. answer to each question
will be compared to 75.8, and then being significant
or insignificant differences between these two
numbers will determined through Chi-Square test.
To rank the seven components of leading and
guiding of principals from teachers’ perspective,
Friedman test is used. In this test, mean differences
between the scales of some variables in a correlated
sample is measured and their significances are
studied. This study shows that function of which
principals have been better in one or more observed
components.
3. Results and findings
Kolmogorov Smirnov test was carried out and the
corresponding significance with test (KS) in all
indicators is less than 0.05 and the results show that
the distributions of studied components are
abnormal (See Table 2).
Table 2: Results of Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (KS) for checking the status of variable distribution of the study
Components
Statistics Test values
Dist. Status
Mean
Standard
deviation
K-S Significance Level
Building Trust 81.2 24.1 4.230 0.000 Abnormal
Method of reward, encouragement
and motivate staff
74.5 24.7 2.933 0.000 Abnormal
Supporting innovation 78.0 24.0 3.487 0.000 Abnormal
Communication 82.7 24.2 4.608 0.000 Abnormal
Increasing Staff’s accountability 83.2 20.7 4.034 0.000 Abnormal
Appling leadership ability of
students
78.3 22.9 3.314 0.000 Abnormal
Compliance of justice and fairness 80.9 24.3 4.166 0.000 Abnormal
Total indicator (leadership and
guidance of Principals)
79.9 21.7 3.443 0.000 Abnormal
This study reports the main question of this
study, which is identified the components of
leadership and their relations with the role of
leadership and guidance of principals as below:
Current status of the role of "leadership and
guidance" of elementary school principals from
primary school teachers’ perspective: 86.8% of
respondents assess the leadership and guidance of
No. of Item
Cronbach’s Alpha Coefficients
Components
10
0.98
Building Trust
10
0.98
Rewarding and creating motivation among staff
10
0.98
Supporting innovation
10
0.97
Communication
10
0.96
Increasing responsibility and accountability among staff
10
0.96
Appling leadership ability of students
10
0.98
Compliance of justice and fairness
70
0.99
Total indicator (leadership and guidance of Principals)
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
16
elementary school principals in very good and good
levels, 7.1% examine this component very low and
low, and 6.1% of respondents have average opinion.
Respondents’ assessment average is 79.9%;
therefore, teachers assess the role of leadership and
guidance of principals in a very good level.
Value of Chi-square test is 474.391 and its
correspondence significance is 0.000. As a result, the
test rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is
confirmed (Table 3).
Table 3: Respondents’ distribution based on leadership and guidance assessment of School’s Principal
Components
Statistics Test values
Dist. Status
Mean
Standard
deviation
K-S Significance Level
Building Trust 81.2 24.1 4.230 0.000 Abnormal
Method of reward, encourage and
motivate staff
74.5 24.7 2.933 0.000 Abnormal
Supporting innovation 78.0 24.0 3.487 0.000 Abnormal
Communication 82.7 24.2 4.608 0.000 Abnormal
Increase Staff’s accountability 83.2 20.7 4.034 0.000 Abnormal
Appling leadership ability of
students
78.3 22.9 3.314 0.000 Abnormal
Compliance of justice and fairness 80.9 24.3 4.166 0.000 Abnormal
Total indicator (leadership and
guidance of Principals)
79.9 21.7 3.443 0.000 Abnormal
Leadership view of teachers about the primary
schools principal’s leadership roles is as follows:
“Trust Building” Component: 86.9% of
respondents assess trust building of principals in
very good and good level, 8.8% assess this
component in low and very low level, and 4.3%
posed average opinion on this issue. Assessment
average is 81.2%. Value of Chi-Square test is 513.761
and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Hence,
teachers assess Trust Building of principals as very
good. As a result, the test rejected the null and a
hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Fig. 1).
Very weak Weak Average Good Very Good
Fig. 1: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of trust building of principals
“Method of reward, encourage and motivate
staff” Component: 76.9% of respondents assess
method of reward, encourage and motivating staffs
component of primary schools’ principals in very
good and good level, 10.4% assess this component in
low and very low level, and 12.7% had average
opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 74.5%.
Value of Chi-Square test is 245.268 and its
correspondent significance is 0.000. Therefore,
teachers assess method of reward, encourage and
motivating staffs by their administrators as very
good (Table 4).
“Supporting innovation” component: 80.6% of
respondents assess supporting innovation
component of primary schools’ principals in very
good and good level, 8.5% assess this component in
low and very low level, and 10.9% had average
opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 78.0%.
Value of Chi-Square test is 340.053 and its
correspondent significance is 0.000, which shows
teachers assess supporting innovation component of
their principals as very good. As a result, the test
rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is
confirmed (Fig. 2).
“Communication” component: 87.8% of
respondents assess communication component of
principals in very good and good level, 8.2% assess
this component in low and very low level, and 4.0%
had average opinion on this issue. Assessment
average is 82.7%. Value of Chi-Square test is 562.138
and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Teachers
assess communication of their principals as very
good. As a result, the test rejected the null and a
hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Table 5).
“Increase accountability of staff” Component:
89.6% of respondents assess “increase
accountability of staff” component of principals in
very good and good level, 4.8% assess this
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
17
component in low and very low level, and 5.6% had average opinion on this issue.
Table 4: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of reward, encourage and motivating staff by principals
Description Frequency
Frequency
Percentage
Valid
Percentage
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Skewness Kurtosis
Very weak 18 4.7 4.8
74.5 24.68 1.26
- 1.29
Weak 21 5.5 5.6
Average 48 12.7 12.7
Good 115 30.3 30.5
Very Good 175 46.2 46.4
No respond 2 0.5 -
SUM 379 100.0 100.0
Very weak Weak Average Good Very Good
Fig. 2: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of principals’ supporting of innovation
Table 5: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of principals’ communications
Description Frequency
Frequency
Percentage
Valid
Percentage
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Skewness Kurtosis
Very weak 18 4.7 4.8
82.71 24.18 2.04
- 3.78
Weak 13 3.4 3.4
Average 15 4.0 4.0
Good 78 20.6 20.7
Very Good 253 66.8 67.1
No respond 2 0.5 -
SUM 379 100.0 100.0
Assessment average is 83.2%. Value of Chi-
Square test is 491.520 and its correspondent
significance is 0.000.
Teachers assess success of “Increase
accountability of staff” of their principals as very
good level (Fig. 3).
Fig. 3: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of increase accountability of schools’ staffs
“Taking advantage of the ability to lead of
students” Component: 81.0% of respondents
assess “taking advantage of the ability to lead of
students” component of principals in very good and
good level, 7.7% assess this component in low and
very low level, and 11.4% had average opinion on
this issue. Assessment average is 78.3%. Value of
Chi-Square test is 330.149 and its correspondent
significance is 0.000.
Teachers assess “taking advantage of the ability
to lead of students” component of principals very
good. As a result, with the rejection of the null,
hypothesis test of this study is confirmed (Table 6).
Table 6: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of taking advantage of the ability to lead of students by principals
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
18
Description Frequency
Frequency
Percentage
Valid
Percentage
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Skewness Kurtosis
Very weak 11 2.9 2.9
78.3 22.85 1.38
- 1.82
Weak 18 4.7 4.8
Average 43 11.3 11.4
Good 105 27.7 27.9
Very Good 200 52.8 53.1
No respond 2 0.5 -
SUM 379 100.0 100.0
“Justice and fairness compliance” Component:
85.5% of respondents assess “Justice and fairness
compliance” component of principals in very good
and good level, 8.3% assess this component in low
and very low level, and 6.2% had average opinion on
this issue. Assessment average is 78.3%. Value of
Chi-Square test is 430.686 and its correspondent
significance is 0.000.
Thus, from the teachers’ view point “Justice and
fairness compliance” is very good. As a result, with
the rejection of the null, hypothesis test of this study
is confirmed (Fig. 4).
Fig.4: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of Justice and fairness compliance of principals
Ranking Seven Components of Leadership and
Guidance in Statistical Population: Highest
average rank is “increase accountability of staff” with
average rank of 4.66 and after that “communication”
component with average rank of 4.64 is placed. The
value of Friedman Test is equal to 280.651and its
correspondent significance is 0.000. This shows that,
an observed difference of average ranks between
seven components is significant and hence it is
generalizable to the population. Therefore, it can be
stated that from the viewpoint of teachers, primary
school principals in sample population has better
condition in “increase accountability of staff” and
“communication” compared to other components.
Also, form the teachers’ perspective, principals of
primary schools in the sample population do not
have good condition in “method of reward,
encourage and motivating staffs” compared to other
components (Table 7).
Table 7: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of leadership and guidance of schools’ principals
Description Frequency
Frequency
Percentage
Valid
Percentage
Mean
Standard
Deviation
Skewness Kurtosis
Very weak 16 4.2 4.2
79.9 21.71 1.69
- 2.83
Weak 11 2.9 2.9
Average 23 6.1 6.1
Good 95 25.1 25.1
Very Good 234 61.7 61.7
SUM 379 100.0 100.0
Considering theoretical principles, literature and
findings of the present study, a framework is
suggested; where each component has mutual effect
with leadership role. I.e. each component has a direct
effect on leadership role of principal and also,
leadership style of that principal has effect on that
regarded element. It also establishes a mutual
relation among all elements; although, some of the
components have greater impact on each other.
Therefore, there is no significant difference between
the components of this proposed framework in
terms of ranking but it is important that each
element placed between those two elements that
have most interactions with that component
compared to the other components. Elements which
have the greatest impact on each other have placed
side by side on a circle and connected to each other
with small two-way arrows. Leadership role is also
placed in the center and connected to each element
with two-way arrows. Choosing a polygonal shape
for leadership role provides this opportunity to add
further components in future. These types of
connections are more like relation between
components of a system; In other words, the
leadership role of principals and its components can
be assumed as a system (Fig. 5).
Fig. 5: Conce
Conceptu
leadership r
elements in
responsibilit
3.Complianc
and creatin
innovation;
leadership a
Ebrahim
leadership s
of school an
distributed
primary: sec
that there
between l
effectivenes
relationship
and perform
studying ma
principals fr
teachers.
Li (201
methods of
and values
This resear
organization
information
their role in
mentioned
transformat
information
patriarchal
poses the
performanc
patriarchal
performanc
the current
of principals
Nickouka
successful e
students’ lea
Ardeb
eptual framew
role of
ual framew
role of princ
ncluding: 1.B
ty and ac
ce of justice
g motivation
6.Commu
ability of stud
and Al-Ta
style of princ
nd its effecti
MLQ questi
condary and
is a signif
leadership
s of his-her
p has not foun
mance of scho
anagerial fac
rom the view
12) investig
f leaders not
of their follo
rcher has as
nal factors
nal, and dist
n leadership.
organizatio
tional lead
nal justice dim
leadership.
most powe
e of follower
leadership
e of followe
study, justic
s which have
ar (2006) s
educational
arning. The r
bil et al/ Internati
work of guidanc
f principals
work of
cipals is sho
uilding Trus
countability
and fairnes
n among sta
nication a
dents.
aneiji (2012
cipal with pe
iveness. The
ionnaire in
high school.
ficant positiv
style of
r role, but
nd between
ool. Current s
ctors and lea
wpoint of ele
gated multi
ticing percep
owers in Chin
ssessed and
of proced
tributive just
Results show
nal justice
dership an
mension can b
Transactio
erful direct
rs regarding
receives li
rs regarding
e is one of th
been studied
studied the
leadership
results imply
ional Journal of A
ce and leadersh
guidance a
own with sev
t; 2. Increas
among st
ss; 4.Reward
ff; 5.Support
and 7.Appl
2) studied
rformance le
researcher
three levels
Results show
ve relations
principal a
any signific
leadership st
study deals w
adership role
ementary sch
ple leaders
ptions of just
nese structur
analyzed fo
ural, person
tice along w
wed that all fo
dimension
d only
be seen more
nal leaders
effect on
their tasks a
ittle effect
g their tasks.
he seven fact
d.
relationship
in school w
that leaders
Advanced and App
19
hip
and
ven
sing
taff;
ding
ting
ling
the
evel
has
s of
wed
ship
and
cant
tyle
with
e of
hool
ship
tice
res.
four
nal,
with
four
in
the
e in
ship
the
and
on
. In
tors
of
with
ship
of
cur
con
Re
com
pri
La
an
pri
the
pra
ha
fac
pri
est
Mi
tea
en
sys
tha
pa
pre
dis
rew
pre
pla
com
pri
oth
ab
com
sho
fro
in.
4.
hu
hu
res
avo
thi
qu
pe
Jud
tha
tru
sam
err
5.
eff
pri
rea
Est
qu
an
aim
ma
plied Sciences, 2(
principal is
rriculum of
nsiderable
esearchers of
mponents w
incipals in t
ngaroudi (20
d perceptua
incipals of el
ere is a sig
actices. On th
ve been stu
ctors have a
incipal. Gho
tablishment o
nistry of Edu
achers. Ghol
courage and
stem of know
at the amo
rticipants’ re
esent study
scussed lead
ward system”
Results ind
esenting enc
aced in the
mponents bu
incipals is pl
her compone
out these
mponents h
owed that p
om the teach
Limitation o
Researches
uman studies
uman limitati
strictions of
oiding them
is study is su
uestionnaire.
ople can b
dgment of p
at may create
uth with re
mpling is don
ror are drama
Conclusions
In this stu
fective leade
incipals. Pro
alizing effe
tablishing s
uality of huma
d shape thes
m, the princip
anagers. Ther
(10) 2015, Pages:
effective on
school and
effect on
f present stu
which are e
their leaders
003) studied
al practices
lementary sc
nificant rela
he other side
udied in this
noticeable e
olami (2005
of knowledge
ucation from
lami assesse
reward sys
wledge manag
ount of the
esponses is
, three effe
dership facto
” and “comm
dicate that s
ourage and
e lowest lev
ut in case of co
aced in the s
ents. In pres
seven gui
ave been a
principals ha
hers’ viewpoi
of the study
being unde
often face co
ions. Some
tools and re
seems imp
urvey and its
In this case, t
e involved
eople is bas
e some dama
esponses of
ne randomly,
atically reduc
s
udy, a frame
rship compo
oductivity o
ective edu
uch an env
an relations o
se relationshi
pals utilize ro
refore, to stu
: 13‐20
n quality of
d this leade
learning o
tudy have ev
effective on
ship role. Ta
d triple techn
of male
chools. Resul
ationship bet
e, leadership
s research
effect on hum
) studied t
e manageme
the perspect
ed six fact
stem and com
gement. The r
e factors a
lower than
ective elem
ors are “enc
munications”.
success of p
reward meth
vel compare
ommunicatio
second level
sent researc
dance and
asked teache
ave acceptab
int on these
ertaken in
omplexity, an
of these lim
esearch techn
possible. Met
s tool is rese
the personal
in the col
sed on their
ages in the a
individuals
this means a
ced.
ework is pr
onents and
of schools
ucational e
vironment
on that. Princ
ips at school
ole and leade
udy effective
f educational
rship has a
of students.
valuated the
success of
aghvaye and
nical, human,
and female
ts show that
tween these
components
which these
man skills of
the rate of
nt in Isfahan
tive of female
tors include
mmunication
results imply
ccording to
average. In
ents among
courage and
principals in
hod factor is
ed to other
on, success of
compared to
ch, questions
leadership
ers. Findings
ble condition
components
the field of
d ethical and
mitations are
niques which
thodology of
archer made
judgment of
lected data.
perceptions
ccordance of
s, but since
and methods’
resented for
practices of
depends on
environment.
depends on
cipals design
s. Based this
ership task of
components
l
a
.
e
f
d
,
e
t
e
s
e
f
f
n
e
e
n
y
o
n
g
d
n
s
r
f
o
s
p
s
n
s
f
d
e
h
f
e
f
.
s
f
e
’
r
f
n
.
n
n
s
f
s
Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20
20
and practices of leadership is necessary. Principals
should be aware of what these elements are, how
their relationship together should be and how the
mentioned elements effect on their leadership role.
For this purpose, seven components and their
relations to principals’ leadership from perspective
of teachers have been studied in the present study.
These seven components includes method of reward,
encourage and motivate staff, building trust and
supporting innovation, communication, increase
accountability of staff, taking advantage of the ability
to lead students, justice and fairness compliance,
overall indicator (leadership and guidance of
Principals).
Results show that teachers recognized the
success of their principals as very good level in all
seven components as well as the overall index of
leadership. The teachers evaluated principals in two
responsibility and accountability and also in
communications as best performance and in
encourage and motivate staff compared to the other
components had weaker performance. Results
indicate that findings of this research are
generalizable to the population.
Present recommended framework in this study
shows principals who play leadership role have to
notice a systematic or semi-systematic relation
between components and leadership and should
know that weakness in any of the components has
not only effect on leadership but has effects all other
components. Hence, poor performance of each
component undermines the role of leadership. Also,
senior managers should pay special attention to this
point for selecting their manager thus organizational
efficiency increase or at least does not decrease. It is
recommended to perform further researches to
identify other important effective factors on
managers’ leadership and study the practicality of
this framework for other organizations through
scientific methods.
References
Ebrahim AS and Al-Taneiji S. (2012). Principal
leadership style, school performance and
principal effectiveness in Dubai schools.
International Journal of Research studies
Education, 2(1): 41-54.
Gholami B (2006). The view of female teachers on
the establishment of knowledge management
factors in Education Department of Isfahan in
Academic year 2005-2006.M.A. Thesis, Khorasgan
branch, Islamic Azad University, Khorasgan.
Grissom JA and Loeb S (2011). Triangulating
Principal Effectiveness: How perspectives of
parents, teachers and assistant principals identify
the central Importance of Managerial skills.
American Educational Research Journal, 48(5):
1091-1123.
Leithwood K, Seashore LK, Anderson S & Wahlstrom
K (2004). Review of research: How leadership
influences student learning, University of
Minnesota, Center for Applied Research and
Educational Improvement and Wallace
Foundation, USA: 4-88.
Leithwooda K, Harrisb A & Hopkinsc D (2008). Seven
strong claims about successful school leadership.
School leadership and management, 28(1): 27-42.
Lewin K (1951). Field theory in social science:
selected theoretical papers, Edited by D.
Cartwright: Oxford, England: 1-346.
Li J (2012). Leadership, supervisor-focused justice,
and follower values: A comparison of three
leadership approaches in China. Ph.D. Thesis,
University of Cincinnati.
Likert R (1961). New patterns of management,
McGraw-Hill pub., USA: 1-278.
Nickoukar SA (2006). Successful educational
leadership of school. Retrieved from
etu.isfedu.org
Robbins SP (2001). Organizational Behavior. 9th ed.:
Prentice Hall Inc, New Jersey: 313-314.
Saadati SA (2007). Study of the relationship between
quality dimensions of organizational leadership
principals and the creativity of teachers in male
High Schools in Maneh and Salmghan, M.A.
Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Bojnord.
Taghvaye S and Langaroudi F (2003). Study of triple
skills (technical, human, and conceptual) male
and female managers of elementary schools in
Region2 of Tehran. M.A. Thesis. Islamic Azad
University Central Tehran Branch.

More Related Content

Similar to A Framework For Effective Leadership Practices And Skills For School Principals

Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...Azreen5520
 
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...Azreen5520
 
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...iosrjce
 
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...Eduexcellence
 
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfSUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfssuser9c1e1d
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...om collins
 
My research proposal
My research proposalMy research proposal
My research proposalom collins
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE om collins
 
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...AkashSharma618775
 
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...AkashSharma618775
 
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...Ramakanta Mohalik
 
Article 1 reginald leon green done
Article 1 reginald leon green doneArticle 1 reginald leon green done
Article 1 reginald leon green doneWilliam Kritsonis
 
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...Lhoraine Tolentino
 
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...ijtsrd
 
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...Alexander Decker
 
How leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningHow leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningElniziana
 

Similar to A Framework For Effective Leadership Practices And Skills For School Principals (20)

Ej1134498 (1)
Ej1134498 (1)Ej1134498 (1)
Ej1134498 (1)
 
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal? How Teachers Assess the Performan...
 
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...
Article Review:What Makes a Good Principal?How Teachers Assess the Performanc...
 
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...
The Influence Of Individual Characteristics And Job Characteristics On Vocati...
 
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...
EDUCARNIVAL 2014 at IIT Delhi- School leadership and its effect on student ac...
 
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdfSUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
SUCCESSFUL LEADERSHIP.pdf
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE ON STUDENTS...
 
My research proposal
My research proposalMy research proposal
My research proposal
 
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
THE IMPACT OF SCHOOL LEADERSHIP ON STUDENTS’ ACADEMIC PERFORMANCE
 
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
 
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
Administrative Behavior and Personal Traits of the School Heads of Bulan Dist...
 
Ej1075155
Ej1075155Ej1075155
Ej1075155
 
Ej1089789
Ej1089789Ej1089789
Ej1089789
 
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...
Leadership style of Head teachers at secondary level in West Bengal. Internat...
 
Article 1 reginald leon green done
Article 1 reginald leon green doneArticle 1 reginald leon green done
Article 1 reginald leon green done
 
Nursheha copyright
Nursheha copyrightNursheha copyright
Nursheha copyright
 
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...
Strengthening Collaborative Leadership for Thai Primary School Administrators...
 
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...
Informational Communication and Leadership Aspect Influence of College Deans ...
 
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...
Analysis of teachers motivation on the overall performance of public basic sc...
 
How leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learningHow leadership-influences-student-learning
How leadership-influences-student-learning
 

More from Nathan Mathis

Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, Fre
Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, FrePage Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, Fre
Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, FreNathan Mathis
 
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy News
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy NewsHow To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy News
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy NewsNathan Mathis
 
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper Prin
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper PrinLined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper Prin
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper PrinNathan Mathis
 
Term Paper Example Telegraph
Term Paper Example TelegraphTerm Paper Example Telegraph
Term Paper Example TelegraphNathan Mathis
 
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast Essay
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast EssayUnusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast Essay
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast EssayNathan Mathis
 
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, Essa
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, EssaHow To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, Essa
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, EssaNathan Mathis
 
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background Ex
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background ExRecolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background Ex
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background ExNathan Mathis
 
Microsoft Word Lined Paper Template
Microsoft Word Lined Paper TemplateMicrosoft Word Lined Paper Template
Microsoft Word Lined Paper TemplateNathan Mathis
 
Owl Writing Paper
Owl Writing PaperOwl Writing Paper
Owl Writing PaperNathan Mathis
 
The Essay Writing Process Essays
The Essay Writing Process EssaysThe Essay Writing Process Essays
The Essay Writing Process EssaysNathan Mathis
 
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - As
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - AsHow To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - As
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - AsNathan Mathis
 
Awesome Creative Writing Essays Thatsnotus
Awesome Creative Writing Essays ThatsnotusAwesome Creative Writing Essays Thatsnotus
Awesome Creative Writing Essays ThatsnotusNathan Mathis
 
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For You
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For YouSites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For You
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For YouNathan Mathis
 
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - HuNathan Mathis
 
Essay Written In First Person
Essay Written In First PersonEssay Written In First Person
Essay Written In First PersonNathan Mathis
 
My Purpose In Life Free Essay Example
My Purpose In Life Free Essay ExampleMy Purpose In Life Free Essay Example
My Purpose In Life Free Essay ExampleNathan Mathis
 
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including TextThe Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including TextNathan Mathis
 
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - Quora
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - QuoraWhat Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - Quora
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - QuoraNathan Mathis
 
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later Bibliogra
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later BibliograPlease Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later Bibliogra
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later BibliograNathan Mathis
 
Ide Populer Word In English, Top
Ide Populer Word In English, TopIde Populer Word In English, Top
Ide Populer Word In English, TopNathan Mathis
 

More from Nathan Mathis (20)

Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, Fre
Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, FrePage Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, Fre
Page Borders Design, Border Design, Baby Clip Art, Fre
 
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy News
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy NewsHow To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy News
How To Write Your Essays In Less Minutes Using This Website Doy News
 
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper Prin
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper PrinLined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper Prin
Lined Paper For Beginning Writers Writing Paper Prin
 
Term Paper Example Telegraph
Term Paper Example TelegraphTerm Paper Example Telegraph
Term Paper Example Telegraph
 
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast Essay
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast EssayUnusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast Essay
Unusual How To Start Off A Compare And Contrast Essay
 
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, Essa
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, EssaHow To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, Essa
How To Write A Methodology Essay, Essay Writer, Essa
 
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background Ex
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background ExRecolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background Ex
Recolectar 144 Imagem Educational Background Ex
 
Microsoft Word Lined Paper Template
Microsoft Word Lined Paper TemplateMicrosoft Word Lined Paper Template
Microsoft Word Lined Paper Template
 
Owl Writing Paper
Owl Writing PaperOwl Writing Paper
Owl Writing Paper
 
The Essay Writing Process Essays
The Essay Writing Process EssaysThe Essay Writing Process Essays
The Essay Writing Process Essays
 
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - As
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - AsHow To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - As
How To Make A Cover Page For Assignment Guide - As
 
Awesome Creative Writing Essays Thatsnotus
Awesome Creative Writing Essays ThatsnotusAwesome Creative Writing Essays Thatsnotus
Awesome Creative Writing Essays Thatsnotus
 
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For You
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For YouSites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For You
Sites That Write Papers For You. Websites That Write Essays For You
 
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu
4.4 How To Organize And Arrange - Hu
 
Essay Written In First Person
Essay Written In First PersonEssay Written In First Person
Essay Written In First Person
 
My Purpose In Life Free Essay Example
My Purpose In Life Free Essay ExampleMy Purpose In Life Free Essay Example
My Purpose In Life Free Essay Example
 
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including TextThe Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
The Structure Of An Outline For A Research Paper, Including Text
 
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - Quora
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - QuoraWhat Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - Quora
What Are Some Topics For Exemplification Essays - Quora
 
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later Bibliogra
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later BibliograPlease Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later Bibliogra
Please Comment, Like, Or Re-Pin For Later Bibliogra
 
Ide Populer Word In English, Top
Ide Populer Word In English, TopIde Populer Word In English, Top
Ide Populer Word In English, Top
 

Recently uploaded

Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactPECB
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfAdmir Softic
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingTechSoup
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdfQucHHunhnh
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsTechSoup
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxAreebaZafar22
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxDenish Jangid
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104misteraugie
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhikauryashika82
 
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfAn Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfSanaAli374401
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docxPoojaSen20
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesCeline George
 
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07Dr. Mazin Mohamed alkathiri
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionMaksud Ahmed
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfagholdier
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxVishalSingh1417
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfciinovamais
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfChris Hunter
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
 
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdfKey note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
Key note speaker Neum_Admir Softic_ENG.pdf
 
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy ConsultingGrant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
Grant Readiness 101 TechSoup and Remy Consulting
 
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi  6.pdf
1029-Danh muc Sach Giao Khoa khoi 6.pdf
 
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The BasicsIntroduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
Introduction to Nonprofit Accounting: The Basics
 
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptxICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
ICT Role in 21st Century Education & its Challenges.pptx
 
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptxBasic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
 
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
Nutritional Needs Presentation - HLTH 104
 
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in DelhiRussian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
Russian Escort Service in Delhi 11k Hotel Foreigner Russian Call Girls in Delhi
 
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
Mehran University Newsletter Vol-X, Issue-I, 2024
 
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdfAn Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
An Overview of Mutual Funds Bcom Project.pdf
 
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
PROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docxPROCESS      RECORDING        FORMAT.docx
PROCESS RECORDING FORMAT.docx
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin ClassesMixin Classes in Odoo 17  How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
Mixin Classes in Odoo 17 How to Extend Models Using Mixin Classes
 
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
Advance Mobile Application Development class 07
 
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introductionmicrowave assisted reaction. General introduction
microwave assisted reaction. General introduction
 
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdfHoldier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
Holdier Curriculum Vitae (April 2024).pdf
 
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptxUnit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
Unit-IV; Professional Sales Representative (PSR).pptx
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdfMaking and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
Making and Justifying Mathematical Decisions.pdf
 

A Framework For Effective Leadership Practices And Skills For School Principals

  • 1. International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 Contents lists available at Science‐Gate International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences Journal homepage: http://www.science‐gate.com/IJAAS.html 13 A framework for effective leadership practices and skills for school principals Susan Karimzadeh Ardebil1, Lotfollah Abbasi Sarvak2, Seyed Farhad Eftekharzadeh2, Azadeh Mehrpouyan2,* 1Department of Education Science, Rodehen Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran 2Department of Education Science, Central Tehran Branch, Islamic Azad University, Tehran, Iran A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T Article history: Received 2 October 2015 Received in revised form 7 November 2015 Accepted 23 November 2015 This paper extends to inspire a shared vision of leadership at schools and identify the practices and components that describe effective leadership. This research also addresses to identify leadership components and their own interrelationships on leadership practices. This paper examines the current status of school principals and grades the studied components and features in this study. This study was conducted through descriptive method and the sampling was done by simple random. Randomly- Cluster and stratified- relatively sampling, the effectiveness of seven identified components on leadership of elementary schools principals’ performance from teachers’ perspective. A framework is designed to increase the effective leadership role of principals and school efficiency, develop students’ social abilities and promote the senior managers to apply the identified components in selecting principals. The paper reports the principals has the highest performance in responsibility and accountability of staff and the lowest performance in the methods of inspiration, rewarding and creating motivation among staff. The results show that a significant difference exists between these two of the mentioned variables of leadership features i.e. cohesion, correlation and solidary among these six components in the designed framework are a must in order to fulfill the leadership. Keywords: Leadership Practices Skills School principals Components Framework Š 2015 IASE Publisher. All rights reserved. 1. Introduction *Efficiency of schools is basically affected by leadership ability of principal and is result of his/her attitude, insight, social and moral character. It is necessary to deal with the most basic role of principal i.e. leadership ability of schools in order to increase the efficiency of education system particularly in social and moral character building. Leader principals pose a vision for their schools and are well aware to achieve mentioned vision. An effective educational environment demands the following basic characteristics of this environment such as dynamic and active cooperation among effective people in education, and reinforcing and supporting their innovative spirits. Since teaching is a core responsibility of teachers and pose the highest rate in the relationship among students and principal, teachers can be the most effective people in the educational environment. Then, being aware of teachers’ attitude toward the leadership role of principal is one of the most appropriate methods to evaluate leadership ability of a school principal. This matter requires describing the major practices and components of leadership. * Corresponding Author. Email Address: dr.mehrpooyan@gmail.com A large and basic stream of literature in the area of principals’ leadership has identified independent dimensions of leadership and the effective behaviors of scientific leadership (e.g. Lewin et al., 1951; Likert et al., 1961; Robbins, 2001). Moyer (1995) studied a method of leadership oriented or group oriented method through teachers’ attitude on job and personal satisfaction about principal behavior based on one of these two methods. Williafrodin (1973) examined a relationship between principal and staff in primary schools of United States with indirect function components based on the rate of observed effective characters by primary schools teachers. Bayard Sally (2011) conducted a study on quantitative analysis of relations between trust of teachers, automation and educational function of schools. Ghafooryan (2002) assessed the functional components of elementary schools of Tehran city. Khajeyee (2001) evaluated skills and qualification of primary schools’ principals to obtain an appropriate management model. Amiri (2007) investigated a relationship between communication skills of managers and staff job satisfaction in Central administration offices of Northern Khorasan (quoted by Grissom and Loeb, 2011). Saadati (2007) also studied a relationship between dimensions of organizational leadership quality and teachers’ creativity rate of boy high
  • 2. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 14 schools in Maneh and Salmaghan. Grissom and Loeb (2011) studied general leadership skills which have a relationship with school’s outcome and showed a skill can constantly predict the rate of student progress and other successes depend on organizational management of principal. The analysis argues for a broad view of principal leadership that includes organizational management skills as a key complement to the work of supporting curriculum and instruction (quoted by Grissom and Loeb, 2011). Symmetry of social character formation and sociability of children with school going age of 6 -7 makes significant to study primary school period in this research. Guidance and giving directions to educational and training processes depend on quality and the way which human relationship underpin at schools and principals are in charge for that; moreover, sociability can be another responsibility of principals. Hence, it is necessary to pay a special attention to the leadership role of principles and its relevant components and their qualifications for obtaining this responsibility in order to increase efficiency at schools. Leithwood et al. (2008) summarizes the main findings from the wealth of empirical studies undertaken in the leadership field and suggest seven strong claims about successful school leadership. On the other hand, this research extends seven components for effective leadership from teachers’ perspective and they might be helpful to principal selection and school performance. Hence, the researchers identify leadership components and examine their interrelationship and relationship with leadership role. Leadership is second only to teaching in its impact on student outcomes (Leithwood et al., 2004). Principals play an essential role as school leaders to achieve. The principal objective of the present research is to identify the practices and components that describe effective leadership. Leader practices are the actions, behaviors and functions found through research and professional experience to have a positive impact on school achievement from teachers’ point of view. Leader components are the skills of effective principals. The framework is not intended as a job description for the leader, or as a checklist against which to assess performance. Rather, it provides framework for growth, which are sufficiently detailed to describe good leadership. Structure of the framework is made up of a major part: leader practices and components. This research was studied through descriptive and literature review survey with applied purpose. This study was conducted in government elementary schools in 19 districts of Tehran education organization. 2. Materials and methods The study was conducted in 2013-2014 in Tehran, Capital city of Iran. The data were collected through researcher-made questionnaire. Items identified from literature review helped in the construction of the survey instrument. 2.1. Sample In the light of the objectives of present study, the survey population was identified as teachers of government-primary schools in Tehran in 2013 – 2014. A convenience sample of 10838 woman teachers and 764 men teachers was drawn using systematic sampling of Krejcie & Morgan Table. As increasing need for a representative statistical sample in empirical research, Krejcie & Morgan Table (1970) has created a demand for an effective method of determining sample size. Present researchers selected this table in order to determine sample size for a given population for easy reference. According to Krejcie & Morgan Table, the sample size for given population of 15000 people determines 375 sample size including 350 female teachers and 25 male teachers. The sample size of present study is 379 (quoted by Leithwood et al., 2004). Sampling methods are clustered randomized and class proportional. Initially, Tehran city has divided into five sectors of north, west, east, and center. Next, accidentally regions number of 3, 8,9,11, and 16 are selected for sampling and schools of these regions are selected as analyzing units. Sampling was carried out based on gender regarding number of female to male teachers’ ratio to the population of total number of teachers each region of Tehran in primary school section. The researchers attempted to select the schools from different urban areas for further standardizing in sampling of statistical population. High volume of the required samplings in each region made call many schools and teachers for responding the questionnaires. Hence, the number of participating schools in each region regarding the required sample volume of each region reaches over 50 schools. 2.2. Instrument survey The researcher-made questionnaire contained two following information sections: a-Personal profile and demographic information b-Questionnaire questions according to study problems Present questionnaire includes 70 questions in 7 sections in 5 scales that evaluate principle’s behavior in each specific case with 10 descriptive questions. The limits of scales are as follows very low, low, medium, high, and very high. Over 50 relevant standard and researcher-made questionnaires has been studied to provide present questionnaire e.g. “Standards of school principals” questionnaire by educational board of New York City. This questionnaire determines some standards for government school principals of New York and the first priority of these standards is “educational leadership standard” of principal.
  • 3. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 15 For descriptive analysis of data, frequency indexes, frequency, standard deviation, percent, skewness, elongation, and for inferential analysis of data univariate chi-square, Kruskal-Wallis, Whitney U, and Friedman test has been used. The reliability of questionnaire examined and confirmed by research guide and consultant professors, and expert professionals. Utilizing Cronbach’s alpha coefficients validity and reliability of present questionnaire has been summarized (See Table 1). Cronbach’s alpha in each component and total components approves popularizing, reliability and repeatability of current test. Table1: The reliability of questionnaire In descriptive statistics section, firstly assessment of responses to questions breakdown of each component has been studied and in the next step, an index is created from the sums of questions of an index for the considered component. Average of respondents’ assessment of each of questionnaires’ questions are indexed in the scale of 1 to 5 and average of components (sums of questions related to each component) are stated in the scale of 1 to 100. For studying method of variables distribution Kolmogorov–Smirnov test (K-S test or KS test) is used. If significant scale of Kolmogorov– Smirnov test (sig) is lower than 0.05; it shows that variable distribution is abnormal. Since all questions are descriptive and the distribution of all variables is abnormal, Single Variable Chi-Square test was used which is a subset of non-parametric tests. In Single Variable Chi-Square test, the observed statistical frequency for each item is compared to the predicted statistical frequency of that item and also, being significant or insignificant differences between them is studied. For example, if frequency is 379 and 5 choices exist to respond each question, the predicted frequency for each choice will be 75.8 and the observed frequency i.e. answer to each question will be compared to 75.8, and then being significant or insignificant differences between these two numbers will determined through Chi-Square test. To rank the seven components of leading and guiding of principals from teachers’ perspective, Friedman test is used. In this test, mean differences between the scales of some variables in a correlated sample is measured and their significances are studied. This study shows that function of which principals have been better in one or more observed components. 3. Results and findings Kolmogorov Smirnov test was carried out and the corresponding significance with test (KS) in all indicators is less than 0.05 and the results show that the distributions of studied components are abnormal (See Table 2). Table 2: Results of Kolmogorov-Smirnov test (KS) for checking the status of variable distribution of the study Components Statistics Test values Dist. Status Mean Standard deviation K-S Significance Level Building Trust 81.2 24.1 4.230 0.000 Abnormal Method of reward, encouragement and motivate staff 74.5 24.7 2.933 0.000 Abnormal Supporting innovation 78.0 24.0 3.487 0.000 Abnormal Communication 82.7 24.2 4.608 0.000 Abnormal Increasing Staff’s accountability 83.2 20.7 4.034 0.000 Abnormal Appling leadership ability of students 78.3 22.9 3.314 0.000 Abnormal Compliance of justice and fairness 80.9 24.3 4.166 0.000 Abnormal Total indicator (leadership and guidance of Principals) 79.9 21.7 3.443 0.000 Abnormal This study reports the main question of this study, which is identified the components of leadership and their relations with the role of leadership and guidance of principals as below: Current status of the role of "leadership and guidance" of elementary school principals from primary school teachers’ perspective: 86.8% of respondents assess the leadership and guidance of No. of Item Cronbach’s Alpha Coefficients Components 10 0.98 Building Trust 10 0.98 Rewarding and creating motivation among staff 10 0.98 Supporting innovation 10 0.97 Communication 10 0.96 Increasing responsibility and accountability among staff 10 0.96 Appling leadership ability of students 10 0.98 Compliance of justice and fairness 70 0.99 Total indicator (leadership and guidance of Principals)
  • 4. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 16 elementary school principals in very good and good levels, 7.1% examine this component very low and low, and 6.1% of respondents have average opinion. Respondents’ assessment average is 79.9%; therefore, teachers assess the role of leadership and guidance of principals in a very good level. Value of Chi-square test is 474.391 and its correspondence significance is 0.000. As a result, the test rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Table 3). Table 3: Respondents’ distribution based on leadership and guidance assessment of School’s Principal Components Statistics Test values Dist. Status Mean Standard deviation K-S Significance Level Building Trust 81.2 24.1 4.230 0.000 Abnormal Method of reward, encourage and motivate staff 74.5 24.7 2.933 0.000 Abnormal Supporting innovation 78.0 24.0 3.487 0.000 Abnormal Communication 82.7 24.2 4.608 0.000 Abnormal Increase Staff’s accountability 83.2 20.7 4.034 0.000 Abnormal Appling leadership ability of students 78.3 22.9 3.314 0.000 Abnormal Compliance of justice and fairness 80.9 24.3 4.166 0.000 Abnormal Total indicator (leadership and guidance of Principals) 79.9 21.7 3.443 0.000 Abnormal Leadership view of teachers about the primary schools principal’s leadership roles is as follows: “Trust Building” Component: 86.9% of respondents assess trust building of principals in very good and good level, 8.8% assess this component in low and very low level, and 4.3% posed average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 81.2%. Value of Chi-Square test is 513.761 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Hence, teachers assess Trust Building of principals as very good. As a result, the test rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Fig. 1). Very weak Weak Average Good Very Good Fig. 1: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of trust building of principals “Method of reward, encourage and motivate staff” Component: 76.9% of respondents assess method of reward, encourage and motivating staffs component of primary schools’ principals in very good and good level, 10.4% assess this component in low and very low level, and 12.7% had average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 74.5%. Value of Chi-Square test is 245.268 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Therefore, teachers assess method of reward, encourage and motivating staffs by their administrators as very good (Table 4). “Supporting innovation” component: 80.6% of respondents assess supporting innovation component of primary schools’ principals in very good and good level, 8.5% assess this component in low and very low level, and 10.9% had average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 78.0%. Value of Chi-Square test is 340.053 and its correspondent significance is 0.000, which shows teachers assess supporting innovation component of their principals as very good. As a result, the test rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Fig. 2). “Communication” component: 87.8% of respondents assess communication component of principals in very good and good level, 8.2% assess this component in low and very low level, and 4.0% had average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 82.7%. Value of Chi-Square test is 562.138 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Teachers assess communication of their principals as very good. As a result, the test rejected the null and a hypothesis of this study is confirmed (Table 5). “Increase accountability of staff” Component: 89.6% of respondents assess “increase accountability of staff” component of principals in very good and good level, 4.8% assess this
  • 5. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 17 component in low and very low level, and 5.6% had average opinion on this issue. Table 4: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of reward, encourage and motivating staff by principals Description Frequency Frequency Percentage Valid Percentage Mean Standard Deviation Skewness Kurtosis Very weak 18 4.7 4.8 74.5 24.68 1.26 - 1.29 Weak 21 5.5 5.6 Average 48 12.7 12.7 Good 115 30.3 30.5 Very Good 175 46.2 46.4 No respond 2 0.5 - SUM 379 100.0 100.0 Very weak Weak Average Good Very Good Fig. 2: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of principals’ supporting of innovation Table 5: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of principals’ communications Description Frequency Frequency Percentage Valid Percentage Mean Standard Deviation Skewness Kurtosis Very weak 18 4.7 4.8 82.71 24.18 2.04 - 3.78 Weak 13 3.4 3.4 Average 15 4.0 4.0 Good 78 20.6 20.7 Very Good 253 66.8 67.1 No respond 2 0.5 - SUM 379 100.0 100.0 Assessment average is 83.2%. Value of Chi- Square test is 491.520 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Teachers assess success of “Increase accountability of staff” of their principals as very good level (Fig. 3). Fig. 3: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of increase accountability of schools’ staffs “Taking advantage of the ability to lead of students” Component: 81.0% of respondents assess “taking advantage of the ability to lead of students” component of principals in very good and good level, 7.7% assess this component in low and very low level, and 11.4% had average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 78.3%. Value of Chi-Square test is 330.149 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Teachers assess “taking advantage of the ability to lead of students” component of principals very good. As a result, with the rejection of the null, hypothesis test of this study is confirmed (Table 6). Table 6: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of taking advantage of the ability to lead of students by principals
  • 6. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 18 Description Frequency Frequency Percentage Valid Percentage Mean Standard Deviation Skewness Kurtosis Very weak 11 2.9 2.9 78.3 22.85 1.38 - 1.82 Weak 18 4.7 4.8 Average 43 11.3 11.4 Good 105 27.7 27.9 Very Good 200 52.8 53.1 No respond 2 0.5 - SUM 379 100.0 100.0 “Justice and fairness compliance” Component: 85.5% of respondents assess “Justice and fairness compliance” component of principals in very good and good level, 8.3% assess this component in low and very low level, and 6.2% had average opinion on this issue. Assessment average is 78.3%. Value of Chi-Square test is 430.686 and its correspondent significance is 0.000. Thus, from the teachers’ view point “Justice and fairness compliance” is very good. As a result, with the rejection of the null, hypothesis test of this study is confirmed (Fig. 4). Fig.4: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of Justice and fairness compliance of principals Ranking Seven Components of Leadership and Guidance in Statistical Population: Highest average rank is “increase accountability of staff” with average rank of 4.66 and after that “communication” component with average rank of 4.64 is placed. The value of Friedman Test is equal to 280.651and its correspondent significance is 0.000. This shows that, an observed difference of average ranks between seven components is significant and hence it is generalizable to the population. Therefore, it can be stated that from the viewpoint of teachers, primary school principals in sample population has better condition in “increase accountability of staff” and “communication” compared to other components. Also, form the teachers’ perspective, principals of primary schools in the sample population do not have good condition in “method of reward, encourage and motivating staffs” compared to other components (Table 7). Table 7: Respondents’ frequency based on assessment of leadership and guidance of schools’ principals Description Frequency Frequency Percentage Valid Percentage Mean Standard Deviation Skewness Kurtosis Very weak 16 4.2 4.2 79.9 21.71 1.69 - 2.83 Weak 11 2.9 2.9 Average 23 6.1 6.1 Good 95 25.1 25.1 Very Good 234 61.7 61.7 SUM 379 100.0 100.0 Considering theoretical principles, literature and findings of the present study, a framework is suggested; where each component has mutual effect with leadership role. I.e. each component has a direct effect on leadership role of principal and also, leadership style of that principal has effect on that regarded element. It also establishes a mutual relation among all elements; although, some of the components have greater impact on each other. Therefore, there is no significant difference between the components of this proposed framework in terms of ranking but it is important that each element placed between those two elements that have most interactions with that component compared to the other components. Elements which have the greatest impact on each other have placed side by side on a circle and connected to each other with small two-way arrows. Leadership role is also placed in the center and connected to each element with two-way arrows. Choosing a polygonal shape for leadership role provides this opportunity to add further components in future. These types of connections are more like relation between components of a system; In other words, the leadership role of principals and its components can be assumed as a system (Fig. 5).
  • 7. Fig. 5: Conce Conceptu leadership r elements in responsibilit 3.Complianc and creatin innovation; leadership a Ebrahim leadership s of school an distributed primary: sec that there between l effectivenes relationship and perform studying ma principals fr teachers. Li (201 methods of and values This resear organization information their role in mentioned transformat information patriarchal poses the performanc patriarchal performanc the current of principals Nickouka successful e students’ lea Ardeb eptual framew role of ual framew role of princ ncluding: 1.B ty and ac ce of justice g motivation 6.Commu ability of stud and Al-Ta style of princ nd its effecti MLQ questi condary and is a signif leadership s of his-her p has not foun mance of scho anagerial fac rom the view 12) investig f leaders not of their follo rcher has as nal factors nal, and dist n leadership. organizatio tional lead nal justice dim leadership. most powe e of follower leadership e of followe study, justic s which have ar (2006) s educational arning. The r bil et al/ Internati work of guidanc f principals work of cipals is sho uilding Trus countability and fairnes n among sta nication a dents. aneiji (2012 cipal with pe iveness. The ionnaire in high school. ficant positiv style of r role, but nd between ool. Current s ctors and lea wpoint of ele gated multi ticing percep owers in Chin ssessed and of proced tributive just Results show nal justice dership an mension can b Transactio erful direct rs regarding receives li rs regarding e is one of th been studied studied the leadership results imply ional Journal of A ce and leadersh guidance a own with sev t; 2. Increas among st ss; 4.Reward ff; 5.Support and 7.Appl 2) studied rformance le researcher three levels Results show ve relations principal a any signific leadership st study deals w adership role ementary sch ple leaders ptions of just nese structur analyzed fo ural, person tice along w wed that all fo dimension d only be seen more nal leaders effect on their tasks a ittle effect g their tasks. he seven fact d. relationship in school w that leaders Advanced and App 19 hip and ven sing taff; ding ting ling the evel has s of wed ship and cant tyle with e of hool ship tice res. four nal, with four in the e in ship the and on . In tors of with ship of cur con Re com pri La an pri the pra ha fac pri est Mi tea en sys tha pa pre dis rew pre pla com pri oth ab com sho fro in. 4. hu hu res avo thi qu pe Jud tha tru sam err 5. eff pri rea Est qu an aim ma plied Sciences, 2( principal is rriculum of nsiderable esearchers of mponents w incipals in t ngaroudi (20 d perceptua incipals of el ere is a sig actices. On th ve been stu ctors have a incipal. Gho tablishment o nistry of Edu achers. Ghol courage and stem of know at the amo rticipants’ re esent study scussed lead ward system” Results ind esenting enc aced in the mponents bu incipals is pl her compone out these mponents h owed that p om the teach Limitation o Researches uman studies uman limitati strictions of oiding them is study is su uestionnaire. ople can b dgment of p at may create uth with re mpling is don ror are drama Conclusions In this stu fective leade incipals. Pro alizing effe tablishing s uality of huma d shape thes m, the princip anagers. Ther (10) 2015, Pages: effective on school and effect on f present stu which are e their leaders 003) studied al practices lementary sc nificant rela he other side udied in this noticeable e olami (2005 of knowledge ucation from lami assesse reward sys wledge manag ount of the esponses is , three effe dership facto ” and “comm dicate that s ourage and e lowest lev ut in case of co aced in the s ents. In pres seven gui ave been a principals ha hers’ viewpoi of the study being unde often face co ions. Some tools and re seems imp urvey and its In this case, t e involved eople is bas e some dama esponses of ne randomly, atically reduc s udy, a frame rship compo oductivity o ective edu uch an env an relations o se relationshi pals utilize ro refore, to stu : 13‐20 n quality of d this leade learning o tudy have ev effective on ship role. Ta d triple techn of male chools. Resul ationship bet e, leadership s research effect on hum ) studied t e manageme the perspect ed six fact stem and com gement. The r e factors a lower than ective elem ors are “enc munications”. success of p reward meth vel compare ommunicatio second level sent researc dance and asked teache ave acceptab int on these ertaken in omplexity, an of these lim esearch techn possible. Met s tool is rese the personal in the col sed on their ages in the a individuals this means a ced. ework is pr onents and of schools ucational e vironment on that. Princ ips at school ole and leade udy effective f educational rship has a of students. valuated the success of aghvaye and nical, human, and female ts show that tween these components which these man skills of the rate of nt in Isfahan tive of female tors include mmunication results imply ccording to average. In ents among courage and principals in hod factor is ed to other on, success of compared to ch, questions leadership ers. Findings ble condition components the field of d ethical and mitations are niques which thodology of archer made judgment of lected data. perceptions ccordance of s, but since and methods’ resented for practices of depends on environment. depends on cipals design s. Based this ership task of components l a . e f d , e t e s e f f n e e n y o n g d n s r f o s p s n s f d e h f e f . s f e ’ r f n . n n s f s
  • 8. Ardebil et al/ International Journal of Advanced and Applied Sciences, 2(10) 2015, Pages: 13‐20 20 and practices of leadership is necessary. Principals should be aware of what these elements are, how their relationship together should be and how the mentioned elements effect on their leadership role. For this purpose, seven components and their relations to principals’ leadership from perspective of teachers have been studied in the present study. These seven components includes method of reward, encourage and motivate staff, building trust and supporting innovation, communication, increase accountability of staff, taking advantage of the ability to lead students, justice and fairness compliance, overall indicator (leadership and guidance of Principals). Results show that teachers recognized the success of their principals as very good level in all seven components as well as the overall index of leadership. The teachers evaluated principals in two responsibility and accountability and also in communications as best performance and in encourage and motivate staff compared to the other components had weaker performance. Results indicate that findings of this research are generalizable to the population. Present recommended framework in this study shows principals who play leadership role have to notice a systematic or semi-systematic relation between components and leadership and should know that weakness in any of the components has not only effect on leadership but has effects all other components. Hence, poor performance of each component undermines the role of leadership. Also, senior managers should pay special attention to this point for selecting their manager thus organizational efficiency increase or at least does not decrease. It is recommended to perform further researches to identify other important effective factors on managers’ leadership and study the practicality of this framework for other organizations through scientific methods. References Ebrahim AS and Al-Taneiji S. (2012). Principal leadership style, school performance and principal effectiveness in Dubai schools. International Journal of Research studies Education, 2(1): 41-54. Gholami B (2006). The view of female teachers on the establishment of knowledge management factors in Education Department of Isfahan in Academic year 2005-2006.M.A. Thesis, Khorasgan branch, Islamic Azad University, Khorasgan. Grissom JA and Loeb S (2011). Triangulating Principal Effectiveness: How perspectives of parents, teachers and assistant principals identify the central Importance of Managerial skills. American Educational Research Journal, 48(5): 1091-1123. Leithwood K, Seashore LK, Anderson S & Wahlstrom K (2004). Review of research: How leadership influences student learning, University of Minnesota, Center for Applied Research and Educational Improvement and Wallace Foundation, USA: 4-88. Leithwooda K, Harrisb A & Hopkinsc D (2008). Seven strong claims about successful school leadership. School leadership and management, 28(1): 27-42. Lewin K (1951). Field theory in social science: selected theoretical papers, Edited by D. Cartwright: Oxford, England: 1-346. Li J (2012). Leadership, supervisor-focused justice, and follower values: A comparison of three leadership approaches in China. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Cincinnati. Likert R (1961). New patterns of management, McGraw-Hill pub., USA: 1-278. Nickoukar SA (2006). Successful educational leadership of school. Retrieved from etu.isfedu.org Robbins SP (2001). Organizational Behavior. 9th ed.: Prentice Hall Inc, New Jersey: 313-314. Saadati SA (2007). Study of the relationship between quality dimensions of organizational leadership principals and the creativity of teachers in male High Schools in Maneh and Salmghan, M.A. Thesis, Islamic Azad University, Bojnord. Taghvaye S and Langaroudi F (2003). Study of triple skills (technical, human, and conceptual) male and female managers of elementary schools in Region2 of Tehran. M.A. Thesis. Islamic Azad University Central Tehran Branch.