Progress Two Years On:
Inclusive Tourism Project in Kayah State:
Ms. Winnie Mai, Assistant Project Coordinator, ITC
Daw Mu Lon, Coordinator, Pan Pet CBT Group
Mr. Peter Richards, Consultant on Cultural Tourism Development, ITC
13th and 14th June, 2017
Horizon Lake View Hotel, Nay Pyi Taw
Today’s Presentation
1 – Project Overview
2 – How do you define success for their CBT project?
3 – Share the success stories of the past two years
4 – Share the challenges and issues of the past two years
5 – What is your advice to communities thinking of being
involved in tourism?
6 – What do you hope to achieve in the next two years?
3
Local SMEs
and communities
Tour operators
Sector
Associations
National and
State
government
HIGHLIGHT: SUPPLY CHAIN APPROACH
Important, strategic actions were
taken at each step along the chain,
from local communities through
to European markets…
Enhance
Myanmar’s
tourism industry
as a way out of
poverty
Project overview: Inclusive Tourism w/ a focus on Kayah
Supply chain project
with CBT component
Context and challenge: from 10
minute, ‘Long Neck’ sightseeing
tour to a full ‘Kayan’ experience
Trekking & Artisans Trail in Pan Pet
 Interpretive trek, lead by
trained local guides;
 Seasonal homemade
lunch by womens’ group;
 Visit local homes and
meet artisans who make
Kayan bracelets, textiles
and bamboo weaving,
carving, millet wine.
Half and full day tours in Hta Nee La Leh, Kayah Community
Hta Nee La Leh, Kayah Community
Replication: Htay Khu, Kayaw village: crafts tour and trekking
Replication: Daw Tha Ma Gyi, Kayah Community – ON HOLD
CBT training of trainers, across ethnic groups
Creative tourism in Loikaw: The Kayah
Sausage experience (2-3h)
Make your own traditional Kayah Sausage
Interact with a local producer
Taste it!
In Loikaw: The Path of natural Dyeing (1h)
tour along a natural path, discover the natural colours
Experience natural dyeing
Visit a weaving workshop, its machines and Kayah Products
Step by step, on the job training & coaching process
Training for community guides and licensed guides
Building marketing capacity and linkages from Kayah to EU
Capacity building at the market end, too:
• In partnership CBI, Dutch government
• Export Marketing training / coaching
• Sustainable tourism / HRD training
• Support for Kayah product integration
• Support trade fair participation
Market access coaching for effective trade fair participation
Need for good information
about the new community
based cultural tours in Kayah.
Need for tourists, guides and
operators to use the tours.
Need to help local community
members who are offering CBT
to solve challenges. Need to
support community to collect
/use data (no tourists, $, etc.).
The CBT Check In… Promotion and Backstopping
How does ITC define success for CBT?
More job opportunities for local communities and SMEs;
More time and money spent in the target communities;
A wider range of CBT / local products and experiences;
More partnerships between Kayah ground handlers and
Yangon based tour operators, sending guests on trips;
Local community members have new skills / confidence
More opportunities for villagers to tell their stories;
Better, richer, more inspiring experiences for visitors;
Manageable in the future as visitor numbers increase.
Success stories: a snapshot of progress
International
Tourists to Kayah
(MOHT, Loikaw)
2014 2015 2016
2,662
Up 79%
3,933
Up 48%
6,374
Up 62%
• At the start of the project, there were no local tour operators,
only transport services. Now, there is an established ground
handling sector, taking bookings from 30 + national DMC / TO’s.
• Loikaw GH’s made industry contacts as a result of ITC FAM trips;
• These GH’s earned total over $45,000 USD for bookings in 2016.
• @500 people in Kayah regularly participating in ITC trainings.
• Gender balance: over 50% participation by women.
• 2016: 811 tourists to Pan Pet, 769 to Hta Nee La Leh, via ITC.
• = Over 1500 community visits of several hours Vs 10-20 minutes
• Prem Song / Salong Kana CBT: Sep to Dec 2016: 2,454,600 Ks
• Hta Nee La Leh CBT: income Jan to Dec 2016 4,377,500 Ks
• However – true ROI will be realized as a field learning center
Building human capacity and capital to improve lives
Meals
59%
Local guide
11%
Community fund
10%
Artisan
9%
Ox cart
8%
Dance
2%
Other
1%
Distribution of income Hta Nee La Leh
Meals Local guide Community fund Artisan Ox cart Dance Other
This is where
the capacity
building work
was focused…
Success factors
Step by step supply chain approach from communities to
the market: strong focus on facilitating market linkages;
ITC management flexible to invest time in trust building;
Effective and trustworthy local leadership made a big
difference to results. Hta Nee La Leh Vs Pan Pet situation.
Actively engaging with local ground handlers / regional
tour guides /inviting them to join activities often (this was
relatively easier because they were mainly new businesses);
Internationals brought in expertise from similar socio-
cultural context, plus local intuition through local team;
Excellent support from MOHT focal point and in Loikaw;
Mobilizing youth volunteers, who became ToT trainees.
Challenges / lessons learned
Low levels of trust in the post conflict context;
Tourism training alone is not enough in remote areas.
Need resources for more infrastructure / basic needs / a
more integrated community development approach;
Some tour operators and guides are still not using the
CBT programs, despite very thorough outreach / training.
Tension between government / ethnic groups impacted
the replication of the project in Daw Ta Ma Gyi;
In the future, managing increased visitation will be a
challenge. ITC have addressed this through the CBT
Check In. However, additional planning and new
destination development will be required in the future.
Overall advice for stakeholders developing CBT
1. Developing tourism in partnership with
communities requires step by step
trust building / training / coaching +
respect, sufficient time and flexibility.
2. Supply chain approach: strategic
capacity building all along the chain: at
destination, B2B hubs, market.
3. Building trusting relationships should
be part of the whole process. Harness
all opportunities to invite tour
operators to visit communities, share
ideas, earn trust, form relationships.
4. Build partnerships at destination level
(e.g. : ground handlers, guides,
community, DMOs, VOLUNTEERS)
What do you hope to achieve in the next 2 years?
Consolidate existing CBT communities
Work with MOHT to plan for the future: balancing
supply / demand / further development;
Fully operational CBT Check In
Replicate model in another state?
Kayah as a CBT Study Center
Share lessons learned for benefit of Myanmar
Keep up to date with the project on our Facebook page
Thank-you for the chance to share experiences

4. kayah cbt project 13 june 2017

  • 1.
    Progress Two YearsOn: Inclusive Tourism Project in Kayah State: Ms. Winnie Mai, Assistant Project Coordinator, ITC Daw Mu Lon, Coordinator, Pan Pet CBT Group Mr. Peter Richards, Consultant on Cultural Tourism Development, ITC 13th and 14th June, 2017 Horizon Lake View Hotel, Nay Pyi Taw
  • 2.
    Today’s Presentation 1 –Project Overview 2 – How do you define success for their CBT project? 3 – Share the success stories of the past two years 4 – Share the challenges and issues of the past two years 5 – What is your advice to communities thinking of being involved in tourism? 6 – What do you hope to achieve in the next two years?
  • 3.
    3 Local SMEs and communities Touroperators Sector Associations National and State government HIGHLIGHT: SUPPLY CHAIN APPROACH Important, strategic actions were taken at each step along the chain, from local communities through to European markets… Enhance Myanmar’s tourism industry as a way out of poverty Project overview: Inclusive Tourism w/ a focus on Kayah Supply chain project with CBT component
  • 4.
    Context and challenge:from 10 minute, ‘Long Neck’ sightseeing tour to a full ‘Kayan’ experience
  • 5.
    Trekking & ArtisansTrail in Pan Pet  Interpretive trek, lead by trained local guides;  Seasonal homemade lunch by womens’ group;  Visit local homes and meet artisans who make Kayan bracelets, textiles and bamboo weaving, carving, millet wine.
  • 6.
    Half and fullday tours in Hta Nee La Leh, Kayah Community Hta Nee La Leh, Kayah Community
  • 7.
    Replication: Htay Khu,Kayaw village: crafts tour and trekking
  • 8.
    Replication: Daw ThaMa Gyi, Kayah Community – ON HOLD
  • 9.
    CBT training oftrainers, across ethnic groups
  • 10.
    Creative tourism inLoikaw: The Kayah Sausage experience (2-3h) Make your own traditional Kayah Sausage Interact with a local producer Taste it!
  • 11.
    In Loikaw: ThePath of natural Dyeing (1h) tour along a natural path, discover the natural colours Experience natural dyeing Visit a weaving workshop, its machines and Kayah Products
  • 12.
    Step by step,on the job training & coaching process
  • 13.
    Training for communityguides and licensed guides
  • 14.
    Building marketing capacityand linkages from Kayah to EU
  • 15.
    Capacity building atthe market end, too: • In partnership CBI, Dutch government • Export Marketing training / coaching • Sustainable tourism / HRD training • Support for Kayah product integration • Support trade fair participation Market access coaching for effective trade fair participation
  • 16.
    Need for goodinformation about the new community based cultural tours in Kayah. Need for tourists, guides and operators to use the tours. Need to help local community members who are offering CBT to solve challenges. Need to support community to collect /use data (no tourists, $, etc.). The CBT Check In… Promotion and Backstopping
  • 17.
    How does ITCdefine success for CBT? More job opportunities for local communities and SMEs; More time and money spent in the target communities; A wider range of CBT / local products and experiences; More partnerships between Kayah ground handlers and Yangon based tour operators, sending guests on trips; Local community members have new skills / confidence More opportunities for villagers to tell their stories; Better, richer, more inspiring experiences for visitors; Manageable in the future as visitor numbers increase.
  • 18.
    Success stories: asnapshot of progress International Tourists to Kayah (MOHT, Loikaw) 2014 2015 2016 2,662 Up 79% 3,933 Up 48% 6,374 Up 62% • At the start of the project, there were no local tour operators, only transport services. Now, there is an established ground handling sector, taking bookings from 30 + national DMC / TO’s. • Loikaw GH’s made industry contacts as a result of ITC FAM trips; • These GH’s earned total over $45,000 USD for bookings in 2016. • @500 people in Kayah regularly participating in ITC trainings. • Gender balance: over 50% participation by women. • 2016: 811 tourists to Pan Pet, 769 to Hta Nee La Leh, via ITC. • = Over 1500 community visits of several hours Vs 10-20 minutes • Prem Song / Salong Kana CBT: Sep to Dec 2016: 2,454,600 Ks • Hta Nee La Leh CBT: income Jan to Dec 2016 4,377,500 Ks • However – true ROI will be realized as a field learning center
  • 19.
    Building human capacityand capital to improve lives Meals 59% Local guide 11% Community fund 10% Artisan 9% Ox cart 8% Dance 2% Other 1% Distribution of income Hta Nee La Leh Meals Local guide Community fund Artisan Ox cart Dance Other This is where the capacity building work was focused…
  • 20.
    Success factors Step bystep supply chain approach from communities to the market: strong focus on facilitating market linkages; ITC management flexible to invest time in trust building; Effective and trustworthy local leadership made a big difference to results. Hta Nee La Leh Vs Pan Pet situation. Actively engaging with local ground handlers / regional tour guides /inviting them to join activities often (this was relatively easier because they were mainly new businesses); Internationals brought in expertise from similar socio- cultural context, plus local intuition through local team; Excellent support from MOHT focal point and in Loikaw; Mobilizing youth volunteers, who became ToT trainees.
  • 21.
    Challenges / lessonslearned Low levels of trust in the post conflict context; Tourism training alone is not enough in remote areas. Need resources for more infrastructure / basic needs / a more integrated community development approach; Some tour operators and guides are still not using the CBT programs, despite very thorough outreach / training. Tension between government / ethnic groups impacted the replication of the project in Daw Ta Ma Gyi; In the future, managing increased visitation will be a challenge. ITC have addressed this through the CBT Check In. However, additional planning and new destination development will be required in the future.
  • 22.
    Overall advice forstakeholders developing CBT 1. Developing tourism in partnership with communities requires step by step trust building / training / coaching + respect, sufficient time and flexibility. 2. Supply chain approach: strategic capacity building all along the chain: at destination, B2B hubs, market. 3. Building trusting relationships should be part of the whole process. Harness all opportunities to invite tour operators to visit communities, share ideas, earn trust, form relationships. 4. Build partnerships at destination level (e.g. : ground handlers, guides, community, DMOs, VOLUNTEERS)
  • 23.
    What do youhope to achieve in the next 2 years? Consolidate existing CBT communities Work with MOHT to plan for the future: balancing supply / demand / further development; Fully operational CBT Check In Replicate model in another state? Kayah as a CBT Study Center Share lessons learned for benefit of Myanmar
  • 24.
    Keep up todate with the project on our Facebook page Thank-you for the chance to share experiences