Case Study: One Jackson Square
Philip Murray, PE
Karl Rubenacker, PE, SE
April 23RD
, 2015
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Project Team
• Hines
• KPF
• SLCE
• GMS
• Flack & Kurtz
• RA Consultants
• Vollmer
• Cerami
• Hunter Roberts
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
New Building Information
• Luxury Residential
Development
• Condominium
• ~ 3 dozen Apartments
• 56,000 SF Residential
• 9,000 SF ground floor
retail
• 11 Stories
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Subway
Map
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Site Background Information
• NYC Subway Eighth Ave.
Line 1932
• NYC Sells Lot to Private
Developer 1948
• Attempt at
Development 1980
• Parking Lot Until this
Project
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
20’
Site Plan
Site
Subway
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Allowable Bldg
Area
30’
Challenges
• Subway tunnel
below two-thirds
of site
• MTA substation
next door
• >250,000 Riders
pass under site
each day
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
More Challenges
• Historic Landmark District
• Neighboring URM Buildings
• Active Community
• Straddles 2 Zoning Districts
• Six-sided Irregular Lot
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Solutions
• Sensitivity to NYCTA
Issues during design
• Care during
construction
• Structure vertical load
within allowable
• No lateral load imposed
on tunnel
• Isolation of the building
from Subway Vibration
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
NYC Transit Approval Process
• Multiple meetings w/NYCTA staff
• Multiple drawing & calculation
submittals
• Adjustments to design
• Duration ~ 9 months
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Subway Protection Measures
• Preconstruction survey
• Monitoring during construction
• Limitation on equipment
• Lateral support during excavation
• Limitation on construction
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Monitoring
• 15 points in tunnel
• Twice/week during foundation work
• Once/story during superstructure work
• 3 months & 6 months after topping
out
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Typical Floor
Plan
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Shear walls
Subway
Roof Plan
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Subway
Structure –
Foundation
Interaction
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Subway
Structure
Analysis
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Foundation
Plan
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
24” Dia
Caisson In
30” Dia
Sleeve
24” Dia
Caisson
Foundation
Cross-
section
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Springs
Caissons
Caissons
• 24 inch round caisson, reinforced
concrete core
• Socketed into the bedrock
• Fixed top & bottom
• Approx 40 kip lateral load
• Approx 750 kip vertical load
• Bedrock ~ 45’ below grade
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Caissons
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Isolation
Springs and
Bearings
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Isolation
Spring
Isolation
Lateral Bracing
Isolators
• Spring assembly pads used to isolate
the building laterally from the subway
tunnel
• Reduces acoustic transmission, for
residential viability
• Lateral bearings provide resistance to
base shear
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Column
Isolation
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Spring Assembly Pads
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Lateral
Bearing
Detail
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Lateral Bearings
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Engineering Data
• Building weight ~ 22,000 kip
• Seismic base shear ~ 1000 kip (R=3)
• Building period ~ 0.9 sec/cycle
• Wind base shear ~ 500 kip
• Wind base shear ~ 250 kip
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Superstructure Data
• Concrete flat plate
• Irregular column layout
• Typically 8” slab thickness
• Punching shear reinforcement
• Transfer floor 16” thick
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Construction
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
ASCE Structures Congress 2015
Thank You
ASCE Structures Congress 2015

2015 Structures Congress - One Jackson Square