10. 4
Reflection of chapter 4
(The environmental context)
For this reflection, the concept that I have picked is from The
Environmental Context in chapter 4. The specific concept that
the paper will discuss is the concept of the cultural preference
for privacy. This is a concept that explains that different
cultures have different preferences for privacy both online and
offline. The preference of privacy ranges from solitude to
isolation to intimacy with friends or with the family to
anonymity and finally reserves. The level of preference that a
culture has forms the basis upon which certain policies are set,
how people socialize and the basis of deciding how to structure
their houses and living spaces.
I have had an experience with this concept especially in regard
to the preference for privacy on the online space. Some time
back in a group of very diverse individual, a topic was raised
about the numerous censoring and limitation that is done on the
web in China. In the group, there was one Chinese individual
who tried to explain that it works well for them and their
country. However, most the other individuals in the group
including myself who come from a culture where there is a lot
of freedom on the internet where individuals can access
anything and post anything, they like were against the whole
concept of internet censoring.
We went round and round telling the Chinese individuals how
the government was denying them a right to freedom and how
much more they were missing on the internet because of being
locked out by the government. No matter how much he tried to
explain how that worked well for their society, none of us were
hearing any of it because we were all convinced that what their
government does is wrong. Surprisingly at the end of the whole
11. discussion and debate, the Chinese individual seemed very
unmoved by our many opinions and was still okay with this
approach the government had decided to take to monitor
activities on their web. From this experience, however, I ended
up feeling like we had gone on an on to impose our views and
criticisms without giving ourselves a chance to listen and
understand the point of view of the one person who felt that
such policies were okay for their country.
If I knew then what I know now that is the concepts of this
course in regard to the fact that different cultures have different
preferences of privacy the experience for me would be very
different. This is because I would have made contributions to
the discussion from a point of a lot more understanding rather
than just imposing my opinion like what everyone else did. I
would have been able to see and understand the point of view of
the Chinese fellow in the group when he said that what they
have worked for them and consequently be more accommodative
of the fact we all do not have to be the same and that our needs
are not their needs.
The communication or the debate, in this case, would have been
more constructive because the argument would be made with
consideration of the differences we have in culture and
preferences. This would have helped to accommodate and bring
to the table different objective rather than subjective points of
view and consequently make the debate a lot more constructive
for all involved. The knowledge that different cultures have
different preferences for privacy help us see why individuals
make the different choices that they do in policies and
structures and that it is okay, and we do not need to impose our
beliefs or critiques on them without understanding the basics.