A 49-year-old female presented with right upper quadrant pain and was found to have multiple gallbladder polyps on ultrasound. She underwent a laparoscopic cholecystectomy. Histopathology revealed the polyps were benign. Gallbladder polyps can present ambiguously with biliary colic-like pain. While polyps larger than 1 cm or in patients over 50 increase malignancy risk, the relationship between polyp number and risk is still unclear. Treatment depends on polyp size, with observation for polyps under 6 mm and cholecystectomy for larger polyps.