Most organizations operating in today’s job market face challenges associated with baby boomer retirement and employee turnover. Those challenges include the retention and maintenance of critical job knowledge and the effectiveness of subsequent hiring efforts with a labor pool formed by a growing number of millennials.
How do organizations navigate today’s labor market while ensuring that a knowledge vacuum isn’t created in the process?
Based on recent research completed with more than 225 learning organizations, this session will share the strategies and best practices learning leaders have adopted for managing the talent pipeline through all phases of the employee lifecycle: pre-employment development, onboarding, knowledge capture and knowledge transfer.
Presentation by Tracy Cox, Director, Applied Strategies and Ken Taylor, President, Training Industry
Introduction to LPC - Facility Design And Re-Engineering
Recognizing Labor Pool Challenges - Driving Knowledge Across the Employee Lifecycle
1. Recognizing Labor Pool Challenges
Driving Knowledge Across the Employee Lifecycle
Ken Taylor (ktaylor@trainingindustry.com)
President, Training Industry
Tracy Cox (tcox@raytheon.com)
Director, Applied Strategies
Raytheon Professional Services LLC
April 14, 2015
1
2. Training Industry
Training Industry is a market intelligence firm for corporate learning and development.
Our focus is on helping business and training professionals obtain the information, insight
and tools needed to more effectively manage the business of learning.
2
3. Raytheon Professional Services
Raytheon
– Over 90 years of innovation
– 62,000 employees worldwide
– Defense, Homeland Security, Aerospace
Raytheon Professional Services
– High consequence training expertise worldwide
– Trains more than 2 million people a year
– 1,100 learning professionals
– Over 100 countries and 28 languages
– Learning solutions designed to solve critical business
challenges
3
4. State of the Labor Pool
Need for effective onboarding, knowledge capture, and knowledge
transfer processes driven by
– Percentage of the global workforce over age 65 growing rapidly
– Median tenure for workers in the U.S. was 4.6 years in 2000; 3.5 years in 2012
– “Millennials” under the age of 35 have an average tenure of 2.3 years, making hiring
and onboarding efforts more common
– Median age of employees was 42.3 years in 2012; only 39.4 in 2000
4
5. Research Demographics
252 respondents from companies across the globe
participated in research
Industries represented
– Technology/telecommunications, 16%
– Business services, 12%
– Financial services, 12%
– Healthcare/Medical, 9%
– Government, 8%
62% came from HR departments
70% represent leadership roles (managerial/executive)
59% came from organizations with 500+ employees
5
6. The Employee Lifecycle
Addressing the skills gap
– Collaborate with local
colleges/universities
– Skill development
apprenticeships
– Internships/scholarships
Pre-
Employment Onboarding
Knowledge
Capture
Knowledge
Transfer
Follow up on 2012 Study
– Tools & Technology
– Best practices
– Challenges
– Trends
Demographic shifts
– Baby boomer
retirement
– Turnover
– Knowledge retention
techniques/tools
6
7. The Employee Lifecycle in the New Millennium
Pre-
Employment Onboarding
Knowledge
Capture
Knowledge
Transfer
Clear understanding of skills required for their position
Information at the pre-employment stage helps potential employees
understand roles, responsibilities, and risks
Focused on setting up potential employees for quick assimilation into the
organization and their roles
Pre-employment development inherently guided by knowledge transfer
from organizational/process stakeholders
7
8. Labor Pool Effectiveness with
Current/Future Hiring Needs
5%
36%
48%
11%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Not at all Somewhat to a moderate extent To a great extent
Percentage of respondents, N = 242
41% report that the labor pool does
not meet their hiring needs
59% report that the labor pool meets
their hiring needs
8
9. Best Practices for Pre-Employment
Development
Offering internships and other forms of pre-employment training
(e.g., certifications, apprenticeships)
Providing candidates with information about organizational culture and policies
Partnering with academic
institutions to develop industry
relevant curricula
Providing candidates with
realistic job previews
Identifying emerging skill
requirements
9
10. The Employee Lifecycle in the New Millennium
Pre-
Employment Onboarding
Knowledge
Capture
Knowledge
Transfer
Onboarding in many industries often involves compliance requirements and/or
certifications
If onboarding is ineffective, high-risk scenarios on the job could result in
danger to employees, co-workers, or customers
Consistent implementation of onboarding programs is key to success and
safety
Onboarding in high consequence jobs can last significantly longer (6 months
to 1 year) compared to most formal onboarding programs (~1 month)
10
11. 2012 vs. 2014: Onboarding Effectiveness
11
16%
54%
20%
10%
12%
54%
23%
11%
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
Very effective Somewhat effective Somewhat ineffective Very ineffective
70% Effective
Percentage of 2014 respondents, N = 245 Percentage of 2012 respondents, N = 206
30% Ineffective
12. Best Practices for Onboarding
Developing a formal onboarding framework
Evaluating effectiveness of programs regularly
Ensuring consistency in implementation for
ongoing onboarding and training programs
Involving leadership before, during and after
the onboarding program
Understanding from current employees what
it takes to be successful
12
84% of organizations using instructor-led training
(ILT), meetings, shadowing, and short-form content
rate themselves effective at onboarding
13. The Employee Lifecycle in the New Millennium
Pre-
Employment Onboarding
Knowledge
Capture
Knowledge
Transfer
The process of knowledge capture is integral to continued organizational
functioning; without capturing and documenting job tasks, relationships and
dependencies, or procedures and processes, there is no content to inform
knowledge transfer
Ineffective knowledge capture can represent a single point of failure in many
companies’ employee lifecycles
Key component of ensuring knowledge that is transferred is up-to-date with the
speed of the market
– e.g., Technological advancements, vertical and horizontal market penetration,
growing competitive landscape
13
14. Effective vs. Ineffective Groups’ Use of
Knowledge Capture Best Practices
14
5%
33%
34%
28%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
30%
35%
40%
Very effective Somewhat effective Somewhat ineffective Very ineffective
38% Effective 62% Ineffective
Percentage of respondents, N = 236
15. Best Practices for Knowledge Capture
Best Practices
– Conducting exit interviews
– Documenting job roles and processes
– Encouraging mentoring, cross training,
knowledge sharing, and social collaboration
Effective knowledge capture
programs are substantially more
likely to use:
– Knowledge repositories
– Assessments
– Online FAQs answered by SMEs
– Videos
15
16. The Employee Lifecycle in the New Millennium
Pre-
Employment Onboarding
Knowledge
Capture
Knowledge
Transfer
Transfer of critical knowledge to employees’ successors is vital to high
consequence jobs where subject matter expertise is a job requirement
Lack of an effective knowledge transfer strategy can inhibit the
development of new and seasoned professionals
16
18. Best Practices for Knowledge Transfer
Facilitating informal learning (P2P/team training, mentor networks, etc.)
Delivering information in a variety of methods, focusing on ease of use and
comprehension
Ensuring leadership support and
involvement
Developing a formal knowledge transfer
strategy and integrating it into daily
operations
Constantly monitoring and updating
the company knowledge repository
18
76% of organizations using work shadowing, paired work and
coaching rate themselves effective at knowledge transfer
20. Key Takeaways
41% of organizations report that the labor pool only somewhat or does
not meet their current and future hiring needs and only 11% of
organizations report that it does fully
Almost half (49%) of organizations report that employee retirement is a
moderate or great problem
The majority (70%) of organizations are rated effective at onboarding
new employees
38% of organizations are rated effective at capturing the knowledge of
key employees and 48% are rated effective at transferring knowledge
20
22. Recognizing Labor Pool Challenges
Driving Knowledge Across the Employee Lifecycle
Tracy Cox
tcox@raytheon.com
Director, Performance Consulting
Raytheon Professional Services LLC
Ken Taylor
(ktaylor@trainingindustry.com)
President, Training Industry
Visit our website:
www.rps.com
Call us: (+1) 972‐205‐5300
Connect with us on one of our social networks:
LinkedIn: Raytheon Professional Services LLC Group
Twitter: @RaytheonRPS
Visit our website:
www.trainingindustry.com
Call us: (+1) 919-653-4992
Connect with us on one of our social networks:
LinkedIn: Training Industry, Inc.
Twitter: @trainingindustry
22
*(Tracy
Raytheon is a technology and innovation leader specializing in defense, homeland security and other government
history of innovation spanning 90 years, Raytheon provides state-of-the-art electronics, mission systems integration and other capabilities in the areas of sensing; effects; and command, control, communications and intelligence systems, as well as a broad range of mission support services.
RPS leads the industry in global learning solutions,
We help organizations improve their operations by designing, implementing, and managing efficient training solutions that align employees to critical goals.
Raytheon teams with NASA at the Neutral Buoyancy Lab in Houston Texas – largest swimming pool in the world.
By applying R6s RPS helps healthcare organizations meet their high consequence objectives by quantifying and making visible
fragmentation, redundancy, and gaps in the learning value stream.
When critical training really matters,. High consequence training Raytheon is there
As lean six sigma practitioners – we see the world through a lens that many others are blind to –
WASTE and VARIATION ARE ALL AROUND US
Tracy:
Ken: Training Industry, Inc. and Raytheon Professional Services LLC conducted a study to examine the programs and initiatives that organizations are using to address these issues. In August 2014, 252 companies completed a survey reporting their organizations’ strategies, effectiveness, and best practices for training employees across the lifecycle.
Tracy:
Pre-employment development
Refers to the process of preparing future employees with information about the relevant competencies and skills required of a specific job or about the practices of the hiring organization
Onboarding
Refers to the process through which new employees acquire the skills, knowledge and behaviors to become effective contributors to an organization
Knowledge Capture
Refers to the process through which an individual's technical knowledge is obtained and recorded such that insights, experiences, social networks and lessons learned can be shared to mitigate organizational knowledge loss
Knowledge Transfer
Refers to the process through which experienced employees share or distribute their knowledge, skills, and behaviors to the employees who replace them
Our research showed that:
Effectiveness in one area is highly related to effectiveness in all other areas and generally related to reports that hiring needs are met for the organization
Beyond the pre-employment development stage, 29% of organizations are effective in all three areas (onboarding, capture and transfer)
Effectiveness was not related to whether or not retirement was considered a pressing issue
Tracy
Ken
Ken
No single practice for pre-employment was endorsed significantly more than others—effective pre-employment develop involves a constellation of practices
Tracy
In high consequence industries such as health care, oil and gas, and aerospace, effective onboarding programs are critical to the success of the business and the safety of employees and potential customers
Effective onboarding can make the difference between employees prepared to respond to and mitigate problems and employees that fail to properly address a life-threatening crisis due to lack of knowledge/skills
Ken
.
Research found that organizations with effective onboarding were more likely to use ILT, formal meetings, job shadowing/observation, short e-learning pieces, coaching, videos, and mentor networks
*Coaching in particular was used twice as often (54%) in effective orgs compared to ineffective orgs (27%)
2012 vs 2014 org ratings:
66% effective vs 70% effective
No marked differences in use of most common onboarding modalities (e.g., 62% ILT in 2012, 66% in 2014; 57% short-form content in 2012, 55% in 2014)
Ken does the slide
then
Tracy: From a supplier side, this continues to be an important focus……..
Shadowing/OTJ observation used by 55% of companies (n.r. in 2012, so new information)
2012 research also identified leadership support and continuous evaluation as best practices
Tracy
Ken
The single point of failure in many organizations’ employee lifecycle? Only 38% are rated effective; knowledge capture is a vital part of the feedback loop between transfer, onboarding, and pre-employment development
Research found that organizations with effective knowledge capture were more likely to use knowledge repositories, regular assessments/metrics, online FAQs, and videos
Ken
Tracy
Research found that organizations with effective knowledge transfer were more likely to use job shadowing, coaching, paired work, knowledge repositories, mentor networks, and rotational assignments
2012 vs 2014 org ratings:
39% effective vs 48% effective
On “very ineffective” ratings, went from 28% in 2012 to 18% in 2014
Ken
41% of ineffective organizations did not endorse any best practices
2014 research showed lower utilization of transfer strategy trends compared to 2012, such as short-form content (e.g., job aids, quick references, 47% 2012, 34% 2014), knowledge repositories (42% 2012, 30% 2014), short e-learning pieces (35% 2012, 22% 2014), and use of chat/forums (21% 2012, 8% 2014
Ken
).
Tracy
Summary of key take aways
Ken:
We’re doing better by entry level employees and new comers than for transitioning and more senior employees
Most organizations operating in today’s market face “boomer” retirement and employee turnover, with a labor pool formed by a growing number of millennials, and a need to retain and maintain critical job knowledge. This is especially critical to high consequence contexts, where new employees need to master information as quickly as possible that has been captured and transferred from retiring/separating employees.
How do organizations navigate today’s labor market while ensuring that a knowledge vacuum isn’t created in the process?
The answer is through alignment of all phases of the employee lifecycle to ensure job-related knowledge and skills are perpetuated through the role itself and do not reside solely with an individual in the role.
Scenarios:
An IT database firm creating HRM solutions for DoD
An IT provider supplying enterprise infrastructure upgrades to a military branch
Org Size:
Gov’t: tends to be between 500 and 10k employees
Tech: Can ranges from small (<50) to very large (10k+)
Government high on labor pool being a problem
Tech is lowest for employee retirement being a problem, government is highest
Gov’t uses pre-employment best practice of partnering with academia for relevant curricula more often
Tech invests more in technical skills onboarding
Gov’t uses onboarding best practice of leadership support more often
Tech uses onboarding best practice of continuous assessment for improvement more often
Scenarios:
A medical device company seeking forecasting assistance
A hospital network seeking consulting on investments in owning versus leasing high-cost medical diagnostic equipment
Org Size:
Medical: tends to be 5k to 10k employees
Financial Svcs: majority are 5K+
Labor pool/retirement not a particular problem for either industry vertical
Financial svcs uses pre-employment best practice of providing org culture/policy info more often
Medical invests more in technical skills onboarding
Medical uses onboarding best practice of developing a framework more often
Medical uses knowledge capture best practice of conducting exit interviews more often
Financial svcs uses knowledge capture best practice of encouraging mentoring/knowledge sharing/social collaboration more often