SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 60
Download to read offline
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and,
Auctions
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Universidad del Turabo
August 16, 2018
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Outline
1 Asymmetric Information
Moral Hazard
Adverse Selection
2 Uncertainty
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Asymmetric Information
In purely competitive markets all agents are fully
informed about traded commodities and other aspects
of the market.
Markets with one side or the other imperfectly
informed are markets with imperfect information.
Imperfectly informed markets with one side better
informed than the other are markets with
asymmetric information.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Asymmetric Information: Some examples
A worker knows more than his employer about how
much eļ¬€ort he puts into his job. (example of a hidden
action)
A seller of a used car knows more than the buyer
about the carā€™s condition. (example of a hidden
characteristic).
a customer knows her taste for a good or a service
better than the ļ¬rm that supplies and prices it.
(example of a hidden characteristic).
a person knows more about his driving habits than the
company that provides his auto insurance (example of
a hidden characteristic)
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Asymmetric Information
Hidden actions are actions taken by one side of an
economic relationship (agent) that the other side of the
relationship (principal) cannot observe.
Agent: a person who is performing an act for another
person, called the Principal.
Hidden characteristics are things that one side of a
transaction knows about itself that the other side
would like to know but does not.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Asymmetric Information
Moral Hazard
Problems after a contract is written.
The tendency of an imperfectly monitored agent to
engage in dishonest or otherwise undesirable behavior.
Adverse Selection
Problems before a contract is written.
Refers to the tendency for the mix of unobserved
attributes to become undesirable from the standpoint
of an uniformed party.
Imperfect information inļ¬‚uences resource allocation
and the price system.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Moral Hazard
Classic example: employment. The employer is the
principal and the worker is the agent. Moral Hazard
is the temptation of imperfectly monitored workers to
shirk their responsibilities.
Employerā€™s possible responses to Moral Hazard:
better monitoring.
higher wages ā€“ employer pays above Value Marginal
Product of Labor (VMPL). Then, the worker getting
this wage is less likely to shirk because if caught he
will not be able to ļ¬nd another high-paying job.
delayed payment ā€“ the employer can delay part of
workerā€™s compensation so that, if caught shirking and
ļ¬red, the worker incurs a higher loss.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Moral Hazard
A homeowner buys ļ¬re insurance and then is likely to
buy too few ļ¬re extinguishers because the homeowners
bears the cost of each extinguisher while the insurance
company receives much of the beneļ¬t.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Adverse Selection
Market for used cars. The lack of complete
information when purchasing a used car increases the
risk of the purchase and lowers the value of the car.
Automobile Insurance: A ļ¬rm selling car insurances
cannot identify owners living in high crime areas. If
average cost is charged, it can lead to insurance ļ¬rm
losing out.
The Market for Credit: Asymmetric information
creates the potential that only high risk borrowers will
seek loans. How can credit histories help make this
market more eļ¬ƒcient and reduce the cost of credit?
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Adverse Selection
Medical Insurance: Buyers of health insurance know
more about their health problems than do insurance
companies. Because people with greater hidden health
problems are more likely to buy health insurance than
are other people, the price of health insurance reļ¬‚ects
the cost of a sicker-than-average person.
Is it possible for insurance companies to separate high
and low risk policy holders? If not, only high risk
people will purchase insurance.
Adverse selection would make medical insurance
unproļ¬table.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Adverse Selection
When markets suļ¬€er from adverse selection, there are
some problems: Owners of good cars may choose to
keep them rather than sell them at the low price that
skeptical buyers are willing to pay.
In insurance markets, buyers with low risk may choose
to remain uninsured, because the policies they are
oļ¬€ered are too expensive, given their true
characteristics.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
Akerlof, George A. (1970). ā€œThe Market for ā€™Lemonsā€™:
Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanismā€.
Quarterly Journal of Economics. The MIT Press. 84
(3): 488ā€“500.
Sellers of cars know their vehiclesā€™ defects while buyers
often do not. Because owners of the worst cars are
more likely to sell them than are the owners of the best
cars, buyers fear they would get a ā€œlemonā€.
Low quality goods drive high quality goods out of the
market.
The market has failed to produce mutually beneļ¬cial
trade.
Adverse selection occurs; the only cars on the market
will be low quality cars.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
Two types of cars: ā€œlemonsā€ and ā€œpeachesā€.
Each lemon seller will accept $1,000; a buyer will pay
at most $1,200.
Each peach seller will accept $2,000; a buyer will pay
at most $2,400.
If every buyer can tell a peach from a lemon, then
lemons sell for between $1,000 and $1,200, and peaches
sell for between $2,000 and $2,400.
Gains-to-trade are generated when buyers are well
informed.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
Suppose no buyer can tell a peach from a lemon before
buying. What is the most a buyer will pay for any car?
Let Ī» be the fraction of peaches. For all, Ī» āˆˆ ]0, 1[
(1 āˆ’ Ī») is the fraction of lemons.
Expected value (EV) to a buyer of any car is at most
Suppose EV > $2000.
Every seller can negotiate a price between $2000 and
$EV (no matter if the car is a lemon or a peach).
All sellers gain from being in the market.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
Suppose EV < $2000.
A ā€œpeachā€ seller cannot negotiate a price below $2000
and will exit the market.
So all buyers know that remaining sellers own lemons
only.
Buyers will pay at most $1200 and only lemons are
sold.
Hence ā€œtoo manyā€ lemons ā€œcrowd outā€ the peaches
from the market.
Gains-to-trade are reduced since no peaches are traded.
The presence of the lemons inļ¬‚icts an external cost on
buyers and peach owners.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
How many lemons can be in the market without
crowding out the peaches?
Buyers will pay $2000 for a car only if
EV = $1200(1 āˆ’ Ī») + $2400Ī» ā‰„ $2000
Ī» ā‰„
2
3
So if over one-third of all cars are lemons, then only
lemons are traded.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€
A market equilibrium in which both types of cars are
traded and cannot be distinguished by the buyers is a
pooling equilibrium.
A market equilibrium in which only one of the two
types of cars is traded, or both are traded but can be
distinguished by the buyers, is a separating
equilibrium.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Quality Choice
Now each seller can choose the quality, or value, of her
product.
Two umbrellas; high-quality and low-quality.
Which will be manufactured and sold?
Buyers value a high-quality umbrella at $14 and a
low-quality umbrella at $8.
Before buying, no buyer can tell quality.
Marginal production cost of a high-quality umbrella is
$11.
Marginal production cost of a low-quality umbrella is
$10.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Quality Choice
Suppose every seller makes only high-quality umbrellas.
Every buyer pays $14 and sellersā€™ proļ¬t per umbrella is
$14 - $11 = $3.
But then a seller can make low-quality umbrellas for
which buyers still pay $14, so increasing proļ¬t to $14 -
$10 = $4.
There is no market equilibrium in which only
high-quality umbrellas are traded.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Quality Choice
Is there a market equilibrium in which only low-quality
umbrellas are traded?
All sellers make only low-quality umbrellas.
Buyers pay at most $8 for an umbrella, while marginal
production cost is $10.
There is no market equilibrium in which only
low-quality umbrellas are traded.
Now we know there is no market equilibrium in which
only one type of umbrella is manufactured.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Quality Choice
Is there an equilibrium in which both types of umbrella
are manufactured?
A fraction Ī» of sellers make high-quality umbrellas;
0 < Ī» < 1
Buyersā€™ expected value of an umbrella is
EV = 14Ī» + 8(1 āˆ’ Ī») = 8 + 6Ī»
High-quality manufacturers must recover the
manufacturing cost
EV = 8 + 6Ī» ā‰„ 11 ā‡’ Ī» ā‰„
1
2
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Quality Choice
So at least half of the sellers must make high-quality
umbrellas for there to be a pooling market equilibrium.
But then a high-quality seller can switch to making
low-quality and increase proļ¬t by $1 on each umbrella
sold.
Since all sellers reason this way, the fraction of
high-quality sellers will shrink towards zero ā€“ but then
buyers will pay only $8.
So there is no equilibrium in which both umbrella
types are traded.
The market has no equilibrium
with just one umbrella type traded
with both umbrella types traded
so the market has no equilibrium at all.
Adverse selection has destroyed the entire market!
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Mechanisms that reduce adverse selection
There is a number of mechanisms that may reduce adverse
selection, and, increase the volume of trade and the total
welfare. These mechanisms include:
Regulation: for instance, the government regulates
the markets for food and drugs, so you can be sure
that even at a very low price you will not buy a
ā€œlemonā€ that will poison you.
Reputation: well-established businesses, such as big
car dealerships, cannot aļ¬€ord to sell ā€œlemonsā€ because
it hurts their reputation and future proļ¬ts.
Assurance: the less-informed party can pay for an
expert opinion, e.g. ,it is common to hire a mechanic to
inspect a used car, and to check the history of the car.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Mechanisms that reduce adverse selection
Warranty: The seller of a used car who claims it to
have a top quality may commit to pay a compensation
to the buyer if the car needs a repair within a certain
time period. In order for warranty to work, it must
incur diļ¬€erent costs for owners of cars of diļ¬€erent
qualities.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling and Screening
Signalling. The better-informed party takes the lead
Often the better informed party would beneļ¬t from
communicating this information.
High-quality seller must do something costly and
veriļ¬able to signal quality convincingly. E.g.
reputation, warranty, job market, etc.
Informed individuals may ļ¬nd ways to signal
information about their unobservable knowledge
through observable actions.
Screening The less-informed party takes the lead.
Uninformed parties may develop mechanism to
distinguish , or screen , informed individuals who have
diļ¬€erent information.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Examples
Looking Busy: Ever known someone whose desk was
always a mess of papers and who always looked
frazzled? You could argue that looking busy is a way
of signaling that your role is important ā€“ and keeping
the boss oļ¬€ your back.
Seller of a used car could oļ¬€er to allow a prospective
buyer to take the car to a mechanic.
Firms may spend money on advertising to signal to
potential buyers.
Students earning college and postgraduate degrees
signal to potential employers that they are high-ability
individuals.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
Michael Spence (1973). ā€œJob Market Signallingā€.
Quarterly Journal of Economics. 87 (3): 355ā€“374.
Two types of workers; high-ability and low-ability.
A high-ability workerā€™s marginal product is aH = 80
A low-ability workerā€™s marginal product is aL = 40
The workersā€™ eļ¬€ort is ļ¬xed (say 40 Hrs. a week) and
plays no role in signalling. The employers are perfectly
competitive (rather than being a monopoly).
50% (= Ī») of all workers are high-ability, and, 50%
(=(1 āˆ’ Ī»)) is the fraction of low-ability workers.
Each worker is paid his expected marginal product.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
If ļ¬rms knew each workerā€™s type they would
pay each high-ability worker wH = aH.
pay each low-ability worker wL = aL.
In the perfect information case when the productivity
of each worker is known to the employers, the able
workers will receive the wage 80 and the unable the
wage 40.
Pooling equilibrium: if ļ¬rms cannot tell workersā€™
types then every worker is paid the wage rate; i.e. the
expected marginal product
wP = (1 āˆ’ Ī»)aL + Ī»aH
wP = 1/2 Ɨ 40 + 1/2 Ɨ 80 = 60
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
Separating equilibrium
wP = (1 āˆ’ Ī»)aL + Ī»aH < aH, the wage rate paid when
the ļ¬rm knows a worker really is high-ability.
High-ability workers have an incentive to ļ¬nd a
credible signal.
Workers can acquire ā€œeducationā€.
Education costs:
For a high-ability worker cH per unit. cH = 10
For a low-ability worker cL per unit. cL = 20
Crucial assumption: Signaling costs are negatively
correlated with productive ability.
It could simply be eļ¬€ort (Hrs. of study necessary to
learn a particular thing).
Or the more able students usually receive more
ļ¬nancial support.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
For simplicity, assume that the education does not
aļ¬€ect productivity at all and serves only the signalling
purpose.
High-ability workers will acquire eH education units if
wH āˆ’ wL = aH āˆ’ aL > cHeH, and
wH āˆ’ wL = aH āˆ’ aL < cLeH
Acquiring eH units of education beneļ¬ts high-ability
workers.
Acquiring eH education units hurts low-ability workers.
if cHeH < aH āˆ’ aL < cLeH, so
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
aH āˆ’ aL
cL
< eH <
aH āˆ’ aL
cH
80 āˆ’ 40
20
< eH <
80 āˆ’ 40
10
2 < eH < 4
Note:
if 4 < eH the able will not want to get the education
eH because it is not worth it: the cost of such
education is above 40, and hence is greater than the
wage diļ¬€erential.
if 2 > eH then both able and unable will choose eH
units of education because the cost is below 40 hence,
is less than the wage diļ¬€erential.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Signalling: Labor Market
Acquiring such an education level credibly signals
high-ability, allowing high-ability workers to separate
themselves from low-ability workers.
Given that high-ability workers acquire eH units of
education, how much education should low-ability
workers acquire?
Zero. Low-ability workers will be paid wL = aL. so
long as they do not have eH units of education and
they are still worse oļ¬€ if they do.
Signalling can improve information in the market.
But, total output did not change and education was
costly so signalling worsened the marketā€™s eļ¬ƒciency.
So improved information need not improve
gains-to-trade.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Examples
Insurance
Insuree knows her risk, insurer does not
Insurer oļ¬€ers several packages with diļ¬€erent premiums
and deductibles. Search for historical Records,
demographic characteristics, etc
Finance
Borrower knows the risk of project, lender does not
Lender oļ¬€ers several packages with diļ¬€erent interest
rates and collateral requirements
Hiring
Applicants know their ability, employer does not
Employers give aptitude tests, check letters of
recommendation, school aļ¬ƒliations, GPA. Give
bonuses, etc.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Examples
Pricing
Buyer knows her valuation of the product, seller does
not
Seller oļ¬€ers diļ¬€erent qualities at diļ¬€erent prices, or
quantity discounts
Selling used cars
Sellers of cars know their vehiclesā€™ defects while buyers
often do not.
Buyer may ask that car may be checked by a
mechanic before the sale. If seller refuses, he reveals
his private information that the car is a lemon.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Insurance
A ļ¬rm sells car insurance. Desirable: charge a low
premium to safe drivers and a high premium to risky
drivers.
How can the ļ¬rm separate the drivers?. Firm separates
drivers by oļ¬€ering diļ¬€erent insurance policies.
Policy 1: high premium and covers all costs (no
deductible). Policy 2: lower premium but the driver is
responsible for the ļ¬rst $1000 of damage ($1000
deductible).
Policy 2 is more of a burden for risky drivers because
they are more likely to have an accident. With a large
enough deductible, risky drivers will choose Policy 1
while safe drivers choose Policy 2.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Credit Market
J. E. Stiglitz and A. Weiss (1981) ā€œCredit Rationing in
Markets with Imperfect Informationā€ The American
Economic Review, 71 (3): 393-410.
If markets worked perfectly, supply and demand for
credit would ļ¬x the interest rate at which lendersā€™ d
assume the risk, and borrowersā€™d accept it in order to
fund their projects.
If the project succeeds, the loan is repaid to the bank;
if it fails, the investor declares bankruptcy and the
bank gets nothing. The possibilities are:
acquiring the loan in good will but despite your best
eļ¬€orts youā€™ll probably default anyway
simply do not care about the interest rate because you
have no intention of paying the loan back in the ļ¬rst
place.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Credit Market
Banks do not know diļ¬€erent kinds of investors.
Each of several potential liquidity constrained investors
has access to a project.
The projectā€™s proļ¬tability is private information.
The bank might be reluctant to raise the interest rates
to a level that clears the loan market. Thus, credit
might be rationed and investment curtailed.
Credit rationing implies that credit is not available for
all those who want it, at any interest rate.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Credit Market
An increase in the bankā€™s interest rate.
Its proļ¬ts increase in the event that the project is
successful.
Signal 1: if we have a good credit rating and are not
desperately in need of funds, we probably wonā€™t
accept excessively high interest rates, we will simply
put oļ¬€ our projects or purchases.
Signal 2: When interest rates rise above a certain
level, ļ¬nancial agents can assume that you are a
ā€œlemonā€, and that the risk of you defaulting on your
credit is too high.
It attracts riskier investors at the margin because the
greater amount that needs to be repaid can only be
generated through riskier projects.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Credit Market
Suppose two types of borrowers, As and Bs.
Both want to invest in similar projects with a diļ¬€erent
level of risk.
Suppose As invest in ā€œsaferā€ projects than Bs although
the mean return is the same, 110.
As ROIs between 90 and 120 for their investment.
If they invest 100, then for interest rates over 20%
their proļ¬t will be 0 even if their project is successful.
Bs ROIs between 70 and 180 for their investment.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Screening: Credit Market
If Bs are really optimistic (as riskier investors tend to
be), they can potentially accept interest rates of up to
80% and still break even.
Suppose both As and Bs default on their credit if their
ROI is negative (below 100).
Suppose that all those willing to accept rates of over
20% are therefore risky investors, Bs.
When interest rates approach Bs, credit will simply
dry up as all those willing to accept higher rates and
still borrow will be singled out as probable defaulters.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Utility Theory
Can we even measure satisfaction or happiness?
Suppose that everyone likes to eat gourmet food at
ļ¬ve-star hotels, drink French wine, vacation in exotic
places, and drive luxury cars.
All these goods are assumed to provide satisfaction,
some more than others.
Utility Theory
bases its beliefs upon individualsā€™ preferences.
rests upon the idea that people behave as if they make
decisions by assigning imaginary utility values to the
original monetary values
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Utility Theory
It explains behavior of individuals based on the
premise people can consistently rank order their
choices depending upon their preferences.
Placing certain restrictions, preferences can be
represented using a utility function
It is a mathematical formulation that ranks the
preferences of the individual in terms of satisfaction
diļ¬€erent consumption bundles provide.
Under the assumptions of utility theory, we can
assume that people behaved as if they had a utility
function and acted according to it.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty
While Utility Theory deals with situations in which
there is no uncertainty, the Expected Utility
Theory deals with choices individuals make when the
outcomes they face are uncertain.
If individuals maximize utility under certainty, they
will also attempt to maximize expected utility under
uncertainty.
Using Expected Utility Theory, we will ļ¬nd that even
if governments did not make purchase of insurance
mandatory, the product would still have existed.
Risk-averse individuals would always demand
insurance for the peace of mind it confers.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty
What is uncertain in economic systems?
tomorrowā€™s prices
future wealth
future availability of commodities
present and future actions of other people.
What are rational responses to uncertainty?
buying insurance (health, life, auto)
a portfolio of contingent consumption goods.
States of Nature: ā€œCar accidentā€ and ā€œno car
accidentā€. Each one occurs with a certain probability.
Contingencies: A contract implemented only when a
particular state of nature occurs is state-contingent.
E.g. the insurer pays only if there is an accident.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty
Expected value (EV) computed as a weighted
average of the events, and the weights are the
probabilities those events will take place with.
Expected utility allows people to compare gambles
Given two gambles, we assume people prefer the
situation that generates the greatest expected utility.
People maximize expected utility.
Many people are risk averse and prefer certainty to the
uncertain gamble.
For example
Job A: certain income of $50K and Job B: 50% chance
of $10K and 50% chance of $90K
Expected income is the same ($50K) but Job A
implies a certain income. Which one is preferred?
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty
Risk-averse individuals: Utility function U(X) =
āˆš
X
EUa =
āˆš
50000 = $223.61 and
EUb = 0.5
āˆš
10000 + 0.5
āˆš
90000 = $200
Job (a) is preferred
Risk-neutral individuals: Utility function U(X) = X
EUa = 50000 = $50000 and
EUb = 0.5 Ɨ 10000 + 0.5 Ɨ 90000 = $50000
Individuals are indiļ¬€erent toward risk
Risk-seeking individuals: Utility function U(X) = X2
EUa = 500002 = 25 Ɨ (10000)2 and
EUb = 0.5 Ɨ (10000)2 + 0.5 Ɨ (90000)2 = 41 Ɨ (10000)2
Job (b) is preferred
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Risk Aversion
Ty is a student who gets a monthly allowance of $200
(initial wealth W0) from his parents.
He might lose $100 on any given day with a probability
0.5 or not lose any amount with 50% chance.
His expected loss (E[L]) is 0.5($0) + 0.5($100) = $50.
His expected ļ¬nal wealth is
E(FW) = 0.5 āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $0) + 0.5 āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $100) =
W0 āˆ’ E(L) = $150.
How much Ty would be willing to pay to hedge his
expected loss of $50?
Assume that Tyā€™s utility function is U(W) =
āˆš
W , a
risk averterā€™s utility function
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Risk Aversion
Expected utility, no insurance
He retains all the uncertainty.
His expected ļ¬nal wealth of $150 as calculated above.
What is his expected utility?
The expected utility is calculated as a weighted sum of
the utilities in the two states, ā€œlossā€ and ā€œno lossā€.
EU = 0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $0)+0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $100) = $12.07
What is the actuarially fair premium (AFP) for Ty?
The AFP is the expected loss ($50).
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Risk Aversion
Expected Utility with insurance at AFP(=$50)
With ā€œno lossā€, his ļ¬nal wealth is $150 (($200)-AFP
($50)).
With a ā€œlossā€, his ļ¬nal wealth = $200-AFP ($50)-Loss
($100)+Indemnity ($100)= $150.
Ty has purchased a certain wealth of $150, by paying
an AFP of $50. His expected utility is $12.25 .
Ty will always purchase full insurance at AFP.
A risk-averse person will always hedge the risk
completely at a cost (AFP) that equals the expected
loss.
A risk-averse person always prefers certainty to
uncertainty, if uncertainty can be hedged away at its
actuarially fair price.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Risk Aversion
Expected Utility with insurance at a price greater
than AFP
What is the maximum premium Ty would be willing
to pay?
We should equate the utility when Ty purchases
insurance at P to the expected utility in the
no-insurance case ($12.07).
Now, Tyā€™s certain utility is
āˆš
200 āˆ’ P, and the
expected utility is:
EU = 0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $P)+0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $P) = 12.07
P = $54.29.
The risk premiun is $54.29-$50= $4.29
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Risk Aversion
Risk Premium: The premium above the AFP that a
risk-averse person is willing to pay to get rid of the
risk.
Any insurance company that charges a premium
greater than $54.29 will not be able to sell insurance to
Ty.
Individualsā€™ risk aversion is a key component in
insurance pricing.
The greater the degree of risk aversion, the higher the
risk premium an individual will be willing to pay.
The premium has to be less than or equal to the
maximum premium the person is willing to pay.
Otherwise, the individual will never buy full insurance.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Risk Aversion
Most individuals with average wealth and good
education tend to be risk neutral over small gambles.
Over larger gambles individuals tend to be risk averse.
(Except when buying lottery tickets.)
Large organizations: banks, insurance companies, ļ¬rms
tend to be risk neutral.Two reasons:
The risks are small relative to the organizationā€™s size.
They have so many risky things that they on average
tend to cancel each other out ā€“ ā€œdiversiļ¬ed riskā€.
A risk averse individual will always be better oļ¬€
buying actuarially fair insurance.
As insurance becomes less fair (administration costs,
deductibles, copays etc), risk averse individuals will
buy less insurance.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
An insurance company has to decide whether to sell an
auto insurance policy to Luke.
Luke is a risk-averse person whose utility function is
U(W) =
āˆš
W.
Luke claims to be a good risk because Lukeā€™s driving
record is excellent.
Luke can also choose to be either a careful driver or a
not-so-careful driver.
Luke drives a car carrying a market value of $10,000.
The only other asset he owns is the $3,000 in his
checking account.
His total initial wealth of $13,000
If he drives carefully, he incurs a cost of $3,000.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
Luke faces the following ā€œloss distributionā€
Drives with Care without Care
Prob. Loss Prob. Loss
accident 0.25 $10,000 0.75 $10,000
no accident 0.75 0 0.25 0
When he has an accident, his car is a total loss.
The probabilities of ā€œlossā€ and ā€œno lossā€ are reversed
when he decides to drive without care.
EV[loss]= $2,500 and EV[loss]= $7,500.
Lukeā€™s problem has 4 parts: whether to drive with or
without care, (I) when he has no insurance and (II)
when he has insurance.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
Case I when he carries no insurance.
Drives with Care without Care
Prob. U(W) Prob. U(W)
accident 0.25 0 0.75 $54.77
no accident 0.75 $100 0.25 $114.02
Drives with care and has an accident:
W = $13000 āˆ’ $3000 āˆ’ $10000 = 0 ā‡’ U(0) = 0
Drives with care and has not an accident:
W = $13000āˆ’$3000āˆ’0 = $10000 ā‡’ U($10000) = $100
Drives without care and has an accident: W =
$13000 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ $10000 = $3000 ā‡’ U($3000) = $54.77
Drives without care and has not an accident:
W = $13000 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ 0 = $13000 ā‡’ U($13000) = $114.02
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
The expected utility of driving with care:
EU = 0.25 Ɨ 0 + 0.75 Ɨ 100 = $75
The expected utility of driving without care:
EU = 0.75 Ɨ 54.77 + 0.25 Ɨ 114.02 = $69.58
Luke will drive carefully since his expected utility is
higher when he exercises due care. His utility is $75
versus $69.58.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
Case II when he carries insurance. Insurance
premiun= $2750 = $2500 Ɨ (1 + 0.1)
Drives with Care without Care
Prob. U(W) Prob. U(W)
accident 0.25 $85.15 0.75 $101.24
no accident 0.75 $85.15 0.25 $101.24
With an insurance, Luke has eliminated the
uncertainty.
If he has an accident, the insurance company
indemniļ¬es him with $10,000.
Drives with care and has an accident:
W = $10250 āˆ’ $3000 āˆ’ $10000 + $10000 = $7250 ā‡’
U(7250) = $85.15
Drives with care and has not an accident:
W = $10250 āˆ’ $3000 = $7250 ā‡’ U(7250) = $85.15
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
Drives without care and has an accident:
W = $10250 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ $10000 + $10000 = $10250 ā‡’
U(10250) = $101.24
Drives without care and has not an accident:
W = $10250 āˆ’ 0 = $10250 ā‡’ U(10250) = $101.24
The expected utility of driving with care:
EU = 0.25 Ɨ 85.15 + 0.75 Ɨ 85.15 = $85.15
The expected utility of driving without care:
EU = 0.75 Ɨ 101.24 + 0.25 Ɨ 101.242 = $101.24
The net result is he switches to driving with no care
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
Insurance: Moral Hazard
Why do we get this result?
The cost of insurance is cheaper than the cost of care.
Insurance companies can charge a price greater than
the cost of care up to a maximum of what Luke is
willing to pay.
In the event of asymmetric information, the insurance
company will not know the cost of care.
Inexpensive insurance distorts the incentives and
individuals switch to riskier behavior ex post.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
References
Varian, Hal R. 2010. Intermediate microeconomics: a
modern approach. New York: W.W. Norton & Co.
Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino
Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions

More Related Content

What's hot

Baumol's model of demand for money
Baumol's model of demand for moneyBaumol's model of demand for money
Baumol's model of demand for moneyPrabha Panth
Ā 
Perfect Competition
Perfect CompetitionPerfect Competition
Perfect Competitiontutor2u
Ā 
Cross elasticity of demand
Cross elasticity of demandCross elasticity of demand
Cross elasticity of demandsuhasoo1shinde
Ā 
Theory of consumption
Theory of consumptionTheory of consumption
Theory of consumptionYashika Parekh
Ā 
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curves
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and CurvesAggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curves
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curvesshahroze11
Ā 
Coase theorem (1)
Coase theorem (1)Coase theorem (1)
Coase theorem (1)Muskaan Dargar
Ā 
welfare economics
welfare economicswelfare economics
welfare economicsSakthivel R
Ā 
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competition
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competitionSocial welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competition
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competitionAkeeb Siddiqui
Ā 
Factor pricing Theory.pdf
Factor pricing Theory.pdfFactor pricing Theory.pdf
Factor pricing Theory.pdfRuchiJainRuchiJain
Ā 
Price discrimination
Price discriminationPrice discrimination
Price discriminationVidhya Kannan
Ā 
Price ceiling and price floor
Price ceiling and price floorPrice ceiling and price floor
Price ceiling and price floorYogesh Singla
Ā 
Price change income and substittution effects
Price change income and substittution effectsPrice change income and substittution effects
Price change income and substittution effectsBhupendra Bule
Ā 
Theory of consumer behavior cardinal approach
Theory of consumer behavior  cardinal approachTheory of consumer behavior  cardinal approach
Theory of consumer behavior cardinal approachTej Kiran
Ā 
Information Asymmetry
Information AsymmetryInformation Asymmetry
Information AsymmetryIrfan Sheikh
Ā 

What's hot (20)

Akalof lemon market
Akalof lemon marketAkalof lemon market
Akalof lemon market
Ā 
Externalities
ExternalitiesExternalities
Externalities
Ā 
Baumol's model of demand for money
Baumol's model of demand for moneyBaumol's model of demand for money
Baumol's model of demand for money
Ā 
Indifrrence curve analysis
Indifrrence curve analysisIndifrrence curve analysis
Indifrrence curve analysis
Ā 
Revealed preference theory
Revealed preference theoryRevealed preference theory
Revealed preference theory
Ā 
Perfect Competition
Perfect CompetitionPerfect Competition
Perfect Competition
Ā 
Cross elasticity of demand
Cross elasticity of demandCross elasticity of demand
Cross elasticity of demand
Ā 
Theory of consumption
Theory of consumptionTheory of consumption
Theory of consumption
Ā 
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curves
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and CurvesAggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curves
Aggregate Demand and Aggregate Supply and Curves
Ā 
Coase theorem (1)
Coase theorem (1)Coase theorem (1)
Coase theorem (1)
Ā 
Demand for money
Demand for moneyDemand for money
Demand for money
Ā 
welfare economics
welfare economicswelfare economics
welfare economics
Ā 
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competition
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competitionSocial welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competition
Social welfare is maximum in case of imperfect competition
Ā 
Factor pricing Theory.pdf
Factor pricing Theory.pdfFactor pricing Theory.pdf
Factor pricing Theory.pdf
Ā 
Price discrimination
Price discriminationPrice discrimination
Price discrimination
Ā 
Price ceiling and price floor
Price ceiling and price floorPrice ceiling and price floor
Price ceiling and price floor
Ā 
Price change income and substittution effects
Price change income and substittution effectsPrice change income and substittution effects
Price change income and substittution effects
Ā 
Theory of consumer behavior cardinal approach
Theory of consumer behavior  cardinal approachTheory of consumer behavior  cardinal approach
Theory of consumer behavior cardinal approach
Ā 
Information Asymmetry
Information AsymmetryInformation Asymmetry
Information Asymmetry
Ā 
Public goods
Public goodsPublic goods
Public goods
Ā 

Similar to Asymmetric Information

Asymmetric Information
Asymmetric InformationAsymmetric Information
Asymmetric Informationssuserb10705
Ā 
A Market For Lemons
A Market For LemonsA Market For Lemons
A Market For Lemonsguestffda0
Ā 
Information Gaps
Information GapsInformation Gaps
Information GapsHugo OGrady
Ā 
Information theory
Information theoryInformation theory
Information theorySunny Goyal
Ā 
050813
050813050813
050813pannomion
Ā 
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...Kitmondo
Ā 
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?Helene LAFFITTE
Ā 
Art elica 04_genesove1993
Art elica 04_genesove1993Art elica 04_genesove1993
Art elica 04_genesove1993Ernesto Esparaquia
Ā 
What IS an Auction?
What IS an Auction?What IS an Auction?
What IS an Auction?steveboyle62
Ā 
Aggression And Blackmail As Normal
Aggression And Blackmail As NormalAggression And Blackmail As Normal
Aggression And Blackmail As Normalbhamori
Ā 
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptx
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptxPR8e_GE_ch17.pptx
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptxfasfasfgrg
Ā 
Taxes and elastcity
Taxes and elastcityTaxes and elastcity
Taxes and elastcityAnnapurna Sinha
Ā 
051013
051013051013
051013pannomion
Ā 
Ch05
Ch05Ch05
Ch05Dorian K
Ā 
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too late
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too lateThe Dangers of selling commercial real estate too late
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too lateJeremy Cyrier, CCIM
Ā 
Listing Presentation To Seller
Listing Presentation To SellerListing Presentation To Seller
Listing Presentation To SellerValerieWhiteman
Ā 

Similar to Asymmetric Information (20)

Asymmetric Information
Asymmetric InformationAsymmetric Information
Asymmetric Information
Ā 
Ch36
Ch36Ch36
Ch36
Ā 
A Market For Lemons
A Market For LemonsA Market For Lemons
A Market For Lemons
Ā 
Econ 204 week 13 outline
Econ 204 week 13 outlineEcon 204 week 13 outline
Econ 204 week 13 outline
Ā 
Information Gaps
Information GapsInformation Gaps
Information Gaps
Ā 
Information theory
Information theoryInformation theory
Information theory
Ā 
050813
050813050813
050813
Ā 
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...
A Blueprint for the Used Equipment Business - Kitmondo 2014 New Site Launch P...
Ā 
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?
What is asymmetrical information,and why should I care?
Ā 
Art elica 04_genesove1993
Art elica 04_genesove1993Art elica 04_genesove1993
Art elica 04_genesove1993
Ā 
What IS an Auction?
What IS an Auction?What IS an Auction?
What IS an Auction?
Ā 
Aggression And Blackmail As Normal
Aggression And Blackmail As NormalAggression And Blackmail As Normal
Aggression And Blackmail As Normal
Ā 
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptx
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptxPR8e_GE_ch17.pptx
PR8e_GE_ch17.pptx
Ā 
I Still Want to Sell My Home!
I Still Want to Sell My Home!I Still Want to Sell My Home!
I Still Want to Sell My Home!
Ā 
Taxes and elastcity
Taxes and elastcityTaxes and elastcity
Taxes and elastcity
Ā 
051013
051013051013
051013
Ā 
Ch05
Ch05Ch05
Ch05
Ā 
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too late
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too lateThe Dangers of selling commercial real estate too late
The Dangers of selling commercial real estate too late
Ā 
Listing Presentation To Seller
Listing Presentation To SellerListing Presentation To Seller
Listing Presentation To Seller
Ā 
Market Failure
Market FailureMarket Failure
Market Failure
Ā 

More from Cesar Sobrino

Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto Rico
Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto RicoRegional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto Rico
Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto RicoCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Introduction to Game Theory
Introduction to Game TheoryIntroduction to Game Theory
Introduction to Game TheoryCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Economies of scale
Economies of scaleEconomies of scale
Economies of scaleCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Comparative Advantage
Comparative AdvantageComparative Advantage
Comparative AdvantageCesar Sobrino
Ā 
National Accounts
National AccountsNational Accounts
National AccountsCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Exchange Rates in the Short Run
Exchange Rates in the Short RunExchange Rates in the Short Run
Exchange Rates in the Short RunCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long RunCh1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long RunCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Regional Income Convergence
Regional Income ConvergenceRegional Income Convergence
Regional Income ConvergenceCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Market structure
Market structureMarket structure
Market structureCesar Sobrino
Ā 
Presentacion coidine 2015
Presentacion coidine 2015Presentacion coidine 2015
Presentacion coidine 2015Cesar Sobrino
Ā 
Chapter 16 fi_2010
Chapter 16 fi_2010Chapter 16 fi_2010
Chapter 16 fi_2010Cesar Sobrino
Ā 
Chapter 14 fa1_2010
Chapter 14 fa1_2010Chapter 14 fa1_2010
Chapter 14 fa1_2010Cesar Sobrino
Ā 
Chapter 13 fa1_2010
Chapter 13 fa1_2010Chapter 13 fa1_2010
Chapter 13 fa1_2010Cesar Sobrino
Ā 
Chapter12 fi 2010
Chapter12 fi 2010Chapter12 fi 2010
Chapter12 fi 2010Cesar Sobrino
Ā 
Chapter11 fi 2010
Chapter11 fi 2010Chapter11 fi 2010
Chapter11 fi 2010Cesar Sobrino
Ā 

More from Cesar Sobrino (20)

Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto Rico
Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto RicoRegional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto Rico
Regional Convergence of Unemployment Rates in Puerto Rico
Ā 
Introduction to Game Theory
Introduction to Game TheoryIntroduction to Game Theory
Introduction to Game Theory
Ā 
Gravity model
Gravity modelGravity model
Gravity model
Ā 
Economies of scale
Economies of scaleEconomies of scale
Economies of scale
Ā 
Comparative Advantage
Comparative AdvantageComparative Advantage
Comparative Advantage
Ā 
National Accounts
National AccountsNational Accounts
National Accounts
Ā 
Exchange Rates in the Short Run
Exchange Rates in the Short RunExchange Rates in the Short Run
Exchange Rates in the Short Run
Ā 
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long RunCh1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Ch1516 Money, Interest and the Exchange Rate in the Long Run
Ā 
Regional Income Convergence
Regional Income ConvergenceRegional Income Convergence
Regional Income Convergence
Ā 
Market structure
Market structureMarket structure
Market structure
Ā 
Presentacion coidine 2015
Presentacion coidine 2015Presentacion coidine 2015
Presentacion coidine 2015
Ā 
Acticidad 7
Acticidad 7Acticidad 7
Acticidad 7
Ā 
Chapter 16 fi_2010
Chapter 16 fi_2010Chapter 16 fi_2010
Chapter 16 fi_2010
Ā 
Chapter 14 fa1_2010
Chapter 14 fa1_2010Chapter 14 fa1_2010
Chapter 14 fa1_2010
Ā 
Chapter 13 fa1_2010
Chapter 13 fa1_2010Chapter 13 fa1_2010
Chapter 13 fa1_2010
Ā 
Chapter12 fi 2010
Chapter12 fi 2010Chapter12 fi 2010
Chapter12 fi 2010
Ā 
Chapter11 fi 2010
Chapter11 fi 2010Chapter11 fi 2010
Chapter11 fi 2010
Ā 
Chapter 10
Chapter 10Chapter 10
Chapter 10
Ā 
Chapter 7
Chapter 7Chapter 7
Chapter 7
Ā 
Chapter 4
Chapter 4Chapter 4
Chapter 4
Ā 

Recently uploaded

Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementmkooblal
Ā 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for BeginnersSabitha Banu
Ā 
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupMARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupJonathanParaisoCruz
Ā 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)eniolaolutunde
Ā 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxGaneshChakor2
Ā 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxOH TEIK BIN
Ā 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxSayali Powar
Ā 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfUjwalaBharambe
Ā 
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon ACrayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon AUnboundStockton
Ā 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...jaredbarbolino94
Ā 
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersSabitha Banu
Ā 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceSamikshaHamane
Ā 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatYousafMalik24
Ā 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxsocialsciencegdgrohi
Ā 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļøcall girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø9953056974 Low Rate Call Girls In Saket, Delhi NCR
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxiammrhaywood
Ā 
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)Dr. Mazin Mohamed alkathiri
Ā 

Recently uploaded (20)

Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of managementHierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Hierarchy of management that covers different levels of management
Ā 
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course  for BeginnersFull Stack Web Development Course  for Beginners
Full Stack Web Development Course for Beginners
Ā 
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized GroupMARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
MARGINALIZATION (Different learners in Marginalized Group
Ā 
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Software Engineering Methodologies (overview)
Ā 
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptxCARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
CARE OF CHILD IN INCUBATOR..........pptx
Ā 
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdfTataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
TataKelola dan KamSiber Kecerdasan Buatan v022.pdf
Ā 
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptxSolving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Solving Puzzles Benefits Everyone (English).pptx
Ā 
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptxPOINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
POINT- BIOCHEMISTRY SEM 2 ENZYMES UNIT 5.pptx
Ā 
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdfFraming an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Framing an Appropriate Research Question 6b9b26d93da94caf993c038d9efcdedb.pdf
Ā 
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon ACrayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Crayon Activity Handout For the Crayon A
Ā 
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Historical philosophical, theoretical, and legal foundations of special and i...
Ā 
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginnersDATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
DATA STRUCTURE AND ALGORITHM for beginners
Ā 
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in PharmacovigilanceRoles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Roles & Responsibilities in Pharmacovigilance
Ā 
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at šŸ”9953056974šŸ”
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at šŸ”9953056974šŸ”Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at šŸ”9953056974šŸ”
Model Call Girl in Tilak Nagar Delhi reach out to us at šŸ”9953056974šŸ”
Ā 
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice greatEarth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Earth Day Presentation wow hello nice great
Ā 
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptxHistory Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
History Class XII Ch. 3 Kinship, Caste and Class (1).pptx
Ā 
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
OS-operating systems- ch04 (Threads) ...
Ā 
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļøcall girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
call girls in Kamla Market (DELHI) šŸ” >ą¼’9953330565šŸ” genuine Escort Service šŸ”āœ”ļøāœ”ļø
Ā 
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptxECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
ECONOMIC CONTEXT - PAPER 1 Q3: NEWSPAPERS.pptx
Ā 
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
ESSENTIAL of (CS/IT/IS) class 06 (database)
Ā 

Asymmetric Information

  • 1. Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Universidad del Turabo August 16, 2018 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 2. Outline 1 Asymmetric Information Moral Hazard Adverse Selection 2 Uncertainty Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 3. Asymmetric Information In purely competitive markets all agents are fully informed about traded commodities and other aspects of the market. Markets with one side or the other imperfectly informed are markets with imperfect information. Imperfectly informed markets with one side better informed than the other are markets with asymmetric information. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 4. Asymmetric Information: Some examples A worker knows more than his employer about how much eļ¬€ort he puts into his job. (example of a hidden action) A seller of a used car knows more than the buyer about the carā€™s condition. (example of a hidden characteristic). a customer knows her taste for a good or a service better than the ļ¬rm that supplies and prices it. (example of a hidden characteristic). a person knows more about his driving habits than the company that provides his auto insurance (example of a hidden characteristic) Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 5. Asymmetric Information Hidden actions are actions taken by one side of an economic relationship (agent) that the other side of the relationship (principal) cannot observe. Agent: a person who is performing an act for another person, called the Principal. Hidden characteristics are things that one side of a transaction knows about itself that the other side would like to know but does not. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 6. Asymmetric Information Moral Hazard Problems after a contract is written. The tendency of an imperfectly monitored agent to engage in dishonest or otherwise undesirable behavior. Adverse Selection Problems before a contract is written. Refers to the tendency for the mix of unobserved attributes to become undesirable from the standpoint of an uniformed party. Imperfect information inļ¬‚uences resource allocation and the price system. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 7. Moral Hazard Classic example: employment. The employer is the principal and the worker is the agent. Moral Hazard is the temptation of imperfectly monitored workers to shirk their responsibilities. Employerā€™s possible responses to Moral Hazard: better monitoring. higher wages ā€“ employer pays above Value Marginal Product of Labor (VMPL). Then, the worker getting this wage is less likely to shirk because if caught he will not be able to ļ¬nd another high-paying job. delayed payment ā€“ the employer can delay part of workerā€™s compensation so that, if caught shirking and ļ¬red, the worker incurs a higher loss. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 8. Moral Hazard A homeowner buys ļ¬re insurance and then is likely to buy too few ļ¬re extinguishers because the homeowners bears the cost of each extinguisher while the insurance company receives much of the beneļ¬t. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 9. Adverse Selection Market for used cars. The lack of complete information when purchasing a used car increases the risk of the purchase and lowers the value of the car. Automobile Insurance: A ļ¬rm selling car insurances cannot identify owners living in high crime areas. If average cost is charged, it can lead to insurance ļ¬rm losing out. The Market for Credit: Asymmetric information creates the potential that only high risk borrowers will seek loans. How can credit histories help make this market more eļ¬ƒcient and reduce the cost of credit? Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 10. Adverse Selection Medical Insurance: Buyers of health insurance know more about their health problems than do insurance companies. Because people with greater hidden health problems are more likely to buy health insurance than are other people, the price of health insurance reļ¬‚ects the cost of a sicker-than-average person. Is it possible for insurance companies to separate high and low risk policy holders? If not, only high risk people will purchase insurance. Adverse selection would make medical insurance unproļ¬table. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 11. Adverse Selection When markets suļ¬€er from adverse selection, there are some problems: Owners of good cars may choose to keep them rather than sell them at the low price that skeptical buyers are willing to pay. In insurance markets, buyers with low risk may choose to remain uninsured, because the policies they are oļ¬€ered are too expensive, given their true characteristics. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 12. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ Akerlof, George A. (1970). ā€œThe Market for ā€™Lemonsā€™: Quality Uncertainty and the Market Mechanismā€. Quarterly Journal of Economics. The MIT Press. 84 (3): 488ā€“500. Sellers of cars know their vehiclesā€™ defects while buyers often do not. Because owners of the worst cars are more likely to sell them than are the owners of the best cars, buyers fear they would get a ā€œlemonā€. Low quality goods drive high quality goods out of the market. The market has failed to produce mutually beneļ¬cial trade. Adverse selection occurs; the only cars on the market will be low quality cars. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 13. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ Two types of cars: ā€œlemonsā€ and ā€œpeachesā€. Each lemon seller will accept $1,000; a buyer will pay at most $1,200. Each peach seller will accept $2,000; a buyer will pay at most $2,400. If every buyer can tell a peach from a lemon, then lemons sell for between $1,000 and $1,200, and peaches sell for between $2,000 and $2,400. Gains-to-trade are generated when buyers are well informed. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 14. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ Suppose no buyer can tell a peach from a lemon before buying. What is the most a buyer will pay for any car? Let Ī» be the fraction of peaches. For all, Ī» āˆˆ ]0, 1[ (1 āˆ’ Ī») is the fraction of lemons. Expected value (EV) to a buyer of any car is at most Suppose EV > $2000. Every seller can negotiate a price between $2000 and $EV (no matter if the car is a lemon or a peach). All sellers gain from being in the market. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 15. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ Suppose EV < $2000. A ā€œpeachā€ seller cannot negotiate a price below $2000 and will exit the market. So all buyers know that remaining sellers own lemons only. Buyers will pay at most $1200 and only lemons are sold. Hence ā€œtoo manyā€ lemons ā€œcrowd outā€ the peaches from the market. Gains-to-trade are reduced since no peaches are traded. The presence of the lemons inļ¬‚icts an external cost on buyers and peach owners. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 16. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ How many lemons can be in the market without crowding out the peaches? Buyers will pay $2000 for a car only if EV = $1200(1 āˆ’ Ī») + $2400Ī» ā‰„ $2000 Ī» ā‰„ 2 3 So if over one-third of all cars are lemons, then only lemons are traded. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 17. Market for used cars:ā€œPeachesā€ and ā€œLemonsā€ A market equilibrium in which both types of cars are traded and cannot be distinguished by the buyers is a pooling equilibrium. A market equilibrium in which only one of the two types of cars is traded, or both are traded but can be distinguished by the buyers, is a separating equilibrium. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 18. Quality Choice Now each seller can choose the quality, or value, of her product. Two umbrellas; high-quality and low-quality. Which will be manufactured and sold? Buyers value a high-quality umbrella at $14 and a low-quality umbrella at $8. Before buying, no buyer can tell quality. Marginal production cost of a high-quality umbrella is $11. Marginal production cost of a low-quality umbrella is $10. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 19. Quality Choice Suppose every seller makes only high-quality umbrellas. Every buyer pays $14 and sellersā€™ proļ¬t per umbrella is $14 - $11 = $3. But then a seller can make low-quality umbrellas for which buyers still pay $14, so increasing proļ¬t to $14 - $10 = $4. There is no market equilibrium in which only high-quality umbrellas are traded. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 20. Quality Choice Is there a market equilibrium in which only low-quality umbrellas are traded? All sellers make only low-quality umbrellas. Buyers pay at most $8 for an umbrella, while marginal production cost is $10. There is no market equilibrium in which only low-quality umbrellas are traded. Now we know there is no market equilibrium in which only one type of umbrella is manufactured. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 21. Quality Choice Is there an equilibrium in which both types of umbrella are manufactured? A fraction Ī» of sellers make high-quality umbrellas; 0 < Ī» < 1 Buyersā€™ expected value of an umbrella is EV = 14Ī» + 8(1 āˆ’ Ī») = 8 + 6Ī» High-quality manufacturers must recover the manufacturing cost EV = 8 + 6Ī» ā‰„ 11 ā‡’ Ī» ā‰„ 1 2 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 22. Quality Choice So at least half of the sellers must make high-quality umbrellas for there to be a pooling market equilibrium. But then a high-quality seller can switch to making low-quality and increase proļ¬t by $1 on each umbrella sold. Since all sellers reason this way, the fraction of high-quality sellers will shrink towards zero ā€“ but then buyers will pay only $8. So there is no equilibrium in which both umbrella types are traded. The market has no equilibrium with just one umbrella type traded with both umbrella types traded so the market has no equilibrium at all. Adverse selection has destroyed the entire market! Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 23. Mechanisms that reduce adverse selection There is a number of mechanisms that may reduce adverse selection, and, increase the volume of trade and the total welfare. These mechanisms include: Regulation: for instance, the government regulates the markets for food and drugs, so you can be sure that even at a very low price you will not buy a ā€œlemonā€ that will poison you. Reputation: well-established businesses, such as big car dealerships, cannot aļ¬€ord to sell ā€œlemonsā€ because it hurts their reputation and future proļ¬ts. Assurance: the less-informed party can pay for an expert opinion, e.g. ,it is common to hire a mechanic to inspect a used car, and to check the history of the car. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 24. Mechanisms that reduce adverse selection Warranty: The seller of a used car who claims it to have a top quality may commit to pay a compensation to the buyer if the car needs a repair within a certain time period. In order for warranty to work, it must incur diļ¬€erent costs for owners of cars of diļ¬€erent qualities. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 25. Signalling and Screening Signalling. The better-informed party takes the lead Often the better informed party would beneļ¬t from communicating this information. High-quality seller must do something costly and veriļ¬able to signal quality convincingly. E.g. reputation, warranty, job market, etc. Informed individuals may ļ¬nd ways to signal information about their unobservable knowledge through observable actions. Screening The less-informed party takes the lead. Uninformed parties may develop mechanism to distinguish , or screen , informed individuals who have diļ¬€erent information. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 26. Signalling: Examples Looking Busy: Ever known someone whose desk was always a mess of papers and who always looked frazzled? You could argue that looking busy is a way of signaling that your role is important ā€“ and keeping the boss oļ¬€ your back. Seller of a used car could oļ¬€er to allow a prospective buyer to take the car to a mechanic. Firms may spend money on advertising to signal to potential buyers. Students earning college and postgraduate degrees signal to potential employers that they are high-ability individuals. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 27. Signalling: Labor Market Michael Spence (1973). ā€œJob Market Signallingā€. Quarterly Journal of Economics. 87 (3): 355ā€“374. Two types of workers; high-ability and low-ability. A high-ability workerā€™s marginal product is aH = 80 A low-ability workerā€™s marginal product is aL = 40 The workersā€™ eļ¬€ort is ļ¬xed (say 40 Hrs. a week) and plays no role in signalling. The employers are perfectly competitive (rather than being a monopoly). 50% (= Ī») of all workers are high-ability, and, 50% (=(1 āˆ’ Ī»)) is the fraction of low-ability workers. Each worker is paid his expected marginal product. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 28. Signalling: Labor Market If ļ¬rms knew each workerā€™s type they would pay each high-ability worker wH = aH. pay each low-ability worker wL = aL. In the perfect information case when the productivity of each worker is known to the employers, the able workers will receive the wage 80 and the unable the wage 40. Pooling equilibrium: if ļ¬rms cannot tell workersā€™ types then every worker is paid the wage rate; i.e. the expected marginal product wP = (1 āˆ’ Ī»)aL + Ī»aH wP = 1/2 Ɨ 40 + 1/2 Ɨ 80 = 60 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 29. Signalling: Labor Market Separating equilibrium wP = (1 āˆ’ Ī»)aL + Ī»aH < aH, the wage rate paid when the ļ¬rm knows a worker really is high-ability. High-ability workers have an incentive to ļ¬nd a credible signal. Workers can acquire ā€œeducationā€. Education costs: For a high-ability worker cH per unit. cH = 10 For a low-ability worker cL per unit. cL = 20 Crucial assumption: Signaling costs are negatively correlated with productive ability. It could simply be eļ¬€ort (Hrs. of study necessary to learn a particular thing). Or the more able students usually receive more ļ¬nancial support. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 30. Signalling: Labor Market For simplicity, assume that the education does not aļ¬€ect productivity at all and serves only the signalling purpose. High-ability workers will acquire eH education units if wH āˆ’ wL = aH āˆ’ aL > cHeH, and wH āˆ’ wL = aH āˆ’ aL < cLeH Acquiring eH units of education beneļ¬ts high-ability workers. Acquiring eH education units hurts low-ability workers. if cHeH < aH āˆ’ aL < cLeH, so Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 31. Signalling: Labor Market aH āˆ’ aL cL < eH < aH āˆ’ aL cH 80 āˆ’ 40 20 < eH < 80 āˆ’ 40 10 2 < eH < 4 Note: if 4 < eH the able will not want to get the education eH because it is not worth it: the cost of such education is above 40, and hence is greater than the wage diļ¬€erential. if 2 > eH then both able and unable will choose eH units of education because the cost is below 40 hence, is less than the wage diļ¬€erential. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 32. Signalling: Labor Market Acquiring such an education level credibly signals high-ability, allowing high-ability workers to separate themselves from low-ability workers. Given that high-ability workers acquire eH units of education, how much education should low-ability workers acquire? Zero. Low-ability workers will be paid wL = aL. so long as they do not have eH units of education and they are still worse oļ¬€ if they do. Signalling can improve information in the market. But, total output did not change and education was costly so signalling worsened the marketā€™s eļ¬ƒciency. So improved information need not improve gains-to-trade. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 33. Screening: Examples Insurance Insuree knows her risk, insurer does not Insurer oļ¬€ers several packages with diļ¬€erent premiums and deductibles. Search for historical Records, demographic characteristics, etc Finance Borrower knows the risk of project, lender does not Lender oļ¬€ers several packages with diļ¬€erent interest rates and collateral requirements Hiring Applicants know their ability, employer does not Employers give aptitude tests, check letters of recommendation, school aļ¬ƒliations, GPA. Give bonuses, etc. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 34. Screening: Examples Pricing Buyer knows her valuation of the product, seller does not Seller oļ¬€ers diļ¬€erent qualities at diļ¬€erent prices, or quantity discounts Selling used cars Sellers of cars know their vehiclesā€™ defects while buyers often do not. Buyer may ask that car may be checked by a mechanic before the sale. If seller refuses, he reveals his private information that the car is a lemon. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 35. Screening: Insurance A ļ¬rm sells car insurance. Desirable: charge a low premium to safe drivers and a high premium to risky drivers. How can the ļ¬rm separate the drivers?. Firm separates drivers by oļ¬€ering diļ¬€erent insurance policies. Policy 1: high premium and covers all costs (no deductible). Policy 2: lower premium but the driver is responsible for the ļ¬rst $1000 of damage ($1000 deductible). Policy 2 is more of a burden for risky drivers because they are more likely to have an accident. With a large enough deductible, risky drivers will choose Policy 1 while safe drivers choose Policy 2. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 36. Screening: Credit Market J. E. Stiglitz and A. Weiss (1981) ā€œCredit Rationing in Markets with Imperfect Informationā€ The American Economic Review, 71 (3): 393-410. If markets worked perfectly, supply and demand for credit would ļ¬x the interest rate at which lendersā€™ d assume the risk, and borrowersā€™d accept it in order to fund their projects. If the project succeeds, the loan is repaid to the bank; if it fails, the investor declares bankruptcy and the bank gets nothing. The possibilities are: acquiring the loan in good will but despite your best eļ¬€orts youā€™ll probably default anyway simply do not care about the interest rate because you have no intention of paying the loan back in the ļ¬rst place. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 37. Screening: Credit Market Banks do not know diļ¬€erent kinds of investors. Each of several potential liquidity constrained investors has access to a project. The projectā€™s proļ¬tability is private information. The bank might be reluctant to raise the interest rates to a level that clears the loan market. Thus, credit might be rationed and investment curtailed. Credit rationing implies that credit is not available for all those who want it, at any interest rate. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 38. Screening: Credit Market An increase in the bankā€™s interest rate. Its proļ¬ts increase in the event that the project is successful. Signal 1: if we have a good credit rating and are not desperately in need of funds, we probably wonā€™t accept excessively high interest rates, we will simply put oļ¬€ our projects or purchases. Signal 2: When interest rates rise above a certain level, ļ¬nancial agents can assume that you are a ā€œlemonā€, and that the risk of you defaulting on your credit is too high. It attracts riskier investors at the margin because the greater amount that needs to be repaid can only be generated through riskier projects. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 39. Screening: Credit Market Suppose two types of borrowers, As and Bs. Both want to invest in similar projects with a diļ¬€erent level of risk. Suppose As invest in ā€œsaferā€ projects than Bs although the mean return is the same, 110. As ROIs between 90 and 120 for their investment. If they invest 100, then for interest rates over 20% their proļ¬t will be 0 even if their project is successful. Bs ROIs between 70 and 180 for their investment. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 40. Screening: Credit Market If Bs are really optimistic (as riskier investors tend to be), they can potentially accept interest rates of up to 80% and still break even. Suppose both As and Bs default on their credit if their ROI is negative (below 100). Suppose that all those willing to accept rates of over 20% are therefore risky investors, Bs. When interest rates approach Bs, credit will simply dry up as all those willing to accept higher rates and still borrow will be singled out as probable defaulters. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 41. Expected Utility Theory: Utility Theory Can we even measure satisfaction or happiness? Suppose that everyone likes to eat gourmet food at ļ¬ve-star hotels, drink French wine, vacation in exotic places, and drive luxury cars. All these goods are assumed to provide satisfaction, some more than others. Utility Theory bases its beliefs upon individualsā€™ preferences. rests upon the idea that people behave as if they make decisions by assigning imaginary utility values to the original monetary values Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 42. Expected Utility Theory: Utility Theory It explains behavior of individuals based on the premise people can consistently rank order their choices depending upon their preferences. Placing certain restrictions, preferences can be represented using a utility function It is a mathematical formulation that ranks the preferences of the individual in terms of satisfaction diļ¬€erent consumption bundles provide. Under the assumptions of utility theory, we can assume that people behaved as if they had a utility function and acted according to it. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 43. Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty While Utility Theory deals with situations in which there is no uncertainty, the Expected Utility Theory deals with choices individuals make when the outcomes they face are uncertain. If individuals maximize utility under certainty, they will also attempt to maximize expected utility under uncertainty. Using Expected Utility Theory, we will ļ¬nd that even if governments did not make purchase of insurance mandatory, the product would still have existed. Risk-averse individuals would always demand insurance for the peace of mind it confers. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 44. Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty What is uncertain in economic systems? tomorrowā€™s prices future wealth future availability of commodities present and future actions of other people. What are rational responses to uncertainty? buying insurance (health, life, auto) a portfolio of contingent consumption goods. States of Nature: ā€œCar accidentā€ and ā€œno car accidentā€. Each one occurs with a certain probability. Contingencies: A contract implemented only when a particular state of nature occurs is state-contingent. E.g. the insurer pays only if there is an accident. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 45. Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty Expected value (EV) computed as a weighted average of the events, and the weights are the probabilities those events will take place with. Expected utility allows people to compare gambles Given two gambles, we assume people prefer the situation that generates the greatest expected utility. People maximize expected utility. Many people are risk averse and prefer certainty to the uncertain gamble. For example Job A: certain income of $50K and Job B: 50% chance of $10K and 50% chance of $90K Expected income is the same ($50K) but Job A implies a certain income. Which one is preferred? Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 46. Expected Utility Theory: Uncertainty Risk-averse individuals: Utility function U(X) = āˆš X EUa = āˆš 50000 = $223.61 and EUb = 0.5 āˆš 10000 + 0.5 āˆš 90000 = $200 Job (a) is preferred Risk-neutral individuals: Utility function U(X) = X EUa = 50000 = $50000 and EUb = 0.5 Ɨ 10000 + 0.5 Ɨ 90000 = $50000 Individuals are indiļ¬€erent toward risk Risk-seeking individuals: Utility function U(X) = X2 EUa = 500002 = 25 Ɨ (10000)2 and EUb = 0.5 Ɨ (10000)2 + 0.5 Ɨ (90000)2 = 41 Ɨ (10000)2 Job (b) is preferred Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 47. Insurance: Risk Aversion Ty is a student who gets a monthly allowance of $200 (initial wealth W0) from his parents. He might lose $100 on any given day with a probability 0.5 or not lose any amount with 50% chance. His expected loss (E[L]) is 0.5($0) + 0.5($100) = $50. His expected ļ¬nal wealth is E(FW) = 0.5 āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $0) + 0.5 āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $100) = W0 āˆ’ E(L) = $150. How much Ty would be willing to pay to hedge his expected loss of $50? Assume that Tyā€™s utility function is U(W) = āˆš W , a risk averterā€™s utility function Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 48. Insurance: Risk Aversion Expected utility, no insurance He retains all the uncertainty. His expected ļ¬nal wealth of $150 as calculated above. What is his expected utility? The expected utility is calculated as a weighted sum of the utilities in the two states, ā€œlossā€ and ā€œno lossā€. EU = 0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $0)+0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $100) = $12.07 What is the actuarially fair premium (AFP) for Ty? The AFP is the expected loss ($50). Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 49. Insurance: Risk Aversion Expected Utility with insurance at AFP(=$50) With ā€œno lossā€, his ļ¬nal wealth is $150 (($200)-AFP ($50)). With a ā€œlossā€, his ļ¬nal wealth = $200-AFP ($50)-Loss ($100)+Indemnity ($100)= $150. Ty has purchased a certain wealth of $150, by paying an AFP of $50. His expected utility is $12.25 . Ty will always purchase full insurance at AFP. A risk-averse person will always hedge the risk completely at a cost (AFP) that equals the expected loss. A risk-averse person always prefers certainty to uncertainty, if uncertainty can be hedged away at its actuarially fair price. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 50. Insurance: Risk Aversion Expected Utility with insurance at a price greater than AFP What is the maximum premium Ty would be willing to pay? We should equate the utility when Ty purchases insurance at P to the expected utility in the no-insurance case ($12.07). Now, Tyā€™s certain utility is āˆš 200 āˆ’ P, and the expected utility is: EU = 0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $P)+0.5āˆ— ($200 āˆ’ $P) = 12.07 P = $54.29. The risk premiun is $54.29-$50= $4.29 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 51. Insurance: Risk Aversion Risk Premium: The premium above the AFP that a risk-averse person is willing to pay to get rid of the risk. Any insurance company that charges a premium greater than $54.29 will not be able to sell insurance to Ty. Individualsā€™ risk aversion is a key component in insurance pricing. The greater the degree of risk aversion, the higher the risk premium an individual will be willing to pay. The premium has to be less than or equal to the maximum premium the person is willing to pay. Otherwise, the individual will never buy full insurance. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 52. Risk Aversion Most individuals with average wealth and good education tend to be risk neutral over small gambles. Over larger gambles individuals tend to be risk averse. (Except when buying lottery tickets.) Large organizations: banks, insurance companies, ļ¬rms tend to be risk neutral.Two reasons: The risks are small relative to the organizationā€™s size. They have so many risky things that they on average tend to cancel each other out ā€“ ā€œdiversiļ¬ed riskā€. A risk averse individual will always be better oļ¬€ buying actuarially fair insurance. As insurance becomes less fair (administration costs, deductibles, copays etc), risk averse individuals will buy less insurance. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 53. Insurance: Moral Hazard An insurance company has to decide whether to sell an auto insurance policy to Luke. Luke is a risk-averse person whose utility function is U(W) = āˆš W. Luke claims to be a good risk because Lukeā€™s driving record is excellent. Luke can also choose to be either a careful driver or a not-so-careful driver. Luke drives a car carrying a market value of $10,000. The only other asset he owns is the $3,000 in his checking account. His total initial wealth of $13,000 If he drives carefully, he incurs a cost of $3,000. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 54. Insurance: Moral Hazard Luke faces the following ā€œloss distributionā€ Drives with Care without Care Prob. Loss Prob. Loss accident 0.25 $10,000 0.75 $10,000 no accident 0.75 0 0.25 0 When he has an accident, his car is a total loss. The probabilities of ā€œlossā€ and ā€œno lossā€ are reversed when he decides to drive without care. EV[loss]= $2,500 and EV[loss]= $7,500. Lukeā€™s problem has 4 parts: whether to drive with or without care, (I) when he has no insurance and (II) when he has insurance. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 55. Insurance: Moral Hazard Case I when he carries no insurance. Drives with Care without Care Prob. U(W) Prob. U(W) accident 0.25 0 0.75 $54.77 no accident 0.75 $100 0.25 $114.02 Drives with care and has an accident: W = $13000 āˆ’ $3000 āˆ’ $10000 = 0 ā‡’ U(0) = 0 Drives with care and has not an accident: W = $13000āˆ’$3000āˆ’0 = $10000 ā‡’ U($10000) = $100 Drives without care and has an accident: W = $13000 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ $10000 = $3000 ā‡’ U($3000) = $54.77 Drives without care and has not an accident: W = $13000 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ 0 = $13000 ā‡’ U($13000) = $114.02 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 56. Insurance: Moral Hazard The expected utility of driving with care: EU = 0.25 Ɨ 0 + 0.75 Ɨ 100 = $75 The expected utility of driving without care: EU = 0.75 Ɨ 54.77 + 0.25 Ɨ 114.02 = $69.58 Luke will drive carefully since his expected utility is higher when he exercises due care. His utility is $75 versus $69.58. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 57. Insurance: Moral Hazard Case II when he carries insurance. Insurance premiun= $2750 = $2500 Ɨ (1 + 0.1) Drives with Care without Care Prob. U(W) Prob. U(W) accident 0.25 $85.15 0.75 $101.24 no accident 0.75 $85.15 0.25 $101.24 With an insurance, Luke has eliminated the uncertainty. If he has an accident, the insurance company indemniļ¬es him with $10,000. Drives with care and has an accident: W = $10250 āˆ’ $3000 āˆ’ $10000 + $10000 = $7250 ā‡’ U(7250) = $85.15 Drives with care and has not an accident: W = $10250 āˆ’ $3000 = $7250 ā‡’ U(7250) = $85.15 Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 58. Insurance: Moral Hazard Drives without care and has an accident: W = $10250 āˆ’ 0 āˆ’ $10000 + $10000 = $10250 ā‡’ U(10250) = $101.24 Drives without care and has not an accident: W = $10250 āˆ’ 0 = $10250 ā‡’ U(10250) = $101.24 The expected utility of driving with care: EU = 0.25 Ɨ 85.15 + 0.75 Ɨ 85.15 = $85.15 The expected utility of driving without care: EU = 0.75 Ɨ 101.24 + 0.25 Ɨ 101.242 = $101.24 The net result is he switches to driving with no care Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 59. Insurance: Moral Hazard Why do we get this result? The cost of insurance is cheaper than the cost of care. Insurance companies can charge a price greater than the cost of care up to a maximum of what Luke is willing to pay. In the event of asymmetric information, the insurance company will not know the cost of care. Inexpensive insurance distorts the incentives and individuals switch to riskier behavior ex post. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions
  • 60. References Varian, Hal R. 2010. Intermediate microeconomics: a modern approach. New York: W.W. Norton & Co. Prepared by CĆ©sar R. Sobrino Asymmetric Information, Uncertainty, and, Auctions