2. For many years, the term operations management, or OM, was
applied almost exclusively to
manufacturing. More recently, the tools of OM have also been
recognized for their potential to improve
operations in the service sector. Still, some view the discipline
too narrowly, identifying it as the purview of
those who hold the title of “operations manager.” Operational
excellence is a broader concept that applies
to all job functions and all pursuits that keep the organization
running in top form. It is the ongoing search
for better ways of achieving results. However, it’s not about
just ‘fine tuning’ the flow of work as it currently
exists, but about stepping back, asking good questions, and
finding ways to improve how the entire
organization operates. The ultimate objective is to leverage
those improvements to strengthen the
organization’s competitive advantage.
Why It Matters
• Operational excellence is a competitive advantage. If your
organization can run faster and leaner
and can deliver products or services to your customers that are
less expensive or better quality
than your competitors can, you will have an edge in the
marketplace.
• Seeking a better way every day encourages team members to
challenge themselves, get their
brains in the game, find ways to reduce tasks that waste
resources, and redirect their time and
energy to tasks that add real value.
• Adopting a broader view of operations opens the door to using
4. INTRODUCTION
Welcome to the Course
If you’ve never worked in or studied operations management,
the subject may be a bit of a mystery to
you. You may have images of factory managers with clipboards
and stopwatches standing beside
assembly lines, measuring output and doing obscure math to
calculate “something” that you’re not sure
you understand. This can be especially true if you work in a
service industry where production metrics are
not front and center every day. You may think that OM is
something other people do, and while you
certainly want them to do well and contribute to your
organization, the impact of OM on your daily life is a
passing interest.
If any of the above is true, you may also see this course as a
“necessary evil” – a required hurdle to
overcome on your path to earning an MBA.
We are going to make sure this is not the case. Throughout the
course, we will focus on solving real-
world problems and on the practical application of the tools we
study. In each topic we address, you will
find a consistent pattern in the approach we take:
1. Understand the current state of operational performance
2. Identify opportunities for improvement
3. Ask the right questions, focusing on what really matters
4. Gather the right data and apply the right tools to answer
5. those questions
5. Develop, present, and implement viable solutions to improve
performance and outcomes
This approach is designed to help you become a better manager
and a more effective leader. You will
hone the skills that will help you take your organization forward
and increase its competitive strength.
The Pursuit of Excellence Impacts Every Part of the
Organization
Management of operations is not the domain of any single
function or department. It is not limited to the
factory floor or to supply chains or to production quality. It
isn’t just part of administration or a company’s
back-office functions. The pursuit of operational excellence is
multifaceted, and seeks to realize multiple
goals and implement process improvements that are:
• Effective – actually addressing the company’s needs
• Efficient – cost-effective and not wasteful
• Global – taking into context the greater economic environment
• Sustainable – not creating long-term liabilities in the pursuit
of short-term gains
• Responsible – fulfilling the business’s fiduciary and
community obligations, such as maintaining
long-term solvency
8. LECTURE NOTES FOR THIS COURSE
The purpose of the lecture notes in this course is not to reteach
topics that are covered in the core texts,
readings, and videos. The purpose of these notes is to:
1. Help you assess your starting point by providing a realistic
picture of the challenges you may
face, but also the payoff that comes from mastering the
necessary skills.
2. Focus your work on the most important themes and
takeaways from each week’s materials.
3. Provide tips on applying what you are learning in your own
workplace to help you become a more
effective business leader.
You are encouraged to read the lecture notes first each week,
and then to reread them after you have
completed your other coursework in order to reinforce what you
have learned.
The core text for this course, Value Stream Mapping by Karen
Martin and Mike Osterling, is introduced in
Week 1. It identifies a key objective of pursuing operational
excellence – adding value. The book offers
not only a rationale for value stream mapping, but also practical
steps that leaders can use in assembling
9. mapping teams, analyzing value streams, and improving how
work gets done. Other core resources in
our course include OM modules from Harvard Business School,
as well as LinkedIn Learning videos.
These are used primarily to introduce the more “technical”
elements of the tools of OM. Throughout the
course, we strive to maintain a balance between big-picture
ideas and specific tools. While OM tools are
critical to success, they are not sufficient. Placing tools before
people is not the right approach. The most
successful operations leaders always keep the big-picture
objectives in focus, apply the appropriate tools
to help them ask the right questions, and leverage
methodologies that guide the organization on a path to
excellence.
THE CHALLENGE AND OPPORTUNITY FOR MANAGERS
In each set of lecture notes, we will include a section: “The
Challenge and Opportunity for Managers.”
This will introduce the topics addressed that week, present some
of the barriers that managers may face,
and explain how the tools and practices we cover can help you
become a better leader.
Learning about the tools of OM can seem intimidating. You will
encounter jargon and unfamiliar
terminology. It’s easy to let those technical terms become a
barrier to your education. However, if you
take the time to engage the course materials, you’ll find that
what you learn is a lot easier to apply than
you might have believed. In fact, with a little effort, that barrier
11. have to perform? Do some of these seem overly cumbersome or
weighed down by
bureaucracy or sub-par communication with other workers or
departments?
3. How do quality issues impact your deliverables? For
example, even if the final output performs
at a high standard, have there been multiple inspection and
repair steps required before the
product was released? How might those steps be reduced
without compromising quality?
4. How do your production metrics compare to those of your
competitors? Are they able to deliver
similar products/services to customers faster, cheaper, or that
perform better?
5. Is senior management eager to engage frontline workers in
finding better ways of working? Is
your organization one that values “getting every brain in the
13. increase competitive strength, you will start to
see opportunities everywhere.
So, whether you work in a manufacturing company or a service
company, for-profit or not-for-profit, large
business or small business, there is one element that every
organization has in common – work. The core
issue, then, is how that work adds value – whether measured by
customer/revenue growth, shareholder
value, or employee satisfaction about the work they exchange
for the paycheck they earn. When you and
your colleagues come to work each day, do the systems, tasks,
tools, and processes enable you to deliver
your product or service effectively and efficiently?
If you are not sure about the answer to that question, you’re not
alone. Martin and Osterling summarize
the challenge as follows:
“The lack of understanding about how work flows – or more
commonly, doesn’t flow – across a
work system that’s sole purpose is to deliver value to a
customer is a fundamental problem that
results in poor performance, poor business decisions, and poor
work environments. Conflicting
priorities, interdepartmental tension, and – in the worst cases –
infighting within leadership teams
are common outcomes when a company attempts to operate
without a clear understanding about
how an organization’s various parts fit together and how value
is delivered to its customers. And
significant time and money is wasted when organizations
attempt to make improvement without a
clearly defined, externally focused improvement strategy that
places the customer in the center.
15. contains Strayer University Confidential and Proprietary
information and may not
be copied, further distributed, or otherwise disclosed in whole
or in part, without the expressed written permission of Strayer
University.
JWI 550 (1208) Page 8 of 13
And a Value Stream Map…?
The “map” is pretty much what it sounds like. Just like a
roadmap, it is a way to visualize a journey. It
shows how you get from one place to another place. Most maps
don’t show every single detail about the
terrain or other specific elements, such as speed limits and
altitudes. Which features of the map are most
important will vary by user and purpose. If the map is too
general, critical information may be missing. But
if it is too detailed, the overall journey can get lost in the
weeds. The same is true of a value stream map.
As we progress through the first several weeks of the course, we
will explore several important topics: (1)
the purpose of value stream maps, (2) what it takes to create a
useful one, and (3) when and why we
would need to drill down deeper into individual “processes” –
which we will explore more in Weeks 3 and
4 – to identify workflow shortcomings and opportunities for
improvement.
As Martin and Osterling point out, value stream maps are not
the same as process maps. “[They] offer a
holistic view of how work flows through entire systems, and
they differ from process maps in several
significant ways.”
16. 1. Value stream maps provide a powerful means to establish a
strategic direction for improvements.
2. Value stream maps provide a visual, full-cycle view of how
work progresses from a request to its
fulfillment.
3. Value stream mapping deepens organizational understanding
about work systems that deliver
value, leading to better decision making and work design.
4. The quantitative nature of value stream maps lays the
foundation for a data-driven, strategic
decision making.
5. Value stream maps reflect work flow as a customer
experiences it, as opposed to process-level
maps that are internally focused.
Value Stream Mapping, pp. 7-10
CHANGE IS HARD
You Can’t See the Forest for the Trees
As the authors note, “[t]ransformation requires fundamental
changes in an organization’s DNA; done well,
value stream mapping can be instrumental in facilitating the
necessary shifts in mindsets and behaviors”
(p. 11). The core of the challenge of change is that the people
who are involved in doing and overseeing
the work often don’t see the big picture of the flow. This sounds
18. from internally focused thinking to customer-focused thinking,
which is the foundation for providing
greater and greater value” (p. 12). In fact, they go as far as to
say, “we’ve found no more powerful way to
heal the tension that often exists between functional areas, such
as sales and operations, quality and
production, and IT and…well, everyone!” (p. 14). That’s a
pretty exciting claim!
They do, however, offer an interesting caveat, noting, “It’s the
process of value stream mapping rather
than the maps themselves that carries the greatest power by
instilling transformational mindsets and
behaviors into the DNA of an organization” (p. 17).
“…improvements that begin with a value stream perspective are
more likely to be sustained and
lead to both top-line and bottom-line growth. In the case of
government agencies and nonprofit
organizations, proper value stream design and management can
reduce costs, improve
organizational effectiveness, reduce the risk of privatization,
free up cash to reinvest in the
agency, and improve employee morale and constituent
satisfaction.”
Value Stream Mapping, p. 18
Like most complex undertakings, there are more ways to get it
wrong than there are to get it right. There
are multiple potential “failings” of value stream mapping
initiatives. These include creating maps without
taking any action, and mapping with the wrong team – or even
without involving the team at all. But
perhaps the biggest failing is mapping without metrics:
20. While there is a lot to get excited about when it comes to value
stream mapping, there is some guidance
about the road ahead:
“Too many organizations dive into value stream mapping before
the organization is properly
prepared and the activity has been properly scoped. Effective
planning is a significant contributor
in elevating value stream mapping from a ‘tool’ to a
management practice that produces long-
lasting transformation.”
“Getting tangled up in the weeds is a common reason why
process improvement efforts fail to
deliver sustainable results, and why inserting value stream
mapping into the improvement
process helps an organization make faster and deeper progress.”
Value Stream Mapping, p. 27, 29
Assembling the Team
Process mapping, like any change initiative, is not a solo
activity. While the size and composition of the
team may vary according to circumstances, Martin and
Osterling offer the following guidance:
“If the ripple effect of the projected improvements is somewhat
contained, you can limit the
overview to the team members and those leaders who oversee
21. the areas within the value stream
being transformed. If the projected improvement(s) will touch a
large percentage of the workforce,
it’s best to include the entire leadership team. For your first few
value stream mapping activities,
it’s also helpful to include leadership from support services,
such as human resources,
information technology, and finance so that they, too, can begin
to see the interconnectedness
within the organization and the benefits of viewing work
through a value stream lens. Ultimately,
every leader needs to understand the organization’s key value
streams and how his or her team
supports the delivery of value to external customers.”
Value Stream Mapping, p. 30
The remainder of the chapter explains the role and components
of a Value Stream Mapping Charter (pp.
31-47). This is an important tool to align the team around a
common objective and define the scope of the
project. Review this guidance carefully before you embark on
this step of your operational excellence
initiative. Like many undertakings, success or failure are
largely determined in the planning stages.
Getting the right team in place means including: (1) affected
leadership, (2) mapping team members who
will help build and analyze the maps, and (3) workers in areas
that will be included in the value stream
walk.
24. advantage
As you begin to explore operational excellence, start close to
home. Don’t try to analyze the
competitive strength of your entire organization – there will be
opportunities for that later. Think
about how you and your team deliver value to the organization
through the work you do and the
outputs you produce. What would the benefits look like if you
could deliver more and/or better
products or services with the same inputs and resources, or if
you could continue to meet your
current output requirements more efficiently? Don’t worry too
much about how you could do this
just yet – focus on the impact. If output or costs could be
improved by, say, 15%, how could that
make the organization more competitive?
• Describe key characteristics of operational excellence
One of the best ways to appreciate the topics we will cover in
this course is to take what you are
learning and test it out in your own job. This “testing” doesn’t
have to mean making any actual
changes just yet; it can be evaluating the concept to see if it
holds water when applied to what
you and your team do. The characteristics of operational
excellence include, but are not limited
to, delivering outputs faster, cheaper, and with fewer errors in a
way that is safe and sustainable.
Make a list of what that would include for your job. Then, rank
your list in terms of priority. Which
of these improvements would have the greatest impact on other
parts of the organization? Why?
26. University.
JWI 550 (1208) Page 13 of 13
ACTION PLAN
To apply what I have learned this week in my course to my job,
I will…
Action Item(s)
Resources and Tools Needed (from this course and in my
workplace)
Timeline and Milestones