Mezirow's Perspective Transformation and its relevance to group dynamics in a competitve work environment. Wilfred Bion's work is examined as a complement to Mezirow's thoughts.
Beyond the Codes_Repositioning towards sustainable development
Mezirow's Perspective Transformation
1. Mezirow’s Transformational Learning Theory
and Its Relevance to Managing Group
Dynamics in a Competitive Work Environment
S. Henry-Campbell, Nova Southeastern University
S. A. Hadeed, Florida International University
Transformation Theory/Group Dynamics SFERC 2015 1
2. THE PURPOSE OF INTELLECT IS THE TRANSFORMATION OF A
“MIRACLE” TO SOMETHING UNDERSTANDABLE.
– ALBERT EINSTEIN
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 2
3. MEZIROW’S TRANSFORMATIONAL THEORY
Involves critical thinking, which includes conducting an internal investigation into
one’s views and philosophies to transform one’s life into a new significant way
(1997)
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 3
4. CLARK’S VIEW..
Transformational learning is defined as learning that induces more far-reaching
change in the learner than other kinds of learning, especially learning
experiences, which shape the learner and produce a significant impact, or
paradigm shift, which affects the learner's subsequent experiences.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 4
5. RECOGNIZING THE SHIFT
• Individuals are able to look at themselves (Introspection)
• Reflect on the beliefs that they possess
• An event acts as a trigger
• Competing expressions of others perspectives
• Recognize that a change can be made
• Make changes to beliefs.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 5
6. UNDERPINNING TRANSFORMATION
Critical reflection is a key element in the process of perspective transformation
(Mezirow, 1990).
• Individuals are able to critically look at every angle of the situation or
experience
• Including other person’s point of view in order to avoid a one-sided
transformation process.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 6
7. BION’S WORK
• Bion (1961) credited with insightful work on group dynamics through his
Tavistock Clinic
• Spoke to the work group and the basic assumption group.
• Work group demonstrates the conscious level of the group process.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 7
8. BION’S WORK
• Basic Work Assumption is the unconscious group process where individuals
adopt measures aimed at protecting themselves from the discomfort of
working in groups.
• Examples include challenging the authority of the leader; hidden agendas.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 8
9. BION’S THREE BASIC ASSUMPTIONS
• Dependency Assumption
Characterized by the groups need to feel safe
Leaders response is to attend to all decisions.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 9
10. BION’S THREE BASIC ASSUMPTIONS
• Fight/Flight – Group desires appropriate leadership at varying times
Guidance for group action when threats surface
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 10
11. BION’S THREE BASIC ASSUMPTIONS
• Act of reproducing – influenced by Sigmund Freud’s work, Bion addresses the
need of the group to form new realities .
Instances of groups being formed to address untoward events (pre/post)
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 11
12. BRIDGING THE DIVIDE
OPERATING IN AN ENVIRONMENT OF
CONTRADICTIONS
• Living with contradictory realities
• Examples: conflict/resolution; light/dark; good evil
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 12
13. PARADOXICAL PROBLEM-SOLVING AS A TOOL
• Reframe how we react to present events (new groups) instead of trying to
change the actual dynamics of the group
• Adjust our perception and response to the group dynamics
• Alter the way we perceive our reactions and our thought processes to the
group (Cloke & Goldsmith, 2011).
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 13
14. PARADOXICAL PROBLEM-SOLVING AS A TOOL
• Recognizing the multiple, typically conflicting truths that shape and inform our
problems.
• Challenge us to deploy higher-level skills and intelligence, to discern multiple
truths and discover fresh ideas in the complex, contradictory nature of our
problem.
• Turn problems into evolutionary imperatives and opportunities.
Cloke and Goldsmith (2011)
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 14
15. 5 STEPS (PARADOXICAL PROBLEM SOLVING)
1. Admit that a problem exists
2. Examine and clarify the elements and nature of problem
3. Investigate, analyze and prioritize the problem
4. Look at possible solutions
5. Jointly act, evaluate results, acknowledge efforts and celebrate success
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 15
16. COMPLEMENTARY THEORETICAL FRAMES
• Complex Structures
• Perspectives change over time
• Influenced by events
• Events that impact at the individual level can impact at the group level.
• Expectation in an organization is for the individual to be subsumed by the org.
will.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 16
17. COMPLEMENTARY THEORETICAL FRAMES
• Managing the individual’s expectations requires an understanding of how
events produce changes for good or bad.
• Perspective transformation is necessary if groups are to adapt to change.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 17
18. ACCESSING AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT IN GROUPS
• Identify the underlying work assumptions that will prevent the group from
meeting targets.
• Create a culture of recognizing success, where the individual is encouraged by
the group’s achievement.
• Provide opportunities for various groups to work together. This builds
awareness and tolerance among members.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 18
19. ACCESSING AREAS FOR IMPROVEMENT IN GROUPS
• Cultivate leaders who are able to champion decisions in the face of change.
• Open opportunities for dialogue. Difficult conversations included.
• List is not exhaustive
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 19
20. REFERENCES
• Bion, W.R. (1961). Experiences in groups. New York, NY: Basic Books
• Clark, M.C. (1993). Transformational learning. New Directions fro Adult and
Continuing Education 57, 47-56
• Freud, S. (1926). Inhibitions, Symptoms and anxiety. New York: W.W. Norton
and Company.
• Mezirow, J. (1997). Transformative learning: Theory to Practice. New directions
for adult and continuing education.
Transformation Theory/Group Dyamics - SFERC 2015 20