This document summarizes information presented by Chaplain William Hartfelder in a CIT training on spiritual challenges, compassion fatigue, moral injury, and law enforcement. It introduces Hartfelder and defines what a chaplain is. It then discusses how law enforcement can experience spiritual struggles and defines compassion fatigue as the physical and mental exhaustion experienced by those who care for others over long periods. Symptoms and risks of compassion fatigue and moral injury are outlined. The document recommends increasing awareness, maintaining balance through self-care, and nurturing connections to cope with these challenges.
How ya holdin' up? - Spiritual Challenges, Compassion Fatigue, Moral Injury and Law Enforcement
1. HOW YA’ HOLDIN’ UP?
Spiritual Challenges,
Compassion Fatigue, Moral
Injury
and Law Enforcement
Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) Training
August 12, 2020
Chaplain William Hartfelder, CPD
2. WHO IS THIS GUY?
• Chaplain William (Will) Hartfelder (614-595-2212)
• Raised in NYC and Yonkers, NY
• Extensive training in Biblical Languages, archaeology
• Extensive travel in Europe and Middle East
• Teaching experience college and seminary levels
• Retired after 31 years in three congregations
• CPD Chaplain five years
• CIT, CISM certified
• International Conference of Police Chaplains (ICPC)
3. WHAT IS A CHAPLAIN?
C: CARING
H: HEARING
A: AVAILABLE
P: PREVENTION
L: LOAD
A: RESOURCE
I: TIME OF NEED
N: NOT A PIPELINE
4. SPIRITUALITY AND LAW ENFORCEMENT
Now matter your definition/description of “spirituality…
In Law Enforcement you will experience what are
essentially “spiritual questions/doubt” about:
• God or Higher Power
• Challenge to or loss of faith in God or Higher
Power
• Cynicism over the ”goodness” of others
• Reality of evil
5. SPIRITUALITY AND LAW ENFORCEMENT
“Put on the whole armor of God, so that you may be
able to stand against the wiles of the devil. For
our struggle is not against enemies of blood and
flesh, but against the rulers, against the authorities,
against the cosmic powers of this present darkness,
against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly
places.” (Ephesians 6:11-12; NRSV)
7. COMPASSION FATIGUE
After what can seem like an unrelenting stream of
needy people compounded by a never-ending
parade of people making (very) bad decisions, we
get to where responding is not only what we don’t
feel like doing, we may not even care anymore. It’s
called compassion fatigue and it happens to the
best of us.
8. COMPASSION FATIGUE
Merriam-Webster definition of compassion
fatigue:
“the physical and mental exhaustion and
emotional withdrawal experienced by those
who care for sick or traumatized people over an
extended period of time.”
10. COMPASSION FATIGUE
• Also “vicarious” or “secondary traumatization
• PTSD-related symptoms
• May occur with one exposure or “cumulative”
• Differs from burn-out, but can co-exist
11. “BURNOUT”
Burnout - when the engine seizes and you
have to get out, leave the car by the side of the
road and get a tow.
Compassion fatigue - when you discover your
car is low on oil. You pull into a gas station,
add the oil you need and get back on your way.
12. COMPASSION FATIGUE
“The natural behaviors and emotions that arise
from knowing about a traumatizing event
experienced by a significant other – the stress
resulting from helping or wanting to help a
traumatized person.”
(Charles R. Figley, PhD)
13. COMPASSION FATIGUE: NATURAL
REACTIONS/SYMPTOMS
• Affects many dimensions of your well-being
• Nervous system arousal (Sleep disturbance)
• Emotional intensity increases
• Cognitive ability decreases
• Behavior and judgment impaired
• Isolation and loss of morale
• Lack of energy
14. COMPASSION FATIGUE: NATURAL
REACTIONS/SYMPTOMS
• Depression and PTSD (increases intensity)
• Loss of self-worth and emotional modulation
• Identity, worldview, and spirituality impacted
• Beliefs and psychological needs-safety, trust, esteem,
intimacy, and control
• Loss of hope and meaning
• Anger toward perpetrators or causal events
15. VICARIOUS/SECONDARY TRAUMATIZATION
• Any individual who hears, sees, or learns of
how a victim/victims have been affected by a
traumatic event
• Work related exposure to traumatized people
25. MORAL INJURY
What is Moral Injury?
Moral injury is the suffering people experience when we are
in high stakes situations, things go wrong, and harm results
that challenges our deepest moral codes and ability to trust
in others or ourselves. The harm may be something we did,
something we witnessed, or something that was done to us.
It results in moral emotions such as shame, guilt, self-
condemnation, outrage, and sorrow.
(The Shay Moral Injury Center)
27. MORAL INJURY - SYMPTOMS
• Loss of trust in self
• Disrupted Relationships
• Mask inner pain with alcohol or drugs.
• Alienation
• Anger at the slightest provocation.
28. MORAL INJURY & PTSD
• PTSD is fear-based.
• Moral injury based in moral judgment, and having it
requires a working conscience.
• Share some symptoms
• PTSD treatment can aggravate moral injury.
29. HOW YA’ HOLDIN’ UP?
Remember:
• Self-Care part of a healthy approach to what you do
• No less important than your equipment
• Pays HUGE dividends
• Is NORMAL
CISM – Critical Incident Stress Management (Billy Graham Rapid Response Training at OPOTA)
WHO? – externals, person with great respect for and care about the well-being of you who have been called to
In addition to the religious requirements, e.g, ordained/officlal clergy (NOTE BILLY GRAHAM RAPID RESPONSE TEAM) of a recognized religious body with established minimum of experience
Available – CPD several, on all months, but always available
From International Conference of Police Chaplains
C: CARING – ”Who cares?” Chaplain someone who genuinely cares
H: HEARING – Called to listen
A: AVAILABLE – Officers top priority
P: PREVENTION – Association with Officers can help before a crisis
L: LOAD – Officers take on tremendous pressure, chaplain present to help
A: RESOURCE – When questions of life, faith, spirituality, meaning come up
I: IN TIME OF NEED - understanding, encouragement without judgment
N: NOT A PIPELINE – Confidentiality is at the center
Clicker:
New Over reliance on faith
Issues of being able to forgive and to be forgiven (cousin Fred in Vietnam)
STORY – HQ first nights of protests DT – “chaplain, I’m finding it really hard to see the face of Jesus in those people”
STORY – officer in Phoenix, AZ – working undercover narcotics, how it went down suspect shot first, officer responded, only wounded, officer’s backup apprehended, when he walked up to the suspect was struck by deeply red eyes and sense of evil filled him. Ten years later in foot pursuit of suspect at Sky Harbor Airport in Phoenix, suspect jumped over hedge, officer followed and had a feeling he had jumped over the suspect. As he hit the ground suspect fired and missed. Officer returned fire and wounded suspect. Other officers arrived on scene and took suspect into custody. What blew the officer’s mind was as the suspect was brought to his cruiser he saw what he could only descry be as the same “red eyes” of ten years before and then the suspect said to him Spanish to the officer, “Good to see you again.” Hard to believe?
Not just a phrase, but studies indicate it is among the most dedicated, top performing officers that issues of self-care manifest themselves
Kent Williams – BREACH POINT CONSULTING – 32 years on the job most recently Chief of Chicago area PD – ”where is the man I fell in love with”
Greater risk for alcohol abuse, divorce, isolation, depression and suicide…
“Caustic Effects of Performing Well in Law Enforcement”
Also “vicarious” or “secondary traumatization
PTSD-related symptoms due to working with patients and families who have trauma and grief
May occur with one exposure or can “cumulative” l
Differs from burn-out, but can co-exist
PTSD (PTS)
Characteristics –
-Intrusive recollected thoughts-Arousal-Numbing/Withdrawal/Avoidance
Symptoms:
FlashbacksDreamsDe`ja vu
AvoidanceSleep disturbance
Loss of interest
Detachment
Emotional numbing
Increased startle response
Intensification
Address Compassion Fatigue BEFORE BURNOUT!
Dr. Figley – born in Chicago, grew up in Ohio, joined Marine Corp right out of HS, served in ‘Nam
Tulane University Paul Henry Kurzweg, MD Distinguished Chair in Disaster Mental Health…Dir. of Traumatology Institute
Emphasis: THE NATURAL BEHAVIORS!!!
charlesfigley.com
Terms interchangeable
Contributes to Compassion Fatigue
Support staff, communications, etc.
Story – Training officer from NC (38 years on the job) – worked with the Mayor’s office and Mayor fond of invoking African saying “It takes a village to raise a child”
Finally asked him why he always seemed to react negatively –
He responded “I’ve seen the villagers!”
Story – smell of perfume upon arrival at a 10-18 – grandma’s same perfume
Especially officers with high level of empathy:
Emotional – “I feel what you feel”
- Cognitive “I understand what you feel”
Options:
Set up a wall
Recognize what is happening and taking steps of self-care
Caveat: Usually don’t like to just hand these out without opportunity for conversation
so seek out EAP, private resource….a CHAPLAIN (define chaplain care)
Practice excellent self-care
Nurture yourself by putting activities in your schedule that are
sources of pleasure, joy and diversion
Allow yourself to take mini-escapes- these relieve the intensity of your work
Transform the negative impact of your work (find meaning, challenge negativity, find gratitude)
MINDFULNESS – amazing how cops can be so “on the job” but not off
Get medical treatment if needed to relieve symptoms that interfere with daily functioning- don’t use alcohol or drugs to self-medicate
Get professional help when needed to get back on track- we all need coaches and consultants at times
Have quiet alone time in a calm, beautiful place- a safe retreat where you feel renewed (EXTROVERT/INTROVERT)
Have an awareness of what restores and replenishes you.
Find ways to acknowledge loss and grief
Stay clear with commitment to career goals or your personal mission
Know how to focus on what you can control
Look at situations as entertaining challenges and opportunities, not problems or stresses
Talk out your stress
Process your thoughts and reactions with someone else (coworker, therapist, clergy, friend, family, supervisor)
Build a positive support system that supports you, not fuels your stress
Pets accept whatever affection you are able to give them without asking for more
Pets are basically invulnerable to “provider burnout”
Blood pressure and heart rate decrease when interacting with animals
Loss of trust in themselves and their moral foundations;
Relationships may be disrupted because they cannot trust others not to judge them, and they self- isolate.
May mask their inner pain with alcohol or drugs.
Become alienated from societal norms and lash out in anger at the slightest provocation.
PTSD is fear-based.
Moral injury is based in moral judgment, and having it requires a working conscience.
The two can share some symptoms, like anger, addiction, or depression, but moral injury has no diagnosis or treatment protocols.
Some PTSD treatment protocols can aggravate moral injury. For example, Dr. William Nash, a psychiatrist and expert on moral injury, points out that reliving a traumatic incident many times in a safe environment to defuse the fear can sometimes bring moral injury “to emotional immediacy” and make it harder to address.
Remember:
Self-Care is an important part of a healthy approach to what you do
It is no less important, even more important, than your equipment
It pays HUGE dividends not only in work performance, but in LIFE PERFORMANCE
It is NORMAL because every officer is a human being in his/her physical, emotional, moral and spiritual WHOLENESS