This is a R&D project between Sopra Steria and Université de Lorraine in France. We want to predict project performance using project maturity models and artificial intellifence
2. 89%
36%
97%
<30%
HOW IMPORTANT IS PROJECT MANAGEMENT FOR YOUR
ORGANIZATION ?
High
performance
Low
Performance
All ProjectsOrganisations
Of organizations believe project management is critical to business
performance and organizational success
High-performing organizations complete 89% of their projects
…while low performers
of those projects successfully completed on time and on
budget
But only
[PMI, 2014], [PWC, 2016]
3. YOU ARE NOT THE ONLY ONE HAVING THIS PROBLEMS
130%
500%20%
75%
AVERAGE COST OVERRUN IN
BIG PROJECTS
[Atif Ansa et al. 2017]
4. ONE SOLUTION IN PM LITTERATURE IS BY DEVELOPING
PROJECT MANAGEMENT MATURITY MODELS (PMMM)
Maturity Level 1
Maturity Level 2
Maturity Level 3
Maturity Level 4 & 5
There are not any project
management practice stablish,
the project is first in its type in
the company (ad hoc), it
doesn’t have a defined team or
senior management support.
there are some good practices
in place and there is a small
team engage, also the
organization have done some
similar work before.
The project management
practices are standardize
within the organization, there
is a clear project team that
have informal skill and training
in project management.
There is a team with strength
teamwork and formal training
in project management, they
benchmark best practices and
formally report the
information. .
[PMI, 2008], [CMMI, 2006], [Ibbs et al., 2000], [Crawford, J.K. 2002] , [OGC, 2008]
5. 90% OF THEM ARE UNDER
LEVEL 2
The maturity models have several
problems:
Level 2 Level 3 Level 4 & 5Level 1
22%
6%
68%
4%
100% Can’t make any
prediction of the success of
projects
90% Can’t take account of
strategy problems in the
environment of the company
72% Not created for the
adequate level of complexity of
the project
65% Are too long to apply, they give
best practice but didn’t help the
company to get to the next level
BUT, AFTER THE EVALUATION OF MORE THAN 200
ORGANIZATIONS…
[Grant & Pennypacker. 2016 ]5
7. FOR DEVELOPPING IT, WE START STUDING THE KM OF SOPRA
STERIA CONSULTING:
AREVA
Evaluation of
Maturity in project
management for 20
projects
01
02 04
03 05
Chrous
Evaluation of the
complexity of
projects
Project Health Check
Evaluation of problems to
turnaround of drift projects
PnM
Tool created to
evaluate Project
Management
Maturity
Tender M4
Tool created to evaluate Bid
management maturity
8. WE PROPOSE THIS CLASSIFICATION OF PROJECTS IN
ORDER TO ANALYSE THEIR MATURITY LEVEL:
2
4
1
ComplexityLevel
Strategic Value
Complexity
Strategic
Agile
Complicate
Leverage
Complex
Projects’ classificationComplex
Projects
2
3
1Complicate
Projects
Agile
Projects
3
Leverage
Projects
4
10. Practices
Practices
Practices
Criterion
Practices
Practices
Practices
Maturity
Level 5
Maturity
Level 4
Maturity
Level 3
Maturity
Level 2
Maturity
Level 1
Dimension
Criterion
Practices
Practices
Practices
Criterion
Practices
Practices
Practices
Dimension
Criterion
CriterionCriterionCriterionCriterion
ML Algorithm
Performance
EfficiencyEfficacity
FINALLY, CONVERGING THE BLACK BOX MODEL INTO A WHITE BOX
MODEL (USING MACHINE LEARNING) TO PREDICT PERFORMANCE:
RETEX
KM
Interviews
11. PLANNING
FOR THE NEXT 3 YEARS
State of the art
PM, AI, ML Criteria,
interviews
01
Model development
Bayes Networks, Quantitative data02
Test of the model:
EOI, Sopra Steria, Customers03
Publications
Articles, sustentation04
S1 2017 S2 2017 S1 2018 S2 2018 S1 2019 S2 2019
Editor's Notes
Maturité et performance de la gestion projet appliqué à la TD
=> Learning Maturity
https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2017/03/learning-about-creativity-from-formula-1?utm_content=buffer364ce&utm_medium=social&utm_source=linkedin.com&utm_campaign=buffer
When was the last time you lead or participle in a project?
97% of organizations believe project management is critical to business performance and organizational success (Source: PWC)
PMI organization affirm that $122 million was wasted for every $1 billion invested in the United States, due to poor project performance.
Fewer than a third of all projects were successfully completed on time and on budget over the past year. (Source: Standish Group)
18. High-performing organizations successfully complete 89% of their projects, while low performers complete only 36%. (Source: PMI.org)
Project Management Maturity: An Assessment of Project Management Capabilities Among and Between Selected Industries
Kevin P. Grant and James S. Pennypacker