1. Development of Afterschool
Education System in Latvia:
Possible Ways for Quality
Assurance in Nowadays Situation
Daiga Kalnina, assistant professor,
University of Latvia, Faculty of Pedagogy, Psychology
and Art
2. Charasteristics of Afterschool
Education System
• Interest-related education – realisation of the individual
educational needs and desires of a person regardless of age
and previously acquired education
• Professional orientation education – the acquisition of
systematised knowledge and skills, as well as the formation
of values orientation in art, culture or sport concurrently with
the basic education or secondary education level, which
provides a possibility to prepare for the acquisition of a
professional education in the selected direction.
3. Borders of research: Interest-related
education
• For 2 – 25 years old children and youth.
• Sponsored by government, local municipalities and
parents.
• Realised by schools, afterschool education centers.
• Child have an opportunity to freely choose and
acquire several interest-related education
programmes.
4. Meta-theoretical Framework of
Research
• System theory in career development as
integrative person-in-context model in
career development (Patton, McMahon,
2006),
• Experiental learning theory (Kolb, 1984).
5. Theoretical background of research
• Understanding of non-formal education (Clarijs, 2008),
• Afterschool education and its historical development
(Skatkins, 1985; Šibajevs, 2002; Law of Education, 1999),
• Understanding about career development as lifelong
self-construction (Super, 1956, 1980; Havighurst, 1972),
• Understanding about development of generic
employability skills (CDELL, 2007; Johnson, Sawicki, Pearson,
Lindsay, McQuaid, Dutton, 2009; Lowden, Hall, Elliot, Lewin, 2011; CBI,
2011; Pegg, Waldock, Hendy-Isaac, Lawton, 2012).
6. Methodology
What society expect from
afterschool education system?
What society expect from
afterschool education system? Discourse analyze
How afterschool education
impact on skills and career
development?
How afterschool education
impact on skills and career
development?
What are the possible ways for
quality assurance of
development of afterschool
education system in Latvia in
nowadays situation?
What are the possible ways for
quality assurance of
development of afterschool
education system in Latvia in
nowadays situation?
Analyze of literature Questionnaire
Expert discussions
In-depth
interviews
7. Main discourses
1. Afterschool education system must be without any
changes, the main potential of it is to keep traditions for
national traditions of singing and dancing.
2. Afterschool education must be changed to use money
effectively to compensate disadvantages of formal
education like skills necessary for career.
3. Afterschool education system is necessary as way and
place to spend time safely between school lessons and
end of working day of parents.
8. Research base
• 308 randomly selected respondents:
– from different age groups from 16 to 67 years old (16-25: 22.3%,
26-35: 22.7%, 36-45g: 24.6%, 46-55:18.8%, 56 and older:
11.3%),
– with different education level ( basic 7.1%, secondary 8.7%,
professional 5.5%, higher 78%),
– with different study destination (country school 20.4%, small
town school 30.7%, Riga 30.7%, other city school 17.8%).
• All respondents during school time participated at least
in one afterschool educational program.
9. Development of generic
employability skills
Self-
direction
Team-
working
Underst
anding
about
business
Problem-
solving
Communica
tion,
reading,
writing
Calculat
ing
Use of IT Initiative
and
enterprisi
ng
More in
interest-
related
education
38,8 46,6 11 28,8 11,7 5,8 8,4 39,5
More in
school lessons
21 17,8 28,8 27,5 65 74,8 41,1 12,9
More in
school life
17,2 20,7 12,9 21,7 9,4 4,9 10,4 22
Impossible to
evaluate
22,7 14,6 46,9 21,7 13,6 14,2 39,8 25,2
13. Main findings
1. Afterschool education system helps to develop career
management skills and personal charasteristics important for
successful career like self-awareness, problem solving skills, time
management, motivation, team-work and give the opportunity to
experiment with different kinds of jobs to understand what is/is not
suitable for individual.
2. 97% of respondents agree that there must be state funded system
of afterschool education in Latvia as it works as compensative
mechanism of lacks of formal education system and gives the
opportunity to try different professions to understand what kind of
job person want and can to do.
14. Results from interviews
• All interviewed respondents participated in some
interest-related programms in the same time.
• They emphasize that all these programms worked as
complex system for them (different content, but
organizational forms and methods allowed to acheive the
result: comprehensively developed personality with extra
skills).
• Teacher as personality is important.
• All respondents remember interest-related programms
as something nice and want to participate again.
15. Problems of Interest-related
Education System
• It is not possible to ensure an equal offer in all
administrative territories.
• There are not clear public procurement for
content and methods of interest-reated
programmes.
• Definition of interest-related education in
education Law is too wide and unconcrete that
allows to interpret it in different ways.
16. Main recommendations
• Latvia must keep the afterschool education system,
but make changes in regulations about content of
interest-related programmes to achieve learning
outcomes that are oriented on development of career
management skills.
• The clear system of payment is necessary to ensure
equal opportunities for all children and to ask for
quality.
• Clear and concrete definition is neccessary for
interest-related education including aim of interest-
related education.
Editor's Notes
Although the current scheme of education of Latvia does not reveal interest-related education, it plays a significant role in LLL. Education Law (1998) Section 1 defines interest-related education as „realisation of the individual educational needs and desires of a person regardless of age and previously acquired education”.
The CoM specifies the procedures for financing of interest-related educational programmes (Section 14). Each local government has an obligation to ensure the opportunity to realise interest-related education (Section 17). District local governments shall establish, reorganise and dissolve interest-related educational institutions co-ordinating with MES. Unlike other educational institutions, those, which implement only interest-related educational programmes, shall not be accredited in accordance with the procedures prescribed by the CoM (Section 27).
According to Education Law (1998) Section 47 Article 1, interest-related education shall be voluntary, and education corresponding to a particular educational level shall not be required for commencement of such. Educational institutions established by the State or local governments are entitled to implement interest related educational programmes without a receipt of a licence (Section 47 Article 2). After the receipt of a relevant licence from the local government, other legal persons and natural persons shall also be entitled to implement interest-related educational programmes (Section 47 Article 3).
A teacher of interest-related education must have higher pedagogical education or must have completed professional development programme and received a corresponding certificate, or if a person has higher education and works as vocational education or vocationally oriented education teacher of professional subjects or as an interest-related education teacher (Noteikumi par prasībām pedagogiem nepieciešamajai izglītībai un profesionālajai kvalifikācijai, 2000). Any teacher must acquire professional development programmes the sope of which has to be at least 36 hours during a three-year period (Pedagogu profesionālās kvalifikācijas pilnveides kārtība, 2011).
Interest-related education has a significant role in the education system of Latvia in the LLL context. An opportunity to freely choose and acquire several interest-related education programmes ensures a possibility to develop one’s interests which for many pupils serves as a basis for choosing the future profession as well as helps understanding which sphere to choose. For example, just some pupils from theatre educational programmes later chose the profession of an actor/actress. However, most of them admit the usefullness of the acquired knowledge and skills, such as a skill to control their body and intonation for the chosen future profession.
Interest-related education in Latvia has stable traditions for 50 years.
The analyze of literature was made to understand what skills is necessary to develop for successful career. On base of findings of literature analyze the questionnaire was constructed and addressed to more than 300 respondents in Latvia.
To identify possible ways of quality assurance and development of after-school education system in Latvia the discourse analyze was made on what society expect from afterschool education system. On base of that was found that there are three main discourses.
As there was found three main discourses and only one of them show the new way to develop this system the second research question was
308 randomly selected respondents from different age groups (16 to 60 years old) participated in this survey. All respondents during school time participated at least in one afterschool educational program. IBM SPSS Statistics 22 was used to analyze data.
Tā kā netika atrastas statistiski nozīmīgas sakarības vai atšķirības starp respondentu sniegtajām atbildēm un respondentu vecumu, iegūto izglītību un izglītības ieguves vietu, tika pieņemts, ka interešu izglītība devusi līdzvērtīgu ieguldījumu personas attīstībā mūsdienu jauniešiem un arī cilvēkiem, kas skolu beiguši pagājušā gadsimtā. Tāpēc tālāk dati analizēti, nenošķirot vecumu.
Aptaujas rezultāti rāda (skat. 1. tabulu), ka interešu izglītībā, salīdzinot ar skolas mācību procesu un skolas sabiedrisko dzīvi, ievērojami vairāk tiek attīstītas tādas nodarbinātībai noderīgas prasmes kā pašvadība (vidēji par 18% vairāk), darbs komandā (vidēji par 27% vairāk) un iniciatīva un uzņēmējspēja (vidēji par 21% vairāk).
2. tabulas datu parāda, ka interešu izglītībā ievērojami vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē tiek attīstītas tādas nodarbinātībai nozīmīgas personības īpašības kā:
entuziasms (par 55% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 43% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē),
prasme sevi prezentēt (par 30% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 29% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē),
pašcieņa (par 25% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 20% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē),
spēja pārvarēt grūtības (par 12% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 26% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē),
motivācija (par 35% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 43% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē),
spēja pielāgoties (par 20% vairāk kā skolas mācību procesā un par 14% vairāk kā skolas sabiedriskajā dzīvē).
Due to the economic situation in the country it is not possible to ensure an equal offer in all administrative territories therefore in cities a more versatile offer of interest-related programmes is available. At the same time in small schools in rural areas there are fewer pupils in a class and teachers have more time and possibilities to pay attention to every pupil in a class.
As interest-related education is allocated definite financing every year, educational institutions that implement Professional orientation education programmes – music and art schools, sports schools – change their programmes and additionally to the finances allocated, claim financing from the state budget allocated to interest-related education. Thus the opportunity for everyone without special previous education to acquire interest-related education programmes envisaged by Education Law (1998) is not observed because in those educational insitutions as a result of severe competition talented children get enroled firsthand. In several administrative territories the state allocated financing is used for other purposes, for example, for financing of extracurricular classes in some definite school subject in general education schools.