Rating scales are assessment tools that evaluate performance, skills, qualities or outcomes using descriptive terms or numbers. They include (1) an interpersonal skills assessment using a scale of 1 to 5 to rate communication, contribution, and punctuality, (2) a practicum performance assessment rating attitude, punctuality, quality of work, and (3) a general discussion of characteristics, types, development and uses of rating scales including their advantages of being easy to administer and reducing bias but also potential disadvantages like ambiguity and subjectivity.
Exploring protein-protein interactions by Weak Affinity Chromatography (WAC) ...
Rating scale
1. Tools of Assessment
RATING SCALE
Assessment tools are a range of tools
and guidelines available to assist the
process of creating effective formal
assessment like observation,
discussion, questioning to asses where
learners are at in their progress along
learning continuum.
2. IInterpersonal skill assessment
Instructor : Date :
Student name: Student Id:
SKILLS POOR
1
WEAK
2
AVERAGE
3
GOOD
4
EXCELLENT
5
A.People skills
B.Communication
skills
C.Contribution to the
work done
D.Contribution to
meeting
E.Punctual to meetings
F.Total
3. Practicum performance assessment
PERFORMANCE AREA NEEDS
IMPROVEMENT
AVERAGE ABOVE
AVERAGE
REMARKS
A.Attitude
Punctuality
Respectful of
equipment
Conscientions
in work
B.Quality of
work done.
4. RATING SCALE
A rating scale is a tool used for assessing the
performance of tasks, skill levels, procedures,
processes, qualities, quantities or end products,
such as reports, drawings, computer programmes.
Similar to checklists but indicates the degree of
accomplishment rather than just ‘YES’ or ‘NO’.
Lists the performance statement in one column
and the range of accomplishment in descriptive
words, with or without numbers, in other columns.
5. These other columns form ‘the scale’ and indicate a
range of achievement – Poor to excellent, never to
always, strongly disagree to strongly agree.
CHARACTERISTICS OF RATING SCALE
Statements should be logical.
Clear wordings with numbers when a number scale
is used.
If performance statement is a behaviour or quality:
1 = poor 5 = excellent
The range of number should always increase or
always decrease
1 = poor 5 = excellent (in one section)
1 = Excellent 5 = poor (in the other section)
6. Specific, clearly distinguishable terms
Using ‘good’ then ‘excellent’ is better
than ‘good’ then ‘very good’.
Difficult to distinguish between ‘good’ and
‘very good’.
Indicate levels of success requires before
proceeding further, if applicable.
May include a column or space for providing
additional feedback.
Could be reviewed by other instructors.
7. TYPES OF RATING SCALE.
(1) NUMERICAL SCALE:
If the rating scale contains numbers, then it is
called numerical scale.
Numeric values can change the meaning of scale
description.
Schwarz et al., found that the responses of German
adults to the question of “How successful would
you say you have been in life?”
8. Scale range 0 (not at all successful) – 10
(extremely successful).
34% selected values between 0 & 5
When the scale went from -5 (not at all
successful) to +5 (extremely successful).
13% selected the values -5 to 0.
Indicates that use of the ‘right’ description for a
scale is not enough.
Results can be affected by the numeric values
attached to the descriptors.
9. (2) A GRAPHIC RATING:
Any rating scale consisting of points on a
continuum, is a generic label given to a broad
category of rating formats.
CHECKLIST FOR DEVELOPING A RATING SCALE.
Determine the scale to use (words or words with
number) to represent the levels of success.
Write a description for the meanings of each points
on the scale as needed.
List the categories of performance to be needed.
Clearly describe each skill.
Arrange the skill in logical order.
10. Write clear instructions for the observer.
Ask for the feedback from other instructors before
using it with students.
MERITS OF RATING SCALE
To evaluate skills product outcomes, activities,
interests, attitude etc..
Easy to administer and score.
Graphic rating scale is easier to make and less time
consuming.
Also used for quantitative methods.
May also be used for assessment of interest,
attitude and personal characteristics.
11. Adaptable and flexible research instrument.
Easy comparison.
Reduce rate of bias and subjectivity.
DISADVANTAGES OF RATING SCALE
Difficult to fix up rating about many aspects of an
individual.
Can be misused.
Sometimes it is unscientific and unreliable.
Lack of uniformity with which terms are
interpreted by evaluators.
Error can be occurred due to ambiguity, personality
of the rater (bias, logical error, attitude) etc.
12. RELEVANCE IN THE FIELD OF RESEARCH.
Clinical research:
In psychiatric medicine, for the assessment of
severity of a patient’s conditions
To assist with diagonostics and classification, and for
comparison of results.
Ergonomics research:
Employs either an analogue or a category type of
scale.
Statistical research:
Observations can be precisely noted when standard
instruments are unavailable.
13. CONCLUSION
Rating scale is an
important technique for evaluation. It
is the expression of opinion or
judgment regarding some situation,
object or character. Rating scale is an
improvement over checklist. There are
different types of rating scales.