3. • Modern Tech in Power electronic, generation &
distribution has resulted R&D in Marine propulsion
system
• IFEP – Cost effective sol which requires low maint,
provide longevity, flexibility and scalability
• Aim to study IFEP concept, its components,
challenges in implementing it onboard
INTRODUCTION
4. BACKGROUND/ HISTORY
History of Electric propulsion is more than 180 yrs old
• A small Russian ferry was built in 1839 which was
propelled by electric motor
• With the development of variable speed drives, SS
Queen Elizabeth II was converted to Ele Prop in 1980
• M/s Elation was introduced with Podded Propulsion in
1990
5. • Conventional Propulsion - Power is generated by a
engine, which mechanically powers the propeller
shaft through a series of reduction gears.
• Integrated Electric Prop - Propulsion & auxiliary
generators are replaced with only main generators as
the prime movers.
• Generators convert all the available power into
electrical power, which is then sent to a common
electrical bus for allocation.
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
6. Conventional Propulsion – Series of mechanically connected
components and reducing gears
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
7. Electrical Propulsion – Electric power system for both propulsion
and ship’s auxiliary & weapons services
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
8. How is it achieved?
• Generating larger capacity Electric power using prime
movers viz diesel/gas engines
• This integrated pool of Electric power is utilised to
meet various power requirements viz ship’s propulsion
(through an electric motor), power for weapons, radar
and auxiliary
• Requirement of Reduction GB & mechanical shaftlines
employed in conventional propulsion system is no
longer required
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
9. (1) Prime Mover (2) Switchboards (3) Convertors (4) Harmonic
Filters (5) Pulse Frequency modulators (6) Electric Propulsion
Motors (EPMs) (7) Propulsors (Pods or In-Hull)
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
10. Broadly classified into three categories
• Hybrid Electric Propulsion (viz CODLAG)
• All Electric Propulsion (AEP)
• Integrated Full Electric Propulsion (IFEP)
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION TYPES
11. Hybrid Electric Propulsion (CODLAG)
• CODLAG arrangement - each shaft driven by gas
turbine (for boost mode) and an electric motor (for
cruise mode)
• Electric drive operated on economical primemovers
viz DGs or low power (LP) GTGs
• High Speed Diesels or high power GTGs, is used to
get boost speeds with fuel economy at higher speed
operations.
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION TYPES
13. All Electric Propulsion (AEP)
• Propulsion Power generators produce power for the
propulsion segment
• Set of auxiliary generators produce power for the
ship’s auxiliaries and feed
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION TYPES
15. Integrated Full Electric Propulsion (IFEP)
• Complete integration of electrical power generated
onboard - both the propulsive & ship’s services power
are integrated and then utilised
• The power is distributed using power buses which are
electrically interconnected
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION TYPES
17. Why qo for IEP?
• Commonality of Equipment
• Reduced Moving Parts
• Redundancy of Gearboxes
• Location of Noise Sources
• Optimised Utilisation of Prime Movers
• Economy of Operations
ELECTRICAL PROPULSION SYSTEM
18. • Arrangement of generating three phase electricity by
GT/DG to power electric motors turning propellers
• Eliminates clutches/GB using electrical transmission
• Reduces the number of engines needed onboard
• Combination of GT & Diesel allows benefits across
full range of operational efficiency
INTEGRATED FULL ELECTRICAL
PROPULSION (IFEP) SYSTEM
21. • The basic components that comprise an effective IEP
system are:-
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
Ser Component Work Performed
(a) Prime Mover Gas Turbine/ Diesel Engine
(b) Alternator Generates Electricity
(c) Switchboard Distributes power for all users including propulsion
(d) Convertors Converts supply available to suit the propulsion
motors
(e) Propulsion Motors Drives the shaft and propeller
(f) Propeller Generates thrust as required (shaft is much smaller)
*Shaft is entirely missing in prodded propeller
designs
22. • The basic components an IEP system can be divided
as:-
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
23. Prime Mover To deliver mechanical energy which will
be converted into electrical energy
• Following Conventional Propulsion Models can be
used for generating power in Electric Propulsion plant
– Diesel
– Gas Turbine
– COGOG
– CODAG
– CODOG
– COGAG
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
28. Combined Gas And Gas Turbine (COGAG)
• A
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
29. Propulsion Options for IEP
• Following two methods of Electric Propulsion can be
used in a ship design:-
– Podded Propulsion
– In-Hull Propulsion
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
33. Propulsion Motors for IEP
• The propulsion motors required for a warship can be of two
type ie AC Motor or DC motor.
– DC Motor not being widely considered view lack of
available brush and slip-ring technology.
DC Homopolar Motors
– AC Motor two types of AC motors which are being
considered for warship propulsion:
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Machines (PMSM)
Advanced Induction Motor (AIM)
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
34. Propulsion Motors for IEP
Permanent Magnet Synchronous Machines (PMSM)
– Permanent magnets embedded in the steel rotor to
create a constant magnetic field.
– PMSM has good power density and quiet operation.
– Presently under development stage and cannot be
considered till technology matures itself and prove to
be successful.
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
35. Propulsion Motors for IEP
Advanced Induction Motor(PMSM)
– Simple and rugged construction
– Developed for applications where low speed and high
torque are required like ship drive
– High Power Density has been achieved thru optimizing
electromagnetic design of the rotor
– Signature Reduction optimal strategy to control flux to
minimize electromagnetic noise
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
36. Power Converters for Controlling Propulsion Motors
• Electric motors required power conversion to provide effective
speed control for the motor.
• Designed to accurately control the motor’s speed
• Various propulsion converters available for IEP are as follows:-
– Pulse Width Modulation (PWM)
– Cyclo-converter
– Synchroconverter
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
37. Power Converters for Controlling Propulsion Motors
Pulse Width Modulation (PWM)
• An Indirect Frequency converter
• Consist of a rectifier and inverter stage
• Has a DC link capacitor to provide constant control voltage
• Typically built using IGBTs (or GTOs)
• Provides phase voltages with high frequency, little harmonics
and smooth motor torque
COMPONENTS OF IFEP SYSTEM
39. • The technology is undergoing constant growth with
advancements in power electronics and major
advantages offered by the technology are as follows
– Flexibility of Layout
– Fuel Cost
– Load diversity
– Economical part load running
– Ease of Control
– Low Noise and Vibrations Characterstics
ADVANTAGES OF IFEP SYSTEM
40. • The major challenge for inducting Electrical
Propulsion Technology are as follows: -
– EMI/EMC Control
– Safety & Protection
– Trained Manpower
– High Initial Capital Costs
– Additional Components
CHALLENGES OF IFEP SYSTEM
41. USS ZUMWALT Class (DDG 1000) Destroyer
– Two Rolls-Royce MT30 gas turbines (35.4 MW each)
– In- Hull Shaft propellers with Advanced Induction Motors
EXAMPLE
42. UK Daring Class Type 45 Destroyer
– Two Rolls-Royce WR21 gas turbines (21.5 MW each)
– Two Wartsila12V200 DG (2 MW each)
– Two Shaft with GE Power Conversion AIM
EXAMPLE
43. • IFEP gaining strong foothold in Marine Propulsion
and its induction in IN is imminent. Certain issues
meriting attention towards adapting IFEP is as follows
– Training for handling of MV components inc FF &
inclusion of MV concepts/ theory in ab-initio course
– Augmentation of training facilities
– Restructuring of specialisation courses
– Setting up of infrastructure at Dockyards to repair
and maintain MV components
– Training and Recruitment of qualified personnel in
Yard
CONCLUSION
Advancement of modern technology in the field of power electronics, power generation and distribution has resulted in significant research and development in marine propulsion systems.
Today, the focus is on cost-effective solutions which require low maintenance, manpower and provide longevity, flexibility and scalability.
IFEP is one such technology that has been adopted worldwide with various degrees of success, and hence is being considered for induction into Indian Navy as well.
In today's conventional propulsion systems, power is generated by a diesel or gas turbine engine, which mechanically powers the propeller shaft through a series of reduction gears.
Ship's service generators convert mechanical energy into electrical power for combat systems and other loads.
In an integrated electric power system, the propulsion and auxiliary generators are replaced with only main generators as the prime movers.
These main generators convert all the available power into electrical power, which is then sent to a common electrical bus for allocation.
In conventional propulsion systems, power is generated by a diesel or gas turbine engine, which mechanically powers the propeller shaft through a series of reduction gears.
Ship's service generators convert mechanical energy into electrical power for combat systems and other loads
Through flexible distribution and switching architecture, the common electrical bus can supply electrical power to both non-propulsion and propulsion electrical loads.
For propulsion, electrical power from the bus is sent to a motor drive, where the voltage and frequency of the electrical energy are modified to operate the propulsion motor at a desired speed
propulsion motor then converts the electrical energy delivered by the motor into mechanical energy to rotate the propeller shaft.
The electric propulsion concept is primarily based on principle of employing either a partially or fully integrated Electric power system for both propulsion and ship’s auxiliary & weapons services.
A hybrid-electric propulsion system architecture comprises of a combination of electric drive with conventional/mechanical drives
Electric drive operates on economical primemovers such as DGs or low power (LP) GTGs to optimize overall energy efficiency and radiated noise levels (RNLs) and cost of operation of the propulsion plant during slow and quiet operations
whereas the conventional drive operates on high speed diesels (HSDs) or high power (HP) GTGs to get boost speeds with fuel economy at higher speed operations.
In an All Electric-Propulsion system or AEP architecture, a set of generators (called as Propulsion Power generators) produce power for the propulsion and transmits power to the components of propulsion segment,
while another set of ship’s auxiliary services generators produce power for the ship’s auxiliaries and transmit power to ship services including electrical weapon systems.
IFEP architecture is the latest technology based on complete integration of electrical power generated onboard i.e., both the propulsive power and ship’s services and electrical weapon system power are integrated and then utilised.
power quality (frequency and voltage) are maintained within tolerances that permit the bulk of the ship services loads (including weapons) to be served directly or through step-down transformers.
Total power required for propulsion and other general ship support functions can be provided by one common set of generators.
flexible cables as transmission media for electrical energy . Hence no GB/ Rotating/reciprocating parts
no longer any necessity to use mechanical gear boxes, which are a considerable source of noise
Prime movers in these platforms can be practically located well above the waterline, thereby significantly reduced radiated noise
Excess power generated by a source can be utilised by other auxi systems, thus eliminating the need for secondary generators.
Helps reduce the life-cycle cost by lowering expenses on fuel and also maintenance costs on associated equipment
(IFEP) is an arrangement of marine propulsion systems such that gas turbines or diesel generators or both generate three phase electricity which is then used to power electric motors turning either propellers or water-jets.
Eliminates the need for clutches and reduces or eliminates the need for gearboxes by using electrical transmission rather than mechanical transmission of energy.
Since all the engines produce electricity, It reduces the number of engines needed onboard as compared to traditional arrangements in which one pool of engines provides electricity and another pool of engines provides propulsion.
integrated electric propulsion arrangement would include diesel engines as well as gas turbines as prime-movers for the electric generators. As gas turbines are efficient only at or near their maximum power and Diesel generators have the advantage of high efficiency over a wide range of power levels, combination allows utilisation across full range of operational efficieny with reduction in weight/volume and a low-vibration quiet mode of operation
The function of the prime mover is to deliver mechanical energy which will be converted into electrical energy.
Diesel engines have good fuel economy over a wide speed range whereas Gas turbine are efficient at higher speed.
Diesel engines have good fuel economy over a wide speed range whereas Gas turbine are efficient at higher speed.
There can be two methods of electric propulsion possible for use in a ship design.
The first method uses direct-drive podded propulsors mostly found in commercial shipping and in cruise liners.
The second method uses a prime mover and shaft configuration, similar to the mechanical drives found in current surface ships known as in-hull propulsion
This propulsion type is a combination of steering and propeller system. The pod propulsion unit is fitted in the place of the conventional propeller, and it comprises of an electric motor mounted inside the pod, and the propeller is directly connected to the motor shaft. The pod propeller assembly can rotate 360 degrees at its place making it easier for ships to have an ahead and astern control without needing for reversing the prime mover (here motor) or using a controllable pitch propeller. This capability eliminates the need for a rudder.
Although, it cannot be considered for immediate use in IN, view limited technology development in this field for warships however, this method has great potential to be used in future ship designs
This propulsion type is a combination of steering and propeller system. The pod propulsion unit is fitted in the place of the conventional propeller, and it comprises of an electric motor mounted inside the pod, and the propeller is directly connected to the motor shaft. The pod propeller assembly can rotate 360 degrees at its place making it easier for ships to have an ahead and astern control without needing for reversing the prime mover (here motor) or using a controllable pitch propeller. This capability eliminates the need for a rudder.
Although, it cannot be considered for immediate use in IN, view limited technology development in this field for warships however, this method has great potential to be used in future ship designs
In this configuration, the prime mover is located inside the hull of the ship. Rotational torque is transferred to the propeller by using a shaft that extends aft from the motor and penetrates the hull of the ship.
The propeller is connected to the end of the shaft and converts rotational torque into forward and reverse thrust.
This method of propulsion requires additional equipment such as shaft bearings at bulkhead penetrations, shaft seals at hull penetrations, and a rudder to provide steering control for the vessel.
Although this method still requires the use of a shaft, significant reductions in shaft length are possible due to increased flexibility in locating the prime mover within the ship.
This method is presently used in IN submarines and warships of many advanced Navies across the globe
The propulsion motors required for a warship can be of two type i.e AC Motor or DC motor.
There are various types of AC and DC motors that are available in propulsion industry.
The propulsion motors required for a warship can be of two type i.e AC Motor or DC motor.
There are various types of AC and DC motors that are available in propulsion industry.
Technological advances in power electronics devices are a major factor in power converter technology
CYCLO-CONVERTER - Direct frequency changers are known as cyclo-converters. They convert an AC supply of utility frequency to a variable frequency. Not appropriate due to large size onboard, low power factor, complex design
SYNCHRO CON - indirect frequency converters that consist of a rectification (AC-DC) and an inversion (DC-AC) stage. A large DC link inductor separates the rectifier and inverter stage. Poor input quality, harmonics output wavefront.
Technological advances in power electronics devices are a major factor in power converter technology
GTO - Gate Turn Off thyristors semiconductor
IGBT – Insulated Gate BiPolar Transistor
A PWM converter is most suitable convertor for controlling the speed. By controlling the switching signals of the PWM converter, will control the propulsion motor torque and flux and will achieve required shaft speed. The PWM converters has higher, more constant power factor for better efficiency. Also, constant harmonic frequencies to ease any supply filtering required and smaller size and weight
The technology is undergoing constant growth with advancements in power electronics and major advantages offered by the technology are as follows
Flexibility: advantage is that in eletrical transmission, prime mover and generator is constrained by any particulat relation with the load.
DA can be ocated at the main deck. 30% reducing in space.
Diversity – Power can be fed from less reuired service to more required service without operating another primemover.
The technology is undergoing constant growth with advancements in power electronics and major advantages offered by the technology are as follows
In order to harness this technology and accrue maximum benefit from the same, technical support, training and administrative issues are required to be planned and executed in a time bound manner.