Most brilliant indian defensive decision of 1965 war

1. THE MOST BRILLIANT
INDIAN DEFENSIVE
DECISION OF 1965 WAR0
From Pakistan Army till

2. 1965 by Major Agha H
Amin (Retired)
#pakistanarmy #pakistan PAKISTAN ARMY TILL
1965
http://www.lulu.com/shop/agha-humayun-
amin/pakistan-army-till-1965/paperback/product-
22207306.html

5. Thus 7th September was lost with just ten tanks across the Rohi Nala. All
this was happening at a time when the situation in 4 Mountain Division as
per Harbaksh Singh was so serious that 'out of six battalions two and half
had left the line and the remaining three and half were under severe
enemy pressure".

6. Harbaksh states that it was under these circumstances that GOC 4
Mountain Division sought permission from GOC 11 Corps to withdraw
and take a position at Assal Uttar in the rear.48
Harbaksh states that early in the morning of 8th September he
received a handwritten letter from GOC 11 Corps recommending that
four infantry units i.e 18 Rajputana, 7 Grenadier, 9 J & K, AND 13 Dogra
be disbanded and that another infantry division should replace
4 Mountain Division.49

7. At this stage Harbaksh had no reserves and exhorted GOC 4 Mountain
Division and GOC 11 Corps to be more resolute.
While all this was happening Brig Bashir commander 5 Armoured Brigade
was throwing to winds Pakistan's Armour superiority by dividing his
brigade into two directions with 24 Cavalry to advance along axis Khem
Karan-Bhikiwind and 6 Lancers towards Valtoha Railway Station.

8. Naik Abdul Hameed , played a crucial role in repelling Pakistani tank attack on 2 Mountain Division and was
awarded Indias highest military award Param Vir Chakra
24 Cavalry contacted defences of 4 Mountain Division and tried to
develop the situation from the west but failed because of lack of infantry
support and timely arrival of 3rd Cavalry (Centurions) which reached the
4 Mountain Division area after mid-day.

10. 6 Lancers reached Valtoha Railway Station but was recalled after last
light back to Khem Karan by Brigadier Bashir to leaguer in line with the
old British practice which in this scenario was not required.50

11. By 9th September when the Pakistani armour once again commenced
advance the Indian armour was well poistioned with 3rd Cavalry
Centurions plugging flanks which could have enabled 5 Armoured
Brigade to get into rear of 4 Mountain Divisioon 8th September.

12. The critical time span was over. The ancient Greeks used to say that the
Goddess of Victory favours those who are bold. Boldness was sadly
missing in 5 Armoured Brigade less Sahibzad Gul the only tank
commander who wanted to lead and fight from the front.

13. oured Brigade recommenced advance from its leaguers near Khem
Karan, 6 Lancers was greeted by Centurion fire of 3rd Cavalry while 24
Cavalry also made nominal progress.

14. Indian Centurions of
3rd Cavalry in defensive
position
To compound things further Sahibzad Gul the only man in the whole
senior lot was killed on 9th September near Valtoha.

15. This indomitable man was only given an SJ since he was not from the
more pampered regiments of the then Pakistan Army!

18. By 10th September the Indians were well poised to meet any outflanking
attack.

19. They had taken a horse shoe position with about three tank regiments,
one in 4 Mountain Division defences, another less one squadron in
Valtoha area and the third and the most formidable in technical terms i.e
the 3rd Cavalry covering the western deep flank of the 4 Mountain
Division.

20. Naseer now launched 4 Cavalry into this valley of death. The result was
catastrophic. 4 Cavalry got bogged down and was forced to surrender.
The Indians claimed that they captured all tanks of the unit, the
Commanding Officer and 12 officers including six majors and several
other ranks.51

21. Shaukat Riza states that "some tank crew of 4 Cavalry trickled into HQ 4
Armoured Brigade.They reported that the regiment had been taken
prisoner...at the end of the day 4 Cavalry reported 4 Officers and 25
Other Ranks missing and a total of ten killed. Almost all the tanks had
been lost".52 The layman reader should not get shocked.In tank warfare
such things happen. In WW two an illustrious British tank unit 8th Hussars
along with 4 Armoured Brigade was captured by the Germans.53

22. Captured tanks of Pakistans
4 Cavalry
The fault in 4 Cavalry fiasco was not of the unit but its CO and GOC 1st
Armoured Division.

23. Indian armour historian admits that 4 Cavalry fought well but ran out of
fuel because of poor planning and was caught in a well laid ambush.
Thus ended an offensive which had the potential to knock the Indian
Army out of the war. The 3rd Armoured Brigade was never employed and
from 11th September the 1st Armoured Division less 5 Armoured Brigade
and 4 Cavalry which was totally written off was despatched to Chawinda.
The Indians launched some very fool hardy frontal attacks on 11 Division
from 11th September till 22nd September. All were repulsed since
surprise had been lost and defence keeping in view terrain and relative
strength was the superior form of war.
--
Man would indeed be in a poor way if he had to be restrained by fear of punishment and hope of reward
after death." --
Albert Einstein !!!

24. From Pakistan Army till 1965 by Major Agha H Amin (Retired)