Strategies for Effective Global Business Management Decisions
1. 7/27/2015
1
International Strategy and
Organization
DY Chhunsong
Lecture 7
1
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
2
Planning
Process of identifying and selecting an organization’s objectives
and deciding how the organization will achieve those objectives.
2. 7/27/2015
2
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
3
Strategy
Set of planned actions taken by managers to help a company meet
its objectives.
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
4
1. Strategy Formulation
The Strategy Formulation Process consists of 3 stages: 1) Identify
Company Missions and Goals, 2) Identify Core Competency
and Value Creating Activity, and 3) Formulate Strategies.
3. 7/27/2015
3
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
5
1. Company Missions and Goals
Most companies have a general purpose for they exist that they
express in their mission statements.
Mission Statement is a written statement of why a company exists
and what it plans to accomplish.
The statements may spell out how a company’s operations affect its
stakeholders: suppliers, employees, stockholders, and consumers….
Sample: As a global eye care company, we will help consumers see,
look and feel better through innovative technology and design.
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
6
2. Formulate Strategies:
Multinational Strategy
Adapting products and their marketing strategies in each national
market to suit local preferences.
It refers to a separate strategy for each of the multiple nations in
which a company markets its products.
Companies establish largely independent subsidiaries in each
national market.
Each subsidiary undertakes its own product research and
development, production and marketing.
4. 7/27/2015
4
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
7
2. Formulate Strategies:
Multinational Strategy (1)
It is appropriate for companies in industries in which buyers’
preferences do not converge across national borders.
The benefit: it allows a company to learn and respond quickly and
effectively as buyers’ preference emerge.
The disadvantage: it does not allow a company to exploit scale
economies in product development, manufacturing, or marketing.
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
8
2. Formulate Strategies: Global Strategy
Offering the same products using the same marketing strategy in all
national markets.
The benefit of the strategy: scale and location economies by
producing inventories of products in a few optimal locations and
cost saving due to product and marketing standardization.
The disadvantage of the strategy: companies may overlook important
differences in buyers’ preferences from 1 market to another.
5. 7/27/2015
5
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
9
Either Multinational or Global Strategy a company undertakes, the
company needs to formulate strategies for the corporation, each
business unit, and each department.
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Issues in Assignment of
Decision Rights
10
• Centralization vs. Decentralization
Decision rights on CEO or on local managers?
• Horizontal placement of decentralized decision rights
CEO
A Branch
Manager
B Branch
Manager
One manager or all managers?
• Coordination vs. Efficient use of information/incentives
6. 7/27/2015
6
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
11
Why do you need to give decision rights
to local managers?
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Benefits of DC: Effective
Use of Local Knowledge
12
Local demand, price sensitivity of consumers, local used product
market condition.. etc..
• Local knowledge
• If you can use local knowledge effectively, you can
Quickly respond to changing market conditions
Make rapid decision
• Decentralization
Need not to transfer relevant knowledge to the headquarter
• Centralization
Permission required to change prices
Local information is transferred to the HQ or ignored (time
consuming and slower decision)
7. 7/27/2015
7
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Benefits of DC: Conversation of
Management Time
13
Operational decision
• Types of managerial decision
Strategic decision (investment in a new product line, R&D
investment decision etc.)
• Delegating operational decision and focusing on strategic
decision
GM’s M-form (HQ has decision rights on strategic incentives and
control)
Top management uses their home on strategic decisions
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Benefits of DC: Training
and Motivating Local Managers
14
More authority is preferred by job applicants
• Attracting and retaining talented/ambitious managers
Local managers tend to stay with jobs with more authority
• Training opportunities
Have to deal with unexpected situations
Accumulate experience in decision making and creative initiatives
• Strong commitment on their projects
Have stronger incentives to exert in fighting, evaluating, and
implementing new projects
8. 7/27/2015
8
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Costs of DC: Agency Problem
15
• What if local managers do not choose to maximize profit?
Local managers may offer very low prices to their friends and
families
Due to the measurement issue, evaluation and compensation have
limitation
Are those preferred customers important for the firm or only
for the managers?
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Costs of DC: Agency Problem (1)
16
• Agency problem
The objectives of a principal and an agent are not aligned
An agent’s behavior is hard to observe
• Costs of direct monitoring
Setting up such monitoring system is costly
9. 7/27/2015
9
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Costs of DC: Pricing Externalities
17
• Externalities
When the decision made by one individual has an effect on other
individuals
And this effect is not taken into account by the decision maker
Divisions often make pricing decisions to maximize their own
profits
• Pricing externalities
But they do not take into account the impact on other division’s
sales and profits
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Costs of DC: Coordination Failure
18
• Independent pricing cannot internalize externality
If Phnom Penh and Battambang are independent markets
When the manager of PP sets up the price, he does not consider its
effect on Battambang market under decentralization
It depends on whether both markets are complement or substitute
Consumers in Phnom Penh may buy from Battambang branch
10. 7/27/2015
10
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Costs of DC: Narrow-Minded
Use of Information
19
• Will a local manager care about the following information?
Manufacturing costs
New product development plans around the world
Demand change in other remote region
• Central managers may have more comprehensive informa-
tion on local divisions
Information across multiple regions through a long period
Fundamentals of Global Business Management
Implications for Organizations
20
• It is necessary for organizations to be decentralized and delegate the
decision-making authority to divisions when:
The corporate level lacks the expertise to make all decisions
Divisions need to act quickly on “local” information
• Problems naturally arise when there are interdependencies among
divisions
Externalities can destroy value in the organization
• The CEO needs to simultaneously keep its “hand off,” letting the
managers do what they do best, and its “hand on,” managing the
interdependencies wisely
The lack of interdivisional coordination can destroy value
Promote information flows
Coordination among decisions