Download as PDF, PPTX
![Mostly a smooth ride
No major problems so far
• CVMFS CSI just works
Driver Pod restarts can be annoying
• The user pods using CVMFS on that node will hang
• Makes CVMFS maintenance non-trivial
Current CSI Driver leaving Zombie processes behind
• Not critical, but still annoying
# ps -ef |awk '{print $1 " " $8 " " $9}’ |
sort |uniq -c
73 cvmfs [cvmfs2] <defunct>
75 cvmfs [sh] <defunct>
1 root awk {print
1 root /bin/bash
1 root /csi-cvmfsplugin --nodeid=…
1 root ps -ef
195 root [sh] <defunct>
1 root sort
1 root uniq -c
1 UID CMD
CernVM Workshop 2019 19](https://image.slidesharecdn.com/cvmfs19prpk8scsi-190604090602/85/Using-CVMFS-on-a-distributed-Kubernetes-cluster-The-PRP-Experience-19-320.jpg)
Uploaded byIgor Sfiligoi
Using CVMFS on a distributed Kubernetes cluster - The PRP Experience
The document discusses using CVMFS on a distributed Kubernetes cluster for the Pacific Research Platform (PRP). It summarizes that PRP uses Kubernetes as a resource manager, CVMFS is needed for OSG users but cannot be mounted in unprivileged containers, so a Kubernetes CSI driver was used to mount CVMFS. The CERN-provided version was fixed and no major operational issues have been found. CVMFS is configured to use Squid caches for small files and OSG StashCache nodes for large files across the distributed PRP setup.
More Related Content
![[表示が崩れる場合ダウンロードしてご覧ください] 2018年のDocker・Moby](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/docker-and-moby-in-2018-180419034237-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[20200720]cloud native develoment - Nelson Lin](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/20200720cloudnativedeveloment-200824031228-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
![[OpenInfra Days Korea 2018] Day 2 - E5-1: "Invited Talk: Kubicorn - Building ...](https://cdn.slidesharecdn.com/ss_thumbnails/e60955buildingsimplekubernetes-180705043459-thumbnail.jpg?width=640&height=640&fit=bounds)
Similar to Using CVMFS on a distributed Kubernetes cluster - The PRP Experience
Using CVMFS on a distributed Kubernetes cluster - The PRP Experience
- 1. Using CVMFS ona distributed Kubernetes cluster The PRP experience Presented by Igor Sfiligoi – UCSD CernVM Workshop 2019 CernVM Workshop 2019 1
- 2. Outline • What isPRP? • How does Kubernetes fit in? • Why do we need CVMFS? • What was done? • Operational experience • Wishlist • Integration with OSG StashCache CernVM Workshop 2019 2
- 3. The Pacific ResearchPlatform The PRP originally created as a regional networking project • Establishing end-to-end links between 10Gbps and 100Gbps (GDC) http://pacificresearchplatform.org CernVM Workshop 2019 3
- 4. Toward the NationalResearch Platform PRP PRPv2 Nautilus Transoceanic Nodes Guam Asian Pacific RP Transoceanic Nodes Australia Korea Singapore Netherlands 10G 35TB UvA FIONA6 10G 35TB KISTI 10G 35TB U of Guam 10G 35TB U of Queensland PRP morphing into TNRP • We expanded nationally • And beyond, too CENIC/PW Link 40G FIONA UIUC 40G 160TB U Hawaii 40G 160TB NCAR-WY 40G 192TB UWashington 40G FIONA I2 Chicago 40G FIONA I2 NYC 40G FIONA I2 Kansas City 40G FIONA1 UIC CernVM Workshop 2019 4
- 5. Recently we evolvedinto a major resource provider, too • Because scientists really need more than bandwidth tests • They need to share their data at high speed and compute on it, too Extensive compute power • About 330 GPUs and 3.5k CPU cores A large distributed storage area • About 2 PBytes Getting into the Compute Business CernVM Workshop 2019 5
- 6. Kubernetes as aResource Manager • Industry standard • Large and active development and support community PRP decided to use Kubernetes as the Resource Manager • Great for network heavy workloads • Very convenient for users Containers provide major benefits • Great for mixing service and user PodsKubernetes has flexible scheduler • Both for networking • and storage Great plugin infrastructure Docker based CernVM Workshop 2019 6
- 7. Serving OSG users Earlier thisyear we wanted to add support for OSG users And OSG has long been an active user of CVMFS CernVM Workshop 2019 7
- 8. CVMFS and UnprivilegedContainers OSG Pods run only unprivileged containers • Like all other users in the k8s cluster • To minimize risk CVMFS cannot be mounted from inside an unprivileged container • Using FUSE is a privileged operation • Unless (maybe) using properly configured latest kernel, which we cannot assume Installing CVMFS bare-metal not an option • We want to have only k8s at bare-metal level Docker based CernVM Workshop 2019 8
- 9. Kubernetes CSI tothe Rescue Kubernetes Container Storage Interface (CSI) • Provides a standard way to add custom filesystems Driver deployed by cluster admin • Privileged operation • But admin controls and can inspect the container images User Pods see it as an additional mount option • No privileges needed https://kubernetes.io/blog/2019/01/15/container-storage-interface-ga/ CernVM Workshop 2019 9
- 10. API Version Blues • TheCVMFS team developed a Kubernetes CSI driver https://github.com/cernops/cvmfs-csi • But they developed against the beta version • Which has since been deprecated! https://kubernetes-csi.github.io/docs/introduction.html CernVM Workshop 2019 10
- 11. UCSD Team Doesthe Refactoring The changes in the API were not huge • But big enough to make the CERN-provided version unusable out-of-the-box Dima Mishin from our UCSD team fixed it • Now fully 1.0 compliant • Also did minor polishing so it can co-exist with other CSI plugins Have been running it since February 2019 on our cluster Contributed back as a Pull Request • Still not merged, though https://github.com/cernops/cvmfs-csi/pull/1 CernVM Workshop 2019 11
- 12. CERN vs OSGSetup CERN provided version was optimized for CERN use • Assuming only CERN-based repositories would ever be used • Would not allow for mounting of OSG repositories The restriction is not really necessary • Removed it from the code • Contributed back as a PR (also still pending) Also switched to OSG packaged CVMFS • Gives me all the needed config out-of-the-box https://github.com/cernops/cvmfs-csi/pull/2 https://github.com/sfiligoi/cvmfs-csi/blob/prp-osg/deploy/docker/Dockerfile https://cloud.docker.com/u/sfiligoi/repository/docker/sfiligoi/csi-cvmfsplugin CernVM Workshop 2019 12
- 13. A little more details,now CernVM Workshop 2019 13
- 14. Deploying CVMFS CVMFS DriverPods deployed as a DaemonSet • One (privileged) Pod starts on each node • Plus a couple Service Pods https://github.com/sfiligoi/prp-osg-cvmfs/tree/master/k8s/cvmfs/csi-processes CVMFS config needs a Squid • We deploy one as a Kubernetes Service • Using the OSG maintained Frontier Squid Image https://github.com/sfiligoi/prp-osg-cvmfs/tree/master/k8s/frontier $ kubectl get pods -n cvmfs NAME READY STATUS csi-cvmfsplugin-2mlqw 2/2 Running csi-cvmfsplugin-2zx76 2/2 Running … csi-cvmfsplugin-8qfdf 2/2 Running csi-cvmfsplugin-provisioner-0 1/1 Running frontier-squid-77bb5546bd-swwdh 1/1 Running $ kubectl get services -n cvmfs NAME TYPE CLUSTER-IP PORT(S) csi-cvmfsplugin-attacher ClusterIP 10.100.161.182 12345/TCP csi-cvmfsplugin-provisioner ClusterIP 10.103.119.130 12345/TCP frontier-squid ClusterIP 10.97.246.52 3128/TCP CernVM Workshop 2019 14
- 15. Defining Mountpoints AutoFS notan option • Seems a limit of the Linux kernel • We have to explicitly list all the supported mountpoints Using one StorageClass x mountpoint • The desired mountpoint is specified as a parameter $ cat storageclass-oasis.yaml apiVersion: storage.k8s.io/v1 kind: StorageClass metadata: name: csi-cvmfs-oasis provisioner: csi-cvmfsplugin parameters: repository: oasis.opensciencegrid.org $ cat storageclass-stash.yaml apiVersion: storage.k8s.io/v1 kind: StorageClass metadata: name: csi-cvmfs-stash provisioner: csi-cvmfsplugin parameters: repository: stash.osgstorage.org https://github.com/sfiligoi/prp-osg-cvmfs/tree/master/k8s/cvmfs/storageclasses CernVM Workshop 2019 15
- 16. Using CVMFS PersistentVolumeClaims cannow be used by the users • Note: Need to be defined in each and all namespaces that use them https://github.com/sfiligoi/prp-osg-cvmfs/tree/master/k8s/cvmfs/pvcs No privileges needed by users to use them in Pods • Just regular “external volumes” • One per CVMFS mountpoint $ cat pvc-oasis.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: PersistentVolumeClaim metadata: name: csi-cvmfs-pvc-oasis namspace: osggpus spec: accessModes: - ReadOnlyMany resources: requests: storage: 1Gi storageClassName: csi-cvmfs-oasis CernVM Workshop 2019 16
- 17. Using CVMFS PersistentVolumeClaims cannow be used by the users • Note: Need to be defined in each and all namespaces that use them https://github.com/sfiligoi/prp-osg-cvmfs/tree/master/k8s/cvmfs/pvcs No privileges needed by users to use them in Pods • Just regular “external volumes” • One per CVMFS mountpoint $ cat pvc-oasis.yaml apiVersion: v1 kind: PersistentVolumeClaim metadata: name: csi-cvmfs-pvc-oasis namspace: osggpus spec: accessModes: - ReadOnlyMany resources: requests: storage: 1Gi storageClassName: csi-cvmfs-oasis kind: Deployment metadata: name: osg-wn-gpu namespace: osggpus spec: template: spec: containers: - name: osg-wn-gpu … volumeMounts: - name: cvmfs-connect mountPath: /cvmfs/connect.opensciencegrid.org readOnly: true - name: cvmfs-stash mountPath: /cvmfs/stash.osgstorage.org readOnly: true volumes: - name: cvmfs-oasis persistentVolumeClaim: claimName: csi-cvmfs-pvc-oasis readOnly: true - name: cvmfs-stash persistentVolumeClaim: claimName: csi-cvmfs-pvc-stash readOnly: true CernVM Workshop 2019 17
- 18.
- 19. Mostly a smoothride No major problems so far • CVMFS CSI just works Driver Pod restarts can be annoying • The user pods using CVMFS on that node will hang • Makes CVMFS maintenance non-trivial Current CSI Driver leaving Zombie processes behind • Not critical, but still annoying # ps -ef |awk '{print $1 " " $8 " " $9}’ | sort |uniq -c 73 cvmfs [cvmfs2] <defunct> 75 cvmfs [sh] <defunct> 1 root awk {print 1 root /bin/bash 1 root /csi-cvmfsplugin --nodeid=… 1 root ps -ef 195 root [sh] <defunct> 1 root sort 1 root uniq -c 1 UID CMD CernVM Workshop 2019 19
- 20. Outstanding problems Cannot mountthe came CVMFS mountpoint from two namespaces • CVMFS CSI Driver fails on an internal check • Recently discovered, did not have time to properly investigate or fix it CernVM Workshop 2019 20
- 21. Wishlist • Would ratheruse a CERN-maintained version • Please let us know if there is anything else we can do to help there Can we get our PRs accepted? • If at all possible • Any other ideas to avoid explicit listing of all possible repositories? AutoFS capabilities CernVM Workshop 2019 21
- 22.
- 23. PRP/TNRP a Distributed Setup CENIC/PW Link 40GFIONA UIUC 40G 160TB U Hawaii 40G 160TB NCAR-WY 40G 192TB UWashington 40G FIONA I2 Chicago 40G FIONA I2 NYC 40G FIONA I2 Kansas City 40G FIONA1 UIC PRP PRPv2 Nautilus Transoceanic Nodes Guam Asian Pacific RP Transoceanic Nodes Australia Korea Singapore Netherlands 10G 35TB UvA FIONA6 10G 35TB KISTI 10G 35TB U of Guam 10G 35TB U of Queensland (GDC) CernVM Workshop 2019 23
- 24. Single Squid makes nosense CENIC/PW Link 40G FIONA UIUC 40G 160TB U Hawaii 40G 160TB NCAR-WY 40G 192TB UWashington 40G FIONA I2 Chicago 40G FIONA I2 NYC 40G FIONA I2 Kansas City 40G FIONA1 UIC PRP PRPv2 Nautilus Transoceanic Nodes Guam Asian Pacific RP Transoceanic Nodes Australia Korea Singapore Netherlands 10G 35TB UvA FIONA6 10G 35TB KISTI 10G 35TB U of Guam 10G 35TB U of Queensland (GDC) CernVM Workshop 2019 24
- 25. OSG Operates a setof StashCache nodes CENIC/PW Link 40G FIONA UIUC 40G 160TB U Hawaii 40G 160TB NCAR-WY 40G 192TB UWashington 40G FIONA I2 Chicago 40G FIONA I2 NYC 40G FIONA I2 Kansas City 40G FIONA1 UIC PRP PRPv2 Nautilus Transoceanic Nodes Guam Asian Pacific RP Transoceanic Nodes Australia Korea Singapore Netherlands 10G 35TB UvA FIONA6 10G 35TB KISTI 10G 35TB U of Guam 10G 35TB U of Queensland (GDC) Using the same PRP Kubernetes cluster CernVM Workshop 2019 25
- 26. OSG Operates a setof StashCache nodes CENIC/PW Link 40G FIONA UIUC 40G 160TB U Hawaii 40G 160TB NCAR-WY 40G 192TB UWashington 40G FIONA I2 Chicago 40G FIONA I2 NYC 40G FIONA I2 Kansas City 40G FIONA1 UIC PRP PRPv2 Nautilus Transoceanic Nodes Guam Asian Pacific RP Transoceanic Nodes Australia Korea Singapore Netherlands 10G 35TB UvA FIONA6 10G 35TB KISTI 10G 35TB U of Guam 10G 35TB U of Queensland (GDC) Essentially XRootD servers CVMFS configured to use GeoIP to pick the closest one when serving large files CernVM Workshop 2019 26
- 27. Summary PRP is usingKubernetes as a resource manager OSG users need CVMFS CVMFS cannot be mounted from unprivileged containers Using Kubernetes CSI to mount CVMFS in PRP Had to fix CERN-provided version No major operational issues found Using Squid for small files and OSG StashCache for large files CernVM Workshop 2019 27
- 28. Acknowledgents This work waspartially funded by US National Science Foundation (NSF) awards CNS-1456638, CNS-1730158, ACI-1540112, ACI-1541349, OAC-1826967, OAC 1450871, OAC-1659169 and OAC-1841530. CernVM Workshop 2019 28