Slide workshop penulisan jurnal di acara MRS-ID (The Materials Research Society of Indonesia) meetings 2014, Denpasar, Bali.

1. TIPS & TRICK
MENEMBUS
JURNAL INTERNASIONAL
BER-IMPACT FACTOR TINGGI
Dr. Satria Zulkarnaen Bisri
Zernike Institute for Advanced Materials
University of Groningen
*Editorial Board MRS-ID Bulletin

2. Tentang saya
• Editorial Board
• Buletin MRS-ID
• Majalah 1000 Guru
• Reviewer for
• Science (AAAS)
• Advanced Materials (Wiley)
• Advanced Energy Materials
• ACS Nano
• Nanoscale (RSC)
• J. Materials Chemistry (RSC)
• Applied Physics Letters (AIP)
• Nanophotonics (SPIE)
• Funding Agency Belgia (FWO)
• Etc.

3. Outline
• Impact Factor
• Filosofi Menulis
• Menulis paper =
bercerita + memberitakan + menjual
• Tips & Tricks: Plotting Data
• Tips & Tricks: Ilustrasi
• Tips & Tricks: Introduction
• Tips & Tricks: Cover Letter
• Etika Publikasi

4. Apa itu Impact Factor?
42.351 31.477 36.425 33.265 15.409 14.385 12.940
푰풎풑풂풄풕 푭풂풄풕풐풓 (ퟐퟎퟏퟑ) =
Terhadap artikel terbitan 2011-2012
푻풐풕풂풍 푺풊풕풂풔풊 ퟐퟎퟏퟑ
푨풓풕풊풌풆풍 푻풆풓풃풊풕 ퟐퟎퟏퟐ + 푨풓풕풊풌풆풍 푻풆풓풃풊풕 (ퟐퟎퟏퟏ)
Terbit 2012
Jumlah sitasi = 81

5. Material Science
1.380 3.530 71040
Jumlah artikel terbit 2013

6. Material Science
di Indonesia
Web of Science – Field: materials science
Address: Indonesia
Dari institusi beralamat di Indonesia

7. Mengapa harus publikasi?
• “Fame”
• Rekan sebidang
• Komunitasnya
• “Fortune”
• Promosi
• Dana Penelitian
• Kelulusan
• Tanggungjawab
• Masyarakat umum
• APBN & penyandang dana
“If your research does not
generate papers, it might just
as well not have been done”
George Whitesides
“Papers provide the shoulders
that others can stand on”
Bentuk komunikasi

8. Presentasi di Conference vs Paper di Jurnal
• “Menyerang”
• Menyampaikan ide
• Iklan
• Komunitas terbatas
• Sebatas ingatan
• “Bertahan”
• Mempertahankan ide
• Produk & manualnya
• Siapapun
• Abadi

9. Editorial Process
Reviewer
Submission
Editorial
Board
Editorial
Board
Reviewer
Reviewer
Reject
Reject
Major revision
or re-review
opportunity
Revision
Re-Appeal
Accept
Minor revision

10. Kenali Audiens-mu
Saya tidak
mengerti. Apa
itu graphene??
“Semakin tinggi impact factor, semakin lebar target audiens-nya”
“Tulis apa yang ingin orang lain baca, bukan apa yang ingin kita baca”

11. Bagaimana orang (& editor & reviewer)
membaca paper?? (< 5 menit)
• Judul
• Table of Content Figures
• Abstrak
• Figures & Caption
• Introduction
• Conclusion
• Isi penjelasan paper-nya

12. Berawal dari akhir
• Methods
• Results
• Discussions
• Conclusions
• Introduction
• Title
• Abstract
B. J. Habibie
Mulai ditulis pada saat sedang melakukan riset
Mulai ditulis pada saat:
• Sudah memutuskan jurnal target
• Story telling
Terakhir dibuat

13. Manuscript yang kuat
• Eksperimen dan Data yang Solid
• Pesannya clear, berguna, dan menarik (exciting)
• Konstruksi dan presentasinya logis
 Kesimpulan menjawab tujuan
• Mudah untuk dibaca
 Reviewer
 Editor

14. Gambar, Plot, dan Caption
Advanced Materials, 2013

15. Gambar, Plot, dan Caption
#1. Gambar haruslah original
#2. Adaptasi  Gambar lagi + sitasi
#3. Re-use  Copyright clearance
#4. Jelas

16. Gambar, Plot, dan Caption
• Bahasa Inggris
• IUPAC/IUPAP guidelines
untuk “satuan”

17. Gambar, Plot, dan Caption
• Proporsional
• Minimum feature = 8 pt

18. Gambar, Plot, dan Caption
Dari: Danang Birowosuto, et al., Nature Materials, 2014.

19. Menyusun Referensi
Kumpulkan referensi-referensi sebelum memulai menulis
• Relevan
• Topik
• Statements
• Update
• Published & Accessible
• Jumlah (Proporsional)
• ? Self-citation
• Friend vs Enemy

20. Menyusun Referensi
Setiap jurnal yang berbeda memiliki format referensi yang berbeda
Advanced
Materials (Wiley)
Nature Materials
(NPG)
Gunakanlah Reference Manager !!
Zotero
www.zotero.org
gratis

21. Pentingnya membaca “Guide for Authors”

22. Tips & Tricks
Basic introduction
More detailed background
General problem
Main result summary (“Here we show”)
Main result explanation
General context of the results
Broader perspectives
Hal yang sama untuk
Advanced Materials

23. Tips & Tricks Introduction
General Intro
State of the art
More Specific
Problems
Purpose statement
Main Results
Advanced Materials, 2012

24. English….. What…???
“Despite the current language of science is broken English,
a manuscript should be well written”
Complaint from an editor (Elsevier):
“This paper fell well below my threshold. I refuse to spend time trying to
understand what the author is trying to say. Besides, I really want to send a
message that they can`t submit garbage to us and expect us to fix it. My rule
of thumb is that if there are more than 6 grammatical errors in the abstract,
then I don`t waste my time carefully reading the rest.”
Cari bantuan “native speakers”
“Language editing services”
Meningkatkan kemampuan Bahasa Inggris
• Membaca jurnal-jurnal
• Journal club
• Sumber lain: Novel, Podcast, dll.

25. Editorial Process
Reviewer
Submission
Editorial
Board
Editorial
Board
Reviewer
Reviewer
Reject
Reject
Major revision
or re-review
opportunity
Revision
Re-Appeal
Accept
Minor revision

26. Tips & Tricks
Cover Letter
Se-personal mungkin
• Nama Jurnal
• Nama Editor
Identitas Manuscript
• Judul
• Author List
• Contact Author(s) – Senior
• E-mail
Tentang Field of study
• Importance
• State of The Art
• Problem to be solved
Isi manuscript
• Tujuan & Kesimpulan
• What`s new
• Claims
• Impacts
Kandidat reviewer
• Proposed – Fair
• Against

27. Authorship
Gunakan alamat e-mail institusi!!!!!

28. Editorial Process
Reviewer
Submission
Editorial
Board
Editorial
Board
Reviewer
Reviewer
Reject
Reject
Major revision
or re-review
opportunity
Revision
Re-Appeal
Accept
Minor revision

29. Menanggapi Referee`s reports
#1. Referee ada untuk meningkatkan kualitas manuscript kita
#2. Kenali referee dari tulisannya
#3. Sebaiknya ikuti mayoritas saran referee
#4. Jika tidak suka, jawablah dengan sopan
JUDUL

30. Etika dan Copyright
www.copyright.com
Jauhilah plagiarism

31. Kesimpulan
Reviewer
Submission
Editorial
Board
Editorial
Board
Reviewer
Reviewer
Reject
Reject
Major revision
or re-review
opportunity
Revision
Re-Appeal
Accept
Minor revision
“Jangan takut untuk ditolak”

33. Kesimpulan