This is a start to the scope baseline but you seem to have forgotten who your audience is. The scope statement should be tailored to the people who will use and be affected by this project. I would think that the people living in that community would benefit the most from know what is going to be delivered and what they should expect of this project. Your scope statement is a listing of the project management and project team activities. That isn't correct. The audience for the WBS and dictionary is the project team. It should explain to them what the results of their work should look like or how it should behave. The dictionary descriptions are specific to THIS project and should be enough for the team member to know how to meet expectations. Your dictionary is missing all that. So look through my specific comments in the attached file. They should guide you in the right direction to help you finalize this assignment. Let me know if you have any questions.
Scope baseline
1. Scope Statement.
The scope for this small project consists of two stages:
• Stage 1. Design and project management required to support the new lift station.
Considerations include: Code and standards, Product requirements, utility requirements.
• Procurement, design, construction and start up of the upgraded station.
• Stage 2. Replacement and upgrade of the actual lift station to be executed by employees of
Pandora Moon Town. A team of experts improving stations and familiar with the current
operation of stations at Pandora Moon town.
• Replacement of key equipment, rehabilitation, repair and maintenance of the station. Also,
increasing the capacity of the station
2. Product scope description.
The scope description for this work cover the upgrade of one residential lift station. Also,
proposes the installation of new mechanical equipment such pumps stations, installation and
construction of new assets. Defined stages for this project plus other information will be contained in
the scope baseline.
The improvement of the station includes above ground and below ground modifications. The
above ground are the upgrades of the lift station surrounding and perimeter such flood protection,
new fencing, lighting, landscaping, new electrical wiring and storm water management.
The below ground improvements consist of replacement of existing pumps, upgraded
monitoring system and new odor control system.
The project includes the following:
• Stage 1. Project management.
• Monthly project updates with sponsor to discuss project budget, update schedule,
improvement specified in the design plan and project issues.
• Meet with project team staff to discuss standards, expectations and project approach.
• Gather information from planning department to review existing station and confirm
recommendations for the proposed updated station to identify advantages and
Commented [BZ1]: You are confusing your terms. The
Scope Stateme.
Basic Civil Engineering first year Notes- Chapter 4 Building.pptx
This is a start to the scope baseline but you seem to have forgott.docx
1. This is a start to the scope baseline but you seem to have
forgotten who your audience is. The scope statement should be
tailored to the people who will use and be affected by this
project. I would think that the people living in that community
would benefit the most from know what is going to be delivered
and what they should expect of this project. Your scope
statement is a listing of the project management and project
team activities. That isn't correct. The audience for the WBS
and dictionary is the project team. It should explain to them
what the results of their work should look like or how it should
behave. The dictionary descriptions are specific to THIS project
and should be enough for the team member to know how to meet
expectations. Your dictionary is missing all that. So look
through my specific comments in the attached file. They should
guide you in the right direction to help you finalize this
assignment. Let me know if you have any questions.
Scope baseline
1. Scope Statement.
The scope for this small project consists of two stages:
• Stage 1. Design and project management required to support
the new lift station.
Considerations include: Code and standards, Product
requirements, utility requirements.
• Procurement, design, construction and start up of the upgraded
2. station.
• Stage 2. Replacement and upgrade of the actual lift station to
be executed by employees of
Pandora Moon Town. A team of experts improving stations and
familiar with the current
operation of stations at Pandora Moon town.
• Replacement of key equipment, rehabilitation, repair and
maintenance of the station. Also,
increasing the capacity of the station
2. Product scope description.
The scope description for this work cover the upgrade of one
residential lift station. Also,
proposes the installation of new mechanical equipment such
pumps stations, installation and
construction of new assets. Defined stages for this project plus
other information will be contained in
the scope baseline.
The improvement of the station includes above ground and
below ground modifications. The
above ground are the upgrades of the lift station surrounding
and perimeter such flood protection,
new fencing, lighting, landscaping, new electrical wiring and
3. storm water management.
The below ground improvements consist of replacement of
existing pumps, upgraded
monitoring system and new odor control system.
The project includes the following:
• Stage 1. Project management.
• Monthly project updates with sponsor to discuss project
budget, update schedule,
improvement specified in the design plan and project issues.
• Meet with project team staff to discuss standards, expectations
and project approach.
• Gather information from planning department to review
existing station and confirm
recommendations for the proposed updated station to identify
advantages and
Commented [BZ1]: You are confusing your terms. The
Scope Statement is the entire document that consists of
sections 2.0 through 6.0. The scope statement is not a
separate paragraph with some high level information in it.
You should get used to using PMBOK terms correctly so you
understand how they are being used on the exam. This
section seems to be an executive summary. Perhaps you
can call it that.
Commented [BZ2]: Is this part of stage 1? I am confused
by the outline here.
4. Commented [BZ3]: Is this part of stage 2?
Commented [BZ4]: Who is your audience? You are
writing these documents as classroom assignments and not
professional documents. I am not supposed to be the
audience. The scope statement should be written to the
people who live in that neighborhood so they know what to
expect during and after this project.
Commented [BZ5]: This is interesting. I would like to see
what these things will look like when the project is
complete.
Commented [BZ6]: Your audience doesn’t care about this
at all. They don’t care how you are going to manage the
project. They only care about how disruptive this will be
while it is underway and what will be different when it is
over.
Save all these activities for the schedule. They don’t help
the reader understand what the result is supposed to look
like.
SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 2 of 7
disadvantages taking in consideration design, costs,
environmental and community
impacts.
5. • Conduct a reconnaissance of the station site to observe
existing conditions such
groundwater levels and actual operation of the station. Also,
verify condition and
capability of alternatives stations for collecting wastewater
while lift station #24 is under
construction.
• Conduct with all personal involved in the construction,
including operations,
maintenance, engineering and staff, a safety meeting to address
safety and health hazard
related to the project. Identify safety issues in the actual station
and stablish a safety
program.
• Coordinate with local, county, regional and federal agencies
when project information is
requested.
• Perform noise analysis before and final of the project to
ensure noise levels are not
exceeded the legal levels and doesn’t affect resident’s
boundary.
• Identify any and all permits requirements required that will be
required for the project.
6. Environmental, building, etc. ensure all permits are submitted in
a timely fashion to
ensure that the design and construction are unimpeded by the
permitting process.
• Prepare documents consisting of design guidelines, standards,
plans, specifications and
city and county requirements for all mechanical, electrical
instrumentation and drawing
of the new station.
• Provide detailed design calculations of pump sizes, selection
and capacity.
• Management of subcontractors for concrete, fences, odor
control system and
subconsultants. (motor suppliers, pump suppliers).
• Develop a quality assurance/quality control plan for all field
work including sampling if
apply and written certification of for concrete mix,
environmental tests and laboratory
work for air and water.
• Plan and implement public and stakeholder meeting for
involvement of the
neighborhood.
7. • Stage 2. Demolition and Construction.
• The existing station will be upgraded to meet current codes,
architectural criteria will be
incorporated to blend in with their surroundings.
Commented [BZ7]: Now, this will be of importance to the
neighbors. But remember they don’t care HOW you do it,
they want to know WHAT you are doing. Will roads be
closed? Will there be any noticeable effect when they flush
a toilet? Will there be loud noises? Will work be done after
hours or on weekends? How long will this take? Can you
show them a picture of what to expect with the new
fencing, landscaping, etc.?
This entire section is focusing on actions, not results. Save
most of these items for the schedule.
SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 3 of 7
• Bypass and isolate lift station to start modifications.
• Structural and electrical work will be completed first, and then
the mechanical work such
work on pumps and pipelines.
• Repair concrete deterioration, cracks, uneven pavement,
regrading of surface to correct
8. uneven topography. and construction of sidewalk.
• Upgrade fall protection system according to safety agencies.
• Upgrade exterior lighting and provide enough work lighting
while construction.
• Replace existing pumps, valves and motors based on provided
design, recommendations
and because they met flow conditions and space requirements.
• Upgrade main electrical distribution panel and electrical
enclosures.
• Property will be surrounded by a security fence to protect
station and prevent
unauthorized personnel from entering the station and a secure
gate.
• Install a gas detection system to detect explosive and
hazardous conditions, low and high
oxygen levels and high Hydro sulfuric acid levels.
• Install an odor control system that treat odors from wells,
chemicals and filters will be
subcontracted to an odor control technology company and
installed by employees.
• A new stand by generator will be included in the
improvements which provide sufficient
9. capacity to power the vital components of the station in case of
power failure.
• Construction of a sidewalk, driveway and employee access to
the new station.
• Installation of corrosion control measures to protect the steel
of the station.
• Setup landscaping improvements.
• Start up and final close out.
SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 4 of 7
3. Acceptance Criteria.
MAJOR PROJECT COMPONENTS STAKEHOLDERS
APPROVAL CRITERIA
Final design. • City Departments.
• Operations and
maintenance
technicians.
10. • Sub-contractors.
• Residents.
• When estimates, construction
plans, technical specifications
have been approved.
• When all equipment purchased
have been delivered.
Environmental Protection. • Residents.
• Federal agencies.
• When all considerations of air,
soil, water, noise and solid waste
comply with all applicable
federal, state and local laws.
Construction work and equipment
installation
• City Departments.
• Operations and
maintenance
technicians.
• Sub-contractors.
11. • When construction and
equipment provided for the
upgrade is in accordance with
the specifications. Equipment
has been tested and results are
acceptable.
Startup of renovated station • City government.
• City administrator
• Town residents.
• Operations and
maintenance
technicians.
• Successfully execution of
procedures of startup, normal
operation and shutdown.
• Preliminary run ins of pumps
and motors.
• Entire work area is free of
accumulation of waste material.
• Operation and maintenance
procedures are approved by
12. project manager.
Close out • City government.
• City administrator
• 24 hours of successful operation
of the station is a requisite of
completion and acceptance.
• When work is completed in
accordance with the designs and
the town of Pandora Moon can
utilize the station for its intended
purpose.
• All deliverables have been
reviewed and in full
conformance with the plan and
signed by project manager.
• All obligations, products and
services have been completed.
Commented [BZ8]: Very good
13. SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 5 of 7
4. Deliverables.
See WBS.
5. Exclusions.
• The existing transformer will remain in place because meets
power consumption, proposed
modifications includes energy saving and efficient equipment.
• This improvement project applies only for the town of Pandora
Moon lift station #24.
• No night shift during construction. Illumination and noise can
adversely affect residents and
motorists.
• Not specific software product other than the actual used in the
station will be installed on the
monitoring of the station.
• All equipment used for the construction will not exceed noise
in excess of 85 decibels at 50
feet.
14. • Irrigation system, fertilizers and landscaping for grass and
trees.
6. Constraints.
• The lift station requires temporary bypass pumping during
construction period, the actual
station will be out of service and the upgraded station is not in
service. Station won’t be on
service making difficult testing during the construction and
drain water in case of a storm.
• Construction noise will be limited to normal working hours
between the hours of 7 AM to 6
PM, Mondays through Friday.
• Finding of contaminated soil and hazardous material during
demolition such asbestos and
hazardous waste materials will lead to identify, sample and
analyze all materials disturbing
the planned demolition.
• Prevent any sewage spill during construction.
• Do not proceed with construction and installation in the
station if discrepancies have not been
fully resolved.
15. • Lift station must be working by May 2020.
• Project will not affect a pond near to the station, wetlands or
other sensitive environmental
resources. Natural resources will be protected.
Commented [BZ9]: Good
Commented [BZ10]: Constraints and assumptions are
not in the current scope statement template but I am glad
you added them. The PMBOK has them in a separate
Assumptions Log but we aren’t creating one of those.
SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 6 of 7
7. Work Breakdown Structure, Deliverables and dictionary.
This WBS define the task to be accomplished and the
description of the deliverable.
Type of task Definition Deliverable
1. Field development.
1.1. Mobilization.
1.1.1. Heavy equipment
16. 1.1.2. Personnel.
1.1.3. Shutdown of facility
This item establishes
the initial
requirements to start
work at the actual
station.
Utilities department
will provide the
guides to shutdown
of valves.
All equipment needed to
start the improvement must
be in place and all
personnel needed to start
the project.
1.2. Administrative requirements.
1.2.1 Agencies, codes, Permits.
1.2.2 References and documentations.
1.2.3 Project management
17. This item includes
the effort provide
permits, initial
documentation and
Codes that govern
design and
construction of the
facility.
Station must adhere to the
design guidelines and
zoning district standards
and comply with all codes
included in the
specifications.
2. Site work construction.
2.1.Relocation of equipment Movement of the
actual equipment to
be replaced or to be
18. maintained.
Work orders for
maintenance of equipment
and asset dispose capital
equipment form for
obsolete equipment.
2.2. Electrical.
2.2.1. Interruption of service.
2.2.2. Interior & exterior lighting
2.2.3. Electrical control panel.
2.2.4. Power protection
2.2.5. Emergency power.
This item describes
the electrical
activities associated
with the project
Coordination with power
utility company for
interruption of service.
Electrical system should be
19. installed in strict
conformance with National
Electric Code and all
applicable federal, state
and local laws.
2.3.Instrumentation and control.
2.3.1. Alarms.
2.3.2. Communication.
This item describes
all level sensing
equipment to be
installed. Also,
describes a control
key operation such a
main method of
level detection and
-A test button should be
installed to test functions
20. of all indicating lights
within the panel.
Test the following
monitoring systems:
-pump failure
-level sensor failure
-loss of power supply
Commented [BZ11]: These definitions are all actions.
Concentrate instead of what the work package should look
like when complete
Commented [BZ12]: You aren’t describing the
deliverable. You are describing acceptance criteria. It is a
good thing to have, just mislabeled.
Commented [BZ13]: Based on the definition, it appears
that you decomposed this section too far.
Commented [BZ14]: This is an activity.
Commented [BZ15]: This is not a proper decomposition.
Commented [BZ16]: Permits are deliverables but are you
delivering agencies and codes? The description should list
every permit needed and the agency that it comes from
Commented [BZ17]: If these documents are important
and take people and time to complete, then they should all
be listed as separate work packages. Put the descriptions at
21. the LOWEST level, not the one above it.
Commented [BZ18]: Remove this, you are not delivering
project management.
Commented [BZ19]: See? You even know you are
describing activities. That isn’t what goes here. I don’t
think it should be broken down into these 5 items. Won’t it
all be done by the same people? Put those details in the
description, not under the work package name.
Commented [BZ20]: When I see an “and”, I assume they
are separate work packages. I don’t think they are made up
of alarms and communication
SCOPE BASELINE Improvement Residential Wastewater Lift
Stations # 24
Page 7 of 7
an alternative sound
and visual
-activation of alternative
power supply.
Wiring diagram must be
provided. Approved.
2.4. Environmental
22. 2.4.1. Odor control
2.4.2. Air quality
This item is a policy
of completing all
environmental
assessment that have
impact within the
project to ensure
worker safety and
protection of the
residents.
Establish EHS policies to
document to ensure all
environmental tests are
identified and
implemented.
Because is an issue for
residents and businesses in
23. the vicinity, a hotline must
be provided in cases of
odor and/or noises
complaints.
2.5. Mechanical
2.5.1. Pumps installation.
2.5.2. Valves installation.
2.5.3. Piping installation.
2.5.4. Pressure gauges installation.
2.5.5. Flow meter installation.
2.5.6. Noise reduction.
This item describes
the mechanical
activities associated
with the project.
Work in comply with the
design guidelines.
Testing of efficient
equipment under worst
case scenario.
24. Documentation provided.
2.6. Site layout
2.6.1. Adequate Ingress/egress
2.6.2. Storm water retention and drainage
2.6.3. Sidewalk and driveway.
2.6.4. Pour concrete mix and fix existing.
2.6.5. Paint.
This item describes
the general guidance
on the layout of the
site
Codes and city ordinances
must be reviewed before,
during and after project.
Documented during project
meeting.
Blend the station into the
neighborhood.
2.7. Architecture and landscaping
2.7.1. Fence.
2.7.2. Gate.
25. 2.7.3. Landscaping.
2.7.4. Paint
2.7.5. Security
2.7.6. Signage
This item describes
how to incorporate
the station into the
surrounding
community.
Establish city standards,
preferences and guidelines
for building layout, site
security and appearance.
Identification signs is
required to warn people
and employees about risks
in the station.
3. Field test.
3.1. Evaluation of equipment.
3.2.Project close out
26. This item brings the
project to a planned
conclusion to
formalize the
acceptance of the
final project.
Perform administrative and
financial close out
document it and formalize
acceptance by project
manager.
Developing of operation,
maintenance and
inspection manuals.
Commented [BZ21]: How are you delivering odor control
or air quality? These aren’t described correctly. Looks like
the work package might be the Environmental Assessment.
Commented [BZ22]: These are activities. Are these parts
listed somewhere? I didn’t see it. Maybe they were implied
27. at Deployment? I would probably just list the part being
installed here and leave it at that. Drop “noise reduction”.
How are you delivering that? If there is another
assessment, then that is the deliverable.
Commented [BZ23]: This is the work package. Move the
details into the description.
Commented [BZ24]: Fence and gate should be one thing
- fencing. They aren’t being installed separately.
Each of these things need their own description of what
they will look like once installed.
Commented [BZ25]: This shouldn’t be broken down
either. The test is the test. If the evaluation occurs during
the test, then describe it in the definition.
Describe what close-out looks like separately.