Mohammad Faheem M. Aliuden, CE, MPA
Classic Theories of Political Science
The Early Philosophers
Describing the ideal political system
 Plato
 Republic (4th C. BC) - Normative examination of governing
 Citizens incapable of governing themselves, a philospher/king should
rule to create a just society.
 Aristotle
 Politics (4th C. BC) - Both normative (what should be) and descriptive
(what is)
 Based on observations of Greek city-states to see "what works and what
doesn't"
 Democracy is best, and best ruled by citizens of the middle class.
 Machiavelli
 The Prince (1513) - obtaining and using political power
 A realist: explanations not based on religious doctrines or what
we wish society to be.
The Contractualists
Explaining the creation of political
systems: social contracts
 Hobbes
 Leviathan (1651) - Civil society is formed out of fear.
 Life in the state of nature is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short."
 People submit to a strong monarch for protection from chaos.
 Locke
 Two Treatises of Government (1689) - Civil society is formed for the
protection of property.
 Life in the state of nature is peaceful, but property rights were
uncertain.
 Government requires consent of the governed.
 Rousseau
 Social Contract (1762) - Civil society formed to ensure freedom.
 People lived as "noble savages" but were corrupted by society.
 The "general will" guides a just society.
Institutional Theories
The Study of Constitutions
 "Traditional" Political Science
 Late 19th, early 20th Century
 Formal, legalistic study of institutions
 Not really "scientific," no systematic attempts
to explain political phenomena.
 Too simplistic - Institutions do not always function the
way they appear on paper.
Modern Political Science Theories
 Behavioralism (1950s - 1960s)
 Influence of Comtean Positivism - emphasis on scientific observation
 Highly critical of Traditional approach as unscientific
 Campbell et al. - The American Voter (1960)
 Post-Behavioralism (1960s -1970s)
 Highly critical of Behavioral approach as too static, irrelevant
 Interested in the prospects of political change, making things "better"
 Research findings have real world implications, researchers have a
social responsibility
 Systems Theory
 David Easton - A Systems Analysis of Political Life (1965)
 An attempt to model the political system
 Inputs - demands and supports
 Conversion Process (government decision makers), "the black box"
 Outputs - decisions and actions
 Components of the system are connected, interdependent
 Helpful, but too simplistic
 Modernization Theory
 Samuel P. Huntington - Political Order in Changing
Societies (1968)
 Explanation of Political Development
 Connection of economic development and democracy
 Rational Choice Theory
 Anthony Downs - An Economic Theory of Democracy (1957)
 Mancur Olsen - The Logic of Collective Action (1965)
 Assumption: Humans are rational "utility-maximizers"
 Game theory: Prisoners' dilemma
 Little role for culture, values, attitudes, etc
 Neo-Institutionalism
 Blending of Traditional approach and Rational Choice
 Studying institutions (traditional) from the perspective of
how the decision-making rules are set up and used by "utility-
maximizing" actors (rational choice)
References:
Archana Srinivasan, Famous Greek Personalities
http://desart.us/courses/1010/index.htm
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-politics/
http://www.wikipedia.org/
https://www.academia.edu/3138759/
Social_Contract_Theory_by_Hobbes_Locke_and_Rousseau

Theories of Political Science

  • 1.
    Mohammad Faheem M.Aliuden, CE, MPA
  • 2.
    Classic Theories ofPolitical Science
  • 3.
    The Early Philosophers Describingthe ideal political system  Plato  Republic (4th C. BC) - Normative examination of governing  Citizens incapable of governing themselves, a philospher/king should rule to create a just society.  Aristotle  Politics (4th C. BC) - Both normative (what should be) and descriptive (what is)  Based on observations of Greek city-states to see "what works and what doesn't"  Democracy is best, and best ruled by citizens of the middle class.  Machiavelli  The Prince (1513) - obtaining and using political power  A realist: explanations not based on religious doctrines or what we wish society to be.
  • 4.
    The Contractualists Explaining thecreation of political systems: social contracts  Hobbes  Leviathan (1651) - Civil society is formed out of fear.  Life in the state of nature is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish and short."  People submit to a strong monarch for protection from chaos.  Locke  Two Treatises of Government (1689) - Civil society is formed for the protection of property.  Life in the state of nature is peaceful, but property rights were uncertain.  Government requires consent of the governed.  Rousseau  Social Contract (1762) - Civil society formed to ensure freedom.  People lived as "noble savages" but were corrupted by society.  The "general will" guides a just society.
  • 5.
    Institutional Theories The Studyof Constitutions  "Traditional" Political Science  Late 19th, early 20th Century  Formal, legalistic study of institutions  Not really "scientific," no systematic attempts to explain political phenomena.  Too simplistic - Institutions do not always function the way they appear on paper.
  • 6.
  • 7.
     Behavioralism (1950s- 1960s)  Influence of Comtean Positivism - emphasis on scientific observation  Highly critical of Traditional approach as unscientific  Campbell et al. - The American Voter (1960)  Post-Behavioralism (1960s -1970s)  Highly critical of Behavioral approach as too static, irrelevant  Interested in the prospects of political change, making things "better"  Research findings have real world implications, researchers have a social responsibility  Systems Theory  David Easton - A Systems Analysis of Political Life (1965)  An attempt to model the political system  Inputs - demands and supports  Conversion Process (government decision makers), "the black box"  Outputs - decisions and actions  Components of the system are connected, interdependent  Helpful, but too simplistic
  • 8.
     Modernization Theory Samuel P. Huntington - Political Order in Changing Societies (1968)  Explanation of Political Development  Connection of economic development and democracy  Rational Choice Theory  Anthony Downs - An Economic Theory of Democracy (1957)  Mancur Olsen - The Logic of Collective Action (1965)  Assumption: Humans are rational "utility-maximizers"  Game theory: Prisoners' dilemma  Little role for culture, values, attitudes, etc  Neo-Institutionalism  Blending of Traditional approach and Rational Choice  Studying institutions (traditional) from the perspective of how the decision-making rules are set up and used by "utility- maximizing" actors (rational choice)
  • 9.
    References: Archana Srinivasan, FamousGreek Personalities http://desart.us/courses/1010/index.htm http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/aristotle-politics/ http://www.wikipedia.org/ https://www.academia.edu/3138759/ Social_Contract_Theory_by_Hobbes_Locke_and_Rousseau