The Open Economy &
Exchange rates
Pure theory of trade




1. Absolute

advantage: A country is said to have
an absolute advantage in the production of a good
when it is more efficient in the production of that
good
Assume each country has equal amounts of
resources and devotes half to X and half to Y

x

y

Country A

20

100

Country B

10

150




Country A has an absolute advantage in the
production of X and country B in production of Y.
2. COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE

:Two countries can

trade with each other if each specializes in the
industry in which it has the lowest opportunity costs.

x
Country A
Country B

20
10

y
200
150




Country A has a
comparative
advantage in the
production of X and B
in the production of Y
Specialization leads to
increased total
production

A

30

100

B

0

300

Total

30

400

A

35

50

B

0

300

Total

35

350
Instruments of trade policy
o
o

o

o
o

Tariffs:
specific tariffs are a fixed charge for
each unit of good produced
Ad valorem: are levied as a fraction of
the value of the imported goods
Quotas
Export subsidies
Effects of alternative trade
policies:
tariffs

Exp.sub quota

VER

Producer Rises
s’ surplus
Consume falls
r surplus

Rises

Rises

Rises

Falls

Falls

Falls

Govt rev Rises

Falls

Total
welfare

falls

No
change
Falls

No
change
No
change

Falls







Adjustable peg- where exchange rates
are fixed for a period of time but may
change
Devaluation: where the Govt re-pegs the
exchange rate at a lower level.
Revaluation – re-pegs at a higher level.
Dirty floating- a system where govt
intervenes to prevent excessive
fluctuations or even to achieve an
unofficial target rate
Exchange Rates



Defining Exchange Rate
Measuring Exchange Rate Movements





Appreciation/Depreciation of a currency

Exchange Rate Equilibrium
Factors that influence Exchange Rate
Movements
Meaning of Exchange Rate and
Measuring Changes in Exchange
Rates








Value of one currency in units of another
currency
A decline in a currency’s value is referred to
as depreciation and an increase in currency’s
value is called appreciation.
If currency A can buy you more units of
foreign currency, currency A has appreciated
and foreign currency depreciated
If currency A can buy you less units of foreign
currency, currency A has depreciated and
foreign currency appreciated
Appreciation/Depreciation


Percentage change in value US $

New Value of Foreign Currency
per unit of $
-

Old value of foreign currency per $

--------------------------------------------------

X 100

Old value of Foreign Currency per $



Percentage change in value of Foreign
Currency

New Value of $ per units of
Foreign Currency
-

Old value of $ per unit of foreign currency

-------------------------------------------------Old value of $ per unit of Foreign Currency

X 100
Exchange Rate Equilibrium







Forces of Demand and Supply
Demand for foreign currency negatively
related to the price of foreign currency
Supply of foreign currency positively
related to the price of foreign currency
Forces of demand and supply together
determine the exchange rate
Demand for Foreign Currency
Price for Foreign Currency

D
$2.00

$1.50

D
50m

75 m

Units of Foreign Currency (£)


Demand for pounds:
1.The firms, households and govt who
import UK goods
2. US citizens travelling to UK
3. Holders of $ who want to invest in UK
stocks and shares
4. US companies wanting to invest in
UK
5. Speculators anticipating a fall in
dollar price
Supply of Foreign Currency
price of foreign currency

S
$2.00

$1.50
S
50 m

75 m

Units of Foreign Currency (£)


Supply of pounds:
1. Importers of US goods into UK
2. UK citizens travelling to US.
3. Holders of pounds who want to buy
financial instruments into US
4. UK companies wanting to invest in US
5. Speculators anticipating a rise in the
value of dollars.
Equilibrium Exchange Rate
Exchange Rate

D

S

$1.6775
S

D
Units of Foreign
Currency(£)
Factors that influence the
Exchange Rate
Relative Inflation Rates
 Relative Interest Rates
 Relative Income Levels
 Expectations of the Market
 Political Events
Exchange rate is the results of an
interaction of these factors

Relative Inflation






High inflation relative to a foreign country, decline in
value of currency
Low inflation relative to a foreign country, increase in
value of currency
If inflation rates in one country are higher, there is an
increased demand for imported goods and decrease
in exports. This increases the demand for foreign
currency and reduces demand for local currency –
leading to depreciation
Relative Interest Rates






High interest rates in home country relative to a
foreign country may cause domestic currency to
appreciate
If US Interest rates fall then outflow of dollars leading
to increase in demand for pounds and British citizens
will not invest in US leading to a fall in supply of
pounds. This causes dollar to depreciate
An increase in the interest rate paid on deposits of a
currency causes that currency to appreciate against
foreign
Relative Income Levels




Increase in domestic income relative to
foreign income may lead to a decline in the
value of domestic currency– Why?
Imports are a function of income . Hence
increasing incomes lead to increase in
imports and hence increase in demand for
foreign currency. This causes domestic
currency to depreciate
Market Expectations









Expectations about future exchange rate
changes on the basis of current and future
political and economic conditions
1960s Strong $
Between 1960s and 1970s: weak $
Strong $ in 1999 – 2001
Weak Dollar today 2005 onwards
1995 European Exchange Rate Mechanism
Devaluation of Asian Currencies
Political Events








Fall of Berlin Wall and unification of
East and West Germany
Rumors about resignation of Mikhail
Gorbachov
Tiananmen Square
Persian Gulf War
September 11, 2001
Fixed vs flexible exchange
rates:


Advantages of flexible exchange rates:








Better adjustment mechanism
Better confidence
No need for central banks to hold money
Gains from freer trade
Increases independence of policy

Disadvantages:




Uncertainty and diminished trade
Instability
speculation


Fixed exchange rate is maintained by






Use of reserves
Trade policies
Exchange control
Domestic macro-adjustments
Raising interest rates


Advantages of fixed exchange rates







Certainty
No speculation
Automatic correction of monetary errors
Prevents irresponsible macro policies

Disadvantages:


Makes monetary policy ineffective




Imbalance persists
BOP deficit may hurt the economy
Problems of international liquidity
Surplus or a Deficit in the BOP:






A deficit in the BOP can have 2
consequences:
The country can borrow from abroad.
It may sell its assets
To rectify a deficit:




Devaluation/depreciation
Import restrictions
Domestic deflation to reduce aggregate
demand
Impact of a Devaluation:


Increase in exports depends on






Price elasticity of demand for the
exportables
Price elasticity of supply in the domestic
market

Decrease in imports depend on



Price elasticity of demand for imports
May result in cost push inflation and hence
a rise in price if exports as well.
J curve:




A depreciation leads to at first a
deterioration of the trade balance and
then an improvement
Marshall Lerner condition: The sum of
proportional change in exports plus the
proportional change in imports minus
the percentage change in depreciation
must be positive
Balance of Payments






A record of international transactions between
residents of one country and the rest of the world
International transactions include exchanges of
goods, services or assets
“Residents” means businesses, individuals and
government agencies, including citizens
temporarily living abroad but excluding local
subsidiaries of foreign corporations
Double-entry Accounting in the BOP




All transactions are either debit or credit
transactions
Credit transactions result in receipt of
payment from foreigners
 Merchandise exports (valued f.o.b.)
 Transportation and travel receipts
 Income received from investments abroad
 Gifts received from foreign residents
 Aid received from foreign governments
Double-entry Accounting (Cont’d)


Debit transactions involve payments to
foreigners








Merchandise imports
Transportation and travel expenditures
Income paid on investments of foreigners
Gifts to foreign residents
Aid given by home government

Each credit transaction has a balancing debit
transaction, and vice versa, so the overall
balance of payments is always in balance.
Balance of payments:


A. Current Account:
 Balance of Trade in goods
 Balance of Trade in services- travel, insurance
and transportation.
 Balance of trade in goods and services
 Other income flows




Investment income
Transfers, balance( aid, remittances)
GNIE


B. Capital Account:









1.Foreign investment
FDI and FII
2.Loans and commercial borrowings
3. Banking capital – assets, liabilities and non
resident deposits.
4.Rupee debt service
5. others.
Capital account = 1+2+3+4+5

C. Errors and omissions
D. Overall balances
E. Monetary movements- IMF / foreign
exchange reserves
balance in current account + balance in
capital account + monetary movts =0
Real exchange rates:




Relative prices of two currencies after
adjusting for changes in domestic
prices
RER of $ per pound:
= ($/£)(PUK/PUS)

If exchange rate = 3$ per £
RER = 1 if prices in UK and US are 30
and 90 respectively.

The+open+economy+&+exchange+rates

  • 1.
    The Open Economy& Exchange rates
  • 2.
    Pure theory oftrade   1. Absolute advantage: A country is said to have an absolute advantage in the production of a good when it is more efficient in the production of that good Assume each country has equal amounts of resources and devotes half to X and half to Y x y Country A 20 100 Country B 10 150
  • 3.
      Country A hasan absolute advantage in the production of X and country B in production of Y. 2. COMPARATIVE ADVANTAGE :Two countries can trade with each other if each specializes in the industry in which it has the lowest opportunity costs. x Country A Country B 20 10 y 200 150
  • 4.
      Country A hasa comparative advantage in the production of X and B in the production of Y Specialization leads to increased total production A 30 100 B 0 300 Total 30 400 A 35 50 B 0 300 Total 35 350
  • 5.
    Instruments of tradepolicy o o o o o Tariffs: specific tariffs are a fixed charge for each unit of good produced Ad valorem: are levied as a fraction of the value of the imported goods Quotas Export subsidies
  • 6.
    Effects of alternativetrade policies: tariffs Exp.sub quota VER Producer Rises s’ surplus Consume falls r surplus Rises Rises Rises Falls Falls Falls Govt rev Rises Falls Total welfare falls No change Falls No change No change Falls
  • 7.
        Adjustable peg- whereexchange rates are fixed for a period of time but may change Devaluation: where the Govt re-pegs the exchange rate at a lower level. Revaluation – re-pegs at a higher level. Dirty floating- a system where govt intervenes to prevent excessive fluctuations or even to achieve an unofficial target rate
  • 8.
    Exchange Rates   Defining ExchangeRate Measuring Exchange Rate Movements    Appreciation/Depreciation of a currency Exchange Rate Equilibrium Factors that influence Exchange Rate Movements
  • 9.
    Meaning of ExchangeRate and Measuring Changes in Exchange Rates     Value of one currency in units of another currency A decline in a currency’s value is referred to as depreciation and an increase in currency’s value is called appreciation. If currency A can buy you more units of foreign currency, currency A has appreciated and foreign currency depreciated If currency A can buy you less units of foreign currency, currency A has depreciated and foreign currency appreciated
  • 10.
    Appreciation/Depreciation  Percentage change invalue US $ New Value of Foreign Currency per unit of $ - Old value of foreign currency per $ -------------------------------------------------- X 100 Old value of Foreign Currency per $  Percentage change in value of Foreign Currency New Value of $ per units of Foreign Currency - Old value of $ per unit of foreign currency -------------------------------------------------Old value of $ per unit of Foreign Currency X 100
  • 11.
    Exchange Rate Equilibrium     Forcesof Demand and Supply Demand for foreign currency negatively related to the price of foreign currency Supply of foreign currency positively related to the price of foreign currency Forces of demand and supply together determine the exchange rate
  • 12.
    Demand for ForeignCurrency Price for Foreign Currency D $2.00 $1.50 D 50m 75 m Units of Foreign Currency (£)
  • 13.
     Demand for pounds: 1.Thefirms, households and govt who import UK goods 2. US citizens travelling to UK 3. Holders of $ who want to invest in UK stocks and shares 4. US companies wanting to invest in UK 5. Speculators anticipating a fall in dollar price
  • 14.
    Supply of ForeignCurrency price of foreign currency S $2.00 $1.50 S 50 m 75 m Units of Foreign Currency (£)
  • 15.
     Supply of pounds: 1.Importers of US goods into UK 2. UK citizens travelling to US. 3. Holders of pounds who want to buy financial instruments into US 4. UK companies wanting to invest in US 5. Speculators anticipating a rise in the value of dollars.
  • 16.
    Equilibrium Exchange Rate ExchangeRate D S $1.6775 S D Units of Foreign Currency(£)
  • 17.
    Factors that influencethe Exchange Rate Relative Inflation Rates  Relative Interest Rates  Relative Income Levels  Expectations of the Market  Political Events Exchange rate is the results of an interaction of these factors 
  • 18.
    Relative Inflation    High inflationrelative to a foreign country, decline in value of currency Low inflation relative to a foreign country, increase in value of currency If inflation rates in one country are higher, there is an increased demand for imported goods and decrease in exports. This increases the demand for foreign currency and reduces demand for local currency – leading to depreciation
  • 19.
    Relative Interest Rates    Highinterest rates in home country relative to a foreign country may cause domestic currency to appreciate If US Interest rates fall then outflow of dollars leading to increase in demand for pounds and British citizens will not invest in US leading to a fall in supply of pounds. This causes dollar to depreciate An increase in the interest rate paid on deposits of a currency causes that currency to appreciate against foreign
  • 20.
    Relative Income Levels   Increasein domestic income relative to foreign income may lead to a decline in the value of domestic currency– Why? Imports are a function of income . Hence increasing incomes lead to increase in imports and hence increase in demand for foreign currency. This causes domestic currency to depreciate
  • 21.
    Market Expectations        Expectations aboutfuture exchange rate changes on the basis of current and future political and economic conditions 1960s Strong $ Between 1960s and 1970s: weak $ Strong $ in 1999 – 2001 Weak Dollar today 2005 onwards 1995 European Exchange Rate Mechanism Devaluation of Asian Currencies
  • 22.
    Political Events      Fall ofBerlin Wall and unification of East and West Germany Rumors about resignation of Mikhail Gorbachov Tiananmen Square Persian Gulf War September 11, 2001
  • 23.
    Fixed vs flexibleexchange rates:  Advantages of flexible exchange rates:       Better adjustment mechanism Better confidence No need for central banks to hold money Gains from freer trade Increases independence of policy Disadvantages:    Uncertainty and diminished trade Instability speculation
  • 24.
     Fixed exchange rateis maintained by      Use of reserves Trade policies Exchange control Domestic macro-adjustments Raising interest rates
  • 25.
     Advantages of fixedexchange rates      Certainty No speculation Automatic correction of monetary errors Prevents irresponsible macro policies Disadvantages:  Makes monetary policy ineffective    Imbalance persists BOP deficit may hurt the economy Problems of international liquidity
  • 26.
    Surplus or aDeficit in the BOP:     A deficit in the BOP can have 2 consequences: The country can borrow from abroad. It may sell its assets To rectify a deficit:    Devaluation/depreciation Import restrictions Domestic deflation to reduce aggregate demand
  • 27.
    Impact of aDevaluation:  Increase in exports depends on    Price elasticity of demand for the exportables Price elasticity of supply in the domestic market Decrease in imports depend on   Price elasticity of demand for imports May result in cost push inflation and hence a rise in price if exports as well.
  • 28.
    J curve:   A depreciationleads to at first a deterioration of the trade balance and then an improvement Marshall Lerner condition: The sum of proportional change in exports plus the proportional change in imports minus the percentage change in depreciation must be positive
  • 29.
    Balance of Payments    Arecord of international transactions between residents of one country and the rest of the world International transactions include exchanges of goods, services or assets “Residents” means businesses, individuals and government agencies, including citizens temporarily living abroad but excluding local subsidiaries of foreign corporations
  • 30.
    Double-entry Accounting inthe BOP   All transactions are either debit or credit transactions Credit transactions result in receipt of payment from foreigners  Merchandise exports (valued f.o.b.)  Transportation and travel receipts  Income received from investments abroad  Gifts received from foreign residents  Aid received from foreign governments
  • 31.
    Double-entry Accounting (Cont’d)  Debittransactions involve payments to foreigners       Merchandise imports Transportation and travel expenditures Income paid on investments of foreigners Gifts to foreign residents Aid given by home government Each credit transaction has a balancing debit transaction, and vice versa, so the overall balance of payments is always in balance.
  • 32.
    Balance of payments:  A.Current Account:  Balance of Trade in goods  Balance of Trade in services- travel, insurance and transportation.  Balance of trade in goods and services  Other income flows    Investment income Transfers, balance( aid, remittances) GNIE
  • 33.
     B. Capital Account:        1.Foreigninvestment FDI and FII 2.Loans and commercial borrowings 3. Banking capital – assets, liabilities and non resident deposits. 4.Rupee debt service 5. others. Capital account = 1+2+3+4+5 C. Errors and omissions D. Overall balances E. Monetary movements- IMF / foreign exchange reserves balance in current account + balance in capital account + monetary movts =0
  • 34.
    Real exchange rates:   Relativeprices of two currencies after adjusting for changes in domestic prices RER of $ per pound: = ($/£)(PUK/PUS) If exchange rate = 3$ per £ RER = 1 if prices in UK and US are 30 and 90 respectively.