SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 8
An n a G r igo r y an an d Joh n M a rk Ki ng—
Tu   r k Ey   and   uni   TEd   sT   a T E s   —




                                Adbusting: Critical Media
                                Literacy in a Multi-Skills
                                Academic Writing Lesson —
                                           media literacy is a field               often used to describe a more rigor-
                                             that began as a grassroots            ous evaluation of the mass media’s
                                             movement among educa-                 relationship to democracy, power, and
                                tors concerned with the growing gap                social justice. As a classroom topic,
                                between popular culture, produced                  critical media literacy encourages dis-
                                by corporations, and the literacy con-             cussions about how the media con-
                                tent in today’s schools (Flores-Koulish            ceptualize race, class, and gender, and
                                2005). Today, many educators rec-                  how it promotes certain social values
                                ognize the pedagogical importance                  through its definitions of such con-
                                of training students to develop an                 cepts as beauty, prestige, family, love,
                                awareness of how and why adver-                    success, sex, freedom, and consumer-
                                tisements and other media messages                 ism, among others. Critical media
                                often misrepresent and manipulate the              analysis allows students to access,
                                facts. Consequently, teachers can find             analyze, and evaluate popular texts
                                many resources on how to develop and               in terms of their cultural, political,
                                implement a media literacy curricu-                ideological, and socioeconomic rami-
                                lum (Schwarz and Brown 2005). —                    fications. Because these are impor-
                                    According to Aufderheide (1993,                tant and relevant issues for students
                                1), a media literate individual “can               and teachers, incorporating critical
                                decode, evaluate, analyze and produce              media analysis into the second lan-
                                both print and electronic media.” Nev-             guage classroom is an excellent way to
                                ertheless, there are different degrees             engage students’ skills in communica-
                                of media literacy. Many analyses are               tion and higher-level thinking. —
                                merely descriptive and do not exam-                    This article will discuss the ratio-
                                ine with any depth how various media               nale for incorporating critical media
                                affect society and individuals; there-             analysis into the second language
                                fore, the term critical media literacy is          classroom and will describe a method

         2                                           2008      N   u m b e r   4   |   E   n g l i s h   T   E a c h i n g   F   o r u m
to combine it with a university level writ-                •	 introduces	 students	 to	 codes	 and	 con-
ing lesson based on the process-centered                      ventions of the target culture and acti-
approach in which students plan, revise, and                  vates their background knowledge; —
produce a written text with a special focus on             •	 offers	the	possibility	for	portfolios	and	
the intended audience. In this writing lesson                 other forms of alternative assessment. —
students will also produce an Adbuster, which               These aspects of communicative language
is a parody of a commercial message. The pri-           teaching are evident in the following ten-step
mary goals of the lesson are to promote critical        lesson plan. —
thinking and to develop formal and informal
language skills through a variety of individual         An integrated media literacy lesson plan —
and group-based, task-oriented activities. —                This lesson plan is designed for a col-
Why integrate media literacy and                        lege or university setting and is based on the
academic writing? —                                     process genre approach in which students not
                                                        only plan and revise two texts, but also meet
    There are many theoretical and practical
                                                        certain	rhetorical	and	structural	requirements	
reasons to combine critical media literacy with
                                                        based on the texts’ audience (Badger and
a modern academic writing lesson. Advertise-
                                                        White 2000). In addition, this lesson will
ments and other media messages are available
                                                        require	students	to	plan	and	revise	a	piece	of	
virtually everywhere, and giving language
                                                        Adbuster art that will accompany the written
learners the opportunity to evaluate them and
                                                        texts. As students become more keenly aware
create their own written texts allows students
                                                        of the role of their target audience, they learn
to develop their critical thinking and commu-
                                                        how to modify language to communicate
nication skills. Because of the interesting and
                                                        through various media and to establish a
relevant nature of the subject matter, this type
                                                        continuity of ideas between two very different
of task-based lesson creates a student-centered
                                                        types of expression—formal writing and art. —
environment that is the foundation of com-
municative language teaching. For example, a            What is an Adbuster? —
media literacy academic writing project: —                   To begin, it is important for teachers and
     •	 uses	 authentic	 materials	 to	 contextual-     students to be familiar with an Adbuster, which
        ize language, appeal to student inter-          is a form of media that looks like an adver-
        ests, and increase their motivation; —          tisement but actually opposes the values and
     •	 requires	 real	 language	 for	 meaningful	      assumptions presented by a corporation through
        communication, which develops stu-              its advertising campaigns (examples of Adbuster
        dents’ cognitive and academic strategies        ads can be found at the following website:
        in multiple skills;—                            http://adbusters.org/spoofads/index.php). —
     •	 inspires	 small	 groups	 to	 create	 mean-           Advertisements sell not only products, but
        ingful	 written	 drafts	 and	 quality	 peer	    also ideas. For instance, an advertisement for
        review and revision; —                          a diet pill is not only selling the actual pill,
     •	 creates	 a	 positive	 social	 and	 affective	   but also the idea that being thin is important,
        working environment; —                          perhaps more important than being healthy.
     •	 permits	 teachers	 to	 include	 various	        Advertisements for diet products often target
        activities that appeal to virtually any         women by showing a young, attractive woman
        kind of learning style; —                       smiling and happy because she has lost weight.
     •	 provides	 a	 large	 amount	 of	 language	       An Adbuster for such an advertisement could
        input and output so students learn to           visually oppose the message of taking the
        use effective communication strategies;         actual pill by showing the potentially nega-
     •	 helps	 student	 evaluate	 and	 respond	 to	     tive side effects, such as osteoporosis, depres-
        arguments, which develops their ana-            sion, or organ damage. The Adbuster could
        lytical skills; —                               also oppose the ideas or assumptions in the
     •	 allows	 for	 the	 integration	 of	 skills	      advertisement by challenging the definition
        through a variety of linguistic situations      of beauty or success as being extremely thin.
        that	require	the	use	of	both	formal	and	        The Adbuster could also offer a definition of
        informal English; —                             beauty, happiness, and success not in terms of


E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m    |   Number     4    2008                               3
outward appearance, but rather as connected            Adbusters that showed the potentially danger-
    to one’s overall health and well-being. —              ous effects of dieting. Many also redefined the
        Most advertisements have a central mes-            notion of beauty offered by popular women’s
    sage: If you buy this product, then you will           magazines as inner beauty, health, and overall
    be “thin,” “rich,” “successful,” or “fit,” and         well-being rather than looking “perfect” or
    therefore “happy” and “fulfilled.” Usually, the        extremely thin. Hence, the assignment allows
    central message can be ascertained by reading          students to critically understand the very
    the slogan and understanding the story being           forces that shape their values, attitudes, and
    told through the visual image. However, in             assumptions—their identities. —
    addition to the central message tied to the
    product, advertisers also create and reinforce         Ten steps of the media literacy lesson plan —
                                                               The primary goals of the lesson are to pro-
    our assumptions of what it means to be a
                                                           mote critical thinking and to develop formal
    beautiful, rich, successful man or woman.
                                                           and informal language skills through a variety
    Advertisers also offer us definitions of sexual-
                                                           of individual and group-based, task-oriented
    ity, happiness, family, love, health, freedom,
                                                           activities. In these activities, students will col-
    and other values that guide our behavior. We
                                                           laborate with their groupmates to prepare a
    may not buy a diet pill or a luxury car, but
                                                           project that they will present to their peers.
    we may nevertheless absorb the idea that “you
                                                           Unlike products of the average academic writ-
    can never be too rich or too thin.” Because
                                                           ing lesson, the texts produced here will be done
    we are surrounded by advertisements, which
                                                           as a group, not individually. This can at first
    are an integral part of our culture, we are like
                                                           create some difficulty for the teacher who is
    fish	in	an	aquarium,	unaware	that	we	live	in	
                                                           trying to maintain order in the class and ensure
    water because we consider it a natural part of
                                                           that	 all	 students	 contribute	 equally	 to	 the	
    our	existence.	In	requiring	students	to	create	        assignment. However, providing varied options
    Adbusters, we are not teaching them simply to          to students for the creation of meaningful lan-
    resist advertisements. We are enhancing their          guage at different stages of the lesson appeals to
    critical thinking skills by making them aware          many different learning styles. As a result, such
    of how culture is created through a set of             a lesson may not be best used to determine a
    assumptions or stories told over and again. —          student’s placement or readiness to advance to
        An Adbuster can be made for virtually              the next level, but it is, nonetheless, designed to
    any advertisement. For this lesson students            improve a student’s overall proficiency in Eng-
    must choose an advertisement, and they may             lish. This is, of course, our ultimate goal. —
    initially seem frustrated or confused about                First, students will create one paragraph that
    which advertisement to choose so that making           examines the assumptions and hidden mes-
    an Adbuster will be easy. However, we tell our         sages in a particular magazine advertisement.
    students to choose advertisements from maga-           A second paragraph will critically evaluate
    zines that they read or that appeal to their           those assumptions. In addition to these para-
    interests. Thus, one group of male students            graphs, each group will produce an Adbuster
    made an Adbuster for videogames in which               as a visual companion to their writing. The
    they explored the effects of violent video             ten steps detailed in the following lesson are
    games on children. Their Adbuster contained            merely suggestions. Throughout the lesson,
    pictures of children holding video game guns,          the teacher must help his or her students to
    of children spending hours in front of televi-         practice the writing process used by successful
    sion, and scenes of blood and violence from            students and professionals in the real world.
    video games that were very realistic. Stu-             Before beginning these steps, teachers should
    dents discussed the effects of video games on          divide students into groups of three or four.
    children’s identity formation and the effects
    of television violence on society in general.          Step 1: Focused freewriting —
    Another student who practices weightlifting               To begin, the teacher tells the students
    and was interested in bodybuilding as a hobby          they are going to look at an advertisement
    completed an Adbuster about the negative               for a commercial product out of a popular
    effects of using steroids to build muscles.            American magazine. The teacher then gives
    Many girls who read fashion magazines did              each group a different advertisement from a


4                            2008      Number          4   |    E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m
magazine. Teachers may also allow students to              In this step, the teacher also introduces
bring magazines that they read at home and             students to a variety of sample Adbusters
have each group select one advertisement to            produced by previous classes to provide them
analyze in the classroom. —                            with clear examples of the designs they will be
    Then, the teacher tells the students to get        expected to complete. If teachers do not have
out a sheet of paper and a pen or pencil and           sample Adbusters or paragraphs from previous
to begin freewriting, which is a pre-writing           classes, they may choose to create their own to
exercise in which students write for a speci-          use	 until	 quality	 student-produced	 materials	
fied time on a specific topic without stopping         are available. Sample Adbusters, however, may
and without making corrections. Typically,             be found at the aforementioned website. —
students keep their freewriting assignments
                                                       Step 3: Understand, analyze, and
and refer to them during later stages of the
                                                       evaluate—find the hidden messages —
writing process in order to build on and fur-
ther refine their ideas. In this lesson students           The teacher should explain that many
are encouraged to write nonstop about their            advertisements sell not only products, but
advertisement for five to ten minutes without          also ideas, by promoting certain values, ste-
making corrections or using a dictionary.              reotypes, and assumptions. The students will
They are free to write whatever they want, as          explore these “hidden messages” using a work-
long as it is in response to whatever they see         sheet entitled Deconstructing an Advertisement
in the ad. If they do not know what to write,          that can be found online from the Media
the teacher should tell them to write “I don’t         Education Foundation (2005). Using this
know what to write.” During this exercise, the         worksheet, the students will complete the fol-
teacher should monitor the students closely to         lowing tasks: —
ensure that they follow the directions. —                 1. Describe the codes and conventions in
    When time is up, the teacher tells the                    their advertisement —
groups to share what they have written with               2. Determine the purpose of their adver-
other members of their groups. They do not                    tisement —
need to read their freewriting aloud; they only           3. Determine the assumptions their adver-
need to summarize their reaction to the adver-                tisement makes —
tisement. This should take no more than ten               4.	 Determine	 possible	 consequences	 of	
minutes, and while the students are talking,                  their advertisement —
the teacher should walk around the room to                 The students work together to complete
monitor their progress. —                              these four tasks, and each member in the
                                                       group will be responsible for writing down
Step 2: Sample paragraphs and
                                                       and reporting one of them to the rest of
Adbusters —
                                                       the class. Thus, each member completes a
    The teacher can now help students to bet-          writing and speaking task as a part of this
ter understand the genre within which they             portion of the activity. If members within
will be working to create their two paragraphs,        a group disagree with one another on their
which can be done by showing students one              evaluation of the advertisement, the teacher
or more examples of successful writing by              can remind them that it is a good exercise in
students in previous classes. Showing sample           critical thinking to argue a point of view that
paragraphs is useful because the academic              you do not necessarily agree with. Also, if two
writing style, which uses one controlling idea         members disagree, they can both share their
for a paragraph and a topic sentence at or near        different views with the class, thus setting up
the beginning, is a genre whose mastery will           the opportunity for conversation, debate, and
certainly help students to succeed in school. —        multiple interpretations. —
    Together with the teacher, students analyze            As each group shares their advertisements
sample paragraphs that are very similar to             and reports their four-point analysis, the other
what they will be asked to produce and dis-            students listen and express their agreement or
cover the paragraphs’ structure on their own.          disagreement with the reporting group’s inter-
The teacher can help, of course, and answer            pretations. For example, a group may report
any	questions	that	come	up. —                          that they found that an advertisement for ciga-


E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m   |   Number     4    2008                                5
rettes draws a connection between “freedom”                  •	 The	wide	open	horizon	in	front	of	the	
    or “independence” and smoking by pointing                       yacht suggests that the people portrayed
    out that the advertisement shows an image of                    are “free.” —
    young men and women sailing on a yacht while                 •	 The	 fact	 that	 the	 people	 are	 dressed	
    smoking cigarettes. Then, the group can evalu-                  nicely, are attractive, and are on a yacht
    ate the validity of this connection: Is smoking                 rather than a small boat suggests that
    at all connected to a lifestyle of the rich and                 they are rich and financially indepen-
    does it really increase your enjoyment of life?                 dent, so their freedom is also financial
    Finally, the group will determine the possible                  freedom. —
    long-	and	short-term	consequences	of	believing	              •	 The	 social	 atmosphere	 on	 the	 yacht	
    the messages presented in the advertisement.                    suggests that cigarettes are a good addi-
    Is the advertisement effective? Will the target                 tion to “happy” social occasions when
    audience be persuaded to buy the product? —                     you are having a good time with friends
        If a group decides that their advertisement                 and enjoying a sense of freedom. —
    has no hidden messages, the teacher can ask                  Then, students brainstorm for their second
    them	 additional	 guided	 questions	 about	 the	         paragraph,	 which	 will	 critique	 the	 central	
    advertisement based on the teacher’s own                 message as well as the hidden messages of
    analysis. In addition, if students offer an              their advertisement. To have the critical skills
    interpretation that is not obvious or may not            necessary to develop this second paragraph, it
    be justifiable, the teacher should not be afraid         is important that students have understood
    to ask them why they made their decision and             and completed the Deconstructing an Adver-
    how they came to it. For instance, if a student          tisement worksheet so they can determine the
    says a woman in the picture looks “healthy,”             advertisement’s assumptions and its possible
    and the connection to health is not obvious,             consequences.	As	a	result,	students	may	write	
    the teacher can say: “What is it in the picture          the following: —
    that makes you think of health?” or “What is
    it about her that makes her look healthy?” —                 •	 The	 ad	 falsely	 connects	 enjoying	 time	
                                                                    with your friends to smoking. —
    Step 4: Brainstorming —                                      •	 Showing	attractive,	young	people	hides	
        Working together, each group member                         the fact that smoking causes the yel-
    writes the central message of the advertise-                    lowing of teeth, poor skin health, and
    ment they analyzed in step three. Usually, the                  smoking-related diseases such as lung
    central message insinuates something like:                      cancer and emphysema. —
    “If you buy this product, then you will be                   •	 The	 ad	 falsely	 connects	 smoking	 with	
    more ‘attractive,’ or ‘slim,’ or ‘free,’ and, as a              personal and financial freedom—
    result, happier.” This central message is usu-                  smoking cannot make you richer or
    ally found in the slogan or in the dominant                     more free. —
    images and texts within the ad. —                            •	 The	 ad	 does	 not	 show	 that	 because	
        Next, students locate their advertisement’s                 smoking cigarettes creates a physical
    hidden messages or assumptions and conduct                      addiction to nicotine, it actually makes
    a group brainstorming exercise about them.                      you less free. —
    Students can refer to answers they came up                   •	 The	ad	does	not	show	that	rather	than	
    with when completing the four tasks from the                    leading to freedom and enjoyment of
    Deconstructing an Advertisement worksheet in                    life, smoking can often lead to death. —
    Step 3. A graphic organizer word map would                  It is important for the teacher to be aware
    work well here, with both the central and hid-           that many of the advertisements available
    den messages forming the center and all the evi-         worldwide come from Western cultures, in
    dence students find for the existence of hidden          many cases the United States. This creates
    messages displayed in word bubbles around the            an opportunity for students to explore the
    center. For example, if the group believes that          ways in which culture of origin is portrayed
    their advertisement promotes smoking as a way            in advertising. Analyzing the assumptions a
    to achieve freedom and independence, they                culture makes can create a great deal of mean-
    would list the following evidence: —                     ingful discussion in the classroom.


6                             2008       Number          4   |    E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m
To take this further, the teacher can              tions in the ad, or the use of the actual prod-
encourage students to analyze their adver-             uct. Then, they can determine the kinds of
tisements based on the assumptions of their            images they will use to express their ideas.
native culture. Students may find that this            The teacher may want to provide a worksheet
can lead either to a deeper understanding              the students can use to record these ideas.
of an advertisement’s hidden messages or,              The	 worksheet	 should	 require	 the	 students	
more likely, gross misinterpretation because           to (1) write down the central messages of the
of cultural differences. This can initiate a class     advertisement, (2) make a list of assumptions
discussion about the importance of knowing             made by the advertisement, and (3) analyze
one’s audience and of being aware that people          the possible effects of using the product that
of different backgrounds can interpret an              are not revealed in the advertisement (e.g.,
individual message in many different ways.             What is there about this product that the
This knowledge and awareness is crucial to             company selling it to you may not want you
the development of academic writing skills. —          to know? How does the main message com-
    Finally, the students decide on the theme          pare to reality?). —
of the Adbuster they will create. Using the                The Deconstructing an Advertisement work-
content of their paragraphs, they will design          sheet (Media Education Foundation 2005)
a visual representation of their academic writ-        should have given the students the analytical
ing. The teacher may remind the students that          tools necessary to complete this stage of the
an Adbuster may oppose either the purchase of          activity. Once the students have made a list of
the actual product, or the assumptions that the        the central message, the assumptions, and the
advertisement makes, or both. For instance,            untold effects of using the product, they can
students may make an Adbuster opposing                 begin considering which messages they will
the purchase of a diet pill because it is unsafe.      oppose in their Adbuster, or whether they will
However, they may also simply make an                  choose to explore the negative side effects of
Adbuster that defines beauty in terms of health        using a product, such as the negative effects of
rather than thinness. The choice is theirs. —          smoking on health or the use of cars on the
                                                       environment. —
Step 5: Outlining and Adbuster design —
    In this step the students write detailed out-      Step 6: First drafts and peer review —
lines of their two paragraphs and then begin               Once the outlines and basic Adbuster
work on the Adbuster itself. Two students              design are completed, the groups begin the
from a group of four use their work from               more detailed work of drafting their projects’
both the freewriting and brainstorming steps           final	appearance.	The	length	required	for	each	
to work on the first paragraph describing the          paragraph is up to the teacher, but it may be
hidden messages, and the other two students            anywhere from five to fifteen sentences. Stu-
do the same with the second paragraph cri-             dent subgroups may work on their paragraphs
tiquing	 the	 hidden	 messages.	 Then	 all	 four	      and the Adbuster simultaneously, or they may
members of the group work together to out-             choose to work on the Adbuster after they
line the Adbuster. —                                   complete the paragraphs. When they write
    To assist, the teacher can give each sub-          the paragraphs, the students should use all the
group an outline worksheet for an academic             work they have done up to this point (freewrit-
paragraph. Outline worksheets are easy to              ing, brainstorming, and outlining) to help
create	 and	 only	 require	 spaces	 for	 the	 topic	   them to create their first draft. This first draft
sentence, supporting details, and the conclud-         can either be handwritten or typed, but it must
ing sentence in its simplest form. The teacher         be neat so that they will be able to use it during
can create a worksheet that is laid out in the         the upcoming peer review activity. Since the
same format as the target writing, but with            Adbuster may take a while to put together, they
headings denoting each important section and           may be given time to finish it outside of class. —
a certain amount of space below each one for               When the subgroups finish the first draft,
the students to fill in their ideas. —                 they can begin the peer review process by
    For the Adbuster, the students can first           exchanging paragraphs within their groups
decide whether they will “bust” the assump-            and completing a peer review worksheet. This


E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m   |   Number     4    2008                                 7
worksheet should contain several open-ended               classmates on the final day of the lesson. The
    questions	 about	 their	 groupmates’	 paragraph	          teacher should tell the groups what will be
    that	require	them	to	read	it	closely	and	think	           expected of them. —
    critically about both its structure and content.
    Example	questions	might	be:	—                             Step 8: Class presentation and final draft —

       •	 How	 well	 do	 the	 paragraph’s	 support-               When students get back their second
          ing details follow the topic established            drafts, time should be spent during class to
          by the first sentence? —                            allow the groups to look over the teacher’s
       •	 Are	there	any	details	that	do	not	belong?	          comments	 and	 ask	 questions	 about	 them.	
          If so, what are they? Why don’t they                Then, students can create their final drafts. —
          belong? —                                               On the final day of the lesson, groups will
                                                              give a 10- to 15-minute presentation of their
        Students should then write comments that              work to their classmates and the teacher. In
    they believe will help their groupmates write a
                                                              this presentation, they will (1) briefly share
    better second draft. It is always best for a teach-
                                                              and describe their original advertisement,
    er to prepare worksheets designed for his or her
                                                              (2) share the ideas in their paragraphs with the
    specific group of students, and various examples
                                                              class, (3) share and describe their Adbuster,
    can be found on the Internet. Since the ideas in
                                                              and	(4)	field	questions	from	their	classmates. —
    the second paragraph must “complement” or
                                                                  We	 suggest	 that	 the	 teacher	 require	 all	
    respond to the ideas in the first, it is expected
                                                              group members to speak. When they finish,
    that the subgroups will speak to one another
                                                              they will turn in not only the most recent
    and exchange ideas to agree on the main ideas
                                                              versions of their work, but also every previ-
    of each of their respective paragraphs. For more
                                                              ous draft. The paragraphs’ final drafts must
    information	 on	 the	 techniques	 and	 effective-
                                                              be typed and must conform to the standards
    ness of peer assessment, see Mendonça and
    Johnson (1994) and Bartels (2003). —                      of style the students will be expected to use
        A variation of this activity can involve              in their later studies. In addition to class pre-
    groups sharing their first drafts with other              sentations, students can share their work with
    groups, rather than simply exchanging within              other classes at their school through exhibits or
    their own groups. This may give students                  school-wide presentations and at gatherings of
    more ideas on ways they can improve their                 parents or other members of the community. —
    writing and also provide a fresh perspective on
                                                              Step 9: Teacher assessment —
    their own work. —
                                                                   Because this is a writing lesson, the teacher
    Step 7: Second draft and final Adbuster —                 will evaluate the groups primarily on their
        Students write a second draft of the two              work in the paragraphs’ final drafts. But the
    paragraphs and make improvements based                    teacher may also assess students’ progression
    on comments they received from their group                through the various drafts, their class presen-
    members. Upon completion of this step, the                tation, and the clarity of ideas represented in
    teacher should collect all the work done up to            the Adbuster. After delivering the final assess-
    this point by all groups and provide specific             ment, the teacher can also schedule individual
    feedback to help students create better final             group conferences to discuss the assessment
    drafts. This work includes all drafts of para-            in	 more	 detail	 and	 to	 answer	 any	 questions	
    graphs, worksheets, and the advertisement.                students may have. —
    Since it has been suggested that written feed-                 In a conference setting, the teacher can pro-
    back in the form of explicit language error cor-          vide suggestions for further improvement and
    rection may not be effective and, in fact, may            also discuss the effectiveness of formative feed-
    have a negative effect on a student’s accuracy            back provided both by the teacher and by their
    (Truscott 2007), it may be most helpful to sup-           peers while students were working on their
    ply most comments on structure and content. —             project. How can students better take advan-
        While the groups wait for the teacher to              tage of this kind of feedback? What strategies
    return their drafts, they can finish working              can students employ to correct mistakes made
    on the Adbuster and begin drafting an out-                in planning and implementation while they are
    line of the presentation they will give to their          still in the process of creating their work?


8                              2008       Number          4   |    E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m
Finally, the teacher can post the groups’          tion that shapes their values, assumptions,
work on the classroom walls and later publish          and attitudes. In addition, many students
it in a class binder that can be used to inspire       need instruction in university-level academic
and inform future students. —                          writing,	 which	 requires	 analytical	 thinking	
                                                       skills. Since advertisements are of interest
Step 10: Peer and self assessment —                    to college-age students, and since research
    In addition to assessment from the teacher,        has consistently shown that meaningful task-
the groups can also receive feedback from              based instruction is one of the best methods
their peers. This can be done in the form of           for improving students’ language proficiency,
anonymous peer assessment worksheets that              the use of advertisements and Adbusters in a
their classmates fill out during and after each        process-centered writing lesson is a worthwhile
presentation and give to the groups once               endeavor. Such an approach provides students
all presentations are completed. The teacher           not only with greater motivation to write and
may determine the exact nature of this assess-         to engage their creativity, but it also leads them
ment, but it would work best if students               toward a higher awareness of contemporary
are asked to comment on their classmates’              social, global, and cultural movements. —
clarity of ideas and creativity and diligence
of approach in relation to the description of          References —
their advertisement’s hidden message and the           Aufderheide, P., ed. 1993. Media literacy: A report
extent to which they expose their advertise-              of the national leadership conference on media
ment’s untruths and unspoken realities in                 literacy. Washington, DC: Aspen Institute. —
                                                       Badger, R., and G. White. 2000. A process genre
their second paragraph and Adbuster. Like                 approach to teaching writing. ELT Journal 54
the peer reviews of the paragraphs’ first drafts,         (2): 153–60. —
this assessment should include open-ended              Bartels, N. 2003. Written peer response in L2 writ-
questions	that	either	allow	for	or	require	more	          ing. English Teaching Forum 41 (1): 34–37. —
than a few words from the evaluator. —                 Flores-Koulish, S. A. 2005. Teacher education for
    The teacher may also provide the students             critical consumption of mass media and popular
                                                          culture. New York: RoutledgeFalmer. —
with self-assessment worksheets. These work-           Mendonça, C. O., and K. E. Johnson. 1994. Peer
sheets	 can	 include	 questions	 about	 how	 well	        review negotiations: Revision activities in ESL
the students feel they completed each step                writing instruction. TESOL Quarterly 28 (4):
of the process, how they felt about working               745–69. —
on their particular portion of the project,            Media Education Foundation. 2005. Deconstructing
                                                          an advertisement. www.mediaed.org/handouts/
and if they would choose a different role if
                                                          pdfs/DeconstructinganAd.pdf. —
or when they complete a similar project. The           Schwarz, G., and Brown, P. U., eds. 2005. Media
worksheet can also ask students to comment                literacy: Transforming curriculum and teaching.
on which steps and segments of the project                Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of
they found most difficult or easy and why, and            Education 104 (1), vi–294. —
how they felt about working in their group             Truscott, J. 2007. The effect of error correction on
                                                          learners’ ability to write accurately. Journal of
and subgroup. And, of course, the worksheet               Second Language Writing 16 (4): 255–72. —
can ask students to provide an honest overall
assessment of their group’s final product. The
                                                       AnnA GriGoryAn holds a Masters in TESOL
peer and self assessments should not affect            from Azusa Pacific University in California.
students’ formal grades. —                             From 2006 to 2008, she served as an
                                                       English Language Fellow in Shymkent,
Conclusion —
                                                       Kazakhstan. She currently works at
   Because of the nature of our ever-changing          Özyegin University in Istanbul. —
                                                            ˘
and ever-shrinking world and the increasing
                                                       John MArk kinG is an instructor in the
reach of American popular culture across the           English as a Second Language program
globe, students of English as a foreign language       at Northern Virginia Community College in
need more than simple language instruction.            Alexandria, Virginia. In 2005 and 2006, he
Indeed, these students need the critical think-        was an English Language Fellow in
ing skills necessary to process and evaluate           Ashgabat, Turkmenistan, where he was an
a constant barrage of multimedia informa-              EFL teacher and teacher trainer.



E   n g l i s h   TE   a c h i n g   F   o r u m   |   Number      4     2008                                 9

More Related Content

What's hot

Presentation1 literacies
Presentation1  literaciesPresentation1  literacies
Presentation1 literaciesddraper
 
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing R...
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing  R...Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing  R...
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing R...Watcharapol Wiboolyasarin
 
What is Learning in a participatory culture?
What is Learning in a participatory culture?What is Learning in a participatory culture?
What is Learning in a participatory culture?The Wolfsonian-FIU
 
2009 Horizon Report K12
2009 Horizon Report K122009 Horizon Report K12
2009 Horizon Report K12Chris Arias
 
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
Week 2   ruth - 2014-15Week 2   ruth - 2014-15
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15rmcquirter
 
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09Terry Anderson
 
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24The Wolfsonian-FIU
 
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information Renee Hobbs
 
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270Pamela Jory
 
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608Erin Reilly
 
21 century skills for students and teachers
21 century skills for students and teachers21 century skills for students and teachers
21 century skills for students and teacherssyasyifa
 
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized Course
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized CourseMiddle Earth 12 Board Authorized Course
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized Coursethielmann
 

What's hot (15)

Presentation1 literacies
Presentation1  literaciesPresentation1  literacies
Presentation1 literacies
 
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing R...
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing  R...Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing  R...
Blended Instructional Model Based on Participatory Communication withUsing R...
 
What is Learning in a participatory culture?
What is Learning in a participatory culture?What is Learning in a participatory culture?
What is Learning in a participatory culture?
 
Inglés liberador
Inglés liberadorInglés liberador
Inglés liberador
 
2009 Horizon Report K12
2009 Horizon Report K122009 Horizon Report K12
2009 Horizon Report K12
 
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
Week 2   ruth - 2014-15Week 2   ruth - 2014-15
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
 
Introduction.
Introduction. Introduction.
Introduction.
 
B10 sivagouri
B10 sivagouriB10 sivagouri
B10 sivagouri
 
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09
Connectivist And Connected Knowledge CCK09
 
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24
Reimagining the museum convening final report 3.24
 
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information
Mapping the Literacies: Media, News, Information
 
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270
Multiliteracy powerpoint assignment 1 edx3270
 
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608
Journalism & the New Media Literacies 101608
 
21 century skills for students and teachers
21 century skills for students and teachers21 century skills for students and teachers
21 century skills for students and teachers
 
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized Course
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized CourseMiddle Earth 12 Board Authorized Course
Middle Earth 12 Board Authorized Course
 

Similar to Tarn 3

What The Research Says, 2007
What The Research Says, 2007What The Research Says, 2007
What The Research Says, 2007Renee Hobbs
 
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
Week 2   ruth - 2014-15Week 2   ruth - 2014-15
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15rmcquirter
 
The 21st Century Learning Part 2
The 21st Century Learning Part 2The 21st Century Learning Part 2
The 21st Century Learning Part 2guest7a7987
 
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State College
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State CollegeEssay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State College
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State CollegeAmanda Anderson
 
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learning
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance LearningThe Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learning
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learningjudykim
 
Rethinking literacy education in new times reinildes
Rethinking literacy education in new times   reinildesRethinking literacy education in new times   reinildes
Rethinking literacy education in new times reinildesbruna_fontoura
 
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of Nursing
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of NursingSample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of Nursing
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of NursingMegan Sanchez
 
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docx
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docxCURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docx
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docxdonnabelleisidro
 
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docx
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docxInformation is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docx
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docxdoylymaura
 
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarrated
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarratedMaking local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarrated
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarratedLeslie Cook
 
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptx
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptxIntegrating 4 c's into teaching.pptx
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptxJoe Viloria
 
Pwr91 syllabus
Pwr91 syllabusPwr91 syllabus
Pwr91 syllabusPWR91
 
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdf
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdfThe Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdf
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdfJennifer Smith
 
Play doc 01
Play doc 01Play doc 01
Play doc 01amandafo
 
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdf
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdfjessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdf
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdfAbegailLopez9
 
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And Assessment
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And AssessmentAn Overview Of Writing Instruction And Assessment
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And AssessmentSteven Wallach
 
Global medialiteracy pt 1
Global medialiteracy pt 1Global medialiteracy pt 1
Global medialiteracy pt 1Melda Yildiz
 

Similar to Tarn 3 (20)

What The Research Says, 2007
What The Research Says, 2007What The Research Says, 2007
What The Research Says, 2007
 
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
Week 2   ruth - 2014-15Week 2   ruth - 2014-15
Week 2 ruth - 2014-15
 
The 21st Century Learning Part 2
The 21st Century Learning Part 2The 21st Century Learning Part 2
The 21st Century Learning Part 2
 
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State College
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State CollegeEssay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State College
Essay On Why Is Education Important. Zane State College
 
NERA2011
NERA2011NERA2011
NERA2011
 
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learning
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance LearningThe Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learning
The Use Of Digital Video And Media To Enhance Learning
 
Rethinking literacy education in new times reinildes
Rethinking literacy education in new times   reinildesRethinking literacy education in new times   reinildes
Rethinking literacy education in new times reinildes
 
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of Nursing
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of NursingSample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of Nursing
Sample Of Essay About Education. Washington Health System School of Nursing
 
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docx
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docxCURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docx
CURRICULUM-MAP-ENGLISH-10-SY-2023-2024.docx
 
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docx
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docxInformation is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docx
Information is used in various ways, including as a tool to gain sup.docx
 
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarrated
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarratedMaking local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarrated
Making local and_global_connections_through_multimodal_compositionnarrated
 
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptx
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptxIntegrating 4 c's into teaching.pptx
Integrating 4 c's into teaching.pptx
 
Pwr91 syllabus
Pwr91 syllabusPwr91 syllabus
Pwr91 syllabus
 
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdf
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdfThe Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdf
The Importance Of Education Essay Writing.pdf
 
Play doc 01
Play doc 01Play doc 01
Play doc 01
 
Shall We Play?
Shall We Play?Shall We Play?
Shall We Play?
 
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdf
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdfjessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdf
jessa jhgukyfuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuyfkuy.pdf
 
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And Assessment
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And AssessmentAn Overview Of Writing Instruction And Assessment
An Overview Of Writing Instruction And Assessment
 
Global medialiteracy pt 1
Global medialiteracy pt 1Global medialiteracy pt 1
Global medialiteracy pt 1
 
_Measures-To-Improve-Teacher's-Competence
_Measures-To-Improve-Teacher's-Competence_Measures-To-Improve-Teacher's-Competence
_Measures-To-Improve-Teacher's-Competence
 

Recently uploaded

Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...EduSkills OECD
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformChameera Dedduwage
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3JemimahLaneBuaron
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...Marc Dusseiller Dusjagr
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfciinovamais
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactPECB
 
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991RKavithamani
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Educationpboyjonauth
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxNirmalaLoungPoorunde1
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphThiyagu K
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeThiyagu K
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxiammrhaywood
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxVS Mahajan Coaching Centre
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfchloefrazer622
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfsanyamsingh5019
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxpboyjonauth
 
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...RKavithamani
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
Presentation by Andreas Schleicher Tackling the School Absenteeism Crisis 30 ...
 
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy ReformA Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
A Critique of the Proposed National Education Policy Reform
 
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
Q4-W6-Restating Informational Text Grade 3
 
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
“Oh GOSH! Reflecting on Hackteria's Collaborative Practices in a Global Do-It...
 
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdfActivity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
Activity 01 - Artificial Culture (1).pdf
 
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global ImpactBeyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
Beyond the EU: DORA and NIS 2 Directive's Global Impact
 
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
Industrial Policy - 1948, 1956, 1973, 1977, 1980, 1991
 
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSDStaff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
Staff of Color (SOC) Retention Efforts DDSD
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: The Basics of Prompt Design"
 
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher EducationIntroduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
Introduction to ArtificiaI Intelligence in Higher Education
 
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptxEmployee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
Employee wellbeing at the workplace.pptx
 
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot GraphZ Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
Z Score,T Score, Percential Rank and Box Plot Graph
 
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and ModeMeasures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
Measures of Central Tendency: Mean, Median and Mode
 
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptxSOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
SOCIAL AND HISTORICAL CONTEXT - LFTVD.pptx
 
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
Mattingly "AI & Prompt Design: Structured Data, Assistants, & RAG"
 
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptxOrganic Name Reactions  for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
Organic Name Reactions for the students and aspirants of Chemistry12th.pptx
 
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdfArihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
Arihant handbook biology for class 11 .pdf
 
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdfSanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
Sanyam Choudhary Chemistry practical.pdf
 
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptxIntroduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
Introduction to AI in Higher Education_draft.pptx
 
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...
Privatization and Disinvestment - Meaning, Objectives, Advantages and Disadva...
 

Tarn 3

  • 1. An n a G r igo r y an an d Joh n M a rk Ki ng— Tu r k Ey and uni TEd sT a T E s — Adbusting: Critical Media Literacy in a Multi-Skills Academic Writing Lesson — media literacy is a field often used to describe a more rigor- that began as a grassroots ous evaluation of the mass media’s movement among educa- relationship to democracy, power, and tors concerned with the growing gap social justice. As a classroom topic, between popular culture, produced critical media literacy encourages dis- by corporations, and the literacy con- cussions about how the media con- tent in today’s schools (Flores-Koulish ceptualize race, class, and gender, and 2005). Today, many educators rec- how it promotes certain social values ognize the pedagogical importance through its definitions of such con- of training students to develop an cepts as beauty, prestige, family, love, awareness of how and why adver- success, sex, freedom, and consumer- tisements and other media messages ism, among others. Critical media often misrepresent and manipulate the analysis allows students to access, facts. Consequently, teachers can find analyze, and evaluate popular texts many resources on how to develop and in terms of their cultural, political, implement a media literacy curricu- ideological, and socioeconomic rami- lum (Schwarz and Brown 2005). — fications. Because these are impor- According to Aufderheide (1993, tant and relevant issues for students 1), a media literate individual “can and teachers, incorporating critical decode, evaluate, analyze and produce media analysis into the second lan- both print and electronic media.” Nev- guage classroom is an excellent way to ertheless, there are different degrees engage students’ skills in communica- of media literacy. Many analyses are tion and higher-level thinking. — merely descriptive and do not exam- This article will discuss the ratio- ine with any depth how various media nale for incorporating critical media affect society and individuals; there- analysis into the second language fore, the term critical media literacy is classroom and will describe a method 2 2008 N u m b e r 4 | E n g l i s h T E a c h i n g F o r u m
  • 2. to combine it with a university level writ- • introduces students to codes and con- ing lesson based on the process-centered ventions of the target culture and acti- approach in which students plan, revise, and vates their background knowledge; — produce a written text with a special focus on • offers the possibility for portfolios and the intended audience. In this writing lesson other forms of alternative assessment. — students will also produce an Adbuster, which These aspects of communicative language is a parody of a commercial message. The pri- teaching are evident in the following ten-step mary goals of the lesson are to promote critical lesson plan. — thinking and to develop formal and informal language skills through a variety of individual An integrated media literacy lesson plan — and group-based, task-oriented activities. — This lesson plan is designed for a col- Why integrate media literacy and lege or university setting and is based on the academic writing? — process genre approach in which students not only plan and revise two texts, but also meet There are many theoretical and practical certain rhetorical and structural requirements reasons to combine critical media literacy with based on the texts’ audience (Badger and a modern academic writing lesson. Advertise- White 2000). In addition, this lesson will ments and other media messages are available require students to plan and revise a piece of virtually everywhere, and giving language Adbuster art that will accompany the written learners the opportunity to evaluate them and texts. As students become more keenly aware create their own written texts allows students of the role of their target audience, they learn to develop their critical thinking and commu- how to modify language to communicate nication skills. Because of the interesting and through various media and to establish a relevant nature of the subject matter, this type continuity of ideas between two very different of task-based lesson creates a student-centered types of expression—formal writing and art. — environment that is the foundation of com- municative language teaching. For example, a What is an Adbuster? — media literacy academic writing project: — To begin, it is important for teachers and • uses authentic materials to contextual- students to be familiar with an Adbuster, which ize language, appeal to student inter- is a form of media that looks like an adver- ests, and increase their motivation; — tisement but actually opposes the values and • requires real language for meaningful assumptions presented by a corporation through communication, which develops stu- its advertising campaigns (examples of Adbuster dents’ cognitive and academic strategies ads can be found at the following website: in multiple skills;— http://adbusters.org/spoofads/index.php). — • inspires small groups to create mean- Advertisements sell not only products, but ingful written drafts and quality peer also ideas. For instance, an advertisement for review and revision; — a diet pill is not only selling the actual pill, • creates a positive social and affective but also the idea that being thin is important, working environment; — perhaps more important than being healthy. • permits teachers to include various Advertisements for diet products often target activities that appeal to virtually any women by showing a young, attractive woman kind of learning style; — smiling and happy because she has lost weight. • provides a large amount of language An Adbuster for such an advertisement could input and output so students learn to visually oppose the message of taking the use effective communication strategies; actual pill by showing the potentially nega- • helps student evaluate and respond to tive side effects, such as osteoporosis, depres- arguments, which develops their ana- sion, or organ damage. The Adbuster could lytical skills; — also oppose the ideas or assumptions in the • allows for the integration of skills advertisement by challenging the definition through a variety of linguistic situations of beauty or success as being extremely thin. that require the use of both formal and The Adbuster could also offer a definition of informal English; — beauty, happiness, and success not in terms of E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m | Number 4 2008 3
  • 3. outward appearance, but rather as connected Adbusters that showed the potentially danger- to one’s overall health and well-being. — ous effects of dieting. Many also redefined the Most advertisements have a central mes- notion of beauty offered by popular women’s sage: If you buy this product, then you will magazines as inner beauty, health, and overall be “thin,” “rich,” “successful,” or “fit,” and well-being rather than looking “perfect” or therefore “happy” and “fulfilled.” Usually, the extremely thin. Hence, the assignment allows central message can be ascertained by reading students to critically understand the very the slogan and understanding the story being forces that shape their values, attitudes, and told through the visual image. However, in assumptions—their identities. — addition to the central message tied to the product, advertisers also create and reinforce Ten steps of the media literacy lesson plan — The primary goals of the lesson are to pro- our assumptions of what it means to be a mote critical thinking and to develop formal beautiful, rich, successful man or woman. and informal language skills through a variety Advertisers also offer us definitions of sexual- of individual and group-based, task-oriented ity, happiness, family, love, health, freedom, activities. In these activities, students will col- and other values that guide our behavior. We laborate with their groupmates to prepare a may not buy a diet pill or a luxury car, but project that they will present to their peers. we may nevertheless absorb the idea that “you Unlike products of the average academic writ- can never be too rich or too thin.” Because ing lesson, the texts produced here will be done we are surrounded by advertisements, which as a group, not individually. This can at first are an integral part of our culture, we are like create some difficulty for the teacher who is fish in an aquarium, unaware that we live in trying to maintain order in the class and ensure water because we consider it a natural part of that all students contribute equally to the our existence. In requiring students to create assignment. However, providing varied options Adbusters, we are not teaching them simply to to students for the creation of meaningful lan- resist advertisements. We are enhancing their guage at different stages of the lesson appeals to critical thinking skills by making them aware many different learning styles. As a result, such of how culture is created through a set of a lesson may not be best used to determine a assumptions or stories told over and again. — student’s placement or readiness to advance to An Adbuster can be made for virtually the next level, but it is, nonetheless, designed to any advertisement. For this lesson students improve a student’s overall proficiency in Eng- must choose an advertisement, and they may lish. This is, of course, our ultimate goal. — initially seem frustrated or confused about First, students will create one paragraph that which advertisement to choose so that making examines the assumptions and hidden mes- an Adbuster will be easy. However, we tell our sages in a particular magazine advertisement. students to choose advertisements from maga- A second paragraph will critically evaluate zines that they read or that appeal to their those assumptions. In addition to these para- interests. Thus, one group of male students graphs, each group will produce an Adbuster made an Adbuster for videogames in which as a visual companion to their writing. The they explored the effects of violent video ten steps detailed in the following lesson are games on children. Their Adbuster contained merely suggestions. Throughout the lesson, pictures of children holding video game guns, the teacher must help his or her students to of children spending hours in front of televi- practice the writing process used by successful sion, and scenes of blood and violence from students and professionals in the real world. video games that were very realistic. Stu- Before beginning these steps, teachers should dents discussed the effects of video games on divide students into groups of three or four. children’s identity formation and the effects of television violence on society in general. Step 1: Focused freewriting — Another student who practices weightlifting To begin, the teacher tells the students and was interested in bodybuilding as a hobby they are going to look at an advertisement completed an Adbuster about the negative for a commercial product out of a popular effects of using steroids to build muscles. American magazine. The teacher then gives Many girls who read fashion magazines did each group a different advertisement from a 4 2008 Number 4 | E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m
  • 4. magazine. Teachers may also allow students to In this step, the teacher also introduces bring magazines that they read at home and students to a variety of sample Adbusters have each group select one advertisement to produced by previous classes to provide them analyze in the classroom. — with clear examples of the designs they will be Then, the teacher tells the students to get expected to complete. If teachers do not have out a sheet of paper and a pen or pencil and sample Adbusters or paragraphs from previous to begin freewriting, which is a pre-writing classes, they may choose to create their own to exercise in which students write for a speci- use until quality student-produced materials fied time on a specific topic without stopping are available. Sample Adbusters, however, may and without making corrections. Typically, be found at the aforementioned website. — students keep their freewriting assignments Step 3: Understand, analyze, and and refer to them during later stages of the evaluate—find the hidden messages — writing process in order to build on and fur- ther refine their ideas. In this lesson students The teacher should explain that many are encouraged to write nonstop about their advertisements sell not only products, but advertisement for five to ten minutes without also ideas, by promoting certain values, ste- making corrections or using a dictionary. reotypes, and assumptions. The students will They are free to write whatever they want, as explore these “hidden messages” using a work- long as it is in response to whatever they see sheet entitled Deconstructing an Advertisement in the ad. If they do not know what to write, that can be found online from the Media the teacher should tell them to write “I don’t Education Foundation (2005). Using this know what to write.” During this exercise, the worksheet, the students will complete the fol- teacher should monitor the students closely to lowing tasks: — ensure that they follow the directions. — 1. Describe the codes and conventions in When time is up, the teacher tells the their advertisement — groups to share what they have written with 2. Determine the purpose of their adver- other members of their groups. They do not tisement — need to read their freewriting aloud; they only 3. Determine the assumptions their adver- need to summarize their reaction to the adver- tisement makes — tisement. This should take no more than ten 4. Determine possible consequences of minutes, and while the students are talking, their advertisement — the teacher should walk around the room to The students work together to complete monitor their progress. — these four tasks, and each member in the group will be responsible for writing down Step 2: Sample paragraphs and and reporting one of them to the rest of Adbusters — the class. Thus, each member completes a The teacher can now help students to bet- writing and speaking task as a part of this ter understand the genre within which they portion of the activity. If members within will be working to create their two paragraphs, a group disagree with one another on their which can be done by showing students one evaluation of the advertisement, the teacher or more examples of successful writing by can remind them that it is a good exercise in students in previous classes. Showing sample critical thinking to argue a point of view that paragraphs is useful because the academic you do not necessarily agree with. Also, if two writing style, which uses one controlling idea members disagree, they can both share their for a paragraph and a topic sentence at or near different views with the class, thus setting up the beginning, is a genre whose mastery will the opportunity for conversation, debate, and certainly help students to succeed in school. — multiple interpretations. — Together with the teacher, students analyze As each group shares their advertisements sample paragraphs that are very similar to and reports their four-point analysis, the other what they will be asked to produce and dis- students listen and express their agreement or cover the paragraphs’ structure on their own. disagreement with the reporting group’s inter- The teacher can help, of course, and answer pretations. For example, a group may report any questions that come up. — that they found that an advertisement for ciga- E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m | Number 4 2008 5
  • 5. rettes draws a connection between “freedom” • The wide open horizon in front of the or “independence” and smoking by pointing yacht suggests that the people portrayed out that the advertisement shows an image of are “free.” — young men and women sailing on a yacht while • The fact that the people are dressed smoking cigarettes. Then, the group can evalu- nicely, are attractive, and are on a yacht ate the validity of this connection: Is smoking rather than a small boat suggests that at all connected to a lifestyle of the rich and they are rich and financially indepen- does it really increase your enjoyment of life? dent, so their freedom is also financial Finally, the group will determine the possible freedom. — long- and short-term consequences of believing • The social atmosphere on the yacht the messages presented in the advertisement. suggests that cigarettes are a good addi- Is the advertisement effective? Will the target tion to “happy” social occasions when audience be persuaded to buy the product? — you are having a good time with friends If a group decides that their advertisement and enjoying a sense of freedom. — has no hidden messages, the teacher can ask Then, students brainstorm for their second them additional guided questions about the paragraph, which will critique the central advertisement based on the teacher’s own message as well as the hidden messages of analysis. In addition, if students offer an their advertisement. To have the critical skills interpretation that is not obvious or may not necessary to develop this second paragraph, it be justifiable, the teacher should not be afraid is important that students have understood to ask them why they made their decision and and completed the Deconstructing an Adver- how they came to it. For instance, if a student tisement worksheet so they can determine the says a woman in the picture looks “healthy,” advertisement’s assumptions and its possible and the connection to health is not obvious, consequences. As a result, students may write the teacher can say: “What is it in the picture the following: — that makes you think of health?” or “What is it about her that makes her look healthy?” — • The ad falsely connects enjoying time with your friends to smoking. — Step 4: Brainstorming — • Showing attractive, young people hides Working together, each group member the fact that smoking causes the yel- writes the central message of the advertise- lowing of teeth, poor skin health, and ment they analyzed in step three. Usually, the smoking-related diseases such as lung central message insinuates something like: cancer and emphysema. — “If you buy this product, then you will be • The ad falsely connects smoking with more ‘attractive,’ or ‘slim,’ or ‘free,’ and, as a personal and financial freedom— result, happier.” This central message is usu- smoking cannot make you richer or ally found in the slogan or in the dominant more free. — images and texts within the ad. — • The ad does not show that because Next, students locate their advertisement’s smoking cigarettes creates a physical hidden messages or assumptions and conduct addiction to nicotine, it actually makes a group brainstorming exercise about them. you less free. — Students can refer to answers they came up • The ad does not show that rather than with when completing the four tasks from the leading to freedom and enjoyment of Deconstructing an Advertisement worksheet in life, smoking can often lead to death. — Step 3. A graphic organizer word map would It is important for the teacher to be aware work well here, with both the central and hid- that many of the advertisements available den messages forming the center and all the evi- worldwide come from Western cultures, in dence students find for the existence of hidden many cases the United States. This creates messages displayed in word bubbles around the an opportunity for students to explore the center. For example, if the group believes that ways in which culture of origin is portrayed their advertisement promotes smoking as a way in advertising. Analyzing the assumptions a to achieve freedom and independence, they culture makes can create a great deal of mean- would list the following evidence: — ingful discussion in the classroom. 6 2008 Number 4 | E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m
  • 6. To take this further, the teacher can tions in the ad, or the use of the actual prod- encourage students to analyze their adver- uct. Then, they can determine the kinds of tisements based on the assumptions of their images they will use to express their ideas. native culture. Students may find that this The teacher may want to provide a worksheet can lead either to a deeper understanding the students can use to record these ideas. of an advertisement’s hidden messages or, The worksheet should require the students more likely, gross misinterpretation because to (1) write down the central messages of the of cultural differences. This can initiate a class advertisement, (2) make a list of assumptions discussion about the importance of knowing made by the advertisement, and (3) analyze one’s audience and of being aware that people the possible effects of using the product that of different backgrounds can interpret an are not revealed in the advertisement (e.g., individual message in many different ways. What is there about this product that the This knowledge and awareness is crucial to company selling it to you may not want you the development of academic writing skills. — to know? How does the main message com- Finally, the students decide on the theme pare to reality?). — of the Adbuster they will create. Using the The Deconstructing an Advertisement work- content of their paragraphs, they will design sheet (Media Education Foundation 2005) a visual representation of their academic writ- should have given the students the analytical ing. The teacher may remind the students that tools necessary to complete this stage of the an Adbuster may oppose either the purchase of activity. Once the students have made a list of the actual product, or the assumptions that the the central message, the assumptions, and the advertisement makes, or both. For instance, untold effects of using the product, they can students may make an Adbuster opposing begin considering which messages they will the purchase of a diet pill because it is unsafe. oppose in their Adbuster, or whether they will However, they may also simply make an choose to explore the negative side effects of Adbuster that defines beauty in terms of health using a product, such as the negative effects of rather than thinness. The choice is theirs. — smoking on health or the use of cars on the environment. — Step 5: Outlining and Adbuster design — In this step the students write detailed out- Step 6: First drafts and peer review — lines of their two paragraphs and then begin Once the outlines and basic Adbuster work on the Adbuster itself. Two students design are completed, the groups begin the from a group of four use their work from more detailed work of drafting their projects’ both the freewriting and brainstorming steps final appearance. The length required for each to work on the first paragraph describing the paragraph is up to the teacher, but it may be hidden messages, and the other two students anywhere from five to fifteen sentences. Stu- do the same with the second paragraph cri- dent subgroups may work on their paragraphs tiquing the hidden messages. Then all four and the Adbuster simultaneously, or they may members of the group work together to out- choose to work on the Adbuster after they line the Adbuster. — complete the paragraphs. When they write To assist, the teacher can give each sub- the paragraphs, the students should use all the group an outline worksheet for an academic work they have done up to this point (freewrit- paragraph. Outline worksheets are easy to ing, brainstorming, and outlining) to help create and only require spaces for the topic them to create their first draft. This first draft sentence, supporting details, and the conclud- can either be handwritten or typed, but it must ing sentence in its simplest form. The teacher be neat so that they will be able to use it during can create a worksheet that is laid out in the the upcoming peer review activity. Since the same format as the target writing, but with Adbuster may take a while to put together, they headings denoting each important section and may be given time to finish it outside of class. — a certain amount of space below each one for When the subgroups finish the first draft, the students to fill in their ideas. — they can begin the peer review process by For the Adbuster, the students can first exchanging paragraphs within their groups decide whether they will “bust” the assump- and completing a peer review worksheet. This E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m | Number 4 2008 7
  • 7. worksheet should contain several open-ended classmates on the final day of the lesson. The questions about their groupmates’ paragraph teacher should tell the groups what will be that require them to read it closely and think expected of them. — critically about both its structure and content. Example questions might be: — Step 8: Class presentation and final draft — • How well do the paragraph’s support- When students get back their second ing details follow the topic established drafts, time should be spent during class to by the first sentence? — allow the groups to look over the teacher’s • Are there any details that do not belong? comments and ask questions about them. If so, what are they? Why don’t they Then, students can create their final drafts. — belong? — On the final day of the lesson, groups will give a 10- to 15-minute presentation of their Students should then write comments that work to their classmates and the teacher. In they believe will help their groupmates write a this presentation, they will (1) briefly share better second draft. It is always best for a teach- and describe their original advertisement, er to prepare worksheets designed for his or her (2) share the ideas in their paragraphs with the specific group of students, and various examples class, (3) share and describe their Adbuster, can be found on the Internet. Since the ideas in and (4) field questions from their classmates. — the second paragraph must “complement” or We suggest that the teacher require all respond to the ideas in the first, it is expected group members to speak. When they finish, that the subgroups will speak to one another they will turn in not only the most recent and exchange ideas to agree on the main ideas versions of their work, but also every previ- of each of their respective paragraphs. For more ous draft. The paragraphs’ final drafts must information on the techniques and effective- be typed and must conform to the standards ness of peer assessment, see Mendonça and Johnson (1994) and Bartels (2003). — of style the students will be expected to use A variation of this activity can involve in their later studies. In addition to class pre- groups sharing their first drafts with other sentations, students can share their work with groups, rather than simply exchanging within other classes at their school through exhibits or their own groups. This may give students school-wide presentations and at gatherings of more ideas on ways they can improve their parents or other members of the community. — writing and also provide a fresh perspective on Step 9: Teacher assessment — their own work. — Because this is a writing lesson, the teacher Step 7: Second draft and final Adbuster — will evaluate the groups primarily on their Students write a second draft of the two work in the paragraphs’ final drafts. But the paragraphs and make improvements based teacher may also assess students’ progression on comments they received from their group through the various drafts, their class presen- members. Upon completion of this step, the tation, and the clarity of ideas represented in teacher should collect all the work done up to the Adbuster. After delivering the final assess- this point by all groups and provide specific ment, the teacher can also schedule individual feedback to help students create better final group conferences to discuss the assessment drafts. This work includes all drafts of para- in more detail and to answer any questions graphs, worksheets, and the advertisement. students may have. — Since it has been suggested that written feed- In a conference setting, the teacher can pro- back in the form of explicit language error cor- vide suggestions for further improvement and rection may not be effective and, in fact, may also discuss the effectiveness of formative feed- have a negative effect on a student’s accuracy back provided both by the teacher and by their (Truscott 2007), it may be most helpful to sup- peers while students were working on their ply most comments on structure and content. — project. How can students better take advan- While the groups wait for the teacher to tage of this kind of feedback? What strategies return their drafts, they can finish working can students employ to correct mistakes made on the Adbuster and begin drafting an out- in planning and implementation while they are line of the presentation they will give to their still in the process of creating their work? 8 2008 Number 4 | E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m
  • 8. Finally, the teacher can post the groups’ tion that shapes their values, assumptions, work on the classroom walls and later publish and attitudes. In addition, many students it in a class binder that can be used to inspire need instruction in university-level academic and inform future students. — writing, which requires analytical thinking skills. Since advertisements are of interest Step 10: Peer and self assessment — to college-age students, and since research In addition to assessment from the teacher, has consistently shown that meaningful task- the groups can also receive feedback from based instruction is one of the best methods their peers. This can be done in the form of for improving students’ language proficiency, anonymous peer assessment worksheets that the use of advertisements and Adbusters in a their classmates fill out during and after each process-centered writing lesson is a worthwhile presentation and give to the groups once endeavor. Such an approach provides students all presentations are completed. The teacher not only with greater motivation to write and may determine the exact nature of this assess- to engage their creativity, but it also leads them ment, but it would work best if students toward a higher awareness of contemporary are asked to comment on their classmates’ social, global, and cultural movements. — clarity of ideas and creativity and diligence of approach in relation to the description of References — their advertisement’s hidden message and the Aufderheide, P., ed. 1993. Media literacy: A report extent to which they expose their advertise- of the national leadership conference on media ment’s untruths and unspoken realities in literacy. Washington, DC: Aspen Institute. — Badger, R., and G. White. 2000. A process genre their second paragraph and Adbuster. Like approach to teaching writing. ELT Journal 54 the peer reviews of the paragraphs’ first drafts, (2): 153–60. — this assessment should include open-ended Bartels, N. 2003. Written peer response in L2 writ- questions that either allow for or require more ing. English Teaching Forum 41 (1): 34–37. — than a few words from the evaluator. — Flores-Koulish, S. A. 2005. Teacher education for The teacher may also provide the students critical consumption of mass media and popular culture. New York: RoutledgeFalmer. — with self-assessment worksheets. These work- Mendonça, C. O., and K. E. Johnson. 1994. Peer sheets can include questions about how well review negotiations: Revision activities in ESL the students feel they completed each step writing instruction. TESOL Quarterly 28 (4): of the process, how they felt about working 745–69. — on their particular portion of the project, Media Education Foundation. 2005. Deconstructing an advertisement. www.mediaed.org/handouts/ and if they would choose a different role if pdfs/DeconstructinganAd.pdf. — or when they complete a similar project. The Schwarz, G., and Brown, P. U., eds. 2005. Media worksheet can also ask students to comment literacy: Transforming curriculum and teaching. on which steps and segments of the project Yearbook of the National Society for the Study of they found most difficult or easy and why, and Education 104 (1), vi–294. — how they felt about working in their group Truscott, J. 2007. The effect of error correction on learners’ ability to write accurately. Journal of and subgroup. And, of course, the worksheet Second Language Writing 16 (4): 255–72. — can ask students to provide an honest overall assessment of their group’s final product. The AnnA GriGoryAn holds a Masters in TESOL peer and self assessments should not affect from Azusa Pacific University in California. students’ formal grades. — From 2006 to 2008, she served as an English Language Fellow in Shymkent, Conclusion — Kazakhstan. She currently works at Because of the nature of our ever-changing Özyegin University in Istanbul. — ˘ and ever-shrinking world and the increasing John MArk kinG is an instructor in the reach of American popular culture across the English as a Second Language program globe, students of English as a foreign language at Northern Virginia Community College in need more than simple language instruction. Alexandria, Virginia. In 2005 and 2006, he Indeed, these students need the critical think- was an English Language Fellow in ing skills necessary to process and evaluate Ashgabat, Turkmenistan, where he was an a constant barrage of multimedia informa- EFL teacher and teacher trainer. E n g l i s h TE a c h i n g F o r u m | Number 4 2008 9