This document discusses evaluating digital humanities publications. It questions whether current quality indicators and peer review procedures for print publications can also evaluate digital products. It suggests that digital publications, which are interactive, multimedia, and interdisciplinary, may require alternative evaluation methods. The document then outlines various approaches to evaluating digital publications, such as peer review, bibliometrics, and collaborative assessment tools. It proposes constructing an ontology and knowledge organization system to help evaluate quality of digital humanities publications in Italy.
Publishing tips for Virtual Heritage articles and related issues (3D models), Cities Cultural Heritage and Digital Humanities, Turin Summer School 17 September 2018
See the WEBCAST as well!! mms://wmedia.it.su.se/SUB/NordLib/3.wmv
Presentation at Nordlib 2.0 in Stockholm, November 21th 2008
http://www.nordlib20.org/programme/
As informações digitais atuais estão sendo interligadas, cruzadas e indexadas de múltiplas maneiras por meio da Web global para que os artigos tenham maior visibilidade e alcance. A recente proliferação das API’s (interfaces de aplicativos) e redes sociais têm facilitado e aumentado ainda mais as possibilidades para os artigos. O foco desta apresentação são os principais produtos e serviços que ampliam o alcance e impacto dos artigos na Web.
Today’s digital information is being linked, cross-linked and indexed in a multitude of ways across the global Web to give articles greater visibility and reach. The recent proliferation of API’s (application interfaces) and social networks have further facilitated and expanded the possibilities for articles. This presentation will focus on the main products and services that extend the reach and impact of articles on the Web.
La información digital hoy día está siendo vinculada (linked), reticulada e indexada en una multitud de formas a través de la Web mundial para dar una mayor visibilidad y acceso a los artículos. La reciente proliferación de APIs (interfaces de aplicaciones) y las redes sociales han facilitado y ampliado aún más las posibilidades de los artículos. Esta presentación se centrará en los principales productos y servicios que amplían el alcance y el impacto de los artículos en la Web.
presented at "Assessing Contribution, Assessing Usage: Metrics in a New Context" NFAIS Virtual Conference, March 28, 2014 - http://nfais.org/event?eventID=542
Keynote presentation at the Lita Forum, Albuquerque. Research and learning practices are enacted in technology rich environments. New tools support digital workflows and the volume and variety of research and learning outputs are growing. Libraries are working to support these new environments and to connect their services to them.
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...Guus van den Brekel
Presentation June 30th 2009 Toulouse at LIBER Conference 2009
http://liber2009.biu-toulouse.fr/
Research Libraries & Web 2.0. Scientists engage in science & research 2.0, libraries should follow, outreach, engage, explore and facilitate etc
Publishing tips for Virtual Heritage articles and related issues (3D models), Cities Cultural Heritage and Digital Humanities, Turin Summer School 17 September 2018
See the WEBCAST as well!! mms://wmedia.it.su.se/SUB/NordLib/3.wmv
Presentation at Nordlib 2.0 in Stockholm, November 21th 2008
http://www.nordlib20.org/programme/
As informações digitais atuais estão sendo interligadas, cruzadas e indexadas de múltiplas maneiras por meio da Web global para que os artigos tenham maior visibilidade e alcance. A recente proliferação das API’s (interfaces de aplicativos) e redes sociais têm facilitado e aumentado ainda mais as possibilidades para os artigos. O foco desta apresentação são os principais produtos e serviços que ampliam o alcance e impacto dos artigos na Web.
Today’s digital information is being linked, cross-linked and indexed in a multitude of ways across the global Web to give articles greater visibility and reach. The recent proliferation of API’s (application interfaces) and social networks have further facilitated and expanded the possibilities for articles. This presentation will focus on the main products and services that extend the reach and impact of articles on the Web.
La información digital hoy día está siendo vinculada (linked), reticulada e indexada en una multitud de formas a través de la Web mundial para dar una mayor visibilidad y acceso a los artículos. La reciente proliferación de APIs (interfaces de aplicaciones) y las redes sociales han facilitado y ampliado aún más las posibilidades de los artículos. Esta presentación se centrará en los principales productos y servicios que amplían el alcance y el impacto de los artículos en la Web.
presented at "Assessing Contribution, Assessing Usage: Metrics in a New Context" NFAIS Virtual Conference, March 28, 2014 - http://nfais.org/event?eventID=542
Keynote presentation at the Lita Forum, Albuquerque. Research and learning practices are enacted in technology rich environments. New tools support digital workflows and the volume and variety of research and learning outputs are growing. Libraries are working to support these new environments and to connect their services to them.
Do Libraries Meet Research 2.0 : collaborative tools and relevance for Resear...Guus van den Brekel
Presentation June 30th 2009 Toulouse at LIBER Conference 2009
http://liber2009.biu-toulouse.fr/
Research Libraries & Web 2.0. Scientists engage in science & research 2.0, libraries should follow, outreach, engage, explore and facilitate etc
Arianna Becerril García – Redalyc: A platform to advance non-commercial Open ...Platforma Otwartej Nauki
Discussion panel during the conference celebrating the public launch of the new platform of the Library of Science (https://bibliotekanauki.pl), developed by the Interdisciplinary Centre for Mathematical and Computational Modelling, University of Warsaw, in cooperation with publishers, journal editorial boards, and indexing databases.
The Library of Science is an Open Access collection of Polish scientific journals and books. All the resources are available as full texts with metadata.
Panelists presented their individual experiences from the development of local and regional infrastructures for Open Access to scientific journals.
Panelists:
Arianna Becerril García (Redalyc)
Miroslav Milinović (HRČAK)
Susan Murray (AJOL)
Ritsuko Nakajima (J-STAGE)
Abel L Packer (SciELO)
moderator: Krzysztof Siewicz (ICM UW)
Recording: https://youtu.be/q8bfstI5vpE
The new version of the platform was developed in the framework of the “Platform of Polish Scientific Publications” project, co-financed from the European Regional Development Fund, 2nd priority axis of the Operational Program Digital Poland 2014-2020, Measure 2.3 (total project value: PLN 5,164,777.78, co-financing from European Funds: PLN 4,370,951.43).
Using Social Media for Academic Practice and ImpactAndy Coverdale
Workshop presentation as part of a one-day event on research impact for Medical Research Council funded PhD students from the University of Nottingham and University of Birmingham. Engineering and Science Learning Centre, 27th November 2012.
presentatie Reputation Management & workshop PhD community Thieme Hennis
PhD meeting 27th of November / TBM faculty Delft University of
Technology.
Thieme Hennis
Faculty of Systems Engineering, Policy Analysis and Management
Delft University of Technology
+31 15 278 73 71 (work)
+31 6 51855 22 0 (mobile)
IM/Skype username: thiemehennis
OA discussion at BILETA 2017, Universidade do Minho, Portugal, focusing on legal journal publication. Co-authored with Catherine Easton and Abhilash Hair
Data curation ovvero quanto durevoli sono i nostri sforzi per una biblioteca ...Anna Maria Tammaro
Klaus Kempf Keynote presentation Panel: Una proposta (non?) sovversiva: le competenze per la cura dei dati. A cura di DILL, in collaborazione con IOSSG, Convegno Stelline 16 marzo 2018
Single point of entry: competenze, attività e ruolo del bibliotecario dei datiAnna Maria Tammaro
Maria Laura Vignocchi, Marisol Occioni Panel Una proposta (non?) sovversiva: le competenze per la cura dei dati a cura di DILL, in collaborazione con IOSSG, Convegno Stelline 16 marzo 2018
Biblioteche di conservazione & Data Curation: dal Custos catalogi al Digital ...Anna Maria Tammaro
Fabio Cusimano Una proposta (non?) sovversiva: le competenze per la cura dei dati A cura di DILL, in collaborazione con IOSSG
Convegno Stelline 16 marzo 2018
Commenti a margine del Libro di Simona Turbanti "Bibliometria e scienze del l...Anna Maria Tammaro
La ricerca internazionale su LIS (Library and Information Science). Presentazione del libro di Simona Turbanti "Bibliometria e Scienze del Libro" a Firenze, 8 novembre 2017
Contesto e infrastrutture dell’Open Education Anna Maria Tammaro e Rosanna De Rosa
Contenuti aperti e piattaforme Eleonora Pantò
Policy per l’Open Education Fabio Nascimbeni
Discussione in gruppi
Conclusioni: verso una politica di sistema in Italia
What education for digital librarian? DILL employers surveyAnna Maria Tammaro
Presentazione al Seminario DILL 10 anni dopo, Convegno delle Stelline, Milano 18 marzo 2016
Risultati dell'indagine delle opinioni dei datori di lavoro sulle competenze del bibliotecario digitale
Il sistema delle competenze ed il portfolio: un cambio di paradigma
Tammaro ircdl 2013
1. Evaluation of digital humanities:
an interdisciplinary approach
Anna Maria Tammaro
University of Parma
IRCDL, Rome
February, 1st, 2013
2.
3. Research question
Can we evaluate digital products and publications with
current quality indicators and the same procedures of
printed publications?
Do we need alternatives to the peer review?
4. What?
Publications with an editorial process (PDF)
Hybrid only with documentation
NOT publications which are marked, hypertextual, dynamic,
multimedia and INTERDISCIPLINARY:
− LOM, OER
− Blog Website
− WIKI
− Text analysis
− Digital asset
9. HOW?
Peer review
− QI based upon affiliation and disciplinar
consensu
− Cultural barriers, bias
Bibliometrics
− QI Citations, quantitative measurements
− Impact Factors, H-index, Eigenfactor
− Examples: Scimago, Latindex, Publish or
Perish, Google Scholar
Combination of the two
− Examples: Mesur, Merlot, Open Edit
10. Collaborative Assessment Tool: KOS
Construction of an ontology which evidences the
junctions / hubs and relationships existing between
digital publications in the Digital Humanities in Italy
Construction of a Knowledge Organisation System, as
a supporting tool for the choices of quality evaluation.
Included in Linking Open Data Project Cloud (LOD),
which is at the moment the most important concrete
development of the Semantic Web.
11. Conclusions
Some solutions can be found to the evaluation of digital
products and publications by taking advantage of
information and communication technology
There is the need to analyze and propose solutions to
theoretical, organizational, educational and legislative issues
to ensure a virtuous cycle of publications evaluation.
12. Thank you for your attention!
Contact:
Annamaria.tammaro@unipr.it