Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

•Download as ODP, PDF•

2 likes•1,004 views

Presentation of my scientific paper to the Third International Workshop on image Media Quality and its Applications (IMQA2008).

Technology Travel Entertainment & Humor

Stéphane Péchard Romuald Pépion Patrick Le Callet IRCCyN — France Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

Outline 1. Introduction 2. Comparison of subjective scores 3. Impact of the number of observers on precision 4. Conclusion

DSIS... ACR... SSCQE... DSCQS... SAMVIQ... SDSCE... SCACJ... ? Which one?

Many factors Sequences order Sequence number Type of scale

random order only one viewing discrete scale no explicit reference used by VQEG ACR

user-driven order multiple viewing continuous scale explicit reference used by EBU SAMVIQ

controled environment recommended number of viewers minimal instructions

100 0 excellent good fair poor bad excellent good fair poor bad ACR SAMVIQ 5 4 3 2 1 80%

CC=0.94 Brotherton [2006] CIF HDTV CC=0.89 ?

ACR less critical than SAMVIQ Distorsions better perceived with SAMVIQ BUT the inverse for reference

What can explain? Scale difference Number of viewing Explicit reference

Scale difference? Corriveau: ACR closer to the extremities But reference MOS only in [68.52;87.04] => not the explanation ACR uses 96.3% SAMVIQ uses 82.1%

Number of viewing? => only explain the plot, not the CC SAMVIQ: unlimited viewing with distorsions: MOS ACR > MOS SAMVIQ more precise scores

Explicit reference presence? No obvious impact SAMVIQ: no difference between references No higher scores than explicit reference => only identical assessments Not the same psychological condition

Results HDTV VGA QVGA 13° 19° 33° 0.969 0.942 0.899 6.73 9.31 14.06 Visual field CC RMSE

Only the number of viewing may imply such an impact. MOS 1 X 1 2 X 2 ~ X 1 3 X 3 ~ X 1 4 X 4 ~ X 1 1 2 3 4 X 1 X 2 ≤ X 1 X 3 ≤ X 2 X 4 ≤ X 3

First conclusion ACR and SAMVIQ are equivalent until a certain resolution

Precision – number of observers N How: 95% confidence interval depends on N ACR: high N SAMVIQ: high precision

Problem: rejection algorithms ACR: from ITU SAMVIQ: own 1. without rejection 2. with ACR rejection 3. with SAMVIQ rejection ≠

Number of validated observers ACR mode 1 mode 2 mode 3 SAMVIQ 28 27 23 18-25 15-25 15-22 all sequences available some sequences available

Analysis Confidence intervals for several N P ACR: N P {28, 25, 22, 20, 18, 15, 12, 10, 8} possible combinations => mean CI

Number of observers Mean confidence interval ACR

Number of observers Mean confidence interval SAMVIQ

Close values? BUT: ACR scale is 80% shorter! 100 0 0 80 ACR SAMVIQ CI=10 CI=10 > more precise x 1.25

Mean confidence intervals 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 25 SAMVIQ ACR (adjusted) 10.296 9.284 8.519 7.658 7.014 6.893 6.701 5.964 12.815 11.567 10.619 9.55 8.749 8.315 7.94 7.461 < number of observers

Rejection modes analysis CI without rejection < CI with rejection because mean computed with more CI without rejection (mode 1) Nevertheless, not important differences

Rejection modes analysis CI SAMVIQ rejection > CI ACR rejection Same reason : number of validated observers in SAMVIQ < in ACR

Conclusion ACR-SAMVIQ comparison different behaviours weak relation when resolution increases SAMVIQ more accurate with multi-viewing more information to process

Conclusion strong impact of the number of observers weak impact of the rejection algorithm ACR requires more than 22 observers to get the same precision than SAMVIQ with 15 interesting for laboratories to select the best methodology

1. The document discusses subjective and objective methods for assessing quality of experience in high definition television. 2. It presents results from subjective quality tests comparing HDTV and SDTV formats using different methodologies. 3. The author proposes a new content-based approach to segmenting video spatially and temporally into categories to relate local distortions to overall perceived quality.

Community of intelligenceFrank Smilda

A new methodology to estimate the impact of H.264 artefacts on subjective vid...

Stéphane Péchard

Iec 62676 5 standardized spezification of image quality

Henry Rutjes

This document discusses IEC 62676-5, a standard for specifying image quality performance metrics for camera devices used in security applications. It outlines several methods defined in the standard for evaluating key image quality parameters such as resolution, optical/electronic characteristic function (OECF), dynamic range, minimum illumination, visible dynamic range, infrared illumination operating distance, image distortion, and image flare. The intention of the standard is to provide standardized procedures and definitions for measuring and reporting these parameters in a meaningful way to help users select the right camera for their application.

Anjali (qa qc on cr dr)

globalsoin

The document discusses quality assurance and quality control procedures for computed radiography (CR) and digital radiography (DR) systems. It recommends various routine tests to ensure equipment is performing properly and producing high quality images with minimum radiation exposure. Tests include daily, weekly, and monthly checks of monitors, printers, image quality metrics like contrast-to-noise ratio, and performing regular calibration procedures. The summary provides an overview of the key tests and frequencies recommended to maintain quality in CR and DR imaging systems.

Section 1 Introduction V Rjo 081007 W Presenter Created Quiz

Richard O'Keeffe

This document provides an overview and introduction to MVision imaging on a Siemens linear accelerator. It describes the physicist tasks related to MVision calibration and quality assurance including cone beam geometry calibration, image quality QA, 2D gain calibration, and adaptive targeting. The key performance parameters and tools for MVision are outlined. Physicist responsibilities involve creating MVision protocols, performing various calibrations, and ensuring image quality.

Impact of novel ms ms all acquisition and processing techniques on forensic t...

Sara Feltesse

Rapid forensic toxicology screening by high resolution mass spectrometry is a powerful technique. However, some compounds cannot be unambiguously identified with high resolution MS1 measurements alone. MS/MS fragmentation yields confident identifications of these compounds, but how to ensure quality MS/MS of these compounds? Data dependent techniques, although very powerful, cannot guarantee the measurement of all possible MS/MS candidates. Targeted MS/MS ensures acquisition of the target compounds, but limits the number of compounds. Data-independent techniques, such as SWATH™ acquisition (the MS/MS of all possible candidates), improve identifications significantly and enable retrospective analysis of the data. The impact of improvements to SWATH acquisition, including variable precursor window sizes, overlapping windows, and data processing were evaluated.

PET - Calibration of QC Instruments for PET Radiopharmaceuticals Testing

@Saudi_nmc

This document discusses calibration procedures and acceptance criteria for various analytical instruments used in a quality control laboratory. It provides details on the frequency of calibration for instruments like HPLC, gas chromatography, gamma spectroscopy systems, radiation scanners, dose calibrators, and osmometers. For each instrument, specific acceptance criteria are outlined, such as tolerance limits for flow rates, wavelengths, retention times, efficiencies, and activities. Maintaining calibrated equipment through regular calibration checks is important to ensure the accuracy and reliability of analytical results.

This document discusses the practical limitations of quantum key distribution (QKD) including speed, distance, security, and deployment challenges. It presents two QKD technologies - discrete variable and continuous variable - and focuses on improving the performance of continuous variable QKD through techniques like multidimensional reconciliation codes, virtual channel analysis, and accounting for finite key sizes in security proofs. Experimental results demonstrate a continuous variable QKD system over 80km of fiber with key rates of over 100 bits/second.

Measurement system analysis Presentation.ppt

jawadullah25

Real-time Bangla License Plate Recognition System for Low Resource Video-base...

MD Abdullah Al Nasim

Automatic License Plate Recognition systems aim to provide a solution for detecting, localizing, and recognizing license plate characters from vehicles appearing in video frames. However, deploying such systems in the real world requires real-time performance in low-resource environments. In our paper, we propose a two-stage detection pipeline paired with Vision API that provides real-time inference speed along with consistently accurate detection and recognition performance. We used a haar-cascade classifier as a filter on top of our backbone MobileNet SSDv2 detection model. This reduces inference time by only focusing on high confidence detections and using them for recognition. We also impose a temporal frame separation strategy to distinguish between multiple vehicle license plates in the same clip. Furthermore, there are no publicly available Bangla license plate datasets, for which we created an image dataset and a video dataset containing license plates in the wild. We trained our models on the image dataset and achieved an AP (0.5) score of 86% and tested our pipeline on the video dataset and observed reasonable detection and recognition performance (82.7% detection rate, and 60.8% OCR F1 score) with real-time processing speed (27.2 frames per second).

MSA STUDY training presentation for manufacturing

abhishek558363

Radiomics and Deep Learning for Lung Cancer Screening

Wookjin Choi

The document summarizes research on using radiomics and deep learning approaches for lung cancer screening. It describes: 1) Using radiomic features like shape, texture, and intensity from lung nodules on CT scans and an SVM-LASSO model to classify nodules with 87.9% sensitivity and 78.2% specificity, outperforming the Lung-RADS system. 2) A deep learning model developed for a Kaggle competition that achieved 67.4% accuracy on nodule classification but only ranked 99th due to overfitting issues without enough data. 3) Future work could integrate quantification of nodule characteristics like spiculation with plasma biomarkers to improve diagnostic accuracy.

Measurement System Analysis - Module 2

Subhodeep Deb

Horizon Presentation

Paul Anderson

This document summarizes the services of a company that specializes in designing and building custom automated systems, including deposition, laser integration, vision systems, software validation, and assembly of complex components. They have 25 years of experience in bespoke automation for applications such as medical devices, diagnostics, and biotechnology. Their services include mechanical and electrical design, software development, machine building, testing, validation, documentation, and distribution partnerships.

Impact of novel ms ms all acquisition and processing techniques on forensic t...

SCIEX

This document evaluates different MS/MS acquisition techniques for forensic toxicological screening using high resolution mass spectrometry. It compares standard data-dependent acquisition to various data-independent acquisition (SWATH) methods. SWATH acquisition ensures MS/MS data is collected for all possible precursors but can result in mixed spectra from multiple compounds. Overlapping variable-width SWATH windows and deconvolution techniques improve spectral quality and identifications over standard wide windows. These methods provide identification results comparable to targeted methods while analyzing all compounds.

Radiomics Analysis of Pulmonary Nodules in Low Dose CT for Early Detection of...

Wookjin Choi

Purpose: To predict the histopathologic subtypes with poor surgery prognosis in early stage lung adenocarcinomas using CT and PET radiomics. Methods: We retrospectively enrolled 53 patients with stage I lung adenocarcinoma who underwent both diagnostic CT and 18F-fluorodeoxyglucose (FDG) PET/CT before complete surgical resection of the tumors. Tumor segmentation was manually contoured by a physician on both the diagnostic CT and the attenuation CT of PET/CT.A total of 170 radiomics features were extracted on both PET and CT images to design predictive models for two histopathologic endpoints: (1) tumors with solid or micropapillary predominant subtype (aggressiveness), and (2) tumors with micropapillary component more than 5% (MIP5). We used least absolute shrinkage and selection operator (LASSO) as a model building method coupled with a class separability feature selection (CSFS) method. For an unbiased model estimate, a 10-fold cross validation approach was used. The area under the curve (AUC) and prediction accuracy were employed to evaluate the performance of the model. P-values were computed using Wilcoxon rank-sum test. Results: Of the 53 patients, 9 and 15 had tumors with aggressiveness and MIP5, respectively. For both endpoints, LASSO models with two PET radiomics features achieved the best performance. For aggressiveness, the LASSO model with PET Cluster Shade and PET 2D Variance resulted in 77.6±2.3% accuracy and 0.71±0.02 AUC (P = 0.011). For MIP5, the LASSO model with PET Eccentricity and PET Cluster Shade resulted in 69.6±3.1% accuracy and 0.68±0.04 AUC (P=0.014). The PET Cluster Shade was commonly selected in both models. Cluster shade is a texture feature that measures the skewness of the co-occurrence matrix. Higher PET cluster shade predicted that the tumor was more aggressive and more likely MIP5. Conclusion: We showed that PET/CT radiomics features can predict tumor aggressiveness. Funding Support, Disclosures, and Conflict of Interest: This work was supported in part by the National Cancer Institute Grants R01CA172638.

Image quality, digital technology and radiation protection

Rad Tech

1. The document discusses key factors that influence image quality for both film-based and digital radiography systems, including density, contrast, resolution, and distortion. 2. It also covers radiation exposure factors like kV, mAs, and techniques to reduce patient dose like using collimation and shields. 3. Digital radiography systems use metrics like exposure index and SNR to assess image quality rather than film density, and also allow for post-processing techniques.

Survival report of 76 breast cancer patients under three different treatments

Dwaipayan Mukhopadhyay

Aim of the Project- An application of the Kaplan-Meier estimator, Lifetable Analysis and a clinical data, the survival time of 76 breast cancer patients categorized under three different treatments, which is presented with respected lifetables along with survival and hazard function for comparison. Statistical techniques Used- Kaplan-Meier estimator, Lifetable Analysis Software Used- SAS, Excel

A 13b SAR ADC with Eye-opening VCO Based Comparator

Kentaro Yoshioka

This document presents a low power technique for high resolution SAR ADCs using a VCO comparator with an eye-opening operation. It motivates the need for low power, high resolution ADCs for applications like IoT devices. It then discusses challenges for the main SAR ADC building blocks, particularly the C-DAC and comparators. The proposed technique uses a VCO comparator that automatically scales its noise and power based on the input difference signal, reducing noise when the difference is small through an eye-opening oscillation operation. Measurement results show the implemented 13b SAR ADC achieves 66.4dB SNDR at 45uW power, demonstrating competitive performance compared to prior works.

Optimal Energy Storage System Operation for Peak Reduction

Daisuke Kodaira

This document presents a study on using energy storage systems (ESS) for peak reduction on a distribution network. The key points are: 1. Two ESS batteries were installed and controlled remotely by the network operator to reduce peaks. Load and ESS schedules were optimized 24 hours ahead. 2. Accurate load prediction is challenging due to errors. Probabilistic prediction intervals (PIs) accounting for uncertainty were proposed to determine ESS schedules. 3. Different PI construction methods like sample base, confidence interval, and Chebyshev were evaluated. Confidence interval achieved the best yearly peak reduction while minimizing the coverage width-based criterion. 4. A modified objective function considering off-peak duration in

CoSECiVi'15 - Predicting the winner in two player StarCraft games

Sociedad Española para las Ciencias del Videojuego

Boston regulated bioanalysis

Bhaswat Chakraborty

The document discusses key principles and guidelines for regulated bioanalysis including validation of quantitative bioanalytical methods. It covers validation of both non-chromatographic and chromatographic assays. Some of the main points covered include validation criteria for calibration curves, quality controls, selectivity, accuracy, precision, reproducibility, recovery, and stability. Examples of validation results are also provided to illustrate concepts like matrix effects, column ruggedness, and recovery.

cdsfdsfdsssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssssss

ChristianQuijiaQueza

This document discusses methods for calculating, interpreting, and analyzing neuraminidase inhibitor IC50 data from influenza viruses. It describes using curve fitting or point-to-point methods to determine IC50 values, and highlights sources of variation. Statistical analyses like SMAD and box-and-whisker plots are presented to identify outlier IC50 values and set cutoffs to monitor trends over time that may indicate changes in viral susceptibility. Close examination of data graphs and curves is also emphasized to validate IC50 results.

Focus Co Management 2016 Edmison

FocusEye

This document summarizes David R. Edmison's 25 years of experience at Focus Eye Centre from 1992 to 2016. It outlines the progression of refractive surgery technologies used at the practice over time, including starting with PRK in 1992, adopting LASIK and Intacs in 2000, and advancing to wavefront guided treatments with CustomVue in 2003 and iDesign in 2013. Patient expectations and outcomes have improved with these technological advances. The integrity and credibility of Focus Eye Centre is maintained through ISO certification, low employee turnover, and use of the most advanced equipment.

QCP user manual EN.pdf

Emerson Ceras

The Quality Control Program (QCP) provides laboratories with statistical reports and tools to improve quality and compare performance to peer groups. It collects data from 800 labs worldwide. The QCP includes 8 statistical comparison reports that provide indicators of precision, accuracy, and uncertainty to help laboratories evaluate their results over time, identify errors, and improve performance relative to international standards. Primary users can enroll laboratories and instruments and enter quality control data either manually or via automatic daily uploads from certain instruments. Secondary users can be added to manage specific instruments.

Ttl interface-7-inch-1024x600-all-view-angle-lcd-d

kingtech display

LVTS - Image Resolution Monitor for Litho-Metrology

Vladislav Kaplan

Significant challenges for various Critical Dimension (CD) measurement matching procedures are reaching a comparable complexity as result of negative effects of roughness on the features. Due to the constant trend of integrated circuit in features reduction, impact of roughness start to be more destructive for various sets of measurement algorithms. Commonly used attempts to increase magnification for pattern recognition in measurement mode could in turn detect higher deviation from predefined patterns and thus initiate shift in placement of measurement gate. The purpose of this paper is to discuss how to reduce measurement gate (MG) placement variation impact and filter acquired data using edge correlation approach. The essence of listed above approach is to create set of width correlation function represents particular feature under test and compare it to “golden” one as a mean of detection of uncorrelated scans, which in turn should be excluded from overall computation of matching results. We describe general approach for algorithm stepping and various techniques for judgment of measurement comparison validity. Presented approach also has particular interest in determination of specified tool performance for predefined pattern recognition feature as well as for pattern recognition algorithm robustness study - direct interest for manufacturer. Precise matching estimation as part of Round Robin (RR) routines creating possibility to work with restricted amount of data and perform quick reliable qualification procedures. This paper concentrated on practical approach and used both simulation and actual data measurements data before and after proposed optimization taken by various generation tools by Hitachi (S-8840, S-9300, S-9380) in production environment

Presentation of the OECD Artificial Intelligence Review of Germany

innovationoecd

Mind map of terminologies used in context of Generative AI

Kumud Singh

20240609 QFM020 Irresponsible AI Reading List May 2024

Matthew Sinclair

Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days

Kari Kakkonen

My slides at Nordic Testing Days 6.6.2024 Climate impact / sustainability of software testing discussed on the talk. ICT and testing must carry their part of global responsibility to help with the climat warming. We can minimize the carbon footprint but we can also have a carbon handprint, a positive impact on the climate. Quality characteristics can be added with sustainability, and then measured continuously. Test environments can be used less, and in smaller scale and on demand. Test techniques can be used in optimizing or minimizing number of tests. Test automation can be used to speed up testing.

Microsoft - Power Platform_G.Aspiotis.pdf

Uni Systems S.M.S.A.

RESUME BUILDER APPLICATION Project for students

KAMESHS29

20240607 QFM018 Elixir Reading List May 2024

Matthew Sinclair

Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !

KatiaHIMEUR1

Today, after several years of existence, an extremely active community and an ultra-dynamic ecosystem, Kubernetes has established itself as the de facto standard in container orchestration. Thanks to a wide range of managed services, it has never been so easy to set up a ready-to-use Kubernetes cluster. However, this ease of use means that the subject of security in Kubernetes is often left for later, or even neglected. This exposes companies to significant risks. In this talk, I'll show you step-by-step how to secure your Kubernetes cluster for greater peace of mind and reliability.

Communications Mining Series - Zero to Hero - Session 1

DianaGray10

This session provides introduction to UiPath Communication Mining, importance and platform overview. You will acquire a good understand of the phases in Communication Mining as we go over the platform with you. Topics covered: • Communication Mining Overview • Why is it important? • How can it help today’s business and the benefits • Phases in Communication Mining • Demo on Platform overview • Q/A

Recently uploaded (20)

Presentation of the OECD Artificial Intelligence Review of Germany

Mind map of terminologies used in context of Generative AI

“Building and Scaling AI Applications with the Nx AI Manager,” a Presentation...

Artificial Intelligence for XMLDevelopment

20 Comprehensive Checklist of Designing and Developing a Website

Large Language Model (LLM) and it’s Geospatial Applications

20240605 QFM017 Machine Intelligence Reading List May 2024

Uni Systems Copilot event_05062024_C.Vlachos.pdf

Video Streaming: Then, Now, and in the Future

Introducing Milvus Lite: Easy-to-Install, Easy-to-Use vector database for you...

Observability Concepts EVERY Developer Should Know -- DeveloperWeek Europe.pdf

GraphSummit Singapore | Graphing Success: Revolutionising Organisational Stru...

みなさんこんにちはこれ何文字まで入るの？40文字以下不可とか本当に意味わからないけどこれ限界文字数書いてないからマジでやばい文字数いけるんじゃないの？えこ...

20240609 QFM020 Irresponsible AI Reading List May 2024

Climate Impact of Software Testing at Nordic Testing Days

Microsoft - Power Platform_G.Aspiotis.pdf

RESUME BUILDER APPLICATION Project for students

20240607 QFM018 Elixir Reading List May 2024

Securing your Kubernetes cluster_ a step-by-step guide to success !

Communications Mining Series - Zero to Hero - Session 1

Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

1. Stéphane Péchard Romuald Pépion Patrick Le Callet IRCCyN — France Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

2. Outline 1. Introduction 2. Comparison of subjective scores 3. Impact of the number of observers on precision 4. Conclusion

3. DSIS... ACR... SSCQE... DSCQS... SAMVIQ... SDSCE... SCACJ... ? Which one?

4. Many factors Sequences order Sequence number Type of scale

5. random order only one viewing discrete scale no explicit reference used by VQEG ACR

6. user-driven order multiple viewing continuous scale explicit reference used by EBU SAMVIQ

7. Subjective quality tests

8. 192 HDTV sequences 7 24 ref --------

9. controled environment recommended number of viewers minimal instructions

10. 100 0 excellent good fair poor bad excellent good fair poor bad ACR SAMVIQ 5 4 3 2 1 80%

11. Quality scale adjustment

12. CC=0.899 RMSE=14.06

13. CC=0.94 Brotherton [2006] CIF HDTV CC=0.89 ?

14. MOS ACR > MOS SAMVIQ

15. ACR less critical than SAMVIQ Distorsions better perceived with SAMVIQ BUT the inverse for reference

16. What can explain? Scale difference Number of viewing Explicit reference

17. Scale difference? Corriveau: ACR closer to the extremities But reference MOS only in [68.52;87.04] => not the explanation ACR uses 96.3% SAMVIQ uses 82.1%

18. Number of viewing? => only explain the plot, not the CC SAMVIQ: unlimited viewing with distorsions: MOS ACR > MOS SAMVIQ more precise scores

19.

20. Explicit reference presence? No obvious impact SAMVIQ: no difference between references No higher scores than explicit reference => only identical assessments Not the same psychological condition

21. More tests! HDTV VGA QVGA

22. Results HDTV VGA QVGA 13° 19° 33° 0.969 0.942 0.899 6.73 9.31 14.06 Visual field CC RMSE

23.

24. Only the number of viewing may imply such an impact. MOS 1 X 1 2 X 2 ~ X 1 3 X 3 ~ X 1 4 X 4 ~ X 1 1 2 3 4 X 1 X 2 ≤ X 1 X 3 ≤ X 2 X 4 ≤ X 3

25. First conclusion ACR and SAMVIQ are equivalent until a certain resolution

26. Precision – number of observers N How: 95% confidence interval depends on N ACR: high N SAMVIQ: high precision

27. Problem: rejection algorithms ACR: from ITU SAMVIQ: own 1. without rejection 2. with ACR rejection 3. with SAMVIQ rejection ≠

28. Number of validated observers ACR mode 1 mode 2 mode 3 SAMVIQ 28 27 23 18-25 15-25 15-22 all sequences available some sequences available

29. Analysis Confidence intervals for several N P ACR: N P {28, 25, 22, 20, 18, 15, 12, 10, 8} possible combinations => mean CI

30. Number of observers Mean confidence interval ACR

31. Number of observers Mean confidence interval SAMVIQ

32. Close values? BUT: ACR scale is 80% shorter! 100 0 0 80 ACR SAMVIQ CI=10 CI=10 > more precise x 1.25

33. Mean confidence intervals 8 10 12 15 18 20 22 25 SAMVIQ ACR (adjusted) 10.296 9.284 8.519 7.658 7.014 6.893 6.701 5.964 12.815 11.567 10.619 9.55 8.749 8.315 7.94 7.461 < number of observers

34.

35. Confidence interval of MCI (ACR)

36. Confidence interval of MCI (SAMVIQ)

37. Rejection modes analysis CI without rejection < CI with rejection because mean computed with more CI without rejection (mode 1) Nevertheless, not important differences

38. Rejection modes analysis CI SAMVIQ rejection > CI ACR rejection Same reason : number of validated observers in SAMVIQ < in ACR

39. Conclusion ACR-SAMVIQ comparison different behaviours weak relation when resolution increases SAMVIQ more accurate with multi-viewing more information to process

40. Conclusion strong impact of the number of observers weak impact of the rejection algorithm ACR requires more than 22 observers to get the same precision than SAMVIQ with 15 interesting for laboratories to select the best methodology

41. Questions?

Editor's Notes

Hello everyone, my name is Stéphane Péchard and I'm a PhD student working in the IRCCyN lab with Patrick Le Callet.

Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

Recommended

Recommended

More Related Content

Similar to Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

Similar to Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm (20)

Recently uploaded

Recently uploaded (20)

Suitable methodology in subjective video quality assessment: a resolution dependent paradigm

Editor's Notes