As executives charged with the task of putting banking on a new commercial course,
you need to be armed with trustworthy, complete facts and analysis. For that, the
institution needs to adopt a business analytics framework. Decisions will then be based
on reliable information and predictive insight – adjusted for known risks across the
institution’s business units, functional areas and channels. For more info: www.nafcu.org/sas
WealthTech Views: Looking into 2021 from William Rouse, Contemi SolutionsContemi Solutions
WealthTech Views Report: Looking into 2021, created by the Wealth Mosaic, provides insights and intelligence from technology thought leaders from across the globe on the main technology trends in wealth management they expect to see in the year ahead.
Contemi's Business Development Director, William Rouse, shared his insights into the challenges, opportunities and industry talking points for 2021.
Robo Advice: Revenge of the Incumbents (MyVest and Aite INVEST session)MyVest
After digital disruptors demonstrated the viability of automated advice, traditional firms are in the middle of responding to this threat and opportunity. MyVest’s CEO Anton Honikman will interview Aite Group’s Alois Pirker about his research into how incumbents are developing their digital wealth offerings. Alois will share how we are moving from the 2nd to the 3rd stage of robo-advice adoption, and his recommendations for how you can prepare for the future through making better use of segmentation, data, and differentiated advice.
Self-Service in Wealth Management: Remaining CompetitiveCapgemini
Globally, companies are using digital technology to transform the way they run operations. This transformation is being driven by the increased sophistication of new channels such a mobile and social media. Across financial services, banks, brokerages and insurance companies are leveraging these evolving technologies to enable self-service capabilities so customers can resolve issues or get information without interacting with a representative. This paper looks at self-service in wealth management and examines the impact to deliver a forward-looking cross-channel client experience.
Solving Financial Constraints with Innovative Funding SolutionGilbert Tam 譚耀宗
After the credit crunch in 2008, SMEs though they are amounted to the 80-90% of business activites but their access to funding has been greatly impacted by the traditional lenders, banks, that after the 2008 credit cruch are reluctant to maintain such business if no "bricks and mortar" are provided by sellers.
The wealth management industry is entering a period of significant disruption, with robo-advice at the heart of this disruption. Digital, automated advice will likely become a standard expectation for the mass-affluent and mass-market segments. But big data and advanced analytics have the potential to dramatically expand the scope of roboadvice, incorporating financial planning into broader retirement, health, and wellbeing, and enabling quasi institutional research, which could then impact all investor segments. All wealth management firms should take notice. Read more: http://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/consulting/articles/robo-advisors-capitalizing-on-growing-opportunity.html
WealthTech Views: Looking into 2021 from William Rouse, Contemi SolutionsContemi Solutions
WealthTech Views Report: Looking into 2021, created by the Wealth Mosaic, provides insights and intelligence from technology thought leaders from across the globe on the main technology trends in wealth management they expect to see in the year ahead.
Contemi's Business Development Director, William Rouse, shared his insights into the challenges, opportunities and industry talking points for 2021.
Robo Advice: Revenge of the Incumbents (MyVest and Aite INVEST session)MyVest
After digital disruptors demonstrated the viability of automated advice, traditional firms are in the middle of responding to this threat and opportunity. MyVest’s CEO Anton Honikman will interview Aite Group’s Alois Pirker about his research into how incumbents are developing their digital wealth offerings. Alois will share how we are moving from the 2nd to the 3rd stage of robo-advice adoption, and his recommendations for how you can prepare for the future through making better use of segmentation, data, and differentiated advice.
Self-Service in Wealth Management: Remaining CompetitiveCapgemini
Globally, companies are using digital technology to transform the way they run operations. This transformation is being driven by the increased sophistication of new channels such a mobile and social media. Across financial services, banks, brokerages and insurance companies are leveraging these evolving technologies to enable self-service capabilities so customers can resolve issues or get information without interacting with a representative. This paper looks at self-service in wealth management and examines the impact to deliver a forward-looking cross-channel client experience.
Solving Financial Constraints with Innovative Funding SolutionGilbert Tam 譚耀宗
After the credit crunch in 2008, SMEs though they are amounted to the 80-90% of business activites but their access to funding has been greatly impacted by the traditional lenders, banks, that after the 2008 credit cruch are reluctant to maintain such business if no "bricks and mortar" are provided by sellers.
The wealth management industry is entering a period of significant disruption, with robo-advice at the heart of this disruption. Digital, automated advice will likely become a standard expectation for the mass-affluent and mass-market segments. But big data and advanced analytics have the potential to dramatically expand the scope of roboadvice, incorporating financial planning into broader retirement, health, and wellbeing, and enabling quasi institutional research, which could then impact all investor segments. All wealth management firms should take notice. Read more: http://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/consulting/articles/robo-advisors-capitalizing-on-growing-opportunity.html
Emerging Trends in Automated Wealth Management AdviceCognizant
As robo advisors expand into more customer segments, European wealth managers need to respond to changing dynamics to stay ahead of emerging providers.
Digitally mature companies outperform their peers by 26% in terms of profitability, driving utilities to adopt transformative programs such as digital utility transformation (DUT).
This presentation dives into one key aspect of DUT that is changing our industry: utility analytics—business intelligence, data organization, and analytics platforms supporting data-driven enterprises. Keeping the architecture consistent across the enterprise with fragmented budgets and diverse business requirements is difficult.
The presentation explores the experiences of a client as it established consensus on budgets, architectures, and technologies.
Originally presented at Oracle OpenWorld 2014 by David DuCharme, Capgemini's NA Utilities Leader, Victor Jimenez, Capgemini Utilities Executive, and Michael Glass, Director, Demand Side Systems, Pacific Gas & Electric Company.
http://www.capgemini.com/oracle
Going Digital? Not Without a Simple, Modern and Secure IT BackboneCognizant
To compete in today’s digital world, enterprises need a fast, efficient and extensible IT foundation that reduces complexity, enhances agility and enables resiliency. Here’s our blueprint on how to get started.
Insurance at the Intersection: Reinventing the Model, Repositioning the BrandCognizant
Insurers that can embrace the changing environment by redesigning their operating models and reinventing their business will be the most successful industry players of the future.
InsureNXT-Unicorn session_Final 21 April 2021.pdfAlchemy Crew
These slides aim to share within our community the great achievements from unicorns.
The challenges to get there and the opportunities within our insurance world.
CommerzVentures: the rise of the robo advisors from an investor’s perspectiveCommerzVentures
Over the course of the last few years, the so-called robo advisors have gained significant media coverage in the financial technology (Fintech) space. Invested assets in automated investment services more than doubled from 2014 to 2015 and no Fintech conference has taken place without a newly established robo advisor. Additionally, there have been inflows of hundreds of millions of dollars in venture capital backing into the start-ups behind the robo advisors. Betterment, for example, one of the most famous and largest robo advisors, raised USD100m venture funding in March 2016. We have also started to see the adoption of automated advice by traditional banks and investment managers. This article serves as an introduction to CommerzVentures and our view on the rise of the robo advisors.
How to Manage Increasing Data Compliance Issues in Community BanksColleen Beck-Domanico
During one of RMA’s Credit Risk Management Audio Conferences, H. Walter Young, chief liquidity risk officer, M&T Bank and chief data officer, CCAR, shared strategies and best practices for community banks facing increased data compliance and integrity issues, once deemed as “big bank issues."
Insights Success has come up with a distinctive issue “The 10 Most Influential Voices in Banking” which recognizes the incalculable contribution of banking enthusiasts who has revolutionized banking processes with their inventive excellence.
The perspective of Fintech executives.
In June of 2015, The Economist Intelligence Unit (sponsored by HP) conducted in-depth surveys of over 100 global bankers and Fintech executives on the future of retail banking. This is what we found.
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings PresentationCapgemini
Ten years after publishing the first World Payments Report, Capgemini and RBS continue to provide insight into global and regional non-cash payment trends. In this presentation from the World Payments Report 2014, we explore what is driving payments growth, the increasing overlap of key regulatory and industry initiatives, the increased cascade effect, and innovation and transformation in payments processing. Visit www.worldpaymentsreport.com for more information.
How Robo Advisers, Fintech Are Revolutionising Wealth ManagementDinis Guarda
How Robo Advisers, Fintech Are Revolutionising Wealth Management. A Reflection and presentation about trends and ideas related with the topic and what is happening in the industry
There have been many exciting developments in the legislative and regulatory arenas so we’re including a lengthy “Washington Viewpoint” with as much up-to-date information for the financial services industry as possible. We anticipate having even more details to share in the coming issues.
Our overview of the Discover U.S. Spending Monitor has relevant information on the current spending habits and trends in the economy as a whole, as well as some credit union–specific customer spending details. In our consultant’s corner, we have an interesting article from the Tower Group about credit card retention tactics and from Philliou Partners, a great comparison between Main Street retailers and online merchants.
Learn more at http://www.nafcu.org/discover
Emerging Trends in Automated Wealth Management AdviceCognizant
As robo advisors expand into more customer segments, European wealth managers need to respond to changing dynamics to stay ahead of emerging providers.
Digitally mature companies outperform their peers by 26% in terms of profitability, driving utilities to adopt transformative programs such as digital utility transformation (DUT).
This presentation dives into one key aspect of DUT that is changing our industry: utility analytics—business intelligence, data organization, and analytics platforms supporting data-driven enterprises. Keeping the architecture consistent across the enterprise with fragmented budgets and diverse business requirements is difficult.
The presentation explores the experiences of a client as it established consensus on budgets, architectures, and technologies.
Originally presented at Oracle OpenWorld 2014 by David DuCharme, Capgemini's NA Utilities Leader, Victor Jimenez, Capgemini Utilities Executive, and Michael Glass, Director, Demand Side Systems, Pacific Gas & Electric Company.
http://www.capgemini.com/oracle
Going Digital? Not Without a Simple, Modern and Secure IT BackboneCognizant
To compete in today’s digital world, enterprises need a fast, efficient and extensible IT foundation that reduces complexity, enhances agility and enables resiliency. Here’s our blueprint on how to get started.
Insurance at the Intersection: Reinventing the Model, Repositioning the BrandCognizant
Insurers that can embrace the changing environment by redesigning their operating models and reinventing their business will be the most successful industry players of the future.
InsureNXT-Unicorn session_Final 21 April 2021.pdfAlchemy Crew
These slides aim to share within our community the great achievements from unicorns.
The challenges to get there and the opportunities within our insurance world.
CommerzVentures: the rise of the robo advisors from an investor’s perspectiveCommerzVentures
Over the course of the last few years, the so-called robo advisors have gained significant media coverage in the financial technology (Fintech) space. Invested assets in automated investment services more than doubled from 2014 to 2015 and no Fintech conference has taken place without a newly established robo advisor. Additionally, there have been inflows of hundreds of millions of dollars in venture capital backing into the start-ups behind the robo advisors. Betterment, for example, one of the most famous and largest robo advisors, raised USD100m venture funding in March 2016. We have also started to see the adoption of automated advice by traditional banks and investment managers. This article serves as an introduction to CommerzVentures and our view on the rise of the robo advisors.
How to Manage Increasing Data Compliance Issues in Community BanksColleen Beck-Domanico
During one of RMA’s Credit Risk Management Audio Conferences, H. Walter Young, chief liquidity risk officer, M&T Bank and chief data officer, CCAR, shared strategies and best practices for community banks facing increased data compliance and integrity issues, once deemed as “big bank issues."
Insights Success has come up with a distinctive issue “The 10 Most Influential Voices in Banking” which recognizes the incalculable contribution of banking enthusiasts who has revolutionized banking processes with their inventive excellence.
The perspective of Fintech executives.
In June of 2015, The Economist Intelligence Unit (sponsored by HP) conducted in-depth surveys of over 100 global bankers and Fintech executives on the future of retail banking. This is what we found.
World Payments Report 2014 Key Findings PresentationCapgemini
Ten years after publishing the first World Payments Report, Capgemini and RBS continue to provide insight into global and regional non-cash payment trends. In this presentation from the World Payments Report 2014, we explore what is driving payments growth, the increasing overlap of key regulatory and industry initiatives, the increased cascade effect, and innovation and transformation in payments processing. Visit www.worldpaymentsreport.com for more information.
How Robo Advisers, Fintech Are Revolutionising Wealth ManagementDinis Guarda
How Robo Advisers, Fintech Are Revolutionising Wealth Management. A Reflection and presentation about trends and ideas related with the topic and what is happening in the industry
There have been many exciting developments in the legislative and regulatory arenas so we’re including a lengthy “Washington Viewpoint” with as much up-to-date information for the financial services industry as possible. We anticipate having even more details to share in the coming issues.
Our overview of the Discover U.S. Spending Monitor has relevant information on the current spending habits and trends in the economy as a whole, as well as some credit union–specific customer spending details. In our consultant’s corner, we have an interesting article from the Tower Group about credit card retention tactics and from Philliou Partners, a great comparison between Main Street retailers and online merchants.
Learn more at http://www.nafcu.org/discover
Succession Planning: Developing an Internal Search Process (Credit Union Conf...NAFCU Services Corporation
Ensuring that credit unions have the leadership and talent needed for future success is a critical responsibility of current CEOs and boards. As baby boomers approach retirement, the careful planning for the eventual replacement of top leadership has gained strategic importance. In this 2011 NAFCU Annual Conference session you learn how to develop a candidate profile based upon the current and future needs of your credit union, identify and assess internal candidates, ensure their continued commitment and outline a competitive compensation package.
Presented by Loretta Dodgen, Ed D., Consultant and Managing Partner, Human Capital Solutions Group
More info at http://www.nafcu.org/hcsgroup
SimmBox Social Media & Internet Marketing PackagesBrands Downunder
SimmBox is a range of out-of-the-box solutions for businesses looking to enter Social Media and Internet Marketing.
Our packages gets you up and running cost effectively, enabling you to see the benefits these mediums provide for your business.
The yin yang of financial reform (gbe03374 usen-00)Lynn Reyes
(see also Yin yang 1, or "The yin yang of financial disruption" at http://www.ibm.com/iibv)
Regulatory reforms that were triggered by the financial crisis intend to address imbalances in the global financial system.
However, these reforms have yet to fundamentally resolve structural tensions in the system. We believe distractions
due to market uncertainty and an absence of trust among market participants further inhibit recovery and healthy growth. To mitigate unintended
consequences, participants must work together to commit to new maxims – principles that spur a new mindset and
guide specific actions.
New consumer needs, a large potential market and the absence of an established market leader make the retirement income market a potentially exciting opportunity.
This paper, authored by Ann Connolly, director, Deloitte Consulting LLP, examines the size and characteristics of the retirement income market, highlights innovation opportunities, assesses the competitive landscape, and lays out action steps that financial services companies across sectors – banks, insurance companies, mutual fund companies, and brokerage firms/investment managers – should consider taking to position themselves for leadership in the market.
The report describes:
The boomer retirement market, and why it’s different than preceding generations
Areas targeted for innovation:
*Product, Advice, Sales, and Service
*Opportunity/advantage/challenge assessment for banks, insurers, mutual funds and brokerage/investment managers
*Ten point action plan for adapting current operating models for future success
The core objectives of a bank’s treasury are clear; to conduct the asset liability management
process and in particular, to invest in creditworthy assets, to maintain sufficient liquidity and to maximise returns. The challenge is that these
three objectives are not always mutually compatible; as a result the Treasurer and their
team has a delicate balancing act, how to measure and manage these complex factors
and to keep proper control of all the processes.
FOR DISCLOSURES AND OTHER IMPORTANT INFORMATION, PLEASE RE.docxAKHIL969626
FOR DISCLOSURES AND OTHER IMPORTANT INFORMATION, PLEASE REFER TO THE BACK OF THIS REPORT.
November 1, 2016
GLOBAL FINANCIAL STRATEGIES
www.credit-suisse.com
Measuring the Moat
Assessing the Magnitude and Sustainability of Value Creation
Authors
Michael J. Mauboussin
[email protected]
Dan Callahan, CFA
[email protected]redit-suisse.com
Darius Majd
[email protected]
“The most important thing to me is figuring out how big a moat there is around
the business. What I love, of course, is a big castle and a big moat with piranhas
and crocodiles.”
Warren E. Buffett
Linda Grant, “Striking Out at Wall Street,” U.S. News & World Report, June 12, 1994
Sustainable value creation is of prime interest to investors who seek to
anticipate expectations revisions.
This report develops a systematic framework to determine the size of a
company’s moat.
We cover industry analysis, firm-specific analysis, and firm interaction.
mailto:[email protected]
mailto:[email protected]
mailto:[email protected]
November 1, 2016
Measuring the Moat 2
Table of Contents
Executive Summary ................................................................................................................................ 3
Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 4
Competitive Life Cycle ................................................................................................................. 4
Economic Moats ......................................................................................................................... 7
What Dictates a Company’s Destiny? ........................................................................................... 8
Industry Analysis ................................................................................................................................... 10
The Lay of the Land .................................................................................................................. 11
Industry Map ................................................................................................................. 11
Profit Pool .................................................................................................................... 13
Industry Stability ............................................................................................................ 15
Industry Classification .................................................................................................... 17
Industry Structure – Five Forces Analysis .................................................................................... 18
Entry and Exit ............................................................................................................... 19
Competitive Rivalry .................................. ...
Managing Risk in Perilous Times- Practical Steps to Accelerate RecoveryFindWhitePapers
The Economist Intelligence Unit examines the lessons learned from the current financial crisis, and proposes ten practical lessons that could help to address perceived weaknesses in risk identification, assessment and management.
A Bridge Too Far? Risk Appetite, Governance and Corporate Strategy (Whitepaper)NAFCU Services Corporation
“Many firms have made progress in developing their risk appetite frameworks and have
begun multiyear projects to improve the supporting IT infrastructure,” said David M.
Wallace, Global Financial Services Marketing Manager at SAS. “As a provider of risk
solutions, we have seen much more interest over the past three years in firms looking to
have additional technology to support a firmwide view of risk exposures. Learn more at: www.nafcu.org/sas
Breakthrough the traditional way of planing. Read Venture Care’s “Corporate Digest” December, 2017 .
Here are some insights of the magazine :
– What are your company strategies in this new Economy?
– Rewritten Risks and Entrepreneurship
– Valuation: A Modern Art
– Financial Modeling A practical view &
– Starting a Producer Company in India.
Learn from the largest subservicer how best to evaluate and select the right subservicing partner for your credit union based on your portfolio, investor mix, product range and other key selection factors.
Nearly one-third of Americans surveyed by Securian Financial Group say they haven’t thought about what would happen to their debt if they – or their cosigners – were to pass away unexpectedly. Fewer than 13 percent say they have taken steps to protect themselves from the sudden loss of a borrower.
With the tsunami of new regulations from NCUA and the CFPB, getting good at compliance is becoming a key success factor for credit unions. In this podcast and presentation from the 2013 NAFCU Annual Conference, Toné Gibson explores how your credit union can develop a cost-effective approach to strike a better balance between compliance and operational efficiency. Through the utilization of three methodologies – strategic development, process excellence, and performance management – learn in detail how to reduce the cost of compliance.
Wolters Kluwer Financial Services is the NAFCU Services Preferred Partner for Consumer and Member Business Lending & Deposit Services. More educational resources and contact information are available at www.nafcu.org/wolterskluwer.
Consumers are willing to pay for services that they find either adds convenience or delivers value. In this podcast and presentation from the 2013 NAFCU Annual Conference, Dave Schneider, Brent Dixon, and Paul Muse discuss how to expand your credit unions credit and debit opportunities and explore innovative products that can help guide your future credit union operations, including new approaches to increasing penetration, activation, and usage of the fundamental card. Also, learn to leverage new payment options that will appeal to Gen Y consumers, including Internet PIN debit, PINless at the point of sale, and payments and delivery of service through mobile.
Succession planning is the right people at the right time doing the right work. In this podcast and presentation from the 2013 NAFCU Annual Conference, Deedee and Peter discuss how you can develop a strategic organization successional plan to ensure the successful transition of key leadership for your credit union. This session covers an overview and best practices, levels and types planning, board evaluation, behind the scenes conversions, and the integration of board succession planning with CEO succession planning.
Rising Above Uncertainty: Opportunities and Challenges for Credit Unions in P...NAFCU Services Corporation
The retail financial services market is in a transformative period where new stakeholders and business models are reshaping the industry. Credit unions still have the opportunity for retention and growth, but must continue to compete. In this presentation, you will get an in-depth look at key market dynamics, including evolving financial services models and regulatory impact; learn about emerging strategies and their impact to credit unions, including EMV, prepaid, and mobile; and find out how to prepare for the future.
In this presentation from the 2013 NAFCU Annual Conference, Barrett Burns provides a comprehensive analysis of credit score models and discusses how your credit union can utilize them for member outreach and education.
Listen to the full podcast here: http://www.nafcu.org/NAFCU_Services_Corporation/Partner_Library/Credit_Scores__What_s_Behind_the_Number___Podcast_and_Presentation_/
2013 NAFCU BFB Survey of Executive Compensation and Benefits (Presentation Sl...NAFCU Services Corporation
First introduced in 2007, the NAFCU-BFB Survey of Federal Credit Union Executive Benefits and Compensation was created to better understand the compensation and benefits for the top five executives of Federal credit unions. For more info: www.nafcu.org/bfb
Study Confirms Debit Strength, Reveals Reward Trends (Payment Choice Study Re...NAFCU Services Corporation
TSYS partnered with Mercator Advisory Group to conduct the 2012 Consumer Debit Payment Choice Research Study. This unique study combines survey questions and focus groups, enabling researchers to have an interactive discussion with participants about payment choices and influences, technology awareness and overall user experiences. Learn more at: www.nafcu.org/discover
Before you embark on the critical path of defining (or redefining) your mortgage strategy, there are five basic truths you need to know and build into your planning. From expenses and technology to people and process, these truths are an essential part of any mortgage discussion. This webinar shares the research behind each tenet and how you can incorporate them into your strategy. Learn more at: www.nafcu.org/morgtagecadence
There is an unprecedented focus today around the future of retail branch networks. Credit union executives are seeking new ways to economically alter the scale, reach, and character of their branch assets to drive growth and enable expansion in profitable new territories and non-traditional locations. While the channel is universally acknowledged as best for both member acquisition and sales, the economics must change in order for this way of member-centric financial services to thrive and realize its potential in the new, consumer-driven, omnichannel environment. For more info: www.nafcu.org/ncr
Risk and Return: Striking the Right Balance (Whitepaper)
1. WHITE PAPER
Risk and Return:
Striking the Right Balance
The role of business analytics in transforming banking
2. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Table of Contents
Foreword............................................................................................................. 5
The necessary transformation of the banking industry............................... 6
Banking basics are back in vogue. ................................................................... 6
The role of business analytics in that transformation.................................. 7
Transforming the customer experience.......................................................... 9
The challenge. ............................................................................................. 9
How business analytics can help............................................................... 9
Define marketing plans that balance revenue and risk............................. 9
Accurately gauge the credit-worthiness of customers........................... 10
Intelligently manage customer debt....................................................... 10
Transforming enterprise risk management.................................................. 11
The challenge. ........................................................................................... 11
How business analytics can help............................................................. 11
Transforming governance and compliance.................................................. 12
The challenge. ........................................................................................... 12
How business analytics can help............................................................. 12
Transforming the fight against financial crime........................................... 13
The challenge. ........................................................................................... 13
How business analytics can help............................................................. 13
Transforming organizational performance................................................... 14
The challenge. ........................................................................................... 14
How business analytics can help............................................................. 15
Closing thoughts.............................................................................................. 16
The SAS Business Analytics Framework..................................................... 18
®
About SAS......................................................................................................... 19
3
3. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
The content provider for this paper was Leigh Bates, Head of Banking Practice,
SAS UK.
4
4. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Foreword
Even if we have seen the worst of the financial crisis – and that is by no means I
n the eye of the storm:
certain – we now have to contend with a global economic slowdown, which in many What’s next?
countries has become a recession. This series of unprecedented events has thrown up
“In my view, the appropriate
numerous challenges for us in all sectors of financial services – retail, private banking,
wealth management, corporate, wholesale, capital markets, insurance, investment
identification, assessment and
management and securities services. These threats, combined with the damage to our handling of risks in the financial
industry’s reputation, jeopardize many organizations’ survival, let alone prosperity. sector are the key issues to be
considered most carefully amid the
Now every one of us in the industry is striving to redress the balance between risk and
current global financial turmoil.
return, and between short- and long-term objectives. There has been no shortage
of comment from the industry, regulators, standard-setters and governments on the Looking back, the main factor that
causes of the crisis and the remedies. Whatever the ultimate consensus, banks must
I would identify as underlying the
transform themselves to meet the new realities. Forward-thinking financial institutions
will move vigorously to address five key areas: turmoil is the broad-based under-
appreciation of risk.
• Improve customer relationships and enhance the customer experience to restore
consumer/market confidence. Looking ahead, the main lesson I
• Improve risk management, rebuild liquidity and overall capital positions – quickly believe we need to draw is therefore
isolating poor-performing assets to strengthen the balance sheet. for the financial sector to establish
• Engage and manage regulators and other stakeholders in a new era of intense a much more rigorous identification,
oversight and scrutiny. assessment and handling of risk.”
• Reduce operational losses and combat financial crime in order to accurately Jean-Claude Trichet
provision capital and ensure customer confidence. President, European Central Bank
Paris, January 2009
• Review business strategies for a different climate, and identify new ways to drive
income and enhance shareholder value.
As executives charged with the task of putting banking on a new commercial course,
you need to be armed with trustworthy, complete facts and analysis. For that, the
Forecasting the financial turmoil
institution needs to adopt a business analytics framework. Decisions will then be based
on reliable information and predictive insight – adjusted for known risks across the “The backwash from defaults in
institution’s business units, functional areas and channels. the US subprime market has been
seen not just in the recent problems
The technology to achieve this vision is available today. This paper looks at these five
faced by some hedge funds exposed
areas and how business analytics can redefine the possibilities.
to this sector, but in credit markets
more widely. ...We have seen
shocks to credit markets in the last
two summers, which were swiftly
reversed. Could recent events be the
beginning of a more lasting change?”
Sir John Gieve
Deputy Governor, Bank of England
London, July 24, 2007
5
5. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
The necessary transformation of the banking industry
In a contentious cover story in BusinessWeek magazine in February 2009, the
banking industry was blasted as a major cause of our current economic downturn
and one of the biggest obstacles to the recovery. “… Banks and their advocates “What the current crisis is telling
in Washington have delayed, diluted and obstructed attempts to address the us is that we need a return to some
problem,” the article asserted (“How Banks Are Worsening the Foreclosure Crisis,”
basic banking principles. I believe
BusinessWeek, February 12, 2009).
we are entering an era in which
“The industry strategy all along has been to buy time and thwart regulation, the industry’s recent propensity
financial-services lobbyists tell BusinessWeek. ‘We were like the Dutch boy with his for high leverage – together with
finger in the dike,’ says one business advocate who, like several colleagues, insists
the extreme complexity of some
on anonymity, fearing career damage.”
investment vehicles – will no longer
The tide has been too much, and the timing too late, for such stopgap measures. be acceptable. This means that
In June 2009, the Obama administration proposed the most significant new sustainable and profitable growth
regulation of the financial industry since the Great Depression, a plan that
will come through strategies that
would give the government new powers to seize key companies whose failure
jeopardizes the financial system, as well as creation of a watchdog agency to look
get back to the basic tenets of the
out for consumers’ interests. banking profession.”
Stephen Green
Of course, the industry had much earlier taken notice and started charting new Chairman, HSBC
paths. The most comprehensive response came from the Institute of International
Finance (IIF), which has more than 390 members worldwide. In July 2008, the
organization had issued a report of best practice recommendations for risk
management, compensation policies, liquidity management, lending, underwriting
and rating of structured products, valuation of assets, and improving transparency
and disclosure. At the October 2008 annual meeting of IIF, chairman Dr. Josef
Ackermann reported that financial institutions had already started taking “vigorous
action to strengthen their operations” in line with the report’s recommendations.
Banking basics are back in vogue
“What the current crisis is telling us is that we need a return to some basic banking
principles,” said Stephen Green, chairman of HSBC in the United Kingdom. “I
believe we are entering an era in which the industry’s recent propensity for high
leverage – together with the extreme complexity of some investment vehicles –
will no longer be acceptable. This means that sustainable and profitable growth
will come through strategies that get back to the basic tenets of the banking
profession.”
This transformation is being enforced by an era of tougher global banking
regulation. This new era is characterized by higher expectations for bank capital,
tighter control over liquidity, and policies designed to discourage excessive
risk taking. Financial institutions need information systems that support these
expectations.
6
6. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
The role of business analytics in that transformation
In this new banking scenario:
• Chief executive officers and their boards of directors are seeking strategic
business directions that will maximize revenue while sustaining regulatory
compliance and investor confidence.
• Marketing executives are seeking a better understanding of customers – their
preferences and propensities – to maximize the profitability and longevity of
valued relationships.
• Chief risk officers need to generate a comprehensive view of risk across the entire
institution, and reduce the costs, burden and uncertainty of meeting regulatory
requirements.
• Chief information officers are wondering, “How can we build and maintain the
IT infrastructure that achieves these results, when we have smaller staffs and
budgets than ever?”
The current mode of operation in many corporations doesn’t provide very effective
answers to such questions, or provides them at very high cost and with dubious
accuracy. Banks need a more holistic approach – a validated, unified, institutionwide
view of what was, coupled with accurate predictive insights about what will be.
The answers to those questions are not found in the mega-spreadsheets that still
proliferate in so many institutions. Spreadsheet programs simply cannot perform
consolidations fast enough for larger organizations to meet the new, shorter reporting
deadlines. They also do not provide the audit trail required for full transparency, or
systematic ways to maintain version control and disseminate important information
throughout the organization.
The right technology foundation integrates people, processes and information to arrive
at a single, reliable view, based upon repeatable, searchable and auditable processes.
Coupled with advanced analytic capabilities – such as forecasting, scenario planning,
optimization and risk analysis – this technology platform reduces uncertainty, quantifies
variability, refines processes and optimally allocates resources. Analytically derived
insights are quickly shared with the users and applications that need them, supporting
better decisions to mitigate risks and maximize returns.
7
7. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Figure 1: The greater the analytic strength, the more powerful and predictive the insights
it delivers.
By implementing a centralized business analytics platform to serve the entire
organization, rather than scattered PC-based tools, banks can ensure adherence
to top-level standards of accountability, achieve the requisite levels of transparency,
and provide strategic insights that guide the institution toward optimum growth and
profitability.
Consider the power of having analytic intelligence with full risk context. For example:
• The board of directors has clear risk metrics embedded into every performance
report, including a short- and long-term view of the market with an economic and
risk-adjusted view of current and planned performance. The directors can then set
the enterprisewide risk appetite, balancing risks with reward in executing business
strategy.
• Marketing and sales managers can identify their most profitable markets and
customers to match customer needs with the right products through appropriate
and timely sales campaigns. They can ensure their strategies are appropriate for
the bank’s appetite for risk.
• Customer service executives can operate profitably by anticipating customer
demand across channels and aligning resources with predicted demand. They
can also improve the service experience by identifying process bottlenecks,
channel design issues, staff training requirements and analyzing complaints.
• Collections and recovery staff can accurately price debt portfolios and identify the
most effective collection mechanism, such as whether to use internal strategies,
outsource or sell to minimize risk and maximize return.
8
8. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Read on for an overview of how business analytics can dramatically reshape the bank’s
capabilities, agility and performance in the five key areas of necessary transformation:
■ A comprehensive business analytics
framework provides decision makers
• Customer experience.
with critical insight, not only into
• Enterprise risk management.
what happened in the past, but why
• Governance and compliance. it happened, what may happen in the
• Combating financial crime. future and how your organization can
• Organizational performance. achieve the best possible outcome
when unplanned events occur.
A comprehensive business analytics framework provides critical insight not only into what
happened in the past, but why it happened, what may happen in the future and how you
can achieve the best possible outcome when unplanned events occur.
Transforming the customer experience
The challenge
Traditional customer strategy in retail banking has been “product-out” rather than
“customer-in.” Most banks focused on cross-selling more and more products and
services, rather than meeting customer needs more effectively and comprehensively.
Now that customer confidence is at a record low, it is time to adopt a more customer-
centric mindset while minimizing risk. Retail bankers have to behave more like retail
merchants, focusing on new ways to gain customers, keep them and maximize
profitability from each – all while reducing costs and risk.
How business analytics can help
Define marketing plans that balance revenue and risk
With a business intelligence platform, you can create a unified view of customers
across products and channels, identify your most valuable customers (now and over
time) and better understand their preferences and predilections, so you have a better
chance of reaching them. Accurate targeting vastly improves the odds of reaching
high-value customers while reducing the risk of wasting resources by trying to sell to
the wrong people.
Business analytics enables marketing and risk teams to collaborate in defining the
marketing plan, balancing marketing objectives with risk appetite. “What-if” simulations
and business optimization capabilities ensure that business objectives, such as
maximizing profitability and market penetration, are achieved within risk constraints,
such as keeping risk portfolio scores below certain levels, or operational constraints
such as capacity and budget.
9
9. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Accurately gauge the credit-worthiness of customers
Many institutions rely heavily on FICO scores as the basis for nearly all risk
management decisions, from processing a loan, revising a credit limit or making
the decision to pay a transaction. But credit bureau scores tell only part of the ■ For Scotiabank in Canada, SAS
picture. They reflect a rear view of past behaviors and not the factors that explain the improved expected campaign ROI by
behaviors. The current credit crisis has called into question the viability of established more than 50 percent, compared to
techniques.
the expected results that would have
An analytics-based credit risk application scores accounts based on deeper, been generated if more traditional
richer information the bank has gleaned from the customer’s history and collective offer selection techniques were
institutional experience. Where there are gaps in the data, a robust approach uses employed. This lift allowed the bank
alternative data to narrow the information gap. Sophisticated models deliver highly
to make better use of its channel
predictive risk scores that can be used to classify credit risk and guide transactions in a
more effective, transparent and forward-looking manner.
resources and marketing dollars.
The ability to capture true risk has significant implications not only for resolving today’s
credit crisis but also for preventing future financial disruption.
Intelligently manage customer debt
As customers find it harder to satisfy their debts, and creditors compete to collect
debts from the same customers, there is growing pressure to manage debt scenarios
more effectively – from pre-delinquency to collections to recovery. “The leading banks and
telecommunications companies
Advanced credit and collections applications collect data from the wider economy, are among our biggest clients, and
industry sectors, businesses and consumers to build a comprehensive database of
so the fact that we also are using
the credit ecosystem. Business analytics continually assesses these factors to detect
changes that could influence a borrower’s ability to pay – and the potential impact to SAS Business Intelligence tools is
the institution. With earlier clues to potential problems, the institution can make wise an obvious factor in them feeling
decisions to minimize risk, set the best collections strategy, identify the optimum time comfortable about choosing our
to sell a debt, and set a market-appropriate price for it.
services.”
The debt management and collection business Baycorp uses SAS to help quantify
®
Andre Debakhapouve
the risks associated with buying large-scale debts by producing long-term statistically Head of Analytics and
Financial Reporting, Baycorp
based recoveries forecasts.
10
10. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Transforming enterprise risk management
The challenge
In spite of the heightened climate associated with risk, many institutions cannot apply
risk management coherently across the entire business. Different types of risks – credit,
market, operational, liquidity and so on – are often managed in separate silos. Where
these various types of risk overlap, there is frequently a gap so great that major risks go
undetected. Institutions urgently need to strengthen overall risk management systems
to rebuild liquidity and overall capital positions.
How business analytics can help
The answer to this problem is enterprise risk management (ERM) – an integrated
approach that aligns strategy, processes, people, knowledge and IT to better
understand and control risk throughout the business. With an ERM strategy, the
institution can develop a single enterprisewide risk portfolio that can be analyzed to
model future anticipated risk exposures, sensitivity risks and concentration risks, all
from an earnings, liquidity and capital perspective.
An advanced risk analytics framework includes data integration, data quality
management, enterprise risk analytics, banking and risk intelligence, as well as a
Basel II analysis and reporting framework. A cohesive ERM solution detects potentially
problematic relationships among disparate data sources and risk types – relationships
and dependencies that even the most experienced risk practitioners may miss.
Specifically, an ERM approach enables a financial institution to:
• Better manage credit, market and operational risk.
• Make more efficient use of capital and liquidity.
• Conduct stress testing (and reverse stress testing) in holistic context.
• Protect shareholders and debt holders from risks that should have been identified.
• Align business activities with the bank’s risk appetite and a clearer picture of risk.
• Improve risk and regulatory reporting.
• Enable integrated risk analysis of income streams across all risk types.
• Provide insight into risk relationships that were not previously apparent.
Used effectively, business analytics can, for example, provide insight into the risk-
adjusted return on a lending product and help predict which changing economic
factors are having the greatest impact on product profitability. You will then be able to
plan the best course of actions that should be taken in the future. Or you could use
a deeper understanding of risk to price products and services more competitively
where you can, rather than treating all customers who borrow as “guilty until proven
innocent.”
11
11. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Value-based pricing is not new, but as the pace of change increases, it becomes
more important to explore which factors are actually influencing product profitability.
These factors are not always obvious, but analytics can unlock this insight. A holistic
approach to risk management will drive optimized risk decision making and further
develop your ability to proactively and prudently manage risks.
Transforming governance and compliance ■ With more than $152 billion in
assets, BBT is the 11th-largest
financial holding company in the
The challenge US. The institution chose SAS to
The growing number of laws, regulations and standards (industry, internal and ethical) help manage risk concentration,
has increased the scope, complexity and burden of compliance on our industry. All
accounting for risk at both the
too often, institutions respond in a piecemeal fashion, which leads to duplication of
processes, data gathering and testing. transaction level and the portfolio
level. With SAS, BBT can now
Banks need to take a holistic approach to legal and regulatory compliance that will correlate interdependencies within
minimize effort, maximize efficiency and reduce the risk of noncompliance. Integrated
the portfolio to help reduce the
data coupled with advanced analytical capabilities will provide you with all the
information and analysis you need to improve compliance with the multiplicity of laws, bank’s risk and price services
regulations and standards in all areas of financial services – retail, private, wholesale at a good value for customers,
and investment banking, insurance and asset management. while ensuring an adequate
return on capital.
How business analytics can help
With a comprehensive compliance solution backed by business analytics, you
reduce the risk of noncompliance by streamlining data management processes and
strengthening internal controls around high-risk process points. You can be confident
that the information presented to internal users and regulators is well-organized,
accurate and has been prepared using transparent and repeatable processes. Audit
trails enable you to track all input sources and transformations applied to any data,
even which individual was responsible.
Business analytics can fully support your Basel II requirements in credit, market,
operational and liquidity risk, regulatory and economic capital management, stress
testing, reverse stress testing, sensitivity and concentration analysis, and risk
measurement reporting.
Another area where business analytics can play a crucial role is in assisting compliance
with anti-money laundering regulations. Advanced network analysis and statistical
techniques can uncover suspicious transactions, not just money laundering offenses
but all types of fraud.
The first benefits of such a solution are obvious: on-time delivery of accurate regulatory
submissions with significantly less cost and effort. Better compliance also reduces
the risk of breaking laws and regulations, and of the legal censure, penalties and
reputational damage that follow if authorities detect the breaches.
12
12. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
At the same time, analytics-based compliance solutions return significant benefits for
internal operations as well. Compliance risk analysts can now redirect their energies
from mundane data management tasks to meaningful analysis. Drill-down reporting
and data visualization techniques quickly identify areas where compliance status might
need action. Loan officers and branch managers can respond to timely information
about loan opportunities in low- to moderate-income neighborhoods, and examine the
institution’s performance relative to the competition.
In short, the solution implemented for regulatory necessity can become a genuine
business advantage.
Transforming the fight against financial crime
The challenge
Banking and government entities are seeing an increase in both the number and
sophistication of fraudulent activities, such as internal and external fraud, bribery,
unauthorized trading, market abuse, money laundering and terrorist financing.
To fight fraud effectively, you must continually improve the monitoring of customer
behavior across multiple accounts and systems. Yet few banks have strong,
enterprisewide fraud management programs that can correlate a customer’s behavior
across all contact channels and products.
The fraud management process itself is often fragmented. Fraud detection, alert and
case management practices are still too often viewed as separate activities, when they
should be managed as a whole.
How business analytics can help
Given the complexity and speed of modern banking transactions, simple rules-based
methods of fraud detection and prevention are no longer enough. Business analytics
with predictive modeling techniques effectively combats fraudsters while minimizing the
level of false positives that can inconvenience customers.
A strong, enterprisewide fraud management approach spans all contact channels and
account types and includes the following integrated elements:
• Data analysis and alert generation – The ability to assimilate data from multiple
sources and apply predictive analytics to accurately assess transactions, activities
and customer state in real time.
• Alert management – The mechanism for accepting, prioritizing and distributing
alerts from the various fraud detection and money laundering tools used across
the enterprise – and to record actions taken to determine whether actual fraud is
present or suspicious activity has been identified.
13
13. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
• Social network analysis – An analysis and visualization tool for uncovering
previously unknown relationships among accounts or entities.
• Case management – A structured environment in which to manage investigation
workflows; document loss incidents; manage the collection of information and
documentation in developing cases for civil and criminal prosecution, restitution
and/or collections; report on fraud management performance and file necessary ■ Within months, SAS delivered
regulatory reports.
a 95 percent increase in check
To more effectively prevent future losses, fraud management systems will have to fraud detection efficiency for
become self-learning, automatically capturing the outcomes of investigations and Commonwealth Bank of Australia.
reusing those outcomes in future scoring. Models would thereby adapt readily to new In five years, the new system has
knowledge and continually be refined. This combination of adaptation and visibility
detected twice as many check fraud
would enable financial institutions to better understand emerging threats, so they can
take action to prevent substantial losses before they happen. incidents as the legacy system,
increased Internet banking fraud
The prospects for the future also extend beyond the scope of any single enterprise. alerts by 60 percent, and improved
As more organizations adopt integrated, automated fraud management systems, the
check and Internet fraud loss-to-
potential is there to create a broad consortium of financial institutions that can draw on
their collective experiences to improve fraud detection across the industry. turnover ratios by 50 and 80 percent,
respectively.
Transforming organizational performance
The challenge
Every institution manages performance, in one way or another, in an attempt to
optimize the organization as a whole while meeting the needs of internal and external
stakeholders. However, many loosely define “performance management” as a reporting
effort. The organization that wants to proactively improve performance – not just report
on it – must have good answers for these questions:
• Do I have all the information I need to understand performance today across the
institution?
• Have I articulated and communicated the strategy in a way that reflects high-level
priorities?
• Am I able to drive accountability to these priorities throughout the institution?
In seeking to answer these questions, many institutions are hindered by organizational
silos, incompatible data systems and information hoarding. To further complicate
matters, flux in economic conditions means that the past is not a reliable indicator of
the future. Banks need more than hindsight reports to make forward decisions.
For example, in small business banking, how can static, behavioral, economic data
be used to predict future resource requirements? Would the cost of an increased local
presence be outweighed by better management of risk and an improved ability to lend
to those customers who are thriving? How might local factors and competitor activity
influence the ideal resource levels?
14
14. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
How business analytics can help ■ A successful bank is ultimately
A business analytics framework enables a timely and consistent version of the truth –
about collaborative progress
and a clear understanding of the factors that influence performance. This knowledge
is delivered in a role-specific way, so managers and executives can track activity
toward a shared vision, based on
and outcomes in alignment with organizationwide strategy, not just department-level dynamic knowledge of the full
objectives. business impacts of processes and
relationships, and understanding and
Based on this trusted data foundation, a scorecard and its supporting strategy map
satisfying all stakeholders.
articulate the institution’s mission and business strategy. The scorecard can reflect
what needs to change – where and by how much. The scorecard’s dashboard gives
executives an at-a-glance picture of the institution’s health and performance. Users
should be able to see within five seconds which results have the greatest impact,
where to focus, and where to drill deeper to discover the root cause of an issue.
A scorecard and strategy map provide the discipline and structure for ensuring that:
• Objectives will be supported by activities.
• Each department will contribute toward goals in a particular way.
• The most important measures are paramount and driven throughout the
business.
When supported by analytics, a strategy map can also validate interdependencies
and also show the strength of each relationship. Managers can recognize the chain
of events that trigger costs related to people, materials, equipment and facilities. They
gain new insight into cause-and-effect relationships that link resources and processes
to results. For example, product marketing activity and credit limit decreases can be
planned in unison to maximize the business objectives for each part of the business,
not just a single silo.
15
15. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Closing thoughts
The banking industry grows more competitive all the time, and volatile markets have
eroded consumer confidence and loyalty, putting a premium on superior service and
strong incentives. To succeed, banks must better manage their information and find
new ways to turn that information into business intelligence.
However, as mergers and acquisitions reshape banks’ information networks, it’s
common to see multiple, incompatible information platforms even within a single
functional area. The competitive and regulatory pressures of today’s banking
environment require a more holistic technology infrastructure, one that supports a
unified view of the organization, its customers, risks and rewards.
Does that mean that the bank’s investment in traditional, transaction-based systems is
obsolete? No. Those systems just need to share their information through a business
analytics architecture that brings the parts into a cohesive whole.
SAS delivers an integrated platform and suite of software and services tailored to
meet the unique needs of the financial services industry. SAS solutions draw on the
vast amounts of data generated by your existing systems and apply banking-specific
analytic models to transform that data into meaningful intelligence about strategic
performance, customer relationships, credit decisions, risk management and regulatory
compliance. All of these solutions are integrated through an enterprise data architecture
designed specifically for banks.
With SAS, you can gain new insights into customer and business information, infuse
intelligence into strategic business decisions, and increase your success in generating
profits, managing risk and delivering rapid return on investment.
16
16. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
The SAS Business Analytics Framework
®
The SAS Business Analytics Framework seamlessly integrates the fundamental
elements of business intelligence:
• Centralized data repositories synthesize data from currently incompatible data
silos on any platform and any format, using common metadata.
• Sophisticated ETL (extract, transform and load) processes maintain data
quality, so you can have faith in the accuracy of plans, reports and analyses
based on that data.
• Banking-specific business analytics enable non-statisticians to surface
meaningful intelligence from vast amounts of information about customers,
products, market conditions and risks.
• Predictive and descriptive analytics deliver more accurate forecasts,
optimization and resource allocation plans – looking not just at what happened,
but what will happen.
• Query and reporting tools give users the highest quality of information in role-
based interfaces – where and when needed, via multiple platforms and channels.
• Targeted business solutions support key areas of your business, such as
customer relationship management, marketing, compliance, risk management
and more – specifically for financial services.
• Strategic performance management enables institution-level guidance,
accountability and integrity.
• Professional services, training and ongoing support, with extensive banking
domain expertise, help your organization get rapid results and maximize the value
of its SAS solutions.
With the SAS Business Analytics Framework, you can address your most critical
business issues right now and then add new functionality over time – all from one
vendor, all through one integrated framework, to help transform the institution to
prosper in a changing industry arena.
17
17. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
Turnkey and hosted solutions deliver results fast, in months rather than years. Prebuilt
solutions are ready-made for specific functions, such as anti-money laundering and
compliance with fair banking regulations. The software works with data from existing
systems and shares it securely on existing networks. In short, the obstacles that made
business analytics seem so daunting in the past have been diminished or dissolved.
18
18. RISK AND RETURN: STRIKING THE RIGHT BALANCE
About SAS
SAS provides all the capabilities described in this document, based on the proven
platform for SAS Business Analytics. Compared to niche or point solutions, SAS
integrates solutions across the institution to bring disparate functions together into an
institutionwide, customer-centric view.
SAS has worked closely with top financial institutions for more than 30 years to create
solutions to address critical business needs. In the financial services industry alone,
SAS data integration, fraud detection, risk management, regulatory compliance,
CRM and other software is used by more than 3,000 financial institutions worldwide,
including 97 percent of banks in the FORTUNE Global 500 . ®
Our award-winning solutions handle the challenges specifically associated with the
volatile financial services industry, and we can help institutions better manage their
strategy, risk, customers and channels to maximize profitability, achieve greater
shareholder value and gain a clear competitive advantage.
Across industries, SAS solutions are used at 45,000 sites in 118 countries. Since 1976,
SAS has been giving customers around the world The Power to Know . ®
www.sas.com
19