The Battle on Selenium Camp conferece February 2017 http://seleniumcamp.com/talk/qa-livecoding-battle-typed-element-framework-jdi-vs-untyped-elements-framework-selenide/ Why typed elements (like Buttons, Images, Checkboxes, Links etc.) are bad practice in UI tests? Or are non-typed elements (like SelenideElement for ´em all!) more evil? Is it better to have predefined Element hierarchy or not? Alexei and Roman have delivered a sound theoretical battle earlier at Heisenbug-2016 Conference in Moscow. But were everything said just words? The both QA wrestlers are still standing behind their concepts and are willing to prove their point at live coding sessions before the judging audience! In this QA Battle the parties will solve problems using a typed framework JDI and an non-typed one – Selenide, commenting their actions. The audience will decide with their votes which of the concept was better.

1. QA Battle of Automation
Approaches
JDI
typed elements
Roman Iovlev Alexei Vinogradov
Selenide
non-typed elements
vs
http://bit.ly/qabattle-pdf
http://bit.ly/qabattle-video

2. ROMAN IOVLEV
Chief QA Automation
In Testing more than 12 years
In Testing Automation 10 years

3. Alexei Vinogradov
IT-Kонсультант
тестирование, управление тестированием,
автоматизация в тестировании, коучинг
15+ лет в IT, докладчик SQA Days / Codefest / QA Fest
Дякую, Боже, що я не програмiст

5. •KISS in Action
•No unnecessary framework code -> no
unnecessary maintenance
•Less to learn -> easier to use
5
SELENIDE MAIN POINTS

6. •Already implemented actions for most used
elements
•Detailed UI actions logs
•Flexible for any UI on any Framework or Platform
•Short and obvious UI Objects (PageObjects)
•EDT support
6
JDI MAIN POINTS

7. 7

8. 8
SCENARIO TASK
1. Open http://imdb.com
2. Login with imdb account
3. Open existing list
4. Press edit link
5. Add 3 shows into list
6. Open compact(table) view
7. Verify that table contains
added Films (title, year, type)
8. Sort by Rating
9. Filter table by "Drama"
10.Go back to Edit list
11.Delete show “Black Mirror”
12.Verify that other two films still
in list
13.Remove all films from list
After test:

9. 9

10. 10
TASK 1

11. 11
TASKS 1
1. Enter text in input field
2. Verify text is displayed
3. Enter text in textarea field
4. Verify text is displayed
• Developers change site layout
• Redesign your tests

12. 12
TASKS 2

13. 13
TASKS 2

14. 14
TASKS 2
1. Open https://www.epam.com/careers/job-listings
2. Click on link Apply for row with
name="Senior QA Automation Engineer”
category="Software Test Engineering“
3. Fill CV form
4. Verify that form filled correctly

15. 15
TASKS 3

16. 16
TASKS 3
1. Open https://material.angularjs.org/latest/demo/input
2. Check the checkbox
3. Verify checkbox is checked
4. Switch off the “switch”
5. Verify “switch” is switched off

17. 17

18. QUESTIONS
Alexei Vinogradov
Twitter: @vinogradoff
Skype: alexejv
Mail: qa@vinogradov-it.de
http://jdi.epam.com/
https://vk.com/jdi_framework
https://github.com/epam/JDI
roman.Iovlev
roman_iovlev@epam.com
https://github.com/vinogradoff/QaBattle-typed-vs-untyped
https://github.com/epam/JDI/tree/selenium-camp/Java/Tests/jdi.examples
Code
Contacts